@@ingmarneple6072 This movie paints it as if the NTSB just railroaded Sully. That isn't at all the case. In real life Sully said the investigators were very understanding and he said that the movie was wrong.
He’s 100% correct. To me, it’s completely irrelevant whether he COULD have made it back to the airport or not under those dire conditions, he had to make a split second decision at the time, which resulted in all souls on board coming out of this situation alive. The man’s a hero in my book.
@@petruis2 just wondering, how and why would someone recycle a pair of completely trashed TurboFan Bypass Rolls Royce Jet Engines and a warped fuselage? Trust me, that A320 likely never saw the clouds again.
“No one warned us.” Is just such a great all encompassing line. Hindsight is always 20/20 but when you are in the moment with lives in your hands you can’t make the perfect maneuvers. You have to the best you can with the information you have.
I hated that line. I reckon there would have been a better punchline to smash these panels. "No one warned us" sounds like Sully backed off after the panel said "They had all the same parameters". It would have been better if he replied with the "humanity out of the cockpit" line as it replies directly to the same parameter non-sense. Decision making is part of the parameter that Sully faced as the plane lost both engines.
@@chupapibingbong Is it not true, though? No one told either pilot, “Hey, you’re going to get hit by a bird strike, but keep calm and go back the way you came.” It just happened. Nothing seemed off that day, no foreboding warning signs. Nothing. They aren’t backing off, they’re telling the truth. They’re saying “your guys were warned about this, we weren’t”.
@@dr.pastrami5272 By that logic police officers, firefighters, EMT's, doctors, and nurses are not heroes either because according to you they are all just doing their job. I guess you also think mothers and fathers who are positive examples for their children are not heroes because they are just doing their job as parents.
@@xyPERSON That's exactly correct. A hero is an average person who selflessly donates their time to people in need for no compensation, or willingly risk their life to help an individual or a community. Parental roles are expected in a family unit. The father provides and protects for the family. The mother nurtures and cares for the offspring. You're not considered a hero for filling your role in a relationship. Its what's expected of you. Cops and security are trained and compensated for putting themselves in harms way to stop criminals. They sign up with the known intention that this scenario could possibly happen. Same goes for firefighters, EMTs, and soldiers alike. Their jobs are admirable because they willingly take on the risk so we don't have to. But they're still jobs in the end. Like an accountant, or an IT specialist. You can be thankful and appreciative for first responders, but dont call them heros for doing their jobs. They were trained for these scenarios. A hero is a store clerk helping a total stranger deliver her baby. A hero is a student teenager willingly raising money to donate to a charity. A hero is a plumber helping a family out of burning building or stopping an act of domestic violence. You see the difference? Heroism takes courage without preperation. Courage is grace under pressure.
@@dr.pastrami5272 That is YOUR opinion of what a hero is or should be but not everyone shares that same opinion or view. A hero is really anyone who can be looked up to which applies to doctors, nurses, EMTs, cops, firefighters, soldiers, educators, parents, etc. Whether or not they get paid for the work they do is irrelevant.
The Controller, the real one, stated in his testimony that they lost radar contact and then regained it- he hoped at the time they may have regained thrust in one engine. Also according to a real pilot in one of those "watch a movie and make comments videos", the ATC is supposed to continually give options and help in any way they can.
@@koalabrownie Только представьте что произошло если пилоты поверили бы диспетчеру... я думаю эта катастрофа была бы близка к 11 сентября. Гибель всего экипажа и пассажиров, серьёзный пожар в плотной городской застройке, задымления и испарения токсичного авиационного топлива погубили бы больше человек, чем было в самолете
Sully stated he did not like this scene. He was not faced with contempt from the officials, in fact they were very respectful of his heroism. The hearing cleared his name beyond all doubt
Even the NTSB investigators viewed Sully as a hero, thought from the beginning that he made the right decisions under the circumstances, and were thrilled to get the benefit of his experience.
Yeah, but that illustrates the difference between drama and real life. In drama you need an antagonist, even one who acts inhumanely. Hah! It comes full circle, like and ouroboros eating it's tail. They needed an inhumane antagonist, so they created an antagonist who took the humanity out of the test as the thing that would make him antagonistic.
@@3dpprofessor It is probably bias because I know about his political leanings, but to me it feels like a deliberate creation by Eastwood to show the, in his eyes, incompetent government trying to sanction a heroic individual.
@@3dpprofessor the problem is that the antagonist are real people who in real life work their asses off to improve transport safety and have to turn every tragedy into a lesson.. then some hollywood movie makes them villains and you have a lot of internet warriors moaning at how evil the NTSB is
@@scotthockenberry3085 the investigation in real life praised Sully so this movie basically did a hatchet job on one of the best government agencies to exist, the NTSB, for no reason.
@@xmlthegreat It is an unfortunate reality with Hollywood that every story has to have a "villain" no matter how poorly placed it is. Reality TV has the exact same problem where they will create a villain where one doesn't need to exist.
