Вы ни как не можете понять одного, Русские как ни кто любят свободу. И эта их любовь и создаёт великую культуру. Ваша пропаганда рассказала вам о том, что Русские дикие волосатые животные. Когда вы очнётесь, вы поймёте, что мы не враги вам, а ваши друзья. Но до тех пор, пока вам рассказывают басни о Русских и России, мы ни когда не будем вместе.
You were happy with your words. I'm 65 years old and I've never seen anything like it. I would certainly say that the only one who would do this would be Gilmour
I’m 56 years old. A life long Floyd fan. I’m a guitarist myself, so I know the work that goes into nailing this sort of thing. I’ve listened to ‘countless’ versions of this incredible piece of music, and I can honestly say that yours is the best! I listened for every dive bomb, squeal, double stops. You got it spot on!! Brilliant job!! Karl. London. England. 🏴
As a 59yr old still learning!! I could not agree more, timing, feeling, expression, note for note perfect and oozing confidence. His playing is truly admirable!! It pains me to see 357 thumbs down, even if it is a small percentage of the number of views, it is simply wrong, if they did not enjoy it they did not need to watch, if they can find fault then they should have the decency to say so in comments!! No one minds constructive criticism, not that there is room or scope for that in this case. Where are the videos of these 357 people showing us how they could have done this better? It surprises me they managed to get their thumbs out their mouths long enough to hit dislike!! Oh to be as perfect as they must consider themselves!! They must love themselves more than only a mother could, I bet if they could kiss their own Ass, they would!!
@@maxbenkard3455 My!! My!! Jealousy is not an admirable trait!! I rewatched this after reading your comment, to mime this would be almost impossible!! Note for note perfect, every vibrato, every tremolo, every dive, every pull up, every string pick, every rake!! Not one slip up anywhere!! Yet when singers mime they often fail to simply open their mouths in time!! Since you are so clever I expect to see your demonstration of miming playing this!! Come on!! Show us all exactly how it's done!! Seems to me this would be easier to play ( not that it is easy!!) than it would be to fake, so Come on!! Show us what you've got!! Put up or Shut up!!
@@josdircken4412 Жаль мы с тобой не проживем еще 100 лет. Но будет так как я сказал, Пинк Флойд и Сатриани - это очень большая разница. Сатриани по сравнению с Пинк Флойд - никто. Я таких как Сатриани слышал сотни. Но такую музыку как Пинк Флойд не делает никто.
@@musikmaury LOL that's a more classy way than saying "hah, post your own before criticising". However, it makes the same mistake in thinking that you have to be able to do something in order to appreciate it. In fact a non-guitarist could just as easily point out that your downward run is completely out of time. That being said, I'll see what I can do before too long.
It's funny you wrote that because I keep coming back to this video. It is absolutely amazing. It's getting to the point where I have watched this solo over David Gilmour's solo on Pulse.
Its absolutelly awsome and perfect. I really love this cover, i can’t understand who could dislike it. Congrats. And Mr Thomas its one of the greatest on the youtube!!!!
It’s been 7 years and I haven’t found not even one video with someone playing pulse solo like this! This is absolutely mind blowing. Just close your eyes!
Best cover of this iconic solo on the Internet. Its not about technically playing the chords, it's about capturing the soul that Gilmour transmits through the strings. Gilmours guitar speaks to you. And you've nailed it my friend.
I'm listening this cover version from past 5 years and counting. It's the best cover I heard Edit: 13-Feb-2024 My mother passed away last year on Feb and this brings tear on my eyes. High on rum and going down and down
Just think that life is tough, she wouldn't be happy if she knew that you are going through such a pain going down and down, such as you wouldn't be happy knowing that she is going that way without you. Get your self up man, life is capable to give you everything you want if you just try your best. You have the best community here supporting you
I’ve probably said this before, but there isn’t a better cover of any song out there or maybe even a better overall guitar player. This guy is so good I cant believe it still. I defy anyone to find a better player or cover. Incredible.
Периодически захожу почитать восторженные комментарии и порадоваться тому, как по-настоящему шедевральные версии абсолютно шедевральных произведений находят своих почитателей и ценителей. Чистая магия
I’ve listened to this solo a billion times between David Gilmore and others who have covered it and I tell you this that your solo is second to only David Gilmore himself. Absolutely stunningly played! Well Done!!!!!!
John Garrett Yupp i am abselutly 110% With you on this😊😊👌👌👌 This cover Version of this legendery guitar solo,done by Andrey Korolov here it,s soooo incredble GOOD and has a perfectly tonal,Wibb arm,tone,up/down strenght stroke control,pull'on'off and pitch are perfectly executed and are a pice of musicaly Ear CANDY
Try Tina S.... She does it all without the whammy bar... And puts Gilmore to task. Watching Gilmore now is boring. If this kid is mimicking Gilmore... He needs to look further for inspiration.
Kevin Jordan Yupp,,i do actually agree whith you,,,looking at gilmoure now is a bitt boring,,,But what is so impressive by this KID is his unbelivble perfect timing,,som effortles and flowless.(sorry for my bad english,,im from Norway) Check Out this KID,,he has al lot if videos,this Version here is several years old,,i do now about the super chic Tina S......she is way more than good
@@dock_su @ Здесь речь совсем не о том,никто под сомнение не ставит величие великого Гилмора,а о том как Андрей из всех смог блестяще исполнить легендарное соло из всех вариантов других гитаристов.Все и так знают что Гилмору принадлежит это соло,речь о том что Андрей лучше всего его повторил. Есть кто лучше оригинала повторяет лунную походку,так что все говорят что Майкл Джексон так себе ее исполнил,нет конечно,ему одному принадлежат лавры,потому как он ее придумал,все просто восхищаются мастерством копии походки.
