(sorry my comment is little big,but worth the reading) Actually they did and came out that they say the truth.But how not?The mother have put this in their mind from were they was little kids!Even one of them (the blonde) have accuse an other family member that he molest her daughter in the SAME age HERS mother believe was. In the bottom line ALL of this is cause his wife (ex now) was molested at this age and have poised EVERYONE
This..exactly this👍 At best they too believe their own truths or may even their own deluded perceptions and at worst they are knowingly accusing an innocent man. At this point without both sides tested, I have no idea.
(sorry my comment is little big,but worth the reading) Actually they did and came out that they say the truth.But how not?The mother have put this in their mind from were they was little kids!Even one of them (the blonde) have accuse an other family member that he molest her daughter in the SAME age HERS mother believe was. In the bottom line ALL of this is cause his wife (ex now) was molested at this age and have poised EVERYONE
@@spartanvt I'm a woman and it upsets me that he tries to make these girls feel like they are innocent, by telling them that he believes everybody in the room says the truth while he didn't even test them. I think Dr. Phil lies himself because he's sceared of society getting mad at him for not believing the "victim". I can clearly see some reversed sexism issues going on in there.
Wouldn't work because if they have been telling a lie for so long they would now think it's true and pass. Well according Doctor I'm always right Phil. That's what told the guy.
Gets found not lying by polygraph, everyone says junk science he could still be lying. Gets found he is lying on polygraph EVERYONE believes the science of polygraph and he's guilty lol. It's not the science you disagree with, it's that they find someone innocent you disagree with.
@@debbiestephenson8494 This is just what happens when a man is falsely accused. If he is proven innocent society still and and will forever see him as guilty
And it was his second test in this matter. I’m sure the women want him to keep testing until they find the one that fits their narrative and gives them the answer they want as opposed to the truth.
So the guy passes the test and Doctor Phil has to make him sound guilty. Why are the girls and the ex-wife not taking lie detector tests. It's like the show set this guy up.
Passing doesn't mean that what you are saying isn't a lie. It just means that he personally believes what he is saying to be the truth. It doesn't matter what the actual truth is, polygraphs can't find that, all they can do is tell you whether or not the test taker is purposefully and knowingly lying. If someone is lying but they don't know that they are because they believe what they are saying to be the truth, they will pass solely because they believe their own lies. Polygraphs are worthless
If I recallcorrectly, the worst crime that they leveled against him was tickling them. Seems they are mad at him for abandoning them and now want revenge!
During a custody battle with my ex, she accused me of molesting our sons. She later admitted in a cross examination that she only said that because she was mad at me. My sons have never forgiven her for this lie and for other reasons. They have had nothing to do with her for the past 18 years.
Glad you were able to clear yourself and have your sons in your life (: it's a shame their "mother" isn't a good person.. I always say just cause you are related to someone does not mean they are good for you. Hope your sons are well! Take care.
@@christinajohnson1804 Thank you very much for your kind comment. I did love my ex, but I couldn’t stop her drinking, which is the main cause of her problems.
@@johnfairweather9188 unfortantly I know that all too well. My mom is an alcoholic and has been my whole life. I'm now 30 and pregnant with my 1st and she's still not good.. sad but at least I know how not to be.. your very welcome!
as a women, I just feel like they should’ve given the women tests as well. I’m not saying they’re completely lying but just to settle it, obviously the man was proven not guilty and he’s innocent. just the way they were crying doesn’t sit right with me.
They are crying because (in their minds) NOW they are not being believed. They are crying because they are afraid that they will not be taken seriously. Either he is a monster or they are liars. There is no third way. And they are crying because NOW (with him passing the lie detector) he has PROVEN his innocence which (logically) proves that they are liars. So OF COURSE they have to cry to get some sympathy (any sympathy) to try and gain allies in the world of public opinion. They are not upset that he molested him. They are upset that he passed the lie detector which makes their accusations look bad. They are upset because this may have "caught" them so to speak. But no, they will never take any tests because they KNOW they are lying. And Dr Phil saying that he doesn't think they are lying doesn't change anything. That is all just for show. Dr Phil knew they were lying from day one.
@@paulcolburn3855 yes, there is a third way. The third way is that he believes that he did no wrong, and the girls believe he did do wrong. It's not as simple as "either he's lying or they're lying". If a person believes what they're saying, then they believe it to be true. A person fails these tests when they're lying and they know they're lying. It's really that simple.
@@missmew3499 : that is true but they are crying because (at that moment) they don't have that moment of clarity on this that you have. They are crying because there is a chance that the audience will no longer believe them. If they could see it the way you did, they probably wouldn't be crying given those results.
@@paulcolburn3855 lol, they're still not lying. Their perception is their truth. Same goes for the man (accused). It's all a sad situation. Sexual abuse/assault isn't funny, and it's nothing to lie about.
I feel so very bad for innocent men that are accused of this. I am so sorry. I personally haven't been sexually abused by a parent, but I have by a stepbrother, a uncle, a cousin and friend of the family. So when someone that is innocent is accused, it's a big DEAL. Stop this madness!
