Always a delight to listen to Dr. Scheuftan. Such wit, candour and pragmatism. Whether one agrees or disagrees with him, there is something to take away from his discourse. Thank you.
I’ve listened to many podcast, TH-cam videos, and read articles since 10/07. This man by far has provided the most insightful and educational explanation of the conflict by far
Early on you wrote that Israel, "physically kicked out the indigenous population & stole their homes," & this is a lie. The ancestors of "Palestinians" were Arabs who believed the leaders of 5 Arab nations who attacked Israel in 1948. The leaders said, "We will win & you can move back after we win.". Those leaders were wrong. They lost. The Arabs who didn't run away have descendents who are Israeli citizens w good educations, medical benefits, voting rights, elected members in the Knesset. Israeli Muslims Arabs aren't required to serve in the IDF & as time goes on more & more volunteer. Fact; Israel ranked #5 in the World Happiness Report, & Israeli Muslims Arabs, 20% of the Israeli population, were part of the survey. The highest ranking Arabic nations are those swimming in oil money, & they are in the 20s in the world happiness Report. The rest of the region is around 100, with Palestinians at #103. Being filled w hate makes a people unhappy. Israeli Muslims are the happiest Muslim community in the region. Hamas expected them to fight Israel on Oct 7, & they did not. Use some real history. Those who fled lost their homes to war, not to theft. And try to use your brains.
@@dt6822 you seem to don’t know most arabs left israel asked by arab leaders. And the land was actually purchased, by arab leaders, who forced arab owners to give it to them, so they could sell it to zionists, in order to rise the price as they wanted, at the same time as speaking against jewish colonialism. The so called “exile” happened 1) purely for safety reasons 2) by arab orders, in order to strike the attack to definitely destroy Israel in 1948 These are historical facts If you like talking about occupation and colonialism, tell me what are muslims doing in Europe, making ghetto boroughs with sharia law, who act de facto as independent enclaves, forcing locals to flee through violence, and eventually telling them that is a no-go zone. Do we europeans have the right to slaughter them all? I’m interested.
@@dt6822Is this from a book of fiction...Koran 5:20-21? I know you're allergic to the truth. Have fun with your lies. What dies without lies? I.S.L.A.M
So after this interview, we can look forward to no lasting solution beyond the solution of being strong and ready to fight and domestically, rejection of extremes.
@@offroadoffshore153 there you go with the moral equivalence. The evidence is see the trajectory of the two groups over the last century. Both started off poor and destitute in the case of the Israelis
Dr. Scheuftan, you are amazing! Defending your statement about the danger of pluralism without limits, you cited the example of the cannibal joining the dinner party. When you said, "No, when I go to dinner, I want to know if I'm on the guest list, or on the menu," I exploded in laughter! How perfectly expressed! I so wish that I could have been one of your students! I agree, don't go out to dinner with the Palestinians or the Iranians! If you do, you'll be on the menu!
Dr Scheuftan explains the Israeli/Palestinian conflict in a realistic detail. With the present mindset of the Palestinians there will never be a peaceful solution to the coflict.
Loved the "dinner with a cannibal" example. People who don't understand that too much of good thing can be terrible are burying their heads in the sand. Even drinking too much water can kill a person.
@@גליתאנגור-ש1צ sometimes there are things that are both funny and sad for example it's both funny and sad to make fun of suicide bombers because it's also tragic and evil what they are doing but funny if you make fun of these types of people .
I'd like to ask Dan a question. It's apparent that there is growing unrest amongst the Iranian population. They would love to have a secular government and become the economic power they are capable of. So what does Dan think would happen if there were a counter-revolution in Iran and a moderate government took power, one that doesn't support funding Hezbollah or Hamas or any other terror groups? And what do you think the chances of that happening are? Persia has a long history of supporting the Jews. The one change that would make all the difference is if the mullahs are removed from power.
I'm not dan and I am not an expert on geopolitics (but find it's interesting) I think when (not if , it's a question of when imo) it would happen that would change the entire picture and Israel should officially support a movement like that even if it's just by sharing intelegance with them , or recognize them diplomatically ( of course there are many other ways we could work together for a shared goal) . I think that if someone is going to be the forefront to push back islamism is going to be the persians from the shia side , and maybe some of the gulf countries from the sunni side and it would be better for everyone but it's also could potentially lead to alot of bloodshed but it's better for the long run and the bloodshed is already happening in Iran , in israel and in the entire region . so the change is necessery . and if a different way could be found where only the blood of the bad guys is spilled it's even better but realistically it's usually not the case unfortenatly ,I hope I can be proven wrong so far it's seems that the good guys keep shooting themselves in the legs and assisting the bad guys instead of anhialiting them , I hope the persians wouldn't do the same mistakes the west and israel keeps doing for decades now . and yes war is bad I aknowledge that but sometimes the alternative is much worse. sometimes if you want to de-escalte you will get an october 7th or in the case of Iran if you want more freedom , you will get even less for assisting the wrong people . it's very similar to the case of the soviet union with the tzar only here instead of the communists getting in power the communists where used by the islamists to get in power . but any way I'd wish to some day being able to visit iran once it's regime is changed to something better than the garbage of a terroristic regime they are having right now (like a cancer that keeps on growing and destroying the country that needed to be removed).