I hope you are aware, Andrey, that you reached an insane level of perfection and skills! You are genius, a rare gem. I am a Pink Floyd fan, I love "Pulse" version of this solo, and all I can say is that your performance is, in my humble opinion, much better than David Gilmour's, and he is the king of guitar solos! Basically, you did the impossible. You have my deepest respect.
I found this by simply browsing through youtube. I'm an original Pink Floyd fan and I was lucky enough to have been at the Pulse concert. The solo performed here was perfect. Every cover drops clanger and plays a bad note or two, not the case here. . . Just close your eyes and ride the tide, simply let the music do its magic
I’m 61 and have been a Floyd fan since the early 70’s and I must say this is absolutely the finest musicianship I’ve run across. Your cover of this epic solo is spot on. Some here have said this is second only to the original played by the master himself. However I feel it is absolutely on par and every bit as good as David’s original performance. As a fellow guitarist I applaud you !
I totally agree!! Dove in Sicilia? I was at Comiso Air Station from 1989-91…so many memories and great people! I can still hear the voice in the mercato della settimana, “Dieci mille lira!!” 😊
@jake I live in Palermo. Thanks for the kind words, in 1991/92 I did my military service in the Navy and was on duty at the NATO base in Isola delle Femmine ( Pa) .many greetings.
th-cam.com/video/f_PHy4mLSss/w-d-xo.html what do you think about this version??? please subscribe to my channel! I work to make video editing of digital audio with tutorial and guide.
All the fight between pentatonic and diatonic scales...all the blue notes, dives and bends. I'm 28 now, I hope to still ear this when I become 68 or more. Legendary Gilmour, Legend of legends. And you sir, you are one of his horsemen. Much love to your work here. From Portugal, respect to the eternity!!
I have heard a lot of guitarist play this solo and in fairness they are all truly amazing. But listening to this, the one thing that this guy Andrey has over all others is his apparent ability to channel Dave Gilmore when playing this solo because I can honestly say I have never heard anyone so accurately emulate what I believe to be the greatest guitar solo of all time so masterfully. Pure Genius.
By far the best “comfortably numb” pulse cover on the internet!!! No one even gets this close to the man himself David Gilmore, except Andrey! I would pay mega bucks to Andrey perform this live with a pink Floyd tribute band!!
I think its pre recorded and then videoed. But the timings so close so hard to tell. Most guitar vids are done this way now hence the doubt people are beginning to have wether its real or not. I want to say he’s playing it live but how clean it is it seems pre recorded. But hey he might have just had one of those magic runs on a good day we all have 🤷♂️
@@VeganStance no ones that clean. Every note is perfect and you can see where he hits certain strings but you dont hear it which means its had production after. Nothing wrong with it but i prefer raw. I like the little mistakes they sometimes lead to some awesome things. He can obviously play but not even gilmore sounds that good live and its his song.
@@crystllclr3743 He might have done some post editing but if you look closely, not much, if any. When you compare this to Gilmour's pulse live version, this is way cleaner. It might have took him quite a few shots though, while Gilmour only had one take. Check out Kingfish's Empty Promises in Nashville. You'll find zero mistakes in one of the best live solos of all times (and that's a live performance btw, not a bedroom recorded one).
This is the 70th time I am listening to this and still can not believe how good you are. This is beyond perfection and if you are a true pink floyd fan, you would notice the perfection. So many people try to cover but they massacre. The tone, bending, feelings, everything is top top level. You could wear a Gilmour mask and sell out arenas.
At a certain time the solo sent a shiver on my spine, got a sense of awakening and I was looking around me. It was like to be in another place in the universe, and everything was different. Once the solo was over, I was back to the reality of my room with my phone in the palm of my hand. Suddenly I realized that even though I am no longer young still I can feel like a child who hears its first song. Thank you, guy for these rare sensations, and thank you for this amazing music!
THIS!!!!! You described it perfectly! Probably this word may not be the most proper, but this version is super "sensual" in a way. As you described it, it's like being in another universe. I experience it as riding a wave of sound. It's so, so, SO amazing... .
Хоть увидела, как это выглядит вблизи. Слушаю пинков со школьной скамьи. Соло комфортного онемения считаю лучшим у Гилмора. А Вам - браво!!!! Это лучший кавер, что слышала!!!
Редчайший случай. Подписчиков почти вполовину меньше, чем ЛАЙКОВ. РЕАЛЬНО ОБАЛДЕННО!!! Но если Гилмор неожиданно умрет, то ЕГО ДЕЛО ПРОДОЛЖИТСЯ БЕЗ ПРОБЛЕМ!!!))) ТАК играть можно ТОЛЬКО ДУШОЙ!!!! Эта композиция - НЕ МУЗЫКА! ЭТО КРИК ДУШИ!!! И еще РЕДЧАЙШИЙ случай... Слушаю ЭТОТ кавер чаще и с большим удовольствием, чем ОРИГИНАЛ....
Playing correct notes is one thing, but you captured the flow, that euphoric, exhilarating feeling one gets when listening to "Comfortably Numb" solo, or many other times when we hear David Gilmour play. Ultimate aural ecstasy. Played bravely, without any hesitation, makes it even more convincing.
