Farm bill 2020 Explained | Why are Farmers Protesting | Agriculture UPSC Current Affairs
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2020
- This video is on Farm Bill 2020 and we will learn why farmers are protesting against it. Farmers in Punjab and Haryana have been protesting against three bills:-
1. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill 2020
2. The Farming Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020
3. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill, 2020
This channel can single handedly destroy every coaching channel if he starts uploading weekly current affairs
very truee
Hey Friend Find Amazing vey helpful Ethics classes Videos at D V ABHIMANYU IAS ACADEMY
Well said
Ik I love him I’m thinking about , subscribing
Exactly
It appears that the mainstream media has forgotten how to research a story. This is such a lucid explanation. Thank you.
All r sold out media
this report adds to the information but not fully discuss all the aspects and scenarios. Why does it not explain how Mandi's and APMCs handle demand-supply fluctuations ? Why does it not discuss scenario of inflation due to monopoly of APMC middlemen? Hoarding can be done at APMC level also. It has been done if past. Why does it not highlight the fact that some of the middlemen in APMC and big farmers have nexus to manipulate prices ? Last but not the least why does it now highlight the fact that any MSP security cover by govt in case of excess produce results in wastage and loss of taxpayers money in buying it ??
Report gives partial truth which can also be counter-productive.
The mainstream media knows very well how to research a story, but since most of them are Leftists for whatever crazy reason, they are deliberately trying to present a very different picture, because they want India to remain poor and impoverished forever, because no one who's earning well will ever support their perverted idealogy which has proven to be a failure everywhere in the world.
@@indiasane9420 Hi...I read your comment..I am not from agriculture background but got curious because of this protest. You seems to be knowledgeable in this topic too. Why don't you discuss about it in your channel. I'll be the first one to subscribe👍👍
MSM has only one point agenda - Oppose Modi.
There are around 2 hr 10 videos in my coaching (for which i paid around 80k) and not a single one is as good as what this guy has taught us in this 14 min video for free. ❤
Ur right!!!!!!
Can u mention the organisation which charged such amt..
😳
Haha clown
His voice is perfect. It almost feels like i am listening to a male google assisstant❤️
😂😂😂
Right
Hear mr whose the boss
true😅
Girls crushing on just about everyone nowdays! 😁
As an English person with no prior knowledge about what is going on in India, this has been extremely insightful. Such a clear and concise explanation of the causes behind the protest.
It's very nice of you to want to learn about this as a non-Indian.
@Shakila Bano True
@Shakila Bano You are one sided. I believe there shouldn't be any reform for farmers, since, they are illiterates. First make the farmers literate, then bring reforms.
@Shakila Bano too much! People call you Bhakt.
@@shekharsinhavicky people call you Andh-Nawazi too!😴
I am from tamilnadu. I like this video quite useful. After celebrating 72 years republic day still farmers in my state are very poor and facing lots of troubles like cyclone , floods , insufficient water storage etc. State and central government will never provide enough money or cancel loans for affected farmers as so many years passed away. So my opinion is central government tried their best and let them do their work. Hope it may be successful for farmers in future. The whole problem is for small and poor farmers let their children's will help them in condition apply legal process after all they are working in IT field for foreign company.
Situations are same in every state.
Bill is already in place in Bihar as a model/pilot project but it failed there badly…. even after witnessing its failure , govt tried to implement it pan India.
@@RajwantKaur-yt5ge it failed because it was a small marketplace. You need a country wide open market to see it working. It's the same concept in Canada, US where many of those who supported the protestors do farming under similar business conditions
Modi should telecast this video in live interview, it will must reach to many people.
Dear All ....you know how muchh damage farm reform bills do to small,poor farmer , let me tell you .. this bill makes the existing contractors mere #sponsers ,which will be making agreement from 1-5 years to an individual or group of farmers , agreement doest nt include anything related to land , and any infrastructure that the firm built on farmer's area will have to be removed by the firm within a month ( after contract period) or else that infrastructure belongs to the farmer while all payment will be done at the time of crop transfer, besides disputes related will be dealt on the fast track path by SDM or DM level and only farmer have the right to go to the sessions court,moreover the penalty for farmer is the loss of sponser while penalty on sponser is 1.5 times the deal amount & a disaster on #mandi system is that yess mandis demand will decrease as farmers dont be needing them and will be merely controlled by authorities, in fact govt wont be spending that much money on buying the crops and can do a lot more imp works... the sponsers can arrange agri -councellors, may lend some amount( with no or little interest),can also include aggregators and can arrange transport facilities or include them in big supply chains..... SEE this is Why it becomes #KAALA kanoon for the opposition and not to the majority of farmers....
dear #All , i consider people raging for farm bills as innocents in pain , please lets not hurt them any more ... iff #Tikait is right , he would have gone to supreme court to challenge the bills, he is running away because he is wrong ...
Bro this guy shows a lot but lost at many points...
@@shubham-yw2nv bro, are you telling about contract farming, right. But it already happening in my village, all sugarcane farmers doing contract farming. They get good profit. That's why gov try to implement in all other crops, it's upto farmer's wish. And I also agreed, why don't they join in supreme court committee instead of doing protest. I support every law has merits and demerits, so you have to rectify by challenge in court but ban is not a solution.
@@shancsk28 main problem was on farm services & price assurance ... So i write it down for that first ... As you know its hard to write 100 pages ...
Bro ... In this bill .... No cons ... Anything wrong will be crime ...& criminals will be prosecuted...
Thats why PM said ganga niyat ...
& look bro .. I dont speak for any party ... Its just for reducing pain in the world..
@@shancsk28 bro this bill is killing the existing contractors .... Thats the point .... They are shouting about ambani adani ... But ambani adaani are againt this bill ... Thats why all are crying in front of PM on roads ...
Isko kehte h chidiya ki ankh p teer maarna ...
