I try to picture that, but I keep seeing Darcy running away from Emma, and Mrs. Bennet chastising Emma over how she knows nothing about weddings, and that why hasn't she found a rich, single guy for Lydia. Which proves your comment true.
rukbat3 Yup: 'He had been in love with Emma and jealous of Frank Churchill from about the same period, one sentiment probably having enlightened him as to the other'. No Frank yet, so Knightley doesn't know!
To everyone complaining about the transmedia: This is why these extra videos are on the Emma Approved account while the others are only on Pemberley Digital's. The Emma Approved account is being shown in real time while the stuff on PD's channel is, to Emma, going to be shown in the future. She never mentions or comments on the videos OR discusses Pemberley Digital, which she would definitely be doing if the documentary videos were going up live. She only talks about things that others would know about anyway, like having a new assistant and her business partner's snarkiness.
Sorry--in the Pemberley Digital FAQ, it states that Emma's channel is out-of-world too. In this video, ppl are asking her about things such as whether her father will appear in her documentary, etc.. There is severe logical confusion of presentation in this series.
Did anyone else notice how Knightly appeared to have been standing there BEFORE knocking on the door. I'm pretty sure he heard the answer to that last question.
That's the Emma we know! “Were I to fall in love, indeed, it would be a different thing; but I have never been in love ; it is not my way, or my nature; and I do not think I ever shall.” And then Mr Snarky comes in... *cough* yes Emma, we know, we know...
Nicely done. I was looking forward to her answer of why she is not looking for a husband herself because none of her answers in the book would really apply in this day an age. And I LOVE that she made a video in THIS universe.
How I see the in-world and out-of-world stuff is that the documentary videos are going because her journey is officially over, but the Q&A videos are after the time of the documentary because Knightly seems to know little more about what's going on.
Somebody help me, I thought these videos were out of world for now, so how can she say "keep those questions coming" if she isn't posting the video ? I'm confused...
This was posted in Emma's personal channel. All the videos from this channel are "in world", just like the Twitter accounts and blog posts. It is only the videos posted by Pemberley Digital that are not meant to be public.
rukbat3 do you mean that she publicly released Harriet's application video ? Seems odd to me... I am starting to think that they are just doing a terrible job at this whole in world/out of world thing. They did such a great job with the LBD, it's too bad that in EA everything is such a mess.
Ida Sanchez I really like EA too ! I love the story, I like how the characters are portrayed... but I just think that they are handling the transmedia wrong this time.
I think Pemberley Digital is her editors and Emma's videos on PD's channel was recorded way before it was uploaded on youtube. This video on Emma's channel is current and if you notice she's less Lydia Bennet-ish on this video and much nicer (not that Lydia Bennet is not nice, just a bit over the top). I think this video was recorded after she [SPOILER] insults Miss Bates and she and Knightley are probably already together!
The in-world/out-of-world problem appears to be escalating, and I'm not sure that the creative team has thought it through thoroughly. If we are to assume that all videos are out-of-world, that's one thing, so long as they stay on the Pemberley Digital and Emma Woodhouse channels. But when you throw in Q&A videos that answer questions by real users (and where there's been no effort to make them look like they're future videos, after Emma has finished her documentary) *and* have Emma posting on her various social media sites linking to each video, you're going to have a constant, ongoing problem of confusion amongst viewers. Either enforce the division between in- and out-of-world (which also means re-figuring Q&As by either dropping them, making them better fit the narrative or making them actor/creative team Q&As), or find a way to make all the videos in-world.
Ok, so if Emma is just "documenting her greatness" for herself, and she doesn't know the videos are on the Internet, who's uploading the videos? Will this be revealed later? Or are we just supposed to suspend disbelief and not care? And why is she answering questions if she doesn't know her videos are seen by the public? PD, I think we need some answers, please!
VERY late answer, but I think Emma might be using the Domino-app from Pemberly Digital in the Lizzie Bennet series as the calling feature is very much alike what Gigi Darcy showed us.. Which would also explain who´s editing as the app would do that for you. I´m thinking she probably posted them to her blog or something
I love this series, I really do, on both the channels, but I am so confused by all the in-world / out-world comments. It's way too confusing to figure out, so I've decided I don't care what world its in, I'm just gonna sit back and enjoy the show! :)
If i understand correctly, everything uploaded on pemberley digital is out of world, meaning not visible for them, but everything uploaded on the Emma Woodhouse-account is in-world, so everyone can see. Ergo, the episodes, private. Harriets application and the Q&A, public. :)
I actually did not see this show as out-of-world. I know in the first episode she says she's making it for "future editors" of her documentary, but I had assumed that she just meant that future editors would use footage from these videos in a documentary, not that the videos themselves that we are watching now are the documentary. Because if Emma's using the Domino thing from PD, it automatically edits and uploads the videos she makes, right? That would explain why we're watching most of the videos on the Pemberley channel. I might be wrong, though...
