The monks of St. Catherine's Monastery at the foot of Mount Sinai, built between 548 & 565, and is the world's oldest continuously inhabited Christian monastery, have records documenting Muhammad staying in the monastery periodically as a child when his nomadic tribe passed through during travel. Father Justin who currently is in charge of the monastery's library also has a document hanging on the wall & encased in glass called the 'Ashtiname of Muhammad', also known as the 'Covenant of Muhammad', which is a charter penned by Muhammad's scribe granting protection and other privileges to the "followers of Jesus", given to the monks at the monastery.
So in conclusion, yes he did exist, but it was so long ago that we can't be sure. As a Muslim, I also believe in the Exodus which according to scholars also probably didn't happen, so suspension of disbelief cones naturally, but I'm glad the answer wasn't a simple no
@@TheHistoryHubsno it isnt, because neither is the quran historically backed neither are the hadiths or the sirat. And even if a guy named „the praised one“ existed in pagan arabia, he wasnt a prophet of the historical monotheistic religion
We know many details about Muhammad pbuh and how we was. it’s not in the Quran because the message God sent Mohammed pbuh is to praise God and no one else. Muhammad pbuh explicitly said on many occasional to not worship him and to only worship God.
The first account of prophet Mohammed is Quran and Hadeeth which both have a chaine of narration that goes all the way to the prophet and his companions, and Ibn Isshaq and Ibn Hisham rely on this for their books .
popat momad did exist and he was popat for the barbaric credo of animal instincts and still is. But time eradicates the existence of the great and the vile as there is shift in Age ........ as we shift from this Iron Age back into the Bronze Age history eradicates the existence of older stalwarts - great spiritual gurus or vile popats. What was Popat momad. History shall make that clear in time. The more longer time frame. Perhaps the vile do not go beyond the Age in which they exist. Only the really spiritual go beyond that as the sages and rishis.
But why did the angel Gabriel pin him to the ground an forces him to do his will ,he never did that to Mary ,also he spoke to Moses face to face .I thought free will is mans right that's why God gave Moses commandments an not on one occasion did God directly speak to Muhammad so how can it be god's words ????
Also there are the monks of St. Catherine's Monastery at the foot of Mount Sinai, built between 548 & 565, and is the world's oldest continuously inhabited Christian monastery, have records documenting Muhammad staying in the monastery periodically as a child when his nomadic tribe passed through during travel. Father Justin who is in charge of the monastery's library also has a document hanging on the wall called the 'Ashtiname of Muhammad', also known as the 'Covenant of Muhammad', which is a charter penned by Muhammad's scribe granting protection and other privileges to the "followers of Jesus", given to the monks at the monastery.
@@Ajmolali82 which proves he was alive , but you have to remember,there's part of Quran burnt , it was still wrote by man ♂️,an if you know your commandments you'll know Muhammad broke nearly all . An still when he went to Jews to confirm himself the thing's they ask off him are non complaint ,when many other prophets of God had no problems.Can a God become a man ? Can he be a bush ? .
While i believe his existence. How do we know more about the revelations her received. Who was present during such revelations or its only his words about the revelations?
Muhammad wasn't born yet. Its talk about future coming servant of god. Jesus come to approve what had been before. He guide human to the truth(triumph) and say i am khattamun nabiy??
The coins are not proof because they have crucifixes on them and the name Mohammed is simply a nickname that means "beloved". Could simply be referencing Christ
Selman amca bizi peygamber ailesini düşüş biraktilar Biziim ve herkesin Şu parasını öde konu kapandı Babam OLUCEM diye uyudu annemi Babami Tugceyi Göktuğ Ferruyu Korumassaniz Ben ölürüm İntaar degil
@kansasscout4322 il n'y a aucun débat là-dessus sur l'existence du Prophète car le l'épreuve de son existence sont les musulmans ont été très fort dès le début leur tradition en perpétuer il n'y a aucune raison de douter de l'existence du prophète Même si j'accepte d'esprit critique des personnes Car c'est avec l L'esprit critique la recherche plutôt la vérité qu'arrivent à des résultats
Joshua fought in battles described in Joshua 1:1-11, 5:13-6:27, and 10:7-15. Deborah fought in battles described in Judges Jonathan fought in battles described in 1 Samuel 14.
