Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb solo cover (Sylwia Urban)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มี.ค. 2012
- Listen to my original music here : phosphere.biglink.to/bb
Solo from this song was my friend's favourite guitar solo, so I decided to play it for her as a birthday gift. Originally, I recorded it on CD and gave her a physical copy, then I uploaded it here on YT later. This is why there are those pages out there. Basically, I wrote "Hey happy birthday" on the pages.
Find me on FB / sylvieplayer
or instagram @sylvieplayer - เพลง
Listen to my own music! th-cam.com/video/ptf9cXR7upg/w-d-xo.html
***** Amazing. Hope to hear more of you... and hoping to buy your first CD soon.
***** both beautiful, just needs a better feedback on processor...um the biggest fan of Pink Floyd and obviously Sir Gilmour's... its really amazing to see someone plays that nice.... carry onnnnnn..........tk cr.
ว
+Sylwia Urban I GREW UP IN THE 70"S AND 80"S MUSIC AND WISH I COULD HAVE PLAYED THE GUITAR. MISS SYLWIA URBAN I SALUTE YOU. BEAUTIFUL JOB WELL DONE.
+Sylwia Urban Well done, I know David would be impressed, he will be 70 in March.
As a player for the better part of about 40 years, I wanted to commend you on your excellent playing. In particular, you have very good vibrato and are able to successfully merge lead and rhythm in the solo. Well done - thanks for posting.!
Absolutly great. I love it when young people still like PF.
I agree! Greatness never really goes away!
@@ckat609 I was lucky enough to see them in concert three times. Outstanding!!!!
@@CaptTom11 man... you're lucky! I wish I had. I hope I can get to experience the bliss that is david gilmour one day, before the inevitable
@@ckat609 Right on. He is the best...:)
The riff she throws in at 150 to 155 is gold. Nicely played
Just the best version of this I have ever heard. This girl has incredible feel. Shredders take note - vibrato, tone, phrasing, timing, feel, soul. Speed is meaningless when compared to this level of musicality.
YES!!! I hear YOUR voice in his solo! You made that piece your own, love your phrasing, your uniqueness to an awesome solo, and you nailed it! Good job girl, very well done!!
Still listening these years later! One of the best covers I’ve heard!
WOW !! Really smooth style, this girl has some real talent !!
Excellence is not something found often, it is the best i've ever heard anywhere other than Pink Floyd playing live. Nicely done
Wow.. you did your own thing, and with alot of soul, and you do something that is VERY rare, you let the notes breathe!
I really loved listening, please keep making and sharing your music.
no such word as "ALOT"!!
Sylwia just delivers the emotion. Just amazing.....
You nailed it, goosebumps and tears just like when i listen to Gilmour
This is the only cover of comfortably numb I've seen that makes me shiver down my spine
Love the tone of the guitar gives it edge. I like it when someone doesn't play a solo exactly note for note it makes it your style. Top marks 🏴😁
I heard a lot of covers of this song but you do it with so much feeling, your the best.
Most rewarding tone of the several covers I have listened to this afternoon....
Love the way you play this - very smooth and soothing, complemented by such a rich gorgeous tone. I keep coming back to listen again :)
Excellently played; and I think you got the feeling just fine and with your own flavour
I can't help it, but the tears are coming down my face whenever I'm listening to your version of this otherworldly song
I just stumbled on this video and was watching when my wife came in. She loves Pink Floyd and I told her to just listen to this solo for a minute, then told her to look at the screen...She says, "Wow! She's excellent! She's Polish!" My Sweetheart is from Krakow and said that she recognized your name as being Polish. When your video finished, I started again and asked her to read the cards you were flipping before you began playing. She said that you were sending birthday greetings to Madziu and that this solo was a gift for her. Very nice - you made our day! Thank you!
I'm quite blown away by this. Really good.
Kevin Southam She is GREAT isn't she guys !!! ...Young too...Awesome !!!
It's very difficult for me to hear people imitate Pink Floyd (I even have a hard time hearing some of their own stuff live, as the studio versions were so immaculate) but I stayed through your whole video. ;) Great work!
