History of the Berber Languages
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ก.พ. 2022
- History of the Berber Languages, Libyco-Berber, Northern Berber, Western Berber, Old Libyan, Eastern Berber, Kabyle, Southern Berber, Guanche, Atlas, Zenati, Tuareg, Zenaga, Tetserret, Tashelhit, Central Middle Atlas, Sanhaja de Srair, Ghomara, Mzab-Wargla, Riffian, Eastern Middle Atlas, Shenwa, East Zenati
Music:
Turn - The Tower of Light
Jal - Edge of Water - Aakash Gandhi
![[Watch Party] APL 2024 ใครชนะเข้ารอบ Hydra 🆚 Flash Wolves Talon 🆚 GGLive](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BvuSgyLy4hA/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm moroccan from the atlas, we are still millions in morocco speaking berber 💪🏼
This video is better than 100 books
Thank you very much
Do you believe in the Atlas = Atlantis theory at the Richot Structure?
@@biggie_boss what is that?
aren't all of you berber , the only difference is whether you know berber or not
@@flingstone1510 Exactly
I'm Berber from Algeria, I still speak Berber my mother tongue and PROUD
where can i learn to speak tamazight? i am a berber from morocco
@@vonibu in morocco there is many millions speak tamazight
You should be
Long live numidia kingdom
@@vonibu Before learning anything, first research about your particular amazight language because there are many.
im from the canary islands and i did a dna test, i had 40% north african, i was shocked but its nice to see my ancestor spoke a unique language
You might have Guanche ancestry, perhaps? Southern Portuguese have an unusually high percentage of African ancestry as well. Cristiano Ronaldo maternal Grandmother was from Cape Verde, if I recall correctly, she migrated to Madeira. That would make him 1/16 African, which possibly the reason his son is so dark skinned. The mother is unknown.
@@DionysiosPhryx Two questions: How does having one African grandparent make someone 1/16 African. It should make him 1/4 African. Or do African genes work differently? Also, how the hell is the mother of his son "unknown"? 😅 Did he give birth?
@@John_Jim It seems like you are not familiar with that country, right? Do you even realise that Cape Verde was uninhabited when European sailors arrived there? Cape Verdeans are already mixed. We do not know who the mother of the child is for whatever reason. Ask Ronaldo why.
Mudman
@@DionysiosPhryx Sick burn, mate. I'm very much familiar with Cape Verde. I'm just baffled by why you drew the conclusion exactly 1/16. Are all Cape Verdeans exactly 1/4 African or what?
i'm a Berber from Morocco, proud of my culture and language..ⴰⵣⵓⵍ ⵉ ⵎⴰⵔⵔⴰ ⵏⵉⵎⴰⵣⵉⵖⵏ
An interesting writing system
@@xstar9567
ⵜⴰⵏⵎⵎⵉⵔⵜ🙏🏻❤️
It means thanks...spelt : thanmmirt
المغرب دولة عربية و يحيى الاتحاد المغرب العربي ⚫⚪🔴
Berbers are an Amazigh people!
@@saadismaili227 ⵓⵀⵓ
Im Chaoui from the Aures region in Algeria and im very proud to be Amazigh ♓
me too
Riffian/Tarifit the native language of my mother! Amazing video. Can't wait for a 'Spread of Afro-Asiatic languages' video.
Thank you very much
Mudman
@@geoDB. ?
je tarifiyt is ta3rabt geworden!!!
mijn tmazight is puur tmazight geen arabisçh woorden!!!
iziyaan atlas gebergte
@@yoessfndranguetta6668 Ik gebruik soms darija woorden in mn Riffijns maar meestal gewoon Tamazight
Proud to be Berber 💪💪💪💪💪💪
Azul
Restore numida kingdom
@@rickyyacine4818 numidia =🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿only algeria
Amazigh. Not bereber
@@gigiout7895 Numidia 🇩🇿ⵣ💪🏼
Proud to be Moroccan Riffian Amazigh 💙
Me too
أنا من المغرب انا أمازيغي من أكادير
I'm Libyan and proud Amazigh, im from a small city called Zuwara, and they call us At Welol.
Good to se an amazigh from libya azul broski
@@aghyrasaitwayagher1196 Azul my brother
Amazigh LybieAzul Ayouma from Rif.
Where's amazigh spoken in Libya ?
