I'm Obnoxious NY Sports Fan, that list took me 50 minutes to make. That just makes me proud. Also I'm a Yankee fan, I did my best to eliminate the bias.
@@CYROMERO2 maybe but putting Lindor in your top 10 isnt exactly a bias, I like fuzzy usually but that and his reaction to the Kluber deal irritated me. Overall him and Marc make some of the best baseball TH-cam content
Marc, this was one of your finest videos!! It really shows how much you put into your craft. I do not understand the Lindor disrespect from so many of these lists. He is a top 7 to 10 type of guy. Plus he played injured for a good part of the year.
It may be a little bias Verlander and Cole had more strikeouts and a lower WHIP as well as actually having wins Oh and they both threw over 300 strikeouts in the same season on the same team MIC DROP
Noah Davis tbh the only guy you can really say is better than DeGrom is Verlander. Cole had one really good season while but DeGrom and Verlander has been doing it for years. But if u think Cole is better than both, you might as well say marte and Semien are top 15
Brendan Kenneally Gerrit Cole had a really good 2018 to with a 2.88 ERA, 276 strikeouts and 15 wins, and also Marc was referring to the last two years and nothing more.
My top 10 list: 1. Mike Trout 2. Mookie Betts 3. Cody Bellinger 4. Christian Yelich 5. Nolan Arenado 6. Alex Bregman 7. Anthony Rendon 8. Jacob DeGrom 9. Gerrit Cole 10. Francisco Lindor
My top 25: 1) Mike Trout 2) Christian Yelich 3) Mookie Betts 4) Cody Bellinger 5) Nolan Arenado 6) Alex Bregman 7) Anthony Rendon 8) Jacob DeGrom 9) Justin Verlander 10) Gerritt Cole 11) Francisco Lindor 12) Ronald Acuna jr 13) Juan Soto 14) Max Scherzer 15) Freddie Freeman 16) Matt Chapman 17) Jose Altuve 18) Aaron Judge 19) George Springer 20) Javier Baez 21) Stephen Strasburg 22) Trevor Story 23) Ketel Marte 24) Xander Bogaerts 25) Josh Donaldson Give me some feedback on what you would change
Here’s mine: 1. Mike Trout 2. Cody Bellinger 3. Christian Yelich 4. Mookie Betts 5. Nolan Arenado 6. Alex Bregman 7. Francisco Lindor 8. Jacob DeGrom 9. Anthony Rendon 10. Max Sherzer 11. Gerrit Cole 12. Ronald Acuña Jr. 13. Freddie Freeman 14. Aaron Judge 15.Justin Verlander 16. Matt Chapman 17. Juan Soto 18. Trevor Story 19. Jose Altuve 20. D. J. LeMahieu 21. Jose Ramirez 22. Anthony Rizzo 23. Javier Baez 24. Gleyber Torres 25. Bryce Harper 26. Matt Olson 27. Pete Alonso 28. George Springer 29. Ketel Marte 30. Stephen Strasburg 31. J. T. Realmuto 32. Josh Donaldson 33. Xander Boagarts 34. Carlos Correa 35. J. D. Martinez 36. Kris Bryant 37. Walker Buehler 38. Nelson Cruz 39. Marcus Semien 40. Eugenio Suarez 41. Charlie Morton 42. Giancarlo Stanton 43. Fernando Tatis Jr. 44. Trea Turner 45. Manny Machado 46. Micheal Brantley 47. Whit Merrifield 48. Mike Clevinger 49. Josh Hader 50. Ozzie Albies
Chippe_Da_Dank Lindor is a star even though he’s never had a 900 ops season. He is a consistent player with athletic ability who has some crazy good gold glove defense who goes 20 for 20 each year and hits close to 40 homeruns as a shortstop. Lindor is a top 10 player in lbaseball on the plate andu in shortstop. Guys like Lindor Bellinger and Trout are all 5 tool players. They do it all. If you need him to hit lead off or third or cleanup he can do it for you. These 3 guys I mentioned are very diverse and well skilled players in every single category. The reason s doesn’t have a 900 ops also is because he doesn’t draw walks and who wants your best hitter walking? How many homers would trout and bellinger hit if they didn’t walk as much? So actually I don’t care about walks I get people look at OBP a lot but I’m my opinion batting average is far more important.
