Pink Floyd- Comfortably Numb REACTION (FIRST TIME)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024
- Please support me on Patreon :) / shannonhemmings
My first time listening and reacting to Pink Floyd- Comfortably Numb!
The video I react to is David Gilmour - Comfortably Numb Live in Pompeii 2016
Original Video- • David Gilmour - Comfo...
You can follow my on Instagram :)
![โฮ่ง! (SUGOI) - LYKN [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nFp4zjAARFs/mqdefault.jpg)
She cried. And with that, she's been Floyded. Welcome, Sweetie. There is no leaving this place.
Still hits me everytime, but the Van Morrison cover is just as good as Johnny Cash covering Hurt.
Watching David Gilmour play the guitar is a beautiful place to be. The music is Erie and beautiful at the same time. You just sit back close your eyes and suck it in because it will open up every feeling in your soul. Music from Pink Floyd is pure genius.
Amen
@@clare1061 --- "erie and beautiful". Excellent characterization.
If you want to cry profoundly and 'groundshakingly' listen to marillion's album 'brave' ), watch the film.
If you want a song from it 'The great escape' followed by 'made again'.
When David Gilmour plays he plugs his guitar into your soul!!!
...true , bro
Well said.
Very good description of his playing..
To Sagan 210: Prose of profound projection. Perfect: priceless.
His new stuff is absolute shite though eh.
Girl, you just heard the greatest and most beautiful guitar solo ever. The world is a great and beautiful place when music can bring humanity together. Rock on!
The only song I’ve heard a million times and still to this day when I hear it it’s like hearing it for the first time again.
Acid’s one hell of a drug. 😉
@@totallybored5526 you know it.unless you go into the trap
That has to be the most honest reaction I have ever seen. You felt it in your soul Shannon, as it should be with Pink Floyd. Welcome to the club.
I love it when the younger crowd gets excited about what us "older" crowd grew up with!!
Pink Floyd is timeless. They belong to every generation. My father introduced me to them and God do I feel fortunate!
i'm a teenager and i absolutely ADORE classic rock (my profile picture is kind of a giveaway)
RIGHT?
@thegeorgezila
Pink Floyd is ageless!
Arguably, the best guitar solo ever: Gilmour defining the solo.
I heard a story about this one guy arguing that his cousin was a better guitarist. Just before he spontaneously combusted. Some say he pissed off God. Who knows?
There are a few solo's that just flat out stand out as epic. This is at the top of the list along with Since Ive been lovin you, Cliff of Dover etc
I love it but my favourite solo of his is the Time solo👍😎
you said it.. life changing!
Can't argue. clem dewitt
There's never a bad version of this, but in my mind the Pulse version is just the ultimate version.
Agree! Insanely good!
Totally agree with you ;)
Maybe, but I think the Live* version is the best. Because they were all 4 together for that one time..
only if you look the pulse uncut version ...
Agreeeeed!!!....its the holy grail of all versions
Why can't my generation (i'm 18) have musicians like this. I find myself absorbed in bands like Pink Floyd, Dire Straits, Clapton, and the Eagles, that were well before my time. The level of talent and thought that goes into those songs is unbelievable. I'm not saying today's music isn't good, but it is absolutely no rival to what music was in the 70s and 80s.
You have these musicians, they are on CD’s, streaming and the radio. At 18 you have your whole music life ahead of you. I was lucky to be born on 1951, I have heard the the best and sometimes the worst. From the Beatles, the Stones, Led Zep, Frank Zappa, to the Clash, to Queen and today I am an Adele fan. Dig into the 60’s and work your way forward to date. And enjoy the journey.
Dude, you are young...use this as fuel for your fire and let your creativity come out. Be the change...carry the torch!
Sadly because all you have are beibers and perrys....
@@tubedude54 My point exactly! Nobody plays instruments anymore. It seems to me that alot of these new artists cannot even write their own songs, let alone compose them.
I often wonder, if the musical geniuses , that might be out there, suffer from the commercialization of music. It's driven by corporations who look at books, vs. the old timers who love music .
