Tim Brando: The Committee Is Corrupt & the Decision Process is Corrupt | CFP Rankings | CFB
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ส.ค. 2024
- Tim Brando, Fox Sports joins 365 Sports to discuss his thoughts on the college football playoff decision to leave out FSU, his thoughts on what the playoff needs to fix before they move to 12 teams, his thoughts on SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey, and more.
With Craig Smoak, David Smoak, & Paul Catalina
Once we have 12 Teams the Corrupt Committee will basically earmark 7 or 8 spots for the SEC and Big 10.
7 or 8? ...more like 10 or 11
Yeah and they’ll throw in mediocre teams that are 9-3 like ole miss lsu and mizzou with unbalanced schedules and I’m afraid they’ll put them over deserving big 12 or acc teams
The fact that a 4th place team could (and will) make the championship tournament is too horrific to even be laughable.
@@MichaelSmith-xb5cp They've prepared themselves well. 11 out of 12 teams in the playoff rankings are Big 10 or SEC next year
@CB-so8xd are you counting Oregon, Washington and Texas in that 12?
Tim Brando is a LEGEND for this interview. 100% spot on.
No. Legend is an Alabama dude who calls into the Paul Finebaum show all the time.
As a Texas alum he was a spot on. Once Georgia lost the door was open for us and Bama. Economics drives the CFP period point blank
Facts
Once Georgia lost the door was open to Texas. Don’t make a Texas and Alabama argument. It’s an Alabama and FSU argument. Leave Texas out of it.@@mynumberoneguy
Tim Brando is a known Alabama hater and a LSU fan. Brando would vote Liberty in over Bama.
I am Washington huskies fan. But I feel bad for FSU because I know they would have done the same thing us to get an SEC team into the playoffs. Fix the system and make transparent!
No, you feel bad for them because you fear the SEC and wish you had the chance to play a shitty FSU team
You shouldn't be there either, the PAC gets its azz kicked every time they play a big boy. FACTS. By the way, the old BCS formula had Bama 3, FSU 4 and Texas 5. These Committee clownnnnssss let one DATA POINT (H2H) Trump all other data points like SOS and top 25 wins.
@@chriswincek8672 Wrong, we still would play Texas even if FSU was at 4? I have been saying the same thing as a Husky fan myself. And do I think FSU has a worse chance, yes but guess what everyone including Vegas and ESPN and all these talking heads saying FSU would have no chance said the same thing about us against Oregon but guess what, you don't know unless the game is played and that's why it is played. To leave them out is to say there was NOTHING within their control that they could do to get in and that is it. Oh you scheduled SEC out of conference teams and beat them (by more than Bama in the case of LSU) sorry, your QB got hurt we don't care. And this whole TCU thing dismisses the fact that they won the first round so by that logic would Michigan not have been blown out by more last year?
@@chriswincek8672 FSU is far from shitty , maybe BAMA is the shitty team fir barely beating Auburn ,you dunce
FSU struggled against Louisville to even get a first down. They aren't the same team without their QB
I'm a Texas alum and fan, and Tim is 100% correct. Texas already beat Alabama, why the hell are they in the playoffs instead of an undefeated Florida State who seems like they could beat anybody if they threw zero passes?
Esecpn and their financial investments in that conference. That pretentious jackass herbstreit started a narrative against FSU before jordan travis got hurt, but we all thought it was just for tv and to get ratings for the selection show. Before this, I thought herb was pretty unbiased, but now herb has shown that he's a spineless cowardly pos. I truly do hope FSU does sue espn and the college football invitational committee. The discovery process would be very interesting.
Because they beat UGA, because they have SOS of 5th, because they have their QB. Why are you afraid to play Bama again? Stop blaming Bama. How about FSU commissioner, or the Florid player who gave Rodemaker a concussion, or the 3 starters out on UF team who could have helped them win.
@JohnSmith-vt5ry You mean like how Bama beat an UGA team missing multiple starters? My god you people are unsufferable. Your team lost, Homer Pyle, and it's a travesty your favorite college students (lmao wait until you discover they're fans of BLM) got in over an undefeated team who won without its best players.
