Thats because old content is Star Wars they tried new stuff but it was all pretty terrible. But when they do the older content stuff it's very successful. They do have many of opportunities to do different stuff if they did the High Republic they can even use didn't force powers that were banned or forgotten by the original movies timeline hell if Rian Johnson did what he tried in the Last Jedi in the High Republic he would've been herald as a genius but instead he tried to mess with a 9 movie series spanning decades and changing things how he saw fit which really screwed the Rise of Skywalker chances badly.
@@ElvusmiwOr the goddamn clone wars lol live action clone wars seem like a waste yet again. Legends had golden content with Luke Skywalker and his jedi order and son going through multiple wars against gods, sith orders, civil wars between Skywalkers, outer galactic savage alien threats all with immense character development and collateral damage across the galaxy. Whoever was in charge of ignoring that and decided to start from scratch is the biggest tragedy for starwars.
Natalie Portman said she wasn't interested in returning to Star Wars so Padme would also probably have to be recast. And it would be weird seeing Hayden as Anakin but a different actor as Padme.
Man I hate when people kill off important characters off screen. That’s one of the biggest flaws in Star Wars. I always go by the rule: if you don’t see them be killed then they’re not dead (especially if they’re an important character).
@@iiDTC Windu's a gray area. While yes Jedi can use the force to slow falls, Mace was heavily electrocuted as he fell and may not have been conscious enough to use that ability. And a fall that far would not be survivable.
Clone Wars live-action show not only brings the Prequel cast together--especially Hayden and Ewan--but it also allows for massive world building in live-action. The world building in animated Clone Wars was incredible, beyond anything seen before or since. So a live-action Clone Wars would become a foundation for the other live-action shows to follow. By bringing back young Ahsoka, they would give Rosario Dawson's Ahsoka some context, since so many people tuned out because they had no idea who she was. People still have a thing against animation, so live-action Clone Wars draws in not only the built-in animated audience but new audiences only interested in live-action. It's just a smart business decision for Disney, as long as they have the right people making it and stop getting into divisive identity politics etc.
I’m perfectly fine with never having a live action clone wars. We already have an animated series I don’t see any reason to go back pedaling again. I’d be nice to just focus on a completely new timeline that has nothing to do with the clone wars or the original trilogy.
While I'm down for more clone wars live action after seeing it actually done proper already, it would be better utilized in a Kenobi season 2 with more emphasis on flashbacks and his PTSD.
0:55 …idk man lol… u want math… here’s math… unless we follow one of the other jedi who aren’t Anakin obi or Ahsoka thru this series, almost the entirety of the significan clone wars era stories were already told
Ive had some sort of problem with basically every project disney has put out except andor and the jedi games. Everything else has had some sort of problem with its writing (the most integral part) that I can no longer get excited for future projects
I think about new animated a clone rebellion series, but the series where Rex and Cody was tearing apart because of that, it making Captain Rex series and Commander Cody series, two new animated series, both series are A Clone Rebellion series.