@@jasonmatteson9909 I'd agree with that definitely, however, I like lindor more for some reason. I think it's mostly a shortstop bias, most of my favorite players have been shortstops.
I don’t have Twitter but here is my top 20 and I would appreciate to know what you think about it 1. Bird 2. Yelich 3.Betts 4.Bellinger 5.Bregman 6.Arenado 7.Lindor 8.Degrom 9. Lindor 10. Rendon 11.Cole 12. Verlander (Fine wine) 13. Scherzer 14. Judge 15. Acuna 16. Story 17. Bogaerts (probably butchered that) 18. Soto 19. Realmuto 20. Marte Jk lol trout is obviously 1
Dude, I’m only 11 but I am pretty sure I can do better than the first one. Like, Ketel Marte is good but not top 10 yet. Maybe not even top 30! He had 1 breakout season which is great for him but that doesn’t make him a Mike Trout type of player already. Same with Semien. He had one breakout season. And Muncy at 17 is crazy. Yes, he’s good but not top 20. And don’t even get me started on the Lindor thing. And also, Wong and Ahmed shouldn’t even be on this list. And Adames? WHAT?! And on the second list, this might be bias but Acuna at 25 might be a little low. First of all, Xander Bogaerts is ahead of him. He is a great player but Ronald just had better seasons and has a better glove. And also on the second list, Alonso seems a little high up on the list. I have lots of others to say but if I said everything I wanted, this comment would be an article. (NOT TRYNA HATE THO.)
I’m a Jays fan and I can’t for the life of me figure out why Rafael Devers isn’t at LEAST in the top 20 in every ranking.. over 200 hits, lead the league in doubles, .311/.555/.916 slash line with 32 bombs and 115 RBI’s and is only 23 years old!! I don’t get it.
Mitch Garver was a BEAST last year his OBP was .365 and he had an insane 10.03 AB per HR that was better than mike trout who led the majors he only had 311 ab total because he split time with Jason Castro so he didn't have enough to qualify for the list I looked at.
My top 50: 1. Mike Trout 2. Christian Yelich 3. Alex Bregman 4. Cody Bellinger 5. Francisco Lindor 6. Anthony Rendon 7. Nolan Arenado 8. Mookie Betts 9. Gerrit Cole 10. Jacob deGrom 11. Freddie Freeman 12. Juan Soto 13. Max Scherzer 14. Ronald Acuna Jr 15. Justin Verlander 16. Aaron Judge 17. Jose Altuve 18. Jose Ramirez 19. Trevor Story 20. Matt Chapman 21. Bryce Harper 22. Stephen Strasburg 23. Josh Donaldson 24. Paul Goldschmidt 25. JD Martinez 26. Walker Buehler 27. Manny Machado 28. Pete Alonso 29. Ketel Marte 30. Carlos Correa 31. Luis Castillo 32. Yasmani Grandal 33. Zack Greinke 34. Eugenio Suárez 35. JT Realmuto 36. George Springer 37. Sonny Gray 38. Hyun Jin Ryu 39. Anthony Rizzo 40. Rafael Devers 41. Javier Baez 42. Shane Bieber 43. Jack Flaherty 44. Trea Turner 45. DJ LeMahieu 46. Charlie Blackmon 47. Aroldis Chapman 48. Kris Bryant 49. Patrick Corbin 50. Fernando Tatis Jr
My Top 10: 1) Mike Trout 2) Christian Yelich 3) Cody Bellinger 4) Mookie Betts 5) Nolan Arenado 6) Alex Bregman 7) Anthony Rendon 8) Francisco Lindor 9) Jacob DeGrom 10) Justin Verlander 11) Geritt Cole 12) Ronald Acuna 13) Max Scherzer 14) Freddie Freeman 15) Matt Chapman
Man do people have a recency bias! And boy is everyone sleeping on Judge b/c of the injuries - mark my words, he'll put up a .900+ OPS and 15+ DRS in each of the next four years if healthy, and I don't even think you can say that about any other player in the game.