@@pdxcorgidad same way Georgia won a national championship against bama without their starting wr. FOH with that bs. Take that L buddy!!🤣😂
@@bigslik75 Oh okay so we only use players as a negative when it happens to FSU. Got it.
100% agreed. There was nothing driving this except money. How much are these committee members paid?
On the books…nothing; back pocket…everything
Not sure…..ask Alabama’s boosters
more than we make in 2 decades.
Yea..the same money that drives you to wake up everyday..without it you will die..for most. Why do we act suprised that money is number 1? Hello, how do you feed the players? With prayers?hahaha
@@bubbadiesel4961 when politicians are corrupt do you just lay down and take it? 🤡
👏👏👏I’m a FAN of Mr. Brando now!!!!! He’s preaching the gospel. Someone with guts to tell the truth! I will subscribe to this page now! Sick of the ESPN narratives!!!
I have been saying this since the BCS. The SEC was a 3rd or 4th ranked conference until ESPN bought it.
Its not an ESPN narrative. It's fact, FSU was not and is not one of the top4 teams in the country.
American college sports fans are far too dumb to know that this decesion to leave Floriday State High and Dry is political. The Traitorl, corrupt, lying criminal Democratically controlled Networks are pissing on Florida because it does not bow down to the gender bender Anti Christ Demon spawn Democrats and their geriatric puppet patien Biden and Kamala the racist. So if your not willing to drop to your knees Florida for your traitor Democrats. you will be shunned again and again.
I totally agree with Brando and have already come to the same conclusions since the very advent of the Mike Slive manufactured committee solution (which is nothing more than an SEC/B1G Co-op booster club in disguise as an electoral college).
But..I'm an old fart, I remember the 2000 BCS when the computers algorithms jobbed Washington for Florida State even though Washington beat two top 5 teams..one was #2 Miami, a common opponent.
Then FSU laid an egg against Oklahoma.
It's always been corrupt, Stanford beat Alabama up and down the field in the 1927 Rose Bowl, 🌹, missed an 18yard chip shot field goal and like the recent Iron Bowl, Alabama is able to use a punting error to stage a last minute drive that results in tie game Stanford wins the Rissman cup, but Alabama claims that Championship like many other endless claims to follow. The Rose proceeds built DENNY stadium and that game was the first coast to coast CFB radio broadcast, where in, bumhick, Alabama, a 13 year old boy is listening, and the wheels begin turning on how best he can rig college football...that boy... grew up to become Bear Bryant....and the rig never ends...
Just so we're all on the same page, I would have chosen FSU, having said that, in 1993 Florida State having one loss was chosen over an undefeated Auburn conference champion just so we're clear on that as well...
This video needs to be shared to every college football fan. big respect for Tim Brando
Tim Brando is an alabama hater
@@michaelnelson1128no he is the voice of reason.
@centrist1008 no, he's an idiot and a hypocrite that would be singing a different tune had it been LSU instead of Alabama.
It's simple, FSU was never one of the Top 4 teams in the country. The record doesn't tell the whole story. But playing a 55th ranked SOS ensured they'd be undefeated.
@@centrist1008 he is an idiot, he did 2 games of my team and no idea what he was talking about.
@@michaelnelson1128 even if thats the case, he did spit facts. what did he say that wasnt true?
Tim Brando spoke true 100% facts! 🙏🏿. These committee members hide behind doors for a reason. I love how he calls out Kirk Herbstret and Reese Davis. This was about what team they wanted in Rio generate the most game time revenue simply put! Chasing that money bag 💰👜
My respect for Tim Brando has quadrupled.
@@19MarkDavid A M E N
100% C O R R E C T
@@19MarkDavidonly because he's feeding you bullshit that you'll buy
Kirk was saying before Jordan got hit that alabama and texas were getting in. And guess wht happened.
Tim Brando has always been one of the most straightforward and knowledgeable analyst for college sports......and 10 million percent Alabama got in because of the SEC narrative
What about Ga. Number 1 one day then out?
