One of my sons, one of your fans, probably reading this post, has successfully done this method. And many more. I have given him at least one of your books. Maybe two? I have seven sons, i can't remember all of the gifts i have given. And, for years, some of my kids go into the woods with only a Swiss Army Knife or Böker multi rescue tool. Everyone alive today needs to see this video. It will save lives and give comfort.
@FelixImmler my son is an actual genius and expert in woods craft. And a hardened combat veteran and former U. S. Marine. You two would go together as investors, researchers, and co-instructors. He is introverted and cerebral in most of his thinking. His maternal grandfather was an actual rocket scientist, MIT educated. Nothing unusual in my wife's side, who also had a high-level genius IQ. And baked the best cakes, pies and bread! You two young men are very much alike in your wood craft and adventure skills.
The ignition of t-shirt material was the most impressive to me. The next time I try it, I will take it all the way to disintegration like you did. Thank you, Felix.
I tried it about 10 times and 3 times I got an ember. In my opinion it's just a matter of how long stays the roll rollable, that you can work enough energie into the roll. My main problem was that layers of the roll moved always sideways into a cone and at the end th roll fell apart before I could build up enough heat. That's why I took a lot of time and almost only did forward strokes for slowly built up the heat. Because with foreward strokes i have more control. Only when I smelled smoke i switched to back and forth movements. If you can't completely manage the inflammation, you can still separate the carbonized part of the T-shirt and roll it up into a new roll. This is how you made a fire roll T-shirt in two steps. Adding a little resin to the roll end to glue it on the roll always worked well for me. And I stretched the t-shirt strip a little on the side before rolling it up. I think with stretching I was able to reduce the sideways collapse of the t-shirt a bit. Also, I would cut a pretty wide strip...maybe close to 2 inches. Unfortunately, the entertainment factor on TH-cam has become increasingly important at the expense of the learning factor. That's why your channel doesn't have millions of subscribers. You have little entertainment value but a lot of learning value. Thanks for very interesting content since over 10 Years!!
I have been using the fire roll technique since I found the Bogey Creek channel a few years back. Whilst his videos inspired and taught me the basics this video has taught the nuances that usually take ages to to learn, so for that, thank you. Plus because of the high popularity of your channel this technique will spread more and gain the popularity it well deserves. 10/10 👍
Very informative. I used fire rolls only a few times, using cotton and ashes, and paper towel and ashes, but never bothered too much after that. I do need to play with it more. This is encouraging. Thanks Felix.
Thank you so much. Your descriptions are perfect. Thank you for showing the other fillers. I'm looking to start fires that don't require already having previous fires. Be Well and Good Journey Richie
Fantastic video Felix. I love your practical scientific approach! I will try this myself.....making fire from a couple of ingredients and some physical effort seems to be magic!!!
beautiful video, very useful tips that I will put into practice since this technique is not my specialty but I will definitely practice with your tips, thank you very much. greetings friend Felix.
@@FelixImmler Jetzt hab ich mich gefragt, warum die Antwort auf Englisch ist. Dabei hab ich selber Englisch geschrieben. Das ganze Video war ja auf Englisch 🤣
Hi Felix! I’ve been subscribed to you & David for many years now! It is good to see you expand David’s work! I almost commented halfway through using the tips that you gave at the end! Thank you for experimenting! These are things that we need to do & share with each other! Thank you again!
Good day Felix, as always your instructions and explanations are very helpful in all your projects. Thanks again for your many helpful contributions to help your fellows in staying safe and increasing our knowledge. Take care & looking forward to more from you 😉👍
@@FelixImmler I think it could work if the split is real even, but in my experience it's usually not. Of course you have the knife so you could make at least one surface flat enough or find a flat service. Also you have to bring or find and prepare the right tinder. And if you bring tinder why not bring a firesteel also? For the bow drill you need a string that most people bring (again why not bring a firesteel) but you could make from natural materials if you can find them and put in the work. The hand drill you only need the board and drill but the hand drill itself should be rather smooth to not hurt your hands so that takes work also. So my preferred method is the fire plough and if you're in bamboo land the fire saw. Depending on where you are one of the two should be easy to find without much preparation aka less amount of work.