I think people were really biased toward players that had a good year this season or they were a player on their team like the Anderson before Baez and the judge in 4 that was clearly bias so I want to say thank you Marc because I realised how hard what you do is and when you put in a lot of work and everyone gives you crap in the comments it must suck. So thank you Marc
marc getting angry at people for not listing the number one shortstop in baseball as the number one shortstop in baseball for 20 minutes is an alternative title
I tweeted at you Marc and I kept checking back at my list and I'm pretty sure I checked every mark you said were essential. I wanted you to critique :/
It's very tough to rank players in MLB because pitching is so dominant. If you have DeGrom, Cole, Verlander in a Game 7 and they're "on" then they can beat a team filled with an All-Star lineup. Good pitching crushes good hitting. If you put all the best pitchers in the league on one team and fill the lineup with replacement players you'd likely win 95 games and the World Series. As a result, I think pitchers are too low on the list.
My 8 year old son is a big fan of your videos. He really liked this one and has created his own top 50 for your review: 1. Trout 2. Betts 3. Yelich 4. Bellinger 5. DeGrom 6. Scherzer 7. Bregman 8. Lindor 9. Baez 10. Arenado 11. Verlander 12. Freeman 13. Acuna Jr. 14. Judge 15. Altuve 16. S. Marte 17. Realmuto 18. Springer 19. M. Chapman 20. Rizzo 21. C. Santana 22. Correa 23. Cole 24. Blackmon 25. Kershaw 26. Seager 27. Bryant 28. Martinez 29. T. Turner 30. Contreras 31. Bell 32. Bauer 33. Mancini 34. Kluber 35. K. Marte 36. T. Anderson 37. Merrifield 38. G. Sanchez 39. Cruz 40. Nola 41. Snell 42. Alonso 43. Paddack 44. Hendricks 45. Lester 46. Pham 47. Benintendi 48. Renfroe 49. Schwarber 50. Cain
Arenado is a superstar and a great player but in the last 5 years, he has never been top 10 in ops+, offensive WAR, Defensive WAR, and only once(7th with 7.1) in War. (using baseball-reference WAR) So should he defiantly be a top 10 player?
I am most likely just very biased as a Nats fan with a Turner jersey, but I dunno about the Lindor vs Turner. Turner is an excellent shortstop but even better baserunner. My love of amazing baserunning would make me go with Turner over Lindor.
“Shaw” in one of them was probably Kershaw
I think George Bernard Shaw is a top twenty playwright.
Ya
“How high can we rank Ketel Marte” Marc 2019
1 Ketel Marte
3:12 gets out of his chair he's so frustrated. 3:14 insults fan,
Ketel
schneiderbakers that’s what I said
You are so weird Thovore6 you have a dodgers logo but you like the dbacks
Thovore6 nooooooooooooooooooo
These make Marc’s rankings look amazing
Big Ballers that’s what he was going for
Marc’s are pretty decent aside from Mets bias
They’re not that bad in the first place
The 3 Prankskateers I don’t know, his catchers and pitchers ones were pretty iffy, though I liked most of the rest of them
no they don’t, Lindor is not a top ten player at all
Here before anyone mentions Marc calling Verlander a fine wine
Sam Watson those jokes are so old though ngl
Maanas Ravishankar but they’re still funny
I died when I saw shaw at 20, I was laughing for abt a minute straight 😂😂😂
I'm guessing Kershaw? Even that is kinda a whack placement but idk
Same
it’s kershaw
DG Edits
It can’t be.
That’s just stupidity...
hes talking about kershaw
I'm Obnoxious NY Sports Fan, that list took me 50 minutes to make. That just makes me proud. Also I'm a Yankee fan, I did my best to eliminate the bias.
Haven’t done manager rankings yet...
Harder to do this day and age with GM's makin the lineups.
jamezguard that’s true
E
Francona at 1
jamezguard mmmmm no
Marc: In what planet is Ketel Marte so high?