@@tennisace40 that was BS too.
He is a clown now, he did the last OU game and was horrible.
The old BCS Polls/Computers have Bama 3, FSU 4 and Texas 5. So, the computers say you are FOS. Here is the truth, you know who is better, you are just too big a coward to admit it. So, FSU plays teams 2 games under .500 whilst Bama plays teams 98-53. Get out with you BS
The straight forward and knowledgeable analysts are 99 time out of a hundred the ones who share the same opinions with the one calling them straight forward and knowledgeable analysts.
It is absolutely sooo refreshing to hear the truth. Do you see how truth when you hear it just shines like nothing else. Lord have mercy. Tim Brando I give you a standing ovation because you’re honest and a man of integrity and character. Thank you!
Dude....It's really nice to have your opinions reinforced but the level to which y'all are going the extra miles after already giving a 5 star blue chip reacharound that would put Jenna Jamison to shame almost makes me want to declare FSU should never be allowed to compete on a college field ever again. Btw...Any sympathetic non FSU or any of the actual FSU fans in 1993 didn't protest when they were chosen over Auburn while having one loss and Auburn was an undefeated SEC Champion. Full circle
@@MosDefnIT88"The 1993 Auburn Tigers football team represented Auburn University in the 1993 NCAA Division I-A football season. Under first-year head coach Terry Bowden, the team went undefeated with a record of 11-0 and finished #4 in the AP Poll. Due to NCAA probation, Auburn was banned from TV and post-season play, and suffered reduced scholarships. The post-season ban prevented Auburn from playing the SEC Championship and a bowl game. Nonetheless, Auburn was the only major college football team to finish the season undefeated. The National Championship Foundation recognized Auburn as one of its four co-national champions;[1] however, Auburn University only formally recognizes championships for the 1957 and 2010 seasons,[2][3] although the official website for Auburn athletics does highlight the 1993 team."
Auburn wasn't eligible... dude. So they weren't the SEC champion and the school itself doesn't even recognize that season as any sort of championship team.
Also an apples to oranges comparison. There wasn't even the BCS yet in '93, let alone a 4 team playoff. The champion was decided by AP and/or coaches poll. Which everyone agreed was a joke of a way to decide a champion because it was just based off subjective opinion. And that's exactly what this sham of a committee reverted back to on Sunday. "We think, we feel, we believe blah blah blah" etc etc. Instead of actual merit based accomplishments like ya know...not losing a single game while playing in a major conference and also scheduling legitimate non-conference opponents. Two of which were from the holier-than-thou SEC in LSU and Florida.
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
I've been a die hard Georgia Bulldog fan for 40 years and what was done to Florida State was absolutely absurd! The selection committee is corrupt and I feel horrible for all them players on the Florida State team.
Totally agree with you 💯
What would you say if Washington would have been left out and George got in.
Bias against Alabama, die-hard Georgia Bulldog fan? 😂
@@jaydenmontgomery800 Dwayne would not have said anything.
So you think FSU is better than UGA? FOH
❤ Thank you , as an FSU fan we need more ppl like you!
God I love Tim Brando!! I absolutely love how beautifully honest he is!!! It is so refreshing to hear! Instead of the Gameday robots!
Love ya Brando!!
If Brando would have said that the committee got things right, would it make him dishonest? 😂
If FSU wins the bowl game, they will say Ga want motivated or Ga was missing too many players. It’s a NO win game. It’s garbage
They should sit out the game.
Actually we (Florida State) have a lot of players who are opting out- Johnny Wilson already opted out and I suspect there will be more-
I wish Georgia and FSU wouldn't even show up
The only way we beat or change the system is stop watching & supporting it
you are exactly right the games is worthless. just an asterisk!
Mr. Brando said what the majority of people think! Kudos to you, sir!
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
You are very foolish. Most fans do NOT think FSU should be in instead of Bama. FSU would be a huge underdog against the all the top 8-9 teams.
Only the morons
Brando is so on point. It’s shocking to hear it laid out on the table.
