La meilleure version! sans commentaire! sensibilité,toucher,phrasé,analyse de la pièce,équilibre,tempo,caractère,technique, tout y est! absolument tout! quelle artiste!!!
hace años y años que escucho a excelentes pianistas de todo el mundo interpretando a Beethoven,.- Es la primera vez que escucho, y no se como se me pasó, esta magnífica visión que da María Pires de ésta Sonata.- Siempre me opongo a las irritantes comparaciones pero no encuentro otra.- Es como "escuchar!" los frescos de la Sixtina después de su restauración.-
I agree. Blown away by her playing. I wish she had played more Bach. As far as I can tell on TH-cam, she plays one each on the 6 English and French suites and partitas. They're all heavenly. Her English Suite No. 3 is perfection -- along with her Schubert, Mozart, Chopin....
Very expressive, sensitive and melodic.Lovely dynamic range. There's no doubting it; Maria lets Beethoven's score speak for itself - no selfish melodramatic demonstrations as so many pianists do when trying to place their mark on this sonata. The third movement just flows and the gentle parts are so gently executed. Beautiful! This is truly music for music's sake. Thanks for uploading.
*Beautifully performance Sonata No. 17 ♫❤ Recently I watched an interview with Maria João Pires, and I realized that it was not only an outstanding musician and pianist, but also a wonderful person with great wisdom and pleasant disposition. ツThank you greetings from Poland*
Yes! The key pressure is perfection. I adore Pires ❤ Her rendition of Bach's English Suite No. 3 is astonishing to me. And her Mozart, and her Chopin.....
En dialogo continuo fluye el pensamiento entregando imágenes perfectas cuando, sublime el pensamiento genera formas y paisajes. Se sostiene el impacto producido en su momento, se percibe el sentimiento, la brisa, la palabra y el suspiro se capta. Bellísimo
This is a good reference. I don't always agree with her view of certain music, especially her Chopin, but here, listening to the Allegretto (last movement) of The Tempest, I'm glad to hear her not "banging" the keyboard as so many pianists do on the last movement of The Tempest. A very nice performance.
This, and the rhapsody in blue are my two goals as to what I want to play on piano. My teacher just ordered this so I can start to learn it but rhapsody may be a little into the future. I will do it though. And my music will be heard by people just like you guys someday.
Sorry, my little baby boy hit that button because I was playing it too loud and it interfered with his Justin Beeber concert.... But I did hit the up button to compensate.
Maria has such a good interpretation for this piece! Her style is different from Daniel Barenboim's and they are both lovely. It's very interesting to discover different understanding from different musicians. Bravo!
If you have the Schnabel editions (or even the Schirmers edition), the Beethoven piano sonatas, they are split between 2 books. This one is the last sonata in Book 1.
The opus 31. no. 2 "Tempest" is the 17th sonata by order of listing. By order of completion, this would be ranked 20th. The opus 49 no. 1 and 2 Sonatas 19 and 20) were composed five or six years earlier, and Beethoven completed Opus 31. no. 3 (listed number 18) before he completed this one.
I just have 2 reservations: The 1st is the speed of the opening arpeggio in the 1st&2nd movements. I feel they're too rapid. My 2nd reservation are the turns in the 2nd movement (see 10th bar). Beethoven was very specific; an 8th note tied to a 32nd note followed by a triplet of 64th notes, ending in two ascending 32nd notes; the 1st of these last 2 notes is not a dotted 32nd followed by a 64th as Maria plays it. Listen to Richter & Pollini play it & you'll see. I still adore Pires' performance!
Er, well...it is the 17th out of Beethoven's 32 piano sonatas. It was published as part of his Op. 31, which is a set of three piano sonatas. It is the second sonata in that set, hence "Op. 31, No. 2". It' really not that complicated.
@Bill Alexander I am so happy that I am not a musicologist and just listen to the music instead of being masturbating my mind with minimal details and comparing this interpretation with that of any other player.
Not my taste at all! Listen to Hélène Grimaud much better, IMHO! Solomon (Cutner), Wilhelm Backhaus and Friedrich Gulda are "my" Beethoven pianists! Just compare
MusikPiratCH à tout vouloir comparer, on finit par passer à côté du meilleur de chacun de ces magnifiques interprètes et Maria João Pires en fait partie servant la musique des compositeurs avec cet immense talent !
***** I see, it's just the way I heard and I'm used to play. I don't know why people get angry and say things like " what a modesty". I'm very humble when it comes to not knowing, I'm very aware of just how little I know in this world, it's something that defines me. Nevertheless, I prefer my way of playing that specific part...