Felix Immler, David West and Boggy Creek Beast - the 3 Amigos of the fire roll method. Your hard work and curious nature have added to the knowledge base and will inspire many new fire rollers - thank you. When you go in the woods it will be nice to see you take the ember to flame like. If you don't have the proper tinder bundle it is easy to lose your ember and have to start all over again.
Nice, very informative, you never seace to amaze me Felix your awesome brother you have the best job in the world working for VIC you take care you and your family luv from across the pond 🇺🇲😎🙏
Hi Felix Immler! Thank you so much for sharing your experience and knowledge!! Absolutely love your book, channel! You’re awesome! My friend the god lord has given you an awesome gift, bless your heart brother!!👍🏽💯❤️. May you, your family and friends be well!! STRENGTH AND HONOR!! See you on the next project!! From Washington state 🇺🇸❤️💯👍🏽
Nice to see you Felix and thanks for the hard work. I've never seen this technique, very interesting! It might be less popular because of the effort in advance outdoors. Finding a flat surface to roll on is not so easy , if you don't happen to stumble upon a resting point with a table, isn't it?
Hallo Felix, danke für Deine Tipps. Die "Feuerrollen" erinnern mich immer an Rüdiger Nehberg. Im englischen habe ich auch von den Rudiger Rolls gelesen ;o) Danke für die Cheat Tipps! Ich bin gespannt auf Dein nächstes Video. VG Eric.
It was cool of you to give a shout out to David West. I watch his video's often. Seems to me the Fire Roll if I was in a bad situation would require less expended energy to create than anything else (other than a bic lighter or a ferro rod). Fire is number 1 priority in survival IMHO. Great thing to learn and practice often. Thanks for the video. Really good stuff.
Du bist verrückt! Das ganze in zwei Tagen? Muskelkater, Blasen an den Händen, Sehnenscheidenentzündung? Ganz klasse Video. Ich dachte bisher, die Rüdiger-Rolle geht nur mit der Baumwolle aus Tampons und Zigarettenasche. Probiert habe ich die Rolltechnik noch nie. Gruß Tino You're crazy! All of that in two days? Sore muscles, blisters on your hands, tendonitis? Great video. I thought the Rüdiger roll only worked with cotton from tampons and cigarette ash. I've never tried the rolling technique. Greetings, Tino
Buenas amigo mío el vídeo es muy interesante y se aprende tela me a sorprendido como se crea fuego con distintos materiales 👏👏👏👌 buen video como siempre saludos desde 🇪🇦
Thank you for a very good video! =) I didn't even know you could roll friction fire, so learnt a lot! I also like David Wests channel, it is almost, but not quite, as good as yours ;)
Hi Felix, really nice tutorial on the fire roll technique. Thumbs up and thanks a lot for these great infos and demonstrations. You must now have a tendinitis somewhere in your right arm after all these repeated rolling over two days! Your arm must be on fire!
@@FelixImmler Hey BTW Felix, I recently got a Victorinox Venture and I like it a lot so far/first impression. Handle is super comfortable and the edge shoulder thickness is on the thin side which I prefer for a knife this size so I look foward to using it in the woods soon.
Hola Felix, estoy trabajando mucho con este sistema en mi canal, has probado a usar hojas verdes como relleno?, funcionan muy bien, un abrazo me encanta tu canal
Excellent experiment and tips! I just came to the conclusion that the filler just need to be a decent abrasive for the fibers used... I could be wrong, but it IS a theory.
This is so interesting! What would you use in a bushcraft situation for the board and roller? I guess you need somethign pretty flat (and rough enough to grip the roll but not shred it)?