Subscribers: Yes
Frankie Lindor is a 6 tool player he’s got everything you need plus a great smile playa😁
And we can't forget, that he's from my country ❤
I know top 10 easily
Watching you MELT DOWN is FAR more entertaining than the RIDICULOUS rankings! Great job Marc!
Oh goddamn, the man's made it big. He got the *Audible Sponsorship.*
Lucas Bell next is raid shadow legends
my boi finally got his Audible sponsorship XD
You should react to fuzzys top 50 list
Its trash. Lindor outside the top 10 tf
@Prayingmantis 211 so he says, I'm not convinced. He's a downer fan who under rated Lindor
Glen Longwell maybe he doesn’t want people to call him biased
@@CYROMERO2 maybe but putting Lindor in your top 10 isnt exactly a bias, I like fuzzy usually but that and his reaction to the Kluber deal irritated me. Overall him and Marc make some of the best baseball TH-cam content
Glen Longwell agree
Marc, this was one of your finest videos!! It really shows how much you put into your craft. I do not understand the Lindor disrespect from so many of these lists. He is a top 7 to 10 type of guy. Plus he played injured for a good part of the year.
The first list made me want to throw up
Christian Donnelly I know sorry
Blah 😷
Christian Donnelly where is the DeGrom
You're by far my favorite baseball youtuber. Keep em coming and thanks for all the great content.
This was a really nice change to your normal videos, definitely do more of these going forward
Thx for the degrom thingy Marc
8:44 yes Marc. It is a debate.
Lol Degrom pitches in the NL
It may be a little bias Verlander and Cole had more strikeouts and a lower WHIP as well as actually having wins
Oh and they both threw over 300 strikeouts in the same season on the same team
MIC DROP
Noah Davis tbh the only guy you can really say is better than DeGrom is Verlander. Cole had one really good season while but DeGrom and Verlander has been doing it for years. But if u think Cole is better than both, you might as well say marte and Semien are top 15
Brendan Kenneally Gerrit Cole had a really good 2018 to with a 2.88 ERA, 276 strikeouts and 15 wins, and also Marc was referring to the last two years and nothing more.
Do a part 2 of this. This is the best video in a while
Marc when a Yankees player gets ranked too high: OK BOOMER
Marc when a Mets player gets ranked too high: NOICE
Joseph Stickyboi He actually called people out for ranking Alonso and McNeil too high
My top 10 list:
1. Mike Trout
2. Mookie Betts
3. Cody Bellinger
4. Christian Yelich
5. Nolan Arenado
6. Alex Bregman
7. Anthony Rendon
8. Jacob DeGrom
9. Gerrit Cole
10. Francisco Lindor
That is right
Ketel Marte??!
I love how Trout is the default #1 for every list 😂. The dude is so good.
Frisky _ Dart he’s the third best on my list
Kodak White
That’s god damn stupid but ok. There are plenty of stupid people in this world so I ain’t surprised.
I stated thinking that this was stupid, but then I realized that Marc does half of these things. We love you Marc!!!
Marc: How is Lindor not a top 10 player?
Me: Because their are people like Jabari Blash, Chris David, etc.
David Teitelbaum ummmm Chris Davis in what world .179 batting is not a top 50
@@happyblobfish6077 r/wooosh
@@happyblobfish6077 r/woooooosh
My top 25:
1) Mike Trout
2) Christian Yelich
3) Mookie Betts
4) Cody Bellinger
5) Nolan Arenado
6) Alex Bregman
7) Anthony Rendon
8) Jacob DeGrom
9) Justin Verlander
10) Gerritt Cole
11) Francisco Lindor
12) Ronald Acuna jr
13) Juan Soto
14) Max Scherzer
15) Freddie Freeman
16) Matt Chapman
17) Jose Altuve
18) Aaron Judge
19) George Springer
20) Javier Baez
21) Stephen Strasburg
22) Trevor Story
23) Ketel Marte
24) Xander Bogaerts
25) Josh Donaldson
Give me some feedback on what you would change
I think this is one of my favorite videos Marc has ever done.
