I love this woman's delivery of faultlessly coherent logic and reasoning. There are no gaps, no gaps in which to insert rebuttals or refutations. Brilliant.
Absolutely one of the finest clearest speakers I have heard. Very impressed with Einat Wilf and she is absolutely correct 100% in every word she said. She has a brilliant insight and a brilliant way of explaining Anti-zionist is ofcourse anti-Jew.
@@mikelundmikel4006stop spamming - all you do is accuse in all you comments that einat is a liar. Well then educate us and point what her lies were, and provide verifiable evidence that they are lies.
@@mikelundmikel4006 you can onley say the same but i tell you the truth hurts and you show that on your words, people who not want to hear the truth have manny pain
Einat Wilf always gives a good lecture. This lecture was particularly value-added. Dr. Wilf added another dozen new insights to the ongoing problems in the Middle East. She is amazingly insightful.
Einat has been a revelation to us all in this last year. The appalling events of 7.10 seems to have blessed us with the likes of Douglas, Natasha and Einat; who speak for us fearlessly and with real courage. Thank you friends of Israel. God will honour and bless you
@@mikelundmikel4006Anybody who speaks the truth with facts, reason and logic is always a paid actor according to you morons. 🤣 If you can't counter any of their points with anything other than that parroted statement, you are just an uneducated and gullible twit who has no right to comment on this war.
Thank you for talking about antisemitism and Israel’ here in the US no one is talking about it. I’m so afraid about the quiet. Trump says he’s pro Israel but as you must know everything he does is for his benefit. He hasn’t said anything about the antisemitism here or around the world. Here he won’t say anything because those people vote for him. Very scary to have the quiet here. People were quiet before WW11 and then the worst came true!
As a therapist and keen follower of history and this issue in particular - one cannot overlook the human collective subconscious. This hatred was planted by early Christianity - Jews as Christ-killers, the ultimate crime. It needs to be called out regularly. The Jews are innocent of this crime and history's constant victims.
Patience Israel . The world right now is sick with hate for the Jews ..as usual. I am not Jewish but i stand for you every day...and it's not easy...Keep on doing what you do ! 😊
Einat has the most eloquent, clear voice not only to talk about the conflict but also to talk the truth!!! Einat is brilliant!!!! Such great voice for peace!!!!
Dr. Wilf, dear Einat, is always right on the mark. I am almost daily in touch with Canadian friends & I worry. But I worry too about Boston. People never think that there's a problem except when Harvard misbehaves. It is not so. Yhis us a dangerous area. Jews here are disorganized and mostly not paying attention. This will end badly.
Really? They aren't paying attention? Here where I live, so many Jews are so leftist it boggles my mind. The majority of Jews in the U. S. are liberal-leftist, and will vote for Harris..and this D administration sure does appease the terrorists...So, that's one major reason I just don't get these J's here in the U. S.
She is really great but I would like to know her positions on other issues. This conflict is easy to get lost in, but what else does she support? I'm.glad she has parted ways with the appeasement thinking but is she a socialist? Does she support supreme court reform? How about a written constitution, and what are her views on the rabbinate?
@@generic260Wow! Isn't it enough that she was totally wrong for decades? Didn't the speech of that British minister exist for 75 years? What did she do with it for decades?
Dr Wilf deserves credit for being able to admit the failure of her hypothesis. It's a bit funny, however, that the "hypothesis" was simply rejected, but no recognition of all those who have been telling us that there is a reality which is suggests a different, a commonsensical "hypothesis." Not just Bevin, but Israeli Jews who have lived in Muslim-majority countries and the opposite side of the aisle... the "Right." Anybody who knows what Arab Nationalists said and what Mosab Hassan Yousef, son of one of the founders of Hamas says about the fake "Palestinian" identity, should have figured it out. Really, when Arab Muslims have invaded, oppressed, enslaved, Arabized and Islamized millions of Non-Arabs, why would they not want to own 100% of the Arab-Jewish land? When they chant "Haibar, Haibar ya Yahud, Jaish Mohammad..." and say that Jews are not indigenous to the Middle East and that Jesus was "Palestinian," Arab Muslim and when tens of intellectuals from Muslim-majority countries have been warning the entire West about Migration, Cultural, Political and Sword Jihad...