It was fantastic! I wish there were more known female guitar players back when I was younger. The future keeps getting brighter with so much female talent that continuously blows my mind. I have major respect for people like you who are stepping in front of the pack shining bright as the sun!
I come back and listen to this every once in a while with my eyes shut... its just a beautiful sound...
HOLY FUCK!!! Honestly I did not expect it to be this good.
Nice interpretation of it with a lot of focus on slower bends and resonance of the note which is what Gilmour is all about. Great job.
Listened to a lot of these and keep coming back to this, the best in my opinion. Great playing.
I still come back to this video for inspiration! amazing tone and so much soul!
Wróciłem tu po latach i nadal tak samo mi się podoba.
Best version on TH-cam ever, I listen it like everyday since it cames out. I love you Sylwia =D
Look the cover from Thomas75S
Look for Noeli Anjos, from Brazil
Wooohoooo!!!!!!! Get it girl!!!!!! That was brilliant... simply brilliant!
Beautiful...simply beautiful. Well played
Well I actually saw David Gilmour play this with Pink Floyd - which is one of the best concerts I ever saw - but this is an awesome version. A lot of people play this solo but not many have put the feeling into it that you do. Nice one thank you...
Haha! Feeling, what feeling?
Baron BangTidy The feeling that ignorant imbeciles like you apparently missed...
Exactly.
***** The problem here is the conflation of IQ with musical talent. Can you support your assumption that the two are somehow related? Sounds like correlating eye color with the ability to count cards at blackjack.
Phil Surtees Jimmy hendrix said that 'blues is easy to play but hard to feel'.
She sorta looks like david gilmour
+DWHITTZ When she tilts her head downwards. :D
+DWHITTZ The resemblance is uncanny.. Not that she looks like a guy at all. Just similar facial structure, like a female David.
+DWHITTZ Holy shit, no joke.
Like @SequenceWork said though, she doesn't look like a guy at all but she looks like she could be his daughter.
Jesus your right
+DWHITTZ no she doesnt ....what the hell is wrong with you?
Again, superb. you are very talented, keep those covers coming ....a fan
Sylvia, you have taken that Fender and created magic. What a sound you have created. The world needs more Sylwias. Nothing more need be said.
Wow, very well done!
TOTAL COOLNESS!
Sylwia Urban...Isn't music a wonderfully universal thing?!! Fantastic!
Lots of people play this, but Sylwia really puts the style and feel to it like only DG seems to do...Well done!
This is like the softest, sexiest version of this solo I've ever heard.
Fantstic!!!!!
Brilliant! A joy to see a beautiful youngster playing a rock anthem!
Am I dreaming .....You go girl!!!!! Thats awesomeeee!!!
It's good to see the young playing the good stuff ;)
I know talent when I see it. She's good.
thats a cool dp bro!
Sriks91 thanks :)
talent is when you can play your own thing from the heart and make it sound good as your own masterpiece, she's good but she's just playing gilmours amazing solo, even if she plays it amazingly
I'm not saying she doesn't have talent, just that this doesn't show it
Dylan Ficeto even though is not her own original piece, it got her 3+ million views. She does have talent and i agree, she should try her own stuff and see where it takes her
just about brought a tear to my eye...to see a young, female Floyd devotee reproduce this sound is uplifting..power on mighty spirit.
Excellent tone and your bends are fantastic. This is where most people fail, getting those bends so snappy and accurate is really hard and yours are brilliant. Very clean and each note was crafted beautifully. Great job.
She plays with grace. Almost like a cellist or playing a harp. Very nice.
Thank you
very true!
I love this ! Nice work :)
Alex M
André riesci a venire
Awesome job Sylwia! I could listen to this 100 times, so smooth for your level. If I heard you playing this in person at a party I would crap! Nice!
Absolutely magnificent!
