Man one: i been dreaming of iron like this since i was a boy! Man two: thats a fine peace right there. Man one: i wanna test this but a man said to me not to, he said i might accidentally kill a friend... Well lets go home and open a beer and chill. Man two: sure, im in!
I don't understand why they didn't give us the "intervene" option on this one like so many other encounters like this. It makes no sense for Arthur to just stand there watching this guy being extremely dangerous and not say anything.
@@ldpenguin7527 I'm not a member of the libertarian political party, but I do agree with some libertarian philosophy, such as the non aggression principle. I prefer to call myself a voluntarist or anti-authoritarian. The meaning behind my profile pic is exactly what it says, "don't tread on me" means leave me alone, let me live in peace, and the rattlesnake implies that if you don't, I will defend myself.
sometimes i wonder if he meant to kill his friend by using the "accident trick" because one day this went on like it would and i walked slightly too close by them while trying to get in the gunsmith's and the friend walked away and the guy who bought the gun turned hostile and tried to kill me instead. he said a unique voice line along the lines of "damn you" (or rather said it in a unique tone) but in a way that was louder as if the player was meant to hear it and the sheriff came out and his deputies gunfighted him for like 2 mins straight lmao. i walked over to him and he was full of holes when they finally gunned the npc down. happened quite quick.
The lasso trick is really cool and the one that make absolute sense to disarm the reckless guy. I can see why discharging a gun when there's no immediate need for it will attract some unwanted attention
@@echoesdetoi537 yes you can, at the point you're talking about it doesn't even give you the option to view your weapon scroll wheel, whereas the person who is playing in this video has that option.
@@firthyfirth9526 He was being extremely unsafe with firearm... they should have given us the option to "intervene" like with other encounters. Then Arthur could call him out for being a moron before he actually shot anyone.
@@firthyfirth9526 Yes, and you do have a point, you can't assault someone with a lasso or gun just because they're being unsafe... but the original comment is also right, that you shouldn't be completely restricted to either letting the guy die or save him and go to jail. There should have been a third option, maybe even a fourth.
What? Do you stand behind a friend when you have a casual conversation with them? That aside, let me remind you that the idiot with the gun aimed directly at his friend. So even if his friend stood on the side the guy would aim at him still.
Well, you're technically preventing a crime that hasn't happened yet.. Unless you can explain how you've seen the future, they won't know you've saved his life 😁
0:32 did I just hear somebody say “Great Scott?” For those who don’t know that’s a reference to a movie called back to the future where a scientist known as Doc Brown created a time machine, and every time something shocking would happen, he’d say “Great Scott.” In one of the movies, he went to retire to the Old West, which was his favorite time period. The fact they added this is legendary.
It’s legit an old saying soon as I saw this comment I knew you was wrong and has nothing to do with reference then saw another comment that also implies it’s an old saying
I brought him to jail and Arthur was like “I found this feller dunking his wifes head in the horse trowel” I was like wtf? That’s not what happened at all!
I was in Annesburg where theres another scenario like this. The guy shot his friend in the leg and actually killed my horse because he shot it in the head.
Never being able to pull out your gun as the deputy takes away from alot of the choice and freedom of how you handle situations while in that town. The only time you CAN pull out your weapon at this point is for one of the special store robberies that has an event attached that I won’t mention any more for those who haven’t seen it.
I encountered this couple in Anessburg, the guy did the same stuffs, but on the 2nd time he unholstered his gun, it went off and shot his leg. Then he went straight running sayin it was all alright and he was going to be fine.
One thing I don’t understand in red dead is when I got shot at by anyone that threatened me and shoots me nearly dead and I shoot back and now I’m wanted for murder.
I didn't get the rest of the dialogue after he said something like fine iron etc he just shot him and ran... I thought he had some rare gun or something so I chased him and took his gun... Was nothing.
Sucks you can't really do anything if you get this in chapter 3. Can't even hogtie him until you get out of the Rhodes area, and even if you chase him out of the area and then hogtie him, if you bring him back to the sherrif's office, you can't do anything from there.