The moral clarity and passion rooted in a serious commitment to understanding the world as it is, empirically and logically, is palpable in her words. We must not forget that Nazi Germany was far from decrepit. It was a cultural and scientific behemoth, one of the most advanced societies in the world by most standards. A strong hatred of Jews and desire to eradicate them can take hold of rich and poor, educated and ignorant alike.
24:50 as an israeli, former peace activist myself, i felt the same, i was not surprised by their barbarism, only by their achievements that day, but more than that i was surprised by the support they got from the majority of the world..
She is one of the Four Horsemen (actually Horsewomen!) of this whole issue: Einat Wilf, Noa Tishby, Fleur Hassan-Nahoum, and most importantly (perhaps): Natasha Hausdorff. Either listen to them or read their books for a full understanding of this unfortunate issue.
Like America mistakenly backed Bin Laden in the early years. When you are surrounded by bad actors it is easy to get it wrong. Also...what should he have done? There was no stomach in Israel for going into Gaza and going after Hamas before Oct 7. ( And needless to say, zero international support.)
We've heard that ridiculous question so many times. Have you ever been in a bad relationship? Getting to know someone and then realizing that this was not at all what you were expecting? Why is this so different?
If you're looking for Palestinian voices to amplify with interaction, exposure and donations, I wholeheartedly recommend The Third Narrative. It's a podcast by two Palestinian Israelis who are adamant on discussing the conflict in the fairest, most truth-oriented way I've ever seen. Einat, thank you for speaking out these harsh truths. And yet, I think you should know there is such a thing as reformed Palestinianism, and I think the Third Narrative crew might pull you back from your understandable level of disbelief. In the end, we all deserve better.
Great speech by the lady. However, the man interviewing her after, needs to stop the long winded speechy questions, just get on and ask the questions. Otherwise it was great!
The speaker refers with approval to the universal principle of self determination but ignores the fact that in 1947/1948, the Arab population formed something like 64% of the population of the former mandatory Palestine. At the beginning of the 20th century, when European migration to what became mandatory Palestine started, the Arab majority was over 90%. In 1947/1948, why did the United Nations not implement a policy of democratic self-determination? It was from this failure that all the future tragedy stemmed.
The British Mandate on the Palestine was created to give to Arab and Jews proper separated states for their nationalistic aspirations. That's how Jordan was created for the Arabs and Palestine was split between the two existing populations. The Arabs rejected the plan to give the Jews any territory and by doing so they rejected (and still reject) the Jews right for self-determination. You need to understand that the Jews can't be a minority in a state because this is the reason the Jewish people have been persecuted for centuries. The Jews without a state and an army are destined to become the scapegoat of nazi/fascist/marxist/jihadist dictators. you: "why did the United Nations not implement a policy of democratic self-determination?" Because as a minority in a majority Muslim country (even if somehow democratic) the Jews can't archive their own aspirations. For instance , Israel allow unlimited immigration of Jews from around the world , this is only possible because Israel is a Jewish state. you: "It was from this failure that all the future tragedy stemmed." Nope, the tragedy has been created by the radical Islamic ideology that deny to any non-muslim people the right for self-determination on the land they consider "Islamic".
Alan, perhaps because of the creation of the Arab state of Jordan on 70% of the territory that was mandated for a Jewish homeland? How many “homelands” do Arabs need? After WWII about 6 new Arab states were created and today there about 23 Arab states. Jews want only one little country.
Alan, perhaps because of the creation of the Arab state of Jordan on 70% of the land mandated for the Jewish state? How many “homelands” do the Arabs need? After WWII many new Arab states were created; today there are about 23 Arab states. Is it so terrible to have one little Jewish state?
In the normal course of life one day is succeeded by the next, and the previous day recedes into the past. October 7th is different, it is a defining moment. As I see it, as of that day the concept of a two-state solution is clearly a non-sequitur for peace. October 7th is burned into the present, it will not recede. The call for cease-fire is a call to the status of October 6th, which will always become October 7th... the Groundhog Day for Israel.
