I watched images of the prisoners on tv as a child in the U.S. and it has stayed with me all of my life. We all must stand up for those who cannot and teach our kids about what humanity is capable of.
As an American German, I'm so happy to see this. Not only the video, but the important work to preserve and honor the memories and good deeds of those involved. Thank You DW, Natalia Romik et. al.
I am so glad to see this film and to know that there are so many who helped in the days of the Holocaust and now, in our time. This all needs to be known and taught.
why exactly? Jews in General believe they are superior to the rest of us, only because the old testament says Abraham was Blessed and so were his children ISRAEL most of all. somehow Israel keeps getting away from the lesson to be learned.
Simple things like just going to the bathroom or getting a drink of water we take for granted. These people had to hide for hours and days in fear. Can't imagine. God bless those who put their lives on the line to aid the Jewish people as well.
@@redkop510 VOTE TRUMP TO BE KING FOREVER. It really doesn't matter anymore, It's like putting a band aid on a shotgun wound. America is beyond repair. sad to say.
Thank you DW for this great documentary 👍. We should never forget our past and instead learn from our past mistakes so that we could avoid repeating them in the future.Thanks to Natalia for carrying out this research and that tree is amazing.
Natalia is a present day hero investigating past heros. Thank you for your dedication to such an important part of our modern history. You brought it back to life for generations to come. I found this video so interesting. I am so impressed by Natalia. Intelligent, passionate, interesting and beautiful are just a few words of admiration I have for her.
“Get it all on record now - get the films - get the witnesses - because somewhere down the track of history some bastard will get up and say that this never happened.” Dwight D. Eisenhower 1945
I always appreciate the documentaries you guys create! Big thanks to Natalia, showcased here. It isn't easy for my polish family to talk about the second world war, or for many people from that generation. Unfortunately it seems as if Poland still isn't ready to talk about such things...and may never be...
Mostly probably due to israel citizens attempting to lay claims to polish assets a private property & I believe they even want to strap the poles with some tax.
@@idahoman325 They can't apply any tax but every once in a while some more right wing Jewish organization tries to raise claims for a compensation which sours the relations. But no, most of people who survived the war don't speak about it because it's too painful and brings back memories of personal trauma. In one of my grandparents home they have never talked about the war. For instance I only found out what my grandfather went through after he died and it was still told to me with a lowered voice almost as if it was a secret I should never talk about, the same with my grandma from that home. My other grandma only opened up about what she's gone through when I was in my early or mid twenties. I don't recall ever being told explicitly not to ask but it was almost an untold rule in the family never to bring this up.
Thank you, Natalia, and other non-Jewish Poles for TRYING to preserve the history, and, especially, talk about this side of your Polish Jewish history, in relation to the hiding places, which, as you said, is viewed as taboo by some. The Germans were able to learn from the Holocaust. You and others like you are also trying to apply the lessons learned from that time to include their socio-political relevance for today, and you are all to be congratulated. Many thanks also to DW TV for allowing this very educational documentary to be made.
@@navajoauckland6003 Poland passed a law making it illegal to say that Polish Catholics collaborated with the Germans, helping to kill Jews. Also some Polish Catholics believe that they suffered more during WW2 thsn Jews
While interesting that someone may have been hiding in the tree, I find it a bit difficult to think this was possible over a long time or even during winter when it would have been extremely cold inside. But as a short-term temporary hiding place, it could definitely have served.
Something so unsettling to me in this video..no one seems to be taking care of the cemetery or graveside at all. So many broken, dirty/moldy stones, long weeds and grass. Does no one in Warsaw care that this cemetery and people should be so respected and looked after? It's sad.
They're hesitant/afraid to move the grave-stones perhaps out of respect. But yes. look after it. i live next to an old graveyard. The lawns are mowed but the grave stones are not moved. I'm in NFLD Canada. The cemetary is 250yrs and more. Catholic is on this side of the lake. The Anglican is on the other. I sometimes trim the hedges but never move the grave stones
Keep doing the fantastic work that your doing for the world never to forget, what happened and for the courage of those people that put their own life and their family’s at risk to help the Jewish people. God bless them 🙏 one and all may we never forget. Thank you for your video I would have never know about this.♥️🇦🇺
Maybe because of the hollowing out of the inside of the tree. Most trees that are hollow have been rotten inside and the rot continues to the point where it kills the tree or causes the tree to fall. The combination of rot and being exposed to the rain and wind can be enough to kill the tree.
