This law was enacted in year 2022 when PN was ruling the country. It was some bersatu leaders who wanted the loopholes to exist in the law at that time. Maybe they entertained the idea that there will be PH representatives who will defect to PN. In years 2020 and 2021, there were a numbers of disloyal PH representatives who defected. But come year 2023 and 2024, defections were from PN, and not to PN for the obvious reasons.
Tindakan PPBM ke atas 6 MP mereka boleh di bawa ke mahkamah krn mempunyai niat jahat cuba menjatuhkn kredibiliti 6 wakil rakyatnya yg telah menukar sokongan kpd kerajaan. Tindakan 6 wakil rakyat tersebut tidak menyalahi undang2 krn Perlembagaan Persekutuan membenarkn wakil rakyat utk tukar sokongan. Dari tindakan 6 MP menukar sokongan PPBM telah cuba menidakkn tindakan mereka. PPBM telah meminda perlembagaan parti yg membenarkn kerusi wakil rakyat bg mereka yg menukar sokongan diisytiharkn kosong. Pindaan perlembagaan PPBM ini sepatutnya berkuatkuasa pd tarikh disahkan oleh ROS, tetapi telah diguna keatas 6 MP mereka yg telah lebih awal menukar sokongan sprt yg dibenarkan oleh perlembagaan persekutuan. Dgn demikian PPBM boleh disabit mempunyai hasrat dan niat jahat utk menjatuhkn kredibiliti 6 MPnya. Meminda perlembagaan parti PPBM merupakan hasrat dan memberi notis nyata pendirian merupakan niat. 6 MP boleh buat laporan polis. Berkaitan perkara terhenti keahlian dgn sendirinya krn ingkar arahan parti tidak berbangkit krn ini merupakn kesan dari tindakan awal parti. Jika pihak mahkamah memihak kpd pengadu maka ada kemungkinan PPBM akan dibatalkan pendaftarannya sebagai sebuah parti politik.
MP2 PN yg tinggal cepat2 sokong PMX. Apa PN boleh buat? Paling max terhenti drp menjadi ahli parti dan jadi MP Bebas. Terhenti di sini krna perlembagaan parti dipinda begitu. Siapa pinda perlembagaan parti? Pimpinan parti. Kenapa? Krn mrka marah 6 MP mrk itu sokong PMX. Oleh itu, pindaan itu dilakukan untuk menghukum 6 MP itu. Serupa dngn tindakan displin yang diambil retrospectively. 6 MP Ber1 itu tdk melanggar perlembagaan pada masa mrk kata mrk sokong PMX. Sungguhpun skrng ni pelanggaran perlmbgaan parti itu boleh dikira berterusan, 6 MP itu dikira terhenti keahlian mrka krna nyokong PMX sewaktu perlembagaan nega dan plmbgn parti tdk menghalang. Apa2 pun pindaan perlmbgn parti itu bertujuan tuk menghukum, dan/atau mengambil tindakan displin. Maka ia smlah dgn memecat 6 MP itu drp keahlian parti. Perlembagaan nega jelas klu hilang keahlian parti krn dipecat, kerusi MP tak perlu dikosongkan. Undang2 tidak boleh ditafsir lari drp maksud dan tujuan hanya dgn permainan kata2.
This katak case CLOSE + NFA ....these 6+1 kataks are officially sponsored by our madani govt.NEXT ..... RON95 subsidy should be CUT immediately to SAVE our beloved country.🙏🙏🙏Good jobs???
The speaker is correct. Midin is as usual foolish. He made the law agst anti hopping so he makan diri. All because of his arrogance. His downfall. What a joke pengerusi PN but do not want the role of ketua pembangkang. Pengecut Din cirit.