Thank you very much Felix for spending this huge efforts and sharing your expirments and results with us. Since I am following Mr West for quite some while now, I am also very familiar with his experiments. I also did similar experiments by my self, and that is where one doubt comes up: I observed, wood ash is in general a very good chemical catalyst which, what I assume, loweres the ignition temperature. I assume this is why it is also used by traditional tinder fungus preparation technics. In your video one can see, that all the experiments are done on the same base bord with the same handle. Therefore, there is a chance that your experiment got conterminated by remains of wood ash on the board. To exlude such an impact, I would love to see two additional experiments: 1) Plain cutton without filler material on a baseboard where prevously wood ash fireroll was practiced. 2) Cutton with tinder fungus on a brand-new baseboard. What is your opinion on that? I am looking forward to see the second part of your experiments. Possibly this will include one of my suggested tests, since in the forest one usually does not find wook ash lying around.
Hello Felix, as always, a very good video clip from one of the best users of a SAK! Very interesting is the physics behind these techniques. Well done (and shown)! One question is left: where can I can get ashes (as a filler) when I have no fire yet? So, being in the woods without any firestarter, the search for resin is my favorite until now. A little problem may be the production of a flat piece of wood, on which you can roll with the needed speed. And surely have a Swiss Army knife _always_ in my pocket... Greets and all the best to you! Achim
Hello Felix. Your lavalier microphone is facing backwards. I know it´s an omnidirectional mic (picks up sound from everywere) but sounds better when pointing at your mouth. Love your videos by the way. Greetings from Ecuador.
Fein, das Thema ist wirklich unterrepräsentiert. Ich probiers es auch ab und zu mit Baumwolle mit durchwachsenen Erfolg. Bast hätte ich gern noch gesehen, hab es nur einmal erfolglos mit Pappel versucht. Viele Grüße!
I am wondering if rolling the materials at an angle works better, like making homemade fuses. You will already have a constant dual-layer of materials, thus the post rolling shouldn't be as time consuming.
Part of a firecraft is preparation, watch for old fires to collect ash and coal from. This is the same as finding resin, rust and grasses from different parts of your search.
fire roll works without a filler. for example, you can ignite dry nettle with this method. but you need to be aware of the history of this technique: it was used by 2. world war POWs and in a POW camp you had dry materials (eg. cotton), wooden planks and ash. you can do it caveman style though, by using 2 flat rocks or you split a log of wood. there are first fire methods (bow drill) and second fire methods (flint&steel with charred materials, fire roll, hand drill, etc).
I have been using this skill for a few years and I usually use coal and rust powder mixed together on a 7x7cm cotton swab, The coal and rust mix do I have pre mixed with me in a stainless waterproof film canister and the swabs do I carry an excess of in my first aid pouch. I always carry a lighter as a part of my on me person edc and in my backpack I carry a lighter matches a magnifier lens parts of a bow drill a ferrocerium rod and a fire steel, it might sound excessive but I'm not a hiker as my body doesn't allow me to walk more then a few hundred meters so when I'm going to the forest it's by car or atv and I can bring tons of unnecessary things xD
Hallo Felix Grüße aus Mecklenburg Vorpommern cool gleich eine neue Aufgabe bzw Aufgaben für meine Kinder man lernt nie aus danke.grüße aus Mecklenburg Vorpommern
Another great way to make fire Felix,well executed. Apparently this came from prisoners,to light there cigarettes. There is a guy, boggy creek beast who has a fully documented channel with almost every thinkable material there is ,using this technique. Also interesting to check him out. Greetings Steve
One of my sons, one of your fans, probably reading this post, has successfully done this method. And many more. I have given him at least one of your books. Maybe two? I have seven sons, i can't remember all of the gifts i have given. And, for years, some of my kids go into the woods with only a Swiss Army Knife or Böker multi rescue tool. Everyone alive today needs to see this video. It will save lives and give comfort.