Florida States defense is 🔥🔥🔥
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
The orange bowl is irrelevant. FSU has many top players opting out playing UGA. Why play and risk injury before going to the NFL. FSU won't have the same team as during the season. Also, That probably goes for UGA, but they have depth. FSU doesn't have the depth. @@perfectblindguy
@@perfectblindguy these kids that made it out the mud aren’t risking Generational Wealth on a meaningless bowl game.
Paul Finebaum needs to be hogtied to a chair and forced to listen to Brando's position on a loop from now until New Years.
Mad respect to Tim Brando for standing up and speaking the truth. Same goes for Booger Mcfarland and RGIII. FSU was absolutely robbed and nobody can convince me otherwise. And not only was FSU robbed. I was robbed of seeing FSU complete their incredible season. The committee and Kirk Herbstreit can kiss my ass!
Totally agree with you 💯
I concur
Thankfully we were all robbed of having to watch FSU try to play football in the playoff.
@@chrisnelson2948as a Texas and TCU fan fsu could beat Michigan with a month to prepare. They have an elite defense elite playmakers and rodemaker with a month gameplan can get the win. They deserved it all the way but esecpn couldn’t have that
FSU would destroy Texas with Rodemaker.
Funny how the Dawgs were bad enough to drop from 1 to 6 with just 1 loss in two seasons but they were good enough to bolt Bama from 8 to 4 ....
And the Dawg loss was by 3 pts..
It was a catch 22. They werent gonna leave the SEC out but they couldn't leave UGA ranked above Bama cause they're ranked close enough to the top theyd both get in. Unless UGA is still ranked ahead of them. Then you certainly cant leave out a conference champ Texas(that beat Bama earlier in the season) AND FSU. They knew leaving FSU out was going to be controversial enough on its own. Conveniently enough FSUs QB situation gave them the perfect out. Granted they definitely looked rough vs Louisville to back that up. So their only option was to dump UGA to 6th to not make leaving FSU out look TOO egregious. Georgia is still a top 4 team 100%.(From a Bama fan).
TLDR^^: UGA dropped so far because they just couldn't get away with snubbing Texas and FSU. Otherwise I think it'd be Michigan, Washington, Bama, UGA, Texas, FSU.
@@dsmxtuner95because the corruption is deep in that committee
@@michaelw366it was worse than 3 only on paper after georgias first score than game wasn't even close bama had full control and the iron bowl gi back and watch that game bama beats awbarn by at least 17 if not for penalties and its the 4 BEST teams nit most deserving tim even said bama beats this fSU team
I just want to say how much I respect Tim for telling the truth . It took him alot of courage to say these things and he has earned my respect. Big time!!!!!
Tim gave an opinion. Him saying something does not make it truth. It makes it his opinion.
Telling the truth is not courage. It is telling the truth. Tim called a spade a spade.
The "Fix" was in ... and Tim Brando NAILED IT in this interview.
I’d bet everything I own, that UT and or Bama would still be in, if their QBs got injured in their title games. Crazy bs corruption.
Bama would not have beaten Georgia without their starting QB. FSU won't either. Georgia deserves to be in over Washington per my eye test.
When Georgia routes FSU in a few weeks all of this yammering will be forgotten.
Washington definitely earned their spot. They won every game they played. Beating a really good Oregon TWICE. Texas isn’t as good as ppl making them out to be. They played like ish a few games. I think Washington is going to surprise a lot of ppl
@@wesleyedwards2764Washington is such a fraud. UGA by 30 over FSU
@@wesleyedwards2764 Nope because none of the FSU starters or seniors will play in preparation from the draft. The orange bowl game is essentially meaningless and lose/lose for FSU. If Georgia wins everyone will say ah ha they weren't supposed to be in the playoffs anyway, but let's say FSU beats Georgia, people will say Georgia wasn't motivated because the game won't win FSU a championship lol 😅
Imo they should cancel the Orange bowl
Give these talented kids on both teams that are NFL prospects a chance to be healthy for the NFL combine & draft
@@amariantiquity8543 You're absolutely right. And if BAMA was FSU they would definitely be in b/c they'd be saying look how dominate BAMA is as a team, look at their domintate defense and they even won their last 3 games with their backups. FSU and GA players should say da heck with that Charity (orange) bowl game. Committee didn't respect us, so we wont respect you.
