Michigan judge sentences Shanda Vander Ark to life without parole
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ม.ค. 2024
- "I will tell you this. I am choosing not to remember your son dead, looking like a Holocaust victim. I'm choosing to remember him like this," Judge Kacel said.
Story: www.wzzm13.com/article/news/i...
➡️Subscribe to 13 ON YOUR SIDE for exclusive content: / 13onyourside
➡️Visit our website: www.13onyourside.com
Follow 13 ON YOUR SIDE on social media!
➡️FACEBOOK: / 13onyourside
➡️TWITTER: / wzzm13
➡️INSTAGRAM: / wzzm13
We stand up for the community. We want to make life better for everyone. We celebrate all that makes West Michigan unique. We are 13 ON YOUR SIDE.
![[Full] อังคารคลุมโปง Close Up EP.49 | คนใกล้ผีคนที่ 49 : หมอฉุกเฉิน “หมอบอส” (Thai Sub)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dKPUaX7UxMQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This judge showed more respect for her son than she did. How bizarre. Pure evil.
God why did a child have to suffer so much
Yes thank God Timothy did win amen
I was thinking the same. Judge was actually kind and thoughtful. No mercy for this itch and what she’s done to Timothy AND her other kids. Making her own son an “executioner “? No mercy. Sorry not sorry
She’s a total and complete sadist. She sits there looking at notes and papers as she’s being sentenced. Vile sick woman.
Absolute, unmitigated evil. It’s shocking.
This judge did not speak from legal textbooks, he spoke from his heart.
An amazing judge.
She is pure evil.
We need more judges like him.
Irregardless, his words are still legal.
@@donnawood3505 no one said they were not
Agree. I was so impressed by him!
For a Judge to say hes glad this child passed , so he wasnt in more pain and torture was incredible.
That’s the way I feel. This child didn’t stand a chance in life!
A wonderful judge ,
I am kind of "happy" that I am not the only one thinking that.
What future for him ? How his life would have been ?
Cannot live with that. I say that to myself for Tesslynn's Ocull case too. This girl was raped just 3 years old so violently her genitalia was literally destroyed. Death seemed to be the only escape for these poor kind of souls.
I have many examples of survivors of abuse who still struggle. Lauren Kavanaugh (she became an abuser), Victoria and Christopher spry (Victoria killed herself). Well.. how can you live normally...
I cant imagine the sadness Timothy must have felt to woke up every f mornings in this tinu room. Just escaped from his dreams to woke up to that horrible reality..
At least, now, timothy is sleeping eternally. No more fear. No more hunger. I am ashamed to say that I am happy hes at peace and not living anymore knowing what he endured.
Timothy won that day by passing on to a better place and having them pay for what they did.
She went and bought extra hot sauce online, expensive cameras, motion sensors, etc.!
She went out of her way, spent extra money, spent all this time to torture him on purpose. She enjoyed harming her sick child who did nothing. Timothy’s only crime was existing.
😢😢😢
A judge with a heart and knows when to sentence accordingly! CHAPEAU!
She's definitely a Joe Biden voter
She was a famous Biden supporter with "VOTE BLUE NO MATTER WHO" all over he FB page. All Dems are crazy pedos or worse
She was notable Blden supporter with "VOTE BLUE NO MATTER WHO" all over her FB page. All the Dems are crazy or worse
“You would have lost the very thing you wanted to torture.” FINALLY a judge that understands the difference between mental illness and sadism. She’s not mentally ill. She got pleasure from the total control, dominance and power she had over this child. The torture happened in the privacy of her home where she could enjoy it at leisure. Thank you judge for speaking for Timothy.
%100 correct
“Enjoy it at leisure” sent shivers down my spine. You nailed it
That’s the way her type are, in fact narcissists typically operate that way. They want their target/victim under their thumb so they can continue to to get their “ supply “ which is control and power. I had a father like that.
I respect the intent of what the judge said, but I agree more with the officer that interviewed Paul. It was a twisted sense of "discipline" to get a child to "submit" to the parent's authority. Timothy was her "problem child" that was keeping her from her independent career goals. A nuisance of no value, that she deeply resented to the point of senseless torture and death. I think she ultimately would rather have him die and get on with her life, rather than enjoy the torture. She wanted FREEDOM! Paul was the child that willingly complied with her behavior - a "good boy", that craved her acceptance and love.
@@kathywidowski9662 then you obviously haven't read her texts. This had little or nothing to do with discipline. She DEFINITELY enjoyed what she did to that poor poor child.
This judge's statement gave me chills. He honored her son.
Yes he did and the little angel will never suffer again! 🥀 Her suffering is just beginning.
it feels like timothy was honoured like he was his own son@@deborahallen3318
He did! Rest in peace sweet boy 🙏🕊️✨❤️✝️. And my prayers for his loved ones and Paul as well 🙏🙏🙏
Read my username
❤
Hey Judge.....youll probably never see or read this.....but YOU, and the PROSECUTOR allowed and gave this child Timothy Dignaty and actual Love thru Justice. Thank you gentlemen. Thank you. Rest in God's arms Sweet Timothy.
how this circus is gonna change anytjing? all that suffer happened and cannot be reverted
That was beautiful..amen
@@lalolanda2239lol. This is how a civilized country asserts and affirms it's morality. Too bad they don't have this where you're from.