@@omarkhamis523 because he's not an over act artist he allways become the character totally and make it look easy it's the hardest think as you know Tom is not like Sully at all
Cao Hai Thanh using the word miracle gives no credit to the people who did their job in outstanding ways on the worst of the situations and circumstances. That makes the difference between crashes that you may ignore details about. In this case also the first responders, the air controllers, the decision Sully made, his decisions after the landing, the flight attendants who directed and helped the passengers. This was not a miracle, this was hard team work of people with decades of experience. They all deserve credit. We have to stop taking credit off of real people, decision making, common sense, critical thinking, fast thinking. Speed when landing in water is critical for the survival of the craft. That makes a difference. He knew how to land at a speed that wouldn’t break it. EXPERIENCE, decisions, thinking fast etc
i truly respect what they did, truly... And i totally agree with u that they deserve all the credits I just mean they also need luck there. Because many other pilots did exactly what they did in other crashes ( they also land on water ), but they failed and all were dead :(
Im so torn over this movie as an Aicraft Engineer. I love the first half with the crash and how accurate it is and how powerful they make it. I absolutely hate the second half where they demonise the NTSB, who are such an important organistion, just one of the many who have helped improve and safeguard aviation as it evovles from their hard work investigating crashes and other related incidents. In real life they were actually singing praises of sully from the get go and the invesgitation was a cordial, with full cooperation from both sides. Like for fucks sake these people probably knew better than anyone including pilots, how amazing it was what sully pulled off at the time. Ultimately I still rewatch part of the crash sequence from time to time, but I usually stop after that.
Unfortunately they needed an "antagonist" for the movie. Most air crash teams are Very fact focused and are there for the truth, not to appease some insurance company or something.
@@SendarSlayer I still would have found the fact finding/truth much more entertaining than the circus they manufactured. If anything they could have focused more on Scully's fears and doubt (which they did touch upon briefly in the film) than throwing hard working and honest people under the bus. Also, fun fact, believe it or not there are people who do it for aviation insurance companies. My dad currently does it.
This should be the first comment everyone reads. Hollywood didn't need to turn real-life people into villains just to make a better movie. Sadly, many people will never know any more than what the movie portrays.
@@thehotwombat fiction or not it's still disrespectful and sullies the reputation of a good hardworking organisation that does important work. Maybe from someones perspective who isn't in aviation, it might not seem important, but to us it is.
The night is darkest just before the dawn. And I promise you...the dawn is coming. You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.
I remember when this happened in 2009. I went to my X-Plane simulator and set a dual engine failure at 2800 feet and tried to make it back to LaGuardia. Possible only if you turn RIGHT AWAY. And I never succeeded going to Teterboro.
Mike Litoris Any failure you can imagine X-Plane can simulate it. Compressor stall, engine failure, bird strike, smoke in cockpit, the list goes on and on. You can set it so these failures happen randomly, pre set altitude, or immediately. It’s neat and great practice for pilots.
Sounds like a hell of a fun way to get some insight into stuff that could happen to you on the job if you're in that industry. Always love to see technology help out where it can. ^^
It’s amazing to see this change because throughout the movie, sully questioned himself if he has done everything he could. But at the end, he had no doubt after seeing the simulations as if they were mocking his decision making. I love this movie
"No one warned us no one said you were going to lose both engines at a lower attitude in any jet in history this was dual engine loss at 2,800 feet followed by a immediate water landing with over 155 souls on board no one has ever trained like a incident like that no one" I so like that line
This scene is total bullshit and not even close to what really happened. In real life Captain Sully after being criticized by the NTSB panel actually got up from where he was sitting and his old karate instincts from his Navy days literally kicked in and he proceeded to go down the panel one by one giving roundhouse kicks and karate chops leaving each member paralyzed for life.
In your version, it is absolutely vital that Sully be played by Chuck Norris in his prime (tho it seems he may have lent his mustache to the copilot in this version)
Ijaz Ali You can always sound clever. But the clever ones come up with a solution afterwards. Not a single piece of criticism is worth jack shit without a solution.
Based on true events means that you take poetic licences to create emotions. In the end it is a celebration to a brilliant captain, this is the way we people give thanks. Never look to movies to understand reality, history or accurate portrayal. It never happens. We turn to Documentaries, biographies and scientific data and history investigation for those things. If movies became the standard of knowledge, people wouldn't know fact from fiction. Movies advertises themselves openly as entertainment with various categories of Drama, Action and so on. You watch it for those purposes; if you watch it for education and truth you are in the completely wrong section. It is pointless to argue. Movies are MOVIES not something else. Educating oneself is done through other mediums. This story has been accurate told through news outlets and books. I never got upset from watching movies when they are "depicting" my ancestors - Vikings - because i know that movies are supposed to be entertainment. So i let every silly thing pass by as i chew down the popcorns. Same with Indians or Cowboys or anything else. It is just a movie. I know history and "truth" already about those topics so i just laugh it off. I haven't watched this movie yet, i haven't come around to it. But i will watch it with the knowledge of HUGE poetic licences being taken.
Based on false events. You can't just invent an adversarial investigation that never took place and make that the plot of your movie. How hard is that to get?
Not saying this movie was good. But if they had gone with what actually have happened the movie would have been boring. It would have had no conflict, no story arc, no character drama,... This is a fucking movie not a documentary.
BioLink I have no interest watching this movie as I have seen the actual hearings. JFK movie was a complete load of crap since it is mostly fiction like this. I thought "schlinders list"was based on something that actually happened but when I researched it it is mostly FICTION. I guess it depends on what you know and what you are willing to believe.
@@Dr_Peeper_ICU This made me laugh I imagine focused pilot and co-pilot landing on Hudson and suddenly a doctor enters and says: "I just want to tell you both good luck. We all counting on you" :D
I've always been amazed at the people who have hours, days, weeks to analyze someone else's actions in an emergency. When your life is on the line, everything changes.