“One of the criteria is available players and coaches”
-Michigan was missing their coach for half the season; no change in ranking
-Texas was missing Quinn Ewers for 5 weeks; no change in rankings
-Florida state loses QB and the SEC might be out; well one player isn’t available so we are NOW using this criteria to put an SEC team in
It’s a sham
Actually FSU went from 5 to 4 after they lost Jordan Travis. Guess what happened when Bama struggled against USF without Milroe? They went the opposite way! Lol.
@@brooksphillips2234 thats a great point you bring up... one week they lose Jordan Travis and they went up a ranking... then 2 weeks later its used as an excuse to move them down... make it make sense
And Alabama almost lost to a terrible Auburn team just 11 days ago from today!
Michigan was missing their integrity for the last two seasons and 3/4 of this one...nothing happened.
But MI played a tougher schedule and they beat the Suckeyes..who did FSU beat? RTR
Tim you are spot on! and i'm a Florida Gator fan from the SEC.
Disband the CFP Selection Committee and start all over with its foundation. Until we do that, the meddling and manipulations will never stop.
You actually think “meddling and manipulation” is going to stop when there are literally billions of dollars at stake?
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@macworkz4338 the more people they piss off, the less they watch. That simple.
@@NiktoonsTVyup just a hundred more fan bases to go. I also highly doubt any FSU fan in 1993 felt bad for Auburn when a one loss FSU was chosen over an undefeated sec champion Auburn.
They usually are. There are new committee members every year.
@@NiktoonsTV actually the opposite, media intake is about 500% this year what it was at the same time last year
Love Tim Brando! This is the BEST scorched earth take I've heard on the CFP @365 Sports
It was really nice to see all of the conference commissioners being interviewed on GameDay and by ESP…oh wait. That never happened. Only the SEC commissioner!
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
Total joke!!!
@@perfectblindguy and what happens when FSU beats Georgia?
Tom Brando is on fire on this Topic! Best take on it I have seen!
ESPN could not resist the lure of a possible Texas & Alabama rematch in the title game. They have way too much control and influence over the process. It should never have been left up to some committee, that I am sure was in some way was influenced by TV ratings over the right thing to do.
Finally someone said the truth. "Show me the money!", the committee is a joke.
Well said by Mr. Brando. Thank you for speaking truth to power.
Unbelievable response and kudos to Tim Brando. 100% spot on. Stephen A on First Take (Friday) said so himself that there was no way in hell that there will be a college football playoff without without an sec team. Nuff said. Going into Saturday nights game with Louisville, Florida State had no chance regardless of margin of victory. Talk about a scandal, this is WATERGATE 2.0.
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
I meant it isn't Watergate but but point taken.
@perfectblindguy the FSU, Georgia will be playing won't be the full throttle team. The majority of the defense is either hitting the portal or going to the NFL.
Fair point, but Watergate wasn’t jack squat.
@jims512 I mean....that's not exactly accurate. Of course, to your point, and I realize I'm gonna piss off the majority of CFB fans by saying this, Watergate truly wasn't jack squat compared to the 2017-2020 fella. Soooo fair point.
Fantastic take! Loved the interview and I’m not even a FSU fan
No more of a comment than Tim Brando is ABSOLUTELY CORRECT!
He is right! FSU got ripped off BIG TIME! GOD BLESS
SEC fan here. I dislike FSU, but they actually are a great team, nothing of this BS about losing the QB, their defensive performance is on point and should be in just because of it
ACC is a clownshow
Yes, didn’t say otherwise
@@arubial1229not by the data
@@arubial1229 says the clown
@arubial1229 ::: so is LSU, Tennessee, Old Miss, ect. SEC went 7-9 against other Power 5 conferences. Clown show of a conference. Completely overrated.