Unfortunately I got this interaction when you can’t use your weapons in Rhodes so I had to watch this guy shoot and friend and couldn’t do anything about it
Wow, did he hit him with a revolver or a car? That is some exaggerated physics, I highly doubt that there exists a single personal weapon capable of knocking a person 10 feet away.
I never saw this one but I did see two guys trying to blow open a Safe by the bridge to saint denis, I walked up and greeted them and then they exploded
I always didn’t understand why the English letter "W" In RDR2 it is always shown as a Russian letter "Sh" or "Ш" This turns out to be not a witness and will be shitness,wanted - shanted,it's really fun
I just stood in between the guys the one with the gun got mad. Arthur knocked him out and I took him to the sheriff I was a deputy still so I wasn’t arrested
its funny after watching this video i stumbled upon this encounter normally they drop a cattleman revolver but i was lucky and got me a free scofield revolver not bad 😊
I accidentally saved his friend by shooting him i didn't mean to my trigger was kinda messed up 😂😂 i ended up shooting him in the stomach area . I had no idea of the outcome
I don’t think a long colt will actually toss someone like that. Maybe knock the whole back of their head off on the way out and break their neck in an clearly unnatural angle but not throw them that hard. It’s been proven the .45 LC (or .45 ACP since it was made to match the almost exact same ballistics) does not carry the knock down power. It’s only flying about 900 FPS max which is the about average cowboy load which literally only translates to about 290-300 ft lbs of force. +P is just more powder which does up those stats a little bit but not by much. So realistically you’re getting body slammed by a seizably obese man or two grown men so off guard you’d lose your footing maybe fall over but in general ready stance you take one center mass with a vest you’ll be wondering who hit you with the paintball.
Thing is this wasn't on 2022 but on 1899, they didn't have youtube back then you know? They weren't all avid gun followers who would watch garand thumb every day learning about the way of the AR or AK. Im explaining this like you are an idiot because you appear to be, so does everyone else in this comment section, no they didn't care about trigger disciple in the 1800's, a lot of people died and were hurt due to it, it was common for cowboy to show off their guns sometimes right outside the gun store and accidents have happened, cowboys bought guns so they could roleplay as outlaws, I am for real, they did that, they dressed like though guys and carried various weapons not only for protection but to look mean, and they would make up stories about how bad ass they were take group pictures and shit.
Scene 9: Hey, you won’t believe this but I’m a man from the future and you’re about to kill your friend accidentally
Man one: i been dreaming of iron like this since i was a boy!
Man two: thats a fine peace right there.
Man one: i wanna test this but a man said to me not to, he said i might accidentally kill a friend... Well lets go home and open a beer and chill.
Man two: sure, im in!
hey hey i've seen this one
this is a classic
@@stanleybochenek1862 Nice reference.
I don't understand why they didn't give us the "intervene" option on this one like so many other encounters like this. It makes no sense for Arthur to just stand there watching this guy being extremely dangerous and not say anything.
I’m seeing you everywhere and I jsut have to say I love your pfp
Well because Arthur doesn't give a shit 🤣
@@_PhunNhiKhang He does though
Are you a libertarian
@@ldpenguin7527 I'm not a member of the libertarian political party, but I do agree with some libertarian philosophy, such as the non aggression principle. I prefer to call myself a voluntarist or anti-authoritarian. The meaning behind my profile pic is exactly what it says, "don't tread on me" means leave me alone, let me live in peace, and the rattlesnake implies that if you don't, I will defend myself.
Guy shoots his best friend:
Whole town: *I sleep*
Arthur saves the man:
Whole town: *Real shit*
No one would believe that Arthur saw the future
Gray killing him was such a nice variation lol
"THE LAST THING YOU'LL SEE IS MY BULLET LEAVING THE BARREL"
"I wouldn't even worry 'bout it"
sometimes i wonder if he meant to kill his friend by using the "accident trick" because one day this went on like it would and i walked slightly too close by them while trying to get in the gunsmith's and the friend walked away and the guy who bought the gun turned hostile and tried to kill me instead. he said a unique voice line along the lines of "damn you" (or rather said it in a unique tone) but in a way that was louder as if the player was meant to hear it and the sheriff came out and his deputies gunfighted him for like 2 mins straight lmao. i walked over to him and he was full of holes when they finally gunned the npc down. happened quite quick.