Francisco Pinto Oh, I wasn't that angry you know, but your comment could tend to be misunderstood (like: "I play it better"), which wasn't apparently the case actually. Maybe I should have added a smiley :)
Yes, very dynamic and passionate. She can produce any piano pieces as exactly written. She has a very immense ability of retelling the story.
ポリーニのテンペストを聴いて、完璧な演奏だと思った。でも、解釈を極限まで高めた作りものの様にも感じた。初めてリヒテルの演奏を聴いた時、Beethoven に、こんな美しい曲があったんだと知らされて、それからBeethoven の聴き方が変わった。そして、川の流れの様な、澱みのないピリスの演奏！癒されます。
La meilleure version! sans commentaire! sensibilité,toucher,phrasé,analyse de la pièce,équilibre,tempo,caractère,technique, tout y est! absolument tout! quelle artiste!!!
Vous avez raison, c'est presque trop parfait !
Rendering more than great justice to a really difficult but absolutely beautiful musical creation by Beethoven.
Eccezionale Maria Joao Pires, tra le più grandi del mondo!
Sublime, just Sublime♥♥♥♥♥♥♥she made this sonata hers 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Excelente. Magnífico concepto del ritmo, tan descuidado por los concertistas clásicos. Bravissima...!!!
hace años y años que escucho a excelentes pianistas de todo el mundo interpretando a Beethoven,.- Es la primera vez que escucho, y no se como se me pasó, esta magnífica visión que da María Pires de ésta Sonata.- Siempre me opongo a las irritantes comparaciones pero no encuentro otra.- Es como "escuchar!" los frescos de la Sixtina después de su restauración.-
no doubt, imho she is the best living classic piano player. no exhibitionism, no frills. love her.
I agree. Blown away by her playing. I wish she had played more Bach. As far as I can tell on TH-cam, she plays one each on the 6 English and French suites and partitas. They're all heavenly. Her English Suite No. 3 is perfection -- along with her Schubert, Mozart, Chopin....
Maria, you are a miracle.
One of the best renditions ever!!
Elegante e misurata nella forma. Toccante nell'interpretazione composta e senza sbavature
Very expressive, sensitive and melodic.Lovely dynamic range. There's no doubting it; Maria lets Beethoven's score speak for itself - no selfish melodramatic demonstrations as so many pianists do when trying to place their mark on this sonata. The third movement just flows and the gentle parts are so gently executed. Beautiful! This is truly music for music's sake. Thanks for uploading.
Tout est bien , Maria égale à elle même, une grande musicienne.
Totalmente de acuerdo.
extraordinaire Maria J.Pires:elle joue avec une grande humilité c'est la sa gloire;elle respecte avec amour ce qu'elle interprete
She is a wonder in live performance...this is beautiful playing here...
her approach to the first movement is clearly announcing opus 57.. the same statement of despair. Stunning.
*Beautifully performance Sonata No. 17 ♫❤ Recently I watched an interview with Maria João Pires, and I realized that it was not only an outstanding musician and pianist, but also a wonderful person with great wisdom and pleasant disposition. ツThank you greetings from Poland*
❤ Calidad. ❤
Fantastico. Gracias a youtube conocemos estos magníficos intérpretes. Cada día un nuevo descubrimiento.
The pace - the key pressure - perfection, as always from Pires
Yes! The key pressure is perfection. I adore Pires ❤ Her rendition of Bach's English Suite No. 3 is astonishing to me. And her Mozart, and her Chopin.....
Best one to play this sonata, so perfectly played.
Your rendition of 'The Tempest' is my favorite. Well done.
That third movement...astounding.
Fantastic!! Love Beethoven and Maria João!
Quelle sensibilité ! J'adore...
En dialogo continuo fluye el pensamiento entregando imágenes perfectas cuando, sublime el pensamiento genera formas y paisajes. Se sostiene el impacto producido en su momento, se percibe el sentimiento, la brisa, la palabra y el suspiro se capta. Bellísimo
Absolutely wonderful!
Excelente
Suavidade de som! Magia de teclas!
She plays like a goddess.
Right !!!
Food for the soul! Brilliant!
This is a good reference. I don't always agree with her view of certain music, especially her Chopin, but here, listening to the Allegretto (last movement) of The Tempest, I'm glad to hear her not "banging" the keyboard as so many pianists do on the last movement of The Tempest. A very nice performance.
This, and the rhapsody in blue are my two goals as to what I want to play on piano. My teacher just ordered this so I can start to learn it but rhapsody may be a little into the future. I will do it though. And my music will be heard by people just like you guys someday.
