I read all your comments about L, yes, he definitely should have been at the top tier, but trust me I did not underestimate him. The second highest tier is basically winning against Dexter too
lol.. being on the 2nd highest tier is kinda like losing.. you not putting him behind bars due to lack of evidence is a win for dexter.. Light had super natural powers on his side and L pin pointed him.. bad take if i may say so..
You should do a tier list on characters who could actually do dexters job. E.g. S Tier = better butcher than dexter, A Tier = Could do dexters job well, B Tier = could do it to the minimum, C Tier = might get caught, D Tier = cant do it and would get could. Idk just an idea
Next do Jack Reacher (although Reacher will just put a bullet in Dexter) Jessica Jones Max Payne (again will just shoot him) The Question Robin (Tim and Grayson) Red Hood Rorschach
I agree. Batman operates during the night, Dexter does most of his kills at night so he will eventually gain Batman attention and when that happens, it would be done for him.
Dexter would be aware of Batman and aware of the fact that he doesn't stand a chance against Batman if they shared a universe. He would keep states between them
The only reason L even remotely had trouble proving Light to be the murderer is because Light had a supernatural weapon on him, one that has never been known to the world before. With normal crimes like those committed by Dexter, L will be on to him in like a day
Was thinking the same. Before Light lost his memories, L had him at every turn despite him using a supernatural weapon. And as smart as Dex is, he's nowhere close to Light. I feel if we wanna include anime characters, Heinrich Runge from Monster vs Dexter makes for a much more interesting scenario as that show is actually grounded in reality. Plus Runge is an interesting character, very intelligent yet incredibly stubborn.
@@Areichi yes because Light literally had a weapon beyond human understand that can kill without leaving any trace of evidence. EVEN THEN L was almost able to catch him, and Light only got away because the Deathnote also had the ability to literally wipe his memory of its existence. Dexter was not offered such luxury
It’s crazy to think about how the show could play out if L didn’t have the same moral code he does. Like he just kills L once he personally knows. Like he becomes the hero, but is also the villain to society but not the viewer, until he fucks up somehow and then the audience AND the show hates him, but he’s actively smarter than both. Could be very complex
The Scooby Doo gang has a 100% success rate when it comes to solving crimes. If there was anyone in the universe I would trust to solve a murder it's Scooby and the gang!
Multiple episodes they have been given a closet in a hotel and Daphne said "it needs a woman's touch" walked in random sounds of tools walked out and the room is now a 5 bedroom apartment
Light had a lower IQ compared to L, but you're overlooking something crucial: he had the Death Note. L, on the other hand, had no idea the concept of the Death Note even existed. Despite this, L was still able to deduce that Light was Kira, even without knowing how Light was killing his victims. In contrast, Dexter physically kills his victims, which leaves behind tangible evidence that L could trace. This makes Dexter's actions far easier to investigate and connect compared to Light's supernatural methods.
Dexter also has a whole collection of evidence in his literal house. L would find that pretty quickly with a warrant and have all the evidence he needs to convict.
@@BoKinetz Bro he is L, no.1, 2 and 3 best detective. I don't think warrant will be a issue as he will put cameras where he want like originally in anime. Also L would only do the mission if he got access of the main country police like in anime
@@BoKinetz you think you need evidence for warrant? The no 1 detective of any state can have easy pass from any judge for probable cause against a serial killer
wasn't part of Light's early killings sloppy because he killed outside of school hours which narrowed the list of potential suspects? or did I dream that in a fever haze?
100%. My big problem with most Detectives trying to track Dexter down is how insanely thorough Dexter is when it comes to cleaning up after himself, But, Columbo relies on Social pressure to crack open criminals. Dexters fate would be sealed the moment Columbo decided to question him.
My personal dislike of Sherlock is that in his show it would just write him to be right no matter how weak his conclusions but in Dexter's show he would be hopeless. So personally I would put as "couldn't prove anything"
@@cipher3966 Yeah I agree. He would look at a hair and tell the life story of some characters. I mean bruh. But in the world of Sherlock, he would defeat Dexter without lifting a single finger, but as you said in Dexter's world, he would certainly face some difficulty if you understand what I mean. It's just a matter of who are we picking and putting in the other's world.
@@YuhabahaMajesty to be fair, Sherlock from the books is not as superhuman as the show. His and Dexter's world are just the same. All his reasoning came from his photographic memories and he never made assumptions, unlike the show.
"And if we remove this mask you'll find its the... Local creepy blood spatter analyst" "ah, me and my dark harbinger would have gotten away with it too, if it wasn't for you damn kids and your meddling dog"
I dunno, he kills serial killers. Is that really so different from hunting monsters? I feel like they'd still take him out in the end, but it would make an excellent crossover if written well
I'm not convinced they would Sam and Dean have proven themselves less effective against humans on sooooo many occasions. Meanwhile Dexter took out Doakes in hand to hand - Doakes is special forces and he KNEW who Dexter was and books and movies he still couldn't take Dexter down. Could they call Castiel for help sure but then it's not really Sam and Dean...it's Castiel and that's a copout.
They wouldnt. There are multiple instances in the show where sam n dean almost give up an investigation because the supernatural element's dont appear to be present, and they leave it to the normal authorities. Im also thinking dean would side with the mission of dexter, maybe not the whole method, but killing killers and bad people who fall through the cracks of justice sounds very dean
@mihailshevchenko2368 but all of those have convenient (albeit difficult) magical solutions. In actual hand to hand without one shot kill magic daggers and guns they get bodied constantly.
Thing is, Sam and Dean wouldn't look for evidence. If they found out any proof that he's the bay harbor butcher, they'd go after him themselves, and take him out if they thought he was a threat to innocent people. At most if they felt he wasn't their business, they'd just give their suspicions to a cop they'd trust, and leave them to it.
6:15 light had a magic book that would magically kill ppl n L still pinpointed down to the house Light was in…L catches Dexter without leaving him chair lol
You're glossing over why he was caught so easily. If Light never had the ego to kill the fake L or do something as bone headed as react to info only known to police, he wouldn't have been caught. Light was stupid. His ego played him. Dexter wouldn't have that flaw.
I feel like Columbo operates mostly on vibes at first to get a really good guess at who the killer is, and the episodes are just him trying to prove it. He's just way better at the cat and mouse game than L is. But yeah he could definitely catch Dexter
@@galateangemmate804I mean the only reason Dex wasn’t ever caught was because of literal bs and the fact Miami metro was run by literal morons except Doaks who was a different type of psychotic
There’s an episode in Brooklyn nine-nine called “unsolvable” where Jake and Terry (95% Jake 5% Terry) solve a case where a guy named Nate Dexter is the killer It’s a reference to Dexter so I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say he could catch him just cause of that
L would definitely catch Dexter, giving the fact that he's the best Detective in Death Note. The whole idea about his character is that if it's possible, he will discover it. If there's a possibility of putting Dexter behind bars, he would
L is broken. His intuition is literally on impossible levels. He makes connections and accurate assumptions out of nowhere, or when something happens he's like "i knew this would happen exactly this way because ..."
They would, The premise of analyzing these fictional characters is based upon using their abilities in their own show as a benchmark. The Scooby gang posses powers that would trivialize Dexter's mind and skills as a murderer.
L clears. While Dexter is better than Light in terms of maturity and ego, Light had the upper hand due to the supernatural powers he used to kill people remotely, while Dexter used traditional means for his killings. Light's methods were also unheard of at the time, but L still managed to suspect him.