The god who allowed this poor child to suffer horrendously while he looked in & did nothing?
You mean that god?
Fkn crazies
The Devil is alive and well and nobody can see it.
“ thank god he finally passed away because he’d still be suffering “ broke my heart into a million pieces. Rest in peace .
We have TRULY reached a all new low when a adult person has to say "thank God this child died so you couldn't torture him anymore" that really hit me hard....
Me too! What a dreadful case this is.
Heart breaking , my Jesus he shows a picture of Timothy, a beautiful little boy 😢😭😭😭😭
What a beautiful child. My heart breaks for Timothy & I’m literally in tears as I write this. I’ve never heard a judge speak from the heart so eloquently.
So sad man...
Me 2
Thanks for standing up for abused children.
stuning and brave!!!!! /s
@@Trumpforeeverwhat about yours?
@@TrumpforeeverWho's Brandon???
This judge gave such a heartfelt speech..I wish all judges were like this man
AS A VERY YOUNG CHILD IT IS A HORRIFIC NIGHTMARE TO BE ABUSED BY YOUR "FAMILY" AND KNOW THERE ISN'T A SOUL ON EARTH THAT WILL RESCUE YOU!
I love this judge. He cared more for Timothy then Shanda ever did,
I would want this judge for any case but especially child abuse cases. He has such compassion and love for children it’s obvious.
How the judge held himself together to speak professionally in this summing up and sentencing was amazing, his distress and anger was seen by everyone.
Judge looks physically sick for what this monster of a woman has done.
Couldn’t even look at her. May she rot in the pits of hell
No wonder...
It made me sick watching it on my phone . I couldn't imagine seeing her in person. She's with Karma now
@@canadianbacon8220 Imagine beeing her lawyer.
You can tell he has a soft heart, seems like a nice judge
I'm so glad she will never be free again. What she did to her son is horrendous.
And hope her cell mates know what she did!
And to Paul. She destroyed him forever.
I love, respect, ok love , this Judge. I feel sorry for her Attny. Imagine being a PD responsible for defending a perp who is so obviously Diabla
Even the snow looks angry
@@debramarble2197 They WILL know, guaranteed! Too many ways for them to find out plus many (most!) of them already know who she is and what she did, she faces nothing but pain and misery in this world and the next!
She had nothing to say. No apology. No remorse. And worst of all no tears of deep sorrow and regret for what she did.
No eye contact regarding the judge. Hideous excuse for a human being.
After hearing all that I don't want to hear what this piece of s*** got to say honestly
Yup. She had nothing. Because she has no soul. Rot in jail you B. To treat a child that way that made a judge that upset, enjoy time thinking about it all behind bars.
Of course not she is pure evil
@@kenglasson2920 she’ll get what’s coming to her in jail, I’m sure.
I am so sick and tired of these parents hurting and killing their children. What is wrong with people today.
It’s not just people these days, they’ve been doing this for too many years, that’s why there’s such a thing as social services. With the advent of the internet, these stories are easily shared so it looks like it’s more of a modern thing.
Not just people today. It has always been evil. They just didn’t advertise it like today. We have a lot more mobile media then we ever have so it looks like we have more evil I don’t think so.
You and I both
Abortion de humanizes children. Period. If all life is not valued, No life is valued.
Unfortunately and tragicly this horror is going on for thousands of years...
Her son who traveled 900 miles to give an impact statement, was also abused. This woman deserves the dea th penalty.
Did you notice he was overweight?
I believe she caused eating disorders (or at least unhealthy relationships with food) in all 5 of her kids.
Time will tell about Gabe. But I fear that he will turn out to be a Monster like his Mom. The way he was raised to believe he deserves special treatment and his brothers were "below" him even though he was younger.
I also believe she had something to do with her husband's stroke. I hope they look into that as well.
Do you know where I can find the footage of him giving his statement?
Yes we need to bring back the death penalty
The kid is absolutely ruined you can't do anything but lock him up too
Look at the beautiful scene of our earthly home outside the window, and she sits there after murdering her boy.
What an incredible judge. Thank you Judge Kacel! Timothy did win today. Justice was served! Now it’s time to throw away the key and let Shanda rot in complete misery.
They should deny her food, to boot.
Great speech by the judge . Justice has been served for Timothy
Excellent job Judge!
All of the mothers in prison who miss their children and would give anything to be able to be with them right now hopefully will give this evil witch a huge dose of prison justice for her whole stay !
Judge Kacel
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Justice Served!
Totally Evil Monster!
☆☆☆☆☆
Excellent! Epic! Eventful!
☆☆☆☆☆
Informative Information!
☆☆☆☆☆
Educational Excellence!
☆☆☆☆☆
WoW! WoW! WoW!
Ive watched documentaries about what it was like to be a POW, be in a Korean death camp, be in a concentration camp, etc...Its not an exaggeration to say that Timothy lived an almost identical life at the hands of his own mother to people imprisoned in literal death camps.
Rest in peace, Timothy. You've more than earned it and Im so sorry for what you went through.