Thank you so much for this wonderful story!
@FelixImmler my son is an actual genius and expert in woods craft. And a hardened combat veteran and former U. S. Marine. You two would go together as investors, researchers, and co-instructors. He is introverted and cerebral in most of his thinking. His maternal grandfather was an actual rocket scientist, MIT educated. Nothing unusual in my wife's side, who also had a high-level genius IQ. And baked the best cakes, pies and bread! You two young men are very much alike in your wood craft and adventure skills.
The ignition of t-shirt material was the most impressive to me. The next time I try it, I will take it all the way to disintegration like you did. Thank you, Felix.
I tried it about 10 times and 3 times I got an ember. In my opinion it's just a matter of how long stays the roll rollable, that you can work enough energie into the roll. My main problem was that layers of the roll moved always sideways into a cone and at the end th roll fell apart before I could build up enough heat. That's why I took a lot of time and almost only did forward strokes for slowly built up the heat. Because with foreward strokes i have more control. Only when I smelled smoke i switched to back and forth movements. If you can't completely manage the inflammation, you can still separate the carbonized part of the T-shirt and roll it up into a new roll. This is how you made a fire roll T-shirt in two steps. Adding a little resin to the roll end to glue it on the roll always worked well for me. And I stretched the t-shirt strip a little on the side before rolling it up. I think with stretching I was able to reduce the sideways collapse of the t-shirt a bit. Also, I would cut a pretty wide strip...maybe close to 2 inches.
Unfortunately, the entertainment factor on TH-cam has become increasingly important at the expense of the learning factor. That's why your channel doesn't have millions of subscribers. You have little entertainment value but a lot of learning value. Thanks for very interesting content since over 10 Years!!
@DavidWestBgood2ppl We all love and trust Felix, so just subscribed to your channel too.
David West is a fire wizard! LoL
I don't catch every video, but I'm always impressed.
I see smoke
Come rain or shine, you gave us another brilliant and well presented demonstration Felix...!
I can't wait to see how you are going to make a block and flat surface in the woods. Great video yet again!
Thanks a lot for your valuable support!
Thank you for putting in the hours of research and hard graft in order to post the results for free. You're a top man.
Wowww, thanks a lot for this wonderful compliment!
Excellent, well demonstrated Felix. Looking forward to part 2 in the woods!
Thank you very much! i hope soon we have a good weather period!
I have been using the fire roll technique since I found the Bogey Creek channel a few years back. Whilst his videos inspired and taught me the basics this video has taught the nuances that usually take ages to to learn, so for that, thank you. Plus because of the high popularity of your channel this technique will spread more and gain the popularity it well deserves. 10/10 👍
Thank you so much for this wonderful compliment!
Very informative. I used fire rolls only a few times, using cotton and ashes, and paper towel and ashes, but never bothered too much after that. I do need to play with it more. This is encouraging. Thanks Felix.
Thank you so much for your kind words
Thank you so much. Your descriptions are perfect. Thank you for showing the other fillers. I'm looking to start fires that don't require already having previous fires. Be Well and Good Journey Richie
Swissmade buscraft at it‘s best! Danke Felix für deine Mühen uns dieses instruktive Video zu präsentieren! 🙏
David West, the firestarter 🔥
exactly :-D
Outstanding demonstration using various materials to achieve a fireroll ember.
Awesome video, Felix 👍 It‘s really surprising what is possible with the fire roll technique!
Greetings Felix. Excellent video. You are very thorough, and clear in your testing. Thank you for the value you bring to the community.
Your comment makes me happy. Thank you!
Fantastic video Felix. I love your practical scientific approach! I will try this myself.....making fire from a couple of ingredients and some physical effort seems to be magic!!!
Thank you very much for your compliment!
Felix, you’re a gem! Your videos are always fun as well as instructive. A great teacher! Thanks. Les in UK 🇬🇧
Thanks a lot for this wonderful compliment!
beautiful video, very useful tips that I will put into practice since this technique is not my specialty but I will definitely practice with your tips, thank you very much. greetings friend Felix.