@@Sinislovesbillcypher.If light wasnt so caught up in his ego unlike Dexter the entire manga ends when L offers up a sacrifice on the news. Light gets manipulated several times like that
True, imagine going against a murderer that doesn't leave any traces, and can seemingly kill anyone he wants like it was magic. And L still found out Light was Kira, and deciphered how the death note worked, he just couldn't find concrete evidence.
*meanwhile in another universe* Dexter*walks up and shakes hand* hi i am Dexter pleasure to meet you sherlock Holmes*shakes his hand and then handcuffs him* and you are under Arrest
@@aestheticmirror9257I mean, some of his victims had missing persons reports. We see during the bay harbour butcher investigation while they’re looking for the identity of Dexters victims that there’s like 3 or so family members who reported some of the missing persons the cops found. Granted, at least one of them doesn’t exactly seem too… distraught about the fact that his father (iirc) is potentially dead, and more or less wanted a confirmation so his mom could stop living in fear.
Velma literally folds like soggy bread if her glasses get knocked off. She ain't doing anything. She definitely hard carries the gang, but she soft af. She ain't cut out anything actually dangerous. Now if she just teamed with batman, that'd be sound, but on her own, she'd get scooped up faster than rocky road ice cream at a summer base ball game
Scooby-doo gang would have caught Dexter. Batman has said Velma is the best detective out there and that they are teenagers. Dexter would never suspect them.
Oh yeah Arkham Batman is OP in the investigation department considering he can literally provide a visual timeline of the crime scene from just a few small clues.
It'll be like season 2 except Doaks wasn't there, He studies his old case and his old history (cause he has access to everything) then either sets a trap or confront while Dexter has no idea about it.
first they have to find dexter tho, just based on the fact that dexter kills irregularly, with decent time between each m**der and because the victims are always really bad guys, they’ll probably just move on to better targets sam and dean don’t have a lot of experience hunting humans and they don’t have the time to do it either + dexter has a lot of experience evading cops so my moneys on dexter but yeah if they catch him , he is done, no escape from the winchester boys
First time we watching your video and like 20 seconds into it you’re talking about how pretty much all your videos is from the viewers. I think that’s pretty cool to give people what they actually want instead of giving them something and hoping they want it. You got your new subscriber, buddy.
Dean and Sam entering the picture makes sense if they suspected it was a supernatural killing spree of sorts. They'd probably figure out that these deaths are just regular killings and pass off the intel they gathered to someone they trust within the police (they're kinda iffy with the law too so it makes sense they wouldn't just hand over everything to a police station and call it a day).
yeah they wouldn't really care about doing things legally... if they thought he was a threat, they'd just kill Dexter, but most likely they'd just tell a cop they trust and move on...
I loved that series until the last season. They went too much over their heads with the conspiracy stuff and it wasn't that much fun to watch the episodes. Oh, just like the last season of Dexter - it wasn't really that entertaining anymore, and Debs reaction was a bit too much too weird that made things not really believable.
L couldn't put Light behind bars legally because he used a supernatural power to kill lol. Even Vince found the M99 in one of the victims, Dexter would go down so hard
Part 2 when? We could have Poirot, Marple, Monk, Psych. Hell, we could go out of bounds a bit and consider spies like Bond, 24 or Burn Notice. Great video!
1:04 bro this is just not true. One of the major problems Dexter had is that the people coming after him were innocent and he couldn’t kill them. And Liddy had kidnapped him and was literally about to expose Dexter, there was no choice.
@d4cheese yeah because near had plot armor honestly no one can write that many names in that much of a short period of time That's literally impossible The finale of death note didn't really make any sense light should have won against near.
You gotta remember, light is up against L who has a 100% case solving record of only the most complicated matters, and stopped ww3 as a child. He is literally built different
Oh my God!!! Dexter used to be my absolute favourite show before I got into Supernatural so just 2 minutes in I'm already losing my mind at the mention of both of them together 😭💖
That's a good tier list, but it definitely cries out for a part two (and even possibly a part three), because there are many more adversaries for Dexter to go up against, such as: Columbo, Spenser, Rust Cohle ("True Detective"), Hercule Poirot, Peter Gunn, Dale Cooper ("Twin Peaks"). Jessica Fletcher, Veronica Mars, Father Brown, Fox Mulder & Dana Scully, Jim Rockford, Miss Marple, Sam Spade, Charlie Chan, Theo Kojak, Remington Steele, and Dr. R. Quincy ("Quincy, M.E.").
Sam Spade would catch Dexter for sure. So would Poirot. They would both instinctively know after 2 inquiries. They would also bait Dexter into showing evidence. Father Brown would actually find evidence and notice every detail on his own, while no one was the wiser.
Monk and psych characters as well would be interesting since they have taken cases similar (psych with yin and yang and monk is pretty much all of them)
@@Johnroberts2457 Shawn Spencer is definitely finding out Dexter is the bay harbor butcher, but I fear he would ultimately end up on the table. Shawn is incredibly smart and gifted but it never really stops him from being kidnapped in the show. Yes, Shawn gets out of most things but I don't think he's getting off the table once he's been strapped down.
SHIVERS (Formiddable) Success: You feel it, across the city, walking away confidently with the smell of the docks still about him. The Bay Harbor Butcher smiles to himself as he thinks of the burned-out wreck of a cop brought in to aid in his capture. He has never felt more at ease than when he heard of your track record and history. He thinks that the game is as good as done. He feels safe. ESPRIT DE CORPS (Formiddable) Success: The cops of Miami sit confidently at their desks. They may doubt your methods, but they are happy to no longer be at the forefront of what has thus far been a wild goose chase. The only person from their precinct that is still playing an active role in the investigation is their top forensic scientist Dexter Morgan. The only person smart enough to be able to immediately recognize the kinds of patterns that violence leaves behind. The only person who'd have a chance of deciphering the methods and mentality of the Bay Harbor Butcher. VISUAL CALCULUS: Perhaps even a match for me. LOGIC: Then why hasn't he? If he's so good at analyzing crime scenes and picking out leads, then why hasn't he found Dexter? ENCYCLOPEDIA (Challenging) Success: Oh yeah, baby, here we go. Big knowledge bomb coming in hot. Dexter Morgan is well known for being a talented forensic scientist, but one of the most intriguing details about his work with Miami PD is the fact that James Doakes really does not like him. ESPRIT DE CORPS: I don't think that's actually the most important detail, about his work. It's certainly much less interesting than all the high-profile killers he's investigated who weren't caught, but whose killings stopped rather suddenly. ENCYCLOPEDIA: Knowing things is my entire job, I think I got this figured out a little better than you. REACTION SPEED: Hold on a second, what was that? ENCYCLOPEDIA: I said- REACTION SPEED: Not you. LOGIC: So Dexter Morgan has investigated multiple high-profile serial killers, and while the killers were never caught by Miami PD, their killings abruptly stopped after Dexter became involved in the investigation? I think I just figured out our prime suspect. ENCYCLOPEDIA (Challenging) Failure: Just as I would have guessed: Sergeant Doakes is the Bay Harbor Butcher! LOGIC: Not quite. We need to talk to Kim about this lead. Kim Kitsuragi: The lieutenant cocks an eyebrow your way. "Detective? You've been awfully quiet this whole time. Is there something on your mind?" There's a weary and emphatic note to his voice as he hurriedly adds on, "Something relevant to the case?" REACTION SPEED: There's no time. SAVOIR FAIRE (Impossible) Success: *TELEPORT TO DEXTER MORGAN*
@@Quinton-om8lg th-cam.com/video/4lES6mYWRYI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Vot1DBMW7OY8TVT6 That’s your evidence. Also yes Batman has compared Velma’s detective skills to his own multiple times
I think you're underestimating the Scooby gang here. There are a few factors to keep in mind: 1. They have a 100% success rate, even on cases that actually involve the supernatural 2. They carry the power of gag characters, which pretty much makes them immune to any sort of real physical harm 3. The gang includes Shaggy, who is a top tier in most media by power scaling
The owner of this channel is only "researching" the stuff he likes and probably just reads a wiki and/or a synopsis on everything else. Could test this by asking him to do Dexter vs Cartoon characters and see him claim Dexter wrecks Homer and doesn't get killed by the writer in an act of black comedy while homer falls down a flight of stairs
Yeah this also threw me off. It shows he is biased. Why would I take seriously the tier list when he didnt gave a chance to one of the characters he picked.
