Shashi Tharoor’s Stinging Criticism Of Sitharaman’s Budget 2024; ‘Modi Govt Has Run Out Of Ideas…’
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- Congress MP Shashi Tharoor slammed the central government over the Union Budget presented by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, calling it "a woefully missed opportunity". Watch this video to know more.
NATIONAL NEWS
#india #INDIA #Shashitharoor #budgetsession #nirmalaSitharaman #Centralgovernment
Hindustan Times Videos brings all the News for the Global Indian under one umbrella. We break down news from across the globe from the unique lens of a Rising India. Tune in for Explainers, Opinions, Analysis and a 360 degree view of big events in India and the World which impact your present and future.
Follow the Hindustan Times Channel on WhatsApp for News Alerts, Top Stories and Editor picks. Join Us Today - www.bit.ly/3PQ...
Subscribe to the Hindustan Times YT channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
Visit our website www.hindustant...
Follow us on Twitter / httweets
Follow us on Facebook / hindustantimes
Mr Tharoor you are speaking to the wrong crowd. Can you please stoop down a bit to the spectators around you. Those jokers pay no attention to you, as they barely understand. Please dont throw pearls to the pigs.
Who is the incompetent uneducated Ringleader and circus clowns who have ZERO knowledge on budget but 100% on extortion n corruption past 11 years....ELECTORAL BONDS ...PM CARES FUND ...BIHAR BROKEN BRIDGE / MORBI FUND ANDHRA capital fund ....This budget A+B = FC ...full corruption and winner is hey Prabhu ....frequent flyer @ tax payers expense...free loader 😂 Zero performance unlike world renowned and highly educated
" DR. MANMOHAN SINGH " Ex PM highly respected than the fancy dress self obsessed 😂
Yes you are also one of the pig😊
You are true shashi tharoor
5000 crores for one marriage shame on modi
no but its been recorded
One of the Worst Budget of Independent India. Wow ...Ms. Sitaraman ...!!!!! Educated Lady.....sucking Blood of Poor & middle class ...
Lol
@@ismaildaimari5553 Can understand your pain
Ugh center ought to ashamed
He is on point, so correct.. joblessness, aam admi's income tax burden are major crisis in the country
Even if bjp continues it should be handed over to yogi rather than modi.
@@anirudhhattangadi3534 yeah and make nameboards mandatory for running business 😂😂
Oh, you want to get a good paying job and don't want to pay taxes and then where the money will come from to run the country? Think about that,
Kaun Banayega jobs?
@@praveenraj2640 correct me if am wrong but there's a point behind it.If we live it to them ,sometimes( though not sure if I should be saying this) the so called religious leaders including love Jihadis ones can just become a nuisances, this doesn't necessarily mean yogi is particularly against someone just because he or she born to a Muslim family
WOW, Mr Tharoor, you really brought out the points which India needs the most.
The budget was written by Adani and his team....sitharaman only read it.
`Adani creats jobs, companies, projects an d wealth for the country like no other and Tharoor drinks and gets into bed with Mahua. Without Adani, Ambani, Tata, Birla, India will be Pakistan!! Just like, without Microsoft, Tesla, Google, NVDA, Ford, USA will become Mexico.
Had Tharoor any other stupid told you that?
Good one 😂😂😂😂😂
Yes, it is true that Adani is doing a lot for India, building ports, airports, coal mines, missiles for Indian Army etc. etc. while politicians of INDI jote are producing 2 kg of fertilizer every day like Rahul Gandhi!!
@@stratfordqbiswas853 doing a lot for india? We do not get any benefits while that guy reaps our hardwork with corruption
The finance minister sitaraman will come back with a rehearsed speech. The speech will be full of blame for the UPA government. She will only play India alliance states against bjparty states and center. Basically, she will not give one straight answer in response to any argument.
all 3 cancer drugs from same pharma company....should be investigated
Electoral bonds must be involved here.
ED or CBI can't investigate.
Or the company must be belonging to Modi parivaar
@@fardadficompany belongs to poonawala he plays both side.
Such a person should be the Finance Minister of our country and not someone arrogant, irresponsible and unsympathetic like Nirmala Sitharaman
You are right.Why isso arrogant?
I hope wherever she goes people stand with placards asking her to resign.
Such a person will sell india and we won't even know.. let expert there jobs
Why are you sending replies to all comments@@AreYouSure007
But he is in wrong party
The BUTT UGLY part of the budget which should trigger a national uproar and protest is Indexation of property sale. My grandfather’s ₹30,000 house purchase is now ₹4cr is taxed at ₹50,00,000. With indexation it would be ₹6 to ₹7 lakhs. !!!! 800% increase in Tax!!!!.