It took 20-30 yers of American occupation to “denazify” Germany but Hitler was only around from 1924-1945. The Arabs have seen Jews as Dhimmis for 1300 years. It is going to be a lot harder for the Israeli to change the Arabs ideology IF EVER.
I notice most comments focus on her mode of delivery and not the content. Since the IDF bombed the Gaza strip and seeing the plight of the Palestinians on the television (in the UK) I'm not in support of Israel and after years and years of 'respecting' the Jews, feel indifferent towards them. It appalled me to think of them gaily going about their daily lives in places like Tel Aviv whilst their 'enemy' lay crushed beneath rubble.
"Gaily going about their daily lives?" Seriously? Nothing shows more than this frase, how people know absolutely nothing about the Israelis. The past year has been one of the worst for Israelis. The terrible massacre of oct 7 is something that will never be erased from memory, exactly like the terrible years of 140 (!) Suicide bombings within 3 years shall never be erased from the collective mind. Your comment literally addresses not one thing in this lecture. The plight of the Palestinians is and always has been, of their own doing. Their leaders always, always preferred choosing their own ego and so-called "Islamic peride" over and at the expense of their people's lives. "The day the arabs will care more about their lives than about the death of jews is the day we will have peace" Golda Meir
there are Palestinians working towards a third narrative, Amira and Ibrahim, Unapologetic: The Third Narrative...they're the new reality, Palestinians who want to talk to Jews and live together, who despise the so-called resistance of Hamas or Fatah
Within 2 days, 12k views, 497 likes, 90 comments = a lot of people began listening, were unmoved by the presentation, and so left without even bothering to contribute in any way. This content is simply bad Hasbara (propaganda) and has been recognised by viewers as such. Personally, I’m still watching because I’m interested in the topics of propaganda, indoctrination, manipulation, cults etc. As a study from that perspective, this video is very informative.
Beg to differ, Sandy! The Jews around the world suffer! This issue is so acute to Jews, people need to evaluate what is going on through discussions! Jews don't riot, they don't stab, they don't attack musl8m secret places, they don't bomb in the name of their greatest... How you choose to react to this conversation is up to what you are looking for. Propaganda for you, food for thought for another.
@@NeverAgain316 Are you aware that a huge proportion of Jews worldwide are opposed to the State of Israel? Research ‘Jewish Dissent’, you’ll discover that many Jewish intellectuals, academics, humanitarians, legal professionals, rabbis, and others are vehemently opposed to the state of Israel. Also did you know that many Israeli youth are ‘refuseniks’, refusing military service, and ex-IDF military speaking out against Israel’s Occupation? There is so much more to this issue than what pro-Israel people are willing to admit.
A lot of big words that literally addressed non of the talking points. Please enlighten me, what exactly in Dr. Wilf's words is false, and based on what evidence?
the hostility of Jews young or not young towards Israel in other countries comes from the hostility towards Israel of the country where they live. If these countries fully supported Israel, some Jews would also support Israel or some would be indifferent
I’m already 26 minutes into her talk and understandably she’s looking at it from her perspective and she’s very good at explaining it. Fine, but but I wonder what she would say if the roles were reversed. Namely, that the Israeli’s were living in an open prison for decades and the Palestinians were keeping them there and the US gave the Palestinians all the weapons they wanted as they keep Israelis under control and under squalid dehumanized conditions. So what would Einat do under such insufferable conditions? Would she put up with it or fight by creating a covert rag tag army to defeat the Palestinians? No one deserves to be treated in dehumanizing ways and while Hamas’s attacks are downright evil, and not to justify their behavior, but it’s safe to say that what they did was a desperate attempts to fight decades of oppression by the Israeli government. What Hamas did was evil but so is being forced to live in an open prison by the Israeli government all the while western governments turn a blind eye, especially the United States. Rest assured, we are setting ourselves up for another 911. And I fear it’s going to be far worse.
