Who is the Greatest Home Run Hitter of All Time?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- I put together the most stacked home run derby in history to answer one question: who is the greatest home run hitter of all time?
It's a topic that has been and will be debated for generations. And while the argument can never be truly settled, today, with the help of MLB The Show, I'm gonna try to get an answer by putting the hardest hitters in history head to head to find the best of the best.
MERCH: SluggerSociety...
Follow me on Twitch: / jarodactyl
Follow me on Twitter: / @jarodactylyt
Follow me on TikTok: / ucyoctay-j_aq04qhg1spsuw
Music from @Lud and Schlatts Musical Emporium / @ludandschlattsmusical...
You should put dingus on the mound and try to pitch a perfect game.
Yes please. I always want more Dingus content, he's Fumble Dimension's Stupid Crapface but for baseball.
Yes
HE DID it
He listened
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned that the bash brothers were McGwire and Canseco, not Sosa.
An argument could be made for Gehrig and Ruth or Mantle and DiMaggio as the "first" bash brothers in my book though.
Big time. Those guys were smashing them out of the park on a regular basis and we know they weren't on performance enhancing drugs
I’m glad a champion of eating balanced meals, working out to a consistent schedule, and a champion of (checks notes) honesty and integrity won this fun simulated competition.
McGwire eats clen, trens very hard, anavar gives up. True role model.
It's amazing that Bagwell still doesn't get any love. He didn't cheat and made the hall of fame. Smh.... I would take him over those two any day.
Facts I think with the obvious Juicers in the game there should be a way their power is mediocre until they enter "Juice mode" or something then and only then can they approach the likes of Aaron, Mays or Griffey, McGwire and Sosa don't belong in any discussion with the rest of the guys.
Bonds juiced and I would still take him over Bagwell. Both his unjuiced form and juiced form.
@@OldBenKenobi2318 as a player, sure but Would He be worth the headache as big a prick as He was? F No dude was insufferable, Both guys underwhelmed in the postseason....Bonds finally had a little success with the needles assistance but before that He was always a post season no show, the most maddening thing about Bonds was He was an easy HOFer without the juice, But He got got jealous over a couple roid heads grabbing more attention than him and preceded to piss on his own legacy as well. Instead of being Cobb, an all time great who was also an all time A**hole Bonds just became An All time A**hole who roided out so bad his head grew, THAT's his legacy.
Same with Pujols.
It’s not even a question, Barry bonds is the best slugger all time. Not even close
*
@Pwnzistor you have one for Ruth being in segregated league?
@@Halmir4126 yes it is hank than pojols
And the most juiced player of all time too. He would be nowhere near the 762 mark without roids.
My dad always said McGwire was the best home run hitter ever cuz if you go by number of at bats per home run he beats everyone
If you are doing the greatest home run hitters of all time, include Sadoharu Oh, who hit over 800 home runs inthe Japanese League. Frankly, that is still more than 40+ home runs than Bonds hit, and he wasn't on steroids.
Im so glad i found your channel bro. love the vids man.
Hank Aaron. He wasn't jacked up on roids like a couple others. It was about his swing, seeing the ball and natural talent.
Griffey Jr? Albert Pujols?
BONDS DUDE this is a bogus ridiculouse video with no bonds and an insult
Your favorite team is the Phillies… and McGwire was your favorite player growing up… are you me?
I thought you would have put Albert Pujols in there because he has 703 Career home runs
Babe rith,no video necessary!!!
54 pound bat!?! 😂
It may be Aaron Judge
BARRY BONDS. 1
Where pujols?
Barry Bonds, the greatest homerun hitter (and perhaps the greatest hitter) of all time, would win.
What? 😂😂😂😂
What says the guy who knows nada about baseball 😂
@@sagelow3274 I’ve forgot more about this game than you’ll ever know!
Mark McGwire was a steroid junkie and he’s in the game and bonds isn’t ? Bonds is blackballed by mlb but no matter what he is still the best of all time
Cheater
If Bonds will be in the game, he should to be the best hitter of the game by far, 175 of contact, power, vision and maybe discipline
As far as pure power/distance… McGwire is WELL ABOVE Balco Bonds. Macs longest home runs dwarfed barry’s ;)
And don’t forget… McGwire’s career Home Run per at bat ratio is better than bonds.