I'm an old dude (49) that has been playing professionally since I was 14. I could play Eruption by Van Halen in my sleep. I just wanted to say, ignore the idiot that tried to shoot you down on here. You sounded LIKE David Gilmore. You rock my friend! Keep it up. :-)
Great solo by great girl:-)
omg this is freaking amazing . that tone and that phasing . great job !
AMAZING!! I love it, Sylvia😃👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Rites on baby amazing quality clear sound -performing!
Dimi Platon luv it!
Finally someone playing Comfortably Numb almost correctly. You have the bends in there very nicely. For the long sustained notes, though, turn to your wammy bar and give it a good shake or two. Watch his New York session and you will see what I mean.
Who ever said to use the whammy bar for more sustain??? David uses it for more vibrato on the sustained notes and that is the only thing she is missing in David's style of play. The only thing.
Awesome young lady! One of the all time great solos!
Fantastic Sylwia!
This almost made me cry
Sie ma Sylw trzymam kciuki, ja stary piernik i chałturzysta nie gram tak jak Ty, trzym sie laska i nie przejmuj sie pajacowym komentarzom, wkładaj w to serce a kiedys Santana przyjdzie do Ciebie na korki, niech moc będzie z Tobą!
Fantastic. Wow! Beautiful
She feels it in her voicing...beautifully done...her take on it is wonderful🌗
U could be David gilmours daughter.
Cooool.....
Or granddaughter! Haha! I made the same observation a few months ago. ;-)
OR MY NEW GIRLFRIEND
she looks a lot like him!
awesome
Sylwia your a great guitarist and beautiful woman... I enjoy listening to all your music and can listen to you all day... Great job!!
Really nice job. You've dialed in the tone really good on this classic!
what about your set-up? this the best tone I've heard in TH-cam for this cover!
th-cam.com/video/ynSc2oYemsE/w-d-xo.html
here is the craziest one th-cam.com/video/MRqjOuhZsoY/w-d-xo.html
Agreed tone is awesome.
... you guys are kidding right
Wow, you even look like Gilmour
It's his daughter
Im fucking dead😂😂😂
Faceless Trauma grow up...
She doesn't look like him but has that stoic presence. And yes maybe kind of looks like him in the early Floyd days😂
I'll let her decide if that's a compliment
I only started playing guitar 5 months ago and I love listening to this (and watching the technique) almost as much as I enjoy listening to the original David Gilmour version.
Wow! So beautiful! So amazing! Thank you!
David Gilmour would be proud.
Great playing. Don`t pay attention to the negative and rude comments. They are all coming from jealousy and stupidity, and I bet none of them can play a single tune.
Keep up the good work, girl.
That doesnt make any sense. You can learn from those "negative" comments, most of them are posted by people who know something about guitar\music. I would say that she did it great, but she should follow the beat a little better, the drummer is the god when you talk about tempo.
Oh my god this is so perfect..your improvisation is on point.
Thanks girl! Great to see a youngster who knows what is worth listening, playing and growing from!
Kudos...
great tone. a little tip that maybe you've already sorted out for yourself, but @00:25 you bend the 14th fret of the B string up that nice sweet half step bend but you take it to the edge of the fingerboard and at the tail end you hear it clip the edge. My advice as a player is to generally bend toward the middle of the neck. so top 3 (E B G) bending up and bottom three (D A E) bending down (i.e. in all cases in towards the middle of the neck. cheers.
just finished listening and wanted to add that you have a really great vibrato, way to go!
I liked the vibrato quite a bit! I wish she'd have used the bridge pickup and included some pinch harmonics.
May God continue to Bless you. That was GREAT!
That was bang on! Loved it!
A beautiful young lady who has an enormous amount of talent.
She will go far with that talent
Alan Synnott I think she will most certainly do so. I Subscribed to her channel, and her own work is just AWESOME!
awesome girl! david Gilmour world be pride of you.
Sorry, but, nope, David Gilmour don't give a shit about her. But, she is awesome, really :)
The best guitar solo ever. Beautifully played too well done Sylwia.
The sound is fantastic!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Oh My God! The Sound is fantastic! It is POD 2.0 ? ...
