Bee Gees Reaction - Fanny Be Tender With My Love
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024
- I'm currently homeless and down on my luck I can really use some help anything will do. Please and thank you, David
Click to Donate
gofund.me/046f... OR Cash App: $vantheory24
Please Come and Join Me at My New Channel Reaction Theory 2.0
Reaction Theory 2.0 : / @reactiontheory20
SOCIALS
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Twitter: Re...
Instagram: / reactiontheory
Facebook: react.theo.9
---------------------------------------------------------------------
For business inquiries: bigreactiontheory@gmail.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm currently homeless and down on my luck, I can really use some help anything will do. Please and thank you, David
Click to Donate
gofund.me/046f127c OR Cash App: $vantheory24
No it's Maurice singing deep
Hey, man, thank you for this. So sick of being laughed at by white folx for taking the Bee Gees seriously. Are you still down on your luck? Your followers might like news about you!
Quincy Jones said "Fanny" was possibly the greatest R&B song ever written.
Holy crap this song is a masterpiece in my opinion! The harmonies are perfection!!!
👌👌👌👌
My favorite song just wonderful
What a prettty breathtaking woman ,hello my Beauty ?
Funnily enough, The Bee Gees started with deeper voices only discovering falsetto abilities in the 70s. Maurice and Robin both harmonised on that deeper line. If you watch live version of Nights on Broadway, Barry is singing very deeply with Maurice doing the falsetto later. Robin had a unique voice which shows up on I started a joke and Massachusetts. The brothers were insanely gifted!
Ppl didn't realize for a long time what an amazing voice and range Maurice had
Robin is the DEEP VOICE on this, but in fact they all have the capacity of deep voice singing. Robin's is the most unique and you can really hear it in their older songs (60's) when Robin did most of the lead singing. This is a magnificent group who made contributions to the universe of music that is still not widely ENOUGH known. Especially with the younger generation. This is what AUTHENTIC talent looks like. And impeccable manners to boot. They were/are a CLASS ACT 100%.
I disagree the editing on the video was a little bit off because most of the deep voice in this video or in this song was actually Maurice.
@@jmartinez9332 it's the two of them together. I was there!
@@texbex9928 You were actually at the recording?? Your photo looks pretty young unless that's not you. By the way if you were around them just curious as to why Maurice didn't sign more lead on occasion because he had a beautiful voice. His voice was amazing in Wildflower. Was Maurice reluctant to sing lead? If you were there I would love to know Thanks.
What makes the BeeGees unique is that they ALL can sing in any voice! This song shows this better than most, of course Barry mostly the falsetto, but they can all do it. Perfect harmonies! 💕🎶 ❤️ Deep voice mostly Maurice.
@@kykittykat2435 - Yeah, but it was reported in an interview with Barry that it was Robin's voice in this case. That's what I placed my understanding of this in.
This song is amazing. They all hit their deep voices in unison. They are truly masters.
My fav song by the Bee Gees, there’ll never be another sound ever like the sound that came out of those three brothers.
Absodabsolutely!!❤️❤️❤️
My favorite Bee Gees song Their harmonies are amazing!.A masterpiece
They could all sing equally well with thier chest voices, and the falsetto voices. Its the combination of the voices that make the unique sound. Love the way they switch between the highs and lows on this song. The lyrics are so beautiful. one of my favorites of thiers.
It's one of the rare songs in which you can hear the range and depth of each Gibb's voice; Maurice stuns with great harmony and Robin, long considered the best singer in the group, also shines with a surprising depth not normally seen in the fragile timber of his voice.👍🏻🤩🏴
They are absolutely sent by God to raise your vibrations. I might be old but we had the best music!
We need to come up with a term for the smiles everyone gets from the Bee Gees.
It the smile you get when one has been BeeGeed. Haha.
Bee Cheese😁
@@kimware348 OK, that's cute.
BiG smile
All of them had incredible vocal range. Mo with his harmonies, but Robin and Barry did a battle of the falcelltos in this one. And yes Robin could do the deep voice and so could Barry and Maurice. So talented these brothers. Love them forever!!
They are truly the most Talented group ever. Writing skills as well as voice skills.