Gideon was a military leader, judge and prophet whose calling and victory over the Midianites are recounted in Judges 6-8 of the Book of Judges in both the Hebrew Bible and the Christian Bible. 1 Kings 18:40: "And Elijah said unto them, Take the prophets of Baal; let not one of them escape. And they took them: and Elijah brought them down to the brook Kishon, and slew them there." Again the voice of Elijah is heard in startling words of command to the people: "Take the prophets of Baal; let not one of them escape." The people are ready to obey his word. They seize the false prophets [286] who have deluded them, and bring them to the brook Kishon, and there, with his own hand, Elijah slays these idolatrous priests. 3T 285.1
No he was a cartoon character the Japanese had a thing called Kabuki theater with paper cartoon characters so one of ixlams teachers made his own version of Kabuki theater and his main cartoon character was this paper cut of a jolly ole chap Muhammad and some numb nuts went and wrote a book about this Kabuki theater character and called it the Quran and made up a bunch of bullshit to make tons of money cause they didn't discover oil just yet so he had to have plan to become rich and his cartoon character Muhammad was his mission and then he turned it in to a religion of sorts so he could become as a God
THERE IS NOT EXITANCE MUHMMAD 8YH CENTURY WRITE IN QURAN ABBASI TIME WRITE IN QURAN EXMUSLIM ATHEIST IN INDIA YOU JOIN TH-cam CHANNEL ZAFAR HERETIC ENGLISH YOU JOIN TH-cam CHANNEL NABI ASLI YOU JOIN TH-cam CHANNEL HARRIS SULTAN
You lost me when you said Mecca was a bustling trade route. That has been disapproved!
Doubting his none existence poses another difficult challenge: the origin of the Quran!
@@josephalison12 a manuscripts with the best bits put together
Even the Romans who hated jesus still wrote about him ,an how come there's no evidence of the moon spliting by anyone?
No one wrote about him contemporarily, it was all after the “crucifixion”
The monks of St. Catherine's Monastery at the foot of Mount Sinai, built between 548 & 565, and is the world's oldest continuously inhabited Christian monastery, have records documenting Muhammad staying in the monastery periodically as a child when his nomadic tribe passed through during travel. Father Justin who currently is in charge of the monastery's library also has a document hanging on the wall & encased in glass called the 'Ashtiname of Muhammad', also known as the 'Covenant of Muhammad', which is a charter penned by Muhammad's scribe granting protection and other privileges to the "followers of Jesus", given to the monks at the monastery.
@mindfulconversation can that be proven ???? .
The earliest source for jesus was hundreds of years after his death
@derekmeade1741 really ?
💎🏆 Great insightful & fruitful video 🏆💎
लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु
( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )
So in conclusion, yes he did exist, but it was so long ago that we can't be sure. As a Muslim, I also believe in the Exodus which according to scholars also probably didn't happen, so suspension of disbelief cones naturally, but I'm glad the answer wasn't a simple no
Prophet Muhammad's existence is backed by various historical records and writings.
@@TheHistoryHubs well, that's even better
Bu aq ya w3ğ@@TheHistoryHubs
@@TheHistoryHubsno it isnt, because neither is the quran historically backed neither are the hadiths or the sirat. And even if a guy named „the praised one“ existed in pagan arabia, he wasnt a prophet of the historical monotheistic religion
He send letters to leaders of his times we have a whole biography we can trace back his family to Abraham
We know many details about Muhammad pbuh and how we was. it’s not in the Quran because the message God sent Mohammed pbuh is to praise God and no one else. Muhammad pbuh explicitly said on many occasional to not worship him and to only worship God.
police be upon him
The first account of prophet Mohammed is Quran and Hadeeth which both have a chaine of narration that goes all the way to the prophet and his companions, and Ibn Isshaq and Ibn Hisham rely on this for their books .
If Pro Mo did exist, he lifted the entire story of going to heaven to hang out with Allah on a magical horse... from an old Zoroastrian source...
No
popat momad did exist and he was popat for the barbaric credo of animal instincts and still is. But time eradicates the existence of the great and the vile as there is shift in Age ........ as we shift from this Iron Age back into the Bronze Age history eradicates the existence of older stalwarts - great spiritual gurus or vile popats. What was Popat momad. History shall make that clear in time. The more longer time frame. Perhaps the vile do not go beyond the Age in which they exist. Only the really spiritual go beyond that as the sages and rishis.
Mate he was shown the 7 heavens. He wasn't hanging out with god.
What about the tomb of prophet muhammad in medina and also his various letters to the kings of rome and persia which still exist in museums.
But why did the angel Gabriel pin him to the ground an forces him to do his will ,he never did that to Mary ,also he spoke to Moses face to face .I thought free will is mans right that's why God gave Moses commandments an not on one occasion did God directly speak to Muhammad so how can it be god's words ????
Are you willing to have his remains exhumed? You will find nothing
Also there are the monks of St. Catherine's Monastery at the foot of Mount Sinai, built between 548 & 565, and is the world's oldest continuously inhabited Christian monastery, have records documenting Muhammad staying in the monastery periodically as a child when his nomadic tribe passed through during travel. Father Justin who is in charge of the monastery's library also has a document hanging on the wall called the 'Ashtiname of Muhammad', also known as the 'Covenant of Muhammad', which is a charter penned by Muhammad's scribe granting protection and other privileges to the "followers of Jesus", given to the monks at the monastery.
