What a pair of interpreters! Hvorostovsky is probably my favorite Germont of all I've seen, and Fleming is always SUCH perfection it's not even fair. I've never seen her in a full production of Traviata, must be brilliant.
Totul este foarte frumos, opera Traviata, de Verdi, aria cântată din această operă, vocile implicate în duet. Dumnezeu să-l odihnească în pace, pe baritonul Dmitri Hvorostovski. 🎼🎶👑🙏😢🥀👏💕🕊️🌾
Great acting on stage. Two of my favorite opera singers and now only one lives to bless us. Thank goodness Dimo recorded so much, and thanks to all who post these videos.
Bravissimi tutti e due certo che Dmitri ci manca moltissimo è difficile vivere senza di lui perché era stupendo e bravo in tutto ciò che faceva e non si può smettere di amarlo xxx
Fleming and Hvorostovsky - It just does not get any better. How I still mourn the passing of that outstanding baritone. The great Architect got it very wrong, when Dmitri Hvorostovsky was taken from us.
Золотые Голоса мирового оперного искусства !!!!! Благородный Красавец Дмитрий и Трепетная, Нежная Рене - сколько радости и счастья подарили вы зрителям !!!!! Вы, и сегодня, заполняете этот Мир Красотой, Нежностью и Любовью !!!!!! Браво, Рене !!! Браво, Дмитрий !!!!! Искренняя благодарность за эту превосходную публикацию !!!
Гениальный дуэт! Как я люблю эту сцену из "Травиаты"В исполнении Рене и Дмитрия!! Какой драматизм, какие необыкновенные голоса! Взгляд, малейший жест, легкая улыбка - и не нужно никакого перевода Все ясно и ТАК. Незабываемый , любимый Дмтрий Александрович, память о Вас вечно будет в наших сердцах, голос Ваш забыть невозможно.
Pasaron varios años de éste momento... recién hace dias que supe de la poca existencia de Dimitri... mi alma se aconggoja de saber que en esta vida ya no está. Me quedan sus obras para escucharlas y admirar que hubo un hombre tan maravilloso con su voz de barítono lirico. D E P DIMITRI.
Cara Renee, ebbene, ogni volta è la conferma: tu sei la grandissima diva del bel canto: intensamente drammatico, sottile nelle sfumature, sensuale nel sentimento che tu mai banalizzi. Voce, timbro, espressione, interpretazione: tutto in te è esemplare e perfetto. Insuperabile nel Trovatore e così in Traviata, che sia rendere in tutta la sua nuda fragilità di donna innamorata ma incostante. La modulazione della tua voce è maestria di studio e talento
Sapendolo morto così giovane per la crudele malattia del secolo mi commuove sempre ascoltarlo perché penso a quant'altro avrebbe potuto darci RIP DMITRI 😢😢😢 Annamaria Lovati
I cannot stop listening to this beautiful piece. Thank you so much for posting frufruJ ... and thank you too for all the text. It is so nice to be able to follow what they are singing. I have a chronic lung disease and this duet is among my favorite medicine. The voices never cease to lift my spirits - on an almost daily basis!
Birgit Halberg Sorry to read about your ailment. I have a different one. This whole opera, tho’ Mozart’s are my favourites, is one of my most effective medicines. Hang in there. And continue to enjoy!
La Fleming canta senza la ''lagrima'' nella voce,per me canto freddo e calcolato. adoro questa ragazza perché à volte /con qualche suono,qualche emozione/ mi fa impazzire! brava ! Dima come sempre con la sua voce e sensibilità artistica è un esempio unico di 'raffinatezza' artistica e di 'buon' gusto interpretativo... no comment. ps. e poi i giovani intenditori con la loro 'sensibilità unica' cercano di convincermi che la volgarità interpretativa non esiste nell'arte lirica moderna?...
Прекрасная опера,,Травиата,, композитор Джузеппе Верди! Чудесный дуэт Виолетта Валери и Жорж Жермон-Рене Флеминг/лирическое сопрано- США/! Дмитрий Хворостовский/драматический баритон-Россия/! БРАВИССИМО!!! С уважением, Валерий Романов.
Yes, it is agony indeed. Still unbelievable. He is so beautiful and strong of voice and person here. Alas this is our human condition. We never know when we or someone we love will be struck down by an incurable illness.