It’s so hard to imagine how cruelty can flourish among people. These days we are once again dealing with evil. I pray that people of good conscience will fight back one more time. For the sake of humanity we have to do it one more time.
Its wonderful that there always are good ppl who always will help.. Im from Denmark and proud about we did save almost all jews in our country by sailing them to sweeden.. Sadly the only country in ww2 who did everything to save them.. Peace💖
@@1catmac then you don't know your history about ww2 and think you need to research some more.. cause now its you who is about bs.. Don't you think i know a lot more about my country and its history than you do??? Vikings Don't go down without a fight.. we showed that in ww2 saving all those jews bc we see them as a part of our society and always have done so.. so stop your shit plz And what about in other countries? Yesh sure some took some in and hided them, but else they was left to fend for themselves in all EU... We were the only country who did everything to save them the night before they was going to be taken and send to a German concentration camp (death)... im willing to give you 1000 dollars free if you can find research proving that we didnt save them
@@starvictory7079 you not just our Swedish neighbors but our brothers and sisters.. And we thank you too.. Without you we couldn't have saved all those jews.. so you saved them as much as we did.. plz remember that my brother
@@Liminal-Lagomorph u are delusional.. I can provide photo evidence my grandfather took.. All you can provide is words without even doing the research before your claim.. lol I wish u was in those camps in that time.. might change ur attitude
Another book to read is "Clara's War". She, her family, and others lived under the floor boards for a couple years in a crawl space and could only sit up or lay down.
The incredible mental fortitude it takes to live in exile for years, knowing one small mistake might lead to death of not only yourself, but everyone else in that hiding space.
Those hiding places each only hid a few poor souls. The wickedness they hid from still happens. Imagine the life of a survivor whose entire kinship and friendship system have been murdered.
My grandmother's parents (great-grandparents) hid a Jewish family in their village home in western Belarus, which used to be eastern Poland before 1939. Risking thier life and thier childrens life hiding a Jewish family.
One of the most amazing stories I know about was of a sizeable group of Jews [Men, Women and Children] who hid underground in complete darkness for over a year and a half .......in Rumania if I remember correctly. Until today this feat holds the world record for such a triumph of existence and sheer will to live. Certain people would go out at night when possible to look for food and water but the majority never ventured outside for fear of being discovered and killed. At one stage the group was discovered and the 'friendly' locals tried to bury them alive by filling in that part of the cave system with dirt but being so extensive the system allowed the group to move elsewhere, lie low for some days and convince the locals that they had suffocated. People became so accustomed to the dark that even up to today as one 'then child' survivor stated when descending into the depths after 60 years or more: Aaaaaaaah..now I feel more at home".' At wars end the group came out of hiding and went about starting new lives far from the darkness and hatred.
Oh man, what a great story, thank you for sharing this... is this a documentary you saw? If so might you know the name or have a link to share? Thanks so much in advance. =)
@@karlabritfeld7104 how is it funny? I don’t think anything about this video is funny. How does my diet have anything to do with what these people went through?
Nice work here. Thank you for what you are doing! Did Abraham have any comment about what happened in the winter time when using the hideout? They would have had to go out and forage for food, leaving footprints in the snow. The Gestapo were already onto this, and would have the forests & other places scoured for these footprints to find Jews in hiding.
I don’t see how anybody lives in apartments in that area they even have apartments now where the Warsaw ghetto was and I just can’t imagine the energy and sadness in those areas I bet people who live there are sick constantly. I know part of my dad‘s family is from Poland but I don’t know if I could ever go there’s just too much sadness in that country.
@SkylarkD 81 You should at least try. Poland is an amazing country with very beautiful areas and the people are super friendly. I'm from UK but spent many years touring around Poland.
@@Bulletguy07 no thanks I’m Jewish I’ll stay away from that area I’ve heard too many bad things from my family members about how they’re just very close minded and not very open to doing anything for anyone.