With the Gang sure, but Scooby Alone i'm not convinced that Scooby wouldn't end up on the table (I mean, ultimately it doesn't matter because toon force but hey)
Nah, Scooby Doo band was almost killed in Supernatural crossover. Winchesters are much better than them and even then they would either leave the investigation or kill Dexter if he tried to kill them.
L was able to deduce that Kira was located in one region in one specific country in literally 1 day to immediately pinpoint where Kira lives. L on his first day of trying to find Kira was able to narrow it down from literally anyone in the whole world to one specific region in Japan and shortly deduced that it was Light afterwards. Not only that but Light barely won against L, he only won because he cheated pretty much. Light had to rely on Rem and Misa to be able to kill L, he wasn't able to do it by himself. So considering how fast L was able to pinpoint Light as Kira and considering Light couldn't even beat him by himself despite having a supernatural weapon i think L would find Dexter incredibly easy
The Scooby Gang would most definitely find out Dexter secret and if you think that they would be be put on the table you have no clue just how insane that gang is for real
What's funny is that Dexter would try to get them onto the table but Scooby and Shaggy would bumble something and it would end up with Dexter getting caught.
I think that the Supernatural guys would catch Dexter. I mean they're used to going after monsters that often don't leave evidence. So they'd figure it out, but Dean would say, "Welp, he's human. Not out problem." Whilst Sam would go on his humanitarian rant about protecting the public. And as Dean usually gives in to Sam, they'd just kill him quietly and burn his body. No going to jail.
Batman has referenced multiple times in crossover comics (which were confirmed canon) that Velma is a smarter detective/investigative mind than any Robin, and at one point was even willing to offer her the role of Robin. If you think Nightwing can figure it out, Velma’s gonna get it.
5:20 Light is superior to Dexter, light is smarter, and light has greater resources (in addition to police intel, he ofc has a shinigami and supernatural methods of murder.). With that being said, I would say L pretty much immediately catches Dexter, he has the massive amount of resources, and he narrowed down a possible worldwide killer, not only to a country but to a specific region, narrowed down the rules of the killing, and the general age of the killer in one move. Then upon meeting Light, was essentially sure that Light was Kira, but legitimately couldn't prove it because of supernatural rules.
The problem whit Dexter is that theres not Even bodies to be found, sure the second season but out of that, never get the absurd amount of bodies catch again 😅
@@christangamalierrodriguezc2974sometimes the show makes me wonder if there’s ever any bodies that like, wash up on shore somewhere… just, out of nowhere. You gotta think that at least one or two of those bags washed ashore in some other part of the world.
The interesting part about this tier list is that people “on the table” are actually better than those who “would come close”, since they would have to be a threat to justify being on the table.
nop, because being on the table means that they exposed themselves so Dexter is aware that is kind of being followed, and the one's that "would come close" they would not be in Dexter radar because 1 the do not expose themselves, 2 because they don't have the expertise, but they came close to the ones who expose themselves(table)
Light straight up had a magic murder notebook and L pieced together he was a student in Japan before the rest of the world even knew if it was a murderer or not. He wouldn't even take the bay harbor butcher case because it would be so easy it'd be beneath him.
@1:58 as a huge supernatural fan I feel like Sam and Dean could or would find out and notice the kinda victims Dexter hunts, human “monsters” and that Dexter isn’t a supernatural being for them to hunt they would probably either leave him alone or leave a tip to one of their trusted contacts in the authorities. Hell Dean would probably joke about wanting to buy him a beer.
L probably could put Dexter behind bars. He has the Money, the Prowess and the Time to do so. I agree with Mills and Somerset, Somerset would be on Dexter’s trail before Dexter either Misdirects him or Mills makes a mistake. I think Rust Cohle would figure out Dexter’s secret easily. Although actually putting Dexter behind bars would be hard considering Rust’s illegal methods.
@wildcrochunter6724 Yeah a teenager that's way smarter than you and me combined and has access to a book that can kill you without a trace also at the end of the anime he's not a teenager anymore he's pretty much an adult
actual real life serial killers are most of the time low life losers targeting children or women or every "easy prey" they can get only in hollywood are they this kind of alpha predators
Batman is finding dexter so fast it isn’t funny. Dick Grayson and tim drake can literally solve scenes just by looking at it this wouldn’t even be a problem
@@Jim-pq9pm that’s ok all he’d have to do is track the disappearances of these people, sneak and find dexter in the act. There doesn’t have to be a crime scene even if it takes a while batman has cameras all over the place and his deduction skills would allow him to find dexters.
Yall must remember that Scooby gang literally have a talking dog! Even if they did go to the table, Scooby would just explain everything to the police 'cause I doubt that Dexter would ever consider taking the dog. Plus, in DC universe, Velma is top 2 detective (only behind Batman)
Tbh it wouldnt even take batman a long time to put dexter away. Nigh-omniscient beings have asked him for help on investigations and have complimented his detective skills
I mean I think in this tier list we have to assume that we are in the point of the show where everyone knows there is a killer. In my head canon its like they find these bags and they have no evidence that points anywhere and they are just calling in the who's who of detectives. And it's just a rat race of these people trying to find out who the bay harbor butcher is. lol
Need I remind you that Batman just so happens to be friends with the literal king of Atlantis (Who reminder is actually STUPID powerful, like its insane how powerful Aquaman actually is)
3:54 I don’t know much about the character being explained but I do know a decent amount about Dexter and I know that Dexter doesn’t leave a crime scene, if u go back to S2, the bodies that were found under the ocean were obviously not at a crime scene so wouldn’t that mean that this detective in question wouldn’t be able to reenact how the victim died because they were chopped up in the bottom of the ocean?
Dexter would be a teched up antihero. Like a DC Punisher/mixed with Batman, if he could get someone to hook him up with the tech stuff. Like a "sponsor" for his "activities" from someone who thinks Batman doesn't go far enough.
I read all your comments about L, yes, he definitely should have been at the top tier, but trust me I did not underestimate him. The second highest tier is basically winning against Dexter too
lol.. being on the 2nd highest tier is kinda like losing.. you not putting him behind bars due to lack of evidence is a win for dexter.. Light had super natural powers on his side and L pin pointed him.. bad take if i may say so..
