2) BRONTES OF HAWORTH (Part 2)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- Part 2 of a lovely tho dated 4 part historical drama from YTV about the Brontes of Haworth. First aired back in the 70s.
With All rights, content & licences are owned by & belong to YORKSHIRE TELEVISION STUDIOS.
This continues to be the most authentic drama about the Brontes I have ever seen. The location, music, script and acting are first class.
Thank you for your comment Sarah, I'm really pleased you enjoyed the upload! 😘
How do you know? Love to hear this reply I really would.
Apart from the posh southern accent!
I like it too, but in my opinion the most accurate, very realistic version is To Walk Invisible: The Bronte Sisters (from 2016)
Beautifully acted. I watched this long ago, when I was 12, in 1973. The old adaptations rarely fail me. In fact, as I revisit them, they are better than ever. More will be spent these days, but actors are in the main, irredeemably modern. We have lost connection with the old world & no longer understand how they viewed life. Most actresses sound like they went to the local comp. England was profoundly class based. It's like Indian actors trying to enact drama from their country with absolutely no understanding of caste. Good or bad, that was the reality then. Thank heaven for classic, older adaptations.
I watched them long ago but it's a cold day and here I am it's my blankie and heating pad. All snug.
Very well said.. Completely agree!
I'm a member of the Australian Bronte Association...what lovely souls they all were and are!!!
How wonderful tho Brian that the impact they have had reaches out to souls even today the world over like yourself, who obviously feels what they was about, I'm lucky enough to live near Bronte country and visit often, in fact I've just been camping there this very weekend past 10th to 13th of July in the grounds of a place called . . . WUTHERING HEIGHTS INN, heaven on earth my friend, more so when on the Sunday while sitting outside the Bronte parsonage museum (A place I've visited many times) I watched live on my phone my beloved Leeds United win away at Swansea 0-1 hahaha a great lil hol all in all.
@@DaleJoyce Lucky U- if I ever go to England again- Haworth is on the list- that place must , and obviously has their vibe/spirit- great place to sit -chill and read and ponder all the things they would-I know everyone and every women is different and unique--but they are my ideal/s of what a women should be like- feminine, yet strong- creative- quirky but super sensitive to the world around them-sweet but daring-they suffered no fools- they pack a great deal of personality punch in the persons
@@brianbeergah7649 I totally agree Brian re the Bronte family, and you yourself obviously feel the true spirit of Haworth all those miles away, you only need a short moorland walk, or to sit on main street, walk thru the church yard or by the parsonage to be taken back to a different time and place, I believe you can really feel the spirituality and magic in the air from a bygone time, it envelopes all around you. My go to place for keeping sane in this crazy paced world we live in 😊
I live in England and hopefully I’ll go to Haworth, I love the Brontes and of course Branwell. I’ve got a book full of some of Branwell’s work, poems and short stories.
@@brianbeergah7649 I feel bad for charolott she died during the first few weeks of pregnancy in 1855 on march 30
I think it’s sad what happened to Branwell. His mental health clearly went down and he had so much potential. I don’t think he’s the monster people think he is.
This is really an astonishing production. It feels to me like history filmed. Thank all for its creation.
It can only truly be filmed in Yorkshire
Michael Kitchen really gives a sympathetic portrayal of Branwell. Beautifully acted!
Every time I study and enjoy one of the Brontës’ wonderful novels or poems, I remember this series, so true, it seems, to the period and what might have bien their lives. The acting is alltogether marvellous and sensitive, the realization respectful and passioned.
Very well said Ricky, I couldn't agree more 👏👏👏
@@DaleJoyce Hi Dale, I get circles so they won't let me write. I guess. Love these old shows no commercials ever. Can't corolate the different timings. Jeanie Hill. x
Kitchen as a very young man, what a shock!
I am kind of surprised how nice Branwell is. I once listened to a critique about how all three Bronte sisters used Branwell as a model for characters in their books. Rochester who was nice once Jane got to know him. The monstrous Heathcliff who Catherine could not help but passionately love. And the abusive drunken Huntingdon who Helen has to flee from. Branwell does not seem like any of those characters. He mostly seems like an irresponsible dreamer short on practical life skills. Not a dark mysterious cruel monster.