@@LK-gp9yv your partner is kife at jail for 5 year? For something he is dont do? Even after they proof she is say lie he is still in jail justice system must broken and yeah believe womans dont say lie is much more easy for them
I think it’s hypocritical that when someone fails a lie detector test, the science is amazing and everyone trusts it, but when someone, who they WANT to be lying, actually tells the truth, all the sudden the test is wrong and he cheated it. I’m shocked that Dr Phil just completely dismissed the polygraph results after he’s always defending how good the test and the examiner is.
Hey alexis, so a polygraph test cant determine the truth, all it can do is show if someone is actively engaging in deception. If someone passes a polygraph, it doesn’t confirm the truth of their statements but it does prove that they themselves 100% believe what they said to be true, which in fairness does increase the validity of their statement, just not to 100%. Whereas if someone fails a polygraph, it shows they were being untruthful when answering the questions, in which case you can much more definitively conclude the truth to be the opposite of what they said, as they knowingly lied about it.
"Jack has conducted over 3500 polygraph exams. Unfortunately, the severity of this type of work has left him with the inability to smile on camera.....ever. "
@@robm4399 you don't need to be with your gf scumbag. Leave her so she can find a real man who can love her children as a father should. You disgust me.
Lie detector tests are never 100%. You cannot use them as a way to make a true judgement. Even doctor Phil says he doesn’t think anyone is lying, that there is just a lot going on and people are getting confused.
Can't believe this dude pays for "the best polygraph analyst in the country" and gets the results and says "nah, test wrong" simply because he doesn't like this guy. Absolute BS.
I am disappointed in Dr. Phil’s explanation as to why this man passed his polygraph test. The test reflects the persons memory and I think Dr. Phil just continued to cast doubt on this guy even though the polygraph showed he told the truth. If it would have come back that he failed, Phil would have crucified him. Shame on Dr. Phil for being dishonest and making things up as he goes. Lost a lot of respect for him.
If u seen the videos that the police reports that the daughters stories didn't add up because first they told a story then the daughters said it's someone else.
RIP Jack! You changed so many lives in your work! I've watched you for years and I know the work you did in your life was a mission complete, over and again!
I feel like if he actually did what was said and the results weren't in their favor. Wouldn't they be more devastated and hysterical than they were at that moment?
That's not how polygraphs work. They tell you only what you believe to be the truth. Say for example that you genuinely believe with every fibre of your being that the sky is green. If you take a polygraph test about the colour of the sky being green, you will pass because you genuinely believe that to be the truth. It doesn't matter what the colour of the sky actually is, what matters is whether or not you believe what you say. If you believe it, you will always pass a polygraph.
@@jupitersnoot4915 that’s not what they’re saying tho. He’s saying that if he did actually touch them and the results of the polygraph said otherwise, then their reactions should’ve been a lot different. They would’ve been a lot more upset, a lot more emotionally afflicted because of trauma. Their reaction was surprisingly calm for something so traumatic
@@sorryoutlandish don't judge someone else's trauma. they've been sitting on it for years. they appear truthful. someone that was lying would jump up and start screeching the test was rigged. they're crying with true emotion
I think these women were abused by someone - but it wasn't the stepfather. I think someone did sexually abuse these women when they were children and the mom coached them to say it was the stepfather.
The stepdaughters are so pathetic, I'm actually surprised that the step father still has these daughters after them treating him bad. I would've left by then.
(sorry my comment is little big,but worth the reading) Actually they did and came out that they say the truth.But how not?The mother have put this in their mind from were they was little kids!Even one of them (the blonde) have accuse an other family member that he molest her daughter in the SAME age HERS mother believe was. In the bottom line ALL of this is cause his wife (ex now) was molested at this age and have poised EVERYONE
Poor guy is accused of abuse, goes on TV to prove his innocence, takes a lie detector test, passes it, and then still has Dr Phil frame it in such a way as to make him sound guilty! At least give the accusers the test as well to see if they genuinely believe their allegations if you're going to go down this "lie detectors only measure what you perceive to be the truth" road. Maybe they just have completely opposite perceptions of the same events and nobody is lying, but it's just as possible that the accusers are just making it up. If you can't just take his word for it that he does not perceive that he did it, then you can't just take their word for it that they do perceive that he did it either. Without them also taking a test then you have to say that the evidence suggests this guy is innocent. Period.
@@nobodythatyouknow305 I didn't say that they couldn't. What I am saying is that in the case of one person's word against the other, with no other evidence to go on, then the person who passed a lie detector test should at least be presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Dr Phil always says this is the best man to do a lie detector. I think he was explaining to the girls that this was put into their mind for so long that they truely believe it.
If they believe it actually happened even though it didn't, they might pass the polygraph test. I think this is the main reason why it's not allowed in the court of law
As someone who spent my entire life growing up watching my mum fake cry to get what she wants, boom. Right here is a prime example of 3 women doing it.
Dr Phil invalidating everything he has ever said in every show he's done down the years where polygraph has been used. He's even debunking himself now🙄
Even as a woman, I cannot even imagine what this man is going through. This is awful, best of luck to him and I hope his daughters get what's coming to them..