@@sarinasbelhocine3400 town called Zuwara and Nafusa mountains it’s couple of cities there as well
ⵜⵓⴷⵔⵜ ⵉ ⵜⵎⴰⵣⵉⵖⵜ
Long live Berber
Dear Berbers, protect and preserve your culture and your language, assimilation is genocide. Love from your Muslim Circassian brothers ❤
Thank you, we're resisting 💔
I'm amazigh and my native berber language is kabylian language 🥰❤️
I'm from Morocco ( agadir City), im berber (amazigh) , best wishes for al Berbers
I'm kabyle from Algeria, greeting to my Amazigh brothers
Amazigh languages are the sisters of our Egyptian Language 🤩💙 Man you're a great Greek TH-camr. Please make a video for the spread of the Egyptian writing systems: Pre-dynastic proto-Egyptian Hieroglyphics, Dynastic Egyptian Hieroglyphics, Egyptian cursive Hieroglyphics, Egyptian Hieratic, Egyptian cursive Hieratic, Egyptian Demotic, Egyptian Coptic Alphabet & Egyptian Proto-Sinatic Alphabet
NO Amazigh people are not related to Arabs. Amazighs are native to North Africa, but Araps are not.
@@moorishsociety7339 No one mentioned Arabs, read before writing.
@@ASMM1981EGY Yes I read it, you said Egypt right ? Egypt doesn't belong to Amazigh nation. So stick to your Arab brothers in Arabia.
@@moorishsociety7339 Egypt is Egyptian ⲩⲟⲡ ɟⲟⲟɭ neither Amazigh nor Arab. Genetically Amazigh are blood brothers of Egyptian North Africans.
@@ASMM1981EGY The only amazigh people in Egypt are those in Siwa oasis which Egypt iIIegaIy annexed from Lybia with the help of british during world war I.
I'm amazigh from north of Morocco, exactly in Rif-alhoceima, people here still speak TAMAZIGHT/TARIFIT
I'm sure the old Libyan had also it's own branches but sadly there's not enough studies on the Libyco-Berber languages to prove this
Unfortunately north African governments support Arabisation and Arab nationalism so they limit every way to study ancient berber history .
this's because no scientists could explore Libya because of the Libyan crisis, I wish it'll be ended and prove to the world that Libya has one of the oldest civilizations and isn't just a "Bedouin" country.
But be aware that This video isnt 100% accurate especially not in the period of the middle ages
The Libyan peoples, who are the origin of Northwest Africa, originated from the Middle East, emigrated from Palestine today, and they are the descendants of Canaan bin Ham bin Noah. As for the fact that the Libyans are a different race, this is an illusion because all human beings are descendants of Noah, because the flood destroyed all of creation except for Noah and those with him from the creatures in his ark. Which is mentioned in all the heavenly books
@@Mahmoud_El3alewi This theory has been debunked by genetic studies
I’ve been waiting for this one for a while, thank you
I'm glad you like it
Good job.thank you for the video.amazigh from Morocco
Thank you
I believe that our language is deeply older than it's demonstrated in this video. Great work though. Thank you
Thank you
As a Berber my self.
The Berber language tree is 5000-4700 years old so it's accurate.
You shoudn't count the Capsian culture, Iberomaurusian and Cardial culture. They were our ancestors but weren’t Berbers(in those times ethnic groups didn't exist)
@@Revitalization4241 when those cultures mix they became. Modern people have a habit of grouping cultures together. Even though that's too early and they were separate. People should know it's much later when they mix and became something.
@@Revitalization4241 Wrong, Capsian culture is Pre-Proto-Berber. While Iberomaurisian spoke an Afroasiatic language, buts its unsure whether its Para-Afroasiatic or some other Afroasiatic language.
@@Revitalization4241 in the beginning Maybe but Around the middle ages it became reaaaaally inaccurate
YES! I've long waited for this! Sinitic or Sino-tibetan might make for a good video, though I understand that would take a long time and a lot of effort to make
Thank you. In the future I want to expand into East Asian languages
I have been waiting for this language family to have its video. Its nice to see its history in details. Good video, once again!
Thank you
Been looking forward to this one!
Your videos are amazing, so helpful.
Thank you
Love your videos! 💞
Thank you
Thank you for uploading this video 👍🔥🌹
ناس ليبيا ههههه
@@charafcharaf4076 انا من المغرب 🤷♂️
In Morocco about 50% still speak the Berber Languages.
about (14.230.000 to 18.290.000)
Morocco's population is 36.7 Million (estimated)
8-10 Million Tachelhit
3-5 Million Central Atlas Tamazight
3 Million Riffian
150.000-200.000 East Atlas Tamazight
50.000 Sanhaja Srair
20.000-30.000 Figuig
10.000 Ghomari
Amazing video, keep up the good work!