I have seen many excellent suggestions, for your musical journey.
I would add Bob Seger, Cheap Trick, and Tom Petty to the mix .
And listen to old school R and B .
No way I can list them all.
Temptations, Four Tops , Smokey Robinson,...
The music just speaks to you .
Enjoy the journey, as we have !
I hope you won't mind my saying this: The expressions on your face as you encountered this masterpiece were just beautiful, a fitting reflection of the sublimity and emotional impact of the music. It blessed me to see someone so young so clearly touched, moved, swept away by one of the classics of my high school days: Watters and Gilmour and the phenomenon that is Pink Floyd. Gilmour in particular goes to the heart with the unique, soulful quality of his voice and his approach on the electric guitar. There have been and are many fantastic soloists on that instrument in rock and jazz. But no other guitarist I've ever heard--no one--can tell a story that tears my heart out like David Gilmour can.
muy cierto.
This album represented the beginning of my high school carrier. I was sure that if the eighties started like that, it would have to be a great decade in music. Then New Wave happened and I realized adult life was just a series of tragedies.
I totally agree!
Right on !!
@@patrickaalfs9584 "Then New Wave happened and I realized adult life was just a series of tragedies." --You better get this copyrighted. 😉
I'm 65 years old now, but I still cry snot and water when I hear Comfortably Numb, Time and Wish You Were Here.
Shit...I'm only 46....will I do this for the rest of my life? (yes I will!)
Gilmour's solo in Time is very very close behind this one.
@@iseeolly9959 Well, I know I will for sure
Koopke Tee 66 here
Well I dont go that far , but it does get to me.
Pink Floyd echoes, shine on you crazy diamond, entire dark side of the moon, wish you were here, animals, and the wall albums. Anything Pink Floyd. Life changing music.
The Floyd
There were some pretty strong albums before Dark side of the moon. You got Meddle, atom heart mother and obscured by clouds. They are worth lending an ear to.
A momentary lapse of reason
Shine on you crazy diamond is my absolute favourite
Live at Pompeii
I attended this concert and it was probably the greatest day of my life. I hope David Gilmour lives forever!
I’m so envious! I know it’s a sin but damn. You
Lucky lucky human!
Young folks: "Old people don't know how to rock out".
David Gilmour: "Hold my beer".
To Political Correct: What does, "Hold my beer," mean?
@@eddyvideostar It means shut up and listen to this.
@@eddyvideostar it really just means "you thought you knew how to do something - let me show you a new reality"
@@swinetrek Dont'listen; feel and expericience it.
@@edp5886 Ed: This is a weird and unusual expression. It seems as if the skillful and sagacious, showing us, had saturated his stomach with the suds of sin.
Wow... Feels so good to see someone of a younger generation experience Pink Floyd. You don't listen to Pink Floyd, you experience it. You feel it. That solo, and every rendition of it over the years has become not only the greatest guitar solo in the history of mankind, but also one of, if not - the - greatest pieces of music that has ever been penned. I hope you continue your journey with Pink Floyd. Each album is an unforgettable experience that everyone that has ever drawn breath should enjoy at least once. There are millions of good musicians. There are thousands of amazing bands and artists. There are hundreds of Hall of Fame worthy talents, but there is only one Pink Floyd. This is as close as you are going to get to dining with the Gods and partaking in their ambrosia. Happy New Year!
Tears coming down your face... there's no other reaction to this masterpiece. I love it! Live forever David!!!
No one makes a guitar cry like David Gilmour. A poet of bending strings.
There is one - Mark Knopfler
@@Lotman-yz9wp Mark Knopfler is different compared to the atmosphere that Gilmour produces, but Knopfler is on a league of his own.
@@Lotman-yz9wp true and same with the guy below
@@Lotman-yz9wp Mark Knopfler is glorious with his style; however, Gilmore has more depth, related to the psychedelic experience. Even Pink Floyd's semi-rockers have that palate of profoundness.
david has that thing that touches your soul
That guitar he’s playing just sold for four million dollars for charity. The guitar strap he’s using used to belong to Jimi Hendrix. Gilmour’s wife bought the strap for his sixtieth birthday.