Конец 2024! Посчитаемся?) Превосходная игра Андрея заставляет возвращаться вновь и вновь. Данная композиция Pink Floyed была первым знакомством с данной группой. Мой папа в далёких 2000х открыл для меня новую страсть. Слушая эту песню, я каждый раз его вспоминаю, так как 4 года назад он ушёл из этого мира, как раз в разгар пандемии. Андрей, продолжайте играть! Вы мастер!
Very moving to watch this. Very emotional touch and feel. You are certainly gifted. Thank you for sharing this amazing video of probably the best ever solo of all time . . .
I have yet to hear a better cover of my all-time favorite Comfortably Numb Pulse solo, and I have listened to literally all of them for over a decade. Congratulations!
Something always brings me to this video. It is like a drug. When I need my spirits to be lifted, I watch this video. You are a very talented young man. ROCK ON ANDREY!!!
This is the only cover version that really nails it 100% here on TH-cam ... IF someone did it better it was maybe David Gilmour himself. Awesome work, Andrey and thanks for sharing.
ive seen 235 versions on you tube ( took me weeks ) this is by far the best outside of tutorials wwhich im pretty sure hell end up doing as well cos he has some neat tricks ,best version ive seen outside of the pink floyd family n thats a huge feather in his cap :)
Yes, one did it better with his own improvisation. I love it more than the original because this version is extended to minutes. Talking about Kfir Ochaion’s Comfortably Numb solo with the Cobra Blue Fender American Ultra HSS Stratocaster. Amazing improvisation of a true masterpiece by David Gilmour. :)
@@Acepilot1312 there is no improvisation here. It's the exact same from PULSE album. The short version is from The Wall album... this is from PULSE album...…..
Caveman Protogonos yeah, but what i’m meaning is that, its extremely difficult to play continuously for 10 minutes straight, at-least for most of us. And also, i don’t know that much about David Gilmour’s songs as i just discovered him by this Comfortably Numb song, so I don’t know what his albums are. :)
I grew up with this from Pink Floyd, AND DAVIDS AWESOME LICKS! at 71 now I am pleased to see our younger generation be moved by the master piece of guitar work called Comfortably numb! It shows how timeless music really is! ROCK ON KIDS! It doesn't get better than this !!🎸 Carry on.
For the first time of my life, I can say that I completely fall in love with a guitar solo. As a Pink Floyd fan I would say that's impossible to do better than Gilmour but men... you've already did it. Thank you so much. You're a great great great Guitarist.
Hitting the translate button over and over shows me just how different English and Russian are. There is literally no correlation between words. If it were Spanish, it would be an almost word for word replacement between English and Spanish words. Russian is wildly different, with a completely different alphabet. Crazy to me.
Rarely enough I comment on somenone's cover of Pink Floyd songs since Pink Floyd was, is and ever will be out of this world, but this, young man, is, but beforehand mad respect to your insane determination of recreating the maybe best, most influential and of course sophisticated guitar solo to every single note David Gilmour played, just inconceivable. I am speechless! Bar none and hands down the best rendition there is out there. Thanks from everyone for sharing your phenomenal talent!
I come back here at least once every year and I can't say anything about this masterpiece. It sounds too good to be true, one of the best things I've ever heard in my life no doubt. Just wow, can someone make me never forget this video please
When talent was coming down in raindrops this guy was outside getting drenched. I teared up listening to this and I’m 61 years old and seen most things. Respect to you young man.
I remember seeing David Gilmour during his rattle that lock tour in Chicago and the chills I got when that first bass note got comfortably numb hit me. I knew I was in for an experience. I walked out of that concert a vastly different man. Thank you for doing this so I can study the masterpiece that this solo is
ONE WORD: GREAT. MONUMENTAL "SOLO" INTERPRETATION.
Dude, that deserves to be performed in a stadium, not in your bedroom! Unbelievable!
Agreed!
It was
Yes !
That's not his bedroom. Looks more like his work room/studio
@@LadanSoodmand u didnt get the point here
I’ve been a musician for over 35 yrs and have never seen this level of perfection in a cover. Absolutely mind blowing!
Вы ни как не можете понять одного, Русские как ни кто любят свободу. И эта их любовь и создаёт великую культуру. Ваша пропаганда рассказала вам о том, что Русские дикие волосатые животные. Когда вы очнётесь, вы поймёте, что мы не враги вам, а ваши друзья. Но до тех пор, пока вам рассказывают басни о Русских и России, мы ни когда не будем вместе.
love that little harmonic bar chord tap at the end ,class stuff
💯
You were happy with your words. I'm 65 years old and I've never seen anything like it. I would certainly say that the only one who would do this would be Gilmour
You ain't lying I've been playing along time and he's hit and and bent ever note to perfection...I stay to the Rhythm part on on this song...
6 years later, and this is still the best cover of the Pulse solo I have ever seen/heard.
Hope you're still around, my friend!
HERES channel does a nice one too but I still prefer this one
And it is porbably the best there will ever be.
It also has the most views of all his videos. I play it in loop mode every morning with my coffee. I never get tired of it. The Best
Awesome 👏🏻
Yup ! I thought guitardude84 version was the shit unit I heard this years back " the best on the tube or anywhere in the world besides Gilmour himself
I’m 56 years old. A life long Floyd fan. I’m a guitarist myself, so I know the work that goes into nailing this sort of thing. I’ve listened to ‘countless’ versions of this incredible piece of music, and I can honestly say that yours is the best! I listened for every dive bomb, squeal, double stops. You got it spot on!! Brilliant job!!