Thank you very much
الأمازيغية من لغات الإفريقية المحلية بشمال إفريقيا 🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦💗💗🌷 وتعتبر اللغة الأولى فبلادي 😉💗 يعترف بها الدستور المغربي
اللغة الثانية* اللغة الاولى هي العربية
I'm Hawwari Berber from Libya and I'm proud, thank you!
You're welcome :)
the hawwara tribe is also big in upper egypt. they came there from morocco in the middle age.
@@zombieat Hawwari are originally from Tripolitania, they migrated to Egypt and western North Africa.
Hawwari's are probaly the most Arabised Berbers from all Berbers, and in Morocco(Houara-Lahlafe, Houara Ouled Teima) they mixed alot with Arabs
@Karzus from which tribe are you
@@Revitalization4241 Karatjih, Yedder
Great work thank you!
Thank you
Greetings to our brothers amazigh around the world, love from Algeria
Awesome bro !
Thank you
Very good video to be honest, and thanks a lot for making a video about berber languages, I waited someone to do this for a long time
Thank you
I was just looking for this exact video yesterday and found that it didn’t exist. The timing could hardly have been better!
Love Amazighs Berber brothers from Albania 🇦🇱🤝♓
@spipo "Islam" is a religion not a race 😂..
Azul love to albania too 👍🏻👍🏻
@@loppino007 45% of Albanians have North african dna Haplogroup E
@@DZRESPECT Cool.. Didn't know that ☺️👍
@@DZRESPECT what? Can you elaborate?
As Tunisian From Berber origin I can speak some words 🌹 🇹🇳🌹
ⵜⵉⴼⵉⵏⴰⵖ
And Arabian To
Azul
what berber languages are in tunisia? shawiya, zuwara and ghadames?
Arabian(عربي )
Arabic (العربية)
Hi I'm from kabylie and we thank you for the video
Good video as always👏
Thank you
Kabyle ♓✌️amazigh
Hhh rak fi kol place
Thank you so much.... personally my parents are berber from Algeria nd i am so happy to see that❤
I'm glad you like it
Will you ever revisit History of Slavic Languages? In comparison to your other fantastic videos it is of much lower quality.
After completing a series of videos I will return to the older
Thank you very much, good job
Great work 👍
Thank you very much
Thanks from Algeria 🇩🇿 ♓
Good job
Thank you
Awesome Bro! 😎👌🏻
Thank you
Great video.
Thank you
Nice work on the animation.
Thank you
Love the work, could you possibly do the Dravidian languages?
Thank you. Yes I would like to make it later
@@CostasMelas can you make Austronesian?
Awesome 😍
Thank you
This video is so beautiful! Would you be doing a video on Sinotibetan languages? They first spread down here in Southeast Asia during the 17th century apparently (at least, that's what my textbook says)
Thank you
17th century? for sino-tibetan, definitely no. for sinitic, at least for definite provable sources for sinitic at least in the philippines for maritime southeast asia, but i dont bet that as well, since around 1590, the disputed first ever printed book in the philippines is also a christian doctrine book written in full chinese characters by spanish missionaries they made from local sangley chinese living in the philippines by then. they made it planning to minister in china. book is in hokkien or that mixed with classical chinese. i have a pdf copy of it. anyways, centuries before that, there were already chinese celadon pottery trade goods found dated even older to like tang to song dynasty times as well and those are bound to have chinese writing on them as well. tho, i bet continental southeast asia like vietnam, myanmar, thailand, etc. has even more ancient sinitic or sino-tibetan influences far beyond those times. i remember seeing thai has a bunch of loanwords loaned from middle chinese, so that goes far back. vietnam even had almost a millennia being ruled under han dynasty... and myanmar is literally dominated by tibeto-burman groups lol
I'm a proud Kabyle from Algeria
Nice vidéo
Thank you
I am looking forward to ‘Spread of Austroasiatic languages’, please!
proud libyan here thank you for this amazing video
modern arabic is not a libyan language but its heavily influenced by old libyan.
we still speak it but only certain parts of libya.
I hope that the Libyans can return their identity, as most Libyans are genetically and originally Berbers.