It was Robin, the three can sing falsetto and deeper ranges. They said this song was the hardest to sing, because of the three part vocal changes/ranges. Yes they did that, 'Jesus and his two Disciples'. lol
I know that you freakin out, 😆 because this is their stunning masterpiece from the 1975 main course album, with Barry Robins and Maurice perfect high pitched falsetto harmonies and amazing blended in 16 audio tracks😱 perfectly mixed by Karl Richardson & Legendary Arif Mardin. As Barry told their instrumentally most complex and difficult song, impossible to cover and praised as the best soul tune of all time from a white group from the RnB "Goat"Quincy Jones and Paul McCartney 🍾
For decades I thought I was the only one who loved and remembered this song, it was largely forgotten by even Bee Gees fans. I don’t know how it got so popular on reaction channels but it did. But my favorite part is the comments section where I find out there are others just like me….who call this their favorite. This just isn’t my favorite Bee Gees song, it’s my all time favorite song! I always figured that something else would come along and knock it off my top spot--but nothing ever did. This is pure perfection!!!
That was Barry's deep voice. Love this song.
That deep voice is Robin. It sounds like him. Barry sings ...standing the rain...in a deep voice. You can tell it is him.
Actually most of this is Barry and Robin with Mo coming in on the harmonies. Mo said that the two of them had a distinctive voice together different then them separate. Barry said the guys have 5 different voices that they can use to sing. Deep voice is a mixture of Barry snd Robin.
The Bee Gees do all ranges-- even the falsettos. The brothers have said in interviews that BOTH Barry and Robin are blending in the deep "chest" voices -- lots of layering over of tracks. I think I heard in that interview 16?? Barry and Robin interchange a lot with "chest" and "head" voices with Maurice adding his harmonies too. They SELDOM sang this song live. Too hard. I listen to the official tract and put my best headphones and JAM. When I remember which interview, I will send you the link. I think Maurice and Robin explain it.
I would LOVE a link to that interview if you have it. I watched it about 3 yrs ago and now I can't find it again. Cheers!
You have excellent taste. After 45 years of listening to them, I have to say this song is my favorite too. :))
Good to see the Bee Gees being recognized, belatedly, for what they are. And yes, the basis of those huge low-pitched rich notes is (dearest) Robin, that slim, slight figure in the middle. His natural range goes from the depths of baritone to near the top of Barry's falsetto. When Robin sings (with his operatic head-voice) in unison with Barry's falsetto it's unbelievable. I had to learn to recognize it. Similarly, the harmonic roar when all three (but anchored by Robin) sing it tight harmony at the low end is, to me, more amazing and carries more emotion than the high stuff.
Fanny be Tender is also my favorite. But for an easier lesson on how the brothers' voices work together, try "Don't Fall in Love With Me" on the Living Eyes album. Also listen hard to Wildflower, another Living Eyes track. That's a rare one led by Maurice, whose voice is sweet, sweet, if not as unique as the other two. But he could have been a solo recording artist if he'd chosen that path. I'm glad he didn't. That voice is so good at blending that it's in many ways the glue that holds these songs together.
RT, this is also my #1 Bee Gees song! (For what it's worth, it was also their mother's favorite.) As for who is singing which parts, it's really hard to tell with this footage because it's been overdubbed with the studio version of the song. The Bee Gees rarely played this song live, because it was too hard to replicate on stage all the vocal layering they were able to accomplish in the studio. Having said that, the deep part might be more than one brother, but if it was only one, then my money would go on Maurice.
Me too...by far!
That's Barry.
It's Barry. Robin can belt it out too, but I know their voices. Listen to Nights on Broadway to hear a lot of Barry's deep chest voice. Maurice has a deep voice, but again a different quality. All three have wonderful individual voices that blend together as heavenly as one will ever hear!!
Maurice had the most versatile voice of the three. If you watch a *lot* of taped interviews (as I have - pandemic) Barry mentions this numerous times. Maurice "always sang the high parts" - and it's Maurice on falsetto in Nights on Broadway. He could also go all the way down to baritone.
@@deborahherman7463Maurice did the falsetto when performing live (The Midnight Special, etc) but the original studio recording it's Barry all the way.🎶
My favorite song!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️ They can all sing deep and high and you just never know!! So amazing!! Watch Run to me!!
They take turns on all the parts, high and low. They liked that people were trying to figure out who sang what in this song.
Maurice has a naturally deeper voice. Take a listen to man in the middle when he takes the lead.
Yet he often takes high harmony, per Barry.
That was Barry's voice. Barry try out various singing until he knew he could sing falsetto voice.
If that’s Jesus & the two disciples, maybe I will go back to church!
🤔😂
We do know what Christ looked like & Barry Gibb does looks like him.