Mio caro Dimitri mi manchi tanto..avevi tutto: bontà d animo..talento..bellezza..insomma eri uno dei più bravi baritono al.mondo e sei andato via precocemente..riposa in pace..resti nei cuori di tutti..
I LOVE You ENDLESS !!! Y MENIA MNOGO, MNOGO SLEZAI DLIA Dmitri Hvorostovski !!! God BLESS Dmitri Hvorostovski's SOUL !!! Always with a lot of love and light ETERNAL FEN Nadia Mirkova and the all my big family from Sofia - Bulgaria
I saw him a few years before he died, at the R.O.H. Covent Garden, in this same role of Papa Germont. He was wonderful!. Diana Damrau was Violeta then. I shall always be grateful that I was able to see him “live” even if it was only that once. Now I console myself by playing all the videos of his concerts and operas that I have. The one of Eugene Onegin is also with Renée Fleming. They are both fantastic in it!
Lourdes Torres - I am very jealous that you got to hear him live. My consolation is that I can hear/see him in these wonderful videos. No one ever gets old. No one ever dies and opera lives on. Bravissimi!
@@mckavitt13 I never had the chance to see him live either in person or on the telly. But I love him all the same. One of the best baritones the world has seen and a good human being as well. If I were Tosca I would have changed the opera so I could run away with this Scarpia.
It’s amazing how really outstanding artists can impressively change convenient interpretation of very familiar operatic scenes. To Turn this scene into kind of confession of innocent soul to practically aggressive “priest”. Amazing reverse of typical “gentle seductive” Germont soothing La Traviata, excited and even “hostile”in the beginning . Watch her humping posture, submissive actions and gentle”whispering” singing compare to aggressive hawkish behavior of Dmitri, harsh dominating tone and short, brief phrasing. Distance and stiff figure acting almost as prosecutor, and singing intentionally “flat”, nuanceless. Amazing.
Gorgeous, both singing and acting. One request: KEEP THE CAMERA ON THE SINGERS! We don't go to the opera to see the orchestra. With these two singers in particular it is a shame to miss any of their wonderful expressiveness, musically or facially or physically.
Sublime duo ,inoubliable et incomparable .Un miracle d'ineffable beauté , miracle d'art à ses plus hauts sommets d'accomplissement touchant le comble de la perfection, miracle de pures et saintes émotions. Превосходный дуэт , незабываемый и несравненный . Чудо несказываемой красоты, чудо искусства до его самих высоких вершин завершения, достигнутого верха совершенства, чудо истинных и святих эмоций.
Fleming’s voice control is phenomenal. Both voices are the finest. We lost greatness with the death of Hvorostovsky.
What a pair of interpreters! Hvorostovsky is probably my favorite Germont of all I've seen, and Fleming is always SUCH perfection it's not even fair. I've never seen her in a full production of Traviata, must be brilliant.
At least there are recordings to remember that wonderful voice and we can see his beautiful face
Renée is in a class of her own. The control is unbelievable. Dmitri too is in a class of his own.
Such a perfection of both, on the top of The World.. !
Exceptional two of the worlds greatest singers
Ce couple reunissait deux voix extraordinaires et assorties à merveille !
Fabulous
These two make a phenomenal duo. I could listen to them until the end of time!!!
Its almost too beautiful for words. They are both beyond exceptional, and their voices together are a gift to the world.
Renee has such a beautiful singing voice! I love her tone, precision and expression. Amazing! Bravo ❤
Pure Joy to watch and listen to these beautiful voices, what a miss he is,
Their voices don't simply blend. They compliment each other.
Totul este foarte frumos, opera Traviata, de Verdi, aria cântată din această operă, vocile implicate în duet.
Dumnezeu să-l odihnească în pace, pe baritonul Dmitri Hvorostovski.
🎼🎶👑🙏😢🥀👏💕🕊️🌾
It was such a pleasure to watch such great voices in an emotive, sensitive and commanding performance Loved it.
Great acting on stage. Two of my favorite opera singers and now only one lives to bless us. Thank goodness Dimo recorded so much, and thanks to all who post these videos.
What a pair.. can’t possibly get any better than this here performance. Both sounding glorious. Bravi tutti!
Лучший жермон,прекрасная Виолетта,лучшег исполнения не слышала!!
