Spoiler alert I guess! As if this video wasn’t torture enough, I’m here to make things worse “I can see the stars my lady” “Bob says hello” “You stupid Aphrodite girl” “See. Charley” “Family Luke, you promised “ “Promise me one thing. Whatever happens, when you get back on Olympus, when you’re a god again, remember, remember what it’s like to be human” “From now on, I’ll be more than Lester. I will be Apollo, I will remember” Now, who wants to join me in crying in the corner. Great video by the way, even if it was sad
@@Unclaimeddemigod you’re very welcome I guess. You kinda get influenced by Rick’s heartlessness after reading the books a million times. Also, forgot to mention this in my original comment, but I’m really looking forward to the lightning thief musical video. Other than reviews, I haven’t found videos solely talking about the musical, so this would be very exciting
@@Unclaimeddemigod I love spoilers cause..... I can't read/watch anything without spoilers or I will have breakdowns everytime something sad happens..... 😔
Wait, am I the only one hwo remembers the fact that Nico felt biancas death? Which means he had to live with that feeling til' percy came back and said to him that she really is dead and killed every peace of hope he had.... That just so sad!
The important thing to remember about Bianca is that she realized her mistake, took full responsibility, and sacrificed herself so that the others could save the world. She wanted to see Nico again, but she knew that she would either be killed by Talos with her friends or die saving them from him, and she chose to save her friends.
Man, Jason was one of my favorites characters, his death just broke me a lot, I almost stopped reading TOA. When Leo asked "where is jason", I just started to cry like a little kid.
I started crying the moment you said "Bob the Titan". I thought I'd survive this, but THIS one is too much. I was spoiled about Jason's death, but I still felt... terrible after reading it. The scene HURT. I actually liked Jason in HoO too.
My opinion: Luke, Ethan, and Silena were all heroes and Bianca leaving Nico is understandable, she wanted a chance to be her own person for a change. Also, Silena's last name is Beauregard and in my experience trust me, Luke is wayyyyyyyyyy more controversial than Silena.
To be honest, while reading 'The Titan's curse' for the first time,I was sure Bianca didn't really die, because it was "off screen" and when it turned out she actually did, I was very surprised. And sad. I'm sure they won't whitewash Beckendorf. I mean, why would they? Glad someone finally remembered Esperanza and Michael. Micheal is so underrated.
To me I thought the top two saddest deaths are Luke as saddest death then Jason as the next one each scarred me emotionally on a deeper level than any other death I’ve ever read in a book.
Spoiler Warning .. I don't really like Jason, in HOO he wasn't all the developed, we were told he was this big hero and then he spends half the battles sitting on his bum waiting for Piper to save him, but his death was so meaningful in TOA because he taught Apollo about human life and OMG Pipers reaction broke me
WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT HE ALWAYS TRIES HIS BEST PIPER NEVER SAVED HIM MAUBE ONCE BUT ARE YOU MAD YES HE GETS KNOKED OUT ALOT BUT , HIS CHARACTER IS DEVELOPED AT LEAST AS DEVELOPED AS PIPERS ! AND HIS ACTIONS IN TRIALS OF APOLLO ARE HEROIC HE DEFINES HEROIC BECASE HE IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE A GREAT HERO WHO NEVER WANTS TO SIT DOWN AND DO NOTHING SO DONT MAKE IT SEEM LIKE HE DID NOTHING , OKAY
I always loved Percy Jackson as a kid and then never read the hero’s of Olympus or any other of the series till I was older and fell back in love with mythology and always thought I was a bit childish for it, I’m so glad I’m not the only grown person who loves Rick riordans work!!
Technically Selena is and was a hero.....if you think about it, the only reason Selena accepted the role of saboteur from Luke, was to save Beckendorf......if Percy or annabeth or any other character was in that situation they would definitely agree, especially Percy because of his fatal flaw........and being the daughter of Aphrodite, she would do anything for love.....it’s just that the scenario or situation she was thrown into, was extremely desperate and manipulative, and emotionally straining 🙂😞............
Nope. She was initially manipulated by luke due to her crush on him ..when she wanted to back off, then luke threatened to escape her and to harm beck. We also can't forget that beck died because of her amd that's y she committed suicide
@@adarshraj2978 i think you’ll find my point in your answer. She was MANIPULATED by luke either ways, we don’t know what exactly he asked her to do at the beginning, but the fact that she tried to back out showed that she had a conscience. Then she was THREATENED by luke. Even though she willingly participated at the beginning, she eventually realised her mistake and tried to fix it. A hero isn’t someone who doesn’t make mistakes, its those who try desperately and sacrifices everything to correct them. In this case Selena payed with her life. Its a difference of opinion; you have yours i have mine, thats all.
yes I was really sad too. I was hoping get would go to Olympus with Apollo or return to the grave but he didn't ;-; . he is underrated (at least I think it's a he)
I wasn't a huge fan of Jason in HOO. But when I started to see him again in the TOA I was so happy and when he died I was so devastated. It's when something or someone dies that you understand he or it was important
Honestly for some reason some of the deaths that hit me the hardest were the side characters...like never getting to hear about Dakota drinking his Kool aid ever again made me so sad.
it is easy to feel bad about the deaths of smaller characters, bc they've only been portrayed in funny or good light, like Dakota, so there is no reason for us to dislike him which makes his death suck. It just feels so unnecessary, where as when bigger characters die, it is usually important to the plot.
Micheal Yew told Percy to cut the tether holding the bridge I was very upset that he died. I also loved his sass during the counselor meeting it was gold
SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER As soon as I reached number 4 I shed some tears ngl :( my phone lockscreen are stars and under them is „Bob says Hello“ written. Great video idea! Very interesting and sad to watch
in my opinion, Silena died a hero. It can be justified as to why she helped Kronos, since she was being manipulated, but i still think it is a little too black and white and simplistic to straight up say she was a hero the way Clarisse said it. I think Clarisses bias towards Silena because of their friendship was kind of affecting her response, because I think whether Silena was a hero is too complex to give a yes or no answer.