They should have taken the test too. He told the truth.. Some people are dying to play the victim, but it's just not all that when you're living in the trauma. It's offensive to those of us who really did go through it.. How could you destroy a person like that? While real survivors live without any kind of justice.. It's outrageous to me.. You either believe in this technique or you don't. You didn't get the results you wanted, so now suddenly it didn't work?
Wait, so no one believed him without the lie detector test, he takes the test and passes it and he’s still a liar? I don’t understand it at all... Someone please explain this to me
Polygraphs will only tell what the test taker believes to be the truth. Say, for example, that you genuinely believe that the sky is green. If you sit down to take a polygraph about the colour of the sky, you will always pass because you genuinely believe what you're saying to be the truth, even when we know for a fact that the sky is not green. This man genuinely believes he did not harm them, and therefore he passed. He passed not because he was telling the truth, but because he 100% believes his lies to the point where he doesn't even realise he's lying.
@@jupitersnoot4915 sorry, I don’t believe that. It’s cool if you do, you know whatever gets you through the night. He passed the lie detector therefor he passed. Done ✅
Memory is not perfect. The mind fills in gaps, alters facts, etc. Narratives can even get created to deal with trauma.
3 ปีที่แล้ว
The girls shoulda taken the test. Alcohol had a heavy play in distorting his recollection of those moments. Idk, I think if they did take the test, ppl woulda had concrete proof and would be so torn
at the end of this video, wasn't dr phil saying it's possible that this man could have memory loss due to alcoholism? and that he may have done things while drunk that he doesn't remember? It's at least a possibility
Now if he had failed the test, they'd be all "I KNEW IT!! HE'S GARBAGE!! THE TEST DOESN'T LIE!!" But he passed...AND THEY DON'T BELIEVE THE TEST😡 WHAT WAS THE POINT???
sad that an innocents man’s life can be ruined by lies - how can they turn around and on this episode claim the test results were not correct - why not give the daughters a test also
Wait, Let me get this straight. He passes the lie detecter test. But he is still the bad guy cause he so happens to be a man surrounded by females? lol If he did lie, It wouldn't come out... "Well, Even though u didn't pass this... It doesn't mean u didn't tell a lie." Sure, They didn't take a lie detector test, So we can't say they lied. But they certainly didn't get it right. And an innocent man could have been sent to prison for that.
Dear Dr Phil. I love your show really I do. But the fact of the matter is here's a man that went the distance and you minimized the trauma and pain that he went through the pain he's going through and the accusations, karomshots, and disrespectful stuff he will have to endure for the rest of his life. This interview felt like you were giving those two women vindication and closure. He got ignored because ad you put it hr beat the science. Shame
I didn’t believe these women soon as they opened their mouths. I seen barely any tears, looked like a bunch of theatrics to me. Poor man. That’s something that sticks. Being labeled a predator is the worst thing possible and lying about someone doing that to you, they should be held accountable if they’re lying. Make those girls take the test too!
Okay, there maybe a reason that's not mentioned here. I know because I had alcoholics in my family. They can get so waisted and not remember something they did. So in their mind, they may not remember the act, but the sober people around them do. I had an Uncle that would wake up in different places and not remember how he got there. He could be guilty, and not have knowledge of it.
Soooooo guy isn't lying BUT everyone still says he's lying. Let's see...Polygraph TODAY are more accurate than the OLDER ones by far. Phil screwed up by saying that EVERYBODY is NOT lying and that alcohol was the reason. Okay...So wouldn't he have had SEXUAL tendencies when NOT drinking??? Yes, he would...ALCOHOL just allows someone to more easily ACT OUT those tendencies. Phil was wrong. Those women were lying.
“I believe that your respect of boundaries in a family full of women is really poor.” Dr.Phil. This is really really well thought of and said. Dr.Phil is extremely capable of describing and handling tough situations in relationships.
So if a polygraph reads what YOU believe, even if you’ve still committed the crime, how many other polygraphs did not match the truth of the crime committed???? How many other dirtbags walked off the show with the public thinking they were innocent?
I think all of them should take the test and if i was him id not talk to any of them again they are out to get him for whatever reason. Wash your hands of false accusers, they will try and take you down for something else if they have the opportunity
yeah f I was his situation I will do it to there is a serious case of favoritism here, not testing girls means looking at it with prejudice, it also contradicts the principle that the prosecution should come with evidence.
If he failed he could be prosecuted, these women should be prosecuted for false accusations, they could have ruined his life , they should be punished to send a message out to others
Dr. Phil is very gender biased on a lot of these episodes. He doesn’t always hold women accountable, and never makes the females do the polygraph test. He should.
Subscribe and ring the bell for notifications 🔔
Yes father
ofc i will phillip
Subbing because comments are on.
U are 3 years late 😂
I love Dan 😍😍
The accusers MUST take a lie detector test as well.
yeah I cant understand that stupid thing if I was that guy I will say well if I say lie se this lie test at girls
Yesssss 🙌🏽
they dont need to. there are years and years of police reports and other people's statements
@@pinkpugginz what it is that mean?
pinkpugginz just because there is paper work still does not mean the girls are being honest. It’s too easy to file police reports on false lies.
Could girls take the test themselves..to settle the matter .