So wonderful to see this happening...I pray if such horrendous wickedness should rise up once again in my/our generation, I will be brave and faithful enough to provide and protect those persecuted....it could be me.. May the G-d of Jacob protect Israel and His people 🙏 ❤️
Natalia Romik has done remarkable work in documenting the Holocaust-era hideouts used by Jews in Poland. I wish she could somehow help the Ukrainians to create their own survival architecture like they did in Poland years ago. Tragically, history is repeating itself after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. I pray that somehow Putin will be stopped but in the meantime I send my healing thoughts and wishes for the Ukrainians as well as to all civilian casualties in other wars like Afghanistan. Let peace and peace and peace be everywhere. Upanishads. Jenny
Pretty sure MANY of these WWII Era Jewish hideouts exist in Ukraine today. Ukrainians were some of the most vicious Nazi collaborators during WWII. I do, however, have sympathy for what Ukrainians are enduring today, under attack by Russia. Ukrainians must/will be victorious...Poland is next on Putin's list.
A historic comparison of how the Bulshevics and the Nazis were similar and different. Both caused a multitude of suffering and knowledge is power to avoid these abominable social tragedies.
Maybe maybe not. Germany was in a situation where any old hitler could have done what hitler did. His besties were arguably worse human beings than he was, and had a lot more of a hands on role in the carnage.
You should read about Jewish peoples more, like - the history and origin of this particular nation. If you study about Jewish history you may change your views and perspectives on them.
@@Tj-vf3ll Saying that we should never ever experience the holocaust again applies to all of humanity. Palestinians included. Caring for the Jews does not mean agreeing with what Israel does
@@eboyjim Thats a laugh cos the world is silent about the Palestinian holocaust taking place today. Double standards serves a corrupted soul. Sympathy is a card played so they can do the "necessary" evil taking place on occupied Palestine. Justified by the holocaust?. Thats a sickman's mentality.
Some very Brave people saving lots of lives during Ww2... The Holocaust was so Horrific.. So many Jews will be so thankful to have been saved... These hiding places are so well thought out... True Survival😘
Biographies and autobiographies of survivors tell of heroic people sneaking them food and/or the people who are hiding out sneaking out from their hiding places and scavenging or stealing food.
Always Documentary( DW)channel shared Respective, Bravery , Eyes opening & useful matters Videos , this Video carrying Excellent quality of Journal coverage video is labelling to this inhumanity , Terrifying, Peoples annihilation Phenomenon of Jewish peoples during 2WW didactic by Nazism Prosecution Systems ....Struggling for survives is ultra Bravery Level in Human kind Manner
Thank you so much for your amazing and such an important work. Unless we preserve what's left of the Jewish-Polish history and Holocaust, celebrate the Polish heroes and deal with the hidden untisemitism, we are at risk of repetiting the awful discrimination and extermination of the nationsas it happens now in Ukraine.
This is brilliant work of research into the Polish Jewish Holocaust. You should get an award for your work by Israel and by Russian Jews, such as Aida Garifullina the great Opera singer of Russia. As you know Pope Jean Paul II was Polish -- Victor Nimrud Alexander
This is how Germans move forward. You move on by facing the past, reconciling previous mistakes and learning the lessons to not repeat them again. Philippines should learn from this especially that now we are about to elect the son of the Marcos dictator to the Presidency.
The Germans move forward because they survived a war they created and never had to pay for it because the US saw the bigger enemy in the Soviet Union and let all the Nazis live their life with their family. Germans git all the money and support from the US and they act like Nazis weren't their grandfathers.
You know nothing about German or European history. Germans moved forward by sweeping their crimes under the carpet. Germans never faced their past, they try to forget it. Germany never took responsibility for its crimes against the Polish people. Majority of Polish victims was never compensated by Germany. Germany enriched itself on the suffering of Poles. German companies exploited Polish people as slaves. Germans looted Poland stealing bank reserves, natural resources, artwork, private and state owned property. Today most Germans are completely unaware what their ancestors did to Poland.
Beautiful documentary, just one tip to the woman who is doing research: these people went through a traumatic experience and it's quite possible they don't want to be found and talk about that. They could be even dead.
I was at the Warsaw cemetery when I went to Poland to see Auschwitz and other camps. At the cemetery, we were shown a hiding spot- if I rem correctly, it was a hole that lead to the sewars
I know people from the region around Gliwice/Gleiwitz but they were children then (born in the 1930s) I now wonder what they would have seen and comprehended then.
On one hand, it's important to know what happened... On the other hand, there's still nazis around and I'm not sure it's a good idea to tell them where to look when it happens again
It’s not just German Historians who are prohibited. The Rightwing Government of Poland would like to wipe away the history of the Holocaust. Antisemitism in Poland is deplorable.