I hated Jason and definitely didn’t appreciate him at all when he was alive, but after his death, I began to love and respect him. So, thank you, Rick, for making me realize all of that, even if it had to be through his death. I’m not ok. JASON DESERVED BETTER 😭😭
I don't like it when a seemingly good super-powerful hero straight up kills a much weaker crapsack no matter how much they "deserve it" That wouldn't be in Percy's character,he didn't kill Smelly Gabe,who made his life sh*t for years. Octaivain accidentally dying is ironic, Nico didn't kill him, if he didn't Gaea might have won.
SPOILER DONT READ MORE UNLESS YOU WANT TO GET SPOILED The Prophecy said that Bianca would be lost so technically she didn't have to die but she did unfortunately
Silena's death is actually in my top 3 saddest death in the entire series. I literally stopped to book to cry my eyes out. Thinking about it now makes me want to tear up again
I got spoiled for Jason's death and I'm honestly kind of glad, if I hadn't known I would've been in denial for so long, I wouldn't have thought it was real. It would've hit me like a brick (Pun intended).
I found Jason's death super sad too. He was actually the hero of heroes of olympus who i liked the least but was just sad that he died. Really, I really cried. The saddest part was when Leo turned up at the others' house and found out about the death and he couldn't even tell him how it was supposed to be. :( I was also super sad with Leo because I loved him so much and then relieved because he would still be there. R.I.P Jason and the others. They were all heroes.
Whole "The Last Olympian" Book ripped me apart. First chapter... death... I stopped reading.... for an hour because I couldn't handle it but I at the other side couldn't stop! And then I finished it in a day and I was so done. My husband asked my many times if I want to go asleep an read the end tomorrow. "Just one chapter" it was and then there was another thing and another death and I couldn't stop and at the end I cryed for the last chapters so hard.
What about Leo Valdez He technically died and came back It took my aunt a super long time to finish the book as she left it alone for 5 years after reading that he died
so... all of the deaths you mentioned that happened in the books broke me. like, i read one book, cried, thought that the next book would be happier, nope, cried some more, ext so, there was a lot of crying... ALSO: if they whitewash Beckendorf, they should at least make Silena black
Ok this is irrelevant but: Why did camp half blood send Grover to get Thalia. When Luke, Thalia and Annabeth were running around together, Grover was send to get Thalia because she was a daughter of Zeus but Grover decided to also help Luke and Annabeth. But Grover is the same age as Percy and Annabeth, in human years Grover is much older but in satyr years he’s the same age, meaning Grover was 7 in satyr years when he was send to bring Thalia to camp half blood, why did they send a 7 year old satyr to retrieve a demigod of high importance like a child of Zeus, I just thought about this and it just doesn’t make sense, there would be many older and more experienced satyrs who could have been sent to get Thalia but they sent A 7 YEAR OLD, why did they send child. Anyway, that’s just something I thought about.
When I read about Jason’s death it took me a whole 4 months to get over him im serious I felt so bad that he died with good intentions. He died with the mission to create statues of all the minor gods not only to honor them so they don’t feel unimportant, but he also wanted to make the shrines so that demigods could complete quests easier without the minor gods hating on them. I have always loved him ❤
All of the deaths are sad but for me the saddest deaths are Zoë Nightshade, Luke Castellan, Silena Beauregard, and Bob. Zoë dying alongside her good friend Artemis was so sad. Even though her death was sad, it was also beautiful because she was turned into a constellation. I did see Luke as a traitor but towards the end, he saw the error of his ways and turned on Kronos and was responsible for defeating him. I think he was a hero towards the end. What Annabeth said to him, "Family, Luke. You promised," was so heartbreaking. He was good towards the end. But that's just my opinion.
I was going to say if you didn't say Jason's death was the saddest I would of had to fight you. I didn't know Jason was going to get killed off like that. When I reread "The Trials of Apollo The Burning Maze" I started tearing up again when he got killed. Then in the 4th one when he was delivered to Camp Jupiter and they did his funeral
The musical has so many references my personal favorite being from grover says about Percy and Annabeth "they'll kill each other or they will kiss if we're lucky they'll end up in an abyss"- in the same boat
Silena literally took the Ares cabin to war that alone is a redemption act in itself. Luke died a traitor who realized he f***ed up, so he was both since he did realize what he did wasn't right. Zoe needed more book time she was awesome and deserves the higher placing since Bianca wasn't given much of a back story, we saw Zoe's hatred for Riptide and the fact that she faced her family who exiled her was beyond heartbreaking. And Beckendorf was an amazing character and all made me cry
The saddest deaths in no order for me are: Charles Beckendorf (TLO), Randolph Chase (HOT), Zoe Nightshade (TTC), Jason Grace (TBM), Luke Castellan (TLO), Crest (TBM), Bianca di Angelo (TTC), Bob (not actually dead but yeah), Gunilla (SOS), and Ethan Nakamura (TLO)
I'm a little unsure about including Bob First, he is immortal, so he can't die Second, it was never confirmed he did Third, it seems Nico was hearing his voice calling out for him from Tartarus in ToN
Percy: (nervous) It started out as a minor scramble with a few monsters, but next thing I know, I'm tangled with half the Titan Army. Annabeth: (panics)
Spoiler Selena and Luke are heros. Definitely. About Bianca, um......I was sad when she died, and I liked her even though she left Nico alone, but when I realized that she made the childish-funny-innocent-adorable Nico disappear, I was like oh.......ur.......Bianca why !?!?😭😭😭 And Jason~~~I don't hate him, and I don't love him, but hi is really such a great character, and how he trates others is very kind, like how he wants to be friends with our favorite death boy, and he died for saving a girl that breaked up with him, a girl he had just met for maybe a week, and a week guy who was a jerk god before. I'm sorry for the Piper lovers, but she made a new girlfriend from nowhere right after Jason's death is making me angry.
I haven't read any of these books for a few years and I don't remember who most of these characters are. Some of them are names I remember and a couple are ones that I remember very clearly.
If the Disney+ show didn't kill Charles Bekendorf...I mean I love the guy but......this fandom practically started a riot because Annabeth wasn't blonde....