They should!!!!
@Kevin van Etten yikes bro
(sorry my comment is little big,but worth the reading) Actually they did and came out that they say the truth.But how not?The mother have put this in their mind from were they was little kids!Even one of them (the blonde) have accuse an other family member that he molest her daughter in the SAME age HERS mother believe was.
In the bottom line ALL of this is cause his wife (ex now) was molested at this age and have poised EVERYONE
@Kevin van Etten me too man...
This..exactly this👍 At best they too believe their own truths or may even their own deluded perceptions and at worst they are knowingly accusing an innocent man. At this point without both sides tested, I have no idea.
Why don't the victims take a lie detector test also
...that's a dam good question...
@Leonora Zeneli doesn't matter. They still can take the test. To know if they sre lying or not.
They all seem like they’re lying
And destroy the "victim's" narrative ?
(sorry my comment is little big,but worth the reading) Actually they did and came out that they say the truth.But how not?The mother have put this in their mind from were they was little kids!Even one of them (the blonde) have accuse an other family member that he molest her daughter in the SAME age HERS mother believe was.
In the bottom line ALL of this is cause his wife (ex now) was molested at this age and have poised EVERYONE
Once a man is accused society will judge him as guilty, regardless of the truth.
Sad, but true. An accusation might as well be a death sentence to society to men. To women, they almost always get a free pass.
@@LK-gp9yv I'm sorry your boyfriend and you are suffering such a cruel fate both.
@@SunBunz on most things I’m seeing women get a lot of free passes. And it’s starting to be perceived as a sense of entitlement.
@@HighonBoots To feminists, it certainly has.
@@SunBunz part of the reason I’m happy to be gay.
Why didn’t Dr. Phil test those two girls to see if they were telling the truth??
Because is not politically correct and he does not want to upset his main audience which is mostly women.
@@spartanvt I'm a woman and it upsets me that he tries to make these girls feel like they are innocent, by telling them that he believes everybody in the room says the truth while he didn't even test them. I think Dr. Phil lies himself because he's sceared of society getting mad at him for not believing the "victim". I can clearly see some reversed sexism issues going on in there.
Wouldn't work because if they have been telling a lie for so long they would now think it's true and pass. Well according Doctor I'm always right Phil. That's what told the guy.
@@spartanvt that's not the reason at all, stop with this childish ranting.
@@jupitersnoot4915 Care to offer a different reason instead of insulting my opinion?
To falsely accuse ANYONE of sexual abuse is pure evil
To abuse someone and not accept that you abused them is worse
@@irubberyouglueonethousand5384Do you think he did it? Since you decided to make that reply.
Gets found not lying by polygraph, everyone says junk science he could still be lying.
Gets found he is lying on polygraph EVERYONE believes the science of polygraph and he's guilty lol. It's not the science you disagree with, it's that they find someone innocent you disagree with.
EXACTLY
I agree..this guy was deemed guilty no matter what was in the envelope(not saying he isn't), there was no point in him taking this test tho.
Spot on sir.
The polygraph guy let out a gem. "Our machine registers truth as the person believes". These machines are not full proof
@@StruggleEndure Sociopaths can pass them. And some narcissists..because they believe their own lies. Scary, but true.
They all should have taken the test. Not just one person.
I feel so bad for this man because nobody clapped for him after Dr Phil told him he passed the polygraph test and he’s telling the truth.
I don't know why Dr Phil all of a sudden believed the girls over the lie detector, he always believes the test results. Don't get it. 😮
@@debbiestephenson8494 This is just what happens when a man is falsely accused. If he is proven innocent society still and and will forever see him as guilty
And it was his second test in this matter. I’m sure the women want him to keep testing until they find the one that fits their narrative and gives them the answer they want as opposed to the truth.
@@debbiestephenson8494 Dr. Phil's audience is female. He will never go against who pays his bills.
So the guy passes the test and Doctor Phil has to make him sound guilty. Why are the girls and the ex-wife not taking lie detector tests. It's like the show set this guy up.
Passing doesn't mean that what you are saying isn't a lie. It just means that he personally believes what he is saying to be the truth. It doesn't matter what the actual truth is, polygraphs can't find that, all they can do is tell you whether or not the test taker is purposefully and knowingly lying. If someone is lying but they don't know that they are because they believe what they are saying to be the truth, they will pass solely because they believe their own lies. Polygraphs are worthless
@@jupitersnoot4915 sometimes.
@@jupitersnoot4915 Innocent people have also failed polygraphs. They aren’t reliable.
@@chriskastner1938 yes I know. I'm not defending polygraphs, I'm clearly against them
If I recallcorrectly, the worst crime that they leveled against him was tickling them.
Seems they are mad at him for abandoning them and now want revenge!
During a custody battle with my ex, she accused me of molesting our sons. She later admitted in a cross examination that she only said that because she was mad at me. My sons have never forgiven her for this lie and for other reasons. They have had nothing to do with her for the past 18 years.
It will stay with the accused. It’s wrong. And it’s used so easily by women and often stepchildren.
Glad you were able to clear yourself and have your sons in your life (: it's a shame their "mother" isn't a good person.. I always say just cause you are related to someone does not mean they are good for you. Hope your sons are well! Take care.