As an airline employee I totally applaud & appreciate this touching movie. Step aside all super heros, all these live savers are real-life hero. Salute!!! Thanks to Clint Eastwood for producing this meaningful movie!
Tell me about it. I can never sleep in an airplane, max 2 hours for a 13hours flight. A bit of anxiety and a lot of wondering about how great it is to have achieved one of the oldest dream of mankind. Will never be used to it. Thanks to all people that make this dream true every day!
Regardless of the factor of what actually happened versus artistic license in movie-making, and in this scene in particular, Tom Hanks has genuinely earned each and every accolade he's won in his career thus far. His acting genius has gotten more spot-on in every movie he's made. I am led to believe every character he's played.
hanks is a good actor but I find his character roles often rather boring. He won't take risks as an actor and branch out into more interesting material
Y’all are literally obsessed with this actress like she’s the character she played. Skylark is not a real person Ana Gunn the actress is not responsible for your feelings about a character she played in a tv show 🙄
The NTSB said they were not like they were portrayed in the film, they were not the bad guys the movie made them look like. Search on TH-cam for this its there. So are the actual hearings.
This is constructed as a court hearing so Sully can be vindicted and is entirely bull. The entire accident and landing covers 30 mins cause it was that timeframe the actual accident happened in, but you can't end the movie after 30 mins, so they came up with all this to expand the plot. In actuality the board is not there to judge or anything, its to investigate and then make future recommendations etc for the overall safety. Sully himself even said that this movies board members were incorrectly portrayed as antagonists, even though throughout the whole thing there were none.
Chesley Burnett "Sully" Sullenberger III (born 1951) is a retired American airline captain who, on January 15, 2009, landed US Airways Flight 1549 in the Hudson River off Manhattan after both engines were disabled by a bird strike; all 155 persons aboard survived. In my opinion this person assited by his co-pilot are no less than heros, he managed in an extreme difficult situation, at a low altitude, in less than 15 minutes, to accomplish a task no one ever had done before.
The fake way in which the NTSB were portrayed is not only extremely inaccurate and insulting, but also quite hurtful to the investigators of the NTSB who did not try to blame the crew at all and in fact praised their skill and professionalism. People may say they needed conflict for the film, but just like the Crown, people will see this film as the truth.
how is this hurtful towards them. yeah maybe some dumbass random moviegoer will go "wow the NTSB sucks! that's messed up" but if someone sees this kinda thing and blindly takes it as fact, and is actually in some position for it to matter towards the NTSB what they think, that's indicative of much more important problems than a movie being dramatic.
I think it’s very Clint Eastwood to pain every situation as the heroic individual versus the oppressive bureaucrats from the overregulatory government. It’s totally ideological, and he doesn’t give a damn if it has nothing to do with reality.
I had the honor to meet Sully Sullenberger in person at a book signing. His quick thinking and experience saved the lives of everyone on board. This man is a true hero.
This was such a great film! I have no idea how true to life it was but it was damn entertaining and Sully will always be a hero to me no matter what anybody ever says.
Yes let's definitely get serious! Regardless of Capt Sully's like or dislike of this film, this was indeed one of Tom Hanks' finest performances ever, he acted just like he'd been there that fateful day nearly 10 yrs now, his role wasn't played like an actor but as the hero himself who saved 155 brave souls from a terrible death amid the freezing waters of the mighty Hudson River!
Tom Hanks did really well in this scene. His delivery, his expression, the way he conducts himself and imitates the situation is done so well and deserves so much respect.
Except this situation never happened. There was never some panel of accusatory NTSB investigators trying to put blame on Capt Sully. They of course did an investigation and had a hearing but he was never treated as anything but the hero that he was. This scene is completely made up and dramatized.
Another awesome movie by tom Hanks, but yet even shows how unbelievable that whole situation was in real life. Sully another one of our heroes here on earth.
The real two men who saved all of those people are in no question two of the biggest hero's of our time. I am glad they made a movie about it and that Tom Hanks was the lead. It did deserve an actor of great standing and who can portray a character very well.
@@garywilson3042 you see those three little dots on the right side of the video? You can select that and then select -> "Not Interested." An interesting thing happens. The video... DISAPPEARS!!
Super movie.. really enjoyed it.... wouldn't be the same without Tom Hanks... As a matter of fact all his co.stars in the movie played their parts really well... thanks for sharing!!!
When everyone heard there was practice attempts, that changed everything. You don't get to have another go if you've killed everyone on board, including yourself.
"You are looking for human error. Then make it human!" Great line
Too bad it is completely fake.
Home of the Mad wdym?
@@ingmarneple6072
This movie paints it as if the NTSB just railroaded Sully. That isn't at all the case. In real life Sully said the investigators were very understanding and he said that the movie was wrong.
Home of the Mad oh yeah that could be, didn’t know that👍🏼 but the moviemakers need to make something entertaining 🙈
@Corey McDonald can you explain the meaning of that line?
Is Tom Hank's just genetically designed to be a good actor?
Zakary Mandley pretty sure. Wonder whose genes he has coursing through his veins
Practice is everything
hahaha probably
Yoshikage Kira, wrangler?
He is the best of bests .. case dismiss.
He’s 100% correct. To me, it’s completely irrelevant whether he COULD have made it back to the airport or not under those dire conditions, he had to make a split second decision at the time, which resulted in all souls on board coming out of this situation alive. The man’s a hero in my book.
all plains can be recycled, human lives can't :)
And he is a hero in the NTSBs book as well. They did not in fact Kangaroo him, this persecution was entirely made up.
