In my opinion 5 min videos work better as I can't spot the AI bugs, while on longers ones they are more noticeable. That being said, I'm impressed with the work you do. Great stuff! Way better than what Rings of Power's 1 billion budget could produce.
We are wanderers but not lost, in Middle-earth world. And we salute you as you become a great storyteller. A bard of a really-really great big company.
A 5 part Children of Hurin, each part being as long as this video would be awesome! You deserve billions of views! This is truly amazing! Tolkien himself would be proud!
thanks so much! I was starting with the first video of The Children of Húrin, but it was necessary to tell the Nirnaeth first to place Húrin where he belongs.
@@TheCottageofLostPlaytotally disagree! The rings of power is a masterpiece for a different reason - its storyline. It doesn't use fancy AI. In fact, some Tolkien purists seem to hate AI. Personally, I don't mind it. And if you disliked rings of power so much, why bother wasting time even mentioning it? Are you deliberating trying to upset rop fans who you know will watch this? Rings of P both compliments and enhances Tolkien. And both series are a million times better than anything peter Jackson produced.
@bottlethrower1544 I've read both hobbit and the Lotrs novels many many times. I think you mean Peter Jackson's movies? The hobbit trilogy bore little relation to the novel and Legolas skateboarding down some steps during the battle of helms deep like friggin Bart Simpson? Or then there's what pj did to Aragorn. Yeah, very Tolkien... Rings of p has never done anything so bad. Like I already said, the TV series both compliments and enhances the novels. All I care about when it comes to anything is whether or not it has a good plot, and rings of p does, otherwise you wouldn't have watched it yourself. Why didn't you like it?
This is beautiful and epic beyond words! As I listen I can't help but imagine a great victory is near! I can feel it alongside the brave heroes who fought and died in that battle! Alas, I read this story. I know the sad tragic end to this heroic tale.
Oh my god! I have no words... This is so great, brilliant, emotional, fantastic. Gwindor's dead... I'm crying. You really did a great job here again! Wow, just wow! Thank you very much!
Really Tolkien's stories are fascinating!! Incredible characters, extraordinary, which makes us fall in love with them. Maedhros and Fingon. The brothers Fëanor and Fingolfin did not fear their enemies, just as Finrod Felagund, the King of Nargothrond, was crucial to the story of Beren and Lúthien Glorofindel and Ecthelion. so many others!!Indeed, the First Age is the most epic age.
One of my favourite parts of the whole Tolkein world One of the many impressive gory Battles for sure In the Silmariillion Book, but awesome and epic in every way its the most memorable i believe. So , Well Done For this portrayal on screen at last The Elves look as formidable as they should finally ! Keep it up,its nicely done.
Try watching the rings of power. It doesn't follow the novel accurately, but it's a highly enjoyable series - and anyone who says it's not Tolkien don't know what they're talking about.
Peter Jackson basically s**t all over Tolkien. Have you read the books? From the bad acting to the long boring stretches in the 2 towers to a character loosely based on Aragorn who kills a negotiator during a ceasefire to chubby hobbits in Mordor, didn't know there was kfc on the plane of Gorgoroth to the borefest which was the hobbit triology. The rings of p is infinitely better than anything PJ produced, from the dwarves singing to mountains to the dagger that called up a volcano to seeing what life is like as a slave in an orc pit to a Galadriel with backbone - she'll always be Galadriel to me and a Sauron who runs rings round everyone, including peter Jackson employees who troll here - my conspiracy theory anyway 😂
@@TheCottageofLostPlaypeter jackson's movies were average - LOTRs to utter rubbish - the borefest moneyspinner hobbit movies. Rings of power is infinitely better than anything PJ produced - lol meant for Kilroy 😂
@@Interessâncio rude. So you think Legolas skateboarding down some steps like Bart Simpson in the 2 Towers movie, during the battle of helms deep is according to Tolkien lore? Rings of p has never done anything so tacky, and anyway, it's plain a good story in its own right. Mate, if you think Aragorn killing the mouth of Sauron is according to Tolkien, you're the one who's delusional. Or that there were 3 novels of the hobbit? Lol, keep taking your meds 😂
Amazing AI videos. These might be the closest fans will ever get to seeing The Silmarillion on screen. Rights issues aside, such a live action project would be cost prohibitive.
@ the silmarillion was always my partner when I lived through bad times. Hurin is my favorite character and he gave me some of his strength to always keep going and endure what the future brings. Now I am sitting in front of my laptop typing my own saga. Half way through the first of three planned books 💪
Bravo! En pocos años veremos obras de arte en películas y series hechos por verdaderos amantes de la obra de Tolkien como tú, haciendonos olvidar el insulto y el maltrato a Tollkien de la serie Los Anillos de Poder de Amazon.