13-0 wow what else can a team do!? this world is corrupt by the love of money
Seriously
Thank you for telling the truth. It won't go away with 12. No one makes a bracket with 12 teams to be fair and honest. They will control those that get the bye week, who plays home games, and feed the negative press on teams they don't like.
Lol...a Michigan fan commenting about honesty and fairness. Oh my.
@molonlabe9602 integrity is Honest Jim Harbaugh's middle name. However, I'm not surprised with those who follow the NCAA and CFP and think they have integrity. Most sheep don't ever believe the shepherd is taking them to slaughter.
Lol@@molonlabe9602
12 teams is just to get more SEC teams in for more money for the SEC.
Brando, Eisen, Richard Sherman, Boog, and Crane & Co are spot on. Brando is the best. He's truth.
Thankful for Tim Brando. Someone willing to tell the truth.
Sums it up! I'm just a fan of college football and this is exactly how it all went down.
It doesn't matter who you played it's how you play and with a zero on your loses you played with heart and determination and won with a backup quarterback
LOL, no. Why do you think 2017 UCF didn’t make it? Because strength of schedule is one of the most important metrics. You can’t allow a team to make the playoffs when they will lose by 28+ in the semis.
You win the Internet for dumbest comment of the year.
Funny you say that, after the announcement on Sunday Herbstreet talking with a committee member that said that Mi to #1 due to pressure of having to play without the HC in 3 tough games/6 all together then he brought up that team played for each other with heart and all that
@arubial1229 we were literally ranked 4th in the nation. Don't ever compare UCF to FSU
@@marquis2319 your right they should of lost a game who they still be 4th this is a joke and finbaum still can't figure it out
Finally, someone says the truth. Heather Dinich wrote a cover up for espn then went on an espn shows to smirk and laugh about how wrong everyone is. Espn spins and lies and occasionally admits it's all about the money and marketable storyline.
Heather hates FSU. Hot garbage
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
@@perfectblindguyI think FSU, having not lost a game and winning their power 5 conference title, did everything they could to earn an invitation. We now know that what happens on the field doesn't matter and that 13 people can make up any convenient reason to get the teams that espn believes will generate the largest audience and the most compelling storyline. Espn should quit telling us the committee was sad and oh so torn by their decision. If you watch Dinich on the follow-up interviews about her article, she's basically scolding people for "conspiracy theories" and not understanding the committees pain. We're not morons. Regarding GA vs FSU, you and I can agree that GA has a good chance of winning while also agreeing that the committee's job is to ensure the most revenue is generated for espn. The reason I appreciate Brando is he lays out clearly the revenue motive that espn is trying to bury.
Tim Brando is a breath of fresh air after listening to Brian Kelly justify FSU wasn't the same team so they were out. Tim went up in my eyes, and Brian Kelly went from high to the bottom.
I bet you he would’ve sang a different tune if he was still at Notre dame and not the sec.
Finally, someone speaking the truth. Thank you.
As much as I love the SEC, I completely agree. SEC bias played a huge part in this.
I applaud your honesty. Thank you so much!
The only reason Alabama was chosen over FSU is because the network broadcasting the playoff gets the exclusive rights to the SEC & their product has to be promoted
Or could it be that Alabama is actually better than Florida State? And if you'd say well they are undefeated and deserve then the participation trophy. Then why isn't also undefeated Liberty in the championship as well. I just wish they would people used logic and commonsense. What happened to Auburn in the 2002 or 2004 when they were left out? Then that year the winner had to vacate the title and Auburn was still left out again.
@@JamesCarter-be9cn Did liberty play at Clemson, LSU, Miami, Louisville, #16 Duke?