The explanation is so unbiased that those who are pro-government, belive the bill is good for farmers and those who are anti understand why the bill is bad for farmers. It also says that the bill has it share of both good and bad, and a proper discussion would make it lot better for every party involved.
That is exactly the case. The bills are debatable. But the problem is every media house has picked teams in advance and will only speak in their teams favour. No one will tell you pros and cons in an unbiased manner.
Every one will do that but farmers are now beating police. Remember protest of 2013 . It was peaceful. Peaceful protest is necessary for any debate. Farmers are telling to repeal the bill but that's not possible. They should debate over it to make it more useful
@AVE Dragons I don't think BJP IS PROTESTING
Dear All ....you know how muchh damage farm reform bills do to small,poor farmer , let me tell you .. this bill makes the existing contractors mere #sponsers ,which will be making agreement from 1-5 years to an individual or group of farmers , agreement doest nt include anything related to land , and any infrastructure that the firm built on farmer's area will have to be removed by the firm within a month ( after contract period) or else that infrastructure belongs to the farmer while all payment will be done at the time of crop transfer, besides disputes related will be dealt on the fast track path by SDM or DM level and only farmer have the right to go to the sessions court,moreover the penalty for farmer is the loss of sponser while penalty on sponser is 1.5 times the deal amount & a disaster on #mandi system is that yess mandis demand will decrease as farmers dont be needing them and will be merely controlled by authorities, in fact govt wont be spending that much money on buying the crops and can do a lot more imp works... the sponsers can arrange agri -councellors, may lend some amount( with no or little interest),can also include aggregators and can arrange transport facilities or include them in big supply chains..... SEE this is Why it becomes #KAALA kanoon for the opposition and not to the majority of farmers....
dear #All , i consider people raging for farm bills as innocents in pain , please lets not hurt them any more ... iff #Tikait is right , he would have gone to supreme court to challenge the bills, he is running away because he is wrong ...
Its not about the pro & anti brother .... There are permanent representatives in the administration ... Who had prepared these farm laws long ago ...
@AVE Dragons why would BJP implement bills and instigate people to oppose it? Your statement doesn't make sense....
This video should be added to essential videos list of 2020 and not removed ..
Agreed
Yes very informative
> and not removed ..
What would cause this video to be removed?
My god you should have been a news anchor who comes at prime time.
He don't support political agenda, so he is here... 🤣😂🤣🤣
There is such a news anchor. Idk if you've heard of Wion's Palki Sharma Upadhyay.
It's a shame that we pay lakhs and lakhs to our lousy universities, and watch great content like this.
Weird world.
Reality hits hard bro 😢, but hope NEP 2020 will change this!
he produced it eaisly. Same software as kahn academy
People like know to take benefits of university teaching unlike us
because Graduation degree is requirement for every competitive......
you won't be able to appear in Upsc ssc or any exam if you don't have a degree..... that's why we go to tier 3 university
Rightly said man, Universities are charging lacs just to teach us some dumb formulas.
Wonderfully explained, if only someone explains all the laws like this.
Thanks a lot
This is Video is for IAS and not from any other horrible youtube influencers like Dhruv Rathee. So obviously it will have a better explanation.
@@deepakrajpurushothaman677 indeed
Thank you for providing facts and not your opinions. India highly needs such content which is unbiased (from either sides/parties) and fact based.
True brother.... Nowadays all I see is either Congress oriented channels or bjp oriented ones...
100% agreed. I've been looking for an unbiased explanation but all I've been seeing is opinions and not actual facts
@@rrxn There are a lot of things this guy has missed and deliberately hiding. Govt. has given option to the farmers in almost all the things which this guy says is against the farmers. It appears that this guy is biased, but pretends to be balanced.
@@RaviChandranjennifer he’s highlighted where people have the potential to be exploited, however that’s not a valid reason to be upset at these bills, as I’m sure you understand. Clearly India is trying to move towards a more efficient market and not be ridiculed in International spaces for heavily subsidizing it’s own farmers but still importing food.
@@poemrockz No he has deliberately omitted many points which are in favor of the farmers. and he is a stooge of the Communists trying to destroy India. he is worse than cancer.
Simple and unbiased explanation. This 14 minutes video gave me clarity that no news channel could
But the actual point is nobody force any farmer to make a contract outside mandi market.
A farmer can choose if he want to sell in mandi or not. its farmers choice. Jai kisan Jai Bharath
Exactly my point...its totally upto farmers with whom they want to do business with its not a compulsion..i tried to explain this to one guy in one of the comments above but doesn't seem to get it ... according to him there will be competition..well reliance fresh and spencers markets are already there when there was no law wasn't this a competition there?
😂 you don't anything about government.
When private players will come in market market the establishment mandi system will collapse. Because government will not do any procurement...
the thing is that the private firms have good capital...hence they will offer better prices and soon APMC will die out leaving farmers at the mercy of private firms. hope this makes u understand.
@@triffleshows7174 the answer is convert APMC to co-op non profit farmer union managed and regulated by farmers, dictating
MSP and supply chain. once you have that farmers will be able to control private companies. if union sees a company mal practising .. ban that company. trust me competition of private company will pick up the goods, people needs to eat.
Bro one thing you missed is , In the Price bill it says .....A farmer can come out of the agreement with a corporate without paying any penalty , but a corporate has to pay penalty if it goes back on the agreement .
How many farmers would stand against corporate buyers? Corporates control governments. Do you think farmers will not be intimidated in the name of legal action? And guess, who is responsible for dispute resolution? Civil servants. Who are highly unapproachable and corrupt, in general.
@@sachin9292 Well the law provides legal protection for farmers who goes back on agreement . Not sure what else can be done ? Now the farmers should form a union to protect from corporate if they still don't have confidence
@@sachin9292 corporate controls only govt. Not judiciary.
@@nidhingana It’s hard to say. Farmers are sceptical. Judiciary is not given the dispute resolution power at first. It lies with bureaucrats in this case.
Big Corporate's are Davil and they are in Market to generate only and only Increase their Profits.