My sad death list... 10. Micheal Yew 9. Luke (never felt too much of a connection but I put him here because he was alright in the end) 8. Pan (it was very depressing for me) 7. Charles Beckendorf 6. Silena Beaurogard 5. Bianca 4. Ethan Nakamura (he may be a bit high but I just felt really bad for the dude) 3. Jason 2. Bob 1. Zoë Nightshade (she literally knew her fate the whole journey) there are probably a couple more deaths that I thought were sad that I can't think of at the moment :')
Me who just read the chapter when jason dies in toa yesterday............and yes I was spoiled abt his death which made me rly mad but yeah his death was super sad but I feel like bob's death in my opinion was sadder These heroes deserve more!
I didn’t know how much I like Jason until I heard of his terrible fate He didn’t do ONE wrong thing (Luke betrayed the gods, Silena was the spy, Bianca stole sth…) and yet he had to BREAK UP with his girlfriend, DIE and then not having all his friends at his funeral Not mentioning being “abducted” (or given up) at 2 years old, having no mental backup (how did he even survive? No one actually cared for him except Reyna, he had to carry duties from a young age…). His whole short life was nothing but devastating, with only a few months of happiness with Piper, and then Piper got into some “identity crisis” and got herself a girlfriend Yeah, probably a typical life of a son of Zeus (minus Perseus?)
I have a question, I read the German version of HOO and at the end Piper and Jason tell their grandchildren about the fight with the giants. Is that also the case in the original because I always thought Jason couldn't die as a result. Can someone enlighten me?
I read Jason’s death scene like a long time ago, and when I read read it I completely forgot about it, then I read the part when they take his body on the plane, and I’m like, why do I remember this one scene, but not who is in, and who died?
I was also spoiled for Jason's death, but it still hurt when I got around to reading it. It REALLY hurt because Jason was just nice. He's not my favorite, but I like how just nice he was. He was a really good kid and I liked that the other books didn't just gloss over his death. They made it mean something. SPOILER: Though Dakota's death hurt too because I wasn't expecting it and I thought he was cool.
I feel that Bianca's death was sadder than Zoe's. It's more tragic because like you said, she brought it upon herself, and DECIDED to make up for it by killing herself.
Luke and Silena are the two deaths that have always had me conflicted. Silenas death hit me really hard, mostly because of Clarisses and the other campers reactions. But another part of me felt like her death was kind of necessary to the story. She was a traitor, and even if her motives can be justified by how you look at it, if she lived, the campers would forever hold a grudge against her for being partially responsible for a lot of deaths. Silena herself would also have to live with the guilt of being responsible for her boyfriends death, and I think there is something bittersweet in the idea that she is now in esylum (or whoever you spell it) with Charles. She might not have fully lived a heros life, but she 100% died a heros death, and that's what i think makes her death so tragic. Lukes death though, I cried at, and I don't fully understand why. I never liked Luke, I have never been able to see him through the hero lens that many other people could. But knowing that a part of him felt remorse and regret for what he did has me conflicted. He chose the right thing in the end, and although I personally believe he deserves the fields of asphodel, he fulfilled the prophecy and died the way he was destined to. Lukes backstory also added a lot to what could have been a fairly basic death scene. His history with Annabeth and what happened to his mom just made it so much worse then it needed to be. Luke was still young when all of this happened, and although he wasn't a hero and he clearly was not a good person, he never wanted Kronos to take full control. He wanted revenge for his parents wrongs, but he picked the wrong outlet for that anger. So idk, those two have always struck a cord with me.
imagine being jason selfless for your whole life 15yrs putting the others needs and the camps needs before himself working hard and preventing the position of leadership and power in any form due to his determination to restore honour back to a disgraced cohort imagine putting a brave face and leading the people though he was scared shitless and barely knew anything about himself or the leadership position he was handed but still he managed to be a good leader even though he never desired it or needed it because he was selfless and too good at his heart that he can't let other people die so he decides to shoulder the responsibility and pressure that crushed him for years leads the disgraced cohort to it's victory (which is a big deal because not many talented people will be there) against mount othrys the home palace and territory of the titan base which had a million monsters and hundreds of scythian draceanae ( the most underrated battle which is not even discussed in detail another reason why author is biased towards jason) and personally managed to beat down krios hand to hand combat without Achilles heel ( remember the attack on mount tam is offense so the fifth cohort and some other legionnaires along with jason went there not the entire camp after successfully managing to conquer mount tam and coming back to camp he was raised on the shield to become a praetor reyna wasn't involved in this since praetors are supposed to guard the camp ) and managed to topple the black throne of Kronos which severed the power connection to kronos much like the throne of the gods on olympus which has the power connection to god's that's y Kronos was trying to destroy the throne of gods so coming back to the story after being selfless for his whole life and then finally finding a girlfriend and a best friend who he finally feels at home with and getting a break and an opportunity to find himself and forge a path for himself that made sure he was a part of both camps just like he wanted finally finding a light in his life finally feeling at home with the person he liked the most after deacades of not choosing anything he wanted he finally chose for himself he finally was selfish and chose to put himself and his needs for the first time after being selfless for nearly a decade realising that he could be his own person having his free will only months later to be revealed that the presumed love of his life feels like she doesn't really love him truly after all just imagine the pain and heartbreak swelling in your chest realising that all the free will and all the future he beleived all those moments he spent happily in his life was after all a lie putting on a brave face once again for his girlfriend telling that he understood her decision so that she should not in any way feel sorry or guilty for him because he was selfless went back to honor his promise of building shrines for minor gods for both camps and then finally he was offered a choice a free will to choose between him and piper and without any hesitation or second thoughts he chose piper to live and for him to die and all in all his last moments he was not angry or bitter for the shit he was thrown in his life he never even thought about himself all he thought was his friends safety and the promise he made to kym the daughter of poseidon that even poseidon himself neglected and made sure the future generation of demigods were safe by making apollo to promise to remember what' it is like to be human in his final moments he gave himself to save his friends honour the promise to prevent the gods From fighting amongst each others and made sure his future demigod brethren had a bright and peaceful future ahead of them he was the true prince of all the demigods now that is why he deserved better from everyone even from the own author who wrote the character that's the kind of character jason is and that's why I want to know more about him and that's why he is my favourite character
Sorry for that was really emotional while writing this so I didn't think too much about giving some changes to the comments or to properly punctuate it
I have an idea. Piper goes down to Hades Orpheus style, and asks him to please let Jason come with her. Hades accepts. Then haters can hate again, fans can be happy again, everything is perfect. Unless she looks back. Then Percy gotta fight/beat Hades.