@@y3s7_ we already have our identity
@@tariqalmukhtar6595 a fake arab identity
@@tariqalmukhtar6595 a fake one
@@laureal3659 I was born with this Identity, my parents were born with it, my grand parents as well, my grand grand parents and so on. Do you really want me to leave it for an imagend ideas devoloped by western archaeologists!!!
Great work , Can I put this video on my channel with berber music ? I will put your channel name as the original source of the video
I'm a berber from Tunisia ❤ we still have our culture and language
I see that you are doing many African language families now. Very nice👍
He finished
@@ZachRULES96 no, there's still pygmy languages and khoisan languages (it's not really a family anymore it has been refused by linguists)
@@ZachRULES96 he has even done Chadic, talkless of Khoi-San.
Defend this language from Arabs!! 🛡️
This language is still spoken by many people. Some of these people are also bi lingual and fluent in Arabic which is a good thing.
great work
Thank you
Great job ✔️👌
Thank you
My language is Amazigh or Berber and I am proud to be an Amazigh and I respect every language
It has declined continuously with the arrival of Arabic.
Yes.
@@qaz1001
Yet it has killed other indigenous languages of the region they conquered.
@@user-nc5yc9es6j not everywhere. Iran and Turkish people did not despite Iran so close to Arabia and became muslim well before North Africa, due to the fact that Iranians are indo-europeans.. Arabic only killed other branches of Afro- Asiatics due to shared ethnic and linguistic roots. This version update was seen throughout history of Semitic people from Akkadien to Babylonien and Assyrian and Amorites to Aramaic and finally Arabic. It almost happened every millennium.
@@ashraftarabishi831 Arabic also killed poor African Romance language
Its steady now and has around 20 to 30 million speakers
well done mate... well done
Thank you
the language is slightly older but nice video. Greetings from a riffian
In Algeria, there is as you shown, Kabyle, Touareg, also others as Chawian, Chenwian, hadrian, Prussian, thadouklian
Prussian in Algeria?
They were replaced at the coastal areas and were able to survive in the mountains and in the desert, basically. Same dynamics can be seen in the Caucasus mountains with the languages that survived there or the Basque language.
History of Every Mountain People Ever:
*People group wander to this place...
"Nice place!"
*New dominant people group wander to this place...
"Oh no! Scary people come to rule the lowlands!!"
"Retreat to the highlands!!"
*Several centuries or millennia later...
Bunch a mountain peeps
@@xXxSkyViperxXx And then there is the reverse case when the mountain people have to come down because of a lack of work and resources.
Greetings from Czech republic and welcome back!😂
Do you think about making Khoe-Kwadi and other Khoisan languages and/or Pygmy languages (Twa, Cwa, etc...) ?
Also great work, I see that you like to know the origins of languages just like me, I'm glad I've found your channel
Thanks. They are difficult families but I will love to make them in the future
ثم يأتيك واحد غايح من بولسارية يقول الجمهوريةوالعربية الصحراوية وهوا لاتاريخ لا والو والارض هاذبك ساكنينهل الامازيغ قبل مايسكن هوا الحزيرة 😂😂😂🇩🇿❤️🇲🇦❤️
البربر باعوا معظم أراضيهم للعرب
هذه حقيقة
Im so proud to be amazigh man. From east of algeria (Chaoui.) And still speak my mother tongue Tamazight with the chaoui variable.
The video is great, but I have a little comment. We Amazighs do not prefer the name Berber or the Berber language, but rather the name Amazigh or the tamazighth language. But thank you anyway
. Azul felawn imazighn mani hallam.
Are you from the Nemencha tribe
@@Revitalization4241 no im from hrakta tribe. From An area between Ain Al-Bayda and Khenchela called Fkirina
@@samominouch5687ah intresting, may i ask you what your sub tribe is?
@@Revitalization4241 im from a tribe called. ayth bou3ziz
@@samominouch5687 A one of the Berber origin tribes nice, unfortunately Haraktas has many Arab sub tribes. But you got luckly that you belong to a Berber one
Amazigh subscriber from morocco♓🇲🇦
I speak 2 dialect of tamazight Eastern middle Atlas bni warayn language from my mother and Kabylian from my father and I can find the link between the two dialects
Thanks for this precious video
Excellent.
I knew the Berber/Tamazight languages were diverse, but not this much.