Cap
@@Kyleoski u don’t understand npcs
Happened to me yesterday
You just cut the animation short and aggro'd one of them by being too close.
Bill would probably accidentally shoot someone in camp like that💀
Who do you think he would shoot?
@@mrnobody8316Kieran
Imagine being a time travelling cowboy and nobody believes you that you just saved the life of a guy who gets shot in any alternate reality.
The lasso trick is really cool and the one that make absolute sense to disarm the reckless guy.
I can see why discharging a gun when there's no immediate need for it will attract some unwanted attention
At this point of the story, it is though impossible to aim with a wapon since you are a marshall...
@@echoesdetoi537 yes you can, at the point you're talking about it doesn't even give you the option to view your weapon scroll wheel, whereas the person who is playing in this video has that option.
@@echoesdetoi537 Yeah, when you’re the marshal. Not after when you can finally use weapons in the town.
hey atleast he goes down in style with a flip
can’t argue there
Ah yes dont take the gun away from the prisoner when you put him in the cell
Ahhh yes
3:30 disdurbing the peace... UNARMED ASSULT?! HE JUST SAVED A GODDAMN LIFE ON A MAN FROM A CARELESS IDIOT... God they should be thanking you😡
except that he just shot a random person’s hand for nothing, they don’t know he saved a life
yeah sadly the a.i isnt that smart
@@danielleayala2171 in a real life situation they are actually, they saw him shot a man's hand for no reason not knowing he was trying to save someone
Makes you sad to see how strict this game is.
Yeah it kinda on and off on how much power the player has. You can save the guy but get arrested or you can let him die and get money
@@hunter70558 ye but it makes sense u get arrested bc he hasnt done anything yet
@@firthyfirth9526 He was being extremely unsafe with firearm... they should have given us the option to "intervene" like with other encounters. Then Arthur could call him out for being a moron before he actually shot anyone.
@@livewire2759 i agree with that but the comment above made it it sound like the game is strict for you getting wanted if you assault/lasso/shoot him
@@firthyfirth9526 Yes, and you do have a point, you can't assault someone with a lasso or gun just because they're being unsafe... but the original comment is also right, that you shouldn't be completely restricted to either letting the guy die or save him and go to jail. There should have been a third option, maybe even a fourth.
You can only save him if you know what’s gonna happen, which you can’t. Only thing you can Dinis to bring him to justice.
Who’s really at fault here, the guy messing with his new gun?
Or his friend who just stands in front of him?
both
What? Do you stand behind a friend when you have a casual conversation with them?
That aside, let me remind you that the idiot with the gun aimed directly at his friend. So even if his friend stood on the side the guy would aim at him still.
Obviously the guy... You always assume any firearm to be loaded when handling it, even when you know it's not... That's basic firearm safety
@@user-so4ov7re3s good point
You don't point a loaded gun at ppl
It’s so dumb that you get in trouble for literally saving a guy from dying
Well, you're technically preventing a crime that hasn't happened yet.. Unless you can explain how you've seen the future, they won't know you've saved his life 😁
It is weird that they can't see in the future?
yeah.. It took me 3 hours to make this video and I saw his friend fly more than 5-6 times lol sometimes I can't stop laughing at my own videos
I mean, the lasso trick works.
And if You're discharging a gun without any valid reason... Of course the Law will get you
If you shoot a man in the hand without a reason its okay? That would be very strange
That's Alec Baldwin's great grandpa
0:32 did I just hear somebody say “Great Scott?” For those who don’t know that’s a reference to a movie called back to the future where a scientist known as Doc Brown created a time machine, and every time something shocking would happen, he’d say “Great Scott.”
In one of the movies, he went to retire to the Old West, which was his favorite time period. The fact they added this is legendary.
And "Great Scott" is a name of an electronics channel on TH-cam.
You can hear it if you Barge into the a Train station for me its Valentine And Rhodes
Whats the time stamp?
Great get!!!