This isn’t PM Netanyahu vs Gaza-this is a struggle between regional and global tyrannical forces as we witnessed in WW2. The US press is so narrow in its focus currently-painting a legally elected PM from a liberal democracy who has far less internal power as PM then do US presidents for example -as a tyrant akin to Sadem Hussein or the Ayatollah of Iran just to scapegoat him as somehow responsible for Oct 7 and somehow perpetuating “war crimes” etc when the war criminals are Hamas and their bosses Iran and Qatar. Putin is deeply involved in Oct 7 as well-why? Because it’s an existential global crisis of tyranny vs liberal democracy being played out -Gaza and Hamas are a microcosm.
if anything bibi is a spineless coward rather than a tyrant . and they would say the same about any israeli leader it's not matter if it's bibi or anyone else.
What else can we expect from Barbaric fundamentalists, other than to embed themselves amongst the civilian population and blame Israel for their strategy and martyrdom. So glad you accentuate that there has to be limits in all fields of liberalism, pluralism etc. A regional M.E. war including all the Islamic states would lead to a Global Abattoir. The Region needs a democratic Israel, the response of our young Israelis to Oct 7th, they stepped up with courage and bravery, true warriors. We can count on our people ( Yes the blunder of the Government/intelligence/IDf failing our State and people hasn't been addressed YET) Nonetheless this generation took up their arms and are giving their best fight. I am so proud and have so much respect for our younger generation of women and men. God Bless the children of Israel.
Where do you think Israeli soldiers, UK soldiers, US soldiers, Australian soldiers and all other soldiers live, on Mars maybe? Every house in Israel with people aged 18-55 harbours soldiers hiding in the civilian population.
It takes bravery to be a soldier but bombing a population that has no army, no Air Force and no air defense is not a brave strategy. In Gaza, Dahiya and the West Bank the IDF has fought the people as a whole instead of engaging the militants where they are. In relative terms this is a cowardly strategy.
@@endertotem4354you obviously didn't hear a word of this interview. He said (I don't quote exactly) : if you are barbarians who commit the most atrocious crimes by your neighbours and then retreat behind the bodies of your own civilians, you have already won because you have idiots on your side who would go to any extent to forbid the victims to defend themselves, all this in the name of "humanity"" In the book of Proverbs: "Whoever is merciful to the cruel, will be cruel to the innocent" Why didn't you object to the carpet bombing of Raqqa and Mosul that caused 70 000 deaths among the "innocent civilians" of Daesh. Daesh and Hamas have the same ideology and the same goals: world Caliphate, extermination of the world Jewry. Their only difference is their immediate target: Europe and regional for Isis, Israel for Hamas. I understand your indignation, killing Js is not such a big deal after all, Christianity and Islam have been doing it since they have detached themselves from their Judaic origins.
one of the best podcast this channel ever had, probably their most watched. scheuftan is amazingly coherent, something we deeply need. (change the "if" in the title to "of")
The only humane solution for the “Palestinian” Arabs is their Right of Return to any of the 22 Arab countries. Israel should assist them financially and logistically.
Did you know that more Jews were expelled from Arab nations than Palestinian Arabs who left Israel? "In total, over 850,000 Jews were forced to leave the Arab countries, in a process of expulsion and exodus which continued through the 1970's." The Arabs were invited to form a separate state in Palestine and they rejected the two-state solution. the Arabs started a war to "throw all the Jews into the sea". As a result: "In the 1948 Palestine war, more than 700,000 Palestinian Arabs - about half of Mandatory Palestine's predominantly Arab population - were expelled or fled from their homes, at first by Zionist paramilitaries, and after the establishment of Israel, by its military."