26-minutes of not listening. She is talking about 1947 before Israel was established, before Gaza, no IDF, before settlements,..., all the reasons you mentioned did not exist. The Arabs, later known as "Palestinians", did not agree for the Jewish people to have a state. They did not agree that Jewish people will have sovereignty. So that's the real reason for the conflict. Now, about Gaza. Israel pulled out if Gaza in 2005. Not a single settlement or IDF soldier. Gaza people, with the aid they got throughout the years ,billions of dollars, they could build Gaza like Singapore, with beach resorts (Gaza has a beautiful beach), restaurants, platter the streets in gold, you name it... and BTW Israel: we would love to assist them with development and co-operation. What did they do? Buried all the cement in the underground, invested in buying weapons and making rockets, making Gaza the biggest terrorist-base in the world.
@GnosisMan50 "From water to water, the land shall be Arab" That is the exact original frase in Arabic of what is today known as "from river to river" That frase encapsulates the motivation and the reason for all the bad decision making done by Palestinian Arabs, forever. Always, the end goal was to turn back to the old days of glory - the Islamic Caliphate. Jews are simply in the way.
With your logic everybody’s ancestors stole the land they are living on. Where did your ancestors live 100, 1000, 10.000 years ago and whose land did they steal when they moved? You better return the stolen land 🤗
Please Einat, consider running for the prime minister! You have my vote.
But she was WRONG for decades !!
@@barouchkrakauer7815 Never too late once you are on the right path.
@@barouchkrakauer7815 People that admit their errors and misjudgments are the wisest people and best to trust
@@JorgeRzezak No.
@@barouchkrakauer7815 Baruch your eloquence is very convincing..... Shabbat shalom
I love this woman's delivery of faultlessly coherent logic and reasoning. There are no gaps, no gaps in which to insert rebuttals or refutations. Brilliant.
Absolutely one of the finest clearest speakers I have heard. Very impressed with Einat Wilf and she is absolutely correct 100% in every word she said. She has a brilliant insight and a brilliant way of explaining
Anti-zionist is ofcourse anti-Jew.
Right. But she's still an elitist leftist in the Israeli body politic.
Are you afraid of your government given what it did on Oct 7th?
Two amazing women I love listening two are Einat Wilf and Natasha Hausdorff. You can’t go wrong with those two highly intelligent Jewish women.
I agree! My two favourite Jewish women!
Amazing. A true masterclass and a beacon of light. Einat Wilf should be Israel's next primer minister.
Einat is so on point. Such clarity on such a complex subject.
Fabulous lady. Wisdom, even humour......... in spite of everything. I admire her courage (which inspires).
lying is courage?
@@mikelundmikel4006 She's so convincing + popular BECAUSE she speaks the truth. You are neither..😉
@@wolfsettgast4945 truth.lol.like headless babies?like hamas stoping aid?like mass rapes?didnt happen.them truths?or just telling truth now?
@@mikelundmikel4006: you just mean you don't agree. You have NO proof she is lying. Take your slur to the toilet, and flush it.
@@mikelundmikel4006stop spamming - all you do is accuse in all you comments that einat is a liar. Well then educate us and point what her lies were, and provide verifiable evidence that they are lies.
EXCELLENT TALK , INTERVIEW. Problem is that no one wants to TALK ABOUT THIS! Einat is brilliant.
its more bullshit from a paid puppet
❤❤❤❤❤❤Thank you Einat, you are the best!
best liar
@@mikelundmikel4006 you can onley say the same but i tell you the truth hurts and you show that on your words, people who not want to hear the truth have manny pain
@@jackdeserno5378 il take an inconvieniant truth over a conviniant lie.try it someday
שנה טובה
Love Einat. You’re a treasure.
She is immoral.
This is gold. Every word of it.
Thank you so much for this! Bravo!
Einat Wilf always gives a good lecture. This lecture was particularly value-added. Dr. Wilf added another dozen new insights to the ongoing problems in the Middle East. She is amazingly insightful.
she a liar
@@mikelundmikel4006 Really, please enlighten me with your details? Palestinians agree with her.
Einat has been a revelation to us all in this last year.
The appalling events of 7.10 seems to have blessed us with the likes of Douglas, Natasha and Einat; who speak for us fearlessly and with real courage.