4 mill?!!! Holy 💩
That guitar needs to be studied. That guitar is magic. That guitar can see into your soul.
@@rohmarts Nothing magical about the guitar. It's the guy who is playing it who is the magician!
@@bujin1977 Yeah, he's pretty good too. : )
Not Pink Floyd, you selected a live version of Comfortably Numb by David Gilmore. Next time select a studio (Album Version) of a Pink Floyd song. It is a better representation of the song as the band recorded it, a Live (Concert Version) is great after the original is experienced! ☮️
I'm almost 50 and been listening to Floyd since 1980 and watching your reaction to this, gotta' admit, made me emotional. Glad you enjoyed it!
David Gilmour and that black Strat together are the closest thing to heaven on this Earth
Oh man your reaction was so genuine, I could read all the emotions right off your face! Welcome to Pink Floyd :D!
I wish I could hear Pink Floyd for the first time again.
Take some LSD and listen to Pink Floyd. It's like listening to them for the first time all over again!
if you ever get a chance to see "brit floyd" tribute band do it. you WILL NOT be disappointed!!!!!
I love how happy the drummer always appears. Every song and every concert. YOU can tell that he's got the Best job in the world.
First solo brings you to tears, the second picks you up off the floor.
Well put
Ms. Hemmings, here's an interesting fact about what you just watched. This was filmed LIVE in Pompeii. Pink Floyd was the first band to perform LIVE in front of an audience in over 2000 years.
They did a concert there with no people in '71 or '72. Then the 2016 concert, in the Pompei amphitheater. I've been there and still they have an exhibit from the concert. Pompei is awesome and haunting, so wish I had been there then!!! Check out the '71 concert, look up "Echoes" for Pink Floyd.
When they do a pull back shot towards the end you can see the outline of the amphitheater and in the back to the right is the modern town of Pompei.
Great call. 1st ever
David's guitars solo on this is considered one of he best solos. Dam this makes me feel young again We boomers had a great life.
It’s impossible for David Gilmour to play a bad note, ever.
And he's an OLD man...
ffjsb so?
@@robertwhite7071 SO, a LOT of people loose dexterity as they age, and can't play like they used to. That's why Neil Peart and Eric Clapton don't play anymore. Evidently the obvious eludes you...
@@ffjsb eric clapton don t play anymore??????????????????that s a joke??
ffjsb you’re totally lost, Gilmour plays with smarts and intelligence. He’s never been about being fast and flashy, dexterities is not an issue clueless.
That epiphany... When you listen to Pink Floyd* for the first time.
*Glimour and Co.😂
I was 20 when I first heard this song. That was 41 years ago. I could see the moment that you were moved by David. I cried with you. Peace
Shannon, I am moved beyond words by your reaction. I can only imagine what was going through your mind during this masterpiece. By seeing your facial reactions, I see something powerful moving inside of you. I can definitely relate, for every time I hear this, the same happens to me. Memories, dreams, longings, sorrows, happiness, all condensed in 9 minutes. Thank you for this amazing video!!
I know this is old but David Gilmore's solo is incredible.
The next one to do is Pink Floyd Time. Try to read the lyrics as you listen. then do The Great Gig in the Sky. Those are the usual first steps. Then you just have fifty more years to catch up on.
Alan Peterson I love just sitting back with my headphones on listening to the whole Dark Side of the Moon album
Great choice mate.
Great gig in the sky.
Yes absolutely... both as one if possible.
@@rob7953 doesn't, get much better than that.
I think David Gilmour was 70 when this was recorded... and I don't think he's ever been better. What a lifetime of practice can do... And I like the look on his face at the end, like, "Yeah, that turned out ok". :)
This is the best rendition of this song I've ever heard! A true MASTERPIECE!!