I watched images of the prisoners on tv as a child in the U.S. and it has stayed with me all of my life. We all must stand up for those who cannot and teach our kids about what humanity is capable of.
The Americans allowed this to go on for years and years before they finally took action.
Yes, this horrible holocaust history should be repeatedly told every day forever. Horrible but it did happen.
As an American German, I'm so happy to see this. Not only the video, but the important work to preserve and honor the memories and good deeds of those involved. Thank You DW, Natalia Romik et. al.
I am so glad to see this film and to know that there are so many who helped in the days of the Holocaust and now, in our time. This all needs to be known and taught.
Unfortunately... They tell the children it never happen. Facts no longer matter...ssd
Zionist string pullers profit in every conflict
Ugh. Majority of it is not true.
why exactly? Jews in General believe they are superior to the rest of us, only because the old testament says Abraham was Blessed and so were his children ISRAEL most of all.
somehow Israel keeps getting away from the lesson to be learned.
@@childrensorg856 antisemite
Simple things like just going to the bathroom or getting a drink of water we take for granted. These people had to hide for hours and days in fear. Can't imagine. God bless those who put their lives on the line to aid the Jewish people as well.
reminds me of the story Trump used to tell about the Snake.
Agree.
@@jesucristojesus3676 TDS has no cure or vaccine.
He lives rent free in your head 24/7.
That's pretty pathetic 🤣🤣🤣
@@jesucristojesus3676 Trump 2024.😎
@@redkop510 VOTE TRUMP TO BE KING FOREVER.
It really doesn't matter anymore, It's like putting a band aid on a shotgun wound. America is beyond repair. sad to say.
Thank you, all, for your dedication and hard work to save all these relics. They world should not forget about these atrocities!
I watch a lot of channels and they do not compare to yours. I learn something new when I watch. Great narration and translation.
If you learn what they want you to learn aren't you just being programmed?
DW #1 for fake news
Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment, Nilsa! We're glad you enjoy our content.
@@donkykon2094 spoken like a true sycophant.
@@donkykon2094 and yet, here you are!
The tree hideout is AMAZING!! I cannot believe it is still alive.
I mean…. The tree is centuries old. What’s another 80 years?
Thank you DW for this great documentary 👍. We should never forget our past and instead learn from our past mistakes so that we could avoid repeating them in the future.Thanks to Natalia for carrying out this research and that tree is amazing.
Uhhh have you turned the television on?? Hitler is back in Russia
Putin is Hitler reincarnated
Natalia is a present day hero investigating past heros. Thank you for your dedication to such an important part of our modern history. You brought it back to life for generations to come. I found this video so interesting. I am so impressed by Natalia. Intelligent, passionate, interesting and beautiful are just a few words of admiration I have for her.
Unbelievable!desperate times called for desperate measures!Salute to those who
Helped to save the survivors
This woman is amazing and her work is so important. Thank you for bringing this history to life.
“Get it all on record now - get the films - get the witnesses - because somewhere down the track of history some bastard will get up and say that this never happened.”
Dwight D. Eisenhower 1945
😆
like the 12 million germans eisenhower killed after the war
Funny how neither he, Winston Churchill or Charles De Gaulle mentioned it in their histories of the second world war.
@@davidwhite4874 The antifa and jud-Marxist forum is full.
@@sandozpop6017 Pardon?
7:12 - Yosef the old Oak Tree... damn, that part gave me chills. That was amazing!
Amazing story. I'm humbled by the bravery of these people and I am so glad there are individuals who are working to preserve this history.
I salute this young woman for taking on this task to preserve history.
I always appreciate the documentaries you guys create! Big thanks to Natalia, showcased here. It isn't easy for my polish family to talk about the second world war, or for many people from that generation. Unfortunately it seems as if Poland still isn't ready to talk about such things...and may never be...
Mostly probably due to israel citizens attempting to lay claims to polish assets a private property & I believe they even want to strap the poles with some tax.
@@idahoman325 They can't apply any tax but every once in a while some more right wing Jewish organization tries to raise claims for a compensation which sours the relations. But no, most of people who survived the war don't speak about it because it's too painful and brings back memories of personal trauma. In one of my grandparents home they have never talked about the war. For instance I only found out what my grandfather went through after he died and it was still told to me with a lowered voice almost as if it was a secret I should never talk about, the same with my grandma from that home. My other grandma only opened up about what she's gone through when I was in my early or mid twenties. I don't recall ever being told explicitly not to ask but it was almost an untold rule in the family never to bring this up.