"Since 1948, we have been demanding the return of the refugees to their homes. But we ourselves are the ones who encouraged them to leave. Only a few months separated our call for them to leave and our appeal to the United Nations to resolve on their return." - Khaled al-Azm, Syrian Prime Minister, 1948-1949 "The Arab exodus from other villages was not caused by the actual battle, but by the exaggerated description spread by Arab leaders to incite them to fight the Jews." - Yunes Ahmad Assad, Palestinian refugee as told to a Jordanian newspaper in 1953. As an israeli arab i concur. We live near the Jordanian border. Mt grandfather was instructed to leave his home by the jordanian army, my grandad told them to get "f****d" and stayed. AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE STILL HERE AND OTHER ARABS ARE NOT. @rafewheadon1963 May 2024
Zahir Muhsein was a Palestinian leader of the pro-Syria As-Sa'iqa Ba'athist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization between 1971 and 1979. In an interview with Trouw Magazine, 31. March 1977 he stated....."The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new tool to continue the fight against Israel and for Arab unity. So where are the geographical roots of the so called Palestinians??????? Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012. Stated..........we all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians. The so called Palestinians are not even from Palestine!!!!!!!!!!
Listening to Prof. Shueftan it is like diving into a sea of culture, knowledge, international politics, history, diplomacy, long life national and international political experience and much more into one shot. All dressed with moderation and good common sense. 👏🏻 thanks for this really outstanding 45 minutes video.
The paradox of tolerance states that if a society's practice of tolerance is inclusive of the intolerant, intolerance will ultimately dominate, eliminating the tolerant and the practice of tolerance with them. Karl Popper describes the paradox as arising from the fact that, in order to maintain a tolerant society, the society must retain the right to be intolerant of intolerance.
This is high academic level analysis . One of the best takes I’ve ever heard . It’s a shame no one invites the top Israeli professors for interviews abroad , only Israeli populists and spoke people get invited to debates and interviews while pro palestinians get their professors everywhere (some of whom phd is based on Hamas stats but nvm)
What a clear and realistic analysis of the current situation here in Israel and in the world. Dan Schueftan has very perceptive things to say, among them: "Everything good comes from the middle of the political spectrum".
Look into volunteers for israel, they offer subsidized trips and you can volunteer on a kibbutz or army base or a variety of other options, I worked in a rubber boot factory in kibbutz dafna near the Lebanese border in 1988 and got a cheap trip in my early twenties. Warning, it's country remote living and some drudgery work if you're in search of the glamor and beaches of tel Aviv skip it and save your money, there's other ways to get there without paying as a tourist, and the tourism industry is struggling so I bet prices are way down, good luck it's definitely memorable.
@@fredtrainer7837 he obviously has no regard for Western values/civilization. Or probably even for any values. But he will use those things as weapons against Western nations. The lengths he goes to in accommodating the Iranian regime is astounding.
"in every Saddam Hussein there is a little Thomas Jefferson trying to come out only he had a difficult childhood and we must give him humanitarian aid..." 😂 Spot on!!!
Loved the show! What would Dr Shuefta say about Dr Kedar's insistance that only by allowing the Gaza, Samaria and Jjudea Arab tribes to rule as they once did, can there be a tolerable peace, with no terrorism towsards Israel. Return them to their ancient tribes and they will govern sensibly, because each tribal leader will have control. The central political power is what is destroying any hopes of peace. Distribute the central power among the tribal authroities and the area can experience normalization.
Dan is brilliant. One can understand now that like Israel hindus can never leave in peace with the Muslims because indian Muslims have the same leadership, ie, MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD
I hoped that the discussion would be over a much more intriguing point. How could it happen that a sophisticated defense system could be blind to what ended happening in 10/7? How was Hamas able to completely shock the fundaments of Israeli society? And why the people that let this happen are still in power?
No question that Dan Scheuftan is very insightful with his analysis about the geopolitical situation regarding the destructive nature of progressivism and the folly of international institutions, the UN and its branches. However, when he says that there is no fundamental issue that split the Israeli part (non Haredim nor Arabs) of our society, he can't be more wrong. How can he say that the Israeli High Court rule over the Knesset is not a major problem that split the Israeli society. I speculate that he comes from the secular elite that is fine with the current situation of non-democratic High Court rule.
I respect a lot of what is said here, but he lost me when he compared the Muslim Brotherhood to the Israeli political party of Shas, and then said "is unbelievably dangerous". Be extremely careful when comparing, because it will probably be misunderstood...
19:57 Ben Gvir and Smotrich represent a large faction of Israelis, Not ultra-orthdox or Arabs, what is your reason for excluding so many good, working, army-serving people?
Problem: Shueftan has a soft spot for Abbas, wants a two state solution but does not give his formula for achieving that goal. Kedar has a superior analytical mind, in my opinion...so it goes.