They are not RATAN TATA who makes Charity for people.
More than farmers middle class should have protested against the bills. Privatisation is not a problem. It’s unregulated privatisation with crony capitalism is a lethal combination. That’s more likely to happen.
Moron these bills stand to bring produce at a lower rate to us ; MSP inflates the price of crop for us to buy it at lower price. If you cannot understand research first.
@@powerslavenegi Exactly. Free market efficiencies are totally overlooked in this video. Moreover govt shd NEVER be in the business of fixing prices. Its time to bring more efficiency into agriculture
@@powerslavenegi You are misinformed. It's only the Central & State Govts. & it's agencies which are procuring crops at MSP rates(mostly wheat & rice) for Public Distribution System or maintenance of buffer reserves of these food items. An average Indian who purchases grains from market is purchasing at market rates and MSP has no bearing on that unless the Fair price shop owners & others are diverting the publicly procured supplies to private market!!
@@asisrout1988 I am very well aware of what I am saying ; the central and state agencies are cartels . Current government knows this and they know many poor and weak farmers are being exploited by these cartels that is why as first step they are simply saying that these farmers be allowed to sell directly to market. To Government's point there is no reason for farmers who sell to APMC or FCI at MSP price to panic for if they want to continue they can . However reason these protests are there in place is those running these cartels know in future the government will reform the system further and their corrupt gravy train will come to stop. Most agitations in this country are being funded by corrupt to stop reforms.
These protests are EXACTLY on same lines as protests from Mulayam Singh and COmmunists when first ATMs and IT came to India , they were against these and conducted many agitations and protests by spreading fear about job losses.
I have never come across a better visual representation of any topic than this. Splendidly spoken, kept it crisp, and delivered the knowledge in the most articulate way. KUDOS!
One correction here, government can't get out of the Agri business. They are bound to buy wheat and rice as per the Food security act. It's mandatory for them to provide wheat and rice to nearly 80 cr people in India via TPDS
You miss that this government is famous in amending all acts via ordinance
@@fishsauce7497 I think you are uneducated about this subject, so let me educate you. This government has done the maximum procurement, compared to all previous governments. Especially the procurement done last year, was bumper ! As well as because farmers were given 1.5x msp last year because of covid, the farmers benefitted both from the fact that all their produce was procured as well as they were given higher price. You should read more newspapers like Hindu and Indian express, you would understand how this procurements last year by govt. was the reason why Agriculture sector saw a boom last year, even though all other sectors were down because of covid.
@@kunalmandhare3144 To add on, just check on the tractor sales figures. They are growing over last year. YoY and MoM sales is altogether increasing. This clearly indicates that agriculture in the country is spiking up but for some illiterates, it would be a hard fact to digest.
@@fishsauce7497 In your face dude. The facts have been stated above. Just gather some courage and try to make sense in your statements. However, despite all the facts aforementioned, I am certain that your upcoming arguments will lack cogency.
@starlord the best guardian watch the video again you will understand... I don't see it as a bad ...if you want to do business with corp sect then its your choice do it you will be benefitted of course there are demands from those corps but as the narrator said you can't have everything you will have to leave something behind that is how IT companies works in short that is how Corp world works..and if you are that insecure and don't trust these corps then mandis are there you go and do your business as u were doing previously there is no compulsion..there is no saying that farmers will have to act according to the bills please someone correct me here cause as per my knowledge mandis are and will still be in a play...
You are absolutely right... But if the farmers are educated they will not be farmers 😀😂🤣
Oh Really !!! So Farmers are uneducated or Farming is for Uneducated People only ??? so if your country become 100% educated , you may not Have Food on the table.
😂😂
that's the case with India
Most productive 14 min spent today
Right
Well said!
I also agree with you..
True ....
@galti mt kar Sirf Punjab ke farmers he Protest nahin kar rahe hein.
now-a-days when TH-cam is becoming a mess finding your channel is nothing but a blessing! More power to you Sir💐. Hope you continue to do so.
Same I also think
His lucid way of explanation and soothing voice bring me here.
This channel do have the power to single handedly replace any coaching institute with the way sir explains everything i think this is the best clearity anyone can get.
Thank you sir
First time on this channel but I must say that I was reaching out for a channel like this which can make things this clear.... Great 🙏
th-cam.com/video/DCVlEyRrpRU/w-d-xo.html
If you like this type of content you can visit this channel too.
THE FARMERS (EMPOWERMENT AND PROTECTION) AGREEMENT
ON PRICE ASSURANCE AND FARM SERVICES ACT, 2020
egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2020/222040.pdf
govt. gazette publication
Brilliantly explained Both Sides of the Coin.Apprecaite it .
first of all the bills violates the constitution as it states that center cannot interfere with agriculture. All the bills are unconstitutional. Supreme Court should have take suomoto cognizance but they didn’t as the Chief Justice of Supreme Court has just jointBJP and became RAJYAPAL member.
Appreciate*
@@DH-is8fg ummm wasn't that the EX CJI and not the current CJI? Members of judiciary can't become members of legislative, basic knowledge bro
Also its rajyasabha not rajyapal dude
The most important bill to set everything right in the long run is a staggered population bill.
India's population will be decreasing in the coming years, since the fertility rate is dropping.
@@cjmech9156 😂 what
@@madtitanthanos6462 do some research.
Not just india.
The entire worlds population will be decreasing
The fertility rates in Bihar, UP and MP are balancing the lowering of TFR across the other states. Rate of growth has decreased but the population is increasing in crores every year. We have a demographic advantage because of higher proportion of youth but there's no use if there aren't enough jobs or skill based education or training. Hopefully NEP 2020 will do good in that sense.
@@cjmech9156 thats not how population workd... 'Rate of increase in population' decrease not the whole population lmao
Nicely explained except for one thing that you missed. “If the PVT companies are not paying the farmer for what they have agreed on, the farmer shall get lower price”, you said. But in this case “the farmers can still sell the product in Mandi on MSP”, you missed.