'easily bruised'
the gentleman even says "I wish we could acclimatize you to the middle Earth, instead of the extremes of paradise and hell". Sounds like bi-polar.
I feel for Branwell. He had a lot of talent, he met that women and then things got worse. I read his biography and it was really sad. I also read somewhere that they suspect he might’ve developed bipolar or something. Not 100% sure though.
Branwell comes across as very high spirited , charismatic and generous to his friends and associates .
Branwell was nothing like the characters in his sisters books, unless possibly the drunken and weak Huntington in Tenant. Characters like Heathcliff and Rochester were based loosely on Byron and Byronic heroes...
Yes poor Branwell. Sensitive artistic people often struggle for balance. They see things others don't And feel.
It's torture much of the time. Drugs and alcohol don't work, but often that's where they go. I know, been there.
He wanted to be a man, but his delicacy of spirit prevented that. He put on a brave front, poor dear boy. Very well acted here.
Michael Kitchen (Inspector Foyle) in his younger days!
Sad, how they hoped to be establish and independent, but death claimed them instead.
They did achieve some literary success and Charlotte made some money from her novels
@3rrlia I would say 2 geniuses, Charlotte and Emily.. But yes Mr Bronte was an unsual man himself having risen from a farming family in Ireland to being a clergyman.. and his intelligence was inherited by his children
@3rrlia Indeed they achieved heaps-much more than most people (us included)Massive odds- try one more- Their brother was just as talented as they-their father tutored them all-but mostly Bramwell (the older brother) they were bohemians way before the concept/term was ever coined- the quality of the persons- their art/writing/speech- rich beyond measure
Did Bramwell suffer from depression? If that's so, maybe drinking and the opium was a self -medication that eventually destroyed his life?
Bramwell liked the drugs and alcohol! From a very young age.
Some people think he might’ve even had symptoms of bipolar, but it is more than likely he suffered with depression, and alcohol is a depressant which would’ve made it worse.
I believe all four of the children were suffering from depression due to the deaths of their mother and two elder sisters. I wish this production had showed the reality of a family living with a drunkard who was becoming an alcoholic. The scene in part one should have showed the girls upset at being woken up by a drunken Bramwell who then vomited on the stairs, which of course the girls would have cleaned up, but the next day Bramwell would have no memory of the trouble he had caused. The stress of hiding the shame of their brothers self destructive behaviour would have made things worse. No wonder they felt so compelled to escape into fantasy worlds.
And worse.... having people nearly two centuries later still calling him "Bramwell" when his name was "Branwell". 🙄
@@dabear2438 Sorry, an easy mistake to make.
Part 2 of a lovely tho dated 4 part historical drama....The setting was 1840 how more dated can you get, I believe the setting though done in the 70's is very accurate.
Indeed. They used the very Parsonage as a set! Couldn't do that today.
by dated I meant filming and camera techniques silly ;-)
Speaking as a New Zealander, there is nothing strange about living in NZ.
Indeed, but for a single woman in the 1840's....it was.
haha it’s been tamed!
@@blessOTMA it was indeed very brave of Mary T to go out there and open her own business
🥰🐞🤗🦜🤩🌈👋
I liked the cheerful, happy scenes... oh wait, there weren't any. Drama, drama, drama. Tomorrow I'll call my shrink LoL. Thanks for the videos :)
I thought i recognised a very young Michael Kitchen . ! K
Very young in deed. Hardly recognized him. Horrible wig, lol
Indeed, and he his my favorite Branwell from all of the films about the family
branwell is so relatable
Surely they would all have had a Yorkshire accent considering they lived in Yorkshire, went to school in yorkshire, were born in Yorkshire and had friends from yorkshire. According to Ellen Nussey, Charlotte's best friend, when Charlotte first arrived at school she spoke with an Irish accent which isn't surprising considering her only parent alive was her northern Irish father and he was a huge influence on her life.