Donaldson should get some more love he’s nuts and now he’s underrated for some reason
1. Bartolo Colon
2. Chris Davis
3. Jabari Blash
Yea Davis first he holds a very holy record
IEnVy CLAN yea Davis is the best like 0for 51 best record ever
1. Bartolo colon
2. Mike Trout
3. Mookie betts
4. Critian yelich
5. Cody bellinger
1. Kettle marte
2. Bartolo colon
3. Adam Dunn
4. Edwin Diaz
5. Phillies bullpen
Can we do this again? Love to add my list into the mix!
Here’s mine:
1. Mike Trout
2. Cody Bellinger
3. Christian Yelich
4. Mookie Betts
5. Nolan Arenado
6. Alex Bregman
7. Francisco Lindor
8. Jacob DeGrom
9. Anthony Rendon
10. Max Sherzer
11. Gerrit Cole
12. Ronald Acuña Jr.
13. Freddie Freeman
14. Aaron Judge
15.Justin Verlander
16. Matt Chapman
17. Juan Soto
18. Trevor Story
19. Jose Altuve
20. D. J. LeMahieu
21. Jose Ramirez
22. Anthony Rizzo
23. Javier Baez
24. Gleyber Torres
25. Bryce Harper
26. Matt Olson
27. Pete Alonso
28. George Springer
29. Ketel Marte
30. Stephen Strasburg
31. J. T. Realmuto
32. Josh Donaldson
33. Xander Boagarts
34. Carlos Correa
35. J. D. Martinez
36. Kris Bryant
37. Walker Buehler
38. Nelson Cruz
39. Marcus Semien
40. Eugenio Suarez
41. Charlie Morton
42. Giancarlo Stanton
43. Fernando Tatis Jr.
44. Trea Turner
45. Manny Machado
46. Micheal Brantley
47. Whit Merrifield
48. Mike Clevinger
49. Josh Hader
50. Ozzie Albies
Imma make some changes
If you gonna correct spelling I’m gonna correct you saying how long players have played. Tim Anderson has played 4 years not 6
It’s crazy how underrated Harper is
I’m confused how Lindor is not getting top 10 😂
0 seasons with an above .900 OPS
Chippe_Da_Dank Lindor is a star even though he’s never had a 900 ops season. He is a consistent player with athletic ability who has some crazy good gold glove defense who goes 20 for 20 each year and hits close to 40 homeruns as a shortstop. Lindor is a top 10 player in lbaseball on the plate andu in shortstop. Guys like Lindor Bellinger and Trout are all 5 tool players. They do it all. If you need him to hit lead off or third or cleanup he can do it for you. These 3 guys I mentioned are very diverse and well skilled players in every single category. The reason s doesn’t have a 900 ops also is because he doesn’t draw walks and who wants your best hitter walking? How many homers would trout and bellinger hit if they didn’t walk as much? So actually I don’t care about walks I get people look at OBP a lot but I’m my opinion batting average is far more important.
Ë g g he bats lead off what do you expect out of slugging?
I think that the first rankings were just based off of the 2019 season alone
This was really fun. I should try and make a top 50 list just to see how tough it is.
Joseph Hanson I'm working on one now, holy shit is it difficult
Betts > Lindor.
@@jasonmatteson9909 I'd agree with that definitely, however, I like lindor more for some reason. I think it's mostly a shortstop bias, most of my favorite players have been shortstops.
Here’s my top 20
1 Trout
2 Betts
3 Yelich
4 Bellinger
5 Bregman
6 Arenado
7 Lindor
8 Rendon
9 Degrom
10 Verlander
11 Judge
12 Cole
13 Freeman
14 Acuna
15 Baez
16 Soto
17 Altuve
18 Story
19 LeMahieu
20 Chapman
7:07 Don't worry...it was Starling Marte not Ketel Marte😂
Ketel>Starling
Andrew Larson
Wow really, we didn’t know that.