Thank you friends of Israel. God will honour and bless you
blessed us with paid puppets lying through thier teeth
@@mikelundmikel4006Anybody who speaks the truth with facts, reason and logic is always a paid actor according to you morons. 🤣 If you can't counter any of their points with anything other than that parroted statement, you are just an uneducated and gullible twit who has no right to comment on this war.
Thank you for talking about antisemitism and Israel’ here in the US no one is talking about it. I’m so afraid about the quiet. Trump says he’s pro Israel but as you must know everything he does is for his benefit. He hasn’t said anything about the antisemitism here or around the world. Here he won’t say anything because those people vote for him. Very scary to have the quiet here. People were quiet before WW11 and then the worst came true!
As a therapist and keen follower of history and this issue in particular - one cannot overlook the human collective subconscious. This hatred was planted by early Christianity - Jews as Christ-killers, the ultimate crime. It needs to be called out regularly. The Jews are innocent of this crime and history's constant victims.
Brilliant, as always!
Einat Wilf is brilliant, I love her intelligence and clarity of mind.
100% true. She should be on the cover of every magazine right now. Nothing provocative. wow So impressive
Absolutely brilliant presentation
Where would the world be without the genius of the Jews?!
What an intelligent audience, judging by the questions.
Patience Israel . The world right now is sick with hate for the Jews ..as usual. I am not Jewish but i stand for you every day...and it's not easy...Keep on doing what you do ! 😊
Einat has the most eloquent, clear voice not only to talk about the conflict but also to talk the truth!!! Einat is brilliant!!!! Such great voice for peace!!!!
Dr. Wilf, dear Einat, is always right on the mark. I am almost daily in touch with Canadian friends & I worry. But I worry too about Boston. People never think that there's a problem except when Harvard misbehaves. It is not so. Yhis us a dangerous area. Jews here are disorganized and mostly not paying attention. This will end badly.
Really? They aren't paying attention? Here where I live, so many Jews are so leftist it boggles my mind.
The majority of Jews in the U. S. are liberal-leftist, and will vote for Harris..and this D administration sure does appease the terrorists...So, that's one major reason I just don't get these J's here in the U. S.
I love Einat, hope one day she will be able to lead Israel!
She was WRONG for decades.
She is really great but I would like to know her positions on other issues. This conflict is easy to get lost in, but what else does she support? I'm.glad she has parted ways with the appeasement thinking but is she a socialist? Does she support supreme court reform? How about a written constitution, and what are her views on the rabbinate?
@@generic260Wow!
Isn't it enough that she was totally wrong for decades?
Didn't the speech of that British minister exist for 75 years?
What did she do with it for decades?
@@generic260she has interviews in Hebrew where she addresses other issues. Also has written a book about the Israeli education system.
@@murderouswolf123 Good. I hope to learn more about her.
So much for the new Saladin. Great talk and Einat is crystal clear.
I agree with Einat Wilf completely; the world is intentionally naive.
Einat , PLEASE tell Canadians government to stop funding to UNRWA?
A national treasure she is.
Dr Einat Wilf brilliant as ever, thank you for your book and clear logic and definitian of the conflict ❤
Thanks for mentioning UNRWA. Please remind Justin Trudeau about how bad sending millions too UNRWA is
great speech, very intelligent woman 👍
Einat Wilf starts talking at 9:19
Dr Wilf deserves credit for being able to admit the failure of her hypothesis. It's a bit funny, however, that the "hypothesis" was simply rejected, but no recognition of all those who have been telling us that there is a reality which is suggests a different, a commonsensical "hypothesis." Not just Bevin, but Israeli Jews who have lived in Muslim-majority countries and the opposite side of the aisle... the "Right." Anybody who knows what Arab Nationalists said and what Mosab Hassan Yousef, son of one of the founders of Hamas says about the fake "Palestinian" identity, should have figured it out. Really, when Arab Muslims have invaded, oppressed, enslaved, Arabized and Islamized millions of Non-Arabs, why would they not want to own 100% of the Arab-Jewish land? When they chant "Haibar, Haibar ya Yahud, Jaish Mohammad..." and say that Jews are not indigenous to the Middle East and that Jesus was "Palestinian," Arab Muslim and when tens of intellectuals from Muslim-majority countries have been warning the entire West about Migration, Cultural, Political and Sword Jihad...