@sunny sunnyday ...? what exactly are you saying is untrue...?
Never forget unbelievable Holocaust.
Do you realize what trauma for the Polish people WWII was?
Thank you for your work and bringing attention to these this lost history. Great Work 👍🏼
You will be blessed for what you are doing☦️
Thank you, Natalia, and other non-Jewish Poles for TRYING to preserve the history, and, especially, talk about this side of your Polish Jewish history, in relation to the hiding places, which, as you said, is viewed as taboo by some. The Germans were able to learn from the Holocaust. You and others like you are also trying to apply the lessons learned from that time to include their socio-political relevance for today, and you are all to be congratulated. Many thanks also to DW TV for allowing this very educational documentary to be made.
.
?
@@navajoauckland6003 Poland passed a law making it illegal to say that Polish Catholics collaborated with the Germans, helping to kill Jews. Also some Polish Catholics believe that they suffered more during WW2 thsn Jews
@@farapipsqueek636 Such a law doesn't exist and never did. Just stop bullshitting and don't spread lies!
Great job she’s doing! God bless her
Great work. Great research. Great preservation!
Wow! I really enjoyed this! Keep up this very important work!
While interesting that someone may have been hiding in the tree, I find it a bit difficult to think this was possible over a long time or even during winter when it would have been extremely cold inside. But as a short-term temporary hiding place, it could definitely have served.
if it was hiding in a tree during winter or leaving for certain death , id stick to the tree.
I’m guessing they did a lot of stealing from surrounding properties to keep supplied. I’d hope so, at least.
There are remembrances from people who lived in forests.
@@BeckBeckGo They were supported by Polish people, without whom they wouldn't be able to survive.
It works for squirrels, why not people? If you need to survive, you will use whatever is available.
Something so unsettling to me in this video..no one seems to be taking care of the cemetery or graveside at all. So many broken, dirty/moldy stones, long weeds and grass. Does no one in Warsaw care that this cemetery and people should be so respected and looked after? It's sad.
They're hesitant/afraid to move the grave-stones perhaps out of respect. But yes. look after it. i live next to an old graveyard. The lawns are mowed but the grave stones are not moved. I'm in NFLD Canada. The cemetary is 250yrs and more. Catholic is on this side of the lake. The Anglican is on the other. I sometimes trim the hedges but never move the grave stones
Fascinating documentary
Keep doing the fantastic work that your doing for the world never to forget, what happened and for the courage of those people that put their own life and their family’s at risk to help the Jewish people. God bless them 🙏 one and all may we never forget. Thank you for your video I would have never know about this.♥️🇦🇺
That tree is amazing! Holy cow. Tgat sent shivers down my spine thinking about using it as a hideout. I can't believe it's still alive.
Why are people having trouble believing how a tree, that’s survived for centuries with a much longer life expectancy, also survived the last 80 years?
Maybe because of the hollowing out of the inside of the tree. Most trees that are hollow have been rotten inside and the rot continues to the point where it kills the tree or causes the tree to fall.
The combination of rot and being exposed to the rain and wind can be enough to kill the tree.
My tears are coming down watching this. Things like this should be told to the world, especially to those who denies it ever happened.
:D
It gets told to the World on a daily basis🤔
@@redkop510by who? I'm 48, we never even discussed it or taught it in school
@@sherryjohnson3804 The fake media of course....who else 🤔
Such an important part of our history. We must never forget what happened.
May God Bless your work!
Very fascinating documentary
It’s so hard to imagine how cruelty can flourish among people. These days we are once again dealing with evil. I pray that people of good conscience will fight back one more time. For the sake of humanity we have to do it one more time.
Love the narrator's voice. Gentle.
Its wonderful that there always are good ppl who always will help..
Im from Denmark and proud about we did save almost all jews in our country by sailing them to sweeden..
Sadly the only country in ww2 who did everything to save them..
Peace💖
That’s a load of bs
@@1catmac As a Swede I agree with my Danish neighbour. Thanks to many Danes most Danish Jews were saved. Luckily, Sweden was not invaded.
@@1catmac then you don't know your history about ww2 and think you need to research some more.. cause now its you who is about bs..
Don't you think i know a lot more about my country and its history than you do???