It’s hard to believe that this song is already 40 years old. I remember it when it was released and I was a senior in high school. Pink Floyd has always been one of my favorite bands, primarily because they had such a unique way of writing and performing their songs. It was musical genius. The Animals, Dark Side of the Moon, and Wish You Were Here albums are forever engrained in my memory, but The Wall album produced arguably one of the best songs in my lifetime in Comfortably Numb and David Gilmour’s solo still hits me every time I hear it. I’m glad to hear you enjoyed it, Shannon.
it was so touching and adorable to see your feelings evolve at the first solo.thanks for sharing this
You know you're doing something right when all 40,000 people at your show know the lyrics, and sing along.
the tears say it all........ still makes me cry after a thousand times listening..
You don't listen to Pink Floyd, you experience it. Greatest band ever.
I just found another reason to shed some tears while watching you watch this song. It was 100 millionth time I saw this song and still not over it.
Saw your reaction to this and had to subscribe. You seem like a very genuine and beautiful person. And I kind of envy you...you get to go on a journey of discovering the musical genius of bands such as Pink Floyd. Enjoy the ride 😀
J M you’re so kind!! Thank you!!! And omg I’m like ashamed and excited at the same time lol I’m so hyped to continue this journey!
I’ve listened to that song a thousand times and that was the first time I’ve heard that version. I enjoyed digitally sharing it with you. That’s what unites us, people. Hop on board. Nicely done, lady.
Beautiful reaction :) You really seem like the nicest person in the world 😀 and beautiful to boot😍, thanks.
Superfly Lee awww thanks lol I’m just a softie 😅
@@ShannonHemmingsTV Want to see a man make a smiling girl cry in 30 seconds using nothing but a guitar? @4:30 - 5:00 ***BOOM*** And now you know how I've felt, every single time I've heard that solo, for the past 35 years of my life.
Agreed ! A Beautiful Soul 👆🙏💘🎶 you can just tell 😊
They can’t produce groups like this today .Pink Floyd are in a class of their own an icon of the sixties and one of the most successful bands of our time this is pure gold .
Listen to the crowd when David turns up his guitar and steps up to solo. Epic.
IT'S SO NICE THAT YOU HAVE FOUND THE BEST BAND IN THE WORLD. Welcome
It was a thing of beauty watching you being drawn into this amazing song. This band will go down in history as the most profound group of all time.
Their music history dates from the late '60s to the present. I bought one of the first Darkside of the Moon albums sold in the US. Just before I was drafted during the Viet Nam war, and they are still with me.
Thank you for your service, sir.
Remembered my first time ...1973!!! I still listen to “Dark Side of the Moon” to crash to. Get the best headphones you can buy and jump into the Floyd rabbit hole. Their influence has saved my life and helped make me into the man i have become.....you MUST listen to these dudes by listening to the whole album song by song it tells you the full story....well enjoy the ride. 😎🎧🤘🏻🇺🇸✌🏻 Rock On
im only 37 yrs old... but PF has been with me since around age 12... They were what made me get into music....
Sounds familiar 1973 ummagumma hooked me for most beautiful musical experience band Pink Floyd. Only One of Kind
@@nellymoriarty_5783 me too but the following albums where just on another, a divine level; it was over when "the Wall" came out ( except "Comfortably Numb" on it )
10-4 ! ! 🎸🎶🎤 , " I was 13 then , , 🎶" Those Were The Day's ! " 🎶 . " Growing up in the Perfect Time , " ✌ " Chicag😎 ✌🎷 ".
Thank you so much 🙏🏾 excited to be on this journey! I do need a better pair of headphones!
I’m still yet to find someone who reacts to this song and doesn’t just stare at the screen without words. I imagine that’s exactly what Pink Floyd wanted when they created this inhuman piece of soul-penetrating magic.
I’m 25, and I’m upset to be born not in this time. I would give years of my life to be at a PF concert.
