What if the Weimar Republic SURVIVED?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2024
- Do you believe that if the Weimar Republic survived, which also means that Germany doesn’t become ultranationalist and expansionist power, that the Second World War would be prevented?
I want to explore this question, but also give you a realistic answer on how the Weimar Republic could have survived and thrived in the 1930s and 40s.
▬ LINKS ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Discord Server - / discord
Patreon - / membership
TH-cam Membership - / @rewriting-history
Book - www.amazon.com...
[1] - epub.ub.uni-mu...
▬ Chanel Description▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
This channel is a haven for those who crave intellectual stimulation and love to ponder the profound "what ifs" of history. Join our passionate community of history enthusiasts, where engaging discussions and insightful commentaries fuel our collective imagination.
Subscribe now and embark on this enthralling adventure with us. Prepare to question, wonder, and discover as we navigate the corridors of time, peeling back the layers of history to reveal a tapestry of alternate paths and captivating possibilities.
Welcome aboard, fellow explorers of alternative history. Let's rewrite the past together!
Subscribe or my girlfriend will break up with me!
Jk jk
He is not joking, I can confirm that.
Unsubscribes😈
Nooooooo @@dulguunjargal1199
@@dulguunjargal1199 okay I leave him
@@dulguunjargal1199 look at what you did!
I think you really underestimated the threat of a communist takeover of Germany. Communist and Ultranationalists were literally fighting in the streets. Perhaps the SPD would control that, but the Communist threat was one of the main causes of the Ultranationalists both gaining support and taking power.
I don't think I underestimated the German communists. They at most got 10% of the votes, and since no party was willing to work with them, they would need to get 50% majority to form a government.
Them starting a civil war is possible, but I don't think they will win.
@@rewriting-history 1/10 people is still a lot. It would have been better had some counter action been taken to ensure the Communists didn’t take power somehow.
@@Dedelblute3The French commmunist party was two times bigger than the german one. They were also many political violence in France. So the communist threat in Germany was chimeric.
That's due to right wing propaganda. The communist were never even close to actually achieving anything in Germany. The fear of the communists was simply overexaggerated to obscurity so that the SPD could justify working with the former army (Ebert-Gröner Pakt).
I can recommend you the "fight for the Republic" podcast. It is bias towards the left but still historically accurate.
@@rewriting-historyincorrect, in 1932 they got 17% of the vote!
As a German, I would totally live in a world like this. Not only the technological advancements, but also eastern Germany including Silesia would've never lost their strong industrialization after the loss of World War 2. The economy would be a lot stronger due to that.
@@thatgermandaniel also Germans landing on the moon
@@rewriting-history Makes me question if there would've been a cold war in a scenario like this
@@thatgermandaniel maybe there is no cold war, or probably there is 4 way cold war
imperialist/old world(uk,fr)
capitalism(usa,other)
liberalism/social democracy(germany,neutral)
communism(ussr,other).
This Cold War happened because everyone have nuke
@@thatgermandanielprobably since like everyone hated communism and Stalin wanted to expand his influence, but it would be much shorter as the USSR is less strong and have much less influence in Europe
thumbnail remind me of those "I made 1000 people do civilization in minecraft"
I did steal the idea from there, I think it was a very nice fit!
Frfr it looks the same template
lmao
Same 😂
LMAOO 💀💀💀💀
Man this scenario makes me sad Germany could have had it so good but the Mustache Man had to ruin everything
Yes, it was a bit sad to see
I do not want to be ruled by a red party
While researching the Weimar Republic, I learned about this little known figure called Adolf. He had crazy nationalistic goals and I think you should do an alternate history where he takes over Germany
Seems a bit unrealistic, so I don't think I will go down this path. An ultranationalist party with 2% of the votes in 1928 starting a world war seems too impossible.
@@rewriting-history yeah but just imagine if somthing like I don't know france a Britain just keep letting him take land it may not be relistic but it would be a great alternate history
Weimar was jewish and gay and ungodly.