Vikings Don't go down without a fight.. we showed that in ww2 saving all those jews bc we see them as a part of our society and always have done so.. so stop your shit plz
And what about in other countries? Yesh sure some took some in and hided them, but else they was left to fend for themselves in all EU...
We were the only country who did everything to save them the night before they was going to be taken and send to a German concentration camp (death)... im willing to give you 1000 dollars free if you can find research proving that we didnt save them
@@starvictory7079 you not just our Swedish neighbors but our brothers and sisters.. And we thank you too..
Without you we couldn't have saved all those jews.. so you saved them as much as we did.. plz remember that my brother
@@Liminal-Lagomorph u are delusional.. I can provide photo evidence my grandfather took..
All you can provide is words without even doing the research before your claim.. lol
I wish u was in those camps in that time.. might change ur attitude
Very interesting, thank you and thumbs up.
Another book to read is "Clara's War". She, her family, and others lived under the floor boards for a couple years in a crawl space and could only sit up or lay down.
@kim Sule thanks for that recommendation. I've checked it out from my library.
Wonderful documentary!
Thanks for watching and taking the time to comment. Be sure to check out our channel for more content.
I hope this young woman continues with this work. It is important for the world never to forget what man did to man.
The incredible mental fortitude it takes to live in exile for years, knowing one small mistake might lead to death of not only yourself, but everyone else in that hiding space.
God bless her and her research.
Thanks for sharing 🌈
Very interesting 🌻
I watch and listen, yet I do with difficulty since my heart weeps.
Those hiding places each only hid a few poor souls. The wickedness they hid from still happens. Imagine the life of a survivor whose entire kinship and friendship system have been murdered.
My grandmother's parents (great-grandparents) hid a Jewish family in their village home in western Belarus, which used to be eastern Poland before 1939. Risking thier life and thier childrens life hiding a Jewish family.
If only that tree could talk.
Would have been nice to see the finished projects.
One of the most amazing stories I know about was of a sizeable group of Jews [Men, Women and Children] who hid underground in complete darkness for over a year and a half .......in Rumania if I remember correctly.
Until today this feat holds the world record for such a triumph of existence and sheer will to live.
Certain people would go out at night when possible to look for food and water but the majority never ventured outside for fear of being discovered and killed.
At one stage the group was discovered and the 'friendly' locals tried to bury them alive by filling in that part of the cave system with dirt but being so extensive the system allowed the group to move elsewhere, lie low for some days and convince the locals that they had suffocated.
People became so accustomed to the dark that even up to today as one 'then child' survivor stated when descending into the depths after 60 years or more: Aaaaaaaah..now I feel more at home".'
At wars end the group came out of hiding and went about starting new lives far from the darkness and hatred.
They are not yet far from Europe.
@@sandozpop6017 I'm sorry but I didn't understand your comment.
Oh man, what a great story, thank you for sharing this... is this a documentary you saw? If so might you know the name or have a link to share? Thanks so much in advance. =)
I wanna read or watch a video of this.
@Scumfuck McDoucheface the documentary is called "No Place On Earth"
184 calories/per day? That’s insanity. We can’t let the world forget what happened.
Funny coming from a vegan.
😂
@@karlabritfeld7104 how is it funny? I don’t think anything about this video is funny. How does my diet have anything to do with what these people went through?
Natalia Romik is doing Amazing Work.
Wow 2 hide in that tree. Brilliant! But sad at the same time
The most significant defect in humanity, is the ability to end life for the most trivial of reasons.
The book " The Girl in the Green Sweater" is about a young girl and her family who hid in the sewers to avoid capture
Excellent book. Heartbreaking to read. The movie is excellent 👌 , a must see
Thanks for mentioning it. I’ll be sure to read it.
@Kim Sule thanks, I've gotten on the hold list at my library.
They escaped to the wilderness where they were nourished For some time ❤️❤️❤️
Nice work here. Thank you for what you are doing! Did Abraham have any comment about what happened in the winter time when using the hideout? They would have had to go out and forage for food, leaving footprints in the snow. The Gestapo were already onto this, and would have the forests & other places scoured for these footprints to find Jews in hiding.
I don’t see how anybody lives in apartments in that area they even have apartments now where the Warsaw ghetto was and I just can’t imagine the energy and sadness in those areas I bet people who live there are sick constantly.
I know part of my dad‘s family is from Poland but I don’t know if I could ever go there’s just too much sadness in that country.