Honestly most of these cons can be avoided by, instead of doing a Live Action of The Clone Wars, creating a Live action Republic Commando show. 1.) The Main Clone Commando's could be voiced/played by Temuera Morrison but you could have Dee Bradley Baker playing the Agent whose providing the Clones with their intel for the mission. 2.) You can get around Christopher Lee not being able to reprise his role as Count Dooku but you could have Corey Burton (Dooku's voice in The Clone Wars) for when you have Dooku issuing command to his troops via transmission if you want to include him in some way. 3.) The overarching story could be about these commandos trying to find Darth Maul on Ord Mantell. They could even use the Son of Dathomir story as a base. This would have Mace Windu being the overall commander in the fight to get Samuel Jackson back, you could have the Jedi General of this said commando group be Kelleran Beq so you have Ahmed Best in the show. The only downside of using this arc would be Count Dooku not appearing but they could do a small retcon and have it be Grievous that's there and not Dooku if they really didn't want to recast for Dooku 4.) Because it would just be around a small Commando group of Clones, Disney wouldn't be aiming to go too over the top at the beginning. And, if they use the Son of Dathomir as a base for the story, then they wouldn't have to worry about making the story from scratch 5.) It could be the first inclusion of Scorch in Live Action so we see how he was during the Clone Wars prior to when he shows up in the Bad Batch as an antagonist. Allowing a greater impact on his character 6.) As the Son of Dathomir arc would be taking place near the end of the Clone Wars, they can use that as a starting off point but then transition to Imperial Commandos as the Empire is being formed. Telling more story between RotS and ANH so they aren't as pigeon-toed as they would be if they go fully Clone Wars. Obviously these later potential seasons wouldn't have Mace Windu anymore but the story could be about these commandos trying to find Kelleran Beq or something so we know what happened to him after he parted ways with Grogu. If they go this route, the clones could still be hunting Maul as we know he's still around via Rebels/Solo. Or, if they don't want to tell the story from the clones perspective because they would be telling the villain's story, they could just make Kelleran the main protaganist of the show and then the later seasons is mostly his story with the commando's coming back now and again as antagonists. You could even throw Darth Vader in here at some point when he gets cornered (lets face it, Disney would 100% end up throwing Vader in regardless....) The only Con you mentioned that likely would still exist would be the action sequences that you mentioned before but, as much as there were issues with the Acolyte, the action sequences were pretty solid for the most part so Disney may be getting better in this aspect. In addition, this type of story wouldn't necessarily focus around lightsabers as much so the action might not look as bad overall in general and, if Kelleran Beq is a main focus, Ahmed Best already showed in The Mandalorian that he wasn't terrible when it came to action scenes. That being said, it is still Disney, and this Con may still be present but that'll be the case in any Star Wars show that's made so I don't really count it against this idea specifically. Keep in mind, I'm also making this idea as if it's starting at the Son of Dathomir point. You could theoretically start the show earlier where it's just the Clone Commandos as their originally cadets and working up from there (think Domino Squad arc in the Clone Wars but not necessarily with only 2 surviving for a long amount of time). It's just, if you go this route, it might not make sense to have Maul in as early so, if you wanted him in season 1, it'd make more sense to start at the Son of Dathomir.
I think there's a 0% chance of a live-action Clone Wars SERIES which is probably for the best. Such a thing would take years to pull together and none of the original cast are getting any younger; de-aging and re-casting have already proven a mixed bag for Star Wars. Also as pointed out as part of your Cons list, Disney's track record regarding plots/scripts and action sequences for their tv series has been spotty as well. That said, if they wanted to do a singular FILM set during the Clone Wars maybe they could over come those things with some solid focus and funding but I wouldn't hold my breath on that.
Ok. I disagree with someone thrown through a window at hights that high or decapitated is a bit of a stretch. I'm 61 years old and saw the original series and one someone jedi or not,Well like I said BIG STRETCH Especially seance someone was killed that was it. Revival never mentioned until the new prequels.
Well it’s been stated a multitude of times in different Star Wars media from older legends comics to new comic, the prequels, games, books and other stuff that Jedi can survive falls from incredible heights, and can enhance their body with the force to increase speed, strength, sight, and other aspects (we see this in the first bit of phantom menace, where obi won and qui gon speed down the hallway to fight Droids), so to me personally I think it’s entirely possible mace windu survived, I think it’s more likely he’s dead, but I remember watching the prequels as a kid and being convinced he was still alive, and I admit I still hold a bit of that sentiment now, there’s even a clip from some interview with Sam Jackson where he said he told George he thinks mace windu is still alive and didn’t want the character to be dead and George was like “sure, mace could still be alive, it’s very well possible”
I would love it. But I don't think it is even possible. Not just because some actors have sadly passed, but because the ones that are still around are now 20 years older. You can only do so much with Makeup, add in all the deaging to have the entire main cast deaged ALL THE TIME, would be prohibitivly expensive.
I know some people prefer live action remakes over cartoons but I don't think live action has anything to add to Clone Wars. The Jedi at their best and most powerful in the middle of a massive war is a story best told through cartoon.
I don't think they should do it. Con #2 outweighs all of the pros. Also, the actors are getting too old to play themselves from 20 years ago. You're going to have to use de-aging technology in every scene, and it's going to look jank AF.