You are too funny!
Really love your comment cause Bee Gees are my gods since 1977💕💕💕💕💖💖💖💖💖💖
A vocal and instrumental masterpiece and Quincy Jones loved it.
Be sure to check out the Stylistics. They had a singer with a falsetto voice, too and did beautiful harmonies together.
Loved your reaction. You looked delighted, like a little boy on his birthday. ☺️
Robin is killer on this his team up with Barry on the crescendo what incredible talent...
Thanks for posting this. I grew up in the south, and the country rock crowd and, to some extent, the general public made fun of these guys relentlessly in the mid to late seventies. I bought most of their albums regardless of the hate. Most people in the USA my age only associated the Bee Gees with Saturday Night Fever, meaning they were only disco types. But even their disco songs were good. This group was so talented on so many levels over many decades.
They weren't a disco band, but R&B, Blue Eyed Soul, had songs in a movie about disco, but they got pigeonholed into that category.
Totally agree with you Joe, they are amazing 🥰
I LOVE THE BEE GEES. I remember where I was and when I heard their first song. It was love at first note. They were super marvelous and original. Sad to know only one is left.
I love how Barry closes his eyes when singing 😊
It doesn't take you long to know when the Bee Gees are singing a song. It's instantaneous. Among the greatest and recognizable voices in music.
Sweet Jesus, my god it sounds like a choir!
What a blessing to spend your life making music with your brothers......shocking!!!!!!
Thank you for the reaction.... Sub'd my friend
It is super cool to see Robin shine. ❤
You cannot tell from this video who is singing what- with a few exceptions. I have heard that deep voice come from Barry before. Maurice pitches in on the 3 part harmony. I think some of it is Barry and Robin harmonizing. Barry does the opening lyrics. Beyond that is really hard to tell! The production by the great producer Arif Mardin on this song was stellar!
They all sang deeply in the beginning. They innovated in the 70's to more falsetto. Amazing 👏
Cresci ouvindo. Bee Gees. me tornei fa numero 1 amoo eternamente. minha banda preferida. bee gees será.pra sempre. etetnamente inesquecivel ❤❤❤❤
To answer your question of, "Whom has the deep voice?" The deep and high sound voices come from Barry, the tallest and older of the brothers. He was pretty humble, so he probably didn't want the camera focused on him all the time. He pretty much wrote most of their songs too. They all were very talented, but in my humble opinion without Barry Gibb, there won't be the Bee Gees we all know today. The guy was incredibly talented. By the way, I think they all complemented each other.
They couldn’t have been Bee Gees without all three of them. I think in this song Robin and Barry did the low voice you can tell it is both. Also Maurice told it in an interview. They all were equally talented none anymore than the other. They all wrote the songs together not sure why you think Barry wrote most of them. Couldn’t have been as successful as they were if not for all three of The Brothers.
Quincy Jones said this was the most perfect RnB song he’d ever heard at the time
That deep voice DID come out of Robin, it wasn’t Barry, like some people are saying
Actually it's Robin and Barry singing at the same time. Maurice said so in an interview. They could never sing this song live because of the over lapping of the falsetto voices.
@@cathysorge8433 All the Bee Gees could go deep or sing Falsetto. To be able to switch up and down so effortless like they did and how Barry still does is amazing. To me the Bee Gees were and will always be better than the Beatles.
@@cathysorge8433 Here it is live
th-cam.com/video/jOb-SjGex1Y/w-d-xo.html
Here they are singing it live
th-cam.com/video/jOb-SjGex1Y/w-d-xo.html
Totally agree with Quincy Jones, this song is amazing💖💖💖💖 Barry, Robin and Mo are Gods💛💙💛💜💙💛💜💙💚💓💓
All three brothers could do high and low tones.Falcetto to baritone.They all had that voice range.And when they harmonize they sound like one voice.
Easily my favorite Bee Gees song. Great reaction!
Check out To Love Somebody, it’s a great song but Maurice comes in right at the end and it’s amazing. I think he should have sung more. Robin does a song called I Started a Joke which gives you an idea of how good his voice is as well. Love the Bee Gees. Jive Talking is another good song.
My belief is that this song is the best song the Bee Gees ever produced, followed closely by Too Much Heaven.
Awesome BeeGees, one of best groups of all time.
The deep voice is Barry. Incredible range with all of them.
Barry and Robin can sing both deep and high so much talent.
They had such versatile voices. They only found their falsetto later in their careers.