The energy can be cleared by a geomancer but you need to know that it exists.
@@neva.2764 I think it’s gonna take a lot more than that.
@@slytherinsky Sure. I'm talking about apartments specifically though (should have specified, sorry).
That energy can be fully cleared.
@SkylarkD 81 You should at least try. Poland is an amazing country with very beautiful areas and the people are super friendly. I'm from UK but spent many years touring around Poland.
@@Bulletguy07 no thanks I’m Jewish I’ll stay away from that area I’ve heard too many bad things from my family members about how they’re just very close minded and not very open to doing anything for anyone.
Reminds me of the high caves that Isralites lived in during the seiges and occupation by Rome.
Interesting video, I love history
Very good surprising me love the info
So wonderful to see this happening...I pray if such horrendous wickedness should rise up once again in my/our generation, I will be brave and faithful enough to provide and protect those persecuted....it could be me.. May the G-d of Jacob protect Israel and His people 🙏 ❤️
Natalia Romik has done remarkable work in documenting the Holocaust-era hideouts used by Jews in Poland. I wish she could somehow help the Ukrainians to create their own survival architecture like they did in Poland years ago. Tragically, history is repeating itself after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. I pray that somehow Putin will be stopped but in the meantime I send my healing thoughts and wishes for the Ukrainians as well as to all civilian casualties in other wars like Afghanistan. Let peace and peace and peace be everywhere. Upanishads. Jenny
Pretty sure MANY of these WWII Era Jewish hideouts exist in Ukraine today. Ukrainians were some of the most vicious Nazi collaborators during WWII. I do, however, have sympathy for what Ukrainians are enduring today, under attack by Russia. Ukrainians must/will be victorious...Poland is next on Putin's list.
Had to throw today's politics into this?!
Absolutely fascinating research 👍
yeee ... God, how many have survived! ...
A historic comparison of how the Bulshevics and the Nazis were similar and different. Both caused a multitude of suffering and knowledge is power to avoid these abominable social tragedies.
I know i should something deeper but natalia s hair is perfect!
History is so important
Mind boggling that had not the one man been born millions would have lived.
Hitler
Maybe maybe not. Germany was in a situation where any old hitler could have done what hitler did. His besties were arguably worse human beings than he was, and had a lot more of a hands on role in the carnage.
Europe soil is full of blood
Which land is not?
@@n.j8622 Antarctica
@@INeverWanted2010 hardly a "soil" though ;)
@@JerzyFeliksKlein You got me there, fuzzycakes 😉
So what? We're still rather peaceful and highly efficient. Looking for certain issues or conflict?
Every Minority around the world can learn from the Jewish people on how to survive and make sure that your future generations do so.
Ummm, yea except so many millions didn’t. They can learn more by learning how this all happened in the first place
You should read about Jewish peoples more, like - the history and origin of this particular nation. If you study about Jewish history you may change your views and perspectives on them.
How?
@@koushikdas1992 ✨Radicals✨
Oyy veyyy
The Ein Sof gathers strength where there is only misery, life where there is only death.
Don’t ever give away hiding spots. Now these and others like them can’t be used again.
Never ever again. Remember the basic rule: if someone else is targeted, you could be next.
Yes just like what's happening to the Palestinians
Who's targetting the Palestinians?
@@4TheRecord
You dont know?
@@Tj-vf3ll Saying that we should never ever experience the holocaust again applies to all of humanity. Palestinians included. Caring for the Jews does not mean agreeing with what Israel does
@@eboyjim
Thats a laugh cos the world is silent about the Palestinian holocaust taking place today. Double standards serves a corrupted soul.
Sympathy is a card played so they can do the "necessary" evil taking place on occupied Palestine.
Justified by the holocaust?. Thats a sickman's mentality.
Some very Brave people saving lots of lives during Ww2...
The Holocaust was so Horrific..
So many Jews will be so thankful to have been saved...
These hiding places are so well thought out...
True Survival😘
What I would like to know is where & how these hiders found food & water?
Biographies and autobiographies of survivors tell of heroic people sneaking them food and/or the people who are hiding out sneaking out from their hiding places and scavenging or stealing food.
Great documentary. I showed it to my high school students during our Jojo Rabbit unit.
Ghastly times
a human is just a human
does not have any other names.
Cain killed his good brother with a rock 🪨
The Jews call the Palestinians "animals". It's a shame they don't respect the idea of Human just being Human.