And 175 steriods.
@@jimclaus1576this literally isnt true at all barry's homerun at angel stadium was like 520
@@jimclaus1576also distance doesnt matter all you gotta do is hit it 325 to get it out
and Bonds did every other aspect of the game better than McGwire by far….not even close. I love McGwire but he’s not in the same class as Bonds.
Is it possible to bunt for an inside the park homerun? You should try that.
There's a video on TH-cam where Ichiro bunted a home run. It's a good edit. 😅
@@Ascending11 That was an edit?!
Why is McGuire in the game but not bonds? Bonds is the goat
bonds pulled himself out of MLBPA's licensing agreement in 2004
It would be fun to see an old timers HR Derby. I miss Old Timers games.
Not the same as the old timers games from the ASG weekend that they used to do, but every year the Yankees host Old Timers Day and you get to watch guys like Goose, Gator, Bernie, O'Neill. Rivera played in one or two. Reggie as well. Not quite what it used to be since the passing of Yogi. It was always a treat just to see him standing on the field.
I'm honestly glad "Balanced Breakfast" Barry wasn't in the video. Had to make it a competition after all.
Facts
Mark McGwire is great but would love to have seen Albert Pujols in the competition.
I wish Barry allowed his likeness in games...
It would break the game 💀💀
Head size overload!!! 😂😂
Bonds had one 50+ home run season, and only led the league in home runs twice over a 22 year career. His 2001 season is all people really remember. He wasn’t the best home run hitter of all time if you look at a rate basis, he was just the most consistent over a longer period of time. Mark McGwire had four 50+ home run seasons and led the league in homers 4 times in his 16 year career. McGwire’s career home run per at bat rate: 10.61.
Bonds career home run per at bat rate: 12.92. McGwire also had 4,946 less plate appearances than Bonds. If McGwire had as many plate appearances as Bonds did he would’ve hit 960 home runs.
McGwire is the true best power hitter of all time, and if I haven’t convinced you with the numbers I’d love to hear your argument.
Neither of those guys are the best HR hitter of all time, HTF is the best pure power of all time gonna be juiced to the Gills?, I mean "pure" has to count for something. Aaron Will always be the king until someone clean actually surpasses him. Griffey May have had a shot had He stayed healthy.
Ken Griffrey Jr got the smoothest swing of them all. his injuries definitely hindered his all-time stats
The bash brothers were Mark McGuire and Jose Canseco when they played for the A’s.
Yea, my memory failed me. Woops.
i thought same thing. but i was like o well who realy cares lol. i dont get why bonds isnt in the game. guess because his stats cant fit lol.
The ideal way to win the home run derby is to hit line drive wallscrapers and also two 440 footers, because the game doesn't let another pitch get thrown until the previous one lands. Guys like Tim Locastro can win derbies at high elevation stadiums because of it.
Why would you leave out bonds? If it’s because of steroids, you should have left out McGuire , Sosa, and Griffey jr(yes I said it, Griffey juiced). Seems pretty bs to me.
I said in the video, he isn't in the game.
I think video games have officially become TOO realistic. I can literally make out each individual person in the crowd lol.
Albert is not in this game? That's criminal. Just 703 homeruns. Wow. The disrespect.
In reality Mark McGwire had by far the best home run rate of all time. I think you had something like 10.8 at bats per home run
3,000 fewer ABs than Ruth who had several seasons where he was mostly pitching during the dead ball era, so he had several seasons where his AB/HR was far below his ability. He also wasn't on steroids, and was playing in VASTLY bigger ballparks. McGwire was a complete product of PEDs.
Except... he cheated.
@@laartwork none of the hundreds of others that cheated could match that rate
Probably because he wasn’t getting IBBed like bonds or bud selig fined teams that didn’t let their roid jesus save baseball
@@LouieiuoL1223and he was on steroids for a longer period of his career than bonds
The answer is me. I am the greatest home run derby hitter of all time. You should know I gave you the work in one.