It’s legit an old saying soon as I saw this comment I knew you was wrong and has nothing to do with reference then saw another comment that also implies it’s an old saying
I brought him to jail and Arthur was like “I found this feller dunking his wifes head in the horse trowel” I was like wtf? That’s not what happened at all!
You might’ve witnessed something like that beforehand and reported that crime instead of the guy who just shot the other guy.
He really went flying though. :()
What if you get in the way of a shot, or bump into him?
The game won't let You do that
@@AshwinY :
@@AshwinY even if you mod yourself between them?
@@poyeah09 are you dumb to understand if you mod in between then the bullet will just phase threw you and killing him
I was in Annesburg where theres another scenario like this. The guy shot his friend in the leg and actually killed my horse because he shot it in the head.
Never being able to pull out your gun as the deputy takes away from alot of the choice and freedom of how you handle situations while in that town. The only time you CAN pull out your weapon at this point is for one of the special store robberies that has an event attached that I won’t mention any more for those who haven’t seen it.
that npc went full ragdoll mode
I encountered this couple in Anessburg, the guy did the same stuffs, but on the 2nd time he unholstered his gun, it went off and shot his leg. Then he went straight running sayin it was all alright and he was going to be fine.
if you just run/walk into them, they both just get pissed off and antagonize arthur; this happened this other night to me while playing = no bounty
Very nice. Next time I replay I'm gonna see what happens if you shoot straight up in the air.
One thing I don’t understand in red dead is when I got shot at by anyone that threatened me and shoots me nearly dead and I shoot back and now I’m wanted for murder.
What happens if you stand between them and get shot?
The guy who fired the gun better be lucky that he wasn't in Armadillo because I'm the Sheriff of Armadillo now
This is a perfect this is a perfect example though that when you try to do good for somebody it always comes back and bite you in the ass
THANK FOR A ANOTHER VIDEO DETAIL I WILL REMEMBER THIS VIDEO FOREVER FROM RASHEED NATHA ONLYS
3:50 “get down mr. president”
2:21 🤣🤣🤣
I tied him up and the townsfolk attacked me.
In my play through, a sheriff seen him, shot him while he was running and draft horses got scared and ran me over. That was the funniest crap ever🤣
Arthur disrupting a canon event
1:03 His "Don't" is remind me of VCPD quote "Don't move a muscle,chump" from GTA Vice City,because of his deep voice
Clearly firearm safety is top priority here
I didn't get the rest of the dialogue after he said something like fine iron etc he just shot him and ran... I thought he had some rare gun or something so I chased him and took his gun... Was nothing.
A similar encounter happened in strawberry for me except the guy just shot himself in the leg. Kind of deserved that for playing with a gun
When I played this the gun store owner came out, chased the guy and shot him.
I just run at him with full speed and do nothing else while arthur say carefull there
Sucks you can't really do anything if you get this in chapter 3. Can't even hogtie him until you get out of the Rhodes area, and even if you chase him out of the area and then hogtie him, if you bring him back to the sherrif's office, you can't do anything from there.
I actually ended up lassoing him and ended up taking him to the Sheriffs. Ended up getting some money afterwards
ended up saying ended up
@@kronoka lmao
Unfortunately I got this interaction when you can’t use your weapons in Rhodes so I had to watch this guy shoot and friend and couldn’t do anything about it
the slow mos are killing me
Bro literally *flew* back
I like the 7th one where gray kills him seems like the only way
This kids is why you dont play with guns.
Rockstar Games qt it again with the linear random encounters.
The ragdoll physics🤣
Wow, did he hit him with a revolver or a car? That is some exaggerated physics, I highly doubt that there exists a single personal weapon capable of knocking a person 10 feet away.
just run into the man with the gun
you have to stand in the middle of them you will catch the bullit for him and he will thank you for that and you will survive
Bruh the bonus clip is literally best option
Can you see him in the gallows?
No..
@@AshwinY I actually did see them hang him a few days later.
Lore of Can You Save The Man Who Gets Killed By His Own Best Friend (All Outcomes) - Red Dead Redemption 2 momentum 100
...This is why we don't allow fools to have guns.
We do though.
@@jamesboswell530 Unfortunately.