You should do a tier list on characters who could actually do dexters job. E.g. S Tier = better butcher than dexter, A Tier = Could do dexters job well, B Tier = could do it to the minimum, C Tier = might get caught, D Tier = cant do it and would get could. Idk just an idea
Next time do a video or short on patrick jane. Please
add columbo, rockford, yagami, Raidou Kuzonoha
Next do
Jack Reacher (although Reacher will just put a bullet in Dexter)
Jessica Jones
Max Payne (again will just shoot him)
The Question
Robin (Tim and Grayson)
Red Hood
Rorschach
For Batman I just don’t think Dexter would be dumb enough to operate in Gotham.
Batman has done cases outside of Gotham before
I agree. Batman operates during the night, Dexter does most of his kills at night so he will eventually gain Batman attention and when that happens, it would be done for him.
Dexter would be aware of Batman and aware of the fact that he doesn't stand a chance against Batman if they shared a universe. He would keep states between them
ngl he'd try that shit and get packed up in gotham lmfao. Them gotham goons no joke😭😭
Isn’t he similar to Red Hood? Only kill murderers and such?
The only reason L even remotely had trouble proving Light to be the murderer is because Light had a supernatural weapon on him, one that has never been known to the world before. With normal crimes like those committed by Dexter, L will be on to him in like a day
Was thinking the same. Before Light lost his memories, L had him at every turn despite him using a supernatural weapon. And as smart as Dex is, he's nowhere close to Light.
I feel if we wanna include anime characters, Heinrich Runge from Monster vs Dexter makes for a much more interesting scenario as that show is actually grounded in reality. Plus Runge is an interesting character, very intelligent yet incredibly stubborn.
Fr
I had heard that L already knew light was kira but he didn’t have enough evidence to put him behind bars.
@@Areichi yes because Light literally had a weapon beyond human understand that can kill without leaving any trace of evidence. EVEN THEN L was almost able to catch him, and Light only got away because the Deathnote also had the ability to literally wipe his memory of its existence. Dexter was not offered such luxury
It’s crazy to think about how the show could play out if L didn’t have the same moral code he does. Like he just kills L once he personally knows. Like he becomes the hero, but is also the villain to society but not the viewer, until he fucks up somehow and then the audience AND the show hates him, but he’s actively smarter than both.
Could be very complex
Dean on Dexters table: "When i come back I'm gona be pissed" 😂😂
The Scooby Doo gang has a 100% success rate when it comes to solving crimes. If there was anyone in the universe I would trust to solve a murder it's Scooby and the gang!
And, they are never by themselves. Even when they "split up," they're still in groups. Poor Dex would never get the chance to needle any of them.
The toon force would basically guarantee Dexter gets caught
They would pull the mask off only to find out that it was Doakes!
@@Hoiku76or the janitor from the old haunted amusement park.
Multiple episodes they have been given a closet in a hotel and Daphne said "it needs a woman's touch" walked in random sounds of tools walked out and the room is now a 5 bedroom apartment
Light had a lower IQ compared to L, but you're overlooking something crucial: he had the Death Note. L, on the other hand, had no idea the concept of the Death Note even existed. Despite this, L was still able to deduce that Light was Kira, even without knowing how Light was killing his victims.
In contrast, Dexter physically kills his victims, which leaves behind tangible evidence that L could trace. This makes Dexter's actions far easier to investigate and connect compared to Light's supernatural methods.
Dexter also has a whole collection of evidence in his literal house. L would find that pretty quickly with a warrant and have all the evidence he needs to convict.
@@TheEpic22but how does he get the warrant without having the evidence to explain
@@BoKinetz Bro he is L, no.1, 2 and 3 best detective. I don't think warrant will be a issue as he will put cameras where he want like originally in anime. Also L would only do the mission if he got access of the main country police like in anime
@@BoKinetz you think you need evidence for warrant? The no 1 detective of any state can have easy pass from any judge for probable cause against a serial killer
wasn't part of Light's early killings sloppy because he killed outside of school hours which narrowed the list of potential suspects?
or did I dream that in a fever haze?
Columbo not being in this list is crime, he would crack the case in matter of hours
“Oh just one more thing”
100%. My big problem with most Detectives trying to track Dexter down is how insanely thorough Dexter is when it comes to cleaning up after himself, But, Columbo relies on Social pressure to crack open criminals. Dexters fate would be sealed the moment Columbo decided to question him.
rust cohle
I was about to say Columbo would like smell the breeze and be like .... the bay harbour butcher? is Dexter?
Considering L stopped World War 3 at 8 years old and almost bested the supernatural. I think catching Dexter would be light work for him.
Hahahhah I get the pun there.
@ lol, someone got it.
😂
L played off of Lights hubris, he'd need some kind of "in" with Dexter, which I don't think he'd provide.
@@Jim-pq9pmYou’ve got the wrong idea then 🤷
The Scooby Doo gang hunting Dexter sounds like a robot chicken sketch
You have a point 😭
Now I need them to make it 😂😂
Yeah it sounds like it tho they would catch him. It's weird but even Batman sees them as equals.
Huge potential here
The Hugh Dancy version of Will Graham would catch Dexter by accident in his sleep.
I love how not a single comment is talking about Sherlock. They're like yeah it's Sherlock, of course he would, and move on. 😂
My personal dislike of Sherlock is that in his show it would just write him to be right no matter how weak his conclusions but in Dexter's show he would be hopeless. So personally I would put as "couldn't prove anything"
@@cipher3966 Yeah I agree. He would look at a hair and tell the life story of some characters. I mean bruh. But in the world of Sherlock, he would defeat Dexter without lifting a single finger, but as you said in Dexter's world, he would certainly face some difficulty if you understand what I mean. It's just a matter of who are we picking and putting in the other's world.
Dexter* sits down on a park bench* look at that sky its a beautiful day to go jog don't u think?
Sherlock Holmes* handcuffs him* and to get Arrested!
@@YuhabahaMajesty to be fair, Sherlock from the books is not as superhuman as the show. His and Dexter's world are just the same. All his reasoning came from his photographic memories and he never made assumptions, unlike the show.
@@saufyazman5227 Yeah the books depict much more realism compared to the show.
Dawg the scooby gang would absolutely put Dexter behind bars. Hell they’d even do it on accident
To be clear: they could only do it on accident
"And if we remove this mask you'll find its the... Local creepy blood spatter analyst"
"ah, me and my dark harbinger would have gotten away with it too, if it wasn't for you damn kids and your meddling dog"
He would have got away with it too if wasn't for those meddling kids
They just straight up rip his face off
@@alexevans4877 lmao
i feel like will graham would find out immediately but keep it a secret because he’s curious and wants to see what happens
picking up his weird european boyfriend’s habits 💀
Lol. I was going to say the same.
Sam and Dean won't prove anything , they would just kill Dexter .
I dunno, he kills serial killers. Is that really so different from hunting monsters? I feel like they'd still take him out in the end, but it would make an excellent crossover if written well
I'm not convinced they would Sam and Dean have proven themselves less effective against humans on sooooo many occasions. Meanwhile Dexter took out Doakes in hand to hand - Doakes is special forces and he KNEW who Dexter was and books and movies he still couldn't take Dexter down. Could they call Castiel for help sure but then it's not really Sam and Dean...it's Castiel and that's a copout.