Live a life pleasing self -- how selfish. You'll never be happy if your always wanting to make your life better- greed will overcome you. What about a life that you choose that helps yourself and others!!
I'm a little confused because some of these questions could only have been asked in light of the content of previous videos (e.g. 'Remember the vegans; Alex complaining about everything she does) and yet in the story she's not actually posting these online right? She's just saving them to document her greatness, or whatever. So?
Yeah, I still don't think the setup makes total sense. I thing maybe it's best to just live with it and try not to think about it too much :P I've given up.
Though it's possible this kind of thing is mentioned in her blog - I haven't read them recently but I think she talks about Alex, and it's possible she's mentioned veganism.
*Emma talks about her potential soulmate.*
*Alex walks in.*
WELL PLAYED WRITERS
Do you ever think about finding yourself a soul mate?
Cue, Mr. Knightly. "Your timing is . . .impeccable. "
Oh, if Emma could do the wedding of Lizzie and Darcy. That would be great.
I try to picture that, but I keep seeing Darcy running away from Emma, and Mrs. Bennet chastising Emma over how she knows nothing about weddings, and that why hasn't she found a rich, single guy for Lydia.
Which proves your comment true.
I would kind of love that even more.
I'm kind of trying to write the fanfic on that. Want to help?
sevhells Do you have a link?
deeehi3
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality
Am I the only one super excited about the Lizzie Bennet question?
CAN WE PLEASE talk for a minute about how Knightley seems to always been interested in Emma and all she does? Asdfghj. Talk about love!
THE SHOULDER BUMP.
YES!
The timing of knightly's arrival is perfectly hilarious
I think everyone knows why he works with Emma, well everyone except Emma that is.
Hmm. I think it's possible that Knightley still doesn't know himself. . . .
rukbat3 Yup: 'He had been in love with Emma and jealous of Frank Churchill from about the same period, one sentiment probably having enlightened him as to the other'.
No Frank yet, so Knightley doesn't know!
To everyone complaining about the transmedia: This is why these extra videos are on the Emma Approved account while the others are only on Pemberley Digital's. The Emma Approved account is being shown in real time while the stuff on PD's channel is, to Emma, going to be shown in the future. She never mentions or comments on the videos OR discusses Pemberley Digital, which she would definitely be doing if the documentary videos were going up live. She only talks about things that others would know about anyway, like having a new assistant and her business partner's snarkiness.
Sorry--in the Pemberley Digital FAQ, it states that Emma's channel is out-of-world too. In this video, ppl are asking her about things such as whether her father will appear in her documentary, etc.. There is severe logical confusion of presentation in this series.
If you think about it, it's kinda weird that she tweets her videos.
***** Those are out-of-world as well.
***** I follow people that do youtube videos and they tweet them when a new one comes out
it's on the pemberly digital website
Did anyone else notice how Knightly appeared to have been standing there BEFORE knocking on the door. I'm pretty sure he heard the answer to that last question.
"Aim high and never settle!" Knightley walks in.
I see what you did
Alex walks in after the question about Emma finding her soulmate is asked. That obvious foreshadowing is Cori approved!
PLEASE PLAN LIZZIE AND DARCY'S WEDDING!!
The way Emma nudged Knightley was sooo cute!
That's the Emma we know! “Were I to fall in love, indeed, it would be a different thing; but I have never been in love ; it is not my way, or my nature; and I do not think I ever shall.” And then Mr Snarky comes in... *cough* yes Emma, we know, we know...
Checked my youtube feed this morning to see new videos from Emma and Jane...life is good :)
"What do you do to make sure you're living your best life?"
"I moisturize"
That shoulder bump
3:07 I love it when she says that!
"Ever think about finding yourself a soulmate?" Cue Knightly haha
Emma saying Lizzie's name gives me so much hope!!!