Very interesting video! Thank you for all the hard work you put into this video. Also thanks for showing us the importance of the filler and/or resin.
Thanks a lot for watching!
Never heard of the rolling technique. Now I know. Thank you. 👍
Thanks for watching!
@@FelixImmler Jetzt hab ich mich gefragt, warum die Antwort auf Englisch ist. Dabei hab ich selber Englisch geschrieben. Das ganze Video war ja auf Englisch 🤣
Thanks again! Informative relaxing and a great project.
Hi Felix! I’ve been subscribed to you & David for many years now! It is good to see you expand David’s work! I almost commented halfway through using the tips that you gave at the end! Thank you for experimenting! These are things that we need to do & share with each other! Thank you again!
Großartig!
Du bist eine absolute Bereicherung!
Deine Worte freuen mich sehr!
Dear Felix,,,this is professional video and skill...👍✌️🤝😇
Thanks a lot for your compliment!
I am so impressed how you do such an incredible job explaining things.
Thank you very much for this compliment!
Wow - very impressive! It all looks soooo easy. ;-) Thanks for sharing.
Thanks a lot for watching!
Good day Felix, as always your instructions and explanations are very helpful in all your projects. Thanks again for your many helpful contributions to help your fellows in staying safe and increasing our knowledge. Take care & looking forward to more from you 😉👍
Thank you so much for this wonderful compliment!
Fascinating Felix. You need some gentle beer glass raising exercises to unwind those muscles now !
Haaa ha haa this is a good idea! 🍺
Awesome stuff Felix, thanks for boiling down all of David West's good work into a great experiment.
This is a wonderful compliment! Thank you!
Good video about tinders and the technique. The problem with the fire roll in nature is to find two flat surfaces.
No, i don't think so. Splitting a branch should work... then you have top board and bottom board.
@@FelixImmler I think it could work if the split is real even, but in my experience it's usually not. Of course you have the knife so you could make at least one surface flat enough or find a flat service. Also you have to bring or find and prepare the right tinder. And if you bring tinder why not bring a firesteel also? For the bow drill you need a string that most people bring (again why not bring a firesteel) but you could make from natural materials if you can find them and put in the work. The hand drill you only need the board and drill but the hand drill itself should be rather smooth to not hurt your hands so that takes work also. So my preferred method is the fire plough and if you're in bamboo land the fire saw. Depending on where you are one of the two should be easy to find without much preparation aka less amount of work.
Awesome video, Felix. Very interesting.
Thank you so much!
Super wie immer - bin schon auf die Fortsetzung im Draußen gespannt ;-)
Liebe Grüße aus Bangalore, Robert
Danke mein lieber Freund!!!! Grüsse nach Indien!
The Rüdiger 'Sir Vival' /friction roll is a really fantastic concept. 👍
Thanks a lot for your positive feedback!
Good informational video Felix , thanks for sharing, YAH bless !
Thank you very much dear Michael!
Sehr interessant, lieber Felix!👍👍👍 Vielen Dank dafür und liebe Grüße aus dem Hausruckviertel!
Danke und liebe Grüße zurück
Felix Immler, David West and Boggy Creek Beast - the 3 Amigos of the fire roll method. Your hard work and curious nature have added to the knowledge base and will inspire many new fire rollers - thank you. When you go in the woods it will be nice to see you take the ember to flame like. If you don't have the proper tinder bundle it is easy to lose your ember and have to start all over again.
Thanks a lot for your positive feedback! you are absolutlely right.. form a ember to a fire is a long way :-D
I must have missed David's vid on processing a green plant to fibers that ignite. That's amazing. Also the dried grass and cotton.
Hi Felix! David West is in my top five favorite TH-camrs, along with yourself. He is VERY passionate about fire making to say the least.
Thank you ver much Terry!