☞ ♾️ 𝕋 𝕀 𝔻 𝔾 𝕐 ✓ I’m upset too! What I would give to have been in that audience. True is art is a beautiful and powerful thing! ❤️
T, at least you have the music. Growing up in the 'Classic Rock' era I was fortunate enough to see Floyd three times, along with other big bands like Led Zep, The Who, The Stones, Tull and the Eagles in their heyday. IMO, we listen to music today whereas back then we experienced it. Cheers...
@@bazzer124 true words
Brings back memories I’m 63 now but I member those back in a day kickback smoke a joint and just really get into the music
Joint and something hallucinogenic magic mushrooms are the best 😍
I'm 73 and have the same memories.
We still do that old man lol
Saw them do this live in LA in 1980...on several doses of blotter. Probably the highlight of any concert!
I remember it like it was yesterday.
Fender made the Stratocaster. David Gilmour said, hold my beer
In the 1994 Pulse concert, David Gilmour's solo of this song caused 7 women and 2 men to spontaneously become pregnant.
And this is how we know there is God, Heaven, and Angels... On the 8th day, He created Pink Floyd
Absolutely no words for this, probably the greatest song written, breaks my heart every time I hear, even after 30 years hearing it.
David gilmour when his bass player taps his back gets me so emotional, so glad to have been alive to hear something so beautiful played
Just before the 5 minute mark, it’s quite visible where you made the emotional connection in a big way. Feels awesome, doesn’t it? Not many groups can do this with a great deal of their music. Pink Floyd is one of those groups and I can confidently say that there will probably never be another group that will come together with such otherworldly musical chemistry. That first solo grabs people that are hearing Pink Floyd for first time right by the heart strings. David didn’t just play the guitar. Rather, he communicated the specific emotion he wanted you to feel and that communication is simply undeniable. Amazing actually. When you match the extraordinary composition with the lyrical poetry these folks assembled, then listen to that spiritual sounding guitar solo, it sends that emotional arrow deep every time. There is a very good reason solo #1 and #2 in this song are known to be 2 of the best of all time primarily for the reason that they elicit such an emotional response. 👍🏻😎👍🏻
You have opened the Pink Floyd box now, your life will never be the same! 🙂
I have had the privilege of seeing Pink Floyd live. I have seen a rather large amount of concerts...Pink Floyd is a spiritual experience.
Insanely jealous of you!! Can’t even lie
I have become a Gilmour disciple, no one evokes emotion from a guitar like he does I would take out a second mortgage to watch Pink Floyd in concert. I have listened to Comfortably numb over a 100 times and I still get goose bumps.
Sad, inspirational and timeless masterpiece.
I saw lots of people reacting on this song and you are the only one to apparently understand this music. Your real tears proove it ! You had 4 reactions : first when you heard the beginning atmosphere, second when you heard violins, third when you heard the first guitar solo and fourth when you heard the scream. I think this song talk to you like it talk to me 💚💚💚
You’re my high for the week, it cancels out the low ! Subscribed due to your aura !
Wayne Denny awwww geeesh you just made my day and canceled out my lows. Thank you! ❤️
James T kirk, on the bridge of the USS Enterprise going to another Galaxy ....woop woop
Personification of a Guitar, fucking speaks to you x
@@ShannonHemmingsTV listen to Coming back to life , pomeii 2016
You should do the Pulse concert performance of this song it is just class.
I feel your sincerity. I love Pink Floyd and it's easy to cry in amazement...
Hey Girl! Just found you and had to say I too was blown away by this version of Pink Floyd's "Comfortably Numb" video. I never listened to them when I was young, but now, here I am approaching 73 years and have fallen in love with their sound and showmanship! I just can't get enough of this wonderful group!
You have just begun down the road to Pink Floyd appreciation. I am 53 now snd it does my heart good to see someone as young as you appreciate quality music when they hear it. Thank you for having an open mind enough to try something new to you.
David Gilmour is one of the few guitarists that makes you feel it to your soul. A true master.
I first heard this song as a kid in the early 80’s while sitting in the garage watching my Dad work on his Bike. I had tears in my eyes too.. Even at that age, I knew. I was Floyded early LOL
I can talk all day about pink floyd however not enough is said about their background singers. Listen to Darkside of the moon and you'll hear what I mean.