They wouldnt. There are multiple instances in the show where sam n dean almost give up an investigation because the supernatural element's dont appear to be present, and they leave it to the normal authorities. Im also thinking dean would side with the mission of dexter, maybe not the whole method, but killing killers and bad people who fall through the cracks of justice sounds very dean
@@avrilfan0521sam and dean would whoop dexter. They have taken vamps, demons, angels and gods in hand to hand.
@mihailshevchenko2368 but all of those have convenient (albeit difficult) magical solutions. In actual hand to hand without one shot kill magic daggers and guns they get bodied constantly.
Thing is, Sam and Dean wouldn't look for evidence. If they found out any proof that he's the bay harbor butcher, they'd go after him themselves, and take him out if they thought he was a threat to innocent people. At most if they felt he wasn't their business, they'd just give their suspicions to a cop they'd trust, and leave them to it.
This isnt a kill dexter tier list. Otherwise anyone with any powers Will defeat sexter
@@avalope Sam and Dean don't have powers though, just plot armor as established by God in their universe.
Dexter*puts burger on the fryer* order up for table number 23.. Hello boys what can i get you
Bam
@@OneofaKimeCreations plot armor is a power.
@@avalopenot inherently. It CAN be a power tho. Usually its a plot point/writers choice.
6:15 light had a magic book that would magically kill ppl n L still pinpointed down to the house Light was in…L catches Dexter without leaving him chair lol
Exactly what I was about to type
Not to forget that he also has the ressources for it just like Batman since every Major Agency Financially supports his ways
You're glossing over why he was caught so easily. If Light never had the ego to kill the fake L or do something as bone headed as react to info only known to police, he wouldn't have been caught.
Light was stupid. His ego played him. Dexter wouldn't have that flaw.
@@PubstarHerohe also doesn’t have a magic notebook that can kill people in impossible ways
@PubstarHero dexter did have ego/a flaw tho. Keeping those trophies (microscope slides) was a mistake everyone saw coming
Columbo talking to Dexter at the start of an episode is a fever dream I have frequently.
Columbo would have him arrested in 45 minutes
Columbo would know immediately and just have to prove it, like most of the movies/episodes
“In a building full of cops…why is Doakes the only one who gets the creeps?”
"Now sir, I just got one more question-"
"Just one more thing. I saw ya do it."
Colombo would wear him down with the “Just one more thing”
To be fair Colombo would know from the start, but would just lead Dexter on to frustrate him.
@ Hehe, exactly. 😂 He always knew the person he was stalking was guilty, it was like a game of cat and mouse to him.
I feel like Columbo operates mostly on vibes at first to get a really good guess at who the killer is, and the episodes are just him trying to prove it. He's just way better at the cat and mouse game than L is. But yeah he could definitely catch Dexter
@@galateangemmate804I mean the only reason Dex wasn’t ever caught was because of literal bs and the fact Miami metro was run by literal morons except Doaks who was a different type of psychotic
0:19 starting the video to see Jake Peralta from B99. Don't disappoint me!
I have been disappointed
@spznormi8497womp womp
There’s an episode in Brooklyn nine-nine called “unsolvable” where Jake and Terry (95% Jake 5% Terry) solve a case where a guy named Nate Dexter is the killer
It’s a reference to Dexter so I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say he could catch him just cause of that
Tier list of Dexter's outfits he has worn throughout the series (clothes)
I like your idea 💡 😉👍✨
#1 The donut fit
Dexter in Targaryen attire
100% yes!
No1. Bare ass naked dexter season 8
Doakes is the bay harbor butcher not Dexter
No
Rita is the real Bay harbour blower not doakes
@ninguemabsolutamentenada399 real
No Masuka is
Is that a blue comment... on youtube
No rahh I am
2:37 Bold of you to assume the identity of Bay Harbor Butcher
We all know it's truly doax
Absolutely not, we all knew it was Masuka the whole time.
L would definitely catch Dexter, giving the fact that he's the best Detective in Death Note. The whole idea about his character is that if it's possible, he will discover it. If there's a possibility of putting Dexter behind bars, he would
even people like lundy and quinn knew theres something up with him, L wouldnt even sweat a drop.
L nearly traped a guy who can magically kill from anywhere, of course he can catch him
L is broken. His intuition is literally on impossible levels. He makes connections and accurate assumptions out of nowhere, or when something happens he's like "i knew this would happen exactly this way because ..."
@@DaMazzaf97Yep, L has Nigh-Omniscient levels of knowledge thanks to his Godlike intuition, he catches Dexter.
The detective's wife that was literally about to catch Light on the first half of the season. Light got away by sheer plot coincidence lol
The mystery gang from Scooby-Doo wouldn’t just catch Dexter, Shaggy would annihilate him with a mere 0.01% of his power.
You’re probably right
Valma catching dexter the batman wants her to become his Robin
Meta
Ez work
They would, The premise of analyzing these fictional characters is based upon using their abilities in their own show as a benchmark. The Scooby gang posses powers that would trivialize Dexter's mind and skills as a murderer.
It's kind of funny having detectives from Seven here, since they didn't catch their killer. He turned himself in
L clears. While Dexter is better than Light in terms of maturity and ego, Light had the upper hand due to the supernatural powers he used to kill people remotely, while Dexter used traditional means for his killings. Light's methods were also unheard of at the time, but L still managed to suspect him.
No way you said that dexter is better than light..
@@Sinislovesbillcypher. in terms of maturity and ego
@@Sinislovesbillcypher.light is way less emotionally mature, and was prone to delusions of grandeur. Dexter doesn’t have these flaws
@@Sinislovesbillcypher.If light wasnt so caught up in his ego unlike Dexter the entire manga ends when L offers up a sacrifice on the news. Light gets manipulated several times like that
True, imagine going against a murderer that doesn't leave any traces, and can seemingly kill anyone he wants like it was magic.
And L still found out Light was Kira, and deciphered how the death note worked, he just couldn't find concrete evidence.
*meanwhile in another universe*
Dexter*walks up and shakes hand* hi i am Dexter pleasure to meet you
sherlock Holmes*shakes his hand and then handcuffs him* and you are under Arrest
Due to being the most realistic detective of all time,
Jimmy McNaulty from the wire would find nothing
What about Lester?
The problem before they discovered dexter's body bags is that nobody even knew a bay harbor butcher even existed
Yeah and nobody is filling missing person reports, but the second the bags come to light, Dexter would be cook since he’s save a lot of time by luck
@@aestheticmirror9257I mean, some of his victims had missing persons reports. We see during the bay harbour butcher investigation while they’re looking for the identity of Dexters victims that there’s like 3 or so family members who reported some of the missing persons the cops found.
Granted, at least one of them doesn’t exactly seem too… distraught about the fact that his father (iirc) is potentially dead, and more or less wanted a confirmation so his mom could stop living in fear.
You're sleeping on the Mystery Inc gang, Velma IS a Batman level IQ character due to comic tie ins
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Velma literally folds like soggy bread if her glasses get knocked off. She ain't doing anything.
She definitely hard carries the gang, but she soft af. She ain't cut out anything actually dangerous. Now if she just teamed with batman, that'd be sound, but on her own, she'd get scooped up faster than rocky road ice cream at a summer base ball game
Batman level IQ is a insane high ball
@@knotadoctor1455tbf she did hack his coms in a movie
Scooby-doo gang would have caught Dexter. Batman has said Velma is the best detective out there and that they are teenagers. Dexter would never suspect them.