Previously he said it will jahanamkan negara if leap frogging allowed Now he is taking a different stance IOW the lawyer is saying Speaker has the right to have a forked tongue (like a snake)? In India's anti hopping law, there is a section in that law which stipulates the Speaker has the power on such issue, but that section was repealed later by India's supreme court when it was discovered it resulted to abuse of power . In our Constitution, there is no where including any relevant section/schedule it indicated specifically that the Speaker has the right on 49A, in particular there is no section within 49A itself saying that 49A is not about urusan Parlimen, it is a law regarding lompat parti. 49A was agreed / voted unanimously to PREVENT leap frogging, but now it is ok because it is convenient for the gov to have more MPs, right or wrong/principled/unprincipled not a matter of concern They are also claiming kebebasan MP is important, but they did not allow the MPs to vote freely in the dewan previously when confirming sokongan towards Nuar (nobody knows actually how many MPs sokong ex banduan till today). How is the gov legally formed? Illegal gov with illegal tricks
Ex banduan pn darjat dia lebih tinggi PDA engkau ..KO ado merengek la KO sampai PRU16....ado YG dulu pn nma je parti Islam tpi up Judi Jadi 22 Kali...ado YG dulu pn bnyk katak2 lompat tubuh kerajaan haram tanpa PRU
@@khairulnorazmam9866 kesian pengikut kaki penipu, cakap merapu saja yg termampu sebab tak boleh sanggah fakta yg ex banduan dah banyhak sangat dikhalyak ramai, malah dalam dewan pun MENIPU pengikut dgn perangai menipu suka ketua penipu, sepusat sepusing kotor
Everyone can read it and form has own opinion but it's the one with the POWER or is granted the POWER who has the final say. It's HIS WAY, not my way nor anyone's way. Btw, has anyone of them acted neutrally in all past administration? Sama Sama lah!. Therefore, stop the drama and claiming one is fair, just and right always.
@@RUHappyATM The Constitution says a lot on citizen's rights, equality and fairness too but are they being FOLLOWED AS WRITTEN or as interpreted by the powers-that-be?
Kera non sorang jawatan 2,3 lg byk dari yg 70.dh djilat penyakau berbilion2 kapal yg di tuduh dulu.project family dn kroni dh suci walanon berbayar jilat
So PH katak is ok now ? 😂😂😂😂
No is PN kataks
Jilat katak@@tortoise1953
@@tortoise1953hidup katak kakakaka 😅
Last General Election, a lot of Katak also? So how?
Balance
Bincang, teliti, gubal undang2 lompat Katak bertahun-tahun dlm parliament, skali gune kuasa utk mansuhkn semua undang2.
Senjata Makan Tuan. Undang2 Katak ciptaan Raja Katak.
Skrg Raja Katak kena telan hidup2 dgn anak2 Katak, salahkan Undang2 ciptaan kamu sendiri ???
hmm jd kalau mp umno beralih sokongan pn x perlu la kosongkn kerusi kan??ke acane sbnrnye??
No more ubi kayu, sudah jadi tapai ubi. 🤣🧠🐙
But he is ubi kayu menteri
Johari entitled to enjoy his ubi kayu
Speaker asa kuasapenuh
PN yng masih ingin tebuk atap lagi
This law was enacted in year 2022 when PN was ruling the country. It was some bersatu leaders who wanted the loopholes to exist in the law at that time. Maybe they entertained the idea that there will be PH representatives who will defect to PN. In years 2020 and 2021, there were a numbers of disloyal PH representatives who defected. But come year 2023 and 2024, defections were from PN, and not to PN for the obvious reasons.
So Malaysia Parliament belongs to johari
So he is above the law and can make decision according to his party needs....omg
IKR.
Above the constitution.
No body above the law la.. dont be stupid
Alhamdulillah
..Tuan speaker
What a joke lol 😂
Kerajaan Kelam kelibut dn tunggang langgang . Undang2 Hutan Belantara
Senjata Makan Tuan, Undang2 Belantara ciptaan King Katak 😎
So speaker is above the law right? Most powerful person in Malaysia parlimen ..