@@petruis2 just wondering, how and why would someone recycle a pair of completely trashed TurboFan Bypass Rolls Royce Jet Engines and a warped fuselage? Trust me, that A320 likely never saw the clouds again.
@@ziggy3237 N106US is on display at the Carolinas Aviation Museum. She'll never fly again.
@@katherineberger6329 ahh, okay.
"With great mustache comes great mustachability."
-Peter Griffin
😂
Robin Olds agrees 🎉
who tf is that?
@@apple54345 Ever heard of Google?
If you close your eyes, you can hear a heroic Woody defending his case.
I got a NTSB Hearing in my boot
I'm imagining buzz getting crashed on his flight mission because of human error, getting hospitalized and woody defending him.
1000
Thank me later
Did he ever played the antagonist in a movie? I always seen him in positive/hero roles.
“No one warned us.” Is just such a great all encompassing line. Hindsight is always 20/20 but when you are in the moment with lives in your hands you can’t make the perfect maneuvers. You have to the best you can with the information you have.
I hated that line. I reckon there would have been a better punchline to smash these panels. "No one warned us" sounds like Sully backed off after the panel said "They had all the same parameters". It would have been better if he replied with the "humanity out of the cockpit" line as it replies directly to the same parameter non-sense. Decision making is part of the parameter that Sully faced as the plane lost both engines.
@@chupapibingbong Is it not true, though? No one told either pilot, “Hey, you’re going to get hit by a bird strike, but keep calm and go back the way you came.” It just happened. Nothing seemed off that day, no foreboding warning signs. Nothing. They aren’t backing off, they’re telling the truth. They’re saying “your guys were warned about this, we weren’t”.
"You're looking for human error. Then make it human.."
Completely fabricated line.
@@homeofthemad3044 yes, welcome to the world of acting and movies
The pilot is a true hero who saved the lives of all the passengers, and Tom Hanks❤️ is brilliant in this movie as always 👏🏻
He's not a hero for doing his job. He's the standard that all other airline pilots should aspire to be.
@@dr.pastrami5272 By that logic police officers, firefighters, EMT's, doctors, and nurses are not heroes either because according to you they are all just doing their job. I guess you also think mothers and fathers who are positive examples for their children are not heroes because they are just doing their job as parents.
@@xyPERSON That's exactly correct. A hero is an average person who selflessly donates their time to people in need for no compensation, or willingly risk their life to help an individual or a community.
Parental roles are expected in a family unit. The father provides and protects for the family. The mother nurtures and cares for the offspring. You're not considered a hero for filling your role in a relationship. Its what's expected of you.
Cops and security are trained and compensated for putting themselves in harms way to stop criminals. They sign up with the known intention that this scenario could possibly happen. Same goes for firefighters, EMTs, and soldiers alike. Their jobs are admirable because they willingly take on the risk so we don't have to. But they're still jobs in the end. Like an accountant, or an IT specialist. You can be thankful and appreciative for first responders, but dont call them heros for doing their jobs. They were trained for these scenarios.
A hero is a store clerk helping a total stranger deliver her baby. A hero is a student teenager willingly raising money to donate to a charity. A hero is a plumber helping a family out of burning building or stopping an act of domestic violence.
You see the difference? Heroism takes courage without preperation. Courage is grace under pressure.
@@dr.pastrami5272 That is YOUR opinion of what a hero is or should be but not everyone shares that same opinion or view. A hero is really anyone who can be looked up to which applies to doctors, nurses, EMTs, cops, firefighters, soldiers, educators, parents, etc. Whether or not they get paid for the work they do is irrelevant.
@UCnoSbMVN5VPvwYeePgZfmCw thats what pilots, and frontline workers are dumbass
Tom Hanks doesn’t have much luck with flying does he, First Apollo thirteen and now this.
And there was also the Fedex flight!
Mmm.... "Castaway."
He even gets stuck in Airports 🙃 “The terminal”
It’s kind of like Angela landsbury from murder she wrote. Wherever she goes, someone dies.
Don’t ever get on a flight with Tom hanks
Don't forget Castaway
*Plane:* Literally 50 meters altitude and about to crash to buildings
*Tower:* "You can still land at Newark 7 miles away.."
Maybe there could have been a thermal that carried the plane up toward that airport 7 miles away.
Remember, the water landing is usually lethal. Landing in Newark seemed the only sensible way to land
The Controller, the real one, stated in his testimony that they lost radar contact and then regained it- he hoped at the time they may have regained thrust in one engine. Also according to a real pilot in one of those "watch a movie and make comments videos", the ATC is supposed to continually give options and help in any way they can.
The controller is just giving bearing and range to airfields while aircrew are 100% focused on flying a bent bird and not doing navigation work.
@@koalabrownie Только представьте что произошло если пилоты поверили бы диспетчеру... я думаю эта катастрофа была бы близка к 11 сентября. Гибель всего экипажа и пассажиров, серьёзный пожар в плотной городской застройке, задымления и испарения токсичного авиационного топлива погубили бы больше человек, чем было в самолете
Sully stated he did not like this scene. He was not faced with contempt from the officials, in fact they were very respectful of his heroism. The hearing cleared his name beyond all doubt
Even the NTSB investigators viewed Sully as a hero, thought from the beginning that he made the right decisions under the circumstances, and were thrilled to get the benefit of his experience.
Yeah, but that illustrates the difference between drama and real life. In drama you need an antagonist, even one who acts inhumanely.