A country which manages its constitution through shared, informal understanding and commitment rather than in a fixed theoretical form is able to manage change and development without breaking the theoretical model.
kind of do, it's an ongoing process, it's built in chapters in Israel.. we call them "Fundamental Rights", these are laws with a super legal status. there's one about the authorities of the parliament, one about courts. one about human dignity and liberty. I believe it's what Americans call amendments, just different name. the ideas and purpose of Israel are generally mentioned in the declaration of independence. check it out.
About the Court in the Hague: Maybe we are at the end of this terrible period where the Progressives have prostituted Liberalism by taking it too far...
Everything he said was spot-on and brilliant--but I'm afraid I have to disagree with Dr. Shueftan's attempt to try to compare Israel's Shas party to the Muslim Brotherhood. Besides both being deeply religious (each in their own way), I don't see many other similarities between them.
From Phoenix, AZ . Your words make the most Truth , Clarity and Intelligence that I’ve heard , since 10-7 !!!
I love Dr. Scheuftan. He “suffers no fools,” and there is no bullsh--t.
exactly 👍
He suffers you.😂
Always a delight to listen to Dr. Scheuftan. Such wit, candour and pragmatism. Whether one agrees or disagrees with him, there is something to take away from his discourse. Thank you.
Yes,Zioniste Propaganda…
He is a hypocrite. One one hand he tirelessly lectures on democracy. On the other hand he laments against Obama on him undermining Mubarak of Egypt.
Bullshit points
@@mike58greenberg Bullshit people in bullshit country talking bullshit…Chalom Chalom…
@@mike58greenbergIgnorant, content-free spam: the best an illiterate apologist for Palestinian terrorism can ever come up with.
I’ve listened to many podcast, TH-cam videos, and read articles since 10/07. This man by far has provided the most insightful and educational explanation of the conflict by far
Mordechai Kedar is good too.
Agree. Clarity and incisive insight
Early on you wrote that Israel, "physically kicked out the indigenous population & stole their homes," & this is a lie.
The ancestors of "Palestinians" were Arabs who believed the leaders of 5 Arab nations who attacked Israel in 1948. The leaders said, "We will win & you can move back after we win.". Those leaders were wrong. They lost.
The Arabs who didn't run away have descendents who are Israeli citizens w good educations, medical benefits, voting rights, elected members in the Knesset.
Israeli Muslims Arabs aren't required to serve in the IDF & as time goes on more & more volunteer.
Fact; Israel ranked #5 in the World Happiness Report, & Israeli Muslims Arabs, 20% of the Israeli population, were part of the survey.
The highest ranking Arabic nations are those swimming in oil money, & they are in the 20s in the world happiness Report. The rest of the region is around 100, with Palestinians at #103.
Being filled w hate makes a people unhappy.
Israeli Muslims are the happiest Muslim community in the region.
Hamas expected them to fight Israel on Oct 7, & they did not.
Use some real history. Those who fled lost their homes to war, not to theft.
And try to use your brains.
@@dt6822 you seem to don’t know most arabs left israel asked by arab leaders. And the land was actually purchased, by arab leaders, who forced arab owners to give it to them, so they could sell it to zionists, in order to rise the price as they wanted, at the same time as speaking against jewish colonialism.
The so called “exile” happened
1) purely for safety reasons
2) by arab orders, in order to strike the attack to definitely destroy Israel in 1948
These are historical facts
If you like talking about occupation and colonialism, tell me what are muslims doing in Europe, making ghetto boroughs with sharia law, who act de facto as independent enclaves, forcing locals to flee through violence, and eventually telling them that is a no-go zone. Do we europeans have the right to slaughter them all? I’m interested.
@@dt6822Is this from a book of fiction...Koran 5:20-21?
I know you're allergic to the truth. Have fun with your lies. What dies without lies? I.S.L.A.M
What a smart Man he is!
I've listened to him before and he is so intelligent and right on the mark and he doesn't candy coat anything and that is refreshing
So after this interview, we can look forward to no lasting solution beyond the solution of being strong and ready to fight and domestically, rejection of extremes.
That was so also before this interview 😊
Until one group stops wanting to get rid of the other then that is the likely outcome. Yes.
Correct peace through the projection of force
@@johndoe-vc1weBoth groups want the same of the other.
@@offroadoffshore153 there you go with the moral equivalence. The evidence is see the trajectory of the two groups over the last century. Both started off poor and destitute in the case of the Israelis
Shueftan is the voice of common sense. Put another way, he is honest - and right!
Dr. Scheuftan, you are amazing! Defending your statement about the danger of pluralism without limits, you cited the example of the cannibal joining the dinner party. When you said, "No, when I go to dinner, I want to know if I'm on the guest list, or on the menu," I exploded in laughter! How perfectly expressed! I so wish that I could have been one of your students!