Michael Radis yep, watch the special discussing the making of DSOTM, how it was produced, mixed, edited, cut and pasted, fade ins and out, the lyrical content and so on. How the songs flow from one to another, goddamn pure brilliance,
Especially the vocals on "The great gig in the sky" never gets old!
I am 53 years old and I was lucky and honored to grow up in the age of PF. That era is not over yet and I hope it will never be and that PF will continue to resonate over time and impact the lives of the young people who are coming. PF is like a warm blanket that I often come back to when I need comfort, a safe home, a crutch that helps me when I'm broken ...
THE best solo of all time, David Gilmour
I've been listening to this song since 1980 and it still does to me what it just did to you,and be prepared because there's many Floyd tracks that will bring your emotions out,stay blessed 🇬🇧
Great reaction. You just witnessed the magic of David Gilmour, at age 70 :-) He's the only Pink Floyd member on stage, but it's one of the best versions he's ever played. For another epic Gilmour solo, check out "Pink Floyd - On The Turning Away (live)". Pick the 1988 version, uploaded by Miguel Freitas with 6.8M views.
Pulsar77 whoooooah 70?! AMAZING! Thank you! I can’t wait to delve in and rock out!
@@ShannonHemmingsTV Yep, he's still got it. This was one of his last concerts to date, back in 2016, and I doubt he'll tour again. I envy you, you have an amazing journey ahead. Pink Floyd and Gilmour's solo work transport you to another world, they are truly unique. Some highlights:
- The four classic albums: Dark Side Of The Moon (1973), Wish You Were Here (1975), Animals (1977), The Wall (1979).
- The song Echoes (1971).
- The Division Bell (1994) and the subsequent tour, released on the Pulse CD/DVD.
- Gilmour's album On An Island (2006) and the tour, released on two DVDs: Remember That Night and Live In Gdansk.
And lots and lots more. But start with On The Turning Away, it's an overlooked gem :)
Are You forgotting about one more Pink Floyd member? Gilmour was great but biggest songs was written by Roger Watters- and he is still on stage.
@@TheVicious83 No, I didn't forget Waters. The best songs were a collaboration of the whole band, even when Waters took most of the credit, and Gilmour was often the real driving force behind the music (Gilmour once said he wrote 90% of the music of Animals, despite getting only credit for Dogs). Waters was the ideas man, he usually came up with the general concepts, demos, and lyrics, but Gilmour was the most musically gifted, and he's essential to the 'Pink Floyd sound'. As for Waters live, it's just not the same.
Pulsar77 I can not agree. It was Waters who was the entire creative machine behind the Floyds. Gilmour brought in money. It is thanks to Waters that we have Wish You Were Here, Dark side of the moon and the overrated The Wall. The best proof of this is that Gilmour didn't create anything interesting (maybe except for the song Division Bell - the rest of the album is just very poor). Gilmour was and is a great musician. Waters is a better composer than a musician. And here's the problem.
Plug in your headphones and let Gilmour play music straight to your soal. RIP Syd, the man that inspired the best music ever written, shine on.
WOW...This is the best reaction vid I've seen so far.....It sure helps that this is my favourite song of all time....but......When it hits you fully 04:58 that reaction there.....
I've listened to this song countless times & it hits me too, just there, every single time.
That, at 04:58 was a beautiful youtube moment, one that I'll remember.
When a piece of music hits somebody like that, it builds all kinds of bridges.
I'm a white bloke in the UK but, right at that moment, we connected in a weird & wonderful youtube way. Different backgrounds, very different ages, different continents, different skin colours, different genders and yet. a 'shared' moment, all because of a piece of music.
Maybe I'm just a wee bit stoned......But the world needs more of this right now...
It's a great metaphor for fighting back against this horrific political climate, that we find ourselves in right now. YNWA.
I could listen to this song over and over again! Best solo ever performed...the magic of David Gilmour!!!