Sekarang semua boleh kencing rakyat
Kahkahkah..what a joke! 😂
Bias
what happens when mp's decides to lompat against PMX..speaker has created a precedence and could back fire
such time wasted for parlimentarian to bicker much about nothing.
Ini kerajaan kami suka hati kami laaa😂😂😂 Undang perlembangan pon mereka langgar habis😂😂 What a joke this government cannot be trusted at all.
Ph never consistent, always cheat and uturn
X mo ikut buku perlembagaan la pulok
Senjata Makan Tuan, Undang2 Katak dicipta King Katak 😎
The Speaker uses the universal " Rule Of Ubi Kayu " ... I guess it is widely accepted globally now !!🤪🤪🤣🤣🤣
The law is above all, what are you talking.
Tindakan PPBM ke atas 6 MP mereka boleh di bawa ke mahkamah krn mempunyai niat jahat cuba menjatuhkn kredibiliti 6 wakil rakyatnya yg telah menukar sokongan kpd kerajaan. Tindakan 6 wakil rakyat tersebut tidak menyalahi undang2 krn Perlembagaan Persekutuan membenarkn wakil rakyat utk tukar sokongan. Dari tindakan 6 MP menukar sokongan PPBM telah cuba menidakkn tindakan mereka. PPBM telah meminda perlembagaan parti yg membenarkn kerusi wakil rakyat bg mereka yg menukar sokongan diisytiharkn kosong. Pindaan perlembagaan PPBM ini sepatutnya berkuatkuasa pd tarikh disahkan oleh ROS, tetapi telah diguna keatas 6 MP mereka yg telah lebih awal menukar sokongan sprt yg dibenarkan oleh perlembagaan persekutuan. Dgn demikian PPBM boleh disabit mempunyai hasrat dan niat jahat utk menjatuhkn kredibiliti 6 MPnya. Meminda perlembagaan parti PPBM merupakan hasrat dan memberi notis nyata pendirian merupakan niat. 6 MP boleh buat laporan polis. Berkaitan perkara terhenti keahlian dgn sendirinya krn ingkar arahan parti tidak berbangkit krn ini merupakn kesan dari tindakan awal parti. Jika pihak mahkamah memihak kpd pengadu maka ada kemungkinan PPBM akan dibatalkan pendaftarannya sebagai sebuah parti politik.
Bersatu sudah meroyan 😂😂.
Bagus, hapuskan parti katak yang dah nyawa nyawa ikan tu
Terbaik Speaker...tlg kerajaan perpaduan jimat duit berjuta-juta ringgit buat 6 PRK
jimat bagi kat katak kenyang...walanon takut kalah..koyak cepat
Jimat lg kalau PADU x dibuat, kos 80juta & mngkn mngkat
Ajaran sesat ubi kayu
MP2 PN yg tinggal cepat2 sokong PMX. Apa PN boleh buat? Paling max terhenti drp menjadi ahli parti dan jadi MP Bebas. Terhenti di sini krna perlembagaan parti dipinda begitu. Siapa pinda perlembagaan parti? Pimpinan parti. Kenapa? Krn mrka marah 6 MP mrk itu sokong PMX. Oleh itu, pindaan itu dilakukan untuk menghukum 6 MP itu. Serupa dngn tindakan displin yang diambil retrospectively. 6 MP Ber1 itu tdk melanggar perlembagaan pada masa mrk kata mrk sokong PMX. Sungguhpun skrng ni pelanggaran perlmbgaan parti itu boleh dikira berterusan, 6 MP itu dikira terhenti keahlian mrka krna nyokong PMX sewaktu perlembagaan nega dan plmbgn parti tdk menghalang. Apa2 pun pindaan perlmbgn parti itu bertujuan tuk menghukum, dan/atau mengambil tindakan displin. Maka ia smlah dgn memecat 6 MP itu drp keahlian parti. Perlembagaan nega jelas klu hilang keahlian parti krn dipecat, kerusi MP tak perlu dikosongkan. Undang2 tidak boleh ditafsir lari drp maksud dan tujuan hanya dgn permainan kata2.