It’s almost as bad as the victims of the holocaust during World War II
Absolutely right.
She should be in solidary confinement, blindfolded and given minutes to use a public bathroom for the rest of her life. No medication for what she believes is her medical issue. What a truly disgusting excuse for a human being. I'm glad she didn't get the death sentence, she doesn't deserve that easy out. At the very least, no one can ever hurt this innocent child ever again. May he thrive in Heaven as the sweet Soul that he truly was. RIP Timothy. 💙💙💙
Prison rules and prisoners rights wouldn’t allow that unfortunately. I hear that women who murder their own children are treated as badly by other inmates in women’s prisons as men who do the same thing are in men’s prisons. Hopefully the guards will be looking the other way if that ever happens.
General population. She's not going to survive
Idc what happen to her oh well find for herself 🤷🤢gross
I loved what this Judge said...Justice for Timothy....He won....What a evil monster she is!!
He got justice he didn't win , a win would have been SOMEONE stopping this before he was murdered 😢
@@lovesallanimals9948 I think the same he won if he was found on time and recovered. 😢😢😢 But he got justice.
He’s in heaven with his creator. He will never suffer again. I’d say that’s a win. He’s out of this insane world of haters and forever free from his monster parents
@@jeanninegunn5412 I disagree
He didn’t win anything he’s dead you can’t win like that no matter what
I am a 64 yr old truck driver. Not sure why I watched this clip. Now I am crying for that young man.
There is some awful things done to kids. There is a who Pedophile/Predator community and who show different courts and givw commentary
😢😢
@theflipper3162 that's good. You're separating yourself from evil.
We ALL are..It takes a REAL MAN STRONG ENOUGH to
cry & show COMPASSION
& CARING..❤🌠
Oh God Bless You. I'm your same age and it also bothered him that none of the Family members did an impact statement. Where was the Father?!
Love this judge for telling her that Timothy won and he saved the younger siblings from going through what he did if she had been cleared. Its so hard to take in how evil she is. I watch this judge's sentence to her every week 😢 Respect to him ❤
Omg when he put that little boys photo up I just broke into tears God love that poor child
Absolutely
To hear the judge say he doesn’t believe she intended to take his life because she wanted the torturing to continue is one of the most chilling things I’ve ever heard. The depth of her depravity knows no bounds.
This is similar to the movie Misery!!! May The Most High Jesus Grant them Peace And Healing IN JESUS NAME
@@VICTORY.inCHRISTJESUS.MINISTRY And where was this "most high" when little Timothy was being literally starved to DEATH by Shanda Vander Ark? Timothy could have used a hand from "JESUS" while he STARVED TO DEATH. It's real easy to invoke god after the evil has done what it's done. Evil exists - its name is Shanda Vander Ark.
Where was god to counter it for Timothy? I won't stop asking that question.
We have free will
@@srirachahero4679 Because there isn't any and if there was, all through the judeo - Christian texts this "most high" is the biggest mass kill@r ever wih far more coming..floods, fires, droughts, plagues etc etc etc
@@srirachahero4679 Precisely.
There’s nothing more deeply tragic or soul wrenching than a child who dies without ever knowing love.
He is in the arms of God now, so he is finally safe and loved. RIP Timothy.
@@stephanietribuna8591Amen!!
This made me feel sad. That poor little boy had no1 in his corner.. Totally heart breaking. He deserved so much more 😢
@@stephanietribuna8591 tell yourself whatever you need to get through life, but there is nothing after death. This evil murderer robbed that boy of everything. At least he suffers no longer.
@@leescott3138I feel sorry for you. I pray you find Jesus before leaving this earth. John 3:16
We need more judges like Judge Matthew Kacel. I hope he is okay himself.
I had a 1-week old baby son while this trial was happening, and it shocked me to my core. The love I feel for my son is so unconditional, I just cannot imagine how someone could hurt their child like this. Thank God Timothy is at peace and she is behind bars away from her.
Some people don’t feel anything, at all, for anyone ever sadly enough
No emotion from her whatsoever. Where have the panic attacks gone all of a sudden and the vomiting?
I guess she could only fake it so long. Pure evil.
She realizes it's over for herself . She knows her fate so no more of a reason to " act" . The women in prison will do a lot to her not just physically but emotionally..verbally everyday .
@@kristinakellogg1732 i hope so! If Justice truly prevails over this wicked, vile creature...karma will definitely pay her a few visits in prison! And by a few, I'm hoping daily! I never liked reading about public stonings from the old testament...but in this case I think it fitting, and I think I would have showed up!
The judge wasn’t having it this time.
@@tamlynn786 I just can’t get over this case. I don’t think Vietnam POW were treated this badly. When I saw the judge put up that photo of him and how sweet and cute he was I lost it. If she didn’t deserve life without parole no one does.
Our country needs more Judge Kacel's. Thank you for bringing justice to Timothy's memory
In Texas where they want to kill children with razor wire
"Kacel's" is possessive.
Kacels is plural.