Farmers can sell to FCI , if market prices are less than MSP .
Pvt companies have to pay ,what they agreed upon, by lower price he meant ,now the farmer is also the part of demand and price cycle, sometimes he might get Less price due to less demand
@@somesweetguy it doesn’t matter whether someone buy from mandi or not. Because mandi is Sarkari and sarkar has to buy is at the MSP. That is a compulsion. This is why its a win win situation for farmers
@@Starkkumar even in case of less demand, the farmer doesn’t have to sell in less price, they can sell in mandis at MSP!
@@jimit143 well only if there are buyers ready to buy at the mandis at MSP, which is unlikely if they can buy at a lower price from the pvt companies
His teaching is the best I’ve ever came across in the internet.
th-cam.com/video/MaXAqBLprEg/w-d-xo.html
Ye dekho
Prashant Dhawan ka naam suna h?
first of all the bills violates the constitution as it states that center cannot interfere with agriculture. All the bills are unconstitutional. Supreme Court should have take suomoto cognizance but they didn’t as the Chief Justice of Supreme Court has just jointBJP and became RAJYAPAL member.
D H it’s still debatable. I believe the legislation has more power than the judiciary. Above that, don’t you think it’s the right time to start practising "one nation one market" policy.
Yeah wrong information
Nowadays Everything comes up with a condition applied which many of the "Educated" people find difficult to follow up.... Whattaaa mark... 🖖🏻
This is true
Yes Deeksha
Good in condition.. view
Yeap
It's true. If u go for airtel, aircell, insurance and for consumers not between businessman. Without clarity no one is going to sign!.
Oh Wow! What a Brilliant explanation. Excellent.... calming voice. Talent at it's best 👌
Cheers from Sri Lanka 🇱🇰
This cleared everything about Farm Bills! Much grateful to you for this.
This is called comprehensive understanding.. thank you 😀
THE FARMERS (EMPOWERMENT AND PROTECTION) AGREEMENT
ON PRICE ASSURANCE AND FARM SERVICES ACT, 2020
egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2020/222040.pdf
This is the information revolution happening in India. When the mainstream media is becoming state media and the remaining media just criticizes everything of the government... we as commoners do not get information... and you Sir .. are a part of this revolution..... bringing objectivity in informing ..... kudos to you and may your flock grow and may we be better Informed. Thank you
People don't want to pay more from their pocket for vegetables, but speak about farmers profit.
How can it happen.
Private companies will take care of the pricing for farmers.
Anyway farmers always have option to go to APMC mandi if they wish to.
Government is not forcing farmers to sell to any individual they can sell as they wish.
Farmers can already sell to private buyers and most of them never pay on time.
APMC will die after these laws because the contract farming will restrict them selling to anybody else, much like BSNL died off after Jio was given all of its infrastructure.
The public is being distracted by the media because if this happens the days of road side vendors selling fresh fruit, vegetables, juice, etc will all disappear and average people will be buying from large reliance superstores at Rs200/ kilo and paying Rs100 for tea from street vendors, and by then it will be too late.
@@TheHardeepu these laws aren’t per say bad but the advantages for the farmers provided are crippled by equal disadvantages arising from the law. At the end of the day tho I believe consumers don’t get to say what is best for farmer’s. I believe that if a farmer truly believed that they would be empowered by this law, their religious/political alliance wouldn’t come into the scenario
It's the news that has made it a 'religious' issue, and the same news channels seem to think that if anybody goes against anything the government does they're automatically anti BJP and in favour of Congress. This is where they're wrong, whoever is in power especially without a decent opposition to debate laws properly before their passed will create problems and this is the core reason. Criticising the seat in power doesnt mean you support the other. It's happened with Trump in the US and in the UK where one party when in power takes advantage of pushing through some very contentious laws. If you look at the parliament footage of the laws being passed you will see that is no way of passing such a big bill...
@@TheHardeepu bhai pata ni tune whatsapp pr pada h kya ye bsnl or jio wala. Point. Or padha bhi h to thoda explain kr de m clearify kr dunga. Doubt. Btw 4g licence jio ko 2013 m congress n diya tha.
@@TheHardeepu how do u know APMC will die?
1. The farmers will before hand know in the contract how much price they are gonna get. If they fail and legal clause I not valid let's say because the farmers couldn't supply the aggred quality, then the farmers will still have the option of selling the crops to APMC.
2. You gave the example of BSNL, well to tell you the fact that BSNL was never ahead in the race, it was already lagging behind even before Jio came. It lacked because of the poor quality of network that they provided in comparison to the private players. If you blame jio for BSNL's loss then you are wrong because bsnl lost because if it's own incompetency.
3. We all have to agree that the farm laws are not perfect. But instead of demanding the laws to be annulled they should be amended , so that the farmers get max profit. We want the best for our farmers.
As I watching this video I am literally crying. This bill is most needed demand of this time. This will definitely incentivise farmers income but due to dirty politics it is repealed by government.
I scored 99/100 in class 10 Social Science JUST BCOZ OF YOU.
I scored 93
I scored 95 in social science in cbse class 10 exam in 2019.
@@KillerofWestoids me 2
I got 98
first of all the bills violates the constitution as it states that center cannot interfere with agriculture. All the bills are unconstitutional. Supreme Court should have take suomoto cognizance but they didn’t as the Chief Justice of Supreme Court has just jointBJP and became RAJYAPAL member.
After watching this video, I think now it is time for Consumers Protest.
If used effectively by farmers, i.e., if they are smart in using these laws, finally they will get more profits but yeah, in the end Consumer is going to pay the bill, hope the Private Companies don't form some kind of Syndicate to fix the prices.
Very nice and we'll explained
What you say that you can't have a cake and also keep it too
@Pooja Sharma
Wish you can mention more context about what exactly you want to say.
@Pooja Sharma
Thank you for your viewss and opinion.