Ubikayuposman syarikat baru johari lepas pru akan datang.😂
Abahcow tutup parlimen, cow² tak ingat?
,👍👍
This katak case CLOSE + NFA ....these 6+1 kataks are officially sponsored by our madani govt.NEXT ..... RON95 subsidy should be CUT immediately to SAVE our beloved country.🙏🙏🙏Good jobs???
The speaker is correct.
Midin is as usual foolish. He made the law agst anti hopping so he makan diri.
All because of his arrogance. His downfall.
What a joke pengerusi PN but do not want the role of ketua pembangkang. Pengecut Din cirit.
Siapa lah Kelantan Speaker nak bandingkan dgn Speaker Parlimen Malaysia . Langit & Bumi beza nya oiiii .
Tp dia lebih faham undang2, sama seperti peguam paham.
Ubi kayu tak paham undang2
@@Rentaka_Lela... vs Speaker Gali Perigi
Lobai biasalah sentiasa gelojoh
Previously he said it will jahanamkan negara if leap frogging allowed
Now he is taking a different stance
IOW the lawyer is saying Speaker has the right to have a forked tongue (like a snake)?
In India's anti hopping law, there is a section in that law which stipulates the Speaker has the power on such issue, but that section was repealed later by India's supreme court when it was discovered it resulted to abuse of power .
In our Constitution, there is no where including any relevant section/schedule it indicated specifically that the Speaker has the right on 49A, in particular there is no section within 49A itself saying that
49A is not about urusan Parlimen, it is a law regarding lompat parti. 49A was agreed / voted unanimously to PREVENT leap frogging, but now it is ok because it is convenient for the gov to have more MPs, right or wrong/principled/unprincipled not a matter of concern
They are also claiming kebebasan MP is important, but they did not allow the MPs to vote freely in the dewan previously when confirming sokongan towards Nuar (nobody knows actually how many MPs sokong ex banduan till today). How is the gov legally formed?
Illegal gov with illegal tricks
Ex banduan pn darjat dia lebih tinggi PDA engkau ..KO ado merengek la KO sampai PRU16....ado YG dulu pn nma je parti Islam tpi up Judi Jadi 22 Kali...ado YG dulu pn bnyk katak2 lompat tubuh kerajaan haram tanpa PRU
@@khairulnorazmam9866 kesian pengikut kaki penipu, cakap merapu saja yg termampu sebab tak boleh sanggah fakta yg ex banduan dah banyhak sangat dikhalyak ramai, malah dalam dewan pun MENIPU
pengikut dgn perangai menipu suka ketua penipu, sepusat sepusing kotor
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Everyone can read it and form has own opinion but it's the one with the POWER or is granted the POWER who has the final say. It's HIS WAY, not my way nor anyone's way.
Btw, has anyone of them acted neutrally in all past administration?
Sama Sama lah!. Therefore, stop the drama and claiming one is fair, just and right always.
What does the constitution say about party hopping?
@@RUHappyATM The Constitution says a lot on citizen's rights, equality and fairness too but are they being FOLLOWED AS WRITTEN or as interpreted by the powers-that-be?
@@ninakhan3803
IDTS.
It's mean this gov is same to the previous gov isn't? so, All those promise to 'reform' before is for what? Lying to Rakyat..BS..
Parti 'KEADILAN' my 4ss..
😂😂😂 koyakrabak dinbabi
Ini tahap komen cytro Madani..kesian.
Komen negatif terhadap speaker ni puak2 walaun dari kera jaan 70 Penyamun. Meroyan siang malam tak dpt menyakau & akaun kena beku
Kera non sorang jawatan 2,3 lg byk dari yg 70.dh djilat penyakau berbilion2 kapal yg di tuduh dulu.project family dn kroni dh suci walanon berbayar jilat
Ramai walaun kecewa 😂
Walanon ikut ajaran sesat sbb tu undang2 tunggang terbalik di langgar.walanon rela menjadi penjilat