What about a post-Order66 Mace Windu live action series? I'd rather see Samuel Jackson as he is, not deepfaked to be younger, although that often does look good too.
SW is bland currently and stuck on the Skywalkers for some reason and that leads to its absurd stagnation and lack of creativity. Disney is garbage and GL should have never sold the franchise to a company that focuses more on its ideology rather than creating a good product (SW) similar to how 343 Studios was to the Halo franchise. The crazy part is that Jedi and Sith alike survive falls even from great heights, so why now is this an issue!?
My biggest issue with Star Wars is the constant recycling of old content, Star Wars is creatively bankrupt in my eyes.
well thats bc the new shit ppl dont like so idk
Thats because old content is Star Wars they tried new stuff but it was all pretty terrible. But when they do the older content stuff it's very successful. They do have many of opportunities to do different stuff if they did the High Republic they can even use didn't force powers that were banned or forgotten by the original movies timeline hell if Rian Johnson did what he tried in the Last Jedi in the High Republic he would've been herald as a genius but instead he tried to mess with a 9 movie series spanning decades and changing things how he saw fit which really screwed the Rise of Skywalker chances badly.
I agree. How many times are we gonna continue to use the empire.
😂😂😂😂😂
@@ElvusmiwOr the goddamn clone wars lol live action clone wars seem like a waste yet again. Legends had golden content with Luke Skywalker and his jedi order and son going through multiple wars against gods, sith orders, civil wars between Skywalkers, outer galactic savage alien threats all with immense character development and collateral damage across the galaxy. Whoever was in charge of ignoring that and decided to start from scratch is the biggest tragedy for starwars.
I’d love live action versions of Clone Wars episodes
“How come every time you fly, we CRASH?!”
“It’s not MY fault, it’s the SHIP!”
Pros: More Star Wars for fans
Cons: Disney
You hit the nail on the head
@@mintmartini100 yessirr
Natalie Portman said she wasn't interested in returning to Star Wars so Padme would also probably have to be recast. And it would be weird seeing Hayden as Anakin but a different actor as Padme.
OMG you have a human body, I thought you were a presence in the force.
Man I hate when people kill off important characters off screen. That’s one of the biggest flaws in Star Wars. I always go by the rule: if you don’t see them be killed then they’re not dead (especially if they’re an important character).
Mace Windu *cough* *cough*
@@iiDTC Windu's a gray area. While yes Jedi can use the force to slow falls, Mace was heavily electrocuted as he fell and may not have been conscious enough to use that ability. And a fall that far would not be survivable.
Disney will screw it yp
Yup
Just like everything else they touch.
Clone Wars live-action show not only brings the Prequel cast together--especially Hayden and Ewan--but it also allows for massive world building in live-action. The world building in animated Clone Wars was incredible, beyond anything seen before or since. So a live-action Clone Wars would become a foundation for the other live-action shows to follow. By bringing back young Ahsoka, they would give Rosario Dawson's Ahsoka some context, since so many people tuned out because they had no idea who she was. People still have a thing against animation, so live-action Clone Wars draws in not only the built-in animated audience but new audiences only interested in live-action. It's just a smart business decision for Disney, as long as they have the right people making it and stop getting into divisive identity politics etc.
I want clone wars as much as we can get it! Anyway we can get it!
Careful, they might inject it with disney cooties.
I’m perfectly fine with never having a live action clone wars.
We already have an animated series I don’t see any reason to go back pedaling again.
I’d be nice to just focus on a completely new timeline that has nothing to do with the clone wars or the original trilogy.
they could even put sam j into the current live action stuff cause again "I dont see a body"
While I'm down for more clone wars live action after seeing it actually done proper already, it would be better utilized in a Kenobi season 2 with more emphasis on flashbacks and his PTSD.
NO NO NO NO NO PLEASE NO LIVE ACTION CLONE WARS! 😫😫😫
Mace Windu still alive?
Emperor Palpatine would have fried Luke Skywalker, had the redeemed Jedi Anakin Skywalker not intervened!