What a lovely woman it was a pleasure to watch you enjoy this masterpiece,your expressions are adorable.
The audience singing along with David Gilmore gave me goose bumps.
The start of Wish you were here at Pompeii too 🎸
Oh how I wish I was there 🙌🏾
Just let me tell you something: you are one of us.
Shannon, It was so awesome to be able to experience this with you! I felt everything that you felt. The unique twist was being able to experience this with you. Thank You for You! Keep Smiling...
45plus years later, this song still brings chills and usually tears. You MUST listen to the original album cut...as well as the whole album. Over the years their performance of this song has changed..to appease time and audiences..also David Gilmore has lived a lifetime now, and his playing reflects that emotion. But the original raw uncommercialized version is so different than all the others..
All my love..heres to a peaceful new year.
As good as David does it, it is Rogers' song. Rogers' voice is important for songs off of this album. I saw The Wall in 1980 and 2012. About Face in 84, On an Island in 06, Rattle that Lock in 16. Us and Them in 17, Dark Side in 09, Pros and Cons in 83-4. Peace Man!
@@jonathansmith3742 Yes, Roger basically wrote the whole album, truly a lyrical genius. A shame that the squabbles kept the two apart. However, it is Gilmore that plays the solos and emitts such an emotional response from listeners..especially those that only are enjoying the music & don t take the time to learn the history.
Have a peaceful new year, my fellow Floyd fan!
Pink Floyd is one of the best bands of all time, in top 5 with Led Zeppelin and The Beatles.
After The Beatles, Pink Floyd. No contest!!!
Great Britain has certainly put forth some remarkable musical talent.
I feel like the rolling stones deserve to be in that mix
@@Po1itica11yNcorrect no one even comes close to the British when it comes to musical talent, maybe America alone.
And Yes.
FYI: There's something about reaction pieces in TH-cam that are attractive. The main parts are the music and the comedy, but watching someone's reaction is also fun. I like watching your stuff because you don't overbalance it with your commentary. I often bail when the producers make it about them. Kudos to you for just rolling with the music and injecting yourself with grace and charm.
I appreciate you! I might just make my first reaction video in over a year with the help of this comment :) I’m but a teeny tiny stone in a magnificent sculpture or at least that’s what I hope to be.
That back Strat! The man is a genius.
Possibly the most gentle and genuine reaction video I’ve seen. Well done girl 👍🏼
David Gimour top 5 guitarists of all time. So cool to see peoples reactions to his unique style. Literally 3rd person today brought to tears listening to Gilmours beautiful solos and voice. Truly a raw talent.
Hearing this again after a long break, it's so apparent that neither Gilmour nor Waters ever reached these heights again, once their collaborations ended. Such an emotional song can only come from the tearing synergy between these two ideologically and spiritually opposed creative minds. This song is a perfect example of what comes from such an antagonistic synergy. The dark lyrics combined with the soaring anger and defiance of the chorus and the guitar solo - well, this will probably never be equalled.
Floyd transcend time and space. Close your eyes and enjoy the ride
I'm pretty sure that the person recommended the Pulse version, but maybe didn't put that word in capital letters. David Gilmour, the guitarist, has been playing this song since he was 33. Here he is 70, and can still play. The problem now is that you've already had your first experience with the song, so what would make re-doing it worth it ? I would suggest going to the Songfacts website first. Then the experience would be enhanced by knowing what the lyrics are about. Just Google the name of the song, and type the word Songfacts afterwards. On this site, (more than on some others which are more of a collection of fans' opinions about song meanings), they usually have excerpts from interviews with the songwriters themselves. I think this would make a second viewing more enjoyable than just playing the other version because most people feel that the guitar solo is his best. This is a great site to know about for classic rock songs (This one is 40yrs old), which also often has information about the recording of the songs.
Correct. But why the education? Arent there other platforms to express your genuis? You lost the simplicity of enjoying music by being a dick/ette? Man..grow up...