Not with the isolated education they had at home or the school for children of the clergy. They were not allowed to mix with other children in Haworth and would have been brought up to speak English without a regional accent as well spoken young ladies. According to Elizabeth Gaskell, Mr Bronte had no trace of an Irish accent left when she knew him and other biographers noted that it was mostly eradicated at Cambridge.
@@RiaLake it's well documented by her life long friend Mary Taylor that at the start of her school life she had a Irish accent, you can find reference to it in many of Charlotte Bronte's biographies. As time went on surrounded by Yorkshire friends with Yorkshire accents she may well have picked up a Yorkshire accent as modern children also do when they move from place to place. Probably not the broad accent that the servants, Tabby and Martha would have had, indeed the sisters laughed at the way they pronounced certain things etc but nevertheless an accent of sorts. They probably had never heard a southern accent till they went to London in their twenties, except from their Cornish aunt who would have had a Penzance accent. What exactly does a ' a well spoken young ladies' accent sound like' ? Perhaps you mean a received pronouciation accent, or AP as it is better known, that only aristocrat, upper classes and royalties had? Again there is no evidence for this, Elizabeth Gaskell herself from Manchester never noted an accent far removed from a Yorkshire one, but then again we shall never know for sure.I will look up the documented evidence that Patrick lost his accent, although with evidence Charlotte had a 'strong' Irish accent at the start of school it would be interesting to know where she got this from. Maybe Patrick " poshed up" for Mrs Gaskell.
Yes, I agree they would have had regional accents. The 70s drama dates itself by this alone! Plus, the wigs are terrible! :)@@charlottebruce979
They used an every day English accent because of the people of other parts of Britain and the world could understand what they are saying.
Why not "simply" hear the person you're talking of for yourself -- in a seance with famous direct voice medium Leslie Flint in 1973 ?!
Here she comes, in a new spirit shape, as a matter of course: th-cam.com/video/gJI7nYN6hdo/w-d-xo.html
Emily knee best her brother's mental illness and his addiction to alcohol and opiates. But for writers to sexulize their relationship is sick n wrong. The house was simply too crowded and very attached to the church...geez. Can't go wrong with a story of the Brontes
Man, that poor porter hauling the trunk behind Charlotte & her schoolgirl pal while they leisurely pause and chat! No two-wheelers available then?
Tug your forelock, churl , and be grateful for a tip!
And it’s a treat to see a YOUNG Oliver Ford Davies (4:19) briefly as Mr. Thompson when Bromwell meets other folks over a pint in Bradford
damnnn m. paul really does look like m. heger
Yes😊
Molly Elizabeth vickria Alexandrianna Marie Louise Catherine kharollte March
And Nicklaus Louie Ryan Edward James Arthur William Henry Oliver March
🤍
Thank you.
I wonder if Aunt Branwell might prefer use of the word “spittle” to “spit?”
…”sputum…?
Mary Josephine franssca louise eilzabeth jane alice Taylor
A lamentably unmulticultural production.
Because that is how Haworth was back then . . history should not be changed to be politicly correct . . now that would be lamentable my friend.
@@DaleJoyce It was a tongue in cheek comment Dale. I missed this programme back in the 70s. Maybe it was only shown in the Yorkshire TV area. Thanks for putting it up mate.
@@TheForkhandles Oops! Sorry for being a bone head my friend 😂
In fairness to Dale, that DID look like one of those short sighted Lib-bigot remarks you might find in the Guardian or some BBC topical prog. I'm SO glad you were joking, I can guarantee some of the more thoroughly indoctrinated will be thinking that thought in real earnest....
I'm still laughing at the forced insertion of an Asian female blacksmith into the Beowulf series set in 8th century Scandinavia....!? I would find it just as funny if a Yorkshire lass turned up as the chief of a tribe in "Roots" btw.
@@poetryjones7946 This is a superb series I missed on first broadcast.I Love Anne since thomk she is the most underrated of the Bronte sisters.
Part 3 anyone.
ive uploaded all 4 parts my friend .
Thanks, Dale - very kind of you............cheers!