Disney are going to screw this up again!
Star wars is dead. George knew he was killing his franchise when he handed it off to his retirement fund. ( Not blaming george I respect his decision)
However, this video is intriguing so i'll take it with a grain of salt or pepper and enjoy it.🎉
FACTS…|
0:55 …idk man lol… u want math… here’s math… unless we follow one of the other jedi who aren’t Anakin obi or Ahsoka thru this series, almost the entirety of the significan clone wars era stories were already told
Man I’d LOVE a live action clone wars
we just need a season 8 with all the unfinished arcs in animation n dat would be cool 💯. then a series that picks up after the bad batch ends
Ive had some sort of problem with basically every project disney has put out except andor and the jedi games. Everything else has had some sort of problem with its writing (the most integral part) that I can no longer get excited for future projects
Perfect age for playing Rex from rebels
I think about new animated a clone rebellion series, but the series where Rex and Cody was tearing apart because of that, it making Captain Rex series and Commander Cody series, two new animated series, both series are A Clone Rebellion series.
I still chase old games that i haven't played abd older books that i've missed. Thats it, i have zero hope for the future of Star Wars
Honestly most of these cons can be avoided by, instead of doing a Live Action of The Clone Wars, creating a Live action Republic Commando show.
1.) The Main Clone Commando's could be voiced/played by Temuera Morrison but you could have Dee Bradley Baker playing the Agent whose providing the Clones with their intel for the mission.
2.) You can get around Christopher Lee not being able to reprise his role as Count Dooku but you could have Corey Burton (Dooku's voice in The Clone Wars) for when you have Dooku issuing command to his troops via transmission if you want to include him in some way.
3.) The overarching story could be about these commandos trying to find Darth Maul on Ord Mantell. They could even use the Son of Dathomir story as a base. This would have Mace Windu being the overall commander in the fight to get Samuel Jackson back, you could have the Jedi General of this said commando group be Kelleran Beq so you have Ahmed Best in the show. The only downside of using this arc would be Count Dooku not appearing but they could do a small retcon and have it be Grievous that's there and not Dooku if they really didn't want to recast for Dooku
4.) Because it would just be around a small Commando group of Clones, Disney wouldn't be aiming to go too over the top at the beginning. And, if they use the Son of Dathomir as a base for the story, then they wouldn't have to worry about making the story from scratch
5.) It could be the first inclusion of Scorch in Live Action so we see how he was during the Clone Wars prior to when he shows up in the Bad Batch as an antagonist. Allowing a greater impact on his character
6.) As the Son of Dathomir arc would be taking place near the end of the Clone Wars, they can use that as a starting off point but then transition to Imperial Commandos as the Empire is being formed. Telling more story between RotS and ANH so they aren't as pigeon-toed as they would be if they go fully Clone Wars. Obviously these later potential seasons wouldn't have Mace Windu anymore but the story could be about these commandos trying to find Kelleran Beq or something so we know what happened to him after he parted ways with Grogu. If they go this route, the clones could still be hunting Maul as we know he's still around via Rebels/Solo.
Or, if they don't want to tell the story from the clones perspective because they would be telling the villain's story, they could just make Kelleran the main protaganist of the show and then the later seasons is mostly his story with the commando's coming back now and again as antagonists. You could even throw Darth Vader in here at some point when he gets cornered (lets face it, Disney would 100% end up throwing Vader in regardless....)
The only Con you mentioned that likely would still exist would be the action sequences that you mentioned before but, as much as there were issues with the Acolyte, the action sequences were pretty solid for the most part so Disney may be getting better in this aspect. In addition, this type of story wouldn't necessarily focus around lightsabers as much so the action might not look as bad overall in general and, if Kelleran Beq is a main focus, Ahmed Best already showed in The Mandalorian that he wasn't terrible when it came to action scenes. That being said, it is still Disney, and this Con may still be present but that'll be the case in any Star Wars show that's made so I don't really count it against this idea specifically.