Браво, браво, браво🌸💓💓💓❤️🌸💓
Mille grazie, thousand thx, truely miraculos, divine grace, love from Germany
Bravissimi tutti e due certo che Dmitri ci manca moltissimo è difficile vivere senza di lui perché era stupendo e bravo in tutto ciò che faceva e non si può smettere di amarlo xxx
Will dearly miss Dimitri whose vocals were worldwide masterpiece !
This extraordinary performance is also dear to my heart because it is in the magical Tchaikovsky theater. Much love to RF and DH. Still missing you 😞.
Какое волшебство!!!
Ах, каждый какое Волшебство!!!!!!!!!!Поют........!!!!!!!¡!
Fleming and Hvorostovsky - It just does not get any better. How I still mourn the passing of that outstanding baritone. The great Architect got it very wrong, when Dmitri Hvorostovsky was taken from us.
He left us in pain
Zeze Mostafa lets be thankful for the time we enjoyed him- a mystery that cannot be comprehended
Heart broken x
Death is mans enemy yet it's part of living.The day is coming when no one will say I am sick. Psalms 37. 10--12. 🌏🌎🌍💙🌿🌹🙏🎵🎶🎼
Zeze Mostafa His pain was greater, I’ll wager.
Счастье,Радость,Восхищение,Наслаждение:слушать смотреть и плакать от этого Великолепия!!!!!!!!!Брависсимо!!!!!!!!!!2024 год август.
Breathtaking performance by two of the very best voices and artists of the last many years.Bravi!!
Смотрю,слушаю,наслаждаюсь,огромное спасибо за такое удовольствие!Помним и любим,Димочка,тебя!!!!
Золотые Голоса мирового оперного искусства !!!!! Благородный Красавец Дмитрий и Трепетная, Нежная Рене - сколько радости и счастья подарили вы зрителям !!!!! Вы, и сегодня, заполняете этот Мир Красотой, Нежностью и Любовью !!!!!!
Браво, Рене !!! Браво, Дмитрий !!!!!
Искренняя благодарность за эту превосходную публикацию !!!
Вы всё отлично сказали.
"Piangi, piangi" e piango in effetti ascoltando questa aria che assomiglia al canto degli angeli.
The mingle of their voices! Oh my God!
Every negative thought is banished when I listen to such beauty.
Maravilloso dueto....
Espectacular video , traviata. Y voces angelicales .desde Sabadell. Barcelona. España.❤,😘 buenas noches
Amazing duet! Amazing voices and acting! Im happy and sad at the same time! 😧
Гениальный дуэт! Как я люблю эту сцену из "Травиаты"В исполнении Рене и Дмитрия!! Какой драматизм, какие необыкновенные голоса! Взгляд, малейший жест, легкая улыбка - и не нужно никакого перевода Все ясно и ТАК. Незабываемый , любимый Дмтрий Александрович, память о Вас вечно будет в наших сердцах, голос Ваш забыть невозможно.
ALL World LOVE Dmitri Hvorostovski !!! Nadia Mirkova - Bulgaria
SIMPLY DIVINE !!! ENDLESS BRAVO !!! ENDLESS THANK You !!! Nadia Mirkova - Sofia - Bulgaria
Two of the most beautiful voices singing divinely
Not a dull and boring performance by any means. Two such dynamic singers, giving there all .
Thanks for sharing. What a beautiful performance by two beautiful people, with voices to match. Sheer joy!
Pasaron varios años de éste momento... recién hace dias que supe de la poca existencia de Dimitri... mi alma se aconggoja de saber que en esta vida ya no está. Me quedan sus obras para escucharlas y admirar que hubo un hombre tan maravilloso con su voz de barítono lirico. D E P DIMITRI.
Magnificent timeless performance in my beloved Moscow concervatory
Dmitri was such a voice! Such a man. Un grande huomo. R.I.P.
Cara Renee, ebbene, ogni volta è la conferma: tu sei la grandissima diva del bel canto: intensamente drammatico, sottile nelle sfumature, sensuale nel sentimento che tu mai banalizzi. Voce, timbro, espressione, interpretazione: tutto in te è esemplare e perfetto. Insuperabile nel Trovatore e così in Traviata, che sia rendere in tutta la sua nuda fragilità di donna innamorata ma incostante. La modulazione della tua voce è maestria di studio e talento
When great voices unite and the chemistry is there, magic is created.