Hah! It comes full circle, like and ouroboros eating it's tail. They needed an inhumane antagonist, so they created an antagonist who took the humanity out of the test as the thing that would make him antagonistic.
@@3dpprofessor It is probably bias because I know about his political leanings, but to me it feels like a deliberate creation by Eastwood to show the, in his eyes, incompetent government trying to sanction a heroic individual.
This whole movie is slander. They should have sued everyone involved for character assassination.
@@3dpprofessor the problem is that the antagonist are real people who in real life work their asses off to improve transport safety and have to turn every tragedy into a lesson.. then some hollywood movie makes them villains and you have a lot of internet warriors moaning at how evil the NTSB is
Sully is ice cold. I’d have had a hard time remaining calm in that hearing, let alone going through it in real life. What a professional
It's a movie? This never happened.
@@Mike-zf4xg it’s a movie?
@@scotthockenberry3085 the investigation in real life praised Sully so this movie basically did a hatchet job on one of the best government agencies to exist, the NTSB, for no reason.
@@xmlthegreat It is an unfortunate reality with Hollywood that every story has to have a "villain" no matter how poorly placed it is. Reality TV has the exact same problem where they will create a villain where one doesn't need to exist.
You might say it would be easier to land a plane on the Hudson than sit through that hearing.
Tom Hanks deserves an Oscar for this scene alone
Why I don't understand. I don't see anything out of the ordinary
No he doesn't it's an over dramatized crap show should have made a documentary and leave it at that Hollywood always finds a way to mess it up.
@@omarkhamis523 because he's not an over act artist he allways become the character totally and make it look easy it's the hardest think as you know Tom is not like Sully at all
i agree ☝️
For Woody
Today, there s another hero like mr Sully in Russia. The pilot did save 233 passengers after the plane lost both engines.
Another Miracle
Cao Hai Thanh - No miracles: EXPERIENCE
@@beccf.s.8012 nope. There were many others crashes lead to thousands of death, and all the pilots were also experienced !
Cao Hai Thanh using the word miracle gives no credit to the people who did their job in outstanding ways on the worst of the situations and circumstances. That makes the difference between crashes that you may ignore details about. In this case also the first responders, the air controllers, the decision Sully made, his decisions after the landing, the flight attendants who directed and helped the passengers. This was not a miracle, this was hard team work of people with decades of experience. They all deserve credit. We have to stop taking credit off of real people, decision making, common sense, critical thinking, fast thinking. Speed when landing in water is critical for the survival of the craft. That makes a difference. He knew how to land at a speed that wouldn’t break it. EXPERIENCE, decisions, thinking fast etc
i truly respect what they did, truly... And i totally agree with u that they deserve all the credits
I just mean they also need luck there. Because many other pilots did exactly what they did in other crashes ( they also land on water ), but they failed and all were dead :(
Cao Hai Thanh So, miracles are just luck? You’re ruining your own argument right now.
“No one warned us” gives me chills every time because of the way he says it.
0:36 *Logic has entered the chat*
"Captain?"
*Sully:* _Imma end this man's whole career._
Sully: "Can we just get plane serious now?"
Mr.Trump that wana very good pun.
@Liam Berg (STUDENT) T’was the point.
"We were not the Thunderbirds up there." Love that line
I didn't get the meaning of the line. whats thunderbird?
@@abcdefgh6121 they're a show squadron. They perform shows flying
@@abcdefgh6121 Its a bunch of F-18s that do insane and amazing stunts
@@abcdefgh6121 it basically means that those planes sink like rocks once you kill the engines. you cant glide them. in easily
@@bbsara0146 do you mean that the a320 sinks faster than other planes? I thought a320 is good at gliding.
Im so torn over this movie as an Aicraft Engineer. I love the first half with the crash and how accurate it is and how powerful they make it. I absolutely hate the second half where they demonise the NTSB, who are such an important organistion, just one of the many who have helped improve and safeguard aviation as it evovles from their hard work investigating crashes and other related incidents. In real life they were actually singing praises of sully from the get go and the invesgitation was a cordial, with full cooperation from both sides. Like for fucks sake these people probably knew better than anyone including pilots, how amazing it was what sully pulled off at the time. Ultimately I still rewatch part of the crash sequence from time to time, but I usually stop after that.
Unfortunately they needed an "antagonist" for the movie. Most air crash teams are Very fact focused and are there for the truth, not to appease some insurance company or something.
@@SendarSlayer I still would have found the fact finding/truth much more entertaining than the circus they manufactured. If anything they could have focused more on Scully's fears and doubt (which they did touch upon briefly in the film) than throwing hard working and honest people under the bus. Also, fun fact, believe it or not there are people who do it for aviation insurance companies. My dad currently does it.
This should be the first comment everyone reads. Hollywood didn't need to turn real-life people into villains just to make a better movie. Sadly, many people will never know any more than what the movie portrays.
It's a movie, not a reconstruction.
@@thehotwombat fiction or not it's still disrespectful and sullies the reputation of a good hardworking organisation that does important work. Maybe from someones perspective who isn't in aviation, it might not seem important, but to us it is.
The good thing here is that Skyler got a new job.
😂
Who said whalts dead?
@@mozzjonas9292 I truly expect he's till alive...
Lets hope he pops up in the BB movie 🤞
Men I Was waching the serie now, you just spoil me😅
Can I just say that I love Tom Hanks . In like every movie and in every role.