That guy broke every damn gun safety rules.
@@MinhNguyen-pk9qk indeed he did!
Especially the fools who shoot around at school. They exist.
I never saw this one but I did see two guys trying to blow open a Safe by the bridge to saint denis, I walked up and greeted them and then they exploded
I always didn’t understand why the English letter "W" In RDR2 it is always shown as a Russian letter "Sh" or "Ш"
This turns out to be not a witness and will be shitness,wanted - shanted,it's really fun
Kind of stupid that you have to let the guy die to gain honor from this encounter
Clearly he didn't practice proper trigger discipline.
Don't.... Laugh... DON'T.... FUCKING LAUGH...
shit 🤣
0:23 OH shit he went flying 🤣🤣🤣 this my first time seeing this sorry its funny aff
High honour me trying to arrest him but I get wanted for kidnapping
Bro i saved him as arthur then as john i couldnt believe it was happening again and i was too late
Yeah I tried to catch him and the cops started shooting at me. This game is great sometimes but glitches so goddamn often
I just stood in between the guys the one with the gun got mad. Arthur knocked him out and I took him to the sheriff I was a deputy still so I wasn’t arrested
I have a theory for character yoy have to shoot the gun out of their hand but doesn't work, try a bow and arrow
its funny after watching this video i stumbled upon this encounter normally they drop a cattleman revolver but i was lucky and got me a free scofield revolver not bad 😊
Have you tried just talking to them and interrupting their dialogue by any chance
he got yeeted
How many times did u try to laso him between the draw and the shot,so he misses completely but still shoots?
Is it possible to stand between them, so bullet won't go
I've pounced on him after he killed the guy and hogtied him and got wanted Bruhhhh
how did you get to do the interaction multiple times?
I forgot bounty give honor
I need to do that so i can Get High Honor
what if you stand in front of the guy thats gonna get shot?
I wonder why would happen if he just stood in between them could he take the bullet? I already passed this part
What if you stand in the way of the gun?
Can't you talk to the NPC's, or is that not an available option?
I accidentally saved his friend by shooting him i didn't mean to my trigger was kinda messed up 😂😂 i ended up shooting him in the stomach area . I had no idea of the outcome
what if you get infront the gun or behind the dude falling
what if you jump in front of the gun?
And if you stand in front of him
Nice cut
I don’t think a long colt will actually toss someone like that. Maybe knock the whole back of their head off on the way out and break their neck in an clearly unnatural angle but not throw them that hard. It’s been proven the .45 LC (or .45 ACP since it was made to match the almost exact same ballistics) does not carry the knock down power. It’s only flying about 900 FPS max which is the about average cowboy load which literally only translates to about 290-300 ft lbs of force. +P is just more powder which does up those stats a little bit but not by much. So realistically you’re getting body slammed by a seizably obese man or two grown men so off guard you’d lose your footing maybe fall over but in general ready stance you take one center mass with a vest you’ll be wondering who hit you with the paintball.
nerd
What is homie waffling about😂
Zero trigger discipline.
Thing is this wasn't on 2022 but on 1899, they didn't have youtube back then you know? They weren't all avid gun followers who would watch garand thumb every day learning about the way of the AR or AK.
Im explaining this like you are an idiot because you appear to be, so does everyone else in this comment section, no they didn't care about trigger disciple in the 1800's, a lot of people died and were hurt due to it, it was common for cowboy to show off their guns sometimes right outside the gun store and accidents have happened, cowboys bought guns so they could roleplay as outlaws, I am for real, they did that, they dressed like though guys and carried various weapons not only for protection but to look mean, and they would make up stories about how bad ass they were take group pictures and shit.
I saved them.
why dont loot them would be nice to see im always interested in haha
what if you go between them
2:22
How are you able to replay those small scenarios?
Mods/saving and reloading
Too bad you cant antagonize
Wdym you can
How do you get a random encounter to spawn multiple times?
save and load
Alec Baldwin in red dead?
i-i-i tried to save him he died in front of me
😂😂😂never seen this in story
Bro how to play same side mission again n again?
Actually You can't.. I save the game file before the encounter
i done lassomove and sed him to the jail