I agree, don't go out to dinner with the Palestinians or the Iranians! If you do, you'll be on the menu!
I completely agree with you on all points!
Dr Scheuftan explains the Israeli/Palestinian conflict in a realistic detail. With the present mindset of the Palestinians there will never be a peaceful solution to the coflict.
He has the same views as the British imperialists, when the natives revolt it's because they are too backward and uncivilized.
Let me correct you, it is Israel at fault for the last 76 years.,
How about the mindstet of israeli zionist jew who thinks he has the right to kick out palestinians out of their properties. Very appealing mindset
Read Likud's manifesto from 1977.
It’s ALL projection
This guy is brilliant!!
Loved the "dinner with a cannibal" example. People who don't understand that too much of good thing can be terrible are burying their heads in the sand. Even drinking too much water can kill a person.
the idea that america needs a '2 state solution' is brilliant ... in a very funny and serious way ..
Actually it's sad and disturbing ( maybe you meant the same thing😊)
@@גליתאנגור-ש1צ
sometimes there are things that are both funny and sad
for example it's both funny and sad to make fun of suicide bombers
because it's also tragic and evil what they are doing but funny if you make fun of these types of people .
Very smart guy
Thank you so much! I've been running out of Dr. Dan content and needed this like a shot of morphine.
Haha, I've been searching since March and then today it appears in my feed 😊
Same for me! 😊
Dan Schueftan, brilliant as always.
I'd like to ask Dan a question. It's apparent that there is growing unrest amongst the Iranian population. They would love to have a secular government and become the economic power they are capable of. So what does Dan think would happen if there were a counter-revolution in Iran and a moderate government took power, one that doesn't support funding Hezbollah or Hamas or any other terror groups? And what do you think the chances of that happening are? Persia has a long history of supporting the Jews. The one change that would make all the difference is if the mullahs are removed from power.
I'm not dan and I am not an expert on geopolitics (but find it's interesting)
I think when (not if , it's a question of when imo) it would happen that would change the entire picture and Israel should officially support a movement like that even if it's just by
sharing intelegance with them , or recognize them diplomatically ( of course there are many other ways we could work together for a shared goal)
.
I think that if someone is going to be the forefront to push back islamism is going to be the persians from the shia side , and maybe some of the gulf countries from the sunni side
and it would be better for everyone
but it's also could potentially lead to alot of bloodshed but it's better for the long run and the bloodshed is already happening in Iran , in israel and in the entire region .
so the change is necessery .
and if a different way could be found where only the blood of the bad guys is spilled it's even better but realistically it's usually not the case unfortenatly ,I hope I can be proven wrong
so far it's seems that the good guys keep shooting themselves in the legs and assisting the bad guys instead of anhialiting them , I hope the persians wouldn't do the same mistakes the west and israel keeps doing for decades now .
and yes war is bad I aknowledge that but sometimes the alternative is much worse.
sometimes if you want to de-escalte you will get an october 7th
or in the case of Iran
if you want more freedom , you will get even less for assisting the wrong people .
it's very similar to the case of the soviet union with the tzar
only here instead of the communists getting in power
the communists where used by the islamists to get in power .
but any way I'd wish to some day being able to visit iran once it's regime is changed to something better than the garbage of a terroristic regime
they are having right now (like a cancer that keeps on growing and destroying the country that needed to be removed).
...muslims in general have a long history of supporting other religions...but i dare say that fact won't fit with your narrative...
@@nanticnaffarpic Tell that to the Coptics in Egypt, or the Jews anywhere.
Excellent!
This isn’t PM Netanyahu vs Gaza-this is a struggle between regional and global tyrannical forces as we witnessed in WW2.
The US press is so narrow in its focus currently-painting a legally elected PM from a liberal democracy who has far less internal power as PM then do US presidents for example -as a tyrant akin to Sadem Hussein or the Ayatollah of Iran just to scapegoat him as somehow responsible for Oct 7 and somehow perpetuating “war crimes” etc when the war criminals are Hamas and their bosses Iran and Qatar.
Putin is deeply involved in Oct 7 as well-why?
Because it’s an existential global crisis of tyranny vs liberal democracy being played out -Gaza and Hamas are a microcosm.
Bibi failed in open the west leaders eye
Clash of civilisations by Samuel Huntington?
Netanyahu is simply the avatar for their antisemitic sentiment. It's not about a particular person. They hate Israel as such.
if anything bibi is a spineless coward rather than a tyrant .
and they would say the same about any israeli leader it's not matter if it's bibi or anyone else.
