i mean the point ladder was horrendous sure but her point was trapping us cause she saw a horrible future waiting for us using her and Nyarlathotep's power. Cruel but thats basically her way of showing affection i suppose?
Fate/Type Redline is not a GUDA GUDA adaptation. It is an adaptation of KOHA ACE (or rather the sub-series fate/KOHA ACE), of which GUDA GUDA was originally a spin-off that was made in the run-up to FGO's JP release in 2015, before becoming in turn the base for FGO's GUDA GUDA events (with elements from KOHA ACE). Fate/KOHA ACE is about a 3rd Holy Grail War in Tokyo in the 1940s and features characters from Fate/Stay Night, Hollow Ataraxia and Tsukihime as some of the Masters. Fate/Type Redline is a remake of Fate/KOHA ACE with a serious tone that replaces the "guest characters" from other series with original characters (that still have quite a few similarities).
I always thought the main problem with the first year of FGO's story is that the writers were afraid to give Ritsuka a personality and were in that mindset of "the MC needs to be bland and generic, so the player can self-insert into them". Not only that, but the story writing from Prologue to Okeanos was just *bad,* if not downright *garbage.* 😑 The writing really wouldn't improve to _good_ again until Camelot and Babylonia onward, and even then there were occasional slip ups (like Agartha and, according to some, Salem). So to represent the Part 1 of the story, I am very thankful for these manga adaptations. 🙂 I haven't checked them yet, but based on your video, I can already guess what they did: pick up the lackluster first chapters of the story _and improve them. Tweak them. Change and add things to them._ That alone makes me excited to check them out and see what shenanigans the authors had some fun with creating!
I thought Salem was good. But I guess it's because I like horror stuff. I enjoyed it quite a bit. I think Agartha is okay-ish if we're comparing them to part 1 before camelot. But it is indeed my least like EoR story. I don't hate it though.
@@meikisaragi1445 I also thought Salem was pretty good, so I was surprised to find out many had the opposite opinion. Agartha was simply disappointing, however. I'd put it on the same level as Septem in terms of how bad it was.
@@MrDibaraI would personally also add Heian Kyo to the worst stories list. It's sad because kintoki is a good protagonist. It's sad that the story involved with him felt incomplete and rushed
Salem is actually pretty good IMO because it just feels so different.. Sure the half leveled servant gimmick is so stupid, but the story feels so claustrophobic, because the scale of the singularity is so small (just a small city), befitting of a horror troupe story.... Agatha has decent potential, until they make the villain character so one dimensional, and even the premise of the chapter being about "Woman", it was written poorly.
I enjoyed reading the lostbelts, because man does it not hold back when it shows how cruel the lostbelts are. I haven't gotten to lostbelts yet but even tho it spoils me, it's not so much since the manga just do it in a perspective of a character. And I'm used to being spoiled, thanks to joining a fandom group (ORV) lmao
Turas Realta is easily the best one because it actually brings in Chaldean Servants so we see how they change the story up with their presence. Also make for great characterization.
The players are literally encouraged to imagine what would the self insert would feel and do as part of the VN charm. But they want to explicitly wants to see what the self insert would be like, they want it served in a silver platter.
Recently began FGO serios again after my luck returned and I got Lady Avalon - 4 rolls, Ibuki Summer - 2 rolls and Summer Skadi + Caster - 1 roll. Today I tried my luck on Summer Anastasia banner and got Caster Charolla second roll and Saber Okitan on third, yet no Anastasia I know this is insane luck and happy as I really like those character and hope to get Halloween Assassin.
Nah, thay crazy fmc is just a special trait for Riyo's manga lmao. Even cool character like Anastasia is crazy in Riyo's. At Salem she actually pretty chill. In Shimousa she kinda match the vibe with Musashi so she looks pretty hype. But if we looking at it in general, they (male, female) r just the same but different look
You can start with Turas Realta first. It has great art, great storytelling, and good pacing. After that, you can jump in anywhere. Because as long as you know the "main point" of fgo's journey (turas realta), reading any manga is fine. Sure, there will be a few spoilers here and there, but it doesn't really matter. Well if you want to read in order, it's like this: turas realta, mortalis stella, fgo shinjuku, fgo agartha, fgo shimousa, fgo salem, fgo seraph
@@mr.skeptic yeah i want read it in order but from what u said its prolog then 1 an jump to 3,5 an 7 leave out 2,4,6 so guess ill have to bounce between the two if wanna follow it in order?
@@kenkaneki2202 If you want to jump between manga, that's fine, but for me it wasn't that much fun. Because the pacing and storytelling are a bit different. So it's fine if you want to read TR to the end, then MS. take it easy, the author also provides explanations between singularities so that readers won't be confused.