I guess you didn't learn the difference between the two in elementary school. 🤔🤨🤦🤷
Like so many other people who post comments on TH-cam.🙄👎
All the judges are just like this guy is
@@JediLoreenyou can correct people's grammar without being a condescending prick. Of all the things you could've learned, you chose to ignore manners
@@JediLoreendid correcting something so miniscule on a yt comment make you feel like a big tough man for three seconds? What a loser
I really wish we could have seen her face during her sentencing.
I thank God for this judge!!! He's the most compassionate judge I've ever seen. He went above and beyond his job with reading over the 2,000 text messages 3 different times but also spoke on behalf of everyone who watched this horrific trial. I can't thank you enough Judge Kacel and God Bless you ❤
GOD, if they were as divine as described, would not have let that happen to Timothy in the first place. Do not THANK God for anything that is even remotely connected to the torture and murder of an innocent child. Instead, ask God where he was when Timothy needed him most. Ask him, how DARE he allow this most heinous abuse to be inflicted on a poor mentally disabled child. Expect more from God if you are going to worship him.
I am a woman who was a loving teacher of young children for 28 years. I have a degree in Child and Human Development, and no criminal record whatsoever. I don't drink or smoke and I've never touched a drug.
Yet I am unable to have children, and this evil monster was able to pump out at least THREE, and then goes on to abuse them, and tortures one to death.
Life is unfair.
It is unfair and in the most horrible of ways. I am so sorry you are unable to have children - 🥰
I know it’s not the same, but at least give yourself credit for enriching the lives of all the children for whom you lovingly taught and inspired for the past 28 yrs. You may not have your own children, but you have touched the hearts of so many students to develop a firm foundation towards their future.
May there be many testimonies from them about you and your impact when you decide to retire and beyond. 😊💗🥰
As a teacher, you WERE a wonderful, loving, giving parent to so many. THAT was an important task and purpose that God gave you. What a gift!! It isnt always those who gave birth to a child, who have given them a parent's love and guidance. God made you EXACTLY the way He wanted you!! 🥰🥰
I understand. Hugs to you
Hate to be like this, but if you've ever taken any otc (over the counter) medication that's a drug - or a prescription, still a drug.
Judge Kacel you rock !!! You truly gave justice to Timothy. Your heartfelt words will stay with me forever. THANK YOU !!
So heartfelt, that judge was POINT ON
So very thankful he was the judge & made this powerful & human statement !!
Same here. So glad he never allowed those pictures of Timothy to be shown to the public. I for one think it would’ve broken my heart to see that. He was spot on that she didn’t want Timothy to die, she wanted to torture him forever. She is evil and sadistic. I hope she gets a taste of what she doled out.
frl i’ll always remember this
She's demonic
This case is so upsetting and horrific. I just can't wrap my head around how a mother can do this to her own flesh and blood. They may have gone to jail but that's not enough. If only they could be tortured and made to endure everything that Timothy had to go through. It breaks my heart that nobody else knew what was going on to help Timothy. They are both monsters and deserve to rot in prison.
I’m a bit at ease knowing she’s going to have to face those women in prison who can’t see their kids. I hope they have a time with her. RIP 🪦 LIL Tim.
This judge is absolutely amazing 👏 Timothy WON
No he didn’t. He is dead and she is alive. She is a devil.
Well... no. The kid is still dead. He did not win. There is no justice. And in cases like this, the death penalty should be a very real option.
@@angelaoickle5607I live in Michigan and they don't have the death penalty here..... Absolutely horrible....Prison justice will be nice... Terrible situation overall 😢
What a wonderful compassionate and kind man this Judge is. God bless him!
Amen 🕊
He’s been really amazing throughout this whole trial ❤
I agree ❤
amen!
I have to wonder if she was blk, would she have received the same punishment.
The fact that this vile individual had absolutely NOTHING to say about her actions speaks VOLUMES about who she is...
I love this judge, this man is showing a different side of the justice system. May the Lord bless him and his family for standing by what’s right. Thank you for your service your honor.
She will get her comeuppance in prison. Bring it on.
Hard to believe somebody in prison would take a 'romantic' interest in her, but there has to be somebody out there to teach her not to drop the soap!
Lord I truly hope so 🤬
Hot sauce enemas for life, and if the prison needs a gofundme for those, be happy to set it up.
I hope they don’t rush it though.
@@flamingpitchfork9168Me too. Excellent idea.
The judge showed more compassion for that poor kid than the “mother” ever did.
That’s because she murdered him
@@helenalovelock1030 OK Sherlock
Copying a reply? Lol
You are such a loser wow
@@helenalovelock1030
She wasn't a Mother. She was an evil Monster. 👹
Timothy Rest in Eternal Peace.
No more pain sweetheart. 🕊💗
This is an excellent judge. He spoke with such passion and love for this child. This judge did not mince words whatsoever. I’m so glad he showed Timothys picture. He had more love for him than his own mother. Rip Timothy
Isn't it poetic that the snow is falling with a quiet, gentle whiteness to blanket the landscape, that God holds this child forever in love and life and peace. She will now know how Timothy felt for the rest of her life.
The judge did an excellent job of telling her exactly how bad she tortured her son.
Even with life in prison, this heinous woman is getting treated far, far better than what she actually deserves. What she did to this boy is unforgiveable.