I did. Which is why I think Berber is a language family not a language. Like Semitic is a language family not a language
Thank you
@@noahtylerpritchett2682 but Semitic is way larger concept than Amazigh though
@@noahtylerpritchett2682
No tamazight or berber laguages are part s of the same language cause in midlle ages (before 16-17 centuries) masmoudi or zenati or sanhaji ... could inderstand all amazigh languages
The division is just the result of tribal leagues and confederations
@@ilyas8597 I can't imagine you applying that same logic for Semites then will you?
greetings from Turkey
💛❤💚kurdistan
@@devran8123 bunu benim yorumumun altına yazma amacın ne ?
@@s.ayenigeldim3687 öylesin yazdım
@@devran8123 sktrlan öylesine yazmışmış git başka yere yaz yorumunu
@@s.ayenigeldim3687 bu bana takıntılı her yerde Türk düşmanlığı yapıyor çok boş birisi
THANK YOU SIR
Thank you for the information. North Africa is all Berber Amazigh.
Its a land of amazigh and amazigh are the native ones here
But we who's Arabic is our first language are still existing come on 😂
@@ju6284 you guys where imazighen but replaced tamazight with arabic so you are still imazighen
@@aghyrasaitwayagher1196 Majoirity are not Berbers.
@@Revitalization4241 majority are amazigh genetically just not in linguistic terma
@@aghyrasaitwayagher1196 The only accurate kind of DNA testing is haplogroup tests or Y-DNA testing. However many people misundertsand haplogroup testing, they automatically think if someone has haplogroup E-M81 he is a Berber or if he has J1c he is a Arab, but thats untrue. Non Berbers can also have haplogroup E-M81, many Berbers nowdays have haplogroup G and many Arabs have other haplogroups like haplogroup T, this has to do with neolithic culture migrations, many Berbers have haplogroup G because in the neolithic period the early European farmers mixed with our ancestors( the Iberomaurusian and Capsian Culture ), same story for the Arabs, if a Arab doesn't have haplogroup J1c it doesnt mean he is not of Arab origin, it's most likely that he got his haplogroup from the neolithic period.
By the way mixed race people who aren't pure bredded Berbers can also have haplogroup E-M81 but it still doens't make them Berber because their origin is still mixed and they are still mix race people.
And!! did you know E-M81 was also present in the Levant, it probaly came from the Mushabian traits that the Natufians took and spread it around the Levant, thats why E-M81 isn't called the Berber marker anymore since it was more widespread than people tought, Syrian Arabs could have also spread some E-M81 into Africa when they invaded North Africa
Autosomal DNA/Ancestory DNA testing is very inaccurate, have you ever wonderd why DNA companies show different results from each other, also if you gonna upload your results into Gedmatch your results will be come out differnetly, if you have 90% so called north african dna it can be 40% if you upload it on Gedmatch, and it's only a tiny fraction of your DNA
Btw Myheritage is the most cheapest and fakest dna test company(it's the most used one by North Africans)
Like you and other Imazighen & North Africans you misunderstand genetics
Greetings from Italy! So sad see these languages fade. What is their status nowadays? Are they protected or still risking extinction?
These languages are still spoking and have governmal recognisition to be the second language of morroco and Algeria beside the Arabic
They arent near anywhere near risking extinction. Quote from wikipedia: ''Thus, the total number of speakers of Berber languages in the Maghreb proper appears to lie anywhere between 16 and 25 million, depending on which estimate is accepted; if we take Basset's estimate, it could be as high as 30 million. The vast majority are concentrated in Morocco and Algeria. The Tuareg of the Sahel adds another million or so to the total.'' and that's excluding the nearly 2 million berber people living in Europe and around the world.
@@TSGC16 A high number of speakers doesn't necessarily imply safety from extinction. If the speakers of a particular language are almost all adults, and their children are growing up speaking a more prestigious language (such as Arabic or a European language), then the language will be approaching extinction once the adults start dying off.
@@omp199 Yes, but almost all Berbers are at least multilingual. Speaking a Berber language first and then followed by Moroccan/Algerian/Tunisian Darija, and then maybe French or English as well.
@@TSGC16 he is right as a riffan my parents haven't teach me how to speak riffan berber and most of this new generation havent as well
Great ! I am Tunisian Berbere 👍♥️
This is so cool
Wonderful video like
Thank you
Sad that arabisation is taking over all these unique, native languages and cultures in MENA :(
@Takanashi Rikka's PSP 3000 It survived but only in Churches
i am tourgui from algeria 🇩🇿
Thanks to you sir ...
your loyal follower from kabyles ♓♓♓♓
Thank you for the support
Good job Costa Mela
Thank you
@@CostasMelas no problom
I’m Libyan and I want to learn the tamashek language but I don’t know how to learn from?