Those people who hid out did not survive not under those conditions. Chances are likely they were ratted out and caught.
Some people survived, not many but some always survived
And how exactly do you know it?
@P W yes, there are many autobiographies of survivors.
Gliwice are near German border? A great documentary by the way.
It was back then, and on the German side.
All people should be free from oppression and aggression. 🇺🇦🇵🇸🇺🇦
Always Documentary( DW)channel shared Respective, Bravery , Eyes opening & useful matters Videos , this Video carrying Excellent quality of Journal coverage video is labelling to this inhumanity , Terrifying, Peoples annihilation Phenomenon of Jewish peoples during 2WW didactic by Nazism Prosecution Systems ....Struggling for survives is ultra Bravery Level in Human kind Manner
Thank you so much for your amazing and such an important work.
Unless we preserve what's left of the Jewish-Polish history and Holocaust, celebrate the Polish heroes and deal with the hidden untisemitism, we are at risk of repetiting the awful
discrimination and extermination of the nationsas it happens now in Ukraine.
ربنا يرحمهم
ومن يتكلم عن الارمن في تركيا
This is brilliant work of research into the Polish Jewish Holocaust. You should get an award for your work by Israel and by Russian Jews, such as Aida Garifullina the great Opera singer of Russia. As you know Pope Jean Paul II was Polish -- Victor Nimrud Alexander
This is how Germans move forward. You move on by facing the past, reconciling previous mistakes and learning the lessons to not repeat them again.
Philippines should learn from this especially that now we are about to elect the son of the Marcos dictator to the Presidency.
The Germans move forward because they survived a war they created and never had to pay for it because the US saw the bigger enemy in the Soviet Union and let all the Nazis live their life with their family. Germans git all the money and support from the US and they act like Nazis weren't their grandfathers.
You know nothing about German or European history. Germans moved forward by sweeping their crimes under the carpet. Germans never faced their past, they try to forget it. Germany never took responsibility for its crimes against the Polish people. Majority of Polish victims was never compensated by Germany. Germany enriched itself on the suffering of Poles. German companies exploited Polish people as slaves. Germans looted Poland stealing bank reserves, natural resources, artwork, private and state owned property. Today most Germans are completely unaware what their ancestors did to Poland.
Beautiful documentary, just one tip to the woman who is doing research: these people went through a traumatic experience and it's quite possible they don't want to be found and talk about that. They could be even dead.
Very likely they are dead or 100 years old.
I was at the Warsaw cemetery when I went to Poland to see Auschwitz and other camps. At the cemetery, we were shown a hiding spot- if I rem correctly, it was a hole that lead to the sewars
In denmark almost every single jewish person got away to sweden.
Because there were few Jews in Denmark and nazi occupation of Denmark was soft.
Awesome!
That was very interesting in what people did to survive the horrors of war and ideology of hate
Interesting story
I know people from the region around Gliwice/Gleiwitz but they were children then (born in the 1930s) I now wonder what they would have seen and comprehended then.
1:11 Is "erosia" an anglicized version of "erozja"?
kinda, it she should've said 'erosion'
Boring. Why talk about secret hiding places then barely show them.
I really wanted to watch this ... but the background 'music' noise is causing nausea and mini seizures.
just use the captions
You need trigger warning?😢
update ...watched again w no problem....must have been having a high anxiety day.
They should use this to find the mass graves.. 👀🙄
@Carlo 95 , shhhhh , it could be like when Geraldo Rivera did the few hours of live coverage to show the nothing burger in al Capone's safe lol ...
@Carlo 95 So the survivors, like my grandfather, just made up everything they witnessed?
On one hand, it's important to know what happened...
On the other hand, there's still nazis around and I'm not sure it's a good idea to tell them where to look when it happens again
Brilliant lady
Why are Germans not allowed the freedom to discuss this topic?
It’s not just German Historians who are prohibited. The Rightwing Government of Poland would like to wipe away the history of the Holocaust. Antisemitism in Poland is deplorable.
@@SeniorJohnQPublic 😂😂
Who says that they don't???
Where did you pick that up? The holocaust is extensively researched and remembered in modern day Germany!
Cant criticize the ones that control u dats why
That's one weird picture behind her at her desk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So no bones were found in first hideout. That's good
They feel the exact same feeling as me when my father farts 💀💀
👍👏