Karl. London. England. 🏴
As a 59yr old still learning!! I could not agree more, timing, feeling, expression, note for note perfect and oozing confidence. His playing is truly admirable!! It pains me to see 357 thumbs down, even if it is a small percentage of the number of views, it is simply wrong, if they did not enjoy it they did not need to watch, if they can find fault then they should have the decency to say so in comments!! No one minds constructive criticism, not that there is room or scope for that in this case. Where are the videos of these 357 people showing us how they could have done this better? It surprises me they managed to get their thumbs out their mouths long enough to hit dislike!! Oh to be as perfect as they must consider themselves!! They must love themselves more than only a mother could, I bet if they could kiss their own Ass, they would!!
@@maxbenkard3455 My!! My!! Jealousy is not an admirable trait!! I rewatched this after reading your comment, to mime this would be almost impossible!! Note for note perfect, every vibrato, every tremolo, every dive, every pull up, every string pick, every rake!! Not one slip up anywhere!! Yet when singers mime they often fail to simply open their mouths in time!! Since you are so clever I expect to see your demonstration of miming playing this!! Come on!! Show us all exactly how it's done!! Seems to me this would be easier to play ( not that it is easy!!) than it would be to fake, so Come on!! Show us what you've got!! Put up or Shut up!!
@@michaellilley6725 don't mess with fools. Their tongue (or fingers) is not connected to brain.
Whahahaaa… no way, dude!
@@josdircken4412 Жаль мы с тобой не проживем еще 100 лет. Но будет так как я сказал, Пинк Флойд и Сатриани - это очень большая разница. Сатриани по сравнению с Пинк Флойд - никто. Я таких как Сатриани слышал сотни. Но такую музыку как Пинк Флойд не делает никто.
The number one rated solo of all time, the number one cover ever played. Simply perfect.
@@musikmaury keep working on it dude 🎸
Je confirme 👏
👍👍
@@musikmaury You know the notes and can play the guitar, but you are totally missing the feel. The homework for you is the bends, trem, and timing...
@@musikmaury LOL that's a more classy way than saying "hah, post your own before criticising". However, it makes the same mistake in thinking that you have to be able to do something in order to appreciate it. In fact a non-guitarist could just as easily point out that your downward run is completely out of time. That being said, I'll see what I can do before too long.
4.6M views. I swear, I claim 10% of them. Simply perfect.
Count mine for next 10% views. Eternal stuff...
lol.. yeah, I keep coming back 👌
Valeu
Mine for next 20%
Mine for the 30% 🤘🏻🤙🏼
4 years later... Still the best cover on youtube
Different songs, but give a look on "Have a Cigar" by Main Squeeze. The guitarist is absolutely insane too
What he said!
Google ‘Kfir comfortably numb 10 minute’... you’re welcome. 👍💪
Brit Floyd Live from Liverpool 2011. And their cover of this solo is amazing too. Which is the best hard to say ))
Nope. Check this: th-cam.com/video/U9LCSeKxroM/w-d-xo.html
My wife always asks me ‘didn’t you get enough of that solo?’ NEVER!!! This is just stunning! I wish I could play like this
It's funny you wrote that because I keep coming back to this video. It is absolutely amazing. It's getting to the point where I have watched this solo over David Gilmour's solo on Pulse.
You can. Practice.
@@Hustada Ахаха )) Так могут играть единицы на планете, друг.
@@Nick--Name practice.
@@Hustada Ты не понимаешь о чем говоришь. Такого уровня не достигнешь и за 30 лет практики, если у тебя нет дара от Бога.
Hey Andrey. This is the best version i have EVER heard. Very cool man.
Hey, check my version aswell :)
Its absolutelly awsome and perfect. I really love this cover, i can’t understand who could dislike it. Congrats. And Mr Thomas its one of the greatest on the youtube!!!!
Both Andrey's and Thomas' versions are my favourites :)
Check out my attemp. th-cam.com/video/R3Wm36PQsYg/w-d-xo.html
I agree. On view number 75
Уже пять лет это слушаю, каждый раз как первый
Такая же фигня ,Марунед так и не дождался от него))
@@АртемИваньковот, кстати, да! Marooned было бы тоже очень круто, наверняка
It’s been 7 years and I haven’t found not even one video with someone playing pulse solo like this! This is absolutely mind blowing. Just close your eyes!
Check my comment from 7 years ago, still listen en watch this guy before I have to play comfy numb live.
Check this out, man! Andrey Korolev and this french guitarist are both just AWESOOOOOOOME!!!! th-cam.com/video/AyANj4Hx5EM/w-d-xo.html
He nailed Gilmours style, im with you, havent found someone who plays "Gilmours style" more accurate than he does
This one comes close
th-cam.com/video/AyANj4Hx5EM/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/KtHaivQ1EXY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=GMiq1CwMmCN-5c6j
Best cover of this iconic solo on the Internet. Its not about technically playing the chords, it's about capturing the soul that Gilmour transmits through the strings. Gilmours guitar speaks to you. And you've nailed it my friend.
Absolutely!! Genius.