@Pooja Sharma I think he said that government will regulate the price fluctuations, by the way Iam in college
Wow that was so clear. I wish my college lectures were like this 😅💯 Thankyou 😁
Thank you for such a detailed and thorough explanation and examples of the laws. Brings things much more into perspective and shines light in the flaws in the existing and proposed systems.
Sir.... Pls explain the following topics also:-
1. Labour laws
2. Foreign contribution regulation Act
3. Need of Fiscal council
4. Election of Deputy speaker and deputy chairman
Thank you....
So is the bill a good thing by the govt or not
No good
@@adharshmanikoth3381
It is a right question and the reply for the is expected only from small farmers who were looted by politicians in the form of commission and mandi tax, etc.,,selling fertilizers in black market with 100% profit margins and not from any corrupted politicians or any leader who is in the payment list of any corrupted politicians.
Mounik if u r upsc aspirant then u check the laxmi kant polity book , there u can find the election of deputy speaker r deputy chairman
@@dipumajumdar3239 Yes... but I like his videos/explanation and it's a current topic at that time. So I asked
We are with our nation's farmers, as they are the core of the country.
That's why you should support the bills
Thanks dear. I am a farmer from Haryana. Support farmers. BJP government doing discrimination with us. Please save us 🙏
@@virendersingh8166 no
@@virendersingh8166 we are with you 💪
@@koushikvijayakumar7924 why? When this bill already failed in bihar?
Being a common man lots of confusion regarding this controversy between Farmers and Govt. Thanks for educating us regarding the 'Bill' .
Farm bills and Yuri Bezmenov's lecture are 2 most viewed video of this channel and irony is, that they both go hand-in-hand with each other.
Well most people are NPC living inside the overton window controlled by the imperialistic Americanized culture.
I tired to show my friends this video, but as Yuri said "you could shower them with facts but their demoralization is complete (at far better scale than we ever anticipated)."
I Have heard topic video everywhere but i was really eagerly waiting for uh to post it...so here m watching again 👏👏🥳🥳🥳
Yes...you said it.. the only balanced one is this ..
THE FARMERS (EMPOWERMENT AND PROTECTION) AGREEMENT
ON PRICE ASSURANCE AND FARM SERVICES ACT, 2020
egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2020/222040.pdf
Simply explained to the understanding of edugated common man. Kudos to your effort. Same way these bills should be explained in regional languages too so that every citizen even if he's illiterate should be able to understand.
Absolutely
This is the best explanation I've come across for farm bills. Damn 🔥
With this kind of clear explanation who wouldn't start liking economics or any other subjects for that matter. I have never understood about economics during my college days and hated it so much but now specifically after watching your videos I'm interested in learning more of the subject (economics).😁😊 Thank you so much Sir 😘 Wish I could give you a hug 😅
Great explanation with pointing out the loopholes. This is an important info and really need to be dubbed in all Indian languages.
Well explained. Has actually given lot of clarity on what the fuss is about.
@@asaf5381 you need to understand how agrarian economy works to understand why they are protesting . You can follow case study of Bihar where iThis model has been applied and their farming has been devasted as a result
It is lot more than a fuss ... Lives are at stake
A Bains. Where is your proof it has been devastated? My family does farming in Bihar. The bill isn't perfect but we are working with it. I'm sure BJP will wind up amending portion of the bills to give better protection to all farmers.
@@asaf5381 bjp IT cell wala hai na tu....ive seen your comments elsewhere also, kitna milta hai Rs. 2 per comment !?! Chindi-chor.
@@PritishA82 it would be better if you would talk about facts rather than shattering your mouth on a person to whom you don't even know.
Thanks for your clear explanation. Now only I understand the real problems. Middle class is always vulnerable to these type of situations.
A big fan of You sir..... for doing without publicity, asking likes or shares... doing freely... we owe you big time sir
Well explained. I support these bills. Farmers are our gods, who provided food for us. They should be good always.
th-cam.com/video/MaXAqBLprEg/w-d-xo.html
Don't skip his ads that's the least we can do
I got an ad of length 5:30 🤔🤔
@@souparnachakraborty 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@souparnachakraborty watch all of it
Install youtube vanced and you wont get any ads
@@bharathnellore581 support good content creators
Since this bill has came, I haven't watched any vedio as I wasn't able to understand these bills but after this vedio, I got to know each and every aspect along with why our farmers are protesting. Thank you sir 🙏
I wish this gets more views than those pretend-to-know-it-all celebs who are pro/anti farmers bill on twitter/SM. Amazing video, can finally make sense of this situation. Still hard to say if this will prove beneficial/detrimental to our farmers.
IMF supports it. So do most economists. This is the step in the right direction. But people care more about what celebrities have to say.
But at-least we know that we all want India to thrive its worth a try, we have to keep trying new things. It's a trial and error nothing can or ever will be perfect.
70% of the farmers have less than 5 acres - they’re not sophisticated enough to interpret such legal contracts. Well explained. Small farmers are screwed.
Aaj se teen saal pehle bhi yahi keh rahe the ...small vendor are illiterate...how will they use online payment method....aaj se 30 saap pehle jb computer aaya desh mein....tb bhi yahi rona tha...jab pehli rajdhani chali tab bhi yahi rona tha ..
So we are accepting ki contract farming acchi hai...bas hamare kisan bhaiyo se ho nahi payegi ....
@@AmanPandey-pf7rq kuch bhi??
How come farm size is a matter of debate in this topic? The agreement will be effective only on crop price, not the land.
Only thing that's "screwed" is your low IQ brain.
I find the first such channel that brings somuch of good knowledge with effects.👍
It's really great explanation
I wasn't able to get the idea about why the farmers are protesting so much no matter how much I researched. Thanks it's really informative
Continuosly watching these lectures.. because the way Amit Sir explaining the concepts are extremely knowledgeable and useful not only for the aspirants of the different competitive examinations but also for those who are in general wanted to get know about different disciplines whether it is Law, Politics, Public Policies, Economy, Geography, Regional and International Relations and offcourse Current affairs.