She acts Violetta the way I always imagined. I've heard singers whose singing I preferred in the role, but Fleming is Violetta for me.
Same here. 😊😊
Sapendolo morto così giovane per la crudele malattia del secolo mi commuove sempre ascoltarlo perché penso a quant'altro avrebbe potuto darci RIP DMITRI 😢😢😢
Annamaria Lovati
Look at these two. Bellisamo !
I don't know of two who could have sung it better ! Formidable !
I cannot stop listening to this beautiful piece. Thank you so much for posting frufruJ ... and thank you too for all the text. It is so nice to be able to follow what they are singing. I have a chronic lung disease and this duet is among my favorite medicine. The voices never cease to lift my spirits - on an almost daily basis!
Birgit Halberg Sorry to read about your ailment. I have a different one. This whole opera, tho’ Mozart’s are my favourites, is one of my most effective medicines. Hang in there. And continue to enjoy!
Yes, one should always have the text.
Una coppia meravigliosa ❤️
Браво, браво!!! Бриллианты голоса! Невозможно наслушаться...
Ong one of the greatest barritones in the word RIp Dimitri xxx
Cannot believe you have gone
Shocking that his glorious vioice was stilled so early. RIP.
Gratitude to the Creator of all these creators, composer, conductor, musicians, and the darling singers.
Just listening to this again and it is so uplifting and beautiful in this time of lockdown😊
La Fleming canta senza la ''lagrima'' nella voce,per me canto freddo e calcolato.
adoro questa ragazza perché à volte /con qualche suono,qualche emozione/ mi fa impazzire!
brava !
Dima come sempre con la sua voce e sensibilità artistica è un esempio unico di 'raffinatezza' artistica e di 'buon' gusto interpretativo...
no comment.
ps. e poi i giovani intenditori con la loro 'sensibilità unica' cercano di convincermi che la volgarità interpretativa non esiste nell'arte lirica moderna?...
Pure magic and timeless. And two beautiful artists at their prime.
DIVINE VOICES !!! BRAVO !!! Nadia Mirkova FROM Buglgaria
Какой волшебный дуэт! Сердце разрывается!
Adio, adio... :'(
Magnifica! Diva Renee Fleming is electric. Thank you, frufruJ.
Beautiful! I love them both!
i can hear it over and over again.
Прекрасная опера,,Травиата,, композитор Джузеппе Верди!
Чудесный дуэт Виолетта Валери и Жорж Жермон-Рене Флеминг/лирическое сопрано- США/!
Дмитрий Хворостовский/драматический баритон-Россия/!
БРАВИССИМО!!!
С уважением, Валерий Романов.
Травиата
@@sergeigalyuk
Благодарю Вас!
Непростительная опечатка с моей стороны!
С уважением, Валерий Романов.
The two most beautiful voices in the world ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Absolutely equisitie. Brilliant.
This is very beautiful and sensitive.
Beautiful! Dimitri for ever!
Perfect performances. But it is agony to see Dimitri here and know he is gone from us. Terrible loss for his family.
Yes, it is agony indeed. Still unbelievable. He is so beautiful and strong of voice and person here. Alas this is our human condition. We never know when we or someone we love will be struck down by an incurable illness.
Mio caro Dimitri mi manchi tanto..avevi tutto: bontà d animo..talento..bellezza..insomma eri uno dei più bravi baritono al.mondo e sei andato via precocemente..riposa in pace..resti nei cuori di tutti..
the two most beautiful voices of this century!
"Beautiful"is always very relative.....
Jean Maurice Dennery I
oh god, you seem to know nothing about operatic voices. there where hundreds of better singers and mor beautiful voices.
Jean Maurice Dennery Two OF the most beautiful, I grant you!
mckavitt13 You are absolutely right!!
Dusza człowieka emanuje nieprzebranym pięknem.
Какая нежная в розовом платье Рене Флемминг, просто ангел, удовольствие, наслаждение слушать таких исполнителей. Интеллектуальное лакомство!
