what you said about Carl is EXACTLY my thoughts on him. He’s my fav character hands-down, especially in the comics, but season 8 Carl ruined his character on so many levels. My fav era of Carl is s4 as I really believe they delved into the fact that he’s actually a child still and dealing with things as a child. But yeah, s8 was strange and the whole time i was effing and blinding at him for how he was suddenly preaching peace. 100 percent turned into a plot device by AMC to keep Negan alive as a character.
People hate when people complain about RJs acting and say he’s just a kid. But like, so many kids have been on TWD and have done far better acting in a short span of epidoes. Kids like Judith, Mika, Lizzie, Megan, Carl, Sophia, and many others have shown more emotion in one scene than RJ has in 2-3 seasons
Personally, I’d have put Carl much lower on my list. I just think he never stood his own on the show and instead was used as a plot device for other characters. Every action his character made was for the sole purpose of developing others (ex: getting shot is used to cause tension between Rick and Lori, killing that Woodbury kid is used to develop Rick’s arc in the first part of Season 4, his bond with Michonne profoundly benefited Michonne, his mini-attack on the Sanctuary used to develop Negan, ect.) He was never really his OWN character which I didn’t like very much. So, I think I’d have put him in the wasted potential category personally.
Judith should be first place she's the best character way better than Carl and everyone don't disrespect Judith again and she's not cringe by the way. Carl cringe 🤦🤦🤦
Beth was annoying that one she was just a teenager brat she was just take care of Judith then season 5 she started fight walker and being more cool but that’s the same season that she died
Beth had a lot of potential - they shouldn’t have killed her off when they did - she had just gotten interesting
what you said about Carl is EXACTLY my thoughts on him. He’s my fav character hands-down, especially in the comics, but season 8 Carl ruined his character on so many levels. My fav era of Carl is s4 as I really believe they delved into the fact that he’s actually a child still and dealing with things as a child. But yeah, s8 was strange and the whole time i was effing and blinding at him for how he was suddenly preaching peace. 100 percent turned into a plot device by AMC to keep Negan alive as a character.
People hate when people complain about RJs acting and say he’s just a kid. But like, so many kids have been on TWD and have done far better acting in a short span of epidoes. Kids like Judith, Mika, Lizzie, Megan, Carl, Sophia, and many others have shown more emotion in one scene than RJ has in 2-3 seasons
@@kharma101 yeah but tbf they cast him when he was like 5 lol, the others are a bit different. Its the show fault they should’ve aged him up
@
They should have recasted after the time jump
Judith does not kill a kid it was a man
Carl and Judith are tied for first
No Judith first. Carl cringe not bad@ss
Personally, I’d have put Carl much lower on my list. I just think he never stood his own on the show and instead was used as a plot device for other characters. Every action his character made was for the sole purpose of developing others (ex: getting shot is used to cause tension between Rick and Lori, killing that Woodbury kid is used to develop Rick’s arc in the first part of Season 4, his bond with Michonne profoundly benefited Michonne, his mini-attack on the Sanctuary used to develop Negan, ect.)
He was never really his OWN character which I didn’t like very much. So, I think I’d have put him in the wasted potential category personally.
It would be great if you made the same list but this time also with the children of Fear TWD, World Beyond, Tales of TWD, Dead City and Daryl Dixon
I'm here to boost the algorithm I'm still watching the when each character should have died video
Judith and Carl
Wheres our guy Kor-Julio from season 3 who merle savagely pops in the head when he wants to the the gov about michonne escaping :P
Maybe you could do a vid ranking each deleted scene
Judith should be first place she's the best character way better than Carl and everyone don't disrespect Judith again and she's not cringe by the way. Carl cringe 🤦🤦🤦
I got mad when they kill of Henry and Carl
had to click on this just to make sure carl is number 1
Carol release Negan because his the only one can get close to Alpha Carol want to do it but she couldn’t
What the name of this tier list
lizzie should not be in the top tier
Beth was annoying that one she was just a teenager brat she was just take care of Judith then season 5 she started fight walker and being more cool but that’s the same season that she died
You talk like a annoying teenager brat