Heartly Thanks for giving such an informative lectures Sir 🙏🙏.
May God always bless you..
From this overall explanation what I understood is
Middle class people will suffer alot
Definitely
Farmers and private companies are safe
Buyers will suffer alot
I don't get how farmers are still safe?
Sure about farmers bro?
Please get this translated in all regional languages. This is a very lucid explanation.
📽🎬🎞💲
Farm Bills even with solution ❤️
th-cam.com/video/DP2JwT_vinI/w-d-xo.html
Please hit the like , share nd subscribe button for more ❤️❤️ support guys !!
In a convoluted search, I came across India farmers protest new laws. After reading several articles, I still couldn't make sense of it, by design b/c I'm not stupid! Thank you, and that's what I thought!
Thank you so much for making it short and simple. Thanks to you ,now I have interest on this subject and will dig deeper into videos that explain vastly on this subject. I'm sharing this to all my friends as it's simpler to grasp.
Please don't stop posting and please cover all the current affairs and everything else necessary 😍✨✨✨ best education channel on TH-cam and I love your calm voice
We need journalists like you ... unbiased and with background research !!!
Thanks, Amit!, I too feel clarity on this topic as a common man looking from the consumer side.
The most informative video I've seen on the subject so far. Thank you!
Finally.... I understood the whole scene behind this farm bill and the protest... I'm soo glad I found your channel. Thank you so much sir...for explaining in such a great way😊
So who is right government or farmers because my English is not good to understand all things he talking please reply
Non Melvin babu is pseudo secular malayalee. Don't listen to him. Modi is right
This is how an explaination should be made.
Correct, that too with great voice and no repeated sentences or AAA uuuu like....
Thank you so much! You've explained this so clearly and objectively.
I really like the way your tone of speaking and how precisely you are teaching those things thanks a lot .
This video need to release in every language!!
Yaa iam expecting in Telugu
Definitely bro
True especially tamil
atleast it can be provided with subtitles
@@pinkisaini4558 do you mean subtitles in every language?
It was much needed!! Considering what is going on in Punjab no one is focusing on what is exactly happening in the bills clarity is much required!
exactly i was also confused with knowing little about flaws and what was being provided as good options to farmers. But now this video made clear by showing the both sides and worries of the farmers in detail.
@@aarzoothakur1811 Right!!Before supporting something, it is important to have a clear idea. The worries are genuine and government do need to address them :)
Dirty cheap politics nothing else. First search about what are the existing kisan programmes, subsidies, trainings, loans, insurance, machines and tools with subsidies, electricity cost by govt. After providing everything also some farmers are poor due to middleman/brokers/commission agents. To solve this problem they modified existing one to help farmers from brokers. Go and read about it.
@@krishnamuruganantham5499 Okay but what about the time when a corporate organisation might dominate the farmers on the legal agreement and once the farmer is fully involved in the direct trade with private org. govt wont interfere even if there will be an issue after 3 yrs. Till 1 to 3 yrs everything will be fine and also no farmers do this storage thing. They cultivate and then sell it. I agree that the middlemen should be removed giving more options to the farmer for their benefit. Also acc. to the third act items might be so costly that people especially middleclass wont be able to afford that. The issue is the things if went wrong what are the necessary measures which a farmer can take. Please enlighten me as I am open to gain more knowledge woth a healthy discussion. :-)
@@aarzoothakur1811 nailed it ❤️.
1.4 million people are well aware of the new farming laws and farmer protests thanks to this video. Hopefully it won’t stop here
I searched these kinds of explanations for months, thank you, now I understood clearly, so gov was not wrong completely as that protesters said, that bills have some flaws it easily rectifiable instead of ban the law. 👍👍👍
Some flaws? A farmer has to live in the constant fear of being exploited by companies, a poor and a middle class family have to live in fear of not being able to feed their families. This is not rectifiable.
@@chaskramer2932 You are kinda of a person who looks for problems in solutions.
@@chaskramer2932 farmers were still getting exploited in APMC mandis as traders waited for the longest time so they could buy products from farmers at cheap rates(for perishable products) since earlier trading outside mandis was prohibited.
@@SSP03 so why not amend APMC act
@@damnburger7351 this actually failed in european countries how could they implement in our country
Commercialization is a factor towards development and economy however privatization should be checked and regulated to protect its citizen from greedy corporates
first of all the bills violates the constitution as it states that center cannot interfere with agriculture. All the bills are unconstitutional. Supreme Court should have take suomoto cognizance but they didn’t as the Chief Justice of Supreme Court has just jointBJP and became RAJYAPAL member.
I didn't find any center interference on state subject. Please explain your observations in bullet
@@DH-is8fg 🤣🤣.. chamcha hi rahoge.. 🤣🤣
It also takes away right to legal recourse. As it clearly states that no one can file a case against government or any other person (which includes corporates), this is dangerous for a democracy and no one is talking about this
@@ANR1122 the government has offered to add a clause for this though. And even allows them to directly approach a higher court since a battle at a lower court between a corporate and an average farmer can never be equal.
Sir, u r incredible. Specifically serenity of your voice. Besides, topic and explanation both are commendable.
Thanks!
Thank you for educating us in an unbiased way!
A great way to educate ones self with the right facts and light on both sides of the coin.
Thanks
This man has got the most beautiful accent. Also sir i rarely find any content more concrete and concise than your's.
The main purpose of these amendments is that farmers have to produce more and more and earn more and more. If the domestic supply increases, then Govt will open the export gates allowing the export of excess production of that particular commodity.
If the domestic production of any item decreases due to monsoon failure,etc.and leads to price escalation, then Govt will import such shortfall items from other countries to maintain price stability.
In our country nearly 40% of vegetables / fruits produced are getting wasted / rotten due to non availability of cold storage facilities. Even large scale farmers can not offer for such a huge investment required for cold storage facilities. Reliance industries had invested nearly 1000 crores in Bangla desh to develop cold storage facilities to overcome the wastage of perishable items produced in Bangla desh. However, the same Reliance Industries is scared to invest in India due to adverse criticism of our opposition parties.