I LOVE You ENDLESS !!! Y MENIA MNOGO, MNOGO SLEZAI DLIA Dmitri Hvorostovski !!! God BLESS Dmitri Hvorostovski's SOUL !!! Always with a lot of love and light ETERNAL FEN Nadia Mirkova and the all my big family from Sofia - Bulgaria
Prelep duet~samo slusati i slusati...andjeoski glasovi oplemenjuju!
Прекрасное исполнение такого трудного дуэта! Браво!!!
An angelic vision to be sure!
I saw him a few years before he died, at the R.O.H. Covent Garden, in this same role of Papa Germont. He was wonderful!. Diana Damrau was Violeta then. I shall always be grateful that I was able to see him “live” even if it was only that once. Now I console myself by playing all the videos of his concerts and operas that I have. The one of Eugene Onegin is also with Renée Fleming. They are both fantastic in it!
Lourdes Torres Live suffices. No "..."
Lourdes Torres - I am very jealous that you got to hear him live. My consolation is that I can hear/see him in these wonderful videos. No one ever gets old. No one ever dies and opera lives on. Bravissimi!
@@shirleyrombough8173 I saw him Live a few times, but on telly.
@@mckavitt13 I never had the chance to see him live either in person or on the telly. But I love him all the same. One of the best baritones the world has seen and a good human being as well. If I were Tosca I would have changed the opera so I could run away with this Scarpia.
@@shirleyrombough8173 How I understand you. Cavaradossi is often sung by a nil tenor too. 🙆
It’s amazing how really outstanding artists can impressively change convenient interpretation of very familiar operatic scenes. To Turn this scene into kind of confession of innocent soul to practically aggressive
“priest”. Amazing reverse of typical “gentle seductive” Germont soothing La Traviata, excited and even “hostile”in the beginning . Watch her humping posture, submissive actions and gentle”whispering” singing compare to aggressive hawkish behavior of Dmitri, harsh dominating tone and short, brief phrasing. Distance and stiff figure acting almost as prosecutor, and singing intentionally “flat”, nuanceless. Amazing.
Gorgeous, both singing and acting. One request: KEEP THE CAMERA ON THE SINGERS! We don't go to the opera to see the orchestra. With these two singers in particular it is a shame to miss any of their wonderful expressiveness, musically or facially or physically.
Agreed.
Шикарно. Любимая Консерватория.
Высокий класс душевных переживаний в непревзойдённых голосах ДУЭТА!❤
A great performance of my favorite scene! Bravi!
OMG dit niveau zal niet snel meer gehaald worden. Wereld top niveau. 10+ triple excellent!
Renee Fleming stole the stage in this one! Perfection! Moved me to tears!
I like Renee Fleming but in this Duet she exaggerated
Astrid Tikal No. She did not exaggerate.
Katie Golan She’s supposed to steal the act, but I think Dmitri holds his own, w his glorious voice & sincere interpretation.
This is very moving! You can see the tears in Fleming's eyes!!
Брависсимо, чудесные Артисты !!! Браво Дмитрий! Браво Рене!!!
Absolutely stunning. Sigh.
I have tears in my eyes. Thanks for posting.
Sublime duo ,inoubliable et incomparable .Un miracle d'ineffable beauté , miracle d'art à ses plus hauts sommets d'accomplissement touchant le comble de la perfection, miracle de pures et saintes émotions.
Превосходный дуэт , незабываемый и несравненный .
Чудо несказываемой красоты, чудо искусства до его самих высоких вершин завершения, достигнутого верха совершенства, чудо истинных и святих эмоций.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❤️❤️💐💐 bravo! Bravo! Superb!
MagnificoDúo ---La Traviata
Maravilhoso demais.
It doesnt get any better than this.
Merveille
Как же это прекрасно!!!
Que belleza! Gran
Ma come mi manca, Dimitri Hvorostovski
Ich mag seine Stimme sehr.
Fantastico
Это прекрасно! Эталон!!❤❤❤👏👏👏
Этот дуэт Д. Хворостовского и Флемминг мне понравился больше всего. Восхитительно ! Какая нежная Виолета в исполнении Флеминг.
Да,это совсем великолепно и очень эмоционально .
Незабываемый и несравненный.
@@jean-christopheMiquel-ef3ur. Violetta meravigliosa,. Dimitri nel mio cuore,. Alfredo indimenticabile, ❤️❤️❤️
Wspaniali
❤❤ Magnificent!
Браво. Плачу.
beautifull performance