NO ONE WILL SELL ANCESTRAL PROPERTY until this is revoked
TOTALLY AGREED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Or sell it for 4.5 Cr. This will surely bring stagnation in the real estate sector.
Invest the entire money. [02 properties]Keep for 03 years. Sell it. Take profit in Cash. Pay NO TAX. Cheers.
@@vir7070 🚓🚓 IT RAID DEPLOYED 🚓🚓
Cheers
@@vir7070 ya if we keep inv sting the money then when are we supposed to use it if not in an emergency
I am SO SO SO GLAD he spoke about the healthcare system in India.. other countries do so much for medical care but India lags far behind thank you Shashi Tharoor
Our Finance Minister (FM) avoids addressing the impact of the current budget on the commoner and gives evasive answers. What is her justification for double taxation on a selected few? Why impose GST on food items, medicine, hospital expenses, etc? This doesn't seem very honest, given that our PM was against taxing food and essential items used by the commoner while he was a Chief Minister. Despite this, our FM implemented GST on almost everything and increased taxation on everyday people's income and expenses. The ordinary citizen does not have social security benefits and continues to be taxed on everything they have until death, which is ironic. State governments also contribute to maximising the overall burden.
Elected officials frequently raise their salaries, and annual operating expenses continue to increase. The ruling parties appear to be taking no effective measures to reduce administrative costs; instead, they continue to raise taxes, levies, fees, and surcharges on everything to maximize revenue. Real inflation exceeds 10%, while the official range published by the authorities is below 6%. What are we trying to achieve: becoming a world superpower or reaching a five trillion-dollar economy, and at what cost?
Every company pays taxes after offsetting its expenses against income. In contrast, ordinary citizens are diligently taxed on their income and expenses, subjecting them to a double tax burden. Does our constitution honestly guarantee equal rights for everyone? Is that the reality today?
“Politics” shall be defined as Poly(i) = Many and Tic = Bloodsucking insects. We must take responsibility for electing these individuals to govern our nation and negatively impact our lives.
Excellent writing
Lol. Nobody elected her. She didn't even participate for election. What's even her expertise to be FM. Is there no body else in the country. Omg.
Not all is bad this budget will also hurt those who are rich and help redistribute income to the citizens
He is absolutely right. Supporting BJP was big mistake
How ?
@@AreYouSure007re watch the video - get your friends to maybe to translate it with language you're comfortable in😅
@@AreYouSure007learn English 😂
@@dhirajdhotre393 oh well video is just about possible financial problems we are facing how its related to the op comment of big mistake ?
People who are in upper middle class or who are loosing money in stock market and high tax due to inflation how does that imply we should not have supported bjp ?
@@vickydesmond5947 🤡
Worse budget, Sitaraman ji should resign
Keep cooking and leave the economy to the educated people!
@@stratfordqbiswas853 you are extremely pathetic and dumb
@@stratfordqbiswas853 Educated people are leaving India, maybe because they are too educated to understand that India doesn't offer them as much as others.
Ji hat gaya hai naam se itni tareef ke baad😂
Not only FM but modi n shah
British lagan 2024. Small scale industries is dying with biased GST and middle class is dying because of tax.
3 guna lagaan bharna padega 😂😂
Yeah rich class who hides behind middle class will definitely get hurt
Brilliant mindset, Brilliantly said, truly very valid points mentioned, but it will definitely rests on deaf, bumb, illiterates,
Percentage of corporate tax getting less.... Percentage of personal tax ( middle class ) getting higher. This sums up the government's vision and mission. No wonder our Prime Minister had time to attend Ambani's wedding but no time for the people of Manipur....
Variety of Tax in India sucking the blood of middle and poor class people in the name of GST, indirect tax, professional tax, cess, surcharge etc keeps going on . No other country in this world has like these taxes . Only one tax flat 5% as VAT
Wedding is main desh seva is modis job lecturing is job of oposition
NO, I live in the USA and 45% of my income go to Federal tax (30%), State income tax (10%) and property tax, sales tax (5%). Some Europeans pay almost 50%.
Once I complained to my boss about high taxes in the USA, he said you should be proud that you pay high taxes because it only means you make high salary.
@@stratfordqbiswas853 what about labour law and salaries in foreign countries it is well organized. when you look at india corporate are underpaying 1000 rupees for Engineering graduates and making them work for whole days. does this happen in USA ? do you accept this conditions.