@@mr.skeptic oh thats good to know guess ill do Dat when i get down to it since I could use a refresher after LB6 an doing T sanctuary right now but since to summer event live atm put it on hold to do the event
Summer events are canon or not? Because... You know in ordeal call 2 fujimaru talks about jalter s swimsuit form and that confuses me so much So please somebody tell me WHAT THE HEEL IS THIS
Id like to think that they're canon. I said "a joke event" because... you know, the conflict is just that jokey and less serious. But those events were canon for them. Just dont think too deep about their swimsuit origin lore. Lmao
In Solomon they made it really clear that all the events of the game are canon, but if you want to specifically talk about Summer, during "A certain character's BIG moment" in Lostbelt 5.2, they directly talk about the events of Summer 4
"summer events are joke event" until BB shows up 💀
i mean the point ladder was horrendous sure but her point was trapping us cause she saw a horrible future waiting for us using her and Nyarlathotep's power. Cruel but thats basically her way of showing affection i suppose?
@@Ayumu31making BB bawl her eyes out after the seraph grail front was cathartic
@@Ayumu31 she already saw horrible future, hmmmm *fingers crossed*
Summer with Yu is very serious.
Not sure about Las Vegas as they didn't Re-run and sadly miss out on Ruler Da Vinci, so can't say.
@@Artemisthemp lmao be fr
Game Ritsuka : Because i want to live.
Turas realta Ritsuka : You should have died at birth.
TR Rits saw all of humanity suffering and said, Stop bitching Goetia.
Fate/Type Redline is not a GUDA GUDA adaptation. It is an adaptation of KOHA ACE (or rather the sub-series fate/KOHA ACE), of which GUDA GUDA was originally a spin-off that was made in the run-up to FGO's JP release in 2015, before becoming in turn the base for FGO's GUDA GUDA events (with elements from KOHA ACE). Fate/KOHA ACE is about a 3rd Holy Grail War in Tokyo in the 1940s and features characters from Fate/Stay Night, Hollow Ataraxia and Tsukihime as some of the Masters. Fate/Type Redline is a remake of Fate/KOHA ACE with a serious tone that replaces the "guest characters" from other series with original characters (that still have quite a few similarities).
Yeah i forgot to mention the name, but you're right. Its Fate Type Redline. Thanks for that
I always thought the main problem with the first year of FGO's story is that the writers were afraid to give Ritsuka a personality and were in that mindset of "the MC needs to be bland and generic, so the player can self-insert into them".
Not only that, but the story writing from Prologue to Okeanos was just *bad,* if not downright *garbage.* 😑 The writing really wouldn't improve to _good_ again until Camelot and Babylonia onward, and even then there were occasional slip ups (like Agartha and, according to some, Salem).
So to represent the Part 1 of the story, I am very thankful for these manga adaptations. 🙂
I haven't checked them yet, but based on your video, I can already guess what they did:
pick up the lackluster first chapters of the story _and improve them. Tweak them. Change and add things to them._ That alone makes me excited to check them out and see what shenanigans the authors had some fun with creating!
I thought Salem was good. But I guess it's because I like horror stuff. I enjoyed it quite a bit.
I think Agartha is okay-ish if we're comparing them to part 1 before camelot. But it is indeed my least like EoR story. I don't hate it though.
@@meikisaragi1445 I also thought Salem was pretty good, so I was surprised to find out many had the opposite opinion.
Agartha was simply disappointing, however. I'd put it on the same level as Septem in terms of how bad it was.
@@MrDibaraI would personally also add Heian Kyo to the worst stories list. It's sad because kintoki is a good protagonist. It's sad that the story involved with him felt incomplete and rushed
@@MrDibara damn. The same as septem lmao. But I can't argue with that. I don't feel any attachment towards Agartha afterall.
Salem is actually pretty good IMO because it just feels so different.. Sure the half leveled servant gimmick is so stupid, but the story feels so claustrophobic, because the scale of the singularity is so small (just a small city), befitting of a horror troupe story....
Agatha has decent potential, until they make the villain character so one dimensional, and even the premise of the chapter being about "Woman", it was written poorly.
i just love how we got a serious gudako with shimosa and salem
I enjoyed reading the lostbelts, because man does it not hold back when it shows how cruel the lostbelts are. I haven't gotten to lostbelts yet but even tho it spoils me, it's not so much since the manga just do it in a perspective of a character. And I'm used to being spoiled, thanks to joining a fandom group (ORV) lmao
The best way to enjoy the story is grand carnival
Thats true, but we need more episode so we can call it "the best way"
@@mr.skeptic nah if we just pretend carnival phantasm is also grand carnival that would be sufficient
now imagine the lostbelts and the ordeal call avenger arc manga where we see how he almost broke.