Keep in mind, I'm also making this idea as if it's starting at the Son of Dathomir point. You could theoretically start the show earlier where it's just the Clone Commandos as their originally cadets and working up from there (think Domino Squad arc in the Clone Wars but not necessarily with only 2 surviving for a long amount of time). It's just, if you go this route, it might not make sense to have Maul in as early so, if you wanted him in season 1, it'd make more sense to start at the Son of Dathomir.
I think there's a 0% chance of a live-action Clone Wars SERIES which is probably for the best. Such a thing would take years to pull together and none of the original cast are getting any younger; de-aging and re-casting have already proven a mixed bag for Star Wars. Also as pointed out as part of your Cons list, Disney's track record regarding plots/scripts and action sequences for their tv series has been spotty as well. That said, if they wanted to do a singular FILM set during the Clone Wars maybe they could over come those things with some solid focus and funding but I wouldn't hold my breath on that.
You seem to be forgetting, this is Disney. They do not have an impressive track record. Especially when it comes to Star Wars.
I'm sorry but Dave Filoni has fallen to the dark side and I don't even trust him with a live action star wars project at this point.
I’ve been saying this brother, great video!
Ok. I disagree with someone thrown through a window at hights that high or decapitated is a bit of a stretch. I'm 61 years old and saw the original series and one someone jedi or not,Well like I said BIG STRETCH Especially seance someone was killed that was it. Revival never mentioned until the new prequels.
Well it’s been stated a multitude of times in different Star Wars media from older legends comics to new comic, the prequels, games, books and other stuff that Jedi can survive falls from incredible heights, and can enhance their body with the force to increase speed, strength, sight, and other aspects (we see this in the first bit of phantom menace, where obi won and qui gon speed down the hallway to fight Droids), so to me personally I think it’s entirely possible mace windu survived, I think it’s more likely he’s dead, but I remember watching the prequels as a kid and being convinced he was still alive, and I admit I still hold a bit of that sentiment now, there’s even a clip from some interview with Sam Jackson where he said he told George he thinks mace windu is still alive and didn’t want the character to be dead and George was like “sure, mace could still be alive, it’s very well possible”
I would love it.
But I don't think it is even possible. Not just because some actors have sadly passed, but because the ones that are still around are now 20 years older. You can only do so much with Makeup, add in all the deaging to have the entire main cast deaged ALL THE TIME, would be prohibitivly expensive.
I know some people prefer live action remakes over cartoons but I don't think live action has anything to add to Clone Wars. The Jedi at their best and most powerful in the middle of a massive war is a story best told through cartoon.
I don't think they should do it. Con #2 outweighs all of the pros. Also, the actors are getting too old to play themselves from 20 years ago. You're going to have to use de-aging technology in every scene, and it's going to look jank AF.
The Clone Wars was the best thing to come out of a shit situation...but it was only a 75% out of 100% in most cases.
dont let them ruin clone wars please
Dissny obi one show we seen the body floting in the tank😅
What about a post-Order66 Mace Windu live action series?
I'd rather see Samuel Jackson as he is, not deepfaked to be younger, although that often does look good too.
Mace Windu is confirmed dead in Ep 9 with his spirit voice to Rey
Right! The Man is dead. Palpatine threw him out the damn window. I love how Disney just has to mess up everything.
he could have died at any point between episode 3 and episode 9 💀 that doesnt prove anything
@@drkdriveand? someone with the force can basically take no fall damage when they are conscious, they use the force to slow themselves down.
@@drkdrive Disney did literally nothing but confirm he was dead by Episode IX, lol
@@ignisinfernal1843 he could have survived the fall and have died due to old age
No need to de-age Samuel Jackson You know what they say black dont crack lol
A face to the name nice. What’s your ethnicity?
AMEN!!!!! Please 🙏🏽👍🏽💯
Nooooooooooooooooo
SW is bland currently and stuck on the Skywalkers for some reason and that leads to its absurd stagnation and lack of creativity. Disney is garbage and GL should have never sold the franchise to a company that focuses more on its ideology rather than creating a good product (SW) similar to how 343 Studios was to the Halo franchise. The crazy part is that Jedi and Sith alike survive falls even from great heights, so why now is this an issue!?
Live action SUCKS