@@udayk19 Wrong, companies or even government organizations do not have any salary scale. people get paid all kind of salaries for the same job. Salaries are mostly confidential and depends on individual negotiation. It is capitalist country and they decide depending on their needs what an employee will get.
Will BJP care to understand this ?
Shashi Taroor Sir 💐
Sir don't blame sitharaman, this budget was drafted from outside the house. Adani and Ambani .😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Exactly true two ani's of India Ambani and Adani
Ambhani 😅😅😅😅😅
Horrors!
The ruling Government should have produced and submitted a Thanks giving Budget to the voters of the country instead of giving a budget for only certain class and sector...
Dr. Shashi Tharoor's speech and the presentation is far far better than the Budget Speech of the Finance Minister..
Probably the Government should give attention to this type of speech and should not take it as a criticism ...
This may be helpful to do better in the coming days....
Tharoor is a failed MP. He has done nothing in his constituency. He is smart at talking bullshits everywhere and dumbs would fall in his false aura.
Can't understand why no one talks about the Sr citizens. The cost of health care and the basic food have gone out of reach of Sr citizens. They survive only on interest income which have come down. I am not talking of the Sr citizens in Parliament who don't pay income tax and get the sevices free.
The FM understand that the common Sr Citizens can't organize protests like the farmers do or dodge the tax net like the industrialists do. So taking advantage of the situation the FM prepared the death bed for the common Sr citizens of India. BRAVO... Long live the progressive budget...
She wants sr citizens to leave the world soon and reduce their burden on the earth
I agree completely with you..it is difficult for them to sustain themselves until they are supported by their children or some relatives in terms of their health expenses which are far too high ..the pressure eventually passes down to the younger generation...and the younger generation themselves are suffering due to high taxes .It is an infinite loop for a family where they all are stuck just managing to
continue and survive..
Wondering why bjp was not shouting during the speech...? It's because they didn't understand the English. 😅
Shashi tharoor should be in British Parliament
Shashi tharoor should be in British Parliament
Shashi tharoor is more intelligent
Brilliant speech
He should be finance minister in upa
One of my idol🙏 Thanks to Kerala for elected him❤
Government should ask for her immediate resignation
Oh why ?
Sitaraman is only the surface of the problem. The main problem is this government which has lost all credibility and this PM who has time and again been exposed as a total fraud. It's high time to change the current regime and give the opportunity to different parties to show their work.
@@AreYouSure007again my why , 😂, learn English or get someone to translate it in a language you understand
@@vickydesmond5947 maybe you should learn to explain better then just dodging the question.. and whats so funny ?
As usual always on point
N no bullshit
Great speech 👍
Tharur, thanks lot... Beautifull presentation... Nobody in the govt side to understand the high worthy of what Tarur the world's best statesmen.
Jio mobile subscription fees were 666 until a few days ago. Now it is 799.
Why the rate of recharge is everytime increasing whereas your net provider was so irregular and gave us so many inconvinencies.
You are out of this world! Shashi, you are no match.
Very truthful speech. Best wishes. Jhn
Pretty sure the chair couldn't keep up with Sashi Tharoor's English 😂
I wish loksobha in future
full of intelligent people
Not dhongi baba, chaiwala,
Chor and gunda
Education health environmental.programs ..none of this interest A fomer chai wallah. With all. Due respect Sir
Just search who is the worst Finance Minister of India and see the results 😩
Search not needed😂
Is it P Chidambaram?
@@sudharshankomandur4118no it's modis mistress
@@sudharshankomandur4118Your Aunty FM 😅
@Achi-g4r LOL. If you had just put her name I would have liked and moved on. But damn you had to turn out as subhuman trash didn't you?
Crystal Clear and precise delivery. Mr Tharoor is a joy to hear. This is why Trivandrum votes him to the Lok Sabha term after term. If BJP could understand what he said.
I'm here just to hear Throor speak with his impeccable English
At least the dogs didn't bark during the speech......I doubt they even understood anything 😅😅
They will listen Dogs and pigs tracks from pf album Animal to understand kaka Shashi speech 😅
I was thinking the exact same thing.. after the sabha they will group together and say "bhagwan jaane ye bol kya raha tha".
People still have sweet memories of economy prior to 2014.
We pay, they play. Plain and simple
Therefore nothing has changed since the English left India: average Indian people are resigned to living like slaves to BJP, Adani and Ambani.
BJP is just killing middle class 😂 why crorepati farmers are enjoying life without tax😂
Because they are the influencers of voting in farmer community.