I'm sure once the moms in prison find out what she did, she will wish she was dead.
Just wait until the other inmates find out what she did and gets ahold of her.
I agree, 100% because it went on for a long time all of Timothy’s life. It was not something short-lived. I don’t even want to think about what he went through as a baby.
Prison karma will make things right.
Pearl Fernandez is getting hers, I’m sure shandra is up there on the shank list, at least when they find out. I love hearing story’s on how inmates are toying with pearl. Can’t wait to here about this monsters stay.
I've been struggling to know how to process this, as the mum of a 17 year old boy with autism. My boy struggles in an educational setting, I fought to keep him in mainstream school, and now he is in college, still struggling. Yet our family has never given up, knowing he deserves the world. His father and stepmother were showing signs of using food to punish him if he wouldn't eat, giving him bread and jam sandwiches as lunch, standing him in a corner when he wouldn't talk (in his early years his speech was extremely limited) I wasn't allowed to ask how his visits to his dad went, as family court in the UK frown upon anything they perceive as parental alienation. He went to school at the age of ten, struggling to articulate how he felt at the way they were treating him. Ultimately, a social services council worker advised me to stop the contact as we were both being emotionally abused by his father and wife, and risk being taken back to court. Which luckily didn't happen. Seeing those slight similarities has shocked me to the core. I wish poor Timothy had a warm and loving family, no matter what the issues, it's the very least of what he deserved. I feel for Paul, but thankfully he is taking accountability. For Shanda, there is no hell hot or deep enough.
She will face the ultimate JUDGE one day!! .....
The country needs more people like this judge.
Death penalty!!!
Nah, this isn't justice. The country needs people that sentence her to Scaphism.
Absolutely
@@elainethomas9532If only there was something more painful and harsher.
I was thinking the same thing.
Go Judge M...you told her the truth in her face. No more lies or excuses. She intentionally tortured this beautiful soul.
I loved watching her cheek twitch with her odd ticks...I'm sure the ladies in prison will have a good time with this vile wicked creature!
😢😢😢
@@angiehayes7397 😥
God rest his precious, sweet soul 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
One of the most compassionate and fair sentencings I have ever witnessed.
Gotta respect he didn’t allow any of his torture photos in open court. Gave Timothy the respect no one else would. Expressed his deep disappointment that no one spoke as a victim impact statement. Kudos, sir.
The judge did a phenomenal job !
What a beautiful man that judge is...no arrogance, just love for a little boy who endured a life I can't even think about.
there Is no such thing as a beautiful judge. alongside cops they are the worst piece rubbish of our society , only there to defend the wealthiest interests
Absolutely right !
Yes.
The evil things judges hear daily.Bless this man.😢💕😢💕
I hope she gets what she deserves in prison from inmates.
Absolutely
She is the reason they should have the death penalty.
She will die in prison. I bet sooner than she thinks. Prisoners have morality in there, I hear. They will handle her
The death penalty is an emotional reaction, not a logical one. Vengeance has no place in justice. or law.
@@xtinkerbellax3 thank you for saying that. I try to tell people but they get angry.
Not only no place in law, but no place at all.
I have got my vengeance many times, and it never once subsides the pain.
Eye for an eye is barbaric n it heals nothing. Ur always left with that pain until u learn to let go
I think adult thieves should have their offending hand removed@@xtinkerbellax3
@@xtinkerbellax3oh yes it does.
What an amazing judge...preserving this young man's dignity...
Yes. I wholly agree
AGREED WHOOOLEHEARTEDLY❤🙏❤🙏❤🙏❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Agreed 👏👏👏👏
This judge is realy a "Honerable" person! So considered, so empathic, so respectful. We need more judges like that. But I feel also sorry for any judge, police officer etc. to have to deal with the horrors of cases like that.
This judges speech really broke my heart 😢
I couldn't imagine treating an animal that way, let alone a child with special needs. This was beyond heartbreaking. May this sweet boy rest in peace 🕊️
I agree with all you said Alison 💕❤️
I was just telling my husband “I can’t even imagine treating one of my precious CHICKENS this way!!! CHICKENS!! Let alone a human being…
I do believe that some people are Evil, truly Evil… now, weather that Evil is born, or made??? Idk?? I guess it really doesn’t matter how they get that way…
Sick, sick, sick… thank GOD Almighty above ❤️💕🙏🏼 she can not birth more children to abuse.
I still say Timothy saved his younger siblings from harm. He really did! With his death, he saved them 💔🙏🏼😢
Wishing all in the comments blessings and happiness 💕❤️🙏🏼
People do even worse to animals.
Well in fact She didn’t treat her Dog that way. The prosecution grilled her on that fact.
@@BostonHollyAndSnoopsadly yes, let’s hope for change
@@nickv7793So would you have been happy if she had treated her dog that way,why do you people always bring animals into this? Hundreds of animals are tortured and killed by their owners and others,worse done to them on a daily basis, atleast in this case the little boy got justice,but in most animal abuse cases they get a slap on the wrist and walk free,stop turning this into a human versus animal issue,all life matters,no one is more important than the other, cruelty is exactly what it is,whether to a human or animal.