There is no way Light is smarter than Dexter. He just has better plot armor
Arkham batman could find out dexter is the bay harbor butcher in less than a day LOWBALLED
Oh yeah Arkham Batman is OP in the investigation department considering he can literally provide a visual timeline of the crime scene from just a few small clues.
It'll be like season 2 except Doaks wasn't there, He studies his old case and his old history (cause he has access to everything) then either sets a trap or confront while Dexter has no idea about it.
@@thomaswilson3827well, IF there’s a crime scene
@@alextempletYTBatman scanners can probably reveal the smallest DNA scans so really it depends on how long can he stall
@ batscanners are just outfuckingrageous lmfao he probably could make a crime scene out of a piece of lint and a fingernail clipping
2:00 i feel like sam and dean would just kill him tbh
dean did kill Hitler so i agree.
That was my first thought. Sam and Dean dont put anyone behind bars.
They'd kill him in the show. In the books, they'd kill the Dark Passenger and free Dexter from it.
with an angel blade juuust to make sure that he is not some monster that cant be killed with conventional weapons.
first they have to find dexter tho, just based on the fact that dexter kills irregularly, with decent time between each m**der and because the victims are always really bad guys, they’ll probably just move on to better targets
sam and dean don’t have a lot of experience hunting humans and they don’t have the time to do it either + dexter has a lot of experience evading cops
so my moneys on dexter but yeah if they catch him , he is done, no escape from the winchester boys
First time we watching your video and like 20 seconds into it you’re talking about how pretty much all your videos is from the viewers. I think that’s pretty cool to give people what they actually want instead of giving them something and hoping they want it. You got your new subscriber, buddy.
Dean and Sam entering the picture makes sense if they suspected it was a supernatural killing spree of sorts. They'd probably figure out that these deaths are just regular killings and pass off the intel they gathered to someone they trust within the police (they're kinda iffy with the law too so it makes sense they wouldn't just hand over everything to a police station and call it a day).
yeah they wouldn't really care about doing things legally...
if they thought he was a threat, they'd just kill Dexter, but most likely they'd just tell a cop they trust and move on...
They don't kill humans so ya they would inform the cops. Most likely blackmailing a crooked cop to do it.@@liliaeth
Well in the books Dexter is actually supernatural. Even in the tv show he constantly talks with a ghost(kinda)
My man disrepecting the scooby gang. Velma is a great detective, actually.
1:30 Ok, I was just going to watch this and move on, but after your comment about the best show in history, you earned a subscriber.
Patrick Jane would toy with Dexter to the point of ending up on the table shouting “Lisbon!!”
Oh he 100% would 😂
So true
The crossover we wished we had
I loved that series until the last season. They went too much over their heads with the conspiracy stuff and it wasn't that much fun to watch the episodes.
Oh, just like the last season of Dexter - it wasn't really that entertaining anymore, and Debs reaction was a bit too much too weird that made things not really believable.
@@valeriafontoura8040 For me its that Dexter let a killer off his table. Thats what ruined it for me
"Oh, mister Morgan, just one more thing sir, sorry to bother you..."
Yes. Columbo would have caught him. 100%.
Every show, EVERY fucking time.
“I saw you do it… I’m going to have to send you to the Columbo dimension”
Hannibal (from the TV show) would have been making Dexter soup half-way through a single episode
6:32 all I can imagine is Michael C Hall say “I would’ve gotten away with it if it wasn’t for you medaling kids”
This version of Sherlock could put Dexter behind bars, but he might very well decide not to.
Book Sherlock would 100% let him go
You should have put jack reacher on the list. And i think he would have found out at least
L couldn't put Light behind bars legally because he used a supernatural power to kill lol. Even Vince found the M99 in one of the victims, Dexter would go down so hard
Part 2 when? We could have Poirot, Marple, Monk, Psych. Hell, we could go out of bounds a bit and consider spies like Bond, 24 or Burn Notice. Great video!
Columbo, or Chloe & Lucy Morningstar, too. 😂
Oooo let's throw Blanc in there too!
Robert Goren of L&O: Criminal Intent
Don't forget Rust Cohle from True Detective season 1! I would love to see a Rust vs. Dexter matchup.
Monk and Psych would make light work of him
What about Columbo? He’s not only smart but he plays himself off as an idiot to put people off guard.
Velma is canonically on par with Batman in the comics. She just one of the members of the gang. They are easily catching him.
on par? BATMAN CAME TO VELMA TO ASK FOR HELP. The dark knight who never asks for anything from anyone came to the scooby gang to ask for help
@@bogdanpetrache6860be fr. That’s just a straight up gag.
@@Smegmodd but it happened, and there isnt anything anyone can do about that fact. Velma clears. Edited for you riders
Cross overs aren't canon bud@@deathsaidhello
@@Wendigo107 oh no! oh my!
anyways...
Considering the entire death note canon,L obliterates dexter in almost every way possible and he could definitely put him behind bars.
Poirot should be in the list. And Scooby doo gang can definitely catch Dexter
1:04 bro this is just not true. One of the major problems Dexter had is that the people coming after him were innocent and he couldn’t kill them. And Liddy had kidnapped him and was literally about to expose Dexter, there was no choice.
It’s just another way of saying they have no chance
@ then he should’ve said that
Hot take, but dexter is smarter than light for just 1 solid reason, that is he lacks the god complex of light and acts less impulsively on emotions.
I think that people think that Light is more intelligent than he is, let's not forget that he can kill without leaving any clue and still got caught
light is definitely more intelligent but dexter has the edge in controlling his emotions since he barely even has any in the first place
@@ontheglo.28 yep that sums it up
@d4cheese yeah because near had plot armor honestly no one can write that many names in that much of a short period of time That's literally impossible The finale of death note didn't really make any sense light should have won against near.
You gotta remember, light is up against L who has a 100% case solving record of only the most complicated matters, and stopped ww3 as a child. He is literally built different
Oh my God!!! Dexter used to be my absolute favourite show before I got into Supernatural so just 2 minutes in I'm already losing my mind at the mention of both of them together 😭💖
That's a good tier list, but it definitely cries out for a part two (and even possibly a part three), because there are many more adversaries for Dexter to go up against, such as: Columbo, Spenser, Rust Cohle ("True Detective"), Hercule Poirot, Peter Gunn, Dale Cooper ("Twin Peaks"). Jessica Fletcher, Veronica Mars, Father Brown, Fox Mulder & Dana Scully, Jim Rockford, Miss Marple, Sam Spade, Charlie Chan, Theo Kojak, Remington Steele, and Dr. R. Quincy ("Quincy, M.E.").
Sam Spade would catch Dexter for sure. So would Poirot. They would both instinctively know after 2 inquiries. They would also bait Dexter into showing evidence. Father Brown would actually find evidence and notice every detail on his own, while no one was the wiser.
Monk and psych characters as well would be interesting since they have taken cases similar (psych with yin and yang and monk is pretty much all of them)
@@Johnroberts2457finally someone mentioned Adrian Monk
@@Johnroberts2457 PSYCH MENTIONED, LET'S GOOOO WHO THE FUCK IS BARTON GUSTER?!?! 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
@@Johnroberts2457 Shawn Spencer is definitely finding out Dexter is the bay harbor butcher, but I fear he would ultimately end up on the table. Shawn is incredibly smart and gifted but it never really stops him from being kidnapped in the show. Yes, Shawn gets out of most things but I don't think he's getting off the table once he's been strapped down.
i know this video isn’t about video games, but seeing Harry and Kim from Disco Elysium try to catch Dexter would be absolutely amazing
Definitely. We need more of Harry and Kim
from my experience Harry will stumble his way into cathcing Dexter and everyone will be left wondering how the hell this happened. Harry included.