Yep, I thought he couldn't top Forrest Gump, then came Philadelphia. 2 Oscars, back-to-back...
“I don’t know what you hope to gain from this gentleman” He then gains everyone respect and admiration and making him look like a fool.
0:28 I can’t look at Jeff skiles with that mustache after watching the dark knight.
The night is darkest just before the dawn. And I promise you...the dawn is coming. You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.
@@RiceDaddy07 girl : what if , Harvey dent is the caped crusader ?
Hd: if were sneaking out everytime , then someone would have noticed ...
that's right skyler. I'M THE ONE WHO KNOCKS!!!
Is she skyler
lmao
Skyler is a bitch
I’m screaming 😂😂😂
@@arnavaggarwal8770 What are you talking about? She was like the only sane person on Breaking Bad.
I remember when this happened in 2009. I went to my X-Plane simulator and set a dual engine failure at 2800 feet and tried to make it back to LaGuardia. Possible only if you turn RIGHT AWAY. And I never succeeded going to Teterboro.
Awesome, is that the sim listed on Steam ?
At the time it was X-Plane 9. X-Plane 11 is out now. It's on steam.
The fact that they offered this scenario is awesome.
Mike Litoris Any failure you can imagine X-Plane can simulate it. Compressor stall, engine failure, bird strike, smoke in cockpit, the list goes on and on. You can set it so these failures happen randomly, pre set altitude, or immediately. It’s neat and great practice for pilots.
Sounds like a hell of a fun way to get some insight into stuff that could happen to you on the job if you're in that industry. Always love to see technology help out where it can. ^^
It’s amazing to see this change because throughout the movie, sully questioned himself if he has done everything he could. But at the end, he had no doubt after seeing the simulations as if they were mocking his decision making. I love this movie
"No one warned us no one said you were going to lose both engines at a lower attitude in any jet in history this was dual engine loss at 2,800 feet followed by a immediate water landing with over 155 souls on board no one has ever trained like a incident like that no one" I so like that line
This scene is total bullshit and not even close to what really happened. In real life Captain Sully after being criticized by the NTSB panel actually got up from where he was sitting and his old karate instincts from his Navy days literally kicked in and he proceeded to go down the panel one by one giving roundhouse kicks and karate chops leaving each member paralyzed for life.
I believe his phone rang at that point and it was his wife. He apparently told her, "Yes, dear, I'm actually taking the trash out as we speak."
thank you for existing
you sure that isn't the Steven Seagal version?
In your version, it is absolutely vital that Sully be played by Chuck Norris in his prime (tho it seems he may have lent his mustache to the copilot in this version)
Nice. I did not know that part.
Best line " You are looking for human error, then make it human"
Ijaz Ali You can always sound clever. But the clever ones come up with a solution afterwards. Not a single piece of criticism is worth jack shit without a solution.
Indeed. I really really like this line.
"Can we get serious now"... loads of truth in that line.
I would give that pilot the biggest hug
It is drama... BASED ON TRUE EVENTS... Not a documentary.
How hard is it to get.
It uses his real name. If it's not supposed to reflect the reality, it shouldn't trade on the guy's real name.
Based on true events means that you take poetic licences to create emotions. In the end it is a celebration to a brilliant captain, this is the way we people give thanks. Never look to movies to understand reality, history or accurate portrayal. It never happens. We turn to Documentaries, biographies and scientific data and history investigation for those things. If movies became the standard of knowledge, people wouldn't know fact from fiction. Movies advertises themselves openly as entertainment with various categories of Drama, Action and so on. You watch it for those purposes; if you watch it for education and truth you are in the completely wrong section.
It is pointless to argue. Movies are MOVIES not something else. Educating oneself is done through other mediums. This story has been accurate told through news outlets and books. I never got upset from watching movies when they are "depicting" my ancestors - Vikings - because i know that movies are supposed to be entertainment. So i let every silly thing pass by as i chew down the popcorns. Same with Indians or Cowboys or anything else. It is just a movie. I know history and "truth" already about those topics so i just laugh it off. I haven't watched this movie yet, i haven't come around to it. But i will watch it with the knowledge of HUGE poetic licences being taken.
Based on false events. You can't just invent an adversarial investigation that never took place and make that the plot of your movie.
How hard is that to get?
Not saying this movie was good. But if they had gone with what actually have happened the movie would have been boring. It would have had no conflict, no story arc, no character drama,... This is a fucking movie not a documentary.
BioLink
I have no interest watching this movie as I have seen the actual hearings. JFK movie was a complete load of crap since it is mostly fiction like this. I thought "schlinders list"was based on something that actually happened but when I researched it it is mostly FICTION. I guess it depends on what you know and what you are willing to believe.
Sully, you can't be serious...
I am serious, and don't call me Sully
That's funny. Airplane!'s last scene "We are all counting on you." is what brought me to this video. LOL.
@@Dr_Peeper_ICU This made me laugh
I imagine focused pilot and co-pilot landing on Hudson and suddenly a doctor enters and says: "I just want to tell you both good luck. We all counting on you" :D
I've always been amazed at the people who have hours, days, weeks to analyze someone else's actions in an emergency. When your life is on the line, everything changes.
As an airline employee I totally applaud & appreciate this touching movie. Step aside all super heros, all these live savers are real-life hero. Salute!!! Thanks to Clint Eastwood for producing this meaningful movie!
Tell me about it. I can never sleep in an airplane, max 2 hours for a 13hours flight. A bit of anxiety and a lot of wondering about how great it is to have achieved one of the oldest dream of mankind. Will never be used to it. Thanks to all people that make this dream true every day!