@@Unclaimeddemigod I thought Percy cause he was already down there several times. Also he already had confrontations with Hades... But yeah, Piper going down and fighting Hades would be cool, though i doubt wether Charmspeak works on the dead...
HEY ALL THOSE WHO DONT LIKE THESE CHARACTERS!!!! SILENA DIDNT DESERVE TO DIE SHE WAS BRAVE GRAFFUL AMAZING KIND AND HONEST BIANCA DIDNT DESERVE TO DIE BECAUSE SHE WAS A BUG THREE KID AND HAD A BRO NICO!!! Sorry I’m lazy and don’t wanna do the others but yeah I love them alll
I'd read The Burning Maze when it first came out and when I came up to Jason's death I slammed the book shut and went into my room (because I was in the living room enjoying a snack and I'm not allowed to eat in my room) and started sobbing. I came out puffy and my mom looked at the shut book and she was like "who was it?" I told her Jason died (mind you my mom never read HOO) and she looked confused for a minute and then nodded. I wasn't a fan of him in HOO but I did like his relationship with Nico (god dammit TSATS hurts thinking about how Nico felt) and I wish he and Piper got a real chance But fucking gods Rick you did not have to go that hard
Ok so everybody is talking about the seven demigods' reaction to Jason's death, and I just want to know how they reacted bc I still don't have the TOA books and I really want to know what their reaction was. Could somebody just at least tell me what chapter it is, so I can find it on TH-cam? Pls
Spoiler alert I guess!
As if this video wasn’t torture enough, I’m here to make things worse
“I can see the stars my lady”
“Bob says hello”
“You stupid Aphrodite girl”
“See. Charley”
“Family Luke, you promised “
“Promise me one thing. Whatever happens, when you get back on Olympus, when you’re a god again, remember, remember what it’s like to be human”
“From now on, I’ll be more than Lester. I will be Apollo, I will remember”
Now, who wants to join me in crying in the corner.
Great video by the way, even if it was sad
@@Unclaimeddemigod you’re very welcome I guess. You kinda get influenced by Rick’s heartlessness after reading the books a million times.
Also, forgot to mention this in my original comment, but I’m really looking forward to the lightning thief musical video. Other than reviews, I haven’t found videos solely talking about the musical, so this would be very exciting
You promised you would protect her
@@suhotdog3135 Yeah and your never getting away from me
@@melamory80 😢
@@suhotdog3135 aaand you made me cry
I was spoiled for Jason's death but I still burst into tears when it actually happened
@@Unclaimeddemigod I love spoilers cause..... I can't read/watch anything without spoilers or I will have breakdowns everytime something sad happens..... 😔
Sameeee Google spoiled it for me
sameee
i look so close to jason i might get a fake scar for halloween and dress up as him
Omg my reaction was as bad as when I hear "Bob says hello."!
Wait, am I the only one hwo remembers the fact that Nico felt biancas death? Which means he had to live with that feeling til' percy came back and said to him that she really is dead and killed every peace of hope he had....
That just so sad!
The important thing to remember about Bianca is that she realized her mistake, took full responsibility, and sacrificed herself so that the others could save the world. She wanted to see Nico again, but she knew that she would either be killed by Talos with her friends or die saving them from him, and she chose to save her friends.
After endangering them
Man, Jason was one of my favorites characters, his death just broke me a lot, I almost stopped reading TOA. When Leo asked "where is jason", I just started to cry like a little kid.
Same i love jason I don't know why peopel hate him HIS a great character
I started liking him around Blood of Olympus 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I started crying the moment you said "Bob the Titan". I thought I'd survive this, but THIS one is too much.
I was spoiled about Jason's death, but I still felt... terrible after reading it. The scene HURT. I actually liked Jason in HoO too.
@@Unclaimeddemigod yeah sorry xd
@@Unclaimeddemigod bob didnt die though
“I actually liked Jason in HoO too.” Me too, nice to hear I wasn’t alone.
My opinion: Luke, Ethan, and Silena were all heroes and Bianca leaving Nico is understandable, she wanted a chance to be her own person for a change. Also, Silena's last name is Beauregard and in my experience trust me, Luke is wayyyyyyyyyy more controversial than Silena.
@@Unclaimeddemigod
Oof
I agree but I don’t think Luke was a hero
Same
@Linda Bi agreed
@@Leila-ni3xz same, i hate luke, he literally asked Annabeth if she loved him (she was *16* and he was *23* like dude, ew tf?!)
To be honest, while reading 'The Titan's curse' for the first time,I was sure Bianca didn't really die, because it was "off screen" and when it turned out she actually did, I was very surprised. And sad.
I'm sure they won't whitewash Beckendorf. I mean, why would they?
Glad someone finally remembered Esperanza and Michael. Micheal is so underrated.
Whenever I even hear of Yew I burst into tears. I miss him so much
Rick knew that nobody loves Jason when he’s alive. But killing him would rose-tint his memory, Rick is clever.
I had the same thought.
Me who loved Jason from the beginning: TmT
I legitimately didn't appreciate Jason's character AT ALL until he died. Clever indeed.
@@gc-qh7rr same :( I don't know why people didn't like him
Selena too
and Luke
My ranking
10)Lee Fetcher
9)Castor
8)Bob the titan
7)Charles Beckendorf
6)Selina beauregaurd
5) Jason Grace
4)Ethan Nakamura
3)Luke Castellain
2)Bianca Di Angelo
1)Zoë Nightshade
Happiest death - 1)Octavian
@@Unclaimeddemigod oh I forgot to mention him.......
Ethan wasn’t sad to me
Who wasn’t happy when Octavian died?
CASTORRRRR 😭
To me I thought the top two saddest deaths are Luke as saddest death then Jason as the next one each scarred me emotionally on a deeper level than any other death I’ve ever read in a book.
Spoiler Warning
..