They could all hit a fairly low tenor/high baritone then go up to the rafters with their falsettos. In this one they swapped off showing their range.
Another song to see their range is Nights On Broadway. If I remember right, that's the first time that they really started using falsetto especially Barry's rafter climbing one.
My top 3 bee gees songs in order hands down forget the rest , 1 fanny be tender , inside and out , Love so right .BANG loop the 3 and live a happy life.
So so pleased to see you genuinely loving the harmonies from the Bee Gees.. It takes time to work it out.. But time is all we have.. So enjoy 🎵👌
I believe that was Barry & Robin singing together. If you want to hear Barry’s lower range, watch “Nights on Broadway” live on the Midnight Special. Also features Robin solo and Maurice falsetto.
They found their Falsetto accidentally. They were recording and Barry sang something and it surprised all of them.
People made a mockery of them. They made some of the finest harmony in the business. They are equal to The Beach Boys, The 4 Seasons and Jackson 5❤
Esse video foi feito com a gravação original da música, feita no Criteria Studios, Miami, 1975, álbum Main Course. Tanto a voz condutora quanto a voz de falsete são do Barry Gibb. Na verdade, Robin e Maurice fizeram apenas o background vocal, na parte do refrão. Aliás, assim como em Nights on Broadway, Barry utilizou a voz de falsete por sugestão do produtor do álbum, Arif Mardin. O resultado foi fantástico. A partir daí, nos albuns posteriores, Barry passou a utilizar mais a voz de falsete, de forma carismática. Adoro músicas como Love so Right, More Than a Woman, Night Fever, Too Much Heaven, elas marcaram a ferro e fogo minha juventude nos anos 70. Gratidão eterna aos irmãos Gibb.
This is just one of the greatest songs ever !
Meravigliosi, incredibili, fantastici, adorabili Robin, Maurice , Barry, sempre e per sempre nel mio cuore, forever in my heart ,,,Anny from Italy
Check out young Robin Gibb singing the song Somewhere. He was 16 and his voice is just incredible. That was still Robin singing low, they just didn't put the camera on him at that time. Robin had incredible range!!
The deep voice is Barry's. Wind of Change is another good one from this album...
It was all three... A lot of the lines we think are Barry are actually Barry and Robin sounding like a single voice.
The deep voice is Maurice, he can sing it all, he's the glue that wholes the group together
Yes, Barry, at least predominantly. Might be blended with a brother or even with himself. There's a lot of layering in this wonderful song.
You're funny, and I can think of no better description than "they went to church!" I love the Bee Gees. I have always loved the Bee Gees and I'm 70 years old
There will never be another group like them. EVER. Today's song writers (with the possible exception of Ed Sheeran) either have never experienced their level of loving or they're too cowardly to articulate it.
I hurt for Barry's loss. And I loved and appreciated the comments he made on an old Mike Douglass show interview where he openly and unashamedly honored and credited R&B (aka "Soul Music") music and vocalists as a pattern for the way he'd adlib and use his falsetto. (Check it out on TH-cam)
(Good Reaction. Glad I found you.)
Note: 2 key changes back to back.
They all have crazy ranges.
Listen to Robin sing I Started A Joke...his voice🎙👏👏👏🎶🎶💕
The deep voice is definitely Barry 's
Love how he called them JESUS AND HIS DISCIPLES
My favorite song by them!
The Bee Gees straight dominated the 70's disco Era, and don't forget about the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack, classic shit. DCOG
Funny thing is that out of all the great songs that they are responsible for, this song has always been at the top of my favorites along with Nights on Broadway.
This. Ah be my favorite BG song, ever!! Always a surprise, right?? Any of them can sing ❤❤❤anything!!
The video is out if sync that deep voice is definitely Barry,'s Nice reaction. That Jesus and the Two disciples was hilarious BTW
This my favorite song too!!
Barry can have a lower voice too. They are multi faceted. Nights on Broadway my fav
+Ann Eaves Thank you, for watching my video. I've moved to a new channel this channel will still be active with fun content but music will be more to the new channel. Check out my least video for why on this channel.
Don't Care to know why and wish to come over anyway subscribe at:
Reaction Theory 2.0 : th-cam.com/channels/ePTMdn3x0MbiZAIJbeqzdA.html
All three brothers sang tenor and falscetto.And were so good at it.If you notice on the last part of "Fanny" they all went with their falscetto.This song is a favorite of most BeeGees fans.