@@christinajohnson1804 Thank you very much for your kind comment. I did love my ex, but I couldn’t stop her drinking, which is the main cause of her problems.
@@johnfairweather9188 unfortantly I know that all too well. My mom is an alcoholic and has been my whole life. I'm now 30 and pregnant with my 1st and she's still not good.. sad but at least I know how not to be.. your very welcome!
It's a disgusting thing to make children believe that they have been molested she doesn't deserve to be forgiven
I'd give the stepdaughters all a lie detector test,if so much as one is lying,I'd file a defamation lawsuit,that cure some of these false claims
Like detector tests are borderline useless. They essentially test anxiety
as a women, I just feel like they should’ve given the women tests as well. I’m not saying they’re completely lying but just to settle it, obviously the man was proven not guilty and he’s innocent. just the way they were crying doesn’t sit right with me.
They are crying because (in their minds) NOW they are not being believed. They are crying because they are afraid that they will not be taken seriously. Either he is a monster or they are liars. There is no third way. And they are crying because NOW (with him passing the lie detector) he has PROVEN his innocence which (logically) proves that they are liars. So OF COURSE they have to cry to get some sympathy (any sympathy) to try and gain allies in the world of public opinion.
They are not upset that he molested him. They are upset that he passed the lie detector which makes their accusations look bad. They are upset because this may have "caught" them so to speak. But no, they will never take any tests because they KNOW they are lying. And Dr Phil saying that he doesn't think they are lying doesn't change anything. That is all just for show. Dr Phil knew they were lying from day one.
@@paulcolburn3855 true
@@paulcolburn3855 yes, there is a third way. The third way is that he believes that he did no wrong, and the girls believe he did do wrong.
It's not as simple as "either he's lying or they're lying". If a person believes what they're saying, then they believe it to be true.
A person fails these tests when they're lying and they know they're lying. It's really that simple.
@@missmew3499 : that is true but they are crying because (at that moment) they don't have that moment of clarity on this that you have. They are crying because there is a chance that the audience will no longer believe them. If they could see it the way you did, they probably wouldn't be crying given those results.
@@paulcolburn3855 lol, they're still not lying. Their perception is their truth. Same goes for the man (accused).
It's all a sad situation. Sexual abuse/assault isn't funny, and it's nothing to lie about.
I feel so very bad for innocent men that are accused of this. I am so sorry. I personally haven't been sexually abused by a parent, but I have by a stepbrother, a uncle, a cousin and friend of the family. So when someone that is innocent is accused, it's a big DEAL. Stop this madness!
I'm so sorry for you
I agree, people who accuse someone falsely do not take actual s3xual abuse seriously.
@@LK-gp9yv your partner is kife at jail for 5 year? For something he is dont do? Even after they proof she is say lie he is still in jail justice system must broken and yeah believe womans dont say lie is much more easy for them
@@LK-gp9yv I hope everything change one day
@@LK-gp9yv your welcome and I wonder your bf is in jail for 5 years? Or he is enter jail new?
I think it’s hypocritical that when someone fails a lie detector test, the science is amazing and everyone trusts it, but when someone, who they WANT to be lying, actually tells the truth, all the sudden the test is wrong and he cheated it. I’m shocked that Dr Phil just completely dismissed the polygraph results after he’s always defending how good the test and the examiner is.
It only shows your reactions you can be a psychopath and pass anything lying through your teeth!
@@nobodythatyouknow305
Nahh
Facts
I thought lie detector tests aren’t 100% accurate though? Hence why they’re not allowed in court ?
Hey alexis, so a polygraph test cant determine the truth, all it can do is show if someone is actively engaging in deception.
If someone passes a polygraph, it doesn’t confirm the truth of their statements but it does prove that they themselves 100% believe what they said to be true, which in fairness does increase the validity of their statement, just not to 100%. Whereas if someone fails a polygraph, it shows they were being untruthful when answering the questions, in which case you can much more definitively conclude the truth to be the opposite of what they said, as they knowingly lied about it.
So, why even give the guy a polygraph in fhe first place if they knew they were not going to accept the results to begin with?
dude bro im saying! this made me so angry seeing those women behave that way.
"Jack has conducted over 3500 polygraph exams. Unfortunately, the severity of this type of work has left him with the inability to smile on camera.....ever. "
Well he's dead now so you don't have to worry about it.
@@shellos8 😟
Not much to smile about...
Jack is all business!
Why are women who make these accusations not facing any punishments for destroying this mans life?
Female privilege
Feminism at its finest
Why are THEY not taking the polygraph test!???
My god...see this is why no one wants stepkids. What little liars. Even when dude is shown innocent, he's still guilty.
@@robm4399 you don't need to be with your gf scumbag. Leave her so she can find a real man who can love her children as a father should. You disgust me.
@@pinkpugginz you're not understanding what he meant, read it again and you'll realise you miss read it.
@@zeni2432 just go look at his videos and you will see what we are dealing with . Thank you for your comment .
You can see the pain in his eyes.
Lie detector tests are never 100%. You cannot use them as a way to make a true judgement. Even doctor Phil says he doesn’t think anyone is lying, that there is just a lot going on and people are getting confused.