*German Reich(the official name), the term Weimar Republic was made by Nazis.
@@LokiSuttonyeah but all of that can only occur if Rhineland was militarized which would probably never occur
Peace was never an option
Unless???
@@rewriting-history UN is actually United Nations
Suggestion : What if the Treaty of Versailles was harsher?
The Saarland would be annexed by France, the Rhineland would be a French mandate, Silesia were given to Czechoslovakia, and Schleswig-Holstein would be given to Denmark.
Yes I've considered doing that, but also if it was less harsh. Expect such videos next month!
Still could be harsher. I might also give Danzig straight to Poland officially instead of doing the Free City compromise stuff, Poland hasn't been given additional territory in this example suggestion yet and they did miss out on Silesia there.
@@gengarzilla1685 True, lets give Poland Danzig, Pomerania, and the polish majority lands in East Prussia, The rest of East Prussia would be given to Lithuania.
Y'all have beef with Germany💀 I rather choose the 1400's border of Germany than what you all suggested
add independence of Bavaria, Hannover, Saxony
Suggestion: What if Austria won the brothers war?
Yes! I will do a lot of Austrian content soon!
@@rewriting-history LET'S GO!
@@danielsantiagourtado3430ph did a video on that already
@@mrcat5508this isn’t ph
LOVE YOUR CONTENT! Thanks For this 😊😊😊❤❤
I appreciate that very much, Daniel!
Revive Otto Von Bismarck, he surely will know what to do
Trueeee
That wouldn't mean a Democratic Weimar Germany though 🙃
@@talrick42Sacrificing democracy to revive Bismarck
@@Soronokei Hm.. well that's one way to look at it. 😅
@@talrick42Worth it
17:02 the Germans actually made the first picture of space in 1934/35 which was by Werner von Braun
What if it started in 1945, as Italy was supposed to protect Austria and stalin would still want Romania, and would be able to give up Yugoslavian land to Italy, see how unprepared France was
I think France would be pretty prepared for a war in 1945, but I didn't explore this scenario either way
Great video, I also like the geographical maps.
Glad you liked them! Will improve my maps in the future!
SDP is actually a music band in Germany lol
I wish I didn't mispronounce it every time lol
I think you should do a video where the treaties of Versailles and Trianon (and the rest I’ve forgot) were less harsh on the central powers
Versailles was everything but harsh. Trianon was a mess though
I really would want to see a part 2 of this scenario that would be focused on Africa and the consequences of decolonisation not happening
Could be another video, I got this suggestion a lot. Maybe next month you can expect something like that
This is a cool and unique alt history scenario. I like these type of ones ❤️!
I really appreciate that!
The Austrians proclaimed to be part of the German Republic in 1918. The state was called German-Austria. The allies forbade this self-determination and declared Anschlussverbot. Against the will of the Austrians and proper German peoples, who demanded reunification
Thx for the video i was searching for this video idea thank you
I'm glad you liked it!
these videos are really awesome dude, keep it up 👍
I really appreciate it!
Very nice video, as always.
Glad you had fun watching it!
YOO NEW VIDEO AND BETTER THUMBNAILS LETS GOO
Ayo I'm improving in all aspects! Always trying to get better!
That "appeasement" jumpscare me middle of the night 13:18
It was a bit too loud I think
I mean, wouldn't the soviets just industrialize even better than in our timeline? Like sure, they're of course much weaker, but they'll still support communists around the world (especially china, africa and india) and I don't see them collapsing in the 1960s
I don't think there would be much to rally for with the average person in the USSR. Barbarossa did many things for the USSR, mostly negative, and one of the few positives was embolden the totalitarian regime with a population fueled by fear of the outside through broad pluralistic nationalism. Without WW2, support for the regime quickly fissles up after the death of Stalin, to which Stalin would be less popular because there is no great achievement past the maintenance of the soviet system. I am going by drawing extrapolations from Stephen Kotkin.
Yes this is a good point, since the USSR this time won't be invaded and suffer so much damage in WW2. I think I neglected that aspect
Good job! Thank you.