Nice, very informative, you never seace to amaze me Felix your awesome brother you have the best job in the world working for VIC you take care you and your family luv from across the pond 🇺🇲😎🙏
Thank you so much for your wonderful comment!
Finally I know what to do with grandma's ashes!
Right 😊 👍 🔥
Outstanding! 👍😎👍
Thank you so much!
I watch David West, too. He's the master at fire making!
Yes, he is....
Brilliant 👍🏻😁🏴
Thank you very much!
Hallo Felix, das ist ja echt unglaublich, das hätte ich so nicht erwartet, dass es so gut funktioniert! Ein schönes WE und LG Micha
Wünsche ich dir auch... danke Micha!
Thank you for your explanations and tips. Some sites just do it without explanations.
Thanks a lot for your kind comment!
Well done, thank you!
very welcome!
Awesome video! Have a great weekend, my friend!
Thanks a lot David!
Fantastic ! Thank you Felix ! 😀👍
Thanks for watching!
Hi Felix Immler! Thank you so much for sharing your experience and knowledge!! Absolutely love your book, channel! You’re awesome! My friend the god lord has given you an awesome gift, bless your heart brother!!👍🏽💯❤️. May you, your family and friends be well!! STRENGTH AND HONOR!! See you on the next project!! From Washington state 🇺🇸❤️💯👍🏽
Wowww, thank you so much!
Nice to see you Felix and thanks for the hard work.
I've never seen this technique, very interesting! It might be less popular because of the effort in advance outdoors.
Finding a flat surface to roll on is not so easy , if you don't happen to stumble upon a resting point with a table, isn't it?
I think a fallen beech tree would be enough. There you will find a flat surface...maybe
Hallo Felix,
danke für Deine Tipps. Die "Feuerrollen" erinnern mich immer an Rüdiger Nehberg. Im englischen habe ich auch von den Rudiger Rolls gelesen ;o)
Danke für die Cheat Tipps!
Ich bin gespannt auf Dein nächstes Video.
VG Eric.
danke Eric und liebe Grüsse!
Wieder ein Feuermachtechnik dazugelernt, obwohl man bei uns kein Feuer in der Natur machen darf. Gruß Karl.
Herzlichen Dank lieber Karl!
It was cool of you to give a shout out to David West. I watch his video's often. Seems to me the Fire Roll if I was in a bad situation would require less expended energy to create than anything else (other than a bic lighter or a ferro rod). Fire is number 1 priority in survival IMHO. Great thing to learn and practice often. Thanks for the video. Really good stuff.
Thank you so much for your compliment!
Um abraço do Brasil!
Thank you very much!
Outstanding thanks
Thanks a lot for watching!
Very cool video idea. Looking forward to seeing the end goal. Thanks, Felix
Thank you so much!
Merci beaucoup pour ce partage très précieux, gratitude pour votre générosité.❤❤❤❤
Merci pour votre précieux soutien !
Très intéressant ❤❤❤merci à vous
Merci bien!
I subscribed to both of you long time ago
Thanks for the great video
Thanks a lot for your valuable support!
Du bist verrückt! Das ganze in zwei Tagen? Muskelkater, Blasen an den Händen, Sehnenscheidenentzündung?
Ganz klasse Video. Ich dachte bisher, die Rüdiger-Rolle geht nur mit der Baumwolle aus Tampons und Zigarettenasche. Probiert habe ich die Rolltechnik noch nie.
Gruß Tino
You're crazy! All of that in two days? Sore muscles, blisters on your hands, tendonitis?
Great video. I thought the Rüdiger roll only worked with cotton from tampons and cigarette ash. I've never tried the rolling technique.
Greetings, Tino
Vielen Dank für deine netten Worte!
thank you, brother. this is great stuff!
Thank you so much!
Nice ! Thanks
Thanks for watching!
Another fun project. Thanks Felix
Thank you very much!