I don't really like Jason, in HOO he wasn't all the developed, we were told he was this big hero and then he spends half the battles sitting on his bum waiting for Piper to save him, but his death was so meaningful in TOA because he taught Apollo about human life and OMG Pipers reaction broke me
Yeah I feel like pipers reaction on the bech that made it so sad for me
Ahh he was developed
Where the heck is crest?
Her reaction as in getting a new gf so soon after jasons death
WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT HE ALWAYS TRIES HIS BEST PIPER NEVER SAVED HIM MAUBE ONCE BUT ARE YOU MAD YES HE GETS KNOKED OUT ALOT BUT , HIS CHARACTER IS DEVELOPED AT LEAST AS DEVELOPED AS PIPERS ! AND HIS ACTIONS IN TRIALS OF APOLLO ARE HEROIC HE DEFINES HEROIC BECASE HE IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE A GREAT HERO WHO NEVER WANTS TO SIT DOWN AND DO NOTHING SO DONT MAKE IT SEEM LIKE HE DID NOTHING , OKAY
I always loved Percy Jackson as a kid and then never read the hero’s of Olympus or any other of the series till I was older and fell back in love with mythology and always thought I was a bit childish for it, I’m so glad I’m not the only grown person who loves Rick riordans work!!
#adultPJOfans, join the club
Technically Selena is and was a hero.....if you think about it, the only reason Selena accepted the role of saboteur from Luke, was to save Beckendorf......if Percy or annabeth or any other character was in that situation they would definitely agree, especially Percy because of his fatal flaw........and being the daughter of Aphrodite, she would do anything for love.....it’s just that the scenario or situation she was thrown into, was extremely desperate and manipulative, and emotionally straining 🙂😞............
Ya, only Jason's hit me worse than hers
Ez for u to say piper
@@BigR2D2. Ok drew.
Nope. She was initially manipulated by luke due to her crush on him ..when she wanted to back off, then luke threatened to escape her and to harm beck. We also can't forget that beck died because of her amd that's y she committed suicide
@@adarshraj2978 i think you’ll find my point in your answer. She was MANIPULATED by luke either ways, we don’t know what exactly he asked her to do at the beginning, but the fact that she tried to back out showed that she had a conscience. Then she was THREATENED by luke. Even though she willingly participated at the beginning, she eventually realised her mistake and tried to fix it. A hero isn’t someone who doesn’t make mistakes, its those who try desperately and sacrifices everything to correct them. In this case Selena payed with her life. Its a difference of opinion; you have yours i have mine, thats all.
I know this is weird but I found the Arrow of Dodona’s death to be so sad.
Yeeeees!!!😭😭
He or She or it is so funny when things get wrong and HE IS A ARROWWWW WHICH IS HILARIOUS
Omg, MY SADDEST DEATH WAS THE ARROW OF DODONA
YES, it made me tear up…
I cried a lot
yes I was really sad too. I was hoping get would go to Olympus with Apollo or return to the grave but he didn't ;-; . he is underrated (at least I think it's a he)
Spoiler Alert!!
I still bang my head on the wall and cry my heart out whenever I think of Jason's death.
@@unchi5462 I haven't read the 4th and 5th parts
Bro...
"The stars... I see the stars again, M'lady"
I ligit couldn't stop crying when Jason died 😭😭
Sad times
I'm a Jason stan he is my bby who must be protected at all costsssssss
Yessssss 😭😭😭
@@Unclaimeddemigod
All I said is that I’m a Jason Stan
@@mythicalgirl2005 yeah but have you read anything besides for heroes of Olympus
@@Manavsharma66
Yes but I don’t see how simply saying I love Jason spoils anything other than that I love Jason. That’s literally all I said.
@@mythicalgirl2005 yeah i agree with you. you didnt spoil anything
I wasn't a huge fan of Jason in HOO. But when I started to see him again in the TOA I was so happy and when he died I was so devastated. It's when something or someone dies that you understand he or it was important
Honestly for some reason some of the deaths that hit me the hardest were the side characters...like never getting to hear about Dakota drinking his Kool aid ever again made me so sad.
it is easy to feel bad about the deaths of smaller characters, bc they've only been portrayed in funny or good light, like Dakota, so there is no reason for us to dislike him which makes his death suck. It just feels so unnecessary, where as when bigger characters die, it is usually important to the plot.
Micheal Yew told Percy to cut the tether holding the bridge I was very upset that he died. I also loved his sass during the counselor meeting it was gold
SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER
As soon as I reached number 4 I shed some tears ngl :( my phone lockscreen are stars and under them is „Bob says Hello“ written. Great video idea! Very interesting and sad to watch
@@Unclaimeddemigod I warnt to think everyday about him and the stars (in special Zoë Nightshade) so I never forget them :) I just love it so much!
OMG I have the same wallpaper too....... 😭
I want to remember him and let people know I looooove PJO and besides the stars are beautiful and sad 😔
Selena was a hero point blank period. Her dear makes me cry everytime
in my opinion, Silena died a hero. It can be justified as to why she helped Kronos, since she was being manipulated, but i still think it is a little too black and white and simplistic to straight up say she was a hero the way Clarisse said it. I think Clarisses bias towards Silena because of their friendship was kind of affecting her response, because I think whether Silena was a hero is too complex to give a yes or no answer.
I hated Jason and definitely didn’t appreciate him at all when he was alive, but after his death, I began to love and respect him. So, thank you, Rick, for making me realize all of that, even if it had to be through his death.
I’m not ok. JASON DESERVED BETTER 😭😭
I think he's generally a much more interesting characters in the Trials of Apollo than in Heroes of Olympus
@@Unclaimeddemigod i agree
Just got home from school. Boom she has a new video, YES!
@@Unclaimeddemigod nope
*SPOILER WARNING*
I've cried like 5 weeks for Jason's death
Me tooooo 😥😭
Not going to lie I cried so hard at Octavians death why did he shot himself out of the cannon Percy should have summoned and a cyclone and crush him
Yeah they should kill him together
But well that is so funny and SOLANGELOOOOOOO
I agree with your statement
I don't like it when a seemingly good super-powerful hero straight up kills a much weaker crapsack no matter how much they "deserve it" That wouldn't be in Percy's character,he didn't kill Smelly Gabe,who made his life sh*t for years. Octaivain accidentally dying is ironic, Nico didn't kill him, if he didn't Gaea might have won.