Wonderful cover! Please check my version here 😎🍷
th-cam.com/video/hNwZqKCCvkY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=tMbFn0b0a4BdKjI4
I'm listening this cover version from past 5 years and counting. It's the best cover I heard
Edit: 13-Feb-2024
My mother passed away last year on Feb and this brings tear on my eyes. High on rum and going down and down
I don't know why but I feel your pain. You have a brother here, comfortably numb like you
Hope you’re doing alright brother man
Just think that life is tough, she wouldn't be happy if she knew that you are going through such a pain going down and down, such as you wouldn't be happy knowing that she is going that way without you. Get your self up man, life is capable to give you everything you want if you just try your best. You have the best community here supporting you
Sorry for your loss 😢. My Mom also died this year
6 years later in 2022 still the best comfortably numb cover out there. Congrats bro
Никто уже не уйдёт отсюда... )
Toujours pareil en 2024 👍
2024 I’ve listened to probably every cover of this song. Many are very good, but this is the best.👍
Best cover on the internet, hands down
I’ve probably said this before, but there isn’t a better cover of any song out there or maybe even a better overall guitar player. This guy is so good I cant believe it still. I defy anyone to find a better player or cover. Incredible.
Периодически захожу почитать восторженные комментарии и порадоваться тому, как по-настоящему шедевральные версии абсолютно шедевральных произведений находят своих почитателей и ценителей. Чистая магия
So true❤
Да.. мой Друг
Bravissimo😊
Stunning, I fully agree, the best cover solo of this masterpiece that I ever seen, simply brillant!
8 years later... Always the best cover of all times... and that shall most probably remain unmatched forever!
🎸
I’ve listened to this solo a billion times between David Gilmore and others who have covered it and I tell you this that your solo is second to only David Gilmore himself. Absolutely stunningly played! Well Done!!!!!!
You're right. I am a big Pink Floyd Fan. And this is soooo close to the original listen in Delicate sound of thunder. Great!
John Garrett
Yupp i am abselutly 110% With you on this😊😊👌👌👌
This cover Version of this legendery guitar solo,done by Andrey Korolov here it,s soooo incredble GOOD and has a perfectly tonal,Wibb arm,tone,up/down strenght stroke control,pull'on'off and pitch are perfectly executed
and are a pice of musicaly Ear CANDY
Yes definitely
Try Tina S.... She does it all without the whammy bar... And puts Gilmore to task. Watching Gilmore now is boring. If this kid is mimicking Gilmore... He needs to look further for inspiration.
Kevin Jordan
Yupp,,i do actually agree whith you,,,looking at gilmoure now is a bitt boring,,,But what is so impressive by this KID is his unbelivble perfect timing,,som effortles and flowless.(sorry for my bad english,,im from Norway)
Check Out this KID,,he has al lot if videos,this Version here is several years old,,i do now about the super chic Tina S......she is way more than good
I have listened to this everyday since I discovered this video 3 years ago. Man that sounds good
Сотни соло пересмотрел на данную композицию, и пришёл к выводу что лучше версии этого солo как у Андрея ни у кого нет.
Точно
Kfir is good too (blue background, live version, not sitting studio one).
герой башарова тоже был уверен что именно он должен был быть вместо Гагарина!
@@dock_su @ Здесь речь совсем не о том,никто под сомнение не ставит величие великого Гилмора,а о том как Андрей из всех смог блестяще исполнить легендарное соло из всех вариантов других гитаристов.Все и так знают что Гилмору принадлежит это соло,речь о том что Андрей лучше всего его повторил.
Есть кто лучше оригинала повторяет лунную походку,так что все говорят что Майкл Джексон так себе ее исполнил,нет конечно,ему одному принадлежат лавры,потому как он ее придумал,все просто восхищаются мастерством копии походки.
Согласен. Великолепно. Но ещё хочу посоветовать вам послушать BRIT FLOYD. Обещаю не пожалеете
Как-же надо любить музыку Девида и Пинк Флойд, чтобы так ее исполнить. Андрей - тебе респект. Я уже 50 лет поклонник Пинк Флойд.
This is the definition of a perfect interpretation of a great solo
well said brother loved the improv
I love the fact Andrey puts his own stamp on it instead of playing it note for note the Gilmour way.
OUTSTANDING!!!!!!
From a Floyd fan who has been listening to them for 45 yrs - this is epic.
Steve Edwards Wow! So You’ve pretty much been listening since Meddle in 1972! It must’ve been mind blowing when You heard Dark side!
Holly F…… thats the first time I’ve seen anyone on the same level as Gilmore. Absolutely perfect!
I hope you are aware, Andrey, that you reached an insane level of perfection and skills! You are genius, a rare gem.
I am a Pink Floyd fan, I love "Pulse" version of this solo, and all I can say is that your performance is, in my humble opinion, much better than David Gilmour's, and he is the king of guitar solos! Basically, you did the impossible. You have my deepest respect.
I found this by simply browsing through youtube. I'm an original Pink Floyd fan and I was lucky enough to have been at the Pulse concert. The solo performed here was perfect. Every cover drops clanger and plays a bad note or two, not the case here. . . Just close your eyes and ride the tide, simply let the music do its magic
im deceased..... this is the best cover of this solo on youtube i swear to god
Lelija45 you should listen to thomas75s i swear to God you wont regret it
Have you seen Tina S cover tho?
I've seen. It's a good stuff.
But this cover (PULSE-tribute) is perfect! There's nothing better.
I agree with that. This is the best cover on youtube.
Perfect. The best cover.