Wow...just incredible with Robin and Barry goin' at it with the vocals...omg just wow...and loved the comment "Jesus and his two disciples" (this made me smile, lol)
What a pretty breathtaking woman ,hello my Beauty ?
@@MrWierchawsky O.o
@@NightFireXD OMG what a pretty woman, hello my princess you, are an angel fallen from the sky how deep is your love for the Bee Gees, you are more than a woman in this Saturday night fever but If i can't have you it is a tragedy with no emotion but still Staying alive alone.
@@MrWierchawsky k
Great reaction…..& love the way you’re lovin on The Bee Gees!
This is in my top five favorite Bee Gees a song!
if you listen to An Audience With Lulu, she sings a duet with Maurice "Come 1st of May" and you will hear how deep Maurice's voice is
Deep voice Maurice he also does high falsetto...talented Maurice. Robin ....n Barry the fab BGSXXXXXXX 😁
Have you listened to "For Whom the Bell Tolls?" Robin really opens up on the chorus.
That deeper voice influx was everything 😍❣️👍👍👍
Still marvelous music....harmonies, talent and like nothing like them since.
Robin and Barry I think. Mo was doing higher Falsetto according to Barry. Both Robin and Mo had great Falsetto and Mo had an amazing deep voice as well. Barry's voice is very distinct and easier to pick out. But the twins blend so seamlessly with him. Epic vocals and song.
Beegees at their B E S T....
They all three had beautiful baritones.
Bee gees were the best. Nobody to touch them
Unas de mis canciones mas bellas beegee x siempre los amare
One comment says Robin and Maurice, and another says Barry. I think it’s Robin and Barry together. The two of them often sang together exactly the same, and usually in the same mic, so sounding like only one voice. Maurice was certainly part of the mix at times, but he usually came in for three part harmonies. Robin had the widest range - higher and lower than his brothers, but didn’t do much in the lower except in the first couple of years after his voice changed, then stayed with his signature and very unique sound. Their first song with a solo part by Robin is WINE AND WOMEN. There’s a video from an Australian tv performance before they returned to England and went international. It’s also the first guitar (or bass?) solo by Maurice. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE react to it!!!
Maurice said Robin and Barry sang together on the line, Fanny be tender with my love. That was the higher part. He didn't say who song that lower opera sounding voice, but it sounds like Robin for sure.
Maurice was singing falsetto as well as harmony and deep part. Robin had a tendency to sing softly so he could come in on time with his voice.
That was Barry singing "Cause it's all that I got & my love won't forsake me" It's probably the worst music video because they had more than one track of vocals overlapped in the studio and why they never played this song in concert but Quincy Jones said, "This Is The Most Perfect R&B Song He Ever Heard" It's a masterpiece anyhow!
All I see is you jamming out to the BeeGees and its making me smile. This is a great jam!
Pretty sure it’s Barry and Robin together on the baritone sounding parts. Barry’s voice is prob the louder of the two.
And someone said that they felt it was one of their hardest songs to sing live since there are so many moving parts. More baritone in Nights on Broadway!
I love your audio quality, well they all took some base lines, this song is a masterpiece.
It is both Robin and Maurice at different times. At 2:08 it clearly Maurice. This is an incredible song.
This song was recorded once and never performed live. In fact once it was recorded they never touched it again. The video is lip syncing. Barry overdubbed his voice numerous times and the brothers offered only distant background vocals and a woo.. I think that was Maurice. This is really a Barry song, he said it was difficult to piece it together so they never played it again. It's one of my favorites of theirs.
That was Maurice, correct.
Here’s more:
Run to me
Holiday
I can’t see nobody
Love you inside and out
Will you still love me tomorrow
Alone
This is just where I came in.
❤️
My favorite Bee Gees too. I think robin and Mo being twins they could mimic each others voices.
the deep voice part was Barry even tho they were showing Robin lol
No, they were singing simultaneously.
My favorite song, just incredible human being like the BG brothers can do that for us and thanks to you Reaction with the way you enjoy the music
Crud, the songs has a combination of 25 to 26 tracks laid over it? It is a combination of all of them at different times and ranges. It's my favorite song!!!!!
Every reaction of this song I see smiles on every time.
Robin and Barry would sing simultaneously at times and sounded like one voice according to Maurice Gibb.
Check out the recent HBO Documentary about them called “Bee Gees How Can You Mend a Broken Heart.” It is amazing and up for 6 Emmys.