Cubs MLB Perfect Inning Gaming 😂😂 crazy right
I don’t have Twitter but here is my top 20 and I would appreciate to know what you think about it
1. Bird
2. Yelich
3.Betts
4.Bellinger
5.Bregman
6.Arenado
7.Lindor
8.Degrom
9. Lindor
10. Rendon
11.Cole
12. Verlander (Fine wine)
13. Scherzer
14. Judge
15. Acuna
16. Story
17. Bogaerts (probably butchered that)
18. Soto
19. Realmuto
20. Marte
Jk lol trout is obviously 1
Honestly, I wouldn't be suprised if someone put Marte at #1
Dude, I’m only 11 but I am pretty sure I can do better than the first one. Like, Ketel Marte is good but not top 10 yet. Maybe not even top 30! He had 1 breakout season which is great for him but that doesn’t make him a Mike Trout type of player already. Same with Semien. He had one breakout season. And Muncy at 17 is crazy. Yes, he’s good but not top 20. And don’t even get me started on the Lindor thing. And also, Wong and Ahmed shouldn’t even be on this list. And Adames? WHAT?! And on the second list, this might be bias but Acuna at 25 might be a little low. First of all, Xander Bogaerts is ahead of him. He is a great player but Ronald just had better seasons and has a better glove. And also on the second list, Alonso seems a little high up on the list. I have lots of others to say but if I said everything I wanted, this comment would be an article. (NOT TRYNA HATE THO.)
I MADDDDE ITTT, thanks Marc 🙏🙏
Austin Kinder cool
Imagine someone putting trout at 2
Trouts gay! He is a number 🌈 player.
@@logan8698gxakgdskhfskyrs oooh uhhh oh yeah! OhYeAhTrOuTsGaY
Trout’s the third best player in the mlb, go ahead with the replies
Kodak White who is 1st and 2nd asking for a friend
Mr. Clean it goes Yelich and deGrom then Trout
Nolan Arenado is the best 3rd basemen everyone had Bregman or Rendon ahead
Lol Marc’s reactions to these lists are what we think about Marc’s rankings
I’m a Jays fan and I can’t for the life of me figure out why Rafael Devers isn’t at LEAST in the top 20 in every ranking.. over 200 hits, lead the league in doubles, .311/.555/.916 slash line with 32 bombs and 115 RBI’s and is only 23 years old!! I don’t get it.
My rankings
1 trout
2 betts
3 yeli
4 belli
5 arenado
6 Lindor
7rendon
8 acuna
9 degrom
10. Verlander
11 bregman
12 cole
13 Chapman
14 scherzer
15 soto
16 judge
17 sale
18 bogaerts
19 springer
20 realmuto
21 Freeman
22 harper
23 E. Suarez
24 rizzo
25 Altuve
26 lemahieu
27 Grandal
28 bryant
29 buehler
30 Alonso
31 Baez
32 Olson
33 Strasburg
34 ketel marte
35 Syndergaard
36 jose ramirez
37 tatis jr
38 jd Martinez
39 Donaldson
40 yordan Alvarez
41cruz
42 trea Turner
43 ryu
44 ohtani
45 devers
46 semien
47 McNeil
48 hader
49 Chapman
50 max muncy
wait. where is bartolo colon. the 🐐
When someone put Rendon twice I died
Mitch Garver was a BEAST last year his OBP was .365 and he had an insane 10.03 AB per HR that was better than mike trout who led the majors he only had 311 ab total because he split time with Jason Castro so he didn't have enough to qualify for the list I looked at.