The moral clarity and passion rooted in a serious commitment to understanding the world as it is, empirically and logically, is palpable in her words.
We must not forget that Nazi Germany was far from decrepit. It was a cultural and scientific behemoth, one of the most advanced societies in the world by most standards. A strong hatred of Jews and desire to eradicate them can take hold of rich and poor, educated and ignorant alike.
Fabulous talk!!! And her last answer is brilliant!!! Don't miss it!
great lecture.
Thank you. Many "Aha!" moments. Especially near the end of the Q&A: deescalation is the new appeasement.
So so wise, Einat thank so very much. This means more than you can imagine. Very perceptive, very insightful.
That was amazing.. Thank you Einat
24:50 as an israeli, former peace activist myself, i felt the same, i was not surprised by their barbarism, only by their achievements that day, but more than that i was surprised by the support they got from the majority of the world..
Thank you!❤
Glory to Israel
She is one of the Four Horsemen (actually Horsewomen!) of this whole issue: Einat Wilf, Noa Tishby, Fleur Hassan-Nahoum, and most importantly (perhaps): Natasha Hausdorff. Either listen to them or read their books for a full understanding of this unfortunate issue.
Absolute unvarnished clarity.
The late Lord Rabbi Jonathan Sacks warned the West years ago in his book “The Politics of Hope .” This would of come as no surprise to him !!!!!
The best
Thank you.
Excellent stuff. Most precise explanation I've heard so far about what's going on.
Thank you! Am Israel Chai 🇮🇱!
Another amazing exposition by Dr Wilf. A Jewish hero
Fantastic introduction speech. Applause Sirs
Very disappointed that the organizers did not turn off all the other microphones. A lot of background noise coming through the right channel
But it took 10 days for MLI to issue a statement. Shame on all of the institutions that responded after 10/8/23.
"The traditional and unceded territory of the Jewish people from time immemorial." Brilliant!!
Gaza was the test. What was the result of that test?
What do you thınk of Netanyahu supporting Hamas for years?
Like America mistakenly backed Bin Laden in the early years.
When you are surrounded by bad actors it is easy to get it wrong.
Also...what should he have done? There was no stomach in Israel for going into Gaza and going after Hamas before Oct 7.
( And needless to say, zero international support.)
We've heard that ridiculous question so many times. Have you ever been in a bad relationship? Getting to know someone and then realizing that this was not at all what you were expecting? Why is this so different?
If you're looking for Palestinian voices to amplify with interaction, exposure and donations, I wholeheartedly recommend The Third Narrative. It's a podcast by two Palestinian Israelis who are adamant on discussing the conflict in the fairest, most truth-oriented way I've ever seen.
Einat, thank you for speaking out these harsh truths. And yet, I think you should know there is such a thing as reformed Palestinianism, and I think the Third Narrative crew might pull you back from your understandable level of disbelief. In the end, we all deserve better.
it gives us hope to see that an intelligent person can SHIFT from the left to the right.
Many have and hopefully, this will continue.
Great speech by the lady. However, the man interviewing her after, needs to stop the long winded speechy questions, just get on and ask the questions. Otherwise it was great!
Brilliant analysis.
Defund unrwa and put ben gvir in jail would be positive steps forward
Einat Wilf is brilliant
Leadership material
It’s IGNORANCE , IGNORANCE , IGNORANCE !!!!
Simply more prosecutions and convictions. Not just talk
What would we do with out you Einat?!?! Thank you
The speaker refers with approval to the universal principle of self determination but ignores the fact that in 1947/1948, the Arab population formed something like 64% of the population of the former mandatory Palestine. At the beginning of the 20th century, when European migration to what became mandatory Palestine started, the Arab majority was over 90%. In 1947/1948, why did the United Nations not implement a policy of democratic self-determination? It was from this failure that all the future tragedy stemmed.
The British Mandate on the Palestine was created to give to Arab and Jews proper separated states for their nationalistic aspirations.
That's how Jordan was created for the Arabs and Palestine was split between the two existing populations.
The Arabs rejected the plan to give the Jews any territory and by doing so they rejected (and still reject) the Jews right for self-determination.