1. The BABY Ruth candy bar is NOT named after Babe Ruth and the Bash Brothers is what people called the late 80s/early 90s Oakland As, mostly Maguire and Canseco.
Your so underrated I love your content i subbed around 10k ❤❤❤
Ruth is the best all time. Period. End of.
He was facing plumbers during the Great Depression. They were throwing 70 mph tops. He is not the best all time. Period. Never give a baseball take again.
Dude, Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa were absolutely NOT known as the Bash Brothers.... that was Mark McGwire and Jose Canseco when they played together on the Oakland A's
I don't know if anyone else has mentioned this before, but the player likenesses are terrible in this game. Almost none of them look like their real-life counter parts. Ken Griffey Jr. was the worst. Not only did they get his face wrong, but his skin also looked to be much too light. Babe Ruth and Willie Mays looked ok, but they could be better. In the age of AI and deep fakes you are telling me they couldn't get face scans of the players for this game.
Why did he not put Sammy vs mark?
Here is my comment to your video "short" about Barry Bonds and his secret to hitting. I offer it here, because comments are not offered on video "shorts".
Very few people know this or have connected the "dots" on why Mr. Barry was such a "great" hitter. Most public discourse on Barry Bonds has always been subject to criticism because of the issue of Race. Something Barry noticably helped create himself by his open disdain and disgust with the media in general, by his self induced reticence in openly talking and/or doing interviews. Especially once the STEROID Era and issues surfaced in the 1990's decade( primarily). So, without further delay, I offer this theory and opinion of Barry Bonds's " Secret to Hitting": Barry Bonds quite obviously ingested of took "steroids" or PEDs. It is obvious. In the video clip, it is mentioned that a hitter still has to HIT the 100+mph thrown baseball. Not something easy to do at all. But few know, that STEROIDS/GH/ and PEDs CAN and DO affect EYESIGHT!!!!!! A person can even develope hyper accurate eyesight BEYOND 20/20, even down to 20/10 vision! Now, stay with me on this. Couple that, with Mr. Barry using an Extremely HUGE padded elbow protector to take away fear from pain of a thrown pitch. Add to that, because of the lack of pain fear with a large Elbow, even Arm protector, Mr. Barry then started to CROWD the plate more and more over time. Partly because of his pedigree( his Father and his Godfather Willie Mays), and because Barry liked to invoke the "Race card", Barry's Strike zone became smaller and smaller and SMALLER over time.
Superior Steroidal induced hyper accurate eyesight, A HUGE Elbow pad protector, crowding the plate more and more fearlessly, playing the race card on called balls and strikes, Mr Barry "Fake Homerun King" Bonds, created such a small small miniscule strike zone for HIMSELF, that he could basically ONLY hit a Homerun, or Walk. THAT IS THE ULTIMATE SECRET OF FAKE HOMERUN KING. He was a super star player before all that. He( and many others of course) did these things for MORE MONEY and FAME. Barry Bonds created a unique Unfair advantage for himself. It is THAT, that is his REAL SECRET. period
would we consider pete alonso one of the best one day? like strictly speaking in terms of hr hitters
i think pete alonso could also deserve a spot in this vid. there is obviously basis because i’m a mets fan but he is one of the best homerun hitters in the game right now
There are some goodones..presteroids..like Dave kingman,Mickey mantle,even Darrel strawberry..
But I'd chose Willie stargell..he was still hitting bombs 16 yrs into the league
To bring the seemingly endless debate to this comment section: Bonds, McGwire, and Sosa all deserve to be in the hall.
You cant tell baseball's history without em, and none of them ever won a World Series while juiced. Plus, steroids dont give you inhuman levels of plate discipline, AND the pitchers were juiced too. On that point, Gagne and Clemens should be in the hall too.
Edited: Which video game character is the greatest video game home run hitter. lol
Barry Bonds is the undisputed GOAT hitter of Baseball. If you disagree you are a hater. He may have been roided out but so were the pitchers throwing him the ball. He is truly the GOAT
I wish Bo Jackson was in the game
hey i know you've completely rebranded ur channel but do u think u could make the bombparty tournament videos public again? theyre kind of a big part of the games history as it was the first documented bigscale tournament. if u dont wanna stain ur recently uploaded, u can upload them on an alt and that would work just as well
That depends are we talking most hrs,most likely to homer or who hit it the longest...cause Willie stargell went full ham on one ball and I think it went 500ft?