Lmao, saying Tim Anderson has had a 6 year career lmao
Bobby Jenkins it’s 4 actually
Everybody knocks him for his shit defense but Baez can't hit an on base higher than .320
BaseballproGamer Javier Baez had a .325 obp in 2015 and in 2018 he had a .326 obp so yes he can get a higher obp than .320
Great video Marc we need a Francisco lindor explanation video the lindor slander is insane. Hopefully we get another video
Hi Marc you are the best
My top 50:
1. Mike Trout
2. Christian Yelich
3. Alex Bregman
4. Cody Bellinger
5. Francisco Lindor
6. Anthony Rendon
7. Nolan Arenado
8. Mookie Betts
9. Gerrit Cole
10. Jacob deGrom
11. Freddie Freeman
12. Juan Soto
13. Max Scherzer
14. Ronald Acuna Jr
15. Justin Verlander
16. Aaron Judge
17. Jose Altuve
18. Jose Ramirez
19. Trevor Story
20. Matt Chapman
21. Bryce Harper
22. Stephen Strasburg
23. Josh Donaldson
24. Paul Goldschmidt
25. JD Martinez
26. Walker Buehler
27. Manny Machado
28. Pete Alonso
29. Ketel Marte
30. Carlos Correa
31. Luis Castillo
32. Yasmani Grandal
33. Zack Greinke
34. Eugenio Suárez
35. JT Realmuto
36. George Springer
37. Sonny Gray
38. Hyun Jin Ryu
39. Anthony Rizzo
40. Rafael Devers
41. Javier Baez
42. Shane Bieber
43. Jack Flaherty
44. Trea Turner
45. DJ LeMahieu
46. Charlie Blackmon
47. Aroldis Chapman
48. Kris Bryant
49. Patrick Corbin
50. Fernando Tatis Jr
acuna is better than Soto
ilyPurpled not by much though
10:55 A+ profile pic
Thanks, that picture was me! For Real lol
👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
You should do best celebrity fans like who is most involved
*cough cough Marlin Man
You know what you should do for 200000 subs do the best 100 players
He should stream it too
That Lindor thingy was crazy. No one understands that right
Maybe Shaw is Kershaw?
When people shorten his name they say Kersh but who really knows
I think Charlie Blackmon should be in everyone’s list
This is what I got from this vid
1 lindor
2 rendon
10000 marte
My Top 10:
1) Mike Trout
2) Christian Yelich
3) Cody Bellinger
4) Mookie Betts
5) Nolan Arenado
6) Alex Bregman
7) Anthony Rendon
8) Francisco Lindor
9) Jacob DeGrom
10) Justin Verlander
11) Geritt Cole
12) Ronald Acuna
13) Max Scherzer
14) Freddie Freeman
15) Matt Chapman
15*
I don’t know why I haven’t seen Chris Sale once in the top 50 players
Thomas D'Andrea he was top 50 until last two to three years
That first list was made to trigger and confuse Marc 😂
Mookie betts is a top 3 player
Nah
MetalCrow448 exactly
Jack Broockerd lmao imagine
Nah
He’s a top ten player at best
Right as he’s talking about trea turner I get a notification that trea turner scores a run against the mets
“Don’t tells me bias in the comments”
Bias in the comments, I think Scherzer and Verlander are both better than deGrom
Same
back to back cy young
Filipe Vieira It doesn’t matter.
Coaster Nerd it fully does. you don’t win cy young just by luck
Filipe Vieira Sure but Scherzer has 3 Cy Young awards in the past decade and Verlander is consistently having incredible years for longer.
Man do people have a recency bias! And boy is everyone sleeping on Judge b/c of the injuries - mark my words, he'll put up a .900+ OPS and 15+ DRS in each of the next four years if healthy, and I don't even think you can say that about any other player in the game.
Logan Goldberg “but but but the Ks”, they will say
I agree with you having lindor in the top 10 but my friend thinks he’s top 20 or 15 because he needs to improve his hitting
Anthony Palmieri he do us NOT need to improve his hitting
That was my friend’s opinion i dont think that lindor needs more hitting
1) Tatis Jr
2) Kirby Yates
3) Manny Machado
4) Eric Hosmer
5) Tommy Pham
Lol
8:13 Kevin?
I love how he says Ketel Marte has only done it for one year but so has Ronald Acuna so
I checked and I’m 27th comment so that’s a bummer.
My favorite number.