So they will believe the test is correct if he failed. But don’t believe when he passed the test. That’s idiotic
Can't believe this dude pays for "the best polygraph analyst in the country" and gets the results and says "nah, test wrong" simply because he doesn't like this guy. Absolute BS.
They lied to get him in trouble. You should give the girls the test.
They would all pass
Just the mom. The girls have implanted memories caused by the mom. Mom will fail
@@jupitersnoot4915 ur 🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@abdihassan328 if you don't understand why they'd pass, then you're the clown
@@jupitersnoot4915 😂 😂 😂 ok
Dr Phil: "you're telling the truth but I decided you're guilty." Be impartial and test the women also.
I am disappointed in Dr. Phil’s explanation as to why this man passed his polygraph test. The test reflects the persons memory and I think Dr. Phil just continued to cast doubt on this guy even though the polygraph showed he told the truth. If it would have come back that he failed, Phil would have crucified him. Shame on Dr. Phil for being dishonest and making things up as he goes. Lost a lot of respect for him.
This guy would maybe get a better outcome on Steve Wilkos.
I would love to have seen these women take the polygraph as well.
If u seen the videos that the police reports that the daughters stories didn't add up because first they told a story then the daughters said it's someone else.
RIP Jack! You changed so many lives in your work! I've watched you for years and I know the work you did in your life was a mission complete, over and again!
2:13 How dare this girl make that face. She seriously thinks he’s being ridiculous after hearing how he feels now that his name was cleared?
Polygraph guy is good, but Dan Ribacoff is the best
Steeeeeeeveeeee
STEEEEEEEEEEEEVE
Mr Di Marco passed away for quite some time now. He was very good, calm, no drama. I think Dr Phil misses him.
@@michelinedecupere8526 I didn't start any drama. Just placing a opinion
I really respect Jack as well... So sorry the has passed.
I feel like if he actually did what was said and the results weren't in their favor. Wouldn't they be more devastated and hysterical than they were at that moment?
That's not how polygraphs work. They tell you only what you believe to be the truth. Say for example that you genuinely believe with every fibre of your being that the sky is green. If you take a polygraph test about the colour of the sky being green, you will pass because you genuinely believe that to be the truth. It doesn't matter what the colour of the sky actually is, what matters is whether or not you believe what you say. If you believe it, you will always pass a polygraph.
@@jupitersnoot4915 that’s not what they’re saying tho. He’s saying that if he did actually touch them and the results of the polygraph said otherwise, then their reactions should’ve been a lot different. They would’ve been a lot more upset, a lot more emotionally afflicted because of trauma. Their reaction was surprisingly calm for something so traumatic
@@sorryoutlandish don't judge someone else's trauma. they've been sitting on it for years. they appear truthful. someone that was lying would jump up and start screeching the test was rigged. they're crying with true emotion
Yeah but if came back positive it would’ve been different
He didn't abuse those girls! The test proof it! Those girls need to take a test! They are liars!
The girls trying to ruin his life because he made their mom mad
Happens more than most would think.
@@mccord100 there’s at least 6 episodes I’ve come across where the mom and children all lie about a man abusing them. It’s disgusting.
I think these women were abused by someone - but it wasn't the stepfather. I think someone did sexually abuse these women when they were children and the mom coached them to say it was the stepfather.
The stepdaughters are so pathetic, I'm actually surprised that the step father still has these daughters after them treating him bad. I would've left by then.
Wait...THEY treated HIM bad??? How are they pathetic!! I haven’t watched the whole thing yet. About halfway through
I'm really terrified that people like you and the 64 people that liked your comment exist. Please never have children and stay away from kids
@@pinkpugginz so lying about being molested isn't pathetic? Please stay away from mankind as a whole.
(sorry my comment is little big,but worth the reading) Actually they did and came out that they say the truth.But how not?The mother have put this in their mind from were they was little kids!Even one of them (the blonde) have accuse an other family member that he molest her daughter in the SAME age HERS mother believe was.
In the bottom line ALL of this is cause his wife (ex now) was molested at this age and have poised EVERYONE
@@pinkpugginz Hey, i hope you never have kids. We don't need another copy of you running around this world
Poor guy is accused of abuse, goes on TV to prove his innocence, takes a lie detector test, passes it, and then still has Dr Phil frame it in such a way as to make him sound guilty!
At least give the accusers the test as well to see if they genuinely believe their allegations if you're going to go down this "lie detectors only measure what you perceive to be the truth" road.
Maybe they just have completely opposite perceptions of the same events and nobody is lying, but it's just as possible that the accusers are just making it up.
If you can't just take his word for it that he does not perceive that he did it, then you can't just take their word for it that they do perceive that he did it either. Without them also taking a test then you have to say that the evidence suggests this guy is innocent. Period.
People can pass it and still lie
@@nobodythatyouknow305 I didn't say that they couldn't.
What I am saying is that in the case of one person's word against the other, with no other evidence to go on, then the person who passed a lie detector test should at least be presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Dr Phil always says this is the best man to do a lie detector. I think he was explaining to the girls that this was put into their mind for so long that they truely believe it.