A judge with heart. He truly did his best to honor Timothy.
THIS IS ONE PHENOMENAL JUDGE!!! NOT ONLY DID HE GIVE TIMOTHY HIS DIGNITY HE SHOWED HIS EMOTIONS IN AWAY ALL OF US FEEL OVER WHAT SHE DID TO THAT CHILD. my grandson is 5 and non verbal autistic my biggest fear is how he is treated in this world bc he is absolutely perfect and innocent so pure and the thought of anyone hurting him makes me physically sick. Also I respect this JUDGE and all Judges when they also stand for the jury because they know they deserve that respect. Not all judges do stand up and I always think it's the arrogance of a judge. BUT this JUDGE is amazing and the jury in this case gave justice to Timothy who so deserved a better life. My heart just hurts for that child. I hope he can now Rest in Peace.
This Judge is Absolutely Amazing hope he gives her son same sentence
I think the son needs consequences and accountability but I think there's a possible chance he could be rehabilitated being away from his mother. She had him so brainwashed
This judge deserves a round of applause, and a big hug. To thank AND comfort him.
True. He needs comfort. He agonized over this case and will never forget it.
This judge gave Timothy the dignity he deserved... I was crying so hard... judge spoke for all of us especially Timothy.
We have to thank this judge!
This Judge was so so articulate, spoton and covered it all.
She is just pure evil. I hope she gets what she deserves in jail.
She probably won't last there...
Her public defender can’t wait to get away from her You can tell the disgust he has for this trash sitting next to him
Unfortunately she won't. I worked at a female prison for 7 years. The women don't give a shit about their crime. Not one bit. So that sucks.
@@kevinm9 I don't know much about female inmates but in my country, if prisoners (male) know one of them is there for abusing a child, he's a goner. Even criminals have their own lines to draw...
Not true, i have a relative who worked in a state penitentiary. it's worse than a male penitentiary. @kevinm9
I've been a Paramedic for 30 years and my wife has been a RN in the ER for 30 years as well. We've taken care of countless children as if they were our own. We have never had children, not from a lack of trying. 23 years later still married and still no children. We would have loved to have these two beautiful children running around our house. Being happy and free. And filling them with loved affection and a caring family and home.
😢❤bless you and your wife for all you do
THANK Y'ALL FOR YOUR SERVICE ❤❤
God knows who you are and he is very pleased. Please seek him out and let him be your guide.
@@french2two How do you know he is not allready a good christian?? To me it looks like it.. and stop talking like YOU know what God is happy about like you are his messenger.. i can not stand this type of religipous entitlement!
Troll@@goymedhundDogtrainingBehavior
Love this judge he had more compassion for this boy then his own mom. Love when he said “Timothy won you did not win”
If you called being tortured to death winning... Then you need help
50 -100 years in prison for abusing her son.👎
What a shame her punishment can’t be exactly what she did to her son !
100%
She did it to both sons, Paul was controlled by the narcissistic mother
It will be worse for her in prison. She's likely to be killed there.
Doing to her what she did to that boy would make them monsters
I agree. Treat her in jail line she treated her son.!!! Eye for an eyr.
Thank God the judge stood up for him in such an eloquent way!!! His words brought tears to my eyes. 😢 RIP little Timothy
I agree and every single word he said hit the nail on the head! I love this judge and he got the sentence right! R.I.P. beautiful child and you have gotten your justice. No more suffering.
@@jusDjango TRUST ME TIMOTHY IS LIVING BETTER NOW THAN YOU EVER WILL
@@jusDjangoNot only where was 'God', but what kind of 'God' would create a world where such cruelty plays out, and do absolutely nothing! Sickening.
@@2FLY-gs1qtOnly a monster, given the choice to create a world with suffering or without, would choose WITH suffering. A monster!
@@T_R_TiffanyRose95... You are just as evil. I will pray for you. Maybe if you would read the word in the Holy Bible you MIGHT would understand, our Creator did not do this to him. It has nothing to do with God.
I hope her forever home will be soooo frightening that this monster will live the next 70+ years in complete and utter terror.
She doesn't care. It's just that straightforward.
She should have made to stand up & look at the judge whilst being sentenced ... What an evil human being ...
Even her lawyer couldn't stand to look or talk to her. He was 100% there out of obligation. I love that photo of Timothy. What's sad is there is no healthy photo of him as a teenager. :(
There’s one of him and Paul with matching t-shirts. Sweet child smiling with dimples. 😢
I found just one on the internet. Him&Paul favor.
@@donnaglogowski3619Wish I could see it!
Nobody loved him enough to take his photo. It’s just awful. His dad kicked him out the day his brother turned 18 (kicked him out too), saying he “couldn’t handle” Timothy anymore. The timing tells me that it was more that he saw his chance to get rid of both of them when Paul turned 18 and be done with them entirely. Sent Timothy to someone who had never and would never love him. Who tortured him for the rest of his sad short life. What a beautiful smile that sweet boy had too.
Very sad what happened to him she could have put him in a nursing home for the disabled. Somebody would have helped him.
I always appreciate a judge who very clearly speaks from a place of empathy and decency for those who cannot speak for themselves. He did that poor boy a great service.
agreed
And MANY OTHERS !