@@Ajmolali82 which proves he was alive , but you have to remember,there's part of Quran burnt , it was still wrote by man ♂️,an if you know your commandments you'll know Muhammad broke nearly all . An still when he went to Jews to confirm himself the thing's they ask off him are non complaint ,when many other prophets of God had no problems.Can a God become a man ? Can he be a bush ? .
Found the triggered Muslim
*”The 6th and 7th centuries AD were tumultuous times in the middle east..”*
What centuries weren’t tumultuous times in the middle east?! 😂
Ummayad MHMD is not the same as Abbasid Muhammad. Different persons altogether
Muhammad is a historical figure. There are Syriac manuscripts dating back to the seventh century AD.
No... Nooooo..... Nooooooo... Never..
FLavius Josephus was jew, non Christian, contemporary of Jesus.
If you say something negative, you will be chased by fanatics whole life 👹
Oh yeahhh… and they will eat you alive…😂
Does the Time/God exist?? 010
Astaghfirullah
I'm sorry if I offend you, but it's good to know what the evidence is.
@@TheHistoryHubs Case and point.
Love From Afghanistan:
Not only Mohammed,from Adam to Jesus are fairy.
If there is God or Allah,must answer (Online).
While i believe his existence. How do we know more about the revelations her received. Who was present during such revelations or its only his words about the revelations?
Muhammad wasn't born yet. Its talk about future coming servant of god. Jesus come to approve what had been before. He guide human to the truth(triumph) and say i am khattamun nabiy??
Muhammad a Prophet , carrying a sword with a 10yr bride?
10 YEARS OLD BRIDE????? ARE YOU SUREEE???? OH MY …. WHAT A PIDOPHILE…A CHILD ABUSER….IF IT HAPPENED IN THIS ERA….15 YEARS IN PRISON.
The coins are not proof because they have crucifixes on them and the name Mohammed is simply a nickname that means "beloved". Could simply be referencing Christ
As an Arabic scholar, let me inform you that Muhammad means praised.
Now include the work of Dan Gibson in here, and ask the quesrion again.
BUYRUN BURADAN YAKIN ..!..
Nonsense
Nope
Him and his companions graves are in Makkah for you to see now
@@shamiekhan5356okay why they dont at least proof that thats actually a grave and not a pagan worship building?
Selman amca bizi peygamber ailesini düşüş biraktilar
Biziim ve herkesin
Şu parasını öde konu kapandı
Babam OLUCEM diye uyudu annemi
Babami
Tugceyi
Göktuğ
Ferruyu
Korumassaniz
Ben ölürüm
İntaar degil
What an ignorant load of tosh!
This is stupid islam isnt maya is a strong civilisation from the beginning
we can see how advanced you are.
@kansasscout4322 il n'y a aucun débat là-dessus sur l'existence du Prophète car le l'épreuve de son existence sont les musulmans ont été très fort dès le début leur tradition en perpétuer il n'y a aucune raison de douter de l'existence du prophète Même si j'accepte d'esprit critique des personnes Car c'est avec l L'esprit critique la recherche plutôt la vérité qu'arrivent à des résultats
LOL
A Prophet with a sword?.Absurd!
Joshua fought in battles described in Joshua 1:1-11, 5:13-6:27, and 10:7-15.
Deborah fought in battles described in Judges
Jonathan fought in battles described in 1 Samuel 14.
Gideon was a military leader, judge and prophet whose calling and victory over the Midianites are recounted in Judges 6-8 of the Book of Judges in both the Hebrew Bible and the Christian Bible.
1 Kings 18:40: "And Elijah said unto them, Take the prophets of Baal; let not one of them escape. And they took them: and Elijah brought them down to the brook Kishon, and slew them there."
Again the voice of Elijah is heard in startling words of command to the people: "Take the prophets of Baal; let not one of them escape." The people are ready to obey his word. They seize the false prophets [286] who have deluded them, and bring them to the brook Kishon, and there, with his own hand, Elijah slays these idolatrous priests. 3T 285.1
No he was a cartoon character the Japanese had a thing called Kabuki theater with paper cartoon characters so one of ixlams teachers made his own version of Kabuki theater and his main cartoon character was this paper cut of a jolly ole chap Muhammad and some numb nuts went and wrote a book about this Kabuki theater character and called it the Quran and made up a bunch of bullshit to make tons of money cause they didn't discover oil just yet so he had to have plan to become rich and his cartoon character Muhammad was his mission and then he turned it in to a religion of sorts so he could become as a God
THERE IS NOT EXITANCE MUHMMAD
8YH CENTURY WRITE IN QURAN
ABBASI TIME WRITE IN QURAN EXMUSLIM ATHEIST IN INDIA
YOU JOIN TH-cam CHANNEL ZAFAR HERETIC ENGLISH
YOU JOIN TH-cam CHANNEL NABI ASLI
YOU JOIN TH-cam CHANNEL HARRIS SULTAN