I’m 61 and have been a Floyd fan since the early 70’s and I must say this is absolutely the finest musicianship I’ve run across. Your cover of this epic solo is spot on. Some here have said this is second only to the original played by the master himself. However I feel it is absolutely on par and every bit as good as David’s original performance. As a fellow guitarist I applaud you !
th-cam.com/video/e5dzOS_yCCA/w-d-xo.html do you like my version 😉
Honestly I slightly prefer this performance to Gilmour's. He still wins because he's the composer.
Yeah I am usually very critical of covers of my favorite solos. But holy hell this was simply amazing.
better than the original! ;)
ЭТО ЛУЧЩЕ ОРИГИНАЛА,ЧИЩЕ СЫГРАНО
The best comfortably cover guitar solo on TH-cam. Congratulations from Sicily, Italy.
I totally agree!! Dove in Sicilia? I was at Comiso Air Station from 1989-91…so many memories and great people! I can still hear the voice in the mercato della settimana, “Dieci mille lira!!” 😊
@jake I live in Palermo. Thanks for the kind words, in 1991/92 I did my military service in the Navy and was on duty at the NATO base in Isola delle Femmine ( Pa) .many greetings.
Vivo a Palermo anche io e concordo, penso che il 10% delle visualizzazioni siano mie 😂
@improntaimmobiliare i Pink sono i Pink 😆 poi sto ragazzo è bravissimo, che zona di Palermo? Io Calatafimi cappuccini .
I'm rarely impressed but THAT was just something else.
David would be proud of this one. To all the people who gave it a thumbs down, I'd like to see you do better.
all of them are trumptards!!
@@BLOVECU
You sound like have the never Trumper disease
@@jeffbecker9515 it's not a disease. it's the cure.
@@BLOVECU there's no need to bring politics into rock and roll. No matter where you align politically we can all come together to rock.
@@BLOVECU What a stupid comment.
Where is the standing ovation button?!
Rohan Bhowmick Or even Hats off will do
Underrated comment 😁
th-cam.com/video/f_PHy4mLSss/w-d-xo.html what do you think about this version??? please subscribe to my channel! I work to make video editing of digital audio with tutorial and guide.
@@nickrkr hey I'm a stranger replying to your comment 7 years late for no reason
@@Qwerrrty-u3sHey stranger.. woah it's been such a long time... Miss those days were times were simpler 😕..
All the fight between pentatonic and diatonic scales...all the blue notes, dives and bends. I'm 28 now, I hope to still ear this when I become 68 or more. Legendary Gilmour, Legend of legends. And you sir, you are one of his horsemen. Much love to your work here. From Portugal, respect to the eternity!!
The best cover, of the best version, of the best guitar solo in the history of music.
Entièrement d'accord
В точку, братан
I'd never thought i would be stunned by 'this' solo played by someone else who isn't Gilmour...
Breathtaking...
No youre breathtaking
no you are
Probably the greatest comfortably numb solo cover that is out there
Слушаю много лет и буду слушать до конца дней. Этот кавер ничем не уступает гилморовскому и даже в чем-то его неуловимо превосходит )
I have heard a lot of guitarist play this solo and in fairness they are all truly amazing. But listening to this, the one thing that this guy Andrey has over all others is his apparent ability to channel Dave Gilmore when playing this solo because I can honestly say I have never heard anyone so accurately emulate what I believe to be the greatest guitar solo of all time so masterfully. Pure Genius.
Another impressive part to it is that he makes it look so fu#king easy!
This is the best guitar solo I've ever heard. Nothing can sound any better than this, in my opinion.
Stevie ray vaughan
pyrolover braindead
@@hamzaabdullah1042 🤔
pyrolover nobody gives a fuck if you think srv is better, just shut ur mouth
Santana "Europa" just as amazing
By far the best “comfortably numb” pulse cover on the internet!!!
No one even gets this close to the man himself David Gilmore, except Andrey!
I would pay mega bucks to Andrey perform this live with a pink Floyd tribute band!!
Ваш клиент хорош
@@колькаломакин he is not my client! I have know ties to him, I am just recognising the amazing talent he has!
This is the best that exists online, period.
If this is a 'Who Can Sound Most Like David Gilmour' contest, you win.
Nobody can win that
@@patrikskoglund5169 Nobody can win the sound most like Gilmour contest? Why not?
@@therealrobinbullock 🤯🤣🤡.. 👏👍
Totally agree mate.
No offense but it's not even close.
This cant be real, every single note was perfect
I think its pre recorded and then videoed. But the timings so close so hard to tell. Most guitar vids are done this way now hence the doubt people are beginning to have wether its real or not. I want to say he’s playing it live but how clean it is it seems pre recorded. But hey he might have just had one of those magic runs on a good day we all have 🤷♂️
@@crystllclr3743 why dont you stop hating and just enjoy the best cover to the best guitar solo ever
@@crystllclr3743 Or maybe he's just a genius on the guitar
@@VeganStance no ones that clean. Every note is perfect and you can see where he hits certain strings but you dont hear it which means its had production after. Nothing wrong with it but i prefer raw. I like the little mistakes they sometimes lead to some awesome things. He can obviously play but not even gilmore sounds that good live and its his song.
@@crystllclr3743 He might have done some post editing but if you look closely, not much, if any. When you compare this to Gilmour's pulse live version, this is way cleaner. It might have took him quite a few shots though, while Gilmour only had one take.
Check out Kingfish's Empty Promises in Nashville. You'll find zero mistakes in one of the best live solos of all times (and that's a live performance btw, not a bedroom recorded one).