That is his job at this point sadly. If someone else had done their job and saved this boy he wouldn't have passed away for it to get here. I am rightously angry every time I see a judge have to make one of these speaches on behalf of a child. If someone else hadn't failed this poor boy it wouldn't have ended up being this judge's job to be his last voice.
@@caseyj779yes.. i do not know this full story [don't really want to, either] listening to the judge is enough to cause a powerful emotional reaction in me.
*this boy suffered worst treatment than the majority of tortured prisoners of war
This judge professing :
"Timothy Won"
*that brave little boy..
*enduring what no other creation of G-d ever should have
Shanda told a friend on the phone she thought her PTSD would get her sympathy from the court. Thank goodness nothing mattered to the judge.
This woman was a sadist and, for some reason, hated her son. We have these sort of cases in the UK. It’s incomprehensible and sad. Well done to the judge for his impact statement. No remorse shown on the face of the defendant. One hard person.
No empathy for her son,
No respect for the courts.
No remorse for what she did.
This creature is unhuman and needs to be treated as such.
May she live a long suffering life.
You misspelled SHORT as long.
@@robertwalker5521 No mistake, I do hope she does have a LONG SUFFERING LIFE. Try prison life an you will understand what it means..
@@robertwalker5521 you've never been to prison.....
Original comment was removed..
@@tartanmctwisted0218
I HAVE been to prison a few times...As Military
Police. Lock up the drunk soldiers...
Usually, the next shift brought them back
to base...and I did the paper work.
I am wise enough to stay clean.
A Dishonorable Discharge can cost an
ex-GI many thousands of $$$$ over
their lifetime.
@@robertwalker5521 you seem to be a level headed gentleman and I understand about the revolving doors,
Being locked up is nowhere near the same as being the person with the keys and doing papers work..
You know what goes on in these institutions while you do you're paper work, no disrespect my friend but it sure ain't the same....
Thank you Judge Kacel for delivering justice for Timothy and for all Americans. We cannot allow each other to treat children this way.
Beautiful comment and I agree. "In the arm's of the Angel's Beautiful Tomothy" you are Loved now. Wonderful Judge. Kindest thoughts to you and your family and Furbabies from Australia 🕯🧸🙏🦋🐞
He’s an incredible judge. That final statement of his was quite something. Such a kind & empathetic man. There needs to be more like him.
I don't want to start an argument or anything I just want to leave an idea out there and hope it means something to other people but the biggest problem we as a society face is treating children like adults. Whether it's someone trying to date a teenager or a parent abusing them it all comes from a place of being able to convince yourself that the child you're talking to is just as mentally capable as yourself and holding them to that standard. I'm not trying to justify anyone that's abused a child but I do want other people to look inside and think about what they get mad at children for and think about how reasonable it is for a child to know any better.
@@Just.ArguingAnd calling 18 yr-old children 'adults' is ridiculous!!!
@@laragara I think anyone under 25 is still somewhat in child mode, I agree with you
My mother and step-father abused me. Severely. In unimaginable ways as a small child. One of the most chilling things I remember was her telling me almost every night that she was taking me to the middle of nowhere to abandon me. When really she was going to get drugs.
Cases like this remind me of what I've been through, and it makes me feel like i shouldn't be here anymore.
Sadistic abuse from a parent leave scars and wounds that can never heal. The memories are so painful that its a knee-jerk reaction to just end it, just to make the memories stop.
Thank you for getting justice for just one of the many kids in this world who died long before the breath actually left their bodies...
As a father and grandfather, I cannot, CAN NOT, wrap my head around how some people can do things like this to a child.
What people fail to realize that a proportion of the population is mentally incapable of supporting a normal society. This is an illness that is destroying our world everywhere. A large group of people think that people can be changed, modified, treated or whatever but these people will be with us always. The greater the population the more visible these sick individuals become.
The only reason is she was demon possessed!
Evilness
I couldn't do that to my pitbull who I spoiled rotten let alone to a child
@@wolfpacguy3824I have tried, and I cannot. I am just too far the opposite way. it almost makes me believe in god, how could something be that evil? only something not human. that is beyond something being wrong with the brain, or some childhood trauma. it’s otherworldly.
This judge is amazing. I burst into tears, when he showed the picture and explained he didnt allow evidence photos, to be shown to the public for Timothys sake, so the world wouldnt remember him like that. And i know the worst punishment he gave her was looking her in the eyes and saying "Timothy won, you lost. The world knows what you are now"
Such a heartbreaking case. May his soul rest
And yet she was not (emotional) incredible, not a tear shed. Strangers are heartbroken for her son and she just sits like she is annoyed by the lecture - pure evil.
Respect to this judge and the prosecuting lawyer. 🙌
Judge is amazing you could tell he was emotional and rightly so. She didn't give a toss evil, she will no doubt get hers in prison. What a lovely looking you boy may he RIP, god bless.
The very definition of EVIL.
Thank you Judge Kacel for your heart and eloquence.
Man...this judge honored Tim in such a good way. Had me in tears. She's a monster
I disagree... some monsters are nice.. she is A DEMON!!!
the judge is whiny. i know the mother is wrong. but hes really upset about hot sauce?