Why would you even learn it ???
@@Skikdii because its a beautiful language and very intresting
Great video but 4500 years ago the Saharan desert had a quite different geography I think for these long running mapping videos it would be more elaborate to show the various ancient lakes that existed there back then because the motion of the patches of berber across the desert doesn't seem to make as much sense without these shown!
Otherwise great video as always!
Thank you. For the last 5000 years, it remains at about the same because the African humid period ended between 4000 and 3000 BC
The Green Sahara lost its rainfall around 4000 BC and the Sahara had completely desertified by 3000 BC. So the map is fine.
Super ! Merci pour le partage. Une petite critique. L'ADN des anciens Amazigh révèle qu'ils existent plus de 5 000 an av-jc au sud du Maroc. C'est l'ADN qui le montre donc je pense que l'ancienneté de la langue Amazigh commence au sud du Maroc et non pas à l'EST. Puis, la langue s'est propagé de l'ouest à l'est jusqu'à l'Égypte. D'ailleurs, on trouve pleins de similitudes des mots à l'époque des pharaons de -3000 et le tamazight.
Tamazight révèle comme toujours la langue la plus vieille au monde !
you should make the history of the khoisan languages
Anyone got any information to share as to the languages spoken BEFORE Berber in the Maghreb? Surely there have been some observations made by linguists about possible substrata in the modern languages or traces preserved in toponymy?!
languages that are related to afro asiatics or extint branches of it
the ancients slumber by the grave. they are by now dust to history's victors
there isn't no much study even about old-lybian ; but personally I think it's an extinct branch of Afro-Asiatic.
Hope the Pan Arab governments fall for a new non oppressive one so that historical studies could be done on the area .
Nilo-Saharan and Niger-Congo in the desert(before Sahara desertification), probably Chadic, paleo-european languages along the coast(coming the European farmers) and other extinct languages
@Yo the thing that those common characteristic are basically Islamic heritage from the many caliphatsles and Islamic state throughout Africa and Asia ,and no pan Arabism is an ideology that isn't dead today , it's in every textbook and every media channel in every country that's under the Arab league,just today it got way closer to liberalism than socialism like the last century because of changing world order that's why it's trying to incorporate now many of non Arab ethnicities into what's called Arab-Islamic identity (more liberal pan Arabism).
Thank you for this video , I ame Berber
You're welcome :)
@@CostasMelas ❤❤❤❤
We are so proud about this amazighin language
nice video
Thank you
Arabization Policies😔
😐
Northern Africa = Arabized Berbers and Copts
I am from north africa I dont speak berber but i am lerning it. Nekni imazighen
Impresionante y riguroso. Refleja el impacto cartagines... Y sobretodo, su arrinconiento progresivo en favor del idioma arábigo.
Wow , half of the continent is AMAZIGH
هدا الفيديو بطيضهر ان المغرب كان كله امازيغ قبل سياسة التعريب
و السبب هو الامازيغ انفسهم بتخليهم عن لغتهم
4:20 بدات سياسة التعريب فالمغرب من 1260م ؟
@@rtr0_insn323
هل تعتمد على اللغة في تحديد الهوية
العربية دخلت دخول الاسلام كما اخدها الفرس و الترك كخط لكتابة لغتهم
@@ziadidabde3662 الخط لكتابة لغة مش بحال النطق بلغة و نعم اللغة جزء من الهوية ديال شعب
@@rtr0_insn323 ننطق بالدارجة خليط من العربية و الامازيغية و الفرنسية و ليس اللغة العربية الفصحى و هناك من لا يفهم الدارجة اصلا
و العربية الفصحى لولا تعلمنا لها في المدارس لما اتقناها اصلا هي ايضا و خير مثال الاميين منا لا يفقهون الفصحى
@@ziadidabde3662 الاكثرية الساحقة من الكلمات الموجودة في الدارجة عندها أصل عربي و كاللهجات للبلدان العربية الاخرى هي ليست كالفصحى ، لا يوجد يا اخي اي بلد عربي يتكلم بالفصحى كل بلد له لهجته و المغرب كذلك
Hello i am kabyle berber from algeria 🇩🇿😎👌
Nice
i proud to be morrocan berber🥰