Pretty good videos 👍
Thank you very much for the 5 Canadian and I'm glad that you like the videos! This one just got out!
@@rewriting-historyI think you meant 5 canadian dollars but I'd like to think that you got 5 canadian men as a donation 👀
@@thatvexiolNAHH💀💀
As a German…
This is the blessed timeline
Germans on the moon 🌝
possible germany now would be a weltmacht when that happends some organisation like the eu would fist founded by germany and we dont have like now an icompetent regiem
edit: and danzig possible gets integr
What if the Weimar Republic survived? So in other words: "What if the USA enforced a moderate treaty after WWI and invested into rebuilding Europe like they did after WWII"
That would also be really cool if it were to happen
To clarify, this basically would have been the only way to prevent the rise of extremism in the Weimar Republic. With the treaty of Versailles there was no chance for reconciliation with the western allies.
The moment he mentioned that Lithuania would be free, I thought this was heaven.
Based
Loves the vid!
Glad you liked it!
Suggestion: What if Ukraine and Belarus also the Baltics was independent after WW1?
Squidward Plot: Its an Orgin Movie about Squidward,Squidward is Recruited by Thanos Trains and Fights the Villain Lebron James,Post Credits Scene Minecraft Obsidian Gets recruited by Thanos and Forms the Black Legion of Thanos Dickriders,Act 1 the Bikini Bottom gets attacked only survivors are Squidward Pattrick Spongebob and Mr krab,Squidward gets recruited by Thanos the Rest Stay Act:2 Squidward Trains after that Squidward and Thanos attack a Lakers Base and gets ambushed Thanos is Captured to let Squidward Escape Act 3:After Escaping Squidward Gathers the Rest of Thanos Army and Assaults Lakers Capital Final Battle happens Lebron James gains the Upper Hand until Spongebob Mr Krabs and Patrick joins the Fight and Together Beats Lebron and Frees Thanos the End
Based
Great video, but i was let down by one thing - not mentioning how it would impact Poland - it was right in the middle between soviets and germans and suffered a coup in the 1920s, I figured their policy might have pivoted towards building an mutual assistance pact with the romanians agaist the soviets, as the germany would be more willing to cooperate
Well I cannot mention every country, but maybe I really should have mentioned them at least once regarding their position in the world
Since I'm pretty German biased and also have created own positive democratic scenarios of germany all the time, I have to say. I think I actually would like to live in this world. With the more nice looking border of germany, sure 😇
As long as really nothing happens 😐
I really appreciate that you enjoyed this scenario!
please make a full What if the French invasion of Honolulu Succeeded on 1849, from that short you did a time a go, it would be awesome to see a full what if of this scenario so interesting
The short didn't gain a lot of views, so I don't think the video will do too well
@@rewriting-history 😭 comon, well at least give it a chance, videos get more views than shorts....... I guess
@@rubenfigueiredo4229 i better make a video on a short that has the most views, rather than least
@@rewriting-history ok
I love this video because someone else made one on this scenario, but unfortunately they were the type of person to call the horrible living standards in weimar "far right propoganda" in stark contrast to you, who is way more unbiased when researching
I tried my best, still I admit there was bias against communism. I made a big mistake to say that the USSR would collapse in the 1960s. I admit I was wrong because the USSR never had 15 million people die in WW2 and etc. We should have a stronger USSR than in our timeline.
I am from Bulgaria and I didn't mention the country once, so my bias is not showing. Always trying to be unbiased
Very interesting
Really glad you liked it!
I could see if Lithuania was invaded by the soviets, Poland and Germany could have an agreement with their troops moving into Memel and Vilnius to protect the Germans and Polish of the respected cities.
With the soviets invading the Baltics. IMO it wouldnt be hard to imagine such an alliance if Britain and France are slow to rearm ( slower than OTL). If such an alliance were to happen, what would happen with Danzig?
What if Rewriting history went viral and got over 50k subscribers in 2022-2023?