Hence, Govt has made it clear that anyone can own a warehouse with or without
cold storage facility any where in India. So now, even opposition party leaders can invest in warehouses with or without cold storage facility of their choice and offer tough competition to corporate players and earn huge profit, rather depending upon only commission money..
In previous farm bill, it is mandatory that farmers have to sell in the APMC markets only which are dominated by politicians.
Now, Govt has given the freedom to farmers to select the customer of their choice.
It is nowhere mentioned that farmers have to sign contract farming agreement with any corporate company and that they have to sell it only to Corporate companies.
Farmers are given full freedom to sell their products to any one of their choice.
Hence, none of the above amendments will give rise to any adverse effect, on farmers earning.
One draw back is politicians will loose commission income which they used to loot from poor farmers for the last 70 years and their cartel can not decide the selling price of any produce of farmers. No doubt, State Govt will loose 10% mandi tax levied on poor farmers but State Govt can easily make up for the above losses by increasing the tax on liquor/ cigarettes,etc or by curtailing the free bees given to rich people like free scooters given to working women, free laptops given to students of rich people, free rations given to Govt employees / tax payers, free Deepavali and Pongal gifts given to affluent families, levying 10% tax on donations received by trusts owned and operated by politicians, levying 10% cess on pension money received by politicians, like MLA, MP, Municipal councillors,etc., ( as the donations received by any political party and the pensions received by MLA,MP, Councillor, etc., are exempted from income tax, State Govt can levy just 10% cess to compensate the loss caused due to forecasted reduction in revenue on mandi tax) etc.,
Nice... Mohan.... again 10% tax of state will be on the head of all people (I.e. Low .. middle... high class).putting cess on MPs & MLAs or any politician is a dream without any future & which never come true.... Moreover, cold storage may be constructed by state govt for storage purpose......As on date, our nation depends on only one pvt sector which is known to all... which leads to monopoly in future..... When monopoly started it will be big loss to farmer and heavy price hike to people. Further, our constitution is so flexible that, any govt can amend or create new act easily. What is the guarantee in future that another Govt will not amend that x company invest on cold storage in Crores... Farmers have to sell commodities to x company only,.... then what will happen....... We are in the democratic country but there is no democratic & fundamental rights....
Whether FCI will be removed ?
@@gowrishankarch.2926
FCI is another corrupted dept of GOI.
They used to pay Rs.6lakhs per month as salary to a coolie who used to load and unload the wheat / rice bags.
So, you can imagine how much others will be paid or shown as paid in their books of account , to the Govt.
This is in addition to the losses shown as quantity eaten by rats, pests and grains spoiled due to poor storage and handling by employees of FCI
No one is answerable for all such losses just because it is Govt dept and the employees are protected by trade union leaders belonging to opposition parties .
All such lootings and wastages are done from
the tax paid by us.
If you want Modi Govt to continue such wastages of tax payers money for doing such loss making business in the name of "food security" , they will continue the same and we have to go on paying more and more taxes year after year.
Alternatively,, if the Govt encourages farmers to form a "farmers society" in each and every villages and with the loan given by the Banks, if they start warehouses in their village, then they can immediately procure farm produce from local farmers and preserve it meticulously in their warehouse and supply it to the Govt with a reasonable profit, as and when required by the Govt. This will give rise to a win - win situation to both the farmers and the Govt . In other words, each and every village in our country can act as a warehouse for the Govt of India and Govt can save huge wage bill paid to FCI employees and the wastage of food grain will come to the lowest level as farmers will take utmost precaution to preserve it from rodent, pets,etc and overcome its wastage caused due to direct exposure to rain or due to water seepage through leaking roof, of the warehouse,etc.,
The above arrangement, if implemented it will generate employment to local farmers with better remuneration and discourages them in migrating to cities for employment.
If opposition party leaders have enough money to invest, then they can also invest in such warehouses rather than investing in Engineering colleges as running a Engineering colleges has become a non lucrative business with the launch of IITs in each and every states.
New Bill's will remove middlemen that's it.. farmers and consumers will have the same problem.. with this new Bill's.. the business will be transferred from mandi owner, commission guys, brokers, retailers to big companies like reliance who has the supermarkets... additionally statement governments will be loosing taxes... its again on ppl head..
@@ChinnathambiParasu
You are under the wrong impression that Modi Govt wants to promote Reliance Industries as a monopoly trader for the entire nation in marketing " farm produce" of our farmers.
The recent amendment gives farmers the freedom to sell their farm produce to anyone of their choice, anywhere in the country by eliminating the corrupted Permit Raj system.
Reliance Retail is closing down their units one by one as they are unable to compete with other local retail traders. Hence, whether Reliance Retail will survive in the market after 5years, is itself doubtful.
If opposition party people who acted as Commission Agent's in APMC markets, can offer better price to farmers and buy their their farm produce, from their farms then Reliance Retail will automatically get closed on its own.
I understand that our Arakkonam DMK MP has invested around Rs.26000 crores in Sri Lanka to commission one Refinery to refine crude oil. He could have very well invested that amount in TN to buy BSNL's TN shares from GOI and could have given better telecom services to the people of TN or he could have utilised that money to promote units to compete with Reliance Retail at least in TN circles so that our farmers would have got better price for their *farm produce" and generated employment to people of TN, thereby we could have forced early closure of Reliance Retail in TN.
No Govt would have prevented him from setting up such industries anywhere in TN. Unfortunately, our opposition leaders do not prefer to invest their earnings in India to generate employment for us but prefer to invest in other countries and they blame local people, especially Ambani, Adani, as and when they start any industries or businesses in India.
Modi Govt has already asked Reliance Industries to surrender Krishna - Godavari oil fields to the Govt as they are unable to pump the contracted qty of crude oil and natural gas and their licence to supply arms and ammunition required for our Navy, is cancelled due to delay in meeting the supply requirements of Navy.