Hello! Great work again ❤️ The last part with Morgoth unleashing his beasts sent shivers down my spine. I love 10 min videos, it makes for better immersion in my opinion! Love from Switzerland 🇨🇭
I'm a big fan of Tolkien's world, and I'm dreaming of a film which can convey how I imagine this world. Only some fan videos are close to my vision, yours is among them :) thank you! Waiting for the second chapter
This is amazing please please never stop making these!! I know these can’t be easy to make but Im sure i speak for everyone when I say your work is appreciated and loved!
Wow…you were right, this was an amazing video. The visuals are so awe inspiring, it is hard to believe it was AI. You did a great job with the quick recap of what had happened before. The “host” of names is hard…but that is pure Tolkien. You did a fantastic job bringing to life the difficult battle and scene(s) from the book. The ending was perfect and will keep me on edge waiting for Part 2. Thank you for this, beyond words, great video.
Excellent in all regards! True to the book and clearly crafted by someone who understands the story and stays true to its narrative. Only one very very minor point to pick up, at 9:10, after his torment on Thangarodrim Maedhros is left-handed not right-handed. Compelling, epic and beautifully crafted. Thank you so much for posting and looking forward to further installments.
Mellon, what an excellent video! Absolutely stunning. Keep up your fantastic work, I wish you all the best for the development of your channel. And thank you so much for bringing life to the wonderful stories of the Silmarillion 😃👍
I know much work still goes into these videos, but I am amazed at how AI continues to advance. A year and a half ago there was no AI video, and I had no way to use the same character in different image generations. Thanks for making a MUCH better and more faithful Silmarillion adaptation than the billion dollar ROP travesty.
Despite all the bile out there regarding AI, i love this video. Ty for all the hard work. Some of the elves sound like they've been taking helium 😂. But only a small thing. Overall, i love it!
This was beautiful. As you probably know my user, I follow you from the beginning and I can only say thank you for bringing to life what we all could have only imagined in our dreams and imaginations of this beautiful world and it's epic battles. And I see that you followed the lore to the detail and I thank you for it. But I have to ask one question, because for me the moment when Fingon sees Turgon and says "Utúlie'n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatarni, utúlie'n aurë!" is the most powerful moment in all Tolkien works and I can see you left it out, is it because AI can't pronaunce Eldari? Please don't understand me wrongly, I love this but I just have to know ❤Thank you ❤️
What did you think of this first chapter of the Nirnaeth? Do you prefer long videos or short ones? Let me know in the comments-I’m reading them all!
In my opinion 5 min videos work better as I can't spot the AI bugs, while on longers ones they are more noticeable. That being said, I'm impressed with the work you do. Great stuff! Way better than what Rings of Power's 1 billion budget could produce.
Both are good.
I'm okay with both. Anyway, I watch your videos again and again. They are awesome!
Long videos
Both are good, this is AMAZING!!!!
We are wanderers but not lost, in Middle-earth world. And we salute you as you become a great storyteller. A bard of a really-really great big company.
thanks a lot for your words!
What makes this channel have an edge over others is his narration skill.
These videos are way better than Rings of Turds!!
Maedhros is the goat!
thanks so much! make a longer video with all these images was a challenge XD
@TheCottageofLostPlay wonderful work indeed! I got goosebumps at the end!
You're just repeating what the others are saying, and you're wrong. What's working for Peter Jackson like lol
A 5 part Children of Hurin, each part being as long as this video would be awesome! You deserve billions of views! This is truly amazing! Tolkien himself would be proud!
thanks so much! I was starting with the first video of The Children of Húrin, but it was necessary to tell the Nirnaeth first to place Húrin where he belongs.
@@TheCottageofLostPlay ah, yes
agree, great job
Tolkien would despise this and any use of AI
@ He might despise the use of ai, but I think he would like how the story is told, it’s accurate, and true to the lore
I have no words to thank you! Never thought I’d see this.
thanks to you for your support!
Same here. I've wanted this to come to life off the pages of the Silmarillion for so long.
This is already better than the Rings of Power
Infinitely better than the horrendous and abominable Rings of Power series.
XD thanks a lot!
@@TheCottageofLostPlaytotally disagree! The rings of power is a masterpiece for a different reason - its storyline. It doesn't use fancy AI. In fact, some Tolkien purists seem to hate AI. Personally, I don't mind it. And if you disliked rings of power so much, why bother wasting time even mentioning it? Are you deliberating trying to upset rop fans who you know will watch this? Rings of P both compliments and enhances Tolkien. And both series are a million times better than anything peter Jackson produced.