@ never doubt the Human Can Opener
SHIVERS (Formiddable) Success: You feel it, across the city, walking away confidently with the smell of the docks still about him. The Bay Harbor Butcher smiles to himself as he thinks of the burned-out wreck of a cop brought in to aid in his capture. He has never felt more at ease than when he heard of your track record and history. He thinks that the game is as good as done. He feels safe.
ESPRIT DE CORPS (Formiddable) Success: The cops of Miami sit confidently at their desks. They may doubt your methods, but they are happy to no longer be at the forefront of what has thus far been a wild goose chase. The only person from their precinct that is still playing an active role in the investigation is their top forensic scientist Dexter Morgan. The only person smart enough to be able to immediately recognize the kinds of patterns that violence leaves behind. The only person who'd have a chance of deciphering the methods and mentality of the Bay Harbor Butcher.
VISUAL CALCULUS: Perhaps even a match for me.
LOGIC: Then why hasn't he? If he's so good at analyzing crime scenes and picking out leads, then why hasn't he found Dexter?
ENCYCLOPEDIA (Challenging) Success: Oh yeah, baby, here we go. Big knowledge bomb coming in hot. Dexter Morgan is well known for being a talented forensic scientist, but one of the most intriguing details about his work with Miami PD is the fact that James Doakes really does not like him.
ESPRIT DE CORPS: I don't think that's actually the most important detail, about his work. It's certainly much less interesting than all the high-profile killers he's investigated who weren't caught, but whose killings stopped rather suddenly.
ENCYCLOPEDIA: Knowing things is my entire job, I think I got this figured out a little better than you.
REACTION SPEED: Hold on a second, what was that?
ENCYCLOPEDIA: I said-
REACTION SPEED: Not you.
LOGIC: So Dexter Morgan has investigated multiple high-profile serial killers, and while the killers were never caught by Miami PD, their killings abruptly stopped after Dexter became involved in the investigation? I think I just figured out our prime suspect.
ENCYCLOPEDIA (Challenging) Failure: Just as I would have guessed: Sergeant Doakes is the Bay Harbor Butcher!
LOGIC: Not quite. We need to talk to Kim about this lead.
Kim Kitsuragi: The lieutenant cocks an eyebrow your way. "Detective? You've been awfully quiet this whole time. Is there something on your mind?" There's a weary and emphatic note to his voice as he hurriedly adds on, "Something relevant to the case?"
REACTION SPEED: There's no time.
SAVOIR FAIRE (Impossible) Success: *TELEPORT TO DEXTER MORGAN*
Inland Empire would go crazy in Dexter Morgan's presence
How bout Columbo?
This was great, btw. You should do a part 2 with the suggestions people have added in the comments.
6:30 Velma has been established to have a detect capability comparable to that of Batman.
Yep Batman and Wonder Woman consider her among the smartest detectives they know. Scooby Doo is catching Dexter 100%.
I don't believe this is there any evidence of this?
@@Quinton-om8lg The "Batman and Scooby Doo Mysteries" Series.
@@Quinton-om8lg th-cam.com/video/4lES6mYWRYI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Vot1DBMW7OY8TVT6
That’s your evidence. Also yes Batman has compared Velma’s detective skills to his own multiple times
Yeah, and then end up on the table
I think you're underestimating the Scooby gang here. There are a few factors to keep in mind:
1. They have a 100% success rate, even on cases that actually involve the supernatural
2. They carry the power of gag characters, which pretty much makes them immune to any sort of real physical harm
3. The gang includes Shaggy, who is a top tier in most media by power scaling
Was really hoping to see bigby and the boys here
Sorry to say it, but Scooby Doo and the gang would probably win if you don’t believe me look up the video Scooby Doo versus The Kira case
fr
The owner of this channel is only "researching" the stuff he likes and probably just reads a wiki and/or a synopsis on everything else. Could test this by asking him to do Dexter vs Cartoon characters and see him claim Dexter wrecks Homer and doesn't get killed by the writer in an act of black comedy while homer falls down a flight of stairs
Yeah this also threw me off. It shows he is biased. Why would I take seriously the tier list when he didnt gave a chance to one of the characters he picked.
With the Gang sure, but Scooby Alone i'm not convinced that Scooby wouldn't end up on the table (I mean, ultimately it doesn't matter because toon force but hey)
Nah, Scooby Doo band was almost killed in Supernatural crossover. Winchesters are much better than them and even then they would either leave the investigation or kill Dexter if he tried to kill them.
*sees the Batsignal*
“It’s over, he knows”
L was able to deduce that Kira was located in one region in one specific country in literally 1 day to immediately pinpoint where Kira lives. L on his first day of trying to find Kira was able to narrow it down from literally anyone in the whole world to one specific region in Japan and shortly deduced that it was Light afterwards. Not only that but Light barely won against L, he only won because he cheated pretty much. Light had to rely on Rem and Misa to be able to kill L, he wasn't able to do it by himself. So considering how fast L was able to pinpoint Light as Kira and considering Light couldn't even beat him by himself despite having a supernatural weapon i think L would find Dexter incredibly easy
The Scooby Gang would most definitely find out Dexter secret and if you think that they would be be put on the table you have no clue just how insane that gang is for real
What's funny is that Dexter would try to get them onto the table but Scooby and Shaggy would bumble something and it would end up with Dexter getting caught.
L is deffinitly top tier
also supernatural is my favorit show you did good explaining to me why they wouldnt catch him blew my mind
I think that the Supernatural guys would catch Dexter. I mean they're used to going after monsters that often don't leave evidence. So they'd figure it out, but Dean would say, "Welp, he's human. Not out problem." Whilst Sam would go on his humanitarian rant about protecting the public. And as Dean usually gives in to Sam, they'd just kill him quietly and burn his body. No going to jail.
Batman has referenced multiple times in crossover comics (which were confirmed canon) that Velma is a smarter detective/investigative mind than any Robin, and at one point was even willing to offer her the role of Robin. If you think Nightwing can figure it out, Velma’s gonna get it.
5:20 Light is superior to Dexter, light is smarter, and light has greater resources (in addition to police intel, he ofc has a shinigami and supernatural methods of murder.). With that being said, I would say L pretty much immediately catches Dexter, he has the massive amount of resources, and he narrowed down a possible worldwide killer, not only to a country but to a specific region, narrowed down the rules of the killing, and the general age of the killer in one move. Then upon meeting Light, was essentially sure that Light was Kira, but legitimately couldn't prove it because of supernatural rules.
Yeah, 100%
Obviously
@@malachidukes4921 I thought so, be didn't seem to think so, this wasn't a comment specifically for you Malachi
The problem whit Dexter is that theres not Even bodies to be found, sure the second season but out of that, never get the absurd amount of bodies catch again 😅
@@christangamalierrodriguezc2974sometimes the show makes me wonder if there’s ever any bodies that like, wash up on shore somewhere… just, out of nowhere. You gotta think that at least one or two of those bags washed ashore in some other part of the world.