There, I watched it! Now get out of my recommends!
Yes, watching it will surely help the algorithms do better in the future....
@@Njald There's no way around, dude. It going to show up for others regardless if I watch it not.
@@Njald JustinCage is right, I've been trying to avoid it for weeks, even pressed the non interested button but it's still showing up
same bruh
@@hackerman5207 When you press not interested, you have to also press 'tell us why' and select a reason, this way it would go away.
This scene always gives me literal chills down my spine. What an amazing performance by Tom Hanks...
Tom hanks. Amazing actor. You can see the emotion and seriousness he put into this movie to play sully.
The way he says “can we get serious now?” just does something to me.
Regardless of the factor of what actually happened versus artistic license in movie-making, and in this scene in particular, Tom Hanks has genuinely earned each and every accolade he's won in his career thus far. His acting genius has gotten more spot-on in every movie he's made. I am led to believe every character he's played.
god damn, Tom Hanks just... owns any and all scenes he's in doesn't he? This man is a cinematic legend and treasure.
I can't remember a movie he was in. Even Money Pit was decent.
Keep in mind, he started as a mildly annoying comedian.
hanks is a good actor but I find his character roles often rather boring. He won't take risks as an actor and branch out into more interesting material
Yeah, he probably is the only good thing about this movie.
He is good but the cinematography always paints him in Jesus lightbeams like a dramatic Zeus; so much for suspense
skylar as horrible as always
lol it’s you, keep up the cool memes dude!
i remember walt said "you stupid bitch" in season 5
Y’all are literally obsessed with this actress like she’s the character she played. Skylark is not a real person Ana Gunn the actress is not responsible for your feelings about a character she played in a tv show 🙄
@@bascal133 we all know :D th-cam.com/video/X4Wby6SNcK8/w-d-xo.html
ok but what's a milf?
I loved this scene from this movie.
The actual hearings were many hours, and over many days I am surprised how they fit it in such a short time. I wonder how accurate that scene was.
Except that it was all Hollywood made-up bullcrap.
M1911jln Sully was based on a true story wasn't it? So it's not "made up Hollywood bullcrap"
The NTSB said they were not like they were portrayed in the film, they were not the bad guys the movie made them look like. Search on TH-cam for this its there. So are the actual hearings.
This is constructed as a court hearing so Sully can be vindicted and is entirely bull. The entire accident and landing covers 30 mins cause it was that timeframe the actual accident happened in, but you can't end the movie after 30 mins, so they came up with all this to expand the plot.
In actuality the board is not there to judge or anything, its to investigate and then make future recommendations etc for the overall safety. Sully himself even said that this movies board members were incorrectly portrayed as antagonists, even though throughout the whole thing there were none.
Chesley Burnett "Sully" Sullenberger III (born 1951) is a retired American airline captain who, on January 15, 2009, landed US Airways Flight 1549 in the Hudson River off Manhattan after both engines were disabled by a bird strike; all 155 persons aboard survived. In my opinion this person assited by his co-pilot are no less than heros, he managed in an extreme difficult situation, at a low altitude, in less than 15 minutes, to accomplish a task no one ever had done before.
HATHOR wow, thanks for that summary, nobody knew any of that before. Kudos!
I didn't know that, so thanks for filling me in.
BTW, I was being sarcastic. 😂
@@Slow_Horse 😩
Less than 3-1/2 minutes!!!!
Tom Hanks could hit me with a plane on purpose and I would apologise
LMBWAO!!!
That’s sound so wrong😂
Fcking same
If I heard that Tom Hanks punted a two-month old baby onto a river, I'd ask what did the baby do.
"Can we get serious now?"
_Proceeds to talk about picking up milk_
Well, he had to be serious because the bench was acting like a bunch of finger pointing dickwads.
Its exaggeration used for emphasis called hyperbole. Its a figure of speech.
Hanks invented three things , acting , and being believable , but foremost charisma as a starter !
The fake way in which the NTSB were portrayed is not only extremely inaccurate and insulting, but also quite hurtful to the investigators of the NTSB who did not try to blame the crew at all and in fact praised their skill and professionalism.
People may say they needed conflict for the film, but just like the Crown, people will see this film as the truth.
how is this hurtful towards them. yeah maybe some dumbass random moviegoer will go "wow the NTSB sucks! that's messed up" but if someone sees this kinda thing and blindly takes it as fact, and is actually in some position for it to matter towards the NTSB what they think, that's indicative of much more important problems than a movie being dramatic.
I think it’s very Clint Eastwood to pain every situation as the heroic individual versus the oppressive bureaucrats from the overregulatory government. It’s totally ideological, and he doesn’t give a damn if it has nothing to do with reality.
Tom Hanks is such a great actor
I had the honor to meet Sully Sullenberger in person at a book signing. His quick thinking and experience saved the lives of everyone on board. This man is a true hero.
Captain Sully was asking the real questions there😎
This was such a great film! I have no idea how true to life it was but it was damn entertaining and Sully will always be a hero to me no matter what anybody ever says.
The investigation part is completely made up. The real NTSB praised Sully.
When she said 17 attempts. 😂😂😂 What a joke these aviation boards are.
Hanks my MAN, you give me CHILLS.... SO GOOD..