@@tennis551tell me you didn’t watch this without telling me. 🙄
I suppose you’re an abuser too.
Absolutely! I think just about everyone was in tears.wonderful Judge.
Makes no difference. The judge is grandstanding, and enjoying his movie drama speech. None of this will get through to a woman like that. There’s no point. Sentence her and move on. Throw away the key.
To Shanda, (nuclear control freak), this was WAR. And since she is also a sociopath, she just isn't capable of any genuine empathy. I love that the judge taunted her by telling her that Timothy had won.
My wife really finds this judge has wisdom and undrstanding. Thank you God for defending this child.
As an abused child that was placed in foster care at 1 1/2 years of age, I approved this message and sentence in prison!!!
❤
🙏 God bless you Sir!
How do you think we can change things?
❤❤
Glad to see you are doing well🙂
I love that he said “Timothy won!”Poor little boy is no longer in pain. These cases sicken me. I’ve never been able to have a child. I will never understand these awful cases.
@Onelightoftheworld - This was a horrendous situation... Sorry for your difficulties with child bearing I wish this boy would have been born to you so he could of had a chance to know the unconditional love of a mother with all of the caring and compassion he deserved in this life!
She had choices to give him up.for adoption
I am so sorry that you weren't able to have children but I am glad that you will never understand the mind of people like this. May the vast majority of the world never understand this kind of mindset.
Being 47 years old and having grown up with an abusive mother who hit her children, bullying and phytologically terrorized them I must admit I had thought/hoped society would have become better at protecting children over the years, how could a case like this happen nowadays, how can a child be treated this horrible and no one notices. Society fail this kid, his mother is a monster, but society failed miserably, when a judge said he is glad the child died so he could finally get peace, it just sounds like resignation and something that couldn't be prevented.
It is a sad fact of life that people who should never had been allowed to have children get them, while good people like you with the heart at the right place can't. Sometimes the world just sucks, and I am sorry that you have ´been denied the chance to becoming a good mother. Why not considered adoption, change a child's life for the better?
No, we didn’t because she’s still breathing.
The snow falling outside is so poetic. Rest in peace Timothy.
Why did no one stand up to help him??? Can't get my head around that, beyond me.
She showed no emotion when he put the picture up. Even her own attorney wouldn’t look at her. Evil woman.
She’s no woman- 👺🪳👹💩
I just tucked my 11 year old boy into bed and kissed his head. He still loves to be tucked at 11. A child needs and wants their mothers life like they need oxygen. This woman is deeply disturbed, hell awaits her. 😢😢😢😢😢😢
Not to burst your bubble, but 90-95% of all people I know say that its their dad they love the most. In my childhood it was my father who wanted to spend time with his kids, play board games, go rafting, helping with schoolwork or take us with him to work (he was a truck driver). When they got divorced he cried because even at ages 14 and 17 he fear losing us, my dear mother on the other hand wanted nothing more then to be free of the responsibility of having us, she wanted to "experience the youth she never had" becoming a mother at age 19, so to my loving mother drinking and partying was more important... not saying you or every women is a bad mother, but frankly the idea that it is always the mother that is the most loving is simply not true
@@fenris6051 Fucking really, dude? What do you get out of that?
Sounds like your kid gets picked on and is a sissy. You are gonna make his life tough
@@fenris6051mommas boy, and daddy's little girl. Most sons love their mom most, and most daughters love their dad most. But if you're lucky enough to have two wonderful loving parents, you should love both of them equally. It's okay if you have different loves, but one shouldn't negate the other. I love pizza, and ice cream. Two completely different foods. But I love them both for different reasons.
@@yoskibroski3446 - oh you are so weak you get offended when presented with another view. OP posted "A child needs and wants their mothers life like they need oxygen" what a load of self delusional BS, just like the fat girls thinking they are a 10 out 10. Reality and even TH-cam tells a different story, but hey live your lie.
The Judge speaks for the victim , remembers him and gave him justice ♡
Rest in Peace little Timothy
"You don't win."
Amen, judge. Well said.
This judge is great. I love how he pointed out that one of her texts said "We can't let Timothy win" and then he went on to say, "Timothy won". That hit hard. He's free now from all pain and suffering, and she gets to sit and rot and spend the rest of her life thinking about what she did.
Yes and sociopathic people always have to WIN. I feel like the judge knows that and that's why he wanted to make that statement and let it ring in her ears for the rest of her life.
That's something her sick mind can understand, so that she can realize she is totally defeated.
Ding Dong The Witch Is Dead the wicked witch is dead - as far as her ever hurting anyone again. I hope she doesn't find her a girlfriend or a protector in prison, I hope she's treated mercilessly in there. She must be reincarnated from an evil WW2 N* zi camp guard 😢 Yes Timothy, whatever type of person he was or woul have become, died like a holocaust victim... without a chance.
Oh, she so needs to feel what it's like to to be fed hot sauce, have ice baths forced on her, limited time to use the bathroom etc.
Timothy did win. But she won't bother thinking about it. She has zero remorse. As far as she is concerned, Timothy was in the wrong and deserved what he got.