This is the 70th time I am listening to this and still can not believe how good you are. This is beyond perfection and if you are a true pink floyd fan, you would notice the perfection. So many people try to cover but they massacre. The tone, bending, feelings, everything is top top level. You could wear a Gilmour mask and sell out arenas.
That is for sure!!👍👍
The winner and still champion… hands down the best cover of the greatest solo of all time! Goosebumps!
At a certain time the solo sent a shiver on my spine, got a sense of awakening and I was looking around me. It was like to be in another place in the universe, and everything was different. Once the solo was over, I was back to the reality of my room with my phone in the palm of my hand. Suddenly I realized that even though I am no longer young still I can feel like a child who hears its first song. Thank you, guy for these rare sensations, and thank you for this amazing music!
Good words.
it's better than an orgasm!
THIS!!!!! You described it perfectly! Probably this word may not be the most proper, but this version is super "sensual" in a way. As you described it, it's like being in another universe. I experience it as riding a wave of sound. It's so, so, SO amazing... .
Хоть увидела, как это выглядит вблизи. Слушаю пинков со школьной скамьи. Соло комфортного онемения считаю лучшим у Гилмора. А Вам - браво!!!! Это лучший кавер, что слышала!!!
Why does this only have 5M view it deserves more. This has got to be one of the best guitar solo covers on the internet
Редчайший случай. Подписчиков почти вполовину меньше, чем ЛАЙКОВ. РЕАЛЬНО ОБАЛДЕННО!!!
Но если Гилмор неожиданно умрет, то ЕГО ДЕЛО ПРОДОЛЖИТСЯ БЕЗ ПРОБЛЕМ!!!)))
ТАК играть можно ТОЛЬКО ДУШОЙ!!!!
Эта композиция - НЕ МУЗЫКА! ЭТО КРИК ДУШИ!!!
И еще РЕДЧАЙШИЙ случай... Слушаю ЭТОТ кавер чаще и с большим удовольствием, чем ОРИГИНАЛ....
Here we are 5 or 6 years later and this is still the best that I have ever heard. Hope life is treating you well bud.
Тот гитарист, который каверы делает ещё более привлекательными и не портит стиль и красоту исходной композиции ❤❤❤
I will repeat myself; God DAMN!!! That's some fine work, son!
This is the best cover on TH-cam by far!!
Мне 54, поклонник Пинк Флойд. Молодец, сынок, исполнение отличное!!! Дерзай, твори!!!
Pink Floyd- состояние души
andrej je odlicno skinuo solazu pesme od grupe pink flojd, sigurno dejvid gilmur gledao kako lepo svira.
Playing correct notes is one thing, but you captured the flow, that euphoric, exhilarating feeling one gets when listening to "Comfortably Numb" solo, or many other times when we hear David Gilmour play. Ultimate aural ecstasy. Played bravely, without any hesitation, makes it even more convincing.
Every single note, and every single tone nailed! Wonderful playing. Dynamically perfect!
Very good, but not note per note, he uses a floating bridge, but David doesn’t, maybe I prefer this one
Конец 2024! Посчитаемся?) Превосходная игра Андрея заставляет возвращаться вновь и вновь. Данная композиция Pink Floyed была первым знакомством с данной группой. Мой папа в далёких 2000х открыл для меня новую страсть. Слушая эту песню, я каждый раз его вспоминаю, так как 4 года назад он ушёл из этого мира, как раз в разгар пандемии. Андрей, продолжайте играть! Вы мастер!
Ho 60 anni e devo dire che questo ragazzo è degno di suonare alla Gilmour complimenti dall’Italia
7 years have been passed and this is still, so far, the best cover of the most impressive guitar solo of all times.
Platinum trophy earned: play the best guitar solo ever
Very moving to watch this. Very emotional touch and feel. You are certainly gifted. Thank you for sharing this amazing video of probably the best ever solo of all time . . .
Браво! Второго такого кавера не существует! Даже Бритфлоид отдыхает!!!!! !Брат, ты велик! Твори , не останавливайся!!!!!!
I just wept like a 5 year old. Words can't describe your heartfelt energy devoted to this song. Bravo. I just purchased your album.
Ну что сказать, шикарно, на мой взгляд этот гитарист передал дух Гилмора, сколько смотрела другие варианты... а тут точное попадание!!!
Точно! Именно ДУХ! Мало один в один воспроизвести звук и мелодию, нужно еще что-то, а это не многим удается ((
Он понимал ритм гилмора
И главное скорость
Фразировка, бенды и вибрато - ГЛАВНОЕ в этом соло...
Только русский человек мог сказать "дух" ! Этим все сказано, мы все же чувствуем, по другому... Не знаю как, но по другому... !!!! А Андрей супер!!!!
Мне 44 и я с детства это слушаю. Именно эта соло всё ещё вызывает у меня мурашки
I have yet to hear a better cover of my all-time favorite Comfortably Numb Pulse solo, and I have listened to literally all of them for over a decade. Congratulations!
Incredibly fluid -- probably the best cover on TH-cam. Nice job, Andrey.
I take that back. Just listened again. It IS the best cover on YT.
Check out mine let me know what you think. th-cam.com/video/R3Wm36PQsYg/w-d-xo.html
👌🤘🖒👊
Возвращаюсь сюда сотый раз,а может и больше.Этот парень хорош,лучший!