...wow!...what planet are you living on?...you've been lied to all your life if you believe any of what you put in your comment...
The Palestinians have rejected a two-state solution over and over again. What is the point?
the two states solution are jordan and egypt .
two states
solution
Smart
What else can we expect from Barbaric fundamentalists, other than to embed themselves amongst the civilian population and blame Israel for their strategy and martyrdom. So glad you accentuate that there has to be limits in all fields of liberalism, pluralism etc. A regional M.E. war including all the Islamic states would lead to a Global Abattoir. The Region needs a democratic Israel, the response of our young Israelis to Oct 7th, they stepped up with courage and bravery, true warriors. We can count on our people ( Yes the blunder of the Government/intelligence/IDf failing our State and people hasn't been addressed YET) Nonetheless this generation took up their arms and are giving their best fight. I am so proud and have so much respect for our younger generation of women and men. God Bless the children of Israel.
Where do you think Israeli soldiers, UK soldiers, US soldiers, Australian soldiers and all other soldiers live, on Mars maybe? Every house in Israel with people aged 18-55 harbours soldiers hiding in the civilian population.
It takes bravery to be a soldier but bombing a population that has no army, no Air Force and no air defense is not a brave strategy. In Gaza, Dahiya and the West Bank the IDF has fought the people as a whole instead of engaging the militants where they are. In relative terms this is a cowardly strategy.
There's no need for moral blackmail, no-one needs to apologise for actions and activities that began with barbarian culture.
@@endertotem4354you obviously didn't hear a word of this interview.
He said (I don't quote exactly) : if you are barbarians who commit the most atrocious crimes by your neighbours and then retreat behind the bodies of your own civilians, you have already won because you have idiots on your side who would go to any extent to forbid the victims to defend themselves, all this in the name of "humanity""
In the book of Proverbs: "Whoever is merciful to the cruel, will be cruel to the innocent"
Why didn't you object to the carpet bombing of Raqqa and Mosul that caused 70 000 deaths among the "innocent civilians" of Daesh.
Daesh and Hamas have the same ideology and the same goals: world Caliphate, extermination of the world Jewry.
Their only difference is their immediate target: Europe and regional for Isis, Israel for Hamas.
I understand your indignation, killing Js is not such a big deal after all, Christianity and Islam have been doing it since they have detached themselves from their Judaic origins.
I am so glad that smart Israelis are increasingly leaving and going back to where they came from in the west. Enjoy.
As an Israeli-American, this pod was a an enlightening and delightful listen. Thanks for bringing Dr. Schueftan
one of the best podcast this channel ever had, probably their most watched. scheuftan is amazingly coherent, something we deeply need.
(change the "if" in the title to "of")
תודה רבה!!❤
Thank you for this prophet... God bless you
The only humane solution for the “Palestinian” Arabs is their Right of Return to any of the 22 Arab countries. Israel should assist them financially and logistically.
Arab/muslim nations should assist them financially to return.
Thank you for tell the truth… that is why all the world hates you.
Did you know that more Jews were expelled from Arab nations than Palestinian Arabs who left Israel?
"In total, over 850,000 Jews were forced to leave the Arab countries, in a process of expulsion and exodus which continued through the 1970's."
The Arabs were invited to form a separate state in Palestine and they rejected the two-state solution.
the Arabs started a war to "throw all the Jews into the sea".
As a result:
"In the 1948 Palestine war, more than 700,000 Palestinian Arabs - about half of Mandatory Palestine's predominantly Arab population - were expelled or fled from their homes, at first by Zionist paramilitaries, and after the establishment of Israel, by its military."
"Since 1948, we have been demanding the return of the refugees to their homes. But we ourselves are the ones who encouraged them to leave. Only a few months separated our call for them to leave and our appeal to the United Nations to resolve on their return." - Khaled al-Azm, Syrian Prime Minister, 1948-1949
"The Arab exodus from other villages was not caused by the actual battle, but by the exaggerated description spread by Arab leaders to incite them to fight the Jews." - Yunes Ahmad Assad, Palestinian refugee as told to a Jordanian newspaper in 1953.
As an israeli arab i concur. We live near the Jordanian border. Mt grandfather was instructed to leave his home by the jordanian army, my grandad told them to get "f****d" and stayed. AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE STILL HERE AND OTHER ARABS ARE NOT. @rafewheadon1963 May 2024
Zahir Muhsein was a Palestinian leader of the pro-Syria As-Sa'iqa Ba'athist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization between 1971 and 1979.
In an interview with Trouw Magazine, 31. March 1977 he stated....."The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new tool to continue the fight against Israel and for Arab unity.