Indeed, this cleans the palate
@@fred20097You really liked RoP? Im guessing you never read any Tolkien writings
@bottlethrower1544 I've read both hobbit and the Lotrs novels many many times. I think you mean Peter Jackson's movies? The hobbit trilogy bore little relation to the novel and Legolas skateboarding down some steps during the battle of helms deep like friggin Bart Simpson? Or then there's what pj did to Aragorn. Yeah, very Tolkien... Rings of p has never done anything so bad. Like I already said, the TV series both compliments and enhances the novels. All I care about when it comes to anything is whether or not it has a good plot, and rings of p does, otherwise you wouldn't have watched it yourself.
Why didn't you like it?
This is beautiful and epic beyond words! As I listen I can't help but imagine a great victory is near! I can feel it alongside the brave heroes who fought and died in that battle!
Alas, I read this story. I know the sad tragic end to this heroic tale.
thanks so much for your words an support!
@@TheCottageofLostPlay You are so welcome!
Oh my god! I have no words... This is so great, brilliant, emotional, fantastic. Gwindor's dead... I'm crying. You really did a great job here again! Wow, just wow! Thank you very much!
thanks to you for your support! I'm glad it excited you; I felt the same while making it :(
Amazing, one just has to bring Tolkiens work to life, not rewrite it
Really Tolkien's stories are fascinating!! Incredible characters, extraordinary, which makes us fall in love with them. Maedhros and Fingon. The brothers Fëanor and Fingolfin did not fear their enemies, just as Finrod Felagund, the King of Nargothrond, was crucial to the story of Beren and Lúthien Glorofindel and Ecthelion. so many others!!Indeed, the First Age is the most epic age.
Amazon, take a look and learn something. 10 minutes of something epic.
One of my favourite parts of the whole Tolkein world
One of the many impressive gory Battles for sure
In the Silmariillion Book, but awesome and epic in every way
its the most memorable i believe.
So , Well Done For this portrayal on screen at last
The Elves look as formidable as they should finally !
Keep it up,its nicely done.
thanks a lot for your words!
Great work! 10 minutes of epicness! Need more of this❤
thanks so much!
I've been waiting my whole life to see the Silmarillion brought to life. This brought a tear to my eye, thank you so much for posting!
thanks so much! working on chapter 2!
XDXDXD yes for sure, try it
Then don't waste your valuable time giving an opinion on something like this, especially if you have no idea how it's done.
Try watching the rings of power. It doesn't follow the novel accurately, but it's a highly enjoyable series - and anyone who says it's not Tolkien don't know what they're talking about.
long or short...just keep them coming. This is the best stuff since Jackson's original movies came out.
thanks so much for your words and support!
Peter Jackson basically s**t all over Tolkien. Have you read the books? From the bad acting to the long boring stretches in the 2 towers to a character loosely based on Aragorn who kills a negotiator during a ceasefire to chubby hobbits in Mordor, didn't know there was kfc on the plane of Gorgoroth to the borefest which was the hobbit triology. The rings of p is infinitely better than anything PJ produced, from the dwarves singing to mountains to the dagger that called up a volcano to seeing what life is like as a slave in an orc pit to a Galadriel with backbone - she'll always be Galadriel to me and a Sauron who runs rings round everyone, including peter Jackson employees who troll here - my conspiracy theory anyway 😂
@@TheCottageofLostPlaypeter jackson's movies were average - LOTRs to utter rubbish - the borefest moneyspinner hobbit movies. Rings of power is infinitely better than anything PJ produced - lol meant for Kilroy 😂
Fred youre só delusional ...
@@Interessâncio rude. So you think Legolas skateboarding down some steps like Bart Simpson in the 2 Towers movie, during the battle of helms deep is according to Tolkien lore? Rings of p has never done anything so tacky, and anyway, it's plain a good story in its own right. Mate, if you think Aragorn killing the mouth of Sauron is according to Tolkien, you're the one who's delusional. Or that there were 3 novels of the hobbit? Lol, keep taking your meds 😂
This is so full of scope and imagination. Your vids are literal Hollywood pitches. Maybe one day we will see one of your epics on the Big Screen.
You’re improving with every upload. All of your work is great. I don’t get tired of watching
thanks so much!
Oh my gosh! This is unbelievably amazing!!! Well done! I have chills. Can’t wait for chapter 2!! ❤ 👏
thanks so much! ready on the channel! did you saw it yet?
Wonderful! Can't wait for Chapter 2! Maedhros 😍😍😍
thanks a lot for your support!