AND saying that they may someday meet! Hopefully Ashley is on this show, that would be amazing.
Nicely done. I was looking forward to her answer of why she is not looking for a husband herself because none of her answers in the book would really apply in this day an age. And I LOVE that she made a video in THIS universe.
How I see the in-world and out-of-world stuff is that the documentary videos are going because her journey is officially over, but the Q&A videos are after the time of the documentary because Knightly seems to know little more about what's going on.
Well done! Truly enjoying the modernization of these classic characters!
Oh my god imagine if Emma interviewed Lizzie as an example as a strong confident business woman who has found her 'mr right'!
I love brent bailey's character
I love the eyebrow thing Knightly does at the end at 3:18
I can never have enough Knightley. Also, Emma is the bees knees. Can't wait to watch her grow! :)
ahhh i love snarky knightley so much
Great timing on the entrance of snarky
Lizzie could do with learning from Emma how to introduce her Q&A videos!
I THINK I KNOW WHY, KNIGHTLEY
These videos always make me smile. Too cute!!
Awww...she's pleased to see him...
what a cool sweater Alex is wearing!
Knightley and Emma ahhh
Thanks for answering our questions, Emma! (and Mr Knightly)
thank you for this vid. It brightened up my saturday of much paper writing
I've got feels comin' out my ears!
SO MANY FEELS.
Love how right after that soul mate question, Knightley appears. #fangirling
YOU LOVES HIM!
I was DESPERATELY hoping for an Emma Approved vid. before Mon. My wish just came true! Eeeh! =D
Somebody help me, I thought these videos were out of world for now, so how can she say "keep those questions coming" if she isn't posting the video ? I'm confused...
because this is on Emma's channel, not pemberly digital
This was posted in Emma's personal channel. All the videos from this channel are "in world", just like the Twitter accounts and blog posts. It is only the videos posted by Pemberley Digital that are not meant to be public.
rukbat3
do you mean that she publicly released Harriet's application video ? Seems odd to me...
I am starting to think that they are just doing a terrible job at this whole in world/out of world thing. They did such a great job with the LBD, it's too bad that in EA everything is such a mess.
Juliette Chaplin I like EA.......
Ida Sanchez
I really like EA too ! I love the story, I like how the characters are portrayed... but I just think that they are handling the transmedia wrong this time.
Please excuse the pterodactyl noises. I just really miss hearing from Lizzie, so it was really nice for Emma to mention her.
When did she mention Lizzie in her previous videos?
It was in one of her blog posts.
Amanda Wise King Which one? I went through them and couldn't find it. :(
Found it. Here it is, www.emmaapproved.com/2013/10/the-next-big-thing/
Oh wow, thank you!!! You're awesome! :)
Lovely to see The Snark Knight pop in. I was also rather hoping he'd answer that question . . . Hmm.
HOW DID THIS NOT END UP IN MY SUB BOX ?
sporkwielder!! love her!
AHHH PLEASE MEET LIZZIE!!!!!
Snarky knightly has the best facial expressions I swear
I love the Black Widow arrow necklace. Sneaky nerdiness. Approved.
I think Pemberley Digital is her editors and Emma's videos on PD's channel was recorded way before it was uploaded on youtube. This video on Emma's channel is current and if you notice she's less Lydia Bennet-ish on this video and much nicer (not that Lydia Bennet is not nice, just a bit over the top). I think this video was recorded after she [SPOILER] insults Miss Bates and she and Knightley are probably already together!
SHE ANSWERED MY QUESTION ABOUT SOULMATES!!!
the jump cuts were killing me....
You don't watch the vlogbrothers, do you? :)
andrewxc1335 nope
Yeah, they do their videos like that all the time. John especially likes asking questions on one side, and answering them on the other.
In what video does Emma mention Lizzie Bennet?? I wanna know!
"Never wear black with color. It makes the color look cheap and the black look boring."
Mr Knightley's face on that last question=priceless! XD
The in-world/out-of-world problem appears to be escalating, and I'm not sure that the creative team has thought it through thoroughly. If we are to assume that all videos are out-of-world, that's one thing, so long as they stay on the Pemberley Digital and Emma Woodhouse channels. But when you throw in Q&A videos that answer questions by real users (and where there's been no effort to make them look like they're future videos, after Emma has finished her documentary) *and* have Emma posting on her various social media sites linking to each video, you're going to have a constant, ongoing problem of confusion amongst viewers. Either enforce the division between in- and out-of-world (which also means re-figuring Q&As by either dropping them, making them better fit the narrative or making them actor/creative team Q&As), or find a way to make all the videos in-world.