What about Rust from True Detective? Feel like he would obsess over it for a decade and complete the job. Alright, alright.
I went to the comment section specially to see if someone else also thought of Rust
Wow put some respect on the mystery gang’s name. They have a 100% success rate
The interesting part about this tier list is that people “on the table” are actually better than those who “would come close”, since they would have to be a threat to justify being on the table.
nop, because being on the table means that they exposed themselves so Dexter is aware that is kind of being followed, and the one's that "would come close" they would not be in Dexter radar because 1 the do not expose themselves, 2 because they don't have the expertise, but they came close to the ones who expose themselves(table)
@@narvini727 Im not even a fan of this character and show but what you just typed deserves this video; th-cam.com/video/67MVBK0LI-4/w-d-xo.html
Light straight up had a magic murder notebook and L pieced together he was a student in Japan before the rest of the world even knew if it was a murderer or not. He wouldn't even take the bay harbor butcher case because it would be so easy it'd be beneath him.
This video is awesome dude I need more of this! SUBBED
The immediate jump into Supernatural shocked me cause youre so right and also I love supernatural. Dean would kill that man easy if Dex kidnapped Sam
Everybody hated the original ending to Dexter...
Then the original showrunner returned for New Blood and said, hold my beer.
L put 30 cameras in a random high schooler's room because he tought he might be Kira. You really think he would have problems catching Dexter?
Suggestions for Part 2: Patrick Jane, Jack Reacher, William Butcher, Vincent Hanna (Heat), Alexander Mahone, Hank Schrader, Monk
Luther!
The Brooklyn 99 team, True Detective...
Alex Mahone isn’t even a detective though
Yes monk
was hoping Monk was in this one
@1:58 as a huge supernatural fan I feel like Sam and Dean could or would find out and notice the kinda victims Dexter hunts, human “monsters” and that Dexter isn’t a supernatural being for them to hunt they would probably either leave him alone or leave a tip to one of their trusted contacts in the authorities. Hell Dean would probably joke about wanting to buy him a beer.
Robert pattinson looked emo in that movie
W for mentioning Will Graham and ranking him pretty well but where's Patrick Jane?
Patrick Jane would be top tier 🔥🔥🔥
@Evan-cf3ot 100% 🔥
L probably could put Dexter behind bars. He has the Money, the Prowess and the Time to do so. I agree with Mills and Somerset, Somerset would be on Dexter’s trail before Dexter either Misdirects him or Mills makes a mistake.
I think Rust Cohle would figure out Dexter’s secret easily. Although actually putting Dexter behind bars would be hard considering Rust’s illegal methods.
L can’t even catch a teenager 😭
@wildcrochunter6724 who gas a magical book to give heart attacks
@wildcrochunter6724 Yeah a teenager that's way smarter than you and me combined and has access to a book that can kill you without a trace also at the end of the anime he's not a teenager anymore he's pretty much an adult
@AngelloGomez-nh6cc hs is a adult at the end I think he is like 21
He definitely can if he had the data of the previous investigations on the bay Harbor butcher.
Batman: "Where are they?!!!!!"
Dexter: "Omelette du Fromage"
Great vid, would love to have seen Monk and Shaun Spencer on this list!
Man I think he would love it but it would also be a killer crossover
Hey. I have a video idea, “rating protagonists on if they could outsmart Dexter”
For Batman, the question isnt whether he could catch Dexter but if Dexter could survive the beating he's gonna get.
Of course he would
Batman dosen’t kill
Idea: could Dexter catch real life serial killers
Doesn't really need a video, Dexter simply outclasses every killer ever with the only exception being the zodiac.
Short answer is yes
@@rahulbansal2 True. Idk I thought it would be interesting until I realised Dexter could basically kill everyone
i think he wouldnt catch jack the ripper because hes 150 years late
actual real life serial killers are most of the time low life losers targeting children or women or every "easy prey" they can get
only in hollywood are they this kind of alpha predators
i approve of sam and dean winchester being on the list supernatural is such a great tv show soooooooo goooooood
3:40 You talk about crime scenes but.. Dexter literally doesnt leave bodies behind. What crime scene?
Clearly this man is unaware of Shaggy's immense power, and his ability to go Ultra Instinct.
Truth is, Dexter never stood a chance.
L is better than batman in detective skills
Prove me room
Dexter is Batmans bread and butter
I think of Dexter as a counter to Batman. He leaves no crime scene to work with. The dumping grounds is all he would have.
@Jim-pq9pm sounds exactly like the type of case the GCPD would call Batman in for.
Batman is finding dexter so fast it isn’t funny. Dick Grayson and tim drake can literally solve scenes just by looking at it this wouldn’t even be a problem
@@totallynotinsane3327 There are no crime scenes with Dexter.
@@Jim-pq9pm that’s ok all he’d have to do is track the disappearances of these people, sneak and find dexter in the act. There doesn’t have to be a crime scene even if it takes a while batman has cameras all over the place and his deduction skills would allow him to find dexters.
No love for Columbo. Dude would've caught Dexter faster than Batman.
Columbo would frame Dexter, by messing with evidence, but before that he would stalk Dexter for like three seasons 😅
Yall must remember that Scooby gang literally have a talking dog! Even if they did go to the table, Scooby would just explain everything to the police 'cause I doubt that Dexter would ever consider taking the dog. Plus, in DC universe, Velma is top 2 detective (only behind Batman)
Password?
monkeyballs4329
Password123!
Say my name...
EnwardThief6990
Fidelio
1:35 bro I just started watching supernatural a couple weeks ago and I’m hooked I’m already on season 7 honestly it’s probably my favorite show
You should do a part 2 with Alex Mahone from Prison Break and Mike Ehrmantraut from Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul
Tbh it wouldnt even take batman a long time to put dexter away. Nigh-omniscient beings have asked him for help on investigations and have complimented his detective skills
Pretty sure it's a crime you didn't add classic characters like Monk, John Smith from the Dead Zone, Shawn from Psych, etc.
Do... do I desperately need a Psych/Dexter crossover?
Dexter- "I would've gotten away with it if it wasn't for you meddling kids!"
they would also have to find dexters victims bagged in the ocean and then find evidence to say its dexter
@@MinajIsQueen Batman “hey Aquaman “
I mean I think in this tier list we have to assume that we are in the point of the show where everyone knows there is a killer. In my head canon its like they find these bags and they have no evidence that points anywhere and they are just calling in the who's who of detectives. And it's just a rat race of these people trying to find out who the bay harbor butcher is. lol
Need I remind you that Batman just so happens to be friends with the literal king of Atlantis (Who reminder is actually STUPID powerful, like its insane how powerful Aquaman actually is)
@@HallowedKeeper_ yes i know that but some of the other guys might not find dexters body bags
3:49 Dexter doesn’t really leave a crime scene
Did you forget about lundy
@ I mean once or twice vs hundreds of kills
3:54 I don’t know much about the character being explained but I do know a decent amount about Dexter and I know that Dexter doesn’t leave a crime scene, if u go back to S2, the bodies that were found under the ocean were obviously not at a crime scene so wouldn’t that mean that this detective in question wouldn’t be able to reenact how the victim died because they were chopped up in the bottom of the ocean?
Dexter would be a teched up antihero. Like a DC Punisher/mixed with Batman, if he could get someone to hook him up with the tech stuff. Like a "sponsor" for his "activities" from someone who thinks Batman doesn't go far enough.