Hence, kindly do not fall prey to the false propaganda of opposition parties that Modi Govt wants to promote only Reliance Industries or Adani Industries. Modi Govt wants each and every one of us have to become industrialists, business people or promoter of startups,etc so that India will progress in all fields. If you come across with any difficulty in starting any industrial units or business houses or start ups and if Modi Govt policies remain as a bottle neck for promotion of the same, then you can raise your voice through public medias so that your concerns will be heard of by Modi Govt and they will do the needful.
Let us not become prey for the false propoganda of our opposition party leaders but remain as a patriotic citizens of India and promote our country's prosperity and security so that our children can have a peaceful and prosperous country to live.
My god! Brilliant explanation in the clearest of voices. I wish this channel hits the million club real soon
Thank you for making this vedio brother it really helped me get a hold of all that
is going on.
Good explanation. A point in price rise for consumers: we are forgetting that if there is sufficient competition, prices will take of itself.
What if it creates monopoly in the market just like telecom.
which competition?? how many private companies will go to buy crop from a 5 acre farmer?? most farmers are less than that.
@@geethkumar89 telecom is not monopolized.
@@dhirendrasinhrana202 what if in the case of floods or draught cultivation costs increases more, and still the output is less with some low quality due to unseasoned rains or some factors then the companies bid for lowest price with that we can't even get cultivation costs if you have a farming background and worked in the fields then you will get to know
@@akhilreddy7408 do remember that for such circumstances of natural calamity/flood/draught, we already have the Kisan Fasal Biman Yojana.
“*it doesn’t matter as it is going to pinch my pocket and yours*”
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣that was amazing btw..!!!
I think you got him wrong😂
No No this will tear your pockets steal your purse too.
Aimann Shakeel indeed🤣🤣🤣
very informative....thank you so much for explaining the farm laws in simple terms with your beautiful presentation
9:45 no they have not.
There is a reason why these three bills were proposed at the same time. As you said, the private companies will try their absolute best to buy at a cheap price from the farmers, and using the third bill, they will sell it at an exorbitant price to the consumers. Both the farmer AND the daily consumer lose but the private companies benefit.
After hearing this, why isn't every common man on the street protesting?
This is scary as the private players will inevitable exploit the farmers and all of us.
@Puneet Garg the point is, improve the existing Infrastructure, guarantee MSP and then invite private players.
@Puneet Garg he is saying the same thing. For first 2 3 years private will pay good prices the farmers will move towards private and then monopoly will exist. See the condition of BSNL. Jio first made free and attracted towards itself and then slowly slowly making plans higher( i know data plans are lower than previous but compare today prices with 2016-17). Same thing goes here. Mere be private company hoge me be same strategy lagunga profit jo kamana hai..
Major private players like reliance retail, spencer, big basket already buy directly from farmers.... will help farmers but will be high on middle-class pockets.
@@stormshadow2012 exactly. First create a level playing field empower Farmers then bring in or roll out to free markets
@@user-pu6op6hs8j bruh literally comparing BSNL and jio? Do you know how much loss BSNL was in? Or it was denied 3g infrastructure? Even after giving many bailouts, they weren't able to recover. And talking about other companies, well I agree that jio does have a monopoly in the telecom sector but one reason can be their facilities... Vodafone-idea don't provide good network. Airtel is trying.
Don't know for how long it would be same but it has been 4 years of good services...
Thank you so much for this video sir. We'd really appreciate more such videos on current issues. Please keep them coming! Yours are way more informative than the other channels. 🙏
The speaker should be lauded for his unbiased and clear thinking which were transformed into intelligible expressions!Thank you sir!
Few things for consideration are:
1. A small farmer will anyway either suffer, or , may not take advantage of the price increase! So, the protest/agitation that is going on does not suggest any way forward for a small farmer.
2. The Mandiwalas will anyway benefit, either thru Mandis/APMCs. The mandiwala cum farmer will enjoy the best advantages and they will even team up with the Corporates against whom they are protesting(no friend or enemy in making money together!)
3. Unless there is a specific solution to protect small and marginal farmers, the protest is just political and is an expression of opposition to the Government at the centre. The Centre may not achieve much by following the dictates of the bill, though, they may not create more harm to the small and marginal farmers than what is being experienced by them now.
Very educational! This brings so much more clarity. Thanks for the detailed explanation.
Sir,
I m in love with Ur accent,Voice & the way u explain everything so clearly....It's really admirable....So soothing to our ears...
As a newbie, I referred 2 resources on this topic before reaching here...They are elaborate but couldn't understand ....This is simple and easily understandable
THE FARMERS (EMPOWERMENT AND PROTECTION) AGREEMENT
ON PRICE ASSURANCE AND FARM SERVICES ACT, 2020
egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2020/222040.pdf
Simple and clear explanation of the bill. But u missed to mention that farmer can choose his buyer and no force or legal obligations to sell to private companies. If he still chooses to sell APC he gets MSP support or to company to get more than MSP price. He is a king if he manages better.
So u r saying this bill impacts Big farmers not small farmers that is true. Big farmers means he is rich and current MSP support ensuring his regular tax free income for second grade or third grade crops produced by them . Same people who are making ruckus at Delhi today.
U provide content after deepest investigation which take alot time for a people like me and u make it easy coz there's no Need of an investigation after watching ur videos.. 🙏
Just wow. The voice, the way of explaining the system and along with an example. The visuals love to see more of the videos. Just keep it up.
Now I finally realised the points of both sides, now I feel not only farmers eveyone shud protest tbh 😶
no.
Can u pls tell why u feel that??
Exactly bro. Bill is for protection but bill contains many loopholes.
I appreciate the time in the effort what you have put into this video and the sketch to understand it
And also gives me knowledge about the 2020 act for farmers and the individual entrepreneurs Wishing you a good luck and looking forward to see more videos 🤝👍🏻