SPOILER DONT READ MORE UNLESS YOU WANT TO GET SPOILED
The Prophecy said that Bianca would be lost so technically she didn't have to die but she did unfortunately
Silena's death is actually in my top 3 saddest death in the entire series. I literally stopped to book to cry my eyes out. Thinking about it now makes me want to tear up again
Hey, I loved Beckendorf as well, I was soooo sad when he died.
I kept thinking no no no no no no he can't die :(
I got spoiled for Jason's death and I'm honestly kind of glad, if I hadn't known I would've been in denial for so long, I wouldn't have thought it was real. It would've hit me like a brick (Pun intended).
I found Jason's death super sad too. He was actually the hero of heroes of olympus who i liked the least but was just sad that he died. Really, I really cried. The saddest part was when Leo turned up at the others' house and found out about the death and he couldn't even tell him how it was supposed to be. :(
I was also super sad with Leo because I loved him so much and then relieved because he would still be there.
R.I.P Jason and the others. They were all heroes.
I read it for like 5 times but I still can’t believe Jason died because he is such a good fighter
Bob says hello. Don't forget what it means to be human.
Whole "The Last Olympian" Book ripped me apart. First chapter... death... I stopped reading.... for an hour because I couldn't handle it but I at the other side couldn't stop! And then I finished it in a day and I was so done. My husband asked my many times if I want to go asleep an read the end tomorrow. "Just one chapter" it was and then there was another thing and another death and I couldn't stop and at the end I cryed for the last chapters so hard.
It’s such a good book 📚
Spoiler following
Omg I cried so hard at the point that Jason Grace dies 😭😭😭😭😭
I read it like 5 times and I still can’t believe that Jason died
What about Leo Valdez
He technically died and came back
It took my aunt a super long time to finish the book as she left it alone for 5 years after reading that he died
The moment when percy thought that his mother died literally broke my heart especially when he started crying I just want to hug him My poor baby
such a good emotional moment
here, and allow me to rip your heart out just a tiny bit more- bianca's love for nico was in some ways the cause of her death
so...
all of the deaths you mentioned that happened in the books broke me. like, i read one book, cried, thought that the next book would be happier, nope, cried some more, ext
so, there was a lot of crying...
ALSO: if they whitewash Beckendorf, they should at least make Silena black
Ok this is irrelevant but:
Why did camp half blood send Grover to get Thalia.
When Luke, Thalia and Annabeth were running around together, Grover was send to get Thalia because she was a daughter of Zeus but Grover decided to also help Luke and Annabeth.
But Grover is the same age as Percy and Annabeth, in human years Grover is much older but in satyr years he’s the same age, meaning Grover was 7 in satyr years when he was send to bring Thalia to camp half blood, why did they send a 7 year old satyr to retrieve a demigod of high importance like a child of Zeus, I just thought about this and it just doesn’t make sense, there would be many older and more experienced satyrs who could have been sent to get Thalia but they sent A 7 YEAR OLD, why did they send child.
Anyway, that’s just something I thought about.
and then they told him it was all his fault
When I read Jason’s death I was in shock. I had to re read it like two times because I was to shocked
Spoiler warning: The Burning Maze
You know what actually broke me? Nico’s reaction to Jason’s death.
Nico? I’m sure you mean Leo unless you’re talking about his reaction in Tower of Nero
Why am I the only one who liked Jason in HoO
I liked him
When I read about Jason’s death it took me a whole 4 months to get over him im serious I felt so bad that he died with good intentions. He died with the mission to create statues of all the minor gods not only to honor them so they don’t feel unimportant, but he also wanted to make the shrines so that demigods could complete quests easier without the minor gods hating on them. I have always loved him ❤
All of the deaths are sad but for me the saddest deaths are Zoë Nightshade, Luke Castellan, Silena Beauregard, and Bob. Zoë dying alongside her good friend Artemis was so sad. Even though her death was sad, it was also beautiful because she was turned into a constellation. I did see Luke as a traitor but towards the end, he saw the error of his ways and turned on Kronos and was responsible for defeating him. I think he was a hero towards the end. What Annabeth said to him, "Family, Luke. You promised," was so heartbreaking. He was good towards the end. But that's just my opinion.
Fun fact bob doesn’t die in Nico and wills book they save him I believe
I haven't engaged with the Rick Riordan fandom much but people hate Silena?? What???? Her death hit me just as hard as Beckendorf's.
Leo Valdez’s death was so saddddddd he came back to life but stilllll
9:09 I love how she isn’t acknowledging the disasters…
I know he was in one book but where is crest?!
I was going to say if you didn't say Jason's death was the saddest I would of had to fight you. I didn't know Jason was going to get killed off like that. When I reread "The Trials of Apollo The Burning Maze" I started tearing up again when he got killed. Then in the 4th one when he was delivered to Camp Jupiter and they did his funeral
The musical has so many references my personal favorite being from grover says about Percy and Annabeth "they'll kill each other or they will kiss if we're lucky they'll end up in an abyss"- in the same boat
Silena literally took the Ares cabin to war that alone is a redemption act in itself. Luke died a traitor who realized he f***ed up, so he was both since he did realize what he did wasn't right. Zoe needed more book time she was awesome and deserves the higher placing since Bianca wasn't given much of a back story, we saw Zoe's hatred for Riptide and the fact that she faced her family who exiled her was beyond heartbreaking. And Beckendorf was an amazing character and all made me cry
finally someone understanding how sad bob's death was
COOL MOM CLUB!!!
Members: Sally Jackson, Ezmerlda Valdez
Frank's mom
@@pipermclean7980 everyone forgets her :(
The saddest deaths in no order for me are: Charles Beckendorf (TLO), Randolph Chase (HOT), Zoe Nightshade (TTC), Jason Grace (TBM), Luke Castellan (TLO), Crest (TBM), Bianca di Angelo (TTC), Bob (not actually dead but yeah), Gunilla (SOS), and Ethan Nakamura (TLO)
I absolutely agree with Crest's death being very sad. I mean, since he's a technically a monster, he would end up in Tartarus despite dying a hero.