One of the best actors in history. Right up there with Denzel Washington 👍🏻
Yes let's definitely get serious! Regardless of Capt Sully's like or dislike of this film, this was indeed one of Tom Hanks' finest performances ever, he acted just like he'd been there that fateful day nearly 10 yrs now, his role wasn't played like an actor but as the hero himself who saved 155 brave souls from a terrible death amid the freezing waters of the mighty Hudson River!
Nobody talk how great and underrated is Aaron eckhart
Tom Hanks did really well in this scene. His delivery, his expression, the way he conducts himself and imitates the situation is done so well and deserves so much respect.
Except this situation never happened. There was never some panel of accusatory NTSB investigators trying to put blame on Capt Sully. They of course did an investigation and had a hearing but he was never treated as anything but the hero that he was. This scene is completely made up and dramatized.
@@Chris-hb2ib I mean you are correct but this person was just talking about how Tom Hanks acted in this scene
My favourite scene from this film. Sully shuts that guy down instantly.
no, no we cannot get serious
where is Wilson
Wilson is not the Captain now.
Wilson jumped ship!
Damn the coward!
Like the drink, only not spelt the same
Wilson!
where is Nate tho
Damn love seeing this scene again. Honestly, thank you TH-cam.
This movie was amazing ! Tom Hanks is one of the greatest actors in show business.
Another awesome movie by tom Hanks, but yet even shows how unbelievable that whole situation was in real life. Sully another one of our heroes here on earth.
I want to be offended at any possible no-matter-how-unrealistic injustice! This clip is perfect for me! I’m so angry. Grrrrrrrrrr!
hahaha
You find me offensive? I find you offensive for finding me offensive!
I am offended at you all arguing that you are offended!
I love it when Tom Hanks is CAPTAIN.
It sounds like Sully was saying: “Can we get serious now” as a statement rather than a question.
Unrelated Topic. Am I the only one who thinks that Tom Hanks would make a great Sully from Uncharted?
Nope and I've never heard of this movie, Clciked it because I thought that's what it was
Case Clevenger Ehh I don't think he would but I can see where you're coming from
A little more moustach and he's him, good call!
I agree with this
nah his voice isnt raspy enough, ya gotta have those 40-50 odd years of cigars for Sully.
Y’all better stop playing with Woody and Two-Face
I think Tom Hanks is literally the best actor who has ever lived. And no one can convince me otherwise lol. I'll accept Leo as an answer though. :)
I do not know how many times I watched thisxalready. I saw this movie on tv a rsndom evening. And it lives rent free in my head since then.
backseat drivers eh, "you could have done this could have done that,"
Pretty much the internet in a nutshell.
It's a lie man, they didn't get blamed. The whole reason ppl are arguing over the insulation.
Hindsight is 20/20, as they say.
And it’s those who write history. Unfortunately..
tubez4321 yep! Hahahaha so many asswipes.....
I love this film about Chelsea’s upcoming season. Falling from the top and relying on Hudson to save them
I could literally listen to his voice for hours. Anyone else feel this way?
Even just seeing the caption to this video makes me want to go watch it again, such an epic movie!
Tom is a chameleon.
He's just that good.
The real two men who saved all of those people are in no question two of the biggest hero's of our time. I am glad they made a movie about it and that Tom Hanks was the lead. It did deserve an actor of great standing and who can portray a character very well.
Hanks deserve an oscar for every single movie he has made... he´s just genius!...
"This is not a video game"
meanwhile me playing flight simulator and yet to master perfect landing in perfectly normal conditions
jesus it feel like this clip have been in my recommend for 100 years, now get out!
Yeah, it’s been lingering in my recommendations for ages.
don't watch similar videos you twat
@cretu bogdan Calm Down Kiddo
i am calm.
@@garywilson3042 you see those three little dots on the right side of the video? You can select that and then select -> "Not Interested." An interesting thing happens. The video... DISAPPEARS!!
There was a meme going around that says " the award for the man with the greatest pair of steel balls goes to Captain Sully!" I fully agree
Then Denzel Washington pops up and says "I drank the vodka bottles on the plane"
This movie gives me chills every time I watch it.
Strange, I watched this movie yesterday and now it appeared in my recommended tab, and the TV isn't even connected to the internet..
“Look at me. I’m the 0:40 now”
Honestly, looking at Aaron Eckhart's face, i do not know how he was not instantly promoted to legendary status.
Never enter a vehicle with Tom Hanks. It’s confirmed to go wrong
NTSB: It's not possible.
Sully: No, it's necessary.
Super movie.. really enjoyed it.... wouldn't be the same without Tom Hanks... As a matter of fact all his co.stars in the movie played their parts really well... thanks for sharing!!!
Anna Gunn - tremble your voice with every response, regardless of the character you're playing = acting
Your Welcome TH-cam... I FINALLY WATCHED IT! ARE YOU HAPPY NOW??
After skyler tells sully “seventeen attempts” he must’ve felt like a freaking god
this scene just made me watch the whole film
Government is such a piece of shit. They want to take down sully and sully his fukcing name. Pieces of cunt shit mother fuckers.
Tom hanks puts life in what he acts
"In these simulations, you've taken all the humanity out of the cockpit." 💯
"every landing you can walk (in this case swim) away from is a good landing, if you can reuse the aircraft afterwards it's a great landing"
When everyone heard there was practice attempts, that changed everything. You don't get to have another go if you've killed everyone on board, including yourself.
Excellent dialogue. I probably rewatched this for the 15th time.
There TH-cam I watched it. Can we get serious now?
The Best actor of the world
Tom Hanks