You need to understand that the Jews can't be a minority in a state because this is the reason the Jewish people have been persecuted for centuries.
The Jews without a state and an army are destined to become the scapegoat of nazi/fascist/marxist/jihadist dictators.
you: "why did the United Nations not implement a policy of democratic self-determination?"
Because as a minority in a majority Muslim country (even if somehow democratic) the Jews can't archive their own aspirations.
For instance , Israel allow unlimited immigration of Jews from around the world , this is only possible because Israel is a Jewish state.
you: "It was from this failure that all the future tragedy stemmed."
Nope, the tragedy has been created by the radical Islamic ideology that deny to any non-muslim people the right for self-determination on the land they consider "Islamic".
Alan, perhaps because of the creation of the Arab state of Jordan on 70% of the territory that was mandated for a Jewish homeland? How many “homelands” do Arabs need? After WWII about 6 new Arab states were created and today there about 23 Arab states. Jews want only one little country.
Alan, perhaps because of the creation of the Arab state of Jordan on 70% of the land mandated for the Jewish state? How many “homelands” do the Arabs need? After WWII many new Arab states were created; today there are about 23 Arab states. Is it so terrible to have one little Jewish state?
In the normal course of life one day is succeeded by the next, and the previous day recedes into the past. October 7th is different, it is a defining moment. As I see it, as of that day the concept of a two-state solution is clearly a non-sequitur for peace. October 7th is burned into the present, it will not recede. The call for cease-fire is a call to the status of October 6th, which will always become October 7th... the Groundhog Day for Israel.
It took 20-30 yers of American occupation to “denazify” Germany but Hitler was only around from 1924-1945. The Arabs have seen Jews as Dhimmis for 1300 years. It is going to be a lot harder for the Israeli to change the Arabs ideology IF EVER.
Where does the word ZION come from ???? The TORAH ! Mentioned many times in the TORAH
!!! The young Jewish are ignorant of their Judaism ! So sad !!!!
I notice most comments focus on her mode of delivery and not the content. Since the IDF bombed the Gaza strip and seeing the plight of the Palestinians on the television (in the UK) I'm not in support of Israel and after years and years of 'respecting' the Jews, feel indifferent towards them. It appalled me to think of them gaily going about their daily lives in places like Tel Aviv whilst their 'enemy' lay crushed beneath rubble.
"Gaily going about their daily lives?" Seriously?
Nothing shows more than this frase, how people know absolutely nothing about the Israelis.
The past year has been one of the worst for Israelis. The terrible massacre of oct 7 is something that will never be erased from memory, exactly like the terrible years of 140 (!) Suicide bombings within 3 years shall never be erased from the collective mind.
Your comment literally addresses not one thing in this lecture.
The plight of the Palestinians is and always has been, of their own doing. Their leaders always, always preferred choosing their own ego and so-called "Islamic peride" over and at the expense of their people's lives.
"The day the arabs will care more about their lives than about the death of jews is the day we will have peace"
Golda Meir
there are Palestinians working towards a third narrative, Amira and Ibrahim, Unapologetic: The Third Narrative...they're the new reality, Palestinians who want to talk to Jews and live together, who despise the so-called resistance of Hamas or Fatah
There are also Palestinian (Arab) members of the Israeli peace group, Standing Together.
Where does the word ZION come from ???? The TORAH ! Mentioned many times in the TORAH
!!!
Yasmine Muhammad should be on your team.
🎉🎉🎉🎉
There are orders of magnitude more Palestiniests than Palestinians.
Within 2 days, 12k views, 497 likes, 90 comments = a lot of people began listening, were unmoved by the presentation, and so left without even bothering to contribute in any way.
This content is simply bad Hasbara (propaganda) and has been recognised by viewers as such.
Personally, I’m still watching because I’m interested in the topics of propaganda, indoctrination, manipulation, cults etc. As a study from that perspective, this video is very informative.
Beg to differ, Sandy!
The Jews around the world suffer!
This issue is so acute to Jews, people need to evaluate what is going on through discussions!
Jews don't riot, they don't stab, they don't attack musl8m secret places, they don't bomb in the name of their greatest...