Amazing AI videos. These might be the closest fans will ever get to seeing The Silmarillion on screen. Rights issues aside, such a live action project would be cost prohibitive.
Its unbelievable, to think that before you would need CGI to make this scenes and yet all you need are prompts
PERFECT!! Absolutely PERFECT!!
thanks so much!
Wow!!!!!! What an amazing work! I couldn't believe that the video finished! I'm patiently waiting for the next part! Thank you so much!!!
thanks so much! working on chapter 2!
As a 30 year ole male this brought me to tears
Friend, I'm 60 and the same happened to me. Good to hear that I'm not the only one😊
@ the silmarillion was always my partner when I lived through bad times. Hurin is my favorite character and he gave me some of his strength to always keep going and endure what the future brings. Now I am sitting in front of my laptop typing my own saga. Half way through the first of three planned books 💪
@@brln.lichtenberg.4693 Hurin and Turin were also my favorite characters. Wish you every success for your project 👍
Epic is little to describe this video! Excellent work my friend! Aure Entuluva!!
What an epic video you made! I have no words to thank you for the unique stories of Middle Earth you offer to youtube community! Well done!
thanks a lot for your support!
Bravo! En pocos años veremos obras de arte en películas y series hechos por verdaderos amantes de la obra de Tolkien como tú, haciendonos olvidar el insulto y el maltrato a Tollkien de la serie Los Anillos de Poder de Amazon.
Hello! Great work again ❤️
The last part with Morgoth unleashing his beasts sent shivers down my spine. I love 10 min videos, it makes for better immersion in my opinion! Love from Switzerland 🇨🇭
thanks a lot!!
I'm a big fan of Tolkien's world, and I'm dreaming of a film which can convey how I imagine this world. Only some fan videos are close to my vision, yours is among them :) thank you! Waiting for the second chapter
Wow….Im hooked…Congratulations, your presentations are absolutely superb. Short or long chapters doesn’t matter the quality speaks for itself.
thanks so much!
@TheCottageofLostPlay Great job!!! The more minutes the videos are the merrier. I've always wanted to watch the Nirnaeth. Thanks a lot!!
thanks to you as always!
This is amazing please please never stop making these!! I know these can’t be easy to make but Im sure i speak for everyone when I say your work is appreciated and loved!
Very well done! The longer videos are outstanding! Keep doing this, I have always wanted to see this stories brought to life!
thanks so much for your support and your words!
Danke!
thanks so much for your support! I really value your gesture!
Excellent! Never been excited for the videos of any channel until now. Keep it up! 👍👍
This is so great, wonderful and epic! Thank you so much.
Kindly regards from Germany.
thanks so much! regards!
I loved this would love for you to do more of this length brining the Simarillion to life! So cool !
thanks a lot!
The long videos for sure, the experience is much more of a journey. Can't wait for the next one!!
thanks so much! working on second chapter!
My friend, you are the one who makes dreams come true, keep going.
thanks so much!
What’s the music at 5:30 or is that AI
Wow…you were right, this was an amazing video. The visuals are so awe inspiring, it is hard to believe it was AI. You did a great job with the quick recap of what had happened before. The “host” of names is hard…but that is pure Tolkien. You did a fantastic job bringing to life the difficult battle and scene(s) from the book. The ending was perfect and will keep me on edge waiting for Part 2. Thank you for this, beyond words, great video.
I remember reading the Silmarillion long years ago. Thanks for bringing my imagination to life!
Excellent in all regards! True to the book and clearly crafted by someone who understands the story and stays true to its narrative.
Only one very very minor point to pick up, at 9:10, after his torment on Thangarodrim Maedhros is left-handed not right-handed.
Compelling, epic and beautifully crafted. Thank you so much for posting and looking forward to further installments.
Thanks so much for your words! Im working on second chapter!
You deserve more attention to your amazing work .. keep going ❤
thanks so much!
Mellon, what an excellent video! Absolutely stunning. Keep up your fantastic work, I wish you all the best for the development of your channel. And thank you so much for bringing life to the wonderful stories of the Silmarillion 😃👍
thanks to you for your words!
Just about pooped myself with the arrival of Turgon to the field of battle. Love the long format!
thanks a lot!
Utúlie'n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatarni, utúlie'n aurë!
The english translation is … strangely unfamiliar…
Amazing work! Long or short these are fantastic
thanks so much!
Aure entuluva!!!! finally! A dream come true, after the horror I had to endure for two seasons on Amazon !
That was excellent, I enjoyed it a lot. You made great progress 🎉🎉🎉🎉
thanks to you and your support always!
Absolutely stunning bro. Good work
This was excellent! I'm looking forward to seeing more.