So starting 2 years earlier pretty much? :D
@@rewriting-historyyeah basically
I think that the Soviets would probably survive till the modern day without the loss of 15 million people and the devestation of most of their country, the Cold war in this Timeline could probably be a Europe VS USSR, since the US stays isolationist, with the soviets suporting communists in places such as Latin America, Africa and in Asia
Yes I think I neglected the USSR, so looking back at it, I don't think they will collapse in the 1960s
The decolonization of the French and British Empires would have been somehow different than in real life: The US and USSR might have stilled pressed for it. Germany (less determined) aswell, because why not - being anti-colonist is easier if you do not have colonies. 🙂
(In fact it is interesting to see how West Germany acted during the Algerian War or the Suez Crisis the in our timeline: On one hand they did not want to alienate the French, on the other hand they had no reason to support colonialism and alienate the US)
Suggestion: What if ''The Painter'' got accepted to art school?
Well pretty much the same scenario
You always have money from the countries,but why only some mark why not 1.000.000 Mark from 1929😢
This inflated currency is hard to get ,at least in Bulgaria. I was surprised how many such banknotes were produced and how expensive they are. Maybe in Germany they are a lot cheaper
Have you considered italy and the ussr signing the pizza - sickle pact ( dividing europe between the 2)
Nice thumbnail
Ayyy I'm very glad you liked it!
I’d love this scenario
Glad you had fun with it!
I think the political situation in the Weimar republic had been very complicated and are often hard to comprehened for us today. The parliament had been hard to govern because there had been no restrictions by size for parties to join. The only big blocks had been the SPD and the center party which had been its foundation in catholicism. It had been Hitler's charism which united the splitted right and got the industrial money to finance him. So he need to go to have a chance with your scenario.
A successful coalition of center and socialists which would reach the mid 30s and needed a reform of the parliament to reduce the parties. With the Italian occupation of Abyssinia there might be the time of cooperation with France and UK which might result in a limited rearmament of army and navy and reintegration of Rhineland, Saarland and danzig into the Weimar republic for support against Italy. That would bring some conservatives and nationalists back into the fold.
Without Italian and German support the Franco upraising would undoubtly fail but it might lead to a conservative and maybe monarchist government in Spain.
And Italy's political isolation would lead to an end of the fashist rule maybe ba a conservative-catholic royal dictatorship like Yougoslavia.
Austria would be stay independent because it would have the growing German tourismn as income source.
A growing German economy would dominate Europe with a strong business relationship to many middle and eastern states in Europe via their German populations.
The greatest instability for peace would be again the Balcans where Yougoslavia would implode with great probability.
It's actually interesting. You didn't even put USSR as a crazy war demanding country, leaving them reasonable.
I think that considering their behaviour at the time, this is likely. Again, apesanent can go too far and a war would start, but then I extended the video by 10 minutes for something that may not happen
The Soviets falling in 1960s and the Japanese somehow winning the war against China are completely impossible.
For the Soviets, the war completely damaged their economy and population until these days. Thanks to the war, the Soviets needed 7-9 more years to surpass the economy and industrial power that they had at the beginning of 1941. For the population, it was even worse. Only after 1954, they could surpass the population that they had in 1941, 13 whole years! That is crazy! So, they would have been more powerful, but less influential in this timeline.
For the Japanese, the oil embargo made by the US would have crippled the war effort. Also, the USSR would have helped the chinese as Germany never attacked them in this scenario. So the Chinese wouldn't have surrendered that easily without fighting back. I even think that the Soviets would have gotten involved at some point.
I never claimed that Japan would win against China, they would sign a peace treaty and invade later. I do agree about the USSR and I changed my mind since the upload.
@@rewriting-history Oh! Then I apologize if that is the case. But I still think that the Chinese wouldn't have signed any peace treaty, at least not until 1943-45. Curiously, China didn't declare any war until 1941.
What if Napoleon instead of becoming the French Emperor helped Corsica to gain indipendence and unified Italy?