What about Leo!? I know he wasn’t actually dead but he was “dead” for a while and everyone was terribly sad and so was I first time reading it
it’d prob make it if he actually stayed dead.
I'm a little unsure about including Bob
First, he is immortal, so he can't die
Second, it was never confirmed he did
Third, it seems Nico was hearing his voice calling out for him from Tartarus in ToN
Percy: (nervous) It started out as a minor scramble with a few monsters, but next thing I know, I'm tangled with half the Titan Army.
Annabeth: (panics)
Spoiler
Selena and Luke are heros. Definitely.
About Bianca, um......I was sad when she died, and I liked her even though she left Nico alone, but when I realized that she made the childish-funny-innocent-adorable Nico disappear, I was like oh.......ur.......Bianca why !?!?😭😭😭
And Jason~~~I don't hate him, and I don't love him, but hi is really such a great character, and how he trates others is very kind, like how he wants to be friends with our favorite death boy, and he died for saving a girl that breaked up with him, a girl he had just met for maybe a week, and a week guy who was a jerk god before. I'm sorry for the Piper lovers, but she made a new girlfriend from nowhere right after Jason's death is making me angry.
When i read jasons death i was less sad then i was shocked. The griffins death was sadder to me ( i forgot the griffins name )
@@Unclaimeddemigod U spelled dam wrong lol
I haven't read any of these books for a few years and I don't remember who most of these characters are. Some of them are names I remember and a couple are ones that I remember very clearly.
It’s a good thing we’re getting a tv show to relieve all these deaths then!
seriously, I used 2 pact of tissue when watching this video
I will still never understand how rick just forgot about Percy and Zoe's story when he wrote mark of athena.
Exactly
if Disney whitewashes Beckendorf, they are asking for riots 😂
Yessss
I cried for a week when Zoe died! She is also the reason I hate the Disney Hercules movie.
If the Disney+ show didn't kill Charles Bekendorf...I mean I love the guy but......this fandom practically started a riot because Annabeth wasn't blonde....
@@Unclaimeddemigod I agree
My sad death list...
10. Micheal Yew
9. Luke (never felt too much of a connection but I put him here because he was alright in the end)
8. Pan (it was very depressing for me)
7. Charles Beckendorf
6. Silena Beaurogard
5. Bianca
4. Ethan Nakamura (he may be a bit high but I just felt really bad for the dude)
3. Jason
2. Bob
1. Zoë Nightshade (she literally knew her fate the whole journey)
there are probably a couple more deaths that I thought were sad that I can't think of at the moment :')
I spent too much time writing this 😂
But Bob never actually died, he was just left behind in Tartarus.
12:54 bob actually does not die as the new solangelo book coming in may 2023 is to rescue bob so that means bob is not dead yet
it had the same emotional impact as a death so on the list it gooooooooooooooes
hahahahaha this video made me cry so many times i eventually lost count.
thank you for that
Me who just read the chapter when jason dies in toa yesterday............and yes I was spoiled abt his death which made me rly mad but yeah his death was super sad but I feel like bob's death in my opinion was sadder
These heroes deserve more!
@@Unclaimeddemigod ikr?! it makes me so angry also cause I have anger issues lol but yeah
honourable mention: Pan
Number two after you’ve read Sun and the Stat: 😅
Oh how things change in the never ending riordanverse
I didn’t know how much I like Jason until I heard of his terrible fate
He didn’t do ONE wrong thing (Luke betrayed the gods, Silena was the spy, Bianca stole sth…) and yet he had to BREAK UP with his girlfriend, DIE and then not having all his friends at his funeral
Not mentioning being “abducted” (or given up) at 2 years old, having no mental backup (how did he even survive? No one actually cared for him except Reyna, he had to carry duties from a young age…). His whole short life was nothing but devastating, with only a few months of happiness with Piper, and then Piper got into some “identity crisis” and got herself a girlfriend
Yeah, probably a typical life of a son of Zeus (minus Perseus?)
I have a question, I read the German version of HOO and at the end Piper and Jason tell their grandchildren about the fight with the giants. Is that also the case in the original because I always thought Jason couldn't die as a result. Can someone enlighten me?
Jason does say that he imagined that as their future, but it was just him imagining, not the actual future.
I read Jason’s death scene like a long time ago, and when I read read it I completely forgot about it, then I read the part when they take his body on the plane, and I’m like, why do I remember this one scene, but not who is in, and who died?
The only death I cried while reading was Bob.
I was also spoiled for Jason's death, but it still hurt when I got around to reading it. It REALLY hurt because Jason was just nice. He's not my favorite, but I like how just nice he was. He was a really good kid and I liked that the other books didn't just gloss over his death. They made it mean something.
SPOILER:
Though Dakota's death hurt too because I wasn't expecting it and I thought he was cool.
I feel that Bianca's death was sadder than Zoe's. It's more tragic because like you said, she brought it upon herself, and DECIDED to make up for it by killing herself.
and still I cannot wait to see it on screen
I love jason(of course nico is the best) and I never understood, and i will never understand, why people hate him
Luke and Silena are the two deaths that have always had me conflicted. Silenas death hit me really hard, mostly because of Clarisses and the other campers reactions. But another part of me felt like her death was kind of necessary to the story. She was a traitor, and even if her motives can be justified by how you look at it, if she lived, the campers would forever hold a grudge against her for being partially responsible for a lot of deaths. Silena herself would also have to live with the guilt of being responsible for her boyfriends death, and I think there is something bittersweet in the idea that she is now in esylum (or whoever you spell it) with Charles. She might not have fully lived a heros life, but she 100% died a heros death, and that's what i think makes her death so tragic.
Lukes death though, I cried at, and I don't fully understand why. I never liked Luke, I have never been able to see him through the hero lens that many other people could. But knowing that a part of him felt remorse and regret for what he did has me conflicted. He chose the right thing in the end, and although I personally believe he deserves the fields of asphodel, he fulfilled the prophecy and died the way he was destined to. Lukes backstory also added a lot to what could have been a fairly basic death scene. His history with Annabeth and what happened to his mom just made it so much worse then it needed to be. Luke was still young when all of this happened, and although he wasn't a hero and he clearly was not a good person, he never wanted Kronos to take full control. He wanted revenge for his parents wrongs, but he picked the wrong outlet for that anger.