So where are the geographical roots of the so called Palestinians???????
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012. Stated..........we all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians.
The so called Palestinians are not even from Palestine!!!!!!!!!!
I like this man , Dr. Scheuftan, very very interistning to listen .❤ thank you very much sir .
Listening to Prof. Shueftan it is like diving into a sea of culture, knowledge, international politics, history, diplomacy, long life national and international political experience and much more into one shot. All dressed with moderation and good common sense. 👏🏻 thanks for this really outstanding 45 minutes video.
Mr Shueftan is the most brilliant, engaging speaker.
The paradox of tolerance states that if a society's practice of tolerance is inclusive of the intolerant, intolerance will ultimately dominate, eliminating the tolerant and the practice of tolerance with them. Karl Popper describes the paradox as arising from the fact that, in order to maintain a tolerant society, the society must retain the right to be intolerant of intolerance.
don't tolerate the intolerants.
Love this! Sanity. And "if you're looking for solutions goto crossword puzzles!" OMG.
Speak the truth speak it loud and speak it often.
Thank you sir.
This is sense for the senseless that's so evident in the world today, one of the best interviews I've ever seen
@@charlenebotha7164 Don't believe that propaganda!
"In every Saddam Hussein there is a little Thomas Jefferson who is trying to come to light only had a difficult childhood..." 😅😢😐
Slight slight mistake in the title "of" not "if" 🖖🖖(I don't speak any Hebrew, so you're doing better than I)
Please, please… the Gov… in Israel…. LISTEN!!!! to this man!!!! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
he has been advising the govts for decades
@@subchan6595 ...that explains why israel is constantly at war with its neighbours...
This is high academic level analysis . One of the best takes I’ve ever heard . It’s a shame no one invites the top Israeli professors for interviews abroad , only Israeli populists and spoke people get invited to debates and interviews while pro palestinians get their professors everywhere (some of whom phd is based on Hamas stats but nvm)
😂😂😂😂 these clowns are paranoid and delusional
This man is on target as always!
Great talk
Dr. Dan, as always, smart, accurate, and funny too.
Very interesting discussion. Thanks!
Dr. Dqn is the best.
Brilliant!
Ido I can finally see you on TH-cam fantastic interview. Eitan from Australia
A VERY sensible man...
What a clear and realistic analysis of the current situation here in Israel and in the world. Dan Schueftan has very perceptive things to say, among them: "Everything good comes from the middle of the political spectrum".
Excellent, thank you. I'velearned so much about this conflict.
Schueftan is the best. Please have him again.
I agree the arabs need israel. I hope i can travel to tel aviv in my lifetime. Not an easy thing to hope for.
Look into volunteers for israel, they offer subsidized trips and you can volunteer on a kibbutz or army base or a variety of other options, I worked in a rubber boot factory in kibbutz dafna near the Lebanese border in 1988 and got a cheap trip in my early twenties.
Warning, it's country remote living and some drudgery work if you're in search of the glamor and beaches of tel Aviv skip it and save your money, there's other ways to get there without paying as a tourist, and the tourism industry is struggling so I bet prices are way down, good luck it's definitely memorable.
where are you from?
Thank you 🙏 This was great.
I want to know if I am on the guest list or on the menu.
his best catchphrase.
and a briliant analogy .
sometimes in order to have freedom you also need to put some limits
like yin and yang.
that was halarious
Very enlightening. I thoroughly enjoyed this man’s thinking.
All the respect. He put it right on.
Brilliant analysis
Please give me the name of every book this brilliant man wrote,I need them all
Great interview. Thank you.
He speaks the truth and practical
Excellent! What Dr. Schueftan says is oh-so true! Spot on!
Thank you, a tour de force. This is the antidote against that weasel Mearsheimer that the non-Iran aligned world needed.
Don’t get how Mearsheimer ends up as a weasel in anybody’s book 🤔
@@fredtrainer7837 he obviously has no regard for Western values/civilization. Or probably even for any values. But he will use those things as weapons against Western nations. The lengths he goes to in accommodating the Iranian regime is astounding.
@@fredtrainer7837 I do
Unbelievable. Best I have listened to in a long while
"in every Saddam Hussein there is a little Thomas Jefferson trying to come out only he had a difficult childhood and we must give him humanitarian aid..." 😂 Spot on!!!
Dan is a genius.
This professor has an insight unlike anyone else I've ever listened to. He wasn't born yesterday
First the barbarians come for the jews. Then they come for the christians. Then they come for -- fill in the blanks.
Amen to your brilliant comment.