@@nobodythatyouknow305 THEN HE SHOULD NOT HAVE THEM ON HIS SHOW!
@@trulovegirl ? What’s your deal man?
The step daughters have been telling this lie for so many years that they now believe it. Give the daughters a polygraph test.
If they believe it actually happened even though it didn't, they might pass the polygraph test. I think this is the main reason why it's not allowed in the court of law
As the saying goes, " there are 3 sides to every story, his side, her side, and then there's the truth".
His side is the truth.
Dr. Phil's explanation was spot on
As someone who spent my entire life growing up watching my mum fake cry to get what she wants, boom. Right here is a prime example of 3 women doing it.
2:13 How dare this girl make that face. She seriously thinks he’s being ridiculous after hearing how he feels now that his name was cleared?
Dr Phil invalidating everything he has ever said in every show he's done down the years where polygraph has been used. He's even debunking himself now🙄
He's woke.. you must believe women
The accusers need to get a polygraph test done. .
Every case
This man is innocent according to the test.
How about they give the women a polygraph test
2:13 How dare this girl make that face. She seriously thinks he’s being ridiculous after hearing how he feels now that his name was cleared?
Polygraphs are NOT admissible in court for a reason.
I feel like everyone should take a lie detector tests in these situations. Accused and accusers.
I can't imagine going on public TV and talking about things like this.
Even as a woman, I cannot even imagine what this man is going through. This is awful, best of luck to him and I hope his daughters get what's coming to them..
Funny how when it suits dr Phil the polygraph doesn’t count. When he doesn’t want it too. Ironic.
They should have taken the test too. He told the truth.. Some people are dying to play the victim, but it's just not all that when you're living in the trauma. It's offensive to those of us who really did go through it.. How could you destroy a person like that? While real survivors live without any kind of justice.. It's outrageous to me.. You either believe in this technique or you don't. You didn't get the results you wanted, so now suddenly it didn't work?
Dr. Phil should start that both parties should take the test.
Wait, so no one believed him without the lie detector test, he takes the test and passes it and he’s still a liar? I don’t understand it at all... Someone please explain this to me
Polygraphs will only tell what the test taker believes to be the truth.
Say, for example, that you genuinely believe that the sky is green. If you sit down to take a polygraph about the colour of the sky, you will always pass because you genuinely believe what you're saying to be the truth, even when we know for a fact that the sky is not green.
This man genuinely believes he did not harm them, and therefore he passed. He passed not because he was telling the truth, but because he 100% believes his lies to the point where he doesn't even realise he's lying.
@@jupitersnoot4915 sorry, I don’t believe that. It’s cool if you do, you know whatever gets you through the night. He passed the lie detector therefor he passed. Done ✅
@@jupitersnoot4915 that's only a possibility. there's no proof that he was covering up the lies with his knowledge.
@@jupitersnoot4915 well why se dont use this test at girls and mom?
@@jupitersnoot4915 Gina didn't pass her test, assuming you know who Gina is, even though she believed in everything she said.
Memory is not perfect. The mind fills in gaps, alters facts, etc. Narratives can even get created to deal with trauma.
The girls shoulda taken the test. Alcohol had a heavy play in distorting his recollection of those moments. Idk, I think if they did take the test, ppl woulda had concrete proof and would be so torn
2:13 How dare this girl make that face. She seriously thinks he’s being ridiculous after hearing how he feels now that his name was cleared?
at the end of this video, wasn't dr phil saying it's possible that this man could have memory loss due to alcoholism? and that he may have done things while drunk that he doesn't remember? It's at least a possibility
Why is it a black screen & these videos screens keep going black & audio only! Sometimes a reload brings back the video & sometimes not. It’s odd!
Keep in mind there's a reason these tests aren't allowed in a court of law.
You pulled that out of your backside, TJ. They are admissible in 21 states and federal court.
but if we cant find tru and best option is that test then that must allowed
aannd we can give them alcohol so this is will more hard they can say lie and we can use this test at girls to
The legal and allowed to be submitted in courts of 21 states. If polygraphs weren’t accurate the states would not allow them at all
@@sweetsavanna2941 true
He's looking down while answering some questions. That's not a good sign....
Doctor Phil is basically saying I believe he abused you but because he was drunk and doesn’t remember he can’t be held accountable
Now if he had failed the test, they'd be all "I KNEW IT!! HE'S GARBAGE!! THE TEST DOESN'T LIE!!" But he passed...AND THEY DON'T BELIEVE THE TEST😡 WHAT WAS THE POINT???
Dr Phil is literally blaming the guy when he just passed the polygraph test. So why blame the ones who fail it also?
2:13 How dare this girl make that face. She seriously thinks he’s being ridiculous after hearing how he feels now that his name was cleared?
sad that an innocents man’s life can be ruined by lies - how can they turn around and on this episode claim the test results were not correct - why not give the daughters a test also
Bingo, why didn't they ALL take the test. Detective school 101
Wait, Let me get this straight. He passes the lie detecter test. But he is still the bad guy cause he so happens to be a man surrounded by females? lol If he did lie, It wouldn't come out... "Well, Even though u didn't pass this... It doesn't mean u didn't tell a lie." Sure, They didn't take a lie detector test, So we can't say they lied. But they certainly didn't get it right. And an innocent man could have been sent to prison for that.