+Hovori Cml The tone is okay. It was Line6 Toneport
+Sylwia Urban The smoothness of the tone on that bend at 0:40 is unrivaled
+Exho Agreed.
+Sylwia Urban
understaement... most raw and awsome sound
Do you guys know what speakers to use for software, to get a sound like this?
mnie też się podoba :)
Amazing, I never tire of this
YOU nailed it. Perfekt tone and music choice. Love it
Muy buen cover el mejor :3 , eres muy hermosa :3 :) :* !!! ***** :3
I like the variation you put into it. The tone was also perfect, and while you could use the whammy bar I think you did just fine. My only question is what guitar is that?
Fender Stratocaster
Really? I've never seen one that looked like this. It looks so... big. Maybe she's just short...
STUNNING! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I love your version better than most covers, you really did such a good job.
That was awesome, Sylwia! You did a great job! If I closed my eyes, I'd think it was Gilmour himself playing! Rock on, girl and don't listen to idiots like "John Smith" (John Smith! Sure!)
Might I ask why she shouldn't listen to those who don't like her cover, and tell her why they don't?
Sub Royalty Did you bother to read John Smith's comment below? You need an explanation for that? Sheesh!
Sub Royalty I think Mr. Nunez said it better than I ever could! I didn't see your reply until I saw his. Thanks, Luis!
Wow grosse klasse!
A very Iconic and Powerful solo to cover, great job keep it up!
Thanks for posting. Good to hear someone making a well known piece their own. Keep playing.
A jeżeli nie jestem Madzią to też mogę posłuchać?
śmiało :)
:)
After watching you, I watched David Glmour at the Royal Festival, and he does not play it as well as you do, for one thing your bends have more life (say more). He may have written it, and maybe you can't do that yet, but you can play it, and maybe that is why your version has been pulled twice as many times as his. You can smile about that. Check it out, David may be better a lot of tmes, but not this time. You really have great feel for this, like a singer, not a shredder.
*****
If you listen to Chuck Berry play "Johnny B. Goode" twice, you will hear plenty of missing notes and mistakes. Mark Knopfler said when he was growing up everyone learned Chet Atkin's material, "even the mistakes". No mention if Chester agreed that there were mistakes. Louis Armstrong thought that flatted fifths were a cheap and tawdry plea for affection. And you can compare Gilmore other guitarists, Don Felder's "Hotel California", I suspect, sold more and has more covers. Judging guitar playing is not like weighing gold, it is more like picking which painting you like. If you consider the affect you want to create, leaving some notes out may not be a mistake. A lot of people, seem to like this version and I am sure 90%, and I, did not notice which notes were missing, but if you like Gilmore's versions better (no missing notes in those? Hard to imagine), good for you.
***** missing notes ? even Gilmour plays hundred versions of this solo
she aint gunna sleep with you
Great job , you made my skin crawl the way it did when I first heard this solo.!
:)
this rocks...so much better than other covers! One small problem, it doesn't appear natural. Why are you concentrating so hard? Maybe you need to stop using picks. Let your face match the flow of your fingers.
LET YOUR FACE MATCH THE FLOW OF YOUR FINGERS.
Such a wonderful life changing story.
Zenomexican Yuo yourself are whiny little jealous nitpcking bitch. And you know that.
She can post whatever she wants, what ever language she wants to you tube as long as it does not offend anybody. English is not the only language in you tube and in the world and you tube is for everyone. Her cover was ment to be public, not the message.
This was indeed one of the best cover from this solo in you tube, deal with it.
Please post your own version of it, we would really like to hear and comment.
Zenomexican No he did not come even close to that but you did, mean it or not. And your language tells it all. "fucktards" is that some new word or what ? haha. Actually your idiotism is more than you tube trolls have offered for a while. Dont bother to reply. Go and spit your anger to somewhere else. I will not read futher comments from you.
It's funny how you assume I'm Mexican just because it's in my name. Proves how much of an artard you are. And no. I said fucktards. Learn to read.
Fuckstars. Hahaha.
Her expression looks no different than Gilmour's does when he plays it! :-D