Real question with that though is would it even be possible Napoleon could Corsica even build the strength to do that alone especially with austria intrest in the region
All you had to do was to get rid of One man
(I love your videos btw)
I appreciate that!
Nice video, i have a suggestion, what if castille united with portugal instead of aragon
That's actually quite fascinating, a Castile-Portugal union that does Spain's typical thing across the Atlantic while Aragon keeps its attention on the Mediterranean.
@@gengarzilla1685 yeah, it was actually really close to happen in real life, since Elizabeth's father actually wanted her to marry the king of portugal instead of Ferdinand of Aragon
Cool idea, but my knowledge isn't there for this topic. I have been suggested this quite a lot
This video might have your best thumbnail…
Yeah the idea was amazing
I have a video idea "What if Četniks (monarchist movement against communism) won and took over in Yougoslavia after WW2 instead of Partizans" love your videos ❤
You end the video on an interesting note: The idea of the Germans leading the way into space.
Considering how enamored of space German figures who came to the US were, like Oberth and von Braun, having them and their colleagues giving the Weimar Republic a "feel good" big project that they can stir up a love for could lead to some interesting outcomes.
Say, they get Deutchland to the Moon by, oh 1960. With continued interest by and the promise of greater things to come for the Germans, some of the rocket folks' more ambitious plans may come to fruition: orbital bases around the time of the moon landing in 1960, first trips to Mars by 1975, asteroid mining by 1990, planting the flag on Io and Europa by 2010... We're talking some impressive gains that affects not just the map here, but our understanding of the solar system and beyond.
So, in answer to your question, yeah, this sounds like it'd be a *great* place to live...
16:07 that depends do they still invent the Internet because I believe it was World War II, which drove innervation for the basis for the Internet in the first place.
Yes I completely agree. The US army developed it as a way to communicate
@@rewriting-history I think if the US were to enter the war, the Germans and the Americans would work extensively to make superior tanks to the Germans
Sooner or later communication networks like the Internet would have happened anyway because the economy asks for fast communication:
Today when I send a ping from my private internet connection in Germany to whitehouse.gov the answer time is 15 milliseconds. 20 years ago it was probably around 150 milliseconds. It does not require wars to trigger technological advances. :) It requires people who believe they can make money.
I think it would still happen eventually, like how mobile phones and cars were created as consumer products
The yellow in the German flag is slightly longer than the rest of the colors
Because I wanted the coat of arms to be centered lol
Italy would for sure need to strike out and establish their own alliance bloc if they'd want to contest the Anglo-French-German trio but I'm not sure if they could get enough substantial local allies to create an even fight. Horthy's Hungary and Boris III's Bulgaria would likely at least consider an offer from the Italians, the Croatian rebels within Yugoslavia can still be co-opted to Italy's benefit, and Franco's Spain would be sympathetic even in the likely case of them remaining officially neutral, but there's no way this petty ragtag band of revanchists and nationalists could overturn the disadvantage Italy faces.
Where do you get all your maps from?
Some cool alt history I see , I like
I'm glad you liked it so far!
Without WW2 there wouldn't have been a reason or a fiscal excuse for such incredibly expensive projects as the atomic bomb, or even the V2. It's almost certain, that weapons would remain much less developed than in our timeline. The Red Army however underwent an unprecedented growth and rearming in the late 1930s. The totalitarian regime had an ideological justification for its aggressive and expensive intentions with disregard forhuman and financial costs. The USSR could have conquered some countries in case of appeasement and bring itself at the age of a world War.
True but the USSR would have probably suffered similar problems as the Axis in real-life if they attacked the "Locarno Treaties" countries UK, France and Germany.
a) Sooner or later the supplyment routes would have become too long.
b) France, Britain and the US might have helped the Germans out; in fact they would be even more likely to support a democratic Germany rather than having a communist Soviet Union reach the Rhine bank.
will u get demonetized if u dont say „austrian painter“ and „ultranationalist party“ or what is the reason?
Yes, this is why all your favorite youtubers do it. We don't want to, but we also want to earn money from it
@@rewriting-history I understand, it just seems weird.