Buenas amigo mío el vídeo es muy interesante y se aprende tela me a sorprendido como se crea fuego con distintos materiales 👏👏👏👌 buen video como siempre saludos desde 🇪🇦
Thank you very much!
Bravo Felix! Super, Respekt! LG Sepp
Danke lieber Sepp!!!
Oha, richtig cool. Habe von dem schon gehört aber nie gemacht. Schon krass mit was allem man Feuer machen kann.😃👍
Grüsse Nicolas🫡
Viel Spass beim Ausprobieren!
@@FelixImmler danke😁🤝
Thank you for a very good video! =)
I didn't even know you could roll friction fire, so learnt a lot!
I also like David Wests channel, it is almost, but not quite, as good as yours ;)
Nice video 🖖
Thank you so much!
Super video! Ciao
Thank you so much!
Hi Felix,
really nice tutorial on the fire roll technique.
Thumbs up and thanks a lot for these great infos and demonstrations.
You must now have a tendinitis somewhere in your right arm after all these repeated rolling over two days! Your arm must be on fire!
Thanks a lot for your funny comment!
@@FelixImmler
Hey BTW Felix, I recently got a Victorinox Venture and I like it a lot so far/first impression. Handle is super comfortable and the edge shoulder thickness is on the thin side which I prefer for a knife this size so I look foward to using it in the woods soon.
Hola Felix, estoy trabajando mucho con este sistema en mi canal, has probado a usar hojas verdes como relleno?, funcionan muy bien, un abrazo me encanta tu canal
great tips
Thanks a lot!
Excellent experiment and tips! I just came to the conclusion that the filler just need to be a decent abrasive for the fibers used... I could be wrong, but it IS a theory.
Thanks a lot for your inspiration!
Do you have any video about the fire plow? Thanks
Outstanding idea! ❤it!😊
Thank you so much!
Super spannendes Projekt,ich freue mich schon auf mehr 👍🔥
Gruß aus der Zwerkstatt
Danke lieber Kai. Grüße zurück!
Hey Felix, nice to see you give props to David West--> is the best 👍 🔥
Yes... i learnd a lot from David.
This is so interesting! What would you use in a bushcraft situation for the board and roller? I guess you need somethign pretty flat (and rough enough to grip the roll but not shred it)?
Splitting a branch ...or may be a rock as botton board...
Interesting 👍🏼
Thank you!
You're too strong Felix !
Ffelix president" !!!
Thank you so much!
wow krass abo selbstverständlich. Super Video Gut Erklärt.
Have you seen in one of Davids latest Firerole videos he succeeded in making an ember in a cotton ball without filler?
Yes that works....but this is a lot of work!
Lob und Anerkennung, an Den MEISTER ⭐🙏⭐
Thank you very much Felix for spending this huge efforts and sharing your expirments and results with us. Since I am following Mr West for quite some while now, I am also very familiar with his experiments. I also did similar experiments by my self, and that is where one doubt comes up:
I observed, wood ash is in general a very good chemical catalyst which, what I assume, loweres the ignition temperature. I assume this is why it is also used by traditional tinder fungus preparation technics. In your video one can see, that all the experiments are done on the same base bord with the same handle. Therefore, there is a chance that your experiment got conterminated by remains of wood ash on the board.
To exlude such an impact, I would love to see two additional experiments:
1) Plain cutton without filler material on a baseboard where prevously wood ash fireroll was practiced.
2) Cutton with tinder fungus on a brand-new baseboard.
What is your opinion on that?
I am looking forward to see the second part of your experiments. Possibly this will include one of my suggested tests, since in the forest one usually does not find wook ash lying around.
Hello Felix,
as always, a very good video clip from one of the best users of a SAK! Very interesting is the physics behind these techniques. Well done (and shown)!
One question is left: where can I can get ashes (as a filler) when I have no fire yet? So, being in the woods without any firestarter, the search for resin is my favorite until now. A little problem may be the production of a flat piece of wood, on which you can roll with the needed speed. And surely have a Swiss Army knife _always_ in my pocket...