First we come for the Saturday people, then we come for the Sunday people
joanr3189. then Israelis become the barbarians and go after Palestinians and the world watches.
They come for everyone else
Hindus 😂😂😂
This man! Common sense in human form....bravo 👏👏
Loved the show! What would Dr Shuefta say about Dr Kedar's insistance that only by allowing the Gaza, Samaria and Jjudea Arab tribes to rule as they once did, can there be a tolerable peace, with no terrorism towsards Israel. Return them to their ancient tribes and they will govern sensibly, because each tribal leader will have control. The central political power is what is destroying any hopes of peace. Distribute the central power among the tribal authroities and the area can experience normalization.
Dan is brilliant. One can understand now that like Israel hindus can never leave in peace with the Muslims because indian Muslims have the same leadership, ie, MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD
Live in peace, not leave in peace….i hope
The problem we have in UK is that most of the population is very naive and unwordly
"I'd like to know if I'm on the guest list or on the menu..." 😂😂😂
Thoroughly enjoyable discussion; super guest!
The dinner analogy is perfect!
It sums it all.
Well said! ❤🙏
Absolutely Dan Scheuftan I totally agree with you, people dont want to know truth
“ fake it until we change it”! Perfect!!!
Thank you and God bless
I hoped that the discussion would be over a much more intriguing point. How could it happen that a sophisticated defense system could be blind to what ended happening in 10/7? How was Hamas able to completely shock the fundaments of Israeli society? And why the people that let this happen are still in power?
Finally realistic and intelligent conversation
Voice of reason!!!! How rare nowadays!!!! Love Dr. Scheuftan!
What clear sense. Thank you
No question that Dan Scheuftan is very insightful with his analysis about the geopolitical situation regarding the destructive nature of progressivism and the folly of international institutions, the UN and its branches. However, when he says that there is no fundamental issue that split the Israeli part (non Haredim nor Arabs) of our society, he can't be more wrong. How can he say that the Israeli High Court rule over the Knesset is not a major problem that split the Israeli society. I speculate that he comes from the secular elite that is fine with the current situation of non-democratic High Court rule.
Sane, logical assessment of today's reality. One comment - there are many centrist in USA as well, but they are the quiet ones.
This was amazing but the ending was rushed. What are his steps to proceed?
The hard ttuth about the ME
I respect a lot of what is said here, but he lost me when he compared the Muslim Brotherhood to the Israeli political party of Shas, and then said "is unbelievably dangerous". Be extremely careful when comparing, because it will probably be misunderstood...
19:57 Ben Gvir and Smotrich represent a large faction of Israelis, Not ultra-orthdox or Arabs, what is your reason for excluding so many good, working, army-serving people?
Excellent analysis
Excellent.
Brilliant. Engaging. Prophetic. - Dan Schueftan gives us hope that Israeli is not going anywhere anytime soon!
Ever since man had a mouth and ears there have been those who proclaim to have “figured it all out”.
Dan Shueftan has an incredibly sharp mind and an incredible analysis.
Yes, but a one sided Zionist view! Dehumanization of the enemy is part of this ideology!
There is Always balance , even between ; pluralism and kaos .
An outstanding example of clear thinking
GLORY TO ISREAL
Problem: Shueftan has a soft spot for Abbas, wants a two state solution but does not give his formula for achieving that goal. Kedar has a superior analytical mind, in my opinion...so it goes.
Love this guy, keeping it real.
What an inteligent man.i could listen to him for hours.thank you doctor
Why can’t Israel have a written and ratified Constitution?
They like to keep their options open. But the body of basic laws they have provides a decent framework for one anyway.
A country which manages its constitution through shared, informal understanding and commitment rather than in a fixed theoretical form is able to manage change and development without breaking the theoretical model.
kind of do, it's an ongoing process, it's built in chapters in Israel.. we call them "Fundamental Rights", these are laws with a super legal status.
there's one about the authorities of the parliament, one about courts. one about human dignity and liberty. I believe it's what Americans call amendments, just different name.
the ideas and purpose of Israel are generally mentioned in the declaration of independence. check it out.
About the Court in the Hague: Maybe we are at the end of this terrible period where the Progressives have prostituted Liberalism by taking it too far...
Ignorance is a darkness greater in power than the light of knowledge. A tiny few of the general population understand every word in this interview.
Everything he said was spot-on and brilliant--but I'm afraid I have to disagree with Dr. Shueftan's attempt to try to compare Israel's Shas party to the Muslim Brotherhood. Besides both being deeply religious (each in their own way), I don't see many other similarities between them.
Dr. Shueftan is really kind of hilarious today! He doesn't mince words 😂