So idk, those two have always struck a cord with me.
The reason silena’s death has more controversy than Luke’s is because the prophecy specifically told us that Luke was a hero.
Jason when I was reading the lost hero
I never thought he would died but I learned he died wall I was reading house of Hades
What about Crest from TOA The Burning Maze?
It might sound dumb,but did Leo die or no.. I'm seriously confused if he is or not
Wait doesn’t Jason come back alive when Piper charm-speaks him into coming back to life?
That's in The Lost Hero, not The Burning Maze. Though there are similarities, like Piper trying charmspeak and the phrase "Fix him".
I was so shocked and sobbing so hard when Jason died.
I THOUGHT HE HAD MAIN CHARACTER RIGHTS???
imagine being jason selfless for your whole life 15yrs putting the others needs and the camps needs before himself working hard and preventing the position of leadership and power in any form due to his determination to restore honour back to a disgraced cohort imagine putting a brave face and leading the people though he was scared shitless and barely knew anything about himself or the leadership position he was handed but still he managed to be a good leader even though he never desired it or needed it because he was selfless and too good at his heart that he can't let other people die so he decides to shoulder the responsibility and pressure that crushed him for years leads the disgraced cohort to it's victory (which is a big deal because not many talented people will be there) against mount othrys the home palace and territory of the titan base which had a million monsters and hundreds of scythian draceanae ( the most underrated battle which is not even discussed in detail another reason why author is biased towards jason) and personally managed to beat down krios hand to hand combat without Achilles heel ( remember the attack on mount tam is offense so the fifth cohort and some other legionnaires along with jason went there not the entire camp after successfully managing to conquer mount tam and coming back to camp he was raised on the shield to become a praetor reyna wasn't involved in this since praetors are supposed to guard the camp ) and managed to topple the black throne of Kronos which severed the power connection to kronos much like the throne of the gods on olympus which has the power connection to god's that's y Kronos was trying to destroy the throne of gods so coming back to the story after being selfless for his whole life and then finally finding a girlfriend and a best friend who he finally feels at home with and getting a break and an opportunity to find himself and forge a path for himself that made sure he was a part of both camps just like he wanted finally finding a light in his life finally feeling at home with the person he liked the most after deacades of not choosing anything he wanted he finally chose for himself he finally was selfish and chose to put himself and his needs for the first time after being selfless for nearly a decade realising that he could be his own person having his free will only months later to be revealed that the presumed love of his life feels like she doesn't really love him truly after all just imagine the pain and heartbreak swelling in your chest realising that all the free will and all the future he beleived all those moments he spent happily in his life was after all a lie putting on a brave face once again for his girlfriend telling that he understood her decision so that she should not in any way feel sorry or guilty for him because he was selfless went back to honor his promise of building shrines for minor gods for both camps and then finally he was offered a choice a free will to choose between him and piper and without any hesitation or second thoughts he chose piper to live and for him to die and all in all his last moments he was not angry or bitter for the shit he was thrown in his life he never even thought about himself all he thought was his friends safety and the promise he made to kym the daughter of poseidon that even poseidon himself neglected and made sure the future generation of demigods were safe by making apollo to promise to remember what' it is like to be human in his final moments he gave himself to save his friends honour the promise to prevent the gods From fighting amongst each others and made sure his future demigod brethren had a bright and peaceful future ahead of them he was the true prince of all the demigods now that is why he deserved better from everyone even from the own author who wrote the character that's the kind of character jason is and that's why I want to know more about him and that's why he is my favourite character
Sorry for that was really emotional while writing this so I didn't think too much about giving some changes to the comments or to properly punctuate it
Bob lives
TSATS
can we get a moment of silence for dacota
RIP
Jason’s really wasn’t sad it was just the character’s reactions to it
8 months late still going to say something. Jason reacted by being sad. The situation caused him to REACT SAD
I have an idea. Piper goes down to Hades Orpheus style, and asks him to please let Jason come with her. Hades accepts. Then haters can hate again, fans can be happy again, everything is perfect. Unless she looks back. Then Percy gotta fight/beat Hades.
@@Unclaimeddemigod I thought Percy cause he was already down there several times. Also he already had confrontations with Hades... But yeah, Piper going down and fighting Hades would be cool, though i doubt wether Charmspeak works on the dead...
HEY ALL THOSE WHO DONT LIKE THESE CHARACTERS!!!!
SILENA DIDNT DESERVE TO DIE SHE WAS BRAVE GRAFFUL AMAZING KIND AND HONEST
BIANCA DIDNT DESERVE TO DIE BECAUSE SHE WAS A BUG THREE KID AND HAD A BRO NICO!!!
Sorry I’m lazy and don’t wanna do the others but yeah I love them alll
I was told that Jason dies, but i was at school when i read his death. It was hard not to cry. 😢😢
Jason was my favorite since the very beginning XD Jason stans are few, but we are strong.
SILENA HERO AND QUEEN
Jason’s my favorite character now, (tied with Hazel) but it took three months to get there.
I'd read The Burning Maze when it first came out and when I came up to Jason's death I slammed the book shut and went into my room (because I was in the living room enjoying a snack and I'm not allowed to eat in my room) and started sobbing. I came out puffy and my mom looked at the shut book and she was like "who was it?" I told her Jason died (mind you my mom never read HOO) and she looked confused for a minute and then nodded.
I wasn't a fan of him in HOO but I did like his relationship with Nico (god dammit TSATS hurts thinking about how Nico felt) and I wish he and Piper got a real chance
But fucking gods Rick you did not have to go that hard
I'm sorry you couldn't enjoy that snack after all
Ok so everybody is talking about the seven demigods' reaction to Jason's death, and I just want to know how they reacted bc I still don't have the TOA books and I really want to know what their reaction was. Could somebody just at least tell me what chapter it is, so I can find it on TH-cam? Pls