Turas Realta is easily the best one because it actually brings in Chaldean Servants so we see how they change the story up with their presence. Also make for great characterization.
The game would be even better if they voiced all the lines in the story
Would have been better if you didn't had to kill milions of useless waves of enemies
@@lohannes20 yeah this is my biggest problem lol. I just love having to do like 100 battles against random mobs
Live 2D would make a whole lot of difference
"he doesnt stand out much" that is bcz he is literally US lmao it's kinda funny
Im going to punch you
The players are literally encouraged to imagine what would the self insert would feel and do as part of the VN charm. But they want to explicitly wants to see what the self insert would be like, they want it served in a silver platter.
My favorit fate type redline
The orleans manga was fine for me till I saw the jalter parts. GOD DAM it was something else, on the good way.
Them expressions tho. She really deserve the title "alter" after making those faces. lol
@@mr.skeptic hell yeah
Salter and OG Jeanne better than Jalter period. Jalter is a trash waifu with chunnibiyo
There is still no Septem, wait what even is Septem?
bro this video realy helped a lot thank you
yea, the manga works really presented one-up versions of the respective stories.
Oh and the fight scenes in Redline. *Chef's Kiss
I didnt know there was manga ive been playing the game for years😂❤
Recently began FGO serios again after my luck returned and I got Lady Avalon - 4 rolls, Ibuki Summer - 2 rolls and Summer Skadi + Caster - 1 roll.
Today I tried my luck on Summer Anastasia banner and got Caster Charolla second roll and Saber Okitan on third, yet no Anastasia
I know this is insane luck and happy as I really like those character and hope to get Halloween Assassin.
But what if we play as Gudako?? Are we stuck with Learning With Manga's unhinged version for representation?
Nah, thay crazy fmc is just a special trait for Riyo's manga lmao. Even cool character like Anastasia is crazy in Riyo's. At Salem she actually pretty chill. In Shimousa she kinda match the vibe with Musashi so she looks pretty hype. But if we looking at it in general, they (male, female) r just the same but different look
Not all manga's are fujimaru.
For example the manga covering Shimousa chapter uses Gudako.
If i have patience for waiting the next chaps, be my guest
As a fgo player this is amazing I knew about it but not where to start so where do I start exactly will i have to jump back n forth?
You can start with Turas Realta first. It has great art, great storytelling, and good pacing. After that, you can jump in anywhere. Because as long as you know the "main point" of fgo's journey (turas realta), reading any manga is fine. Sure, there will be a few spoilers here and there, but it doesn't really matter. Well if you want to read in order, it's like this: turas realta, mortalis stella, fgo shinjuku, fgo agartha, fgo shimousa, fgo salem, fgo seraph
@@mr.skeptic yeah i want read it in order but from what u said its prolog then 1 an jump to 3,5 an 7 leave out 2,4,6 so guess ill have to bounce between the two if wanna follow it in order?
@@kenkaneki2202 If you want to jump between manga, that's fine, but for me it wasn't that much fun. Because the pacing and storytelling are a bit different. So it's fine if you want to read TR to the end, then MS. take it easy, the author also provides explanations between singularities so that readers won't be confused.
@@mr.skeptic oh thats good to know guess ill do Dat when i get down to it since I could use a refresher after LB6 an doing T sanctuary right now but since to summer event live atm put it on hold to do the event
The reason like the manga because I'm not gonna spend $300 gambling on PNGs again
Fair enough🤣
Are there any officially release in english physical format?
Summer events are canon or not?
Because... You know in ordeal call 2 fujimaru talks about jalter s swimsuit form and that confuses me so much
So please somebody tell me WHAT THE HEEL IS THIS
Id like to think that they're canon. I said "a joke event" because... you know, the conflict is just that jokey and less serious. But those events were canon for them. Just dont think too deep about their swimsuit origin lore. Lmao
In Solomon they made it really clear that all the events of the game are canon, but if you want to specifically talk about Summer, during "A certain character's BIG moment" in Lostbelt 5.2, they directly talk about the events of Summer 4
Turas Realta manga is awesome
Kiyohime fighting Heracles, Hektor defending Babylonia, ARJUNA FIGHTING ISHTAR
@JohnPeacekeeper ikr. It's so cool to give some spotlight for them.
Wtf Musashi copying Roland's Iconic line 😮
I thought theres a Saber Wars 2 manga?
Oh really? I didnt know that
@@mr.skeptic there's a prologue Manga for Saber Wars 2