How you choose to react to this conversation is up to what you are looking for. Propaganda for you, food for thought for another.
@@NeverAgain316 Are you aware that a huge proportion of Jews worldwide are opposed to the State of Israel? Research ‘Jewish Dissent’, you’ll discover that many Jewish intellectuals, academics, humanitarians, legal professionals, rabbis, and others are vehemently opposed to the state of Israel. Also did you know that many Israeli youth are ‘refuseniks’, refusing military service, and ex-IDF military speaking out against Israel’s Occupation? There is so much more to this issue than what pro-Israel people are willing to admit.
A lot of big words that literally addressed non of the talking points.
Please enlighten me, what exactly in Dr. Wilf's words is false, and based on what evidence?
the bible said wait your going against the word of God so.....
Pharisean Rehoboamite tallmudder heirs of Cain are not of שָּׁמַ֖יִ.
INRIX
Thank you.. wonder how many Jews will flee to Florida..
AIPAC
Awwww…..
the hostility of Jews young or not young towards Israel in other countries comes from the hostility towards Israel of the country where they live. If these countries fully supported Israel, some Jews would also support Israel or some would be indifferent
1:10:20 😂😂😂😂😂
she so full of it
I’m already 26 minutes into her talk and understandably she’s looking at it from her perspective and she’s very good at explaining it. Fine, but but I wonder what she would say if the roles were reversed. Namely, that the Israeli’s were living in an open prison for decades and the Palestinians were keeping them there and the US gave the Palestinians all the weapons they wanted as they keep Israelis under control and under squalid dehumanized conditions. So what would Einat do under such insufferable conditions? Would she put up with it or fight by creating a covert rag tag army to defeat the Palestinians? No one deserves to be treated in dehumanizing ways and while Hamas’s attacks are downright evil, and not to justify their behavior, but it’s safe to say that what they did was a desperate attempts to fight decades of oppression by the Israeli government. What Hamas did was evil but so is being forced to live in an open prison by the Israeli government all the while western governments turn a blind eye, especially the United States. Rest assured, we are setting ourselves up for another 911. And I fear it’s going to be far worse.
26-minutes of not listening.
She is talking about 1947 before Israel was established, before Gaza, no IDF, before settlements,..., all the reasons you mentioned did not exist.
The Arabs, later known as "Palestinians", did not agree for the Jewish people to have a state. They did not agree that Jewish people will have sovereignty. So that's the real reason for the conflict.
Now, about Gaza. Israel pulled out if Gaza in 2005. Not a single settlement or IDF soldier.
Gaza people, with the aid they got throughout the years ,billions of dollars, they could build Gaza like Singapore, with beach resorts (Gaza has a beautiful beach), restaurants, platter the streets in gold, you name it... and BTW Israel: we would love to assist them with development and co-operation.
What did they do?
Buried all the cement in the underground, invested in buying weapons and making rockets, making Gaza the biggest terrorist-base in the world.
@@retrobike3859 Why did Gaza become the biggest terrorist-base in the world? What was their underlying motivation?
@@GnosisMan50 Hamas turned Gaza into a prison. Their underlying motivation: Anti-Semitism.
@GnosisMan50
"From water to water, the land shall be Arab"
That is the exact original frase in Arabic of what is today known as "from river to river"
That frase encapsulates the motivation and the reason for all the bad decision making done by Palestinian Arabs, forever.
Always, the end goal was to turn back to the old days of glory - the Islamic Caliphate.
Jews are simply in the way.
Giving advice whilst living on stolen land.😂
The Jews did not steal land.
With your logic everybody’s ancestors stole the land they are living on.
Where did your ancestors live 100, 1000, 10.000 years ago and whose land did they steal when they moved? You better return the stolen land 🤗
If you think that this conflict is territorial, you are delusional
You did not listen and are fare from facts and reality!
@@nancyfriedberg9516 of course it is! You’re deflecting
Obnoxious. Nothing less.
Yourself?
@@wizzyno1566 What's the matter? Can't read?
You mean the October 7th genocidal invasion of Israel by Hamas?
Respect from belgium ❤️
Brilliant! As usual!