Quiero más !!! Brutal. Gracias !!!
Muchas gracias a ti!
Best thing i've watched in YT for quite some time. Keep up the good work
thanks so much for your words!
voices need some help but other than that better than any Amazon production so far
Aurë entuluva!
Truly epic!
This is most excellent! Can't wait for Chapter 2!
Exceptional !! Fantastic ! What an incredible job 👍
thanks so much!
Everything you do is perfect! Long videos pliiiiiz! I get euphoria whenever I watch your Silmarillion videos!✨✨✨
thanks a lot for your words!
Thanks for putting together all the effort to create this! Great part 1
Glad you enjoyed it!
Fantastic!! Really well done, thanks!
thank to you for your visit!
On se met a rêvé, superbe reconstitution, bravo, vivement la suite 👍👍
I know much work still goes into these videos, but I am amazed at how AI continues to advance. A year and a half ago there was no AI video, and I had no way to use the same character in different image generations. Thanks for making a MUCH better and more faithful Silmarillion adaptation than the billion dollar ROP travesty.
This is effing AWESOME! ❤❤
thanks so much!
Pure and beautiful! KEEP IT COMING
Wow this is starting to get serious, well done!
thanks a lot!
Absolutely amazing. Great work. 🔥🔥🔥
thanks so much!
These are excellent! Well done!
thanks so much!
Incredible...truly beautiful Ai Cinematography!♥♥♥ Long videos Please!
thanks so much!
Seems to be getting better and better!
thanks so much!
Это невероятно красиво, спасибо за твою работу
thanks so much!!
1:33 AI is so funny sometimes lol (great video btw)
Awesome 👏 best of the best movie keeping going
Tks 🎉❤🎉❤
thanks to you for your support!
Despite all the bile out there regarding AI, i love this video. Ty for all the hard work. Some of the elves sound like they've been taking helium 😂. But only a small thing. Overall, i love it!
This was beautiful. As you probably know my user, I follow you from the beginning and I can only say thank you for bringing to life what we all could have only imagined in our dreams and imaginations of this beautiful world and it's epic battles. And I see that you followed the lore to the detail and I thank you for it. But I have to ask one question, because for me the moment when Fingon sees Turgon and says "Utúlie'n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatarni, utúlie'n aurë!" is the most powerful moment in all Tolkien works and I can see you left it out, is it because AI can't pronaunce Eldari?
Please don't understand me wrongly, I love this but I just have to know ❤Thank you ❤️
thanks so much for your support! yes,I tried, but it didn’t turn out well, and I didn’t feel like getting roasted by people. XDXD
Finally, a good use for AI!
thank you a lot!
Tô arrepiado meu brother ❤
thanks a lot for your support!
Exceptional work💯☝️🫵
thanks a lot!
Better than rings of power
Отличная работа, эфектно, эпично, красиво.😊❤👍
Thanks so much! Im working on second chapter!
Remake of The Challenge of Fingolfin video with the quality of this vid please🙋♂️🙋♂️
Another great channel is the Numenorean, especially The Making of the Witch King. Not trying to lose viewers here, just another one people may like.
Much Better than the Rings of Power ! hahaha
thanks a lot!
and now even this ten minute sequence is better than the whole amazon series (rop)
"Utúlie'n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatári, utúlie'n aurë!"
This is far better than what amazon did with billions
thanks so much!
great potential here! keep working on your audio and you will go far
thanks so much!
Much better than "Rings of Power"
Trust an old Man
“This is the best AI video I’ve seen so far. Great job!”
Glad you liked it!
Really well done! So Silmarillion movies fanmade now are possible!
Subbed! One of the few times I´ve liked Ai generated stuff. It was awesome.☺
thanks so much!!more on my channel!
more realistic than Rings of Power
Wow super cool Man, 30 Minute Videos is Best NOT too, long Not to shot
Much better than ROP
thanks so much!
Have been waiting for you. Is there any upcoming video?
thanks! yes, working on chapter 2 and other´s tolkien projects i want to show soon!
In the thumbnail. Maedhros should not have a right hand at this point?
Yes, he didn't have the right palm, so he should wield sword in in left hand.
파워풀한 목소리 영상 음악 정말 멋 집니다.
thanks so much!
Epic sir
thanks a lot!
Whole book ai movie when? It looks just MARVELOUS head ahead of rInGs oF pOwEr, keep it up brother 💪
thanks a lot for your support!
Give us a longer one please
Epic 🔥
The longer, the better !
(Balrogs have no wings, by the way).
Amazing job ! Can't wait for the next videos.
thanks a lot!