Finally! movement 3 played truly beautifully and not like a mechanical piece of crap :)
I can't believe someone actually disliked this. The nerve.
Sorry, my little baby boy hit that button because I was playing it too loud and it interfered with his Justin Beeber concert....
But I did hit the up button to compensate.
There is no accounting for taste,..those who have none,are usually, also crass enough to tell you.
Me too
Lynne😁
Maria has such a good interpretation for this piece! Her style is different from Daniel Barenboim's and they are both lovely. It's very interesting to discover different understanding from different musicians. Bravo!
Wonderful
I love this song.... It's just beautiful. She plays it impeccably. Bravo. My favorite is the way she plays the third movement.
If you have the Schnabel editions (or even the Schirmers edition), the Beethoven piano sonatas, they are split between 2 books. This one is the last sonata in Book 1.
Excellent!
AMAZING!!!!!!
Oh wow!!!!!
Wollte nur mal einen DEUTSCHEN Kommentar zwischenschieben: Beethoven is genial!
Mußkeiner Wissen endlich mal ein richtiger DEUTSCHER😂
Well done! Just what I needed after a rather long day.
magistral
Maria João Pires 👍👍👍
ADORABLE!
Bravo!
The opus 31. no. 2 "Tempest" is the 17th sonata by order of listing. By order of completion, this would be ranked 20th. The opus 49 no. 1 and 2 Sonatas 19 and 20) were composed five or six years earlier, and Beethoven completed Opus 31. no. 3 (listed number 18) before he completed this one.
I just have 2 reservations: The 1st is the speed of the opening arpeggio in the 1st&2nd movements. I feel they're too rapid. My 2nd reservation are the turns in the 2nd movement (see 10th bar). Beethoven was very specific; an 8th note tied to a 32nd note followed by a triplet of 64th notes, ending in two ascending 32nd notes; the 1st of these last 2 notes is not a dotted 32nd followed by a 64th as Maria plays it. Listen to Richter & Pollini play it & you'll see. I still adore Pires' performance!
excellent!
Great!
It makes me want to read The Tempest of Shakespeare.
감동스러워요!
들으면 행복하고 차분해지는 피아노 그래서 포루투칼을 여행을 갔다 그곳도 훌륭했다 음악 시디를 사면서 얼마나 기쁜지...
🌺🌿💐🌷🥀
The allegretto is really pretty.
❣️ 🎹 🌈
Er, well...it is the 17th out of Beethoven's 32 piano sonatas. It was published as part of his Op. 31, which is a set of three piano sonatas. It is the second sonata in that set, hence "Op. 31, No. 2". It' really not that complicated.
0:00 - Largo - Allegro
08:45 - Adagio
16:06 - Allegretto
MJP vc. faz o piano cantar!!! Vc. é brilhante.
You Are Lucky My Friend My Mobile Battery Is 57% Only And That Prayer Would Go On For 2 Hours
РАСПРАВИВ КРЫЛЬЯ
НАД МОРЕМ ГОРЯ 🌠🔥
МЕТЕОРОМ ПРОНЕСТИСЬ
@Bill Alexander I am so happy that I am not a musicologist and just listen to the music instead of being masturbating my mind with minimal details and comparing this interpretation with that of any other player.
I'm sorry,but I don't get your description. Is it number 17 or number 2 ? I know for sure it's op 31 no 2. Something does not add up.
I don't miss Backhaus here at all
Zetsuen no Tempest
3rd movement @ 16:..
16:06
Not my taste at all! Listen to Hélène Grimaud much better, IMHO!
Solomon (Cutner), Wilhelm Backhaus and Friedrich Gulda are "my" Beethoven pianists!
Just compare
MusikPiratCH à tout vouloir comparer, on finit par passer à côté du meilleur de chacun de ces magnifiques interprètes et Maria João Pires en fait partie servant la musique des compositeurs avec cet immense talent !
I prefer my way of playing it xD
she's too slow for me in some parts where I want to feel the storm..
What a modesty...
***** Really?
***** I see, it's just the way I heard and I'm used to play.
I don't know why people get angry and say things like " what a modesty".
I'm very humble when it comes to not knowing, I'm very aware of just how little I know in this world, it's something that defines me.
Nevertheless, I prefer my way of playing that specific part...
Francisco Pinto Oh, I wasn't that angry you know, but your comment could tend to be misunderstood (like: "I play it better"), which wasn't apparently the case actually. Maybe I should have added a smiley :)
***** :) ok sry
Hm, maybe a bit too restrained - Ludmilla Beethoven, perhaps.