Hey, i have a idea.
What if Germany never helped Italy against Greece?
I even have a few (although a bit unrealistic) ideas of how it could happen.
1.Italy loses against Ethiopia, so when Greece starts to enter Albania, Hitler loses all hope for Mussolini and see's him as useless.
2.Germany starts their battle against the Soviet Union way earlier, so they don't have time for Greece.
3.Hitler never gets power, and Germany dosen't become nationalist. So there is no Germany to help Greece.
*help against greece
For the first point you'd have to explain how Italy could have lost to Ethiopia, cause it was literally impossible, unless the allies joined in the war other than just sanctioning Italy, but that's so unlikely it's almost impossible too.
And even if Germany didn't help against Greece, all Italy needed to do was holding on for a little while, the Greek economy was collapsing and the Greeks didn't have any more troops, they were using all they had, Italy was using only a small part of their entire army.
The Italian royal army was busy in multiple fronts against the British, all it would have taken was to take a few troops from there and relocate them in Greece for a quick victory, but that would have meant a slightly worse performance in northern Africa, that would have also meant no occupation of the balkans and a Greece fully under italian occupation until the end of the war, so Athens wouldn't be under German infulence.
@@idk-cj8mn Fair points. As for them losing Ethiopia, the only sensible way i could see it happening is if either
1.The allies are EXTRA HARSH on Italy that they join in on the war so fascism is weaker.
2.Ethiopia promises them land if they help them against Italy.
Also, when i said:"What if Germany never helped Italy agaisnt Greece" i never said Greece would win. I more so just wanna know what the countries other reactions would be to Italy losing heavily against Greece, after them needing gas to take Ethiopia and their not very good invasion of Egypt.
In the end, i'm sure Italy would win with their full army, and maybe with the help of Bulgaria.
@@Bluestone775
Yeah, these are all fair points.
For Italy to lose against the Greeks they would need more than just the British sending troops like they did irl, maybe Yugoslavia could help them seeing the Greeks pushing into Albania.
Bulgaria was kinda forced by Germany to help if i remember correctly so i don't think they'd send troops.
Italy also only used gas on Ethiopia to speed things up, it wasn't really needed, but yes, the invasion of Egypt was kinda a disaster, that's what happens when you rush stuff instead of waiting for supplies ig lol.
@@idk-cj8mn yeah, i do think Yugoslavia would help against Italy, but i think that would most likely bring Germany into the war if we don't follow the scenario where Germany becomes Ultra-Nationalist because Yugoslavia would be a pretty large threat. Plus it would definetly bring Hungary in to get back their Croatian and Serbian lands. Same with Bulgaria and Macedonia.
9:30 you forgot our boy Ernst Rohm, he got killed by Hitler 😢
little mispelling at 11:34😅
Oh no, I have committed a crime against humanity!
the communists were very much a more prevelant issue, especially if the ultranationalists are gone
I understand, but they didn't get a lot more than 10% in the elections. Them starting a civil war is possible, but I don't think they will win. Germany becoming communist is unlikely I think
Do you accept suggestions for alt history vids?
Of course! Mostly from my discord, as this idea was suggested there! Join and give me your idea
United Germany, more technologically advanced and with a remaining East Prussia? Hell yeah!
And Germans on the moon!
plz make the video what would happen if kingdom
of yugoslavia survived
On first glance I cannot think of anything that would change the world if this were to happen
"Do you believe that if the Weimar Republi-"
"no"
Oh no
Glad you liked it!
Say many famous nazis that mat take over the party
Me: WHERE IS GOEBBLES?
Short answer: no war
If we're optimistic, yes
@@rewriting-history 🤣🤣🤣
Can't really see Estonia and Latvia going down that easily. It would be met with outcry from the estonians and latvians. Not to mention the reaction of the nordics as Estonia had good relations with Finland and Sweden and a GDP higher than Finland's (1938).