Yeh parasites, politicians kaun sa tax dete hain? Hamara khoon choosne ke liye hain, angrej chaley gaye, inhone unki jagah le li.
Understand that a very small percentage of farmers are millionaires. Mainly, these politicians and business people take land after land and show themselves as an farmers. It's mainly loop holes from them to take the land not farmers.
Shashi, you are a great speaker.
You make us understand very vital factors .
You are the voice of the common .man.n you are way ahead of most politicians stay blessed always 🙏 ❤️ ✨️ jhn
As Kejriwal rightly said "mitron ki sarkar" probably that's why he's sitting in jail. Shame on Mr.Modi for betraying the trust of our citizens.
In Oxford people will listen to this man with utmost sincerity and respect, as he is a man of wisdom. But in our Indian Parliament, the under educated and under qualified speaker, who knows nothing about international affairs, wouldn't hesitate to ring the bell to save the precious few minutes, so that the opposition can start screaming to divert the truth
Shashi Tharoor is of a calibre fit to be a PM considering his overwhelming intellectual ability while being down to earth as is evidenced in his parliamentary debates which shows his great depth of understanding. But his own party did not make him Congress President which is sad. India would be a totally different nation if we had such leaders as him and say, Sachin, Gogoi, Gadkari or Rajnath Singh at the highest levels of authority
90 percent of the MPs might not have comprehend what he said 😂😂
Thank you Dr.Shashi Tharoor🌸
18% tax on life insurance premium..what a shame to collect money
The (honour)un worthy Finance minister is absent because she will not be capable of addressing the issues raised by intelligent opposition leaders like P. Chidambaram and Sashi tharoor.
He is very correct
Can we do election again, I want to change my vote.
same. i wish there was an UNDO button I could press 😢
BJP fellows are headless
You were blinded by other factors. You must enjoy this government.
Next time 2029 just remember this budget dont get manipulated by any fake surgical strike
Lol ignorant fools regretting after election... Didn't you see the blue print of what's happening even before election you fools
Wish Congress had chosen him to lead.
Valid arguments🎉
Compared to 2004 with now inflation hike , the Government should collect Income tax only after 15 lakhs of earning.. Then only the middle class can make some small savings too.. But for this Government only the rich should save, Invest and spend luxuriously!
For this the govt or FM will not refer 2014,2004 etc but for all matters they will compare Nehru,Indira, Rajiv,Sonia (!)
WONDERFUL SPEECH BY SHASHI THAROOR JEE
The opposition was silent because they don't understand English 😅
Mr.Tharoor is talking in English in front of SUPER-EDUCATED politicians who understand only Norwegian language🤣
We have hospital but we don't have doctors in it most of the government semi government hospital
India's loss, 5 eyes gain😂
Reservation lo
Well expressed Shashi!!!
Rightly named *NDA...No Data Available* government
12% gst on medicine whilst on gold only 3%😢
DID ANYBODY SEE SASI IN TRIVANDRUM DURING | Joy | Amayizhanchan Thodu | Rescue ? - He never get 1 hour for Trivandrum people...and he talks for 140 crore people
Have you selected him to participate in Parliament Discussion or for TVM ward?
He is member of parliament ward based problems should be solved by local body .
Tharoor is a pan Indian leader, only he is representative of Trivandrum, but he representative of all Indians throughout our country!!
Such Dumbness....I am appalled and equally surprised by your education itself. What kind of academia are you from?
@@georgejacob4327I thought elected representatives were also supposed to bring development to their constituencies? Is trvandrum an exception?
.Mr Shashi Tharur should have been either Congress PM candidate or Congress President. He is most learned intellectual.
As you said, the F. M. is always trying to shout on the members whoever try to point out the Government's partialities
1) the wedding yes thank you for pointing it out.
2) Peeche wale dekho so raha hai…
Dr Tharoor 's erudite speech falls on Modi's deaf ears. And where is our PM when budget is being discussed? No PM before has ever skipped budget discs.
No one dared to raise a voice from the opposition because they know how intellectual he is and accurate at his points 🙌🙌
Nirma presented to us Burma Tax.
The birth of Black Money
I pay the same 33% of tax that Ambani or Adani pay.. Or some of the Bollywood stars or crickteers pay. These rich guys should pay upwards of 50 % or more.
What about some help for medical studies, medical profession. Nothing mentioned in the budget.