Mike trouts #
I think people were really biased toward players that had a good year this season or they were a player on their team like the Anderson before Baez and the judge in 4 that was clearly bias so I want to say thank you Marc because I realised how hard what you do is and when you put in a lot of work and everyone gives you crap in the comments it must suck. So thank you Marc
JT Relmuto at 36😂😂😂
I started dying laughing when Gallo at 19, Reynolds at 24, and Ahmed at 31 came up HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Let me say it: LINDOR IS NOT A TOP 10 PLAYER!
Not even the top shortstop
Your stupid
Was the “Shaw” he was referring to as Kershaw? Instead of Brian or Travis
First
marc getting angry at people for not listing the number one shortstop in baseball as the number one shortstop in baseball for 20 minutes is an alternative title
Please do this again as there are so many lists you can critique 😂
My top 5 is 1.Mike Trout 2.Mookie Betts 3. Juan Soto 4. Cody Bellinger 5. Anthony Rendon
Do you think the diamondbacks will trade for mookie betts or lindor
I tweeted at you Marc and I kept checking back at my list and I'm pretty sure I checked every mark you said were essential. I wanted you to critique :/
1990 called....want their corona shirt back....haha
Keep up the great work
Baez, Bryant, Rizzo, Contreras, The Professor. Easy top 5, Ketel Marte a close 6th
It's very tough to rank players in MLB because pitching is so dominant. If you have DeGrom, Cole, Verlander in a Game 7 and they're "on" then they can beat a team filled with an All-Star lineup. Good pitching crushes good hitting. If you put all the best pitchers in the league on one team and fill the lineup with replacement players you'd likely win 95 games and the World Series. As a result, I think pitchers are too low on the list.
Best part of the video watching Marc freak out👌
Here is my top 25
1. Trout
2. Lindor
3. Yelich
4. Bregman
5. Rendon
6. Arendo
7. Donaldson
8. Machado
9. Freeman
10. Harper
11. Albies
12. Bellinger
13. Cole
14. Strasburg
15. Scherzer
16. Arodis Chapman
17. Soto
18. Pete Alonso
19. Fernando Tatis
20. Mookie Betts
21. Marte
22. Degrom
23. Verlander
24. Alutve
25. Rizzo
Not bad. I think Donaldson is a little high though
Cool list.
Throwback to when Marc was wearing a Corona shirt. He predicted it before it came.
I died when one of the list didn't even have judge on it
Where was Albies on your list?
My 8 year old son is a big fan of your videos. He really liked this one and has created his own top 50 for your review:
1. Trout
2. Betts
3. Yelich
4. Bellinger
5. DeGrom
6. Scherzer
7. Bregman
8. Lindor
9. Baez
10. Arenado
11. Verlander
12. Freeman
13. Acuna Jr.
14. Judge
15. Altuve
16. S. Marte
17. Realmuto
18. Springer
19. M. Chapman
20. Rizzo
21. C. Santana
22. Correa
23. Cole
24. Blackmon
25. Kershaw
26. Seager
27. Bryant
28. Martinez
29. T. Turner
30. Contreras
31. Bell
32. Bauer
33. Mancini
34. Kluber
35. K. Marte
36. T. Anderson
37. Merrifield
38. G. Sanchez
39. Cruz
40. Nola
41. Snell
42. Alonso
43. Paddack
44. Hendricks
45. Lester
46. Pham
47. Benintendi
48. Renfroe
49. Schwarber
50. Cain
I think this is actually very good list except for starling marte
What is that cursed logo on your shirt
Arenado is a superstar and a great player but in the last 5 years, he has never been top 10 in ops+, offensive WAR, Defensive WAR, and only once(7th with 7.1) in War. (using baseball-reference WAR)
So should he defiantly be a top 10 player?
Top
1 Trout
2 Yelich
3 Bellinger
4 Arenado
5 Betts
6 Bregman
7 Lindor
8 Rendon
9 Degrom
10 Cole
You forgot Chris Davis and Bartolo Colon
I love the vids Marc keep it up!
Marc reactions are hilarious
I am most likely just very biased as a Nats fan with a Turner jersey, but I dunno about the Lindor vs Turner. Turner is an excellent shortstop but even better baserunner. My love of amazing baserunning would make me go with Turner over Lindor.