With it being appeasement this time around, there would be no Soviet-Estonian Mutual Assistance Treaty? And no Winter War? If Estonia and Latvia refuse this appeasement, I could see a war breaking out between the baltics and likely Finland too with the Soviets, thus forcing allies to send aid to the baltics aswell.
"Stalin ia not That stupid" i Beg you pardon, but we are Talking about the same Stalin who in the polish-soviet war chose to stupidly stand near lwów instead of help with attack on Warsaw polish capital, literally he waste communism chance to go over a polish dead body to West, germany, hangary, etc.
I understand that, but these were different times. He wanted to prove that he is worth something and rise the ranks of the communist party. Now that he is the leader, his behaviour would be different
I have a terrible sleep schedule, this was a good video very informative (communist Moldova when?)
Lol sorry for worsening your sleep schedule, didn't know my videos were so addictive! :D
@@rewriting-history it’s 11:08 right now I’m so tired anyway look forward to your content going forward since from your community post you’re gonna start focusing on other periods of time not just World War II
1. Make Versailles Less Extreme
2. that is it
I think what if Hungary revolted against Austria during ww1 would be intresting.
Now what if instead of hitler becoming leader of the party Himmler or Rudolf Hess Or Hermann Goering Or Joseph Goebbels or Ernst Rohm Became leader of The Party
This could be interesting, but I will step away from WW2 content, as the videos I make get demonetized a fair bit
100 days civilisation in minecraft ahh thumbnail
Weimar Republik did survive. The official state name of Germany since 1871 was German Reich. This remained so in 1918/19. Weimar was the city in which the new republican constitution was drafted, hence the nickname Weimar Republic. All laws that followed were still under this Weimar republican constitution. Germany didn’t become a monarchy again, when Hitler was elected Chancellor and a year later also assumed the presidency of the republic. The Allies suspended this Weimar constitution in 1945 and installed various other provisional basic laws, under which the land of still existing de jure Weimar Republic exists, now are de facto law.
The Hindenburg project survives? 👀
mh yes, it's real Germany Kaiser 100 time
Alternate title: if modern germany showed up in 1930
"Minecraft civilization simulation" ahh thumbnail
what if Rewriting History oiled up?
What
@@rewriting-history make it a short 🥺
Don't comment again, EVER
NEVER COMMENT EVER AGAIN
You're banned
What if Andorra won the Spanish Civil War 🗿
mmmm yes appeasent my favourite allied strategy
It totally works out great!
This alt hist is much better imo bc no communist Romania
Glad you liked it! Romania also has Bessarabia!
@@rewriting-history true
15:37 the hell 💀💀💀☠️☠️☠️
Shhhhh 🤫
Fun Fact. But in Weimar Republic, there was the first ever Trans Gender Clinic and in general, more equality for LGBT people living in Germany before the Nazi's came into power. So in this alternate time line where the Nazi's don't come into power, I can definitely see this progress of LGBT equality continuing on.
Didn't know that, it's super interesting to consider
what if germany became more and more successful after ww2? massive reforms and massive support within its nation, bigger economy and such.
basically, if germany locked in even more.
You forgot east Prussia on the thumbnail
I did not, it cannot fit and look good at the same time
@@rewriting-historyWrong!
Dear god that’s a long essay
The source?
The Thumbnail looked like it was in minecraft idk why
I did take inspiration from there
I think you are underestimating irredentism. As far as I am aware even weimar germany wanted to start a war in like 1940. While irredentism towards the allies may seize because of the cooperation and austria, the problem with danzig and other german majority lands in mostly the polish corridor still remains.
Poland wasnt very nice to germans you know. Anyway, even if we ignore the germans there, germany would still want to reclaim these lands as they were a core part of Prussia.
What if I wrote a comment under every Rewriting History video?
That would be based and very appropriated!
Tito whould come to power in buddist syria, that's what whould happen
@@fabianrolewski172
Facts
Suggestion: What If Mexico Accepted The Zimmermann Telegram?
Thank you, I saved it and will make a video probably next month!
truely the best timeline
minceraft ahh thumbnaill dawg