🙄
Long winded rhetoric doesnt diguise someone who cant enjoy the simple pleasures of listening to great music...lets all try to understand this music on a more intellectual plane..or more factually as adequately expounded above...or fk off and just enjoy the pleasure..if not first base...then as others enjoy...then as you explain..fk me..explain how we mere mortals enjoy others while you explain another phenomenon according to YOU...get off your horse..this isnt a debatable fraction of anything..ya tit..as in nipple
Och..shut your face..who cares...its someone enjoying a song for the 2nd time...save your advice for idiots...as far as your advice...go boil your head...who cares...idiot...longwinded crap about what? Ya tit...Heres a tip...our eyes are easily bored...i had to squint a couple of times...long isnt good..nor is your content...ta
Such warmth and dignity in your reaction. When I hear his guitar cry, I cry like a baby.
The singing brings the pain; the guitar solo washes it away.
First video I've seen from this TH-camr and I love everything about it. Wonderful personality, reactions, and of course the performance is incredible. I want to give this 1,000 likes!
"In another life I would have been a drummer".. me too.. and I played drums for 40 years. To get the best reaction for yourself.. watch the "Pulse" 2007 concert of Pink Floyd. You will cry.. I do every time!
@Shahzada Misbah Farhat Uh, oops.. you are correct.. Dunno why I cross referenced it with a different one in my head.. old I guess
my high point this week was seeing you react to Pink Floyd, ... my low point... having to go to work everyday. You're a lovely person inside and out. You might need to check out some more of Pink Floyd, one of the best bands.... ever.
Wayne Sullins ugh WORK. I hear you! Thank you so much! Your comment helped brighten my day after a work shift and I’m beyond pumped to listen to more!
THAT moment when kids realise that they have been short-changed with recent machine-manufactured bubble-gum for the ears crap. The moment when they understand skill, talent and real emotion that music can actually produce in a person.
They absolutely haven't mate. Just looking in the wrong places. There's more music than ever.
@@MrBaronCabron thank, sir! You're absolutely right! There was never a shortage of good music or musicians, just people not willing to go out and find and/or support them.
Just stumbled across this. Of all the reactions I have watched, this is my favourite. It’s so good watching someone getting the feeling that I have had for years watching pink floyd. I recently played pink floyd (high hopes) at my mothers funeral. So moving. !!
The most genuine reaction I"ve seen. Wonderful to see the joy and emotions on your face!
David Gilmore could elicit so much emotion and soul from his guitar that it leaves his audience in breathless amazement. Pink Floyd is a life altering experience. The vast majority of reactors have the same reaction that you did to Pink Floyd. I highly recommend that you listen to “The Great Gig In the Sky” from the Dark Side Of the Moon album. Actually that album is one continuous rock opera that tells the story of one of the founding members of the band, Sid Barrett. Sid suffered from a total psychological melt down and went insane.
I'm so glad that someone brought up the fact about the guitar strap he's using used to belong to Hendrix, it kind of puts things into perspective as obviously Gilmour was a fan of Hendrix. Anyway, the Pulse version is my personal favorite of this and I was there for original version of this from The Wall. Give it a listen, you won't regret.
Welcome to the beauty of David Gilmour.
And Roger Waters' song writing. I don't think he gets nearly enough credit. Post-Waters Floyd is pretty weak.
@@allahspreadshate6486
Disagree
As someone who saw the Pink Floyd for the first time live in1970 at the Opera House approx 2000 seat theatre in Manchester England where I was a student at the time. It is heartwarming to see your reaction to this superb song. Over the passing years, I have seen the many versions of Pink Floyd and always the same their music goes deep to your core. I hope that you will listen to more of the Floyd and discover lots of other wonderful music. Peace and Love xxx
Hi- just came across this video, and it made my heart feel good to see tears running down your face. The history and depth of the Floyd/Gilmour performances cannot be overstated. I've seen this video, heard the various Comfortably Numb versions/solos hundreds (thousands?) of times, and it still, STILL, makes me feel weepy and emotional. Thank you for sharing this moment!