Greets and all the best to you!
Achim
How hard are you pressing down on the block you are use if to roll the materials
uffff, thats hard to estimate...my be with 7-8kg (15 pounds) .
Félix Victorinox'man !
Thanks a lot for your visit on my channel!
Schönes Video aber ich bleib erstmal beim Feuerstahl. Aber wie immer super erklärt 👍
Viel Erfolg! Danke für das Kompliment!
I wonder if just cotton was used with no filler if it would work? Or just a strip of t shirt material just rolled up? Or is a filler always necessary?
No, just Cotton works... David West have such a Video th-cam.com/video/-pXyiIWksQo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=kZq7B_UFY0EBRqJu
@@FelixImmlerThanks Felix!
Hello Felix. Your lavalier microphone is facing backwards. I know it´s an omnidirectional mic (picks up sound from everywere) but sounds better when pointing at your mouth. Love your videos by the way. Greetings from Ecuador.
Thank you so much for your tip!!!
Fein, das Thema ist wirklich unterrepräsentiert. Ich probiers es auch ab und zu mit Baumwolle mit durchwachsenen Erfolg. Bast hätte ich gern noch gesehen, hab es nur einmal erfolglos mit Pappel versucht. Viele Grüße!
Super interessant... mit Bast habe ich es noch nie versucht!
What is the resin you used??
resin from a Spruce...
I am wondering if rolling the materials at an angle works better, like making homemade fuses. You will already have a constant dual-layer of materials, thus the post rolling shouldn't be as time consuming.
Thanks a lot for your comment. I 'don't understand your pints..but they sound interesting. Sorry
Einfach super 💚
Dankeschön!
cool!
Thank you!
Where do you get the ashes from,the first time you want to light a fire???
That's why i shoed you in this video 7 other fillers then ash!!!
@@FelixImmler 😄
Part of a firecraft is preparation, watch for old fires to collect ash and coal from.
This is the same as finding resin, rust and grasses from different parts of your search.
fire roll works without a filler. for example, you can ignite dry nettle with this method. but you need to be aware of the history of this technique: it was used by 2. world war POWs and in a POW camp you had dry materials (eg. cotton), wooden planks and ash.
you can do it caveman style though, by using 2 flat rocks or you split a log of wood.
there are first fire methods (bow drill) and second fire methods (flint&steel with charred materials, fire roll, hand drill, etc).
I have been using this skill for a few years and I usually use coal and rust powder mixed together on a 7x7cm cotton swab, The coal and rust mix do I have pre mixed with me in a stainless waterproof film canister and the swabs do I carry an excess of in my first aid pouch. I always carry a lighter as a part of my on me person edc and in my backpack I carry a lighter matches a magnifier lens parts of a bow drill a ferrocerium rod and a fire steel, it might sound excessive but I'm not a hiker as my body doesn't allow me to walk more then a few hundred meters so when I'm going to the forest it's by car or atv and I can bring tons of unnecessary things xD
Thanks a lot for your very interesting comment!
Hallo Felix Grüße aus Mecklenburg Vorpommern cool gleich eine neue Aufgabe bzw Aufgaben für meine Kinder man lernt nie aus danke.grüße aus Mecklenburg Vorpommern
Liebe Grüße zurück und viel Erfolg!
Hocam sen yaptın ben yoruldum🥵
Thanks a lot for your comment!
Another great way to make fire Felix,well executed.
Apparently this came from prisoners,to light there cigarettes.
There is a guy, boggy creek beast who has a fully documented channel with almost every thinkable material there is ,using this technique.
Also interesting to check him out.
Greetings
Steve
Thank you very much for your intersting Hint. I will visit his channel...
I have had luck with ashes and rust in milk weed fiber and yucca fibers
Thanks a lot for this super interesting hint!