Cute little Knightley in his cute little sweater ^_^
Thank you for answering my question, Emma!@AgeofIrony :-D
good timing knightley :)
oh knightley....
her intro was so cute and i almost forgot that i didn't like her character for a second
aww he's got a jumper on :)
Ok, so if Emma is just "documenting her greatness" for herself, and she doesn't know the videos are on the Internet, who's uploading the videos? Will this be revealed later? Or are we just supposed to suspend disbelief and not care?
And why is she answering questions if she doesn't know her videos are seen by the public?
PD, I think we need some answers, please!
VERY late answer, but I think Emma might be using the Domino-app from Pemberly Digital in the Lizzie Bennet series as the calling feature is very much alike what Gigi Darcy showed us.. Which would also explain who´s editing as the app would do that for you. I´m thinking she probably posted them to her blog or something
speaking of soul mates...
gosh damn it i saw it and totally screamed !!!!
Love the Q&A!
if she is using pd they are automatically uploaded if you remember from sanditon and the end of lbd pd takes the most interesting and posts
Am I the only one who's addicted to Emma Approved but can't stand the Lizzie Bennett Diaries?
i could never find the will to continue watching lbd after the first two episodes, but i love emma!
this is really growing on me :)
I love this series, I really do, on both the channels, but I am so confused by all the in-world / out-world comments. It's way too confusing to figure out, so I've decided I don't care what world its in, I'm just gonna sit back and enjoy the show! :)
lol same here.
Wait I thought in her world these videos weren't online. How would....
That’s a delicious sweater, Alex
this was so cute
Which blog post does she mention Lizzie Bennet??
I actually want to know as well. In which blog post did she mention Lizzie? I think I missed this. :)
***** Me too!!
www.emmaapproved.com/2013/10/the-next-big-thing/
When will your father appear?
It was great see Knightley again :3
If i understand correctly, everything uploaded on pemberley digital is out of world, meaning not visible for them, but everything uploaded on the Emma Woodhouse-account is in-world, so everyone can see. Ergo, the episodes, private. Harriets application and the Q&A, public. :)
What no vine?
Hey Emma, can you start documenting Alex's wardrobe? I think I need to help my husband live HIS best life starting with a new wardrobe! =)
When did she mention Lizzie?
I love Knightley's sweater. I wanna cuddle with it. Preferably with him in it....
I actually did not see this show as out-of-world. I know in the first episode she says she's making it for "future editors" of her documentary, but I had assumed that she just meant that future editors would use footage from these videos in a documentary, not that the videos themselves that we are watching now are the documentary. Because if Emma's using the Domino thing from PD, it automatically edits and uploads the videos she makes, right? That would explain why we're watching most of the videos on the Pemberley channel. I might be wrong, though...
Again with the expected "Jazz hand!"
I can't find the post where she mentions Lizzie!! Someone please help!
OMG WHAT IF DRACY AND LIZZIE WERE ON HERE. OMG WHAT IF
when did she mention lizzie B.?
Basically like the office?
Live a life pleasing self -- how selfish. You'll never be happy if your always wanting to make your life better- greed will overcome you. What about a life that you choose that helps yourself and others!!
When she winks, I can't help but wink back XD
Is she uploading these on youtube or not? Now I'm really confused.
"Maybe someday" Yes, when she plans Lizzie and Darcy's wedding
I'm a little confused because some of these questions could only have been asked in light of the content of previous videos (e.g. 'Remember the vegans; Alex complaining about everything she does) and yet in the story she's not actually posting these online right? She's just saving them to document her greatness, or whatever. So?
Yeah, I still don't think the setup makes total sense. I thing maybe it's best to just live with it and try not to think about it too much :P I've given up.
Though it's possible this kind of thing is mentioned in her blog - I haven't read them recently but I think she talks about Alex, and it's possible she's mentioned veganism.
Is that a nook?
"Who are you again?", hilarious
The shoulder bump is a THING now.
aren't you two disgustingly adorable
I feel like the amount of cuts kind of take away from the natural manner that Emma usually is :S
This Q&A was funny and all, but also doesn't make sense at all, considering the videos are "out of world". GOD DAMNIT.