If polygraphs not used in court! Why Dr Pee uses them!!!!
Dear Dr Phil. I love your show really I do. But the fact of the matter is here's a man that went the distance and you minimized the trauma and pain that he went through the pain he's going through and the accusations, karomshots, and disrespectful stuff he will have to endure for the rest of his life. This interview felt like you were giving those two women vindication and closure. He got ignored because ad you put it hr beat the science. Shame
Make the girls take the test and see how they do, before you make any judgement.
I didn’t believe these women soon as they opened their mouths. I seen barely any tears, looked like a bunch of theatrics to me. Poor man. That’s something that sticks. Being labeled a predator is the worst thing possible and lying about someone doing that to you, they should be held accountable if they’re lying. Make those girls take the test too!
Okay, there maybe a reason that's not mentioned here. I know because I had alcoholics in my family. They can get so waisted and not remember something they did. So in their mind, they may not remember the act, but the sober people around them do. I had an Uncle that would wake up in different places and not remember how he got there. He could be guilty, and not have knowledge of it.
This is how he runs his show. He needs to control the narrative.
Oh good an armchair beer in my hand Expert.
Why didn't they do tests for both parties?
Soooooo guy isn't lying BUT everyone still says he's lying. Let's see...Polygraph TODAY are more accurate than the OLDER ones by far. Phil screwed up by saying that EVERYBODY is NOT lying and that alcohol was the reason. Okay...So wouldn't he have had SEXUAL tendencies when NOT drinking??? Yes, he would...ALCOHOL just allows someone to more easily ACT OUT those tendencies. Phil was wrong. Those women were lying.
He is innocent. Suddenly the lie detector is junk science. 🤦🏽♀️
Did you c that lady shaking her head no when he passed? She probably made up that story to get him out of their lives!
“I believe that your respect of boundaries in a family full of women is really poor.” Dr.Phil.
This is really really well thought of and said. Dr.Phil is extremely capable of describing and handling tough situations in relationships.
This is one of the biggest reasons why you DO NOT RAISE SOMEONE ELSE’S CHILDREN!!!
So if a polygraph reads what YOU believe, even if you’ve still committed the crime, how many other polygraphs did not match the truth of the crime committed???? How many other dirtbags walked off the show with the public thinking they were innocent?
So he passes your test and you still condemn him for having poor boundaries on tv. Nice.
what you wanna say with poor boundaries? and they say he is believe his lie? girls say that? or the server? the dr
Polygraph shouldn't be allowed, unless all parties are tested. Even then its fallible.
Why take the test if he's not going to believe him. Would Phil be saying the same if he was found out to be lying, i don't think so.
Guilty until proven innocent. And even then, everyone still thinks you're guilty
MAKE THE ACCUSERS TAKE A DAMN TEST ALSO!!!
Why are these women shaking their heads.
Y so the test then ?? How do u trust all the rest of the test on shows then??
R.I.P Jack! 🍻
Those that blamed on him should take a test. Cause somethin ain’t right. Shame on them. Smh
If he fails the test, he was lying. If he passes, then he still lying and he distorted reality. Lol this guy cant win. Why give him the test ??
I love when the accusers cry with no tears. Hmm cough cough....liars
The test proves him innocent, seems you don't want to accept his innocence
as soon as the guy opened his mouth, u knew he was being truthful. these women should be ashamed
RIP Jack! You were the best
They ask for a polygraph, they got an answer, they disagree, nothing more can be done, they should give the victims a polygraph
I think all of them should take the test and if i was him id not talk to any of them again they are out to get him for whatever reason. Wash your hands of false accusers, they will try and take you down for something else if they have the opportunity
yeah f I was his situation I will do it to there is a serious case of favoritism here, not testing girls means looking at it with prejudice, it also contradicts the principle that the prosecution should come with evidence.
If he failed he could be prosecuted, these women should be prosecuted for false accusations, they could have ruined his life , they should be punished to send a message out to others
He's innocent and period!!!
He believes his lies, that's why the test showed positive. Polygraphs are worthless.
@@jupitersnoot4915 THEN HE SHOULD NOT HAVE THEM!
These women lied good grief.
Dr. Phil is very gender biased on a lot of these episodes. He doesn’t always hold women accountable, and never makes the females do the polygraph test. He should.
hım what can he do out of polygraph test?
@@mr.dudbud4551 to see if they’re also lying?
@@SunBunz yup
why were the daughters not tested I bet they would have failed
Men have rights too.
That polygraph examiner has the most serious look I have ever soon.
Notice how none of them shed a tear. Bunch of Amber heard’s, especially that one at the end. Their mom did a job on those girls.
Nah what they did to this man was bad. He passed the test and they blamed it on alcohol.
Why dont these women take the test as well.
So we will never know the truth
The mother was molested (for real) at that age and she have poised EVERYONE by that,this is the truth
So why bother with testing then? What BS.
Dr. Phil Spent a whole 2 minutes trying to explain how that happened 🤣🍺