They actually named the Baby Ruth candy bar after Grover Cleveland's daughter who was named Ruth but lets be honest thats bullshit
I feel like stanton should be here just if you are looking at who hits the hardest and farthest home runs
Little upset at no Pujols.
I thought I was the only one who called Ken Griffey Jr KGJ 🤷♂️
Rip Willie mays😢
The bash brothers were McGwire and canseco, not McGwire and Sosa.
It’s a crime not having Bonds in the game
Tell him to get his head out of his ass and join the MLBPA then
Criminal that you left out Pete Alonso
I can only choose 8 batters in the history of baseball and you think Alonso is on that list 🧐
Small nitpick, Sosa and McGwire weren't the Bash Brothers, that was Canseco and McGwire when they were in Oakland.
Wrong players on thumbnail. Trout shouldn't be there
/babe Ruth routinely stepped up to bat with a 74 inch bat/
Bonds is an ass, but leaving him off the list is a crime. Most feared hitter of all time.
Why is it ok to put Sosa and Mcgwire in the game but no Bonds lol?
Rip David Ortiz and Manny Ramirez
Omg, baby Ruth is not named
For the babe and sosa wasn’t a bash brother
Babe Ruth.
Jose Canseco just had a heart attack when he heard you call them the bash Brothers
*The ‘bash brothers’ was Canseco & McGwire*
Prime Steroid Giant Barry Bonds was, without question the most dominant HR hitter of all time. Guy was dropping 70 bombs WHILE taking 200 walks. Nothing ever like that.
He was a monster pre juice but his power game was in the 33 a year HR range, 40 to 50 stolen bases, and stellar defense.
When his head started to grow, I still want to know what exercise makes your hat size go up 4 or 5 non fraction sizings. But when his head grew, that choked up bat was the most dominant offensive threat in MLB history.
You can hate the roids, the era, and even Bonds himself, but you can’t deny that presence. Screw a derby, MLB pitching vs MLB hitting, Bonds was THAT dude.
Babe Ruth wasn't the inspiration for the name of Baby Ruth Candy bars, but actually after the deceased daughter of former President Grover Cleveland, one Ruth Cleveland
I'm pretty sure that's just the story the company used to avoid paying the money
Bro is SO underated
I deadass thought u had 100k plus 😂 u a goat fr though
Actually baby Ruths are not named after Babe Ruth
answer is simple: la steroid daddy hack IV
Bro I hate the fact that Barry bonds isn’t in the game
That’s not Willy mays that’s russel Westbrook
I can say my favorite player (jr) would of definitely joined the 700 club if he stayed healthy. I'd like to think he would beat Ruth, but I'm unsure beyond that. Definitely the best swing!
Sosa and McGuire should not be in because juice
Rip pujols and his 700 HRs
He's not in this game 🤷♂️
@@Jarodactyl big oof by the developers.
Jr. Here is why. He missed about 3 seasons and still ended up with the number of HR je had! Figure 30 each yr for those 3 yrs he missed, so that is 90 more and that would have given him
720
We should divide this between Juiced and non Juiced
The disrespect on Pujols 700+
What happens if Dingus Dingerson’s only high stats are fielding and durability? Can he win a golden glove without being able to move or throw for shit?
How do you do this video without Barry Bonds?
Bro i subbed so I'm not a scrub 😄
Hold up, Bonds not in game soooo now pointless.
Bash Brothers were Mcgwire and Canseco
Actually Jose Canseco and Mark McGwire were know as the bash brothers while on the Athletics. Not Sosa
Henry Aaron and Babe Ruth second
“He’ll probably hit a home run with a Pringles can” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
mickey mantle barry bonds?
ZERO cred with no Bonds.
You should of put jose altuve in this
Lasteroid wins
you should make longer vids
an all time HR derby with no Bonds??? already messed up
It is only messed up if his cheating ass is on there, idiot!
David Ortiz!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! needs to be in it
Barry Bonds!!!