This government works only for aadani like corporates. They had written off 16.8 lakh crore loans of the corporates but not even a single rupee of the annadada. where does this money comes from ? from, the poor common man in the form of rakshaSiy GST and personal tax
kisan sadak par aye tho unko rokte he gigantic baricades khada karke. hazaron kisan
atmahatya karthe he nirash hoke.
bhatho ka bharath mahan 😌
EXCELLENT TRULY SAID THAROOR JI ❤❤
WORST PM AND FM EVER BORN IN HISTORY OF🇮🇳 INDIA 😮😮
MUST RESIGN 😅
I don’t see anyone trying to obstruct Mr Tharoor because he is too educated for anyone there for opposition 😂
Senior citizens must be tax free
This budget was prepared mainly for Adani and Ambani
In one sentence, to say that, [2024] it is 'the most mindless budget, prepared by the mindless government machinery', for which, as a frontal face, Finance Minister is taking the blame, without knowing by every one that, she is only for the name sake Finance Minister, but the actual play is prepared, designed, & operated by the bureaucracy, in concurrence with, the Honorable Prime Minister of India. Thank you.
Everyone was silent throughout while he was speaking because kuch bolne k liye pehle samajhna padta hai ki samne wala kiya bol raha hai.. 😄
Excellent presentation 🎉
I have some Andhbhakt friends who are defending high taxation they will pay after this budget. This is like chicken defending KFC.
ask them to pay your share too they will shutup nxt moment
Mr. Tharoor, Congress MP gives h truth out of the 2024 Budget presented by the Finance Minister Dr. Mrs. Nirmala Sitaraman. She’s a highly educated lady, but a hardcore BJP unfortunately. They are killing the common man and uplifting Adani & Ambani like buisinessmen. It’s such a pity & shame on her. She’s inclined to the rich 🤑 and not the poor 😅. She goes along with the BJP regime. Her husband himself is so much against her. The policies of BJP is irresponsible totally. What Dr. Sashi Tharoor says is absolutely correct 100%. People should have the guts to open up their dark side of the budget. There’s so much pomp and show in the BJP. It’s quite disturbing and disgusting 🤢. BJP project it as a good budget, the budget is far from the disadvantaged people in all ways. Dr. Manmohan Singh time had a great budget presentation. Let them hear and learn about it, so that they can learn from good people. May God bless Bharath Madha abundantly in all ways. It’s for the good of all. God bless 🙏🙌👆
Access to quality and compulsory education as been overlooked. It must be available to everyone, absolutely everywhere
Very well spoken❤
Very good speech.
Here in present situation, No minister has any authority. Only 4 ministers are authorised, P. M, Defence Minister, Home Minister & Little part to Gadkari (just bcoz of RSS)
Mr . Shashi . I do admire your fluent English ! Being from Kerala ! I do also admire your words on the present status of this country ! May God bless you ! ! !
Senior citizens must get free health care in all hospitals ,above 70 absolutely free
More than 80percent of the
Members must not have understood sharoors speech
This is a worst government in Indian history
A typical crony capitalism budget! The pathetic budget ever in independent India! 😢
18 percent gst on life and health insurance shame
eye opening ,& present reality . Excellent presentation . by tharoor
Indexation of property is atrociously steep,very scheming budget,same old story of middle class being squeezed, budget is biased towards uber rich class, various stratas of taxation is phenomenally high.
Corporates give them gifts, sponsor their expenses,hence they are allowed lesser tax rates, whilst what do individuals give them?
He is gem
There is no much difference between "employed" and "un-employed" in these economies. You are employed, take all risks and pay back money earned to Government in different forms of taxes. It seems, it's not far away, that govt. might introduce an additional tax of tax on payment of tax 🙂. Please re-consider and reduce the burden on middle class and salaried or employed and investment class.
Mean while a sewage worker got stuck and lost his life on his line of duty in a deluge " ask were "
I am from Andhra Pradesh
I am not happy about the budget
😑
just hearing him makes me want to pursue language
Such an intelligent way to criticize the budget. Based on numbers and not personal attacks. We need leaders like you in the opposition speaking up more to create a balance view of the country. Keep it up.
Jumlas have ruined India's story forever.
Bridges were down in Bihar is made by the state Govt.
"Name changing Government > Game Changing Government " Mr. Tharoor
For all those who voted for BJP........the big hindu middle class....Modani had thanked in a wonderful way through Nirmalamma budget. Enjoy getting robbed......
It's seem the BJP mp doesn't understand what and where this budget is wrong, they just num as fools and totally depends on their financial minister, so only her knowing where and what she had doing wrong