Никто уже не уйдёт отсюда... )
That was the most authentic sounding cover I've ever heard
Absolutely stunning. Watched this so many times.
Something always brings me to this video. It is like a drug. When I need my spirits to be lifted, I watch this video. You are a very talented young man. ROCK ON ANDREY!!!
Me too.
Same here, I always come back to this video!!
Same I watch this multiple times everyday
Simply excellence. Even Gilmour would stop whatever he was doing and listen with a smile.
that's the reason why Gilmour gave the black strat away
This is the most impressive/genuine cover of the Comfortably Numb Solo from Pulse on TH-cam by far - well done Andrey.
7 years later and still gives me goosebumps.
Made me cry. It was beyond beautiful.
❤️🥰
This is the only cover version that really nails it 100% here on TH-cam ... IF someone did it better it was maybe David Gilmour himself. Awesome work, Andrey and thanks for sharing.
ive seen 235 versions on you tube ( took me weeks ) this is by far the best outside of tutorials wwhich im pretty sure hell end up doing as well cos he has some neat tricks ,best version ive seen outside of the pink floyd family n thats a huge feather in his cap :)
th-cam.com/video/6LnJBmrkj1g/w-d-xo.html
Yes, one did it better with his own improvisation. I love it more than the original because this version is extended to minutes. Talking about Kfir Ochaion’s Comfortably Numb solo with the Cobra Blue Fender American Ultra HSS Stratocaster. Amazing improvisation of a true masterpiece by David Gilmour. :)
@@Acepilot1312 there is no improvisation here. It's the exact same from PULSE album. The short version is from The Wall album... this is from PULSE album...…..
Caveman Protogonos yeah, but what i’m meaning is that, its extremely difficult to play continuously for 10 minutes straight, at-least for most of us. And also, i don’t know that much about David Gilmour’s songs as i just discovered him by this Comfortably Numb song, so I don’t know what his albums are. :)
I grew up with this from Pink Floyd, AND DAVIDS AWESOME LICKS! at 71 now I am pleased to see our younger generation be moved by the master piece of guitar work called Comfortably numb! It shows how timeless music really is! ROCK ON KIDS! It doesn't get better than this !!🎸 Carry on.
Spot on comment! Spot on 🎉🎉🎉
For the first time of my life, I can say that I completely fall in love with a guitar solo. As a Pink Floyd fan I would say that's impossible to do better than Gilmour but men... you've already did it. Thank you so much. You're a great great great Guitarist.
Я себя представляю за этой гитарой))) Это нечто конечно, лучшее соло всех времён лично для меня, вся страсть, боль, радость и любовь в нем
Мне кажется, великий Гилмор отдал бы Андрею главный приз за лучшее исполнение его произведения
Hitting the translate button over and over shows me just how different English and Russian are. There is literally no correlation between words. If it were Spanish, it would be an almost word for word replacement between English and Spanish words. Russian is wildly different, with a completely different alphabet. Crazy to me.
Без сомнения, улучшил Гилмора
@@NJFPV зато то что ты написал перевело просто отлично))
Secondo me... Ha superato loriginale... 🤔😞😍😇😘💘❤️💔💋💯💯💯💯💯
@@anelladambrosio2513согласен
Back again after many years. Like a fine wine, your solo has kept it's wonderful taste, body and soul. Hope you are doing well.
Seriously, that is the most authentic and perfectly measured solo cover I have heard. Incredible rendition
It really is
6 years later, Andrey, and I still can't stop listening... Absolutely spectacular. You mastered this solo.
Андрей - у нас было 30 выпуска Суворовского училища, мы слушали Свой среди чужих, 47-летние мужики плакали, спасибо .
Is that really you plying, best cover on the Internet, hand down, it make me wiep with just how good this is, game changer.
АНДРЕЙ❤ ОЧЕНЬ,ОЧЕНЬ достойно ,это лучший кавер ,слушаю эту замечательную группу 50 лет ,ну просто поразил.❤❤❤❤
this solo take me out of my body
that's the exact definition of perfect cover
After many years, still the best cover ever...
Still the best cover afer all that time, legendary.
Rarely enough I comment on somenone's cover of Pink Floyd songs since Pink Floyd was, is and ever will be out of this world, but this, young man, is, but beforehand mad respect to your insane determination of recreating the maybe best, most influential and of course sophisticated guitar solo to every single note David Gilmour played, just inconceivable. I am speechless! Bar none and hands down the best rendition there is out there. Thanks from everyone for sharing your phenomenal talent!
Of all covers out there, none has ever managed to top yours.
I've seen hundreds of people playing this my favourite solo of all times this guy is the best I've come across well done man perfection
What about David Gilmour
Complimenti !!! è la migliore interpretazione che abbia mai visto finora.
Unbelievable!!! The best rendition I've heard to David Gilmour! Lots of skilled talent, congratulations! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I come back here at least once every year and I can't say anything about this masterpiece. It sounds too good to be true, one of the best things I've ever heard in my life no doubt. Just wow, can someone make me never forget this video please
True
Stratospheric Korolev 😉
When talent was coming down in raindrops this guy was outside getting drenched. I teared up listening to this and I’m 61 years old and seen most things. Respect to you young man.
I remember seeing David Gilmour during his rattle that lock tour in Chicago and the chills I got when that first bass note got comfortably numb hit me. I knew I was in for an experience. I walked out of that concert a vastly different man. Thank you for doing this so I can study the masterpiece that this solo is