No, it was they beat the #1 team that was on a 3-year undefeated winning streak. That's how they got in and with the 5th strength of the schedule not 55th. lol
@@johnnycage6681 Every team you listed are the middle of the pact teams this year. What is their best record? Are they all at best all 3 loss teams? And logically doesn't make sense in a power standpoint. By putting Florida State in would be a give me freebie game to Michigan or Washington. The top 8 teams not Florida State would destroy the Noles. This is based on pure logic via data and commonsense. During that announcement at Michigan, did you hear the gasps and the moans when they found out who they were going to play? Because now they have to go out there and earn it and the first round wasn't a freebie. I expect Alabama to take it all for redemption and revenge reasons.. I do get it though undefeated should bare tons of weight. But you have to also note if they played the rest of the top who wins. Florida State will have their revenge on a former two time national champions in Georgia and they still can claim their AP national championship trophy. Just like Central Florida did a couple years back. Undefeated Liberty could also make the same argument too.
@@johnnycage6681are you trying to imply Clemson, Miami, Louisville, and Duke are good teams right now? The ACC has been a clownshow for years.
FSU and ACC should sue the committee. FSU 13-0 should be over Bama. It is the money that made the decision.
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
@@perfectblindguy All FSU best players are going to opt out. It's not a real game. Game don't matter remember
As an FSU fan I'm a little bummed out that we didn't make the ESPN invitational college football "championship". The Orange bowl game has no significance because both teams will have players, NFL prospects opting out of because they want to transfer etc. If FSU wins well persons would argue that 3 offensive line men a safety and running back opted out of playing. If Georgia wins well two DTs, a linebacker, running back, two corners from FSU opted out.
In regards to the 12 team invitational championship, the top 4 spots that get a bye week are guaranteed to teams that win a conference championship and not the win loss strength of schedule. So that will still make it crap.
I do wish that FSU would give them the middle finger by going to the Orange Bowl and after the coin toss line up for the kick off and then the coach call a time out. When the timeout expires, call the next time out and the final time out and then the entire team walks off the field gets on the bus and heads back to Tallahassee.
It would cost ESPN so much money and screw them over. It would be costly to FSU, but well worth it. The bowl revenue we get will be split between all teams in the ACC conference so we wouldn't lose as much.
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
@@perfectblindguyCopy paste something else, Homer Pyle.
Were you the kid who took your ball and went home if you couldn't play qb or if someone tackled you too hard?
@@perfectblindguyhe already made the excuse. "Our best players sat out and we let the practice squad play"
Perfect pod cast guys!
The FSU rank has been adjusted all year to match the newest narrative. They were never getting invited. Undefeated seasons are rare. The Orange Bowl will not reflect anything but a watered down meaningless games with players missing with nothing to be gained
Wow… this is the best commentary that I’ve heard about college football playoffs system…
Thank you Tim. Really appreciate your opinion approach and commitment to journalistic integrity.
The game of the Century in college football was USC vs Texas when Vince Young scored on a last second touchdown goal line run
This guy is1000% correct on everything. Only thing I'd add is that FSU actually outscored their opponents 91-28 with backup QB's in the last 3 games and their very good backup QB-Rodemaker would have been available for the playoffs had they gone.
FSU’s offense is horrible right now. Their opponents’ overall record is 77-79 lol. Pathetic.
Very good Backup? What I saw vs Florida was Pathetic!
@@arubial1229clown take
@@arubial1229 we had more offensive yards with the third string against a higher ranked and against a better defense than Michigan did with their starting QB
@@arubial1229 also FSU can’t control what our openers records are. Only their own. It was 13-0
Thank you, Mr. Brando, you are 100% correct!
DON'T sugarcoat it Tim. Tell us what you really feel.
Excellent take on this unbelievable frickin' mess... spot on!
I truly miss late '80s early '90s college football.
So very true !!!
Brando nailed it!
Thats the real reason why michigan was disappointed at alabama being in. Not because they are affraid of bama but because its BS that Florida state got snubbed.
I've been a Michigan fan for 30 years. The last team I wanted them to play in a win or go home scenario is Bama. Half their team will be in the NFL. They wanted Florida st with a backup. The emotion was too fast for them to be thinking fl st got screwed
It doesn't matter if Georgia won Alabama was still going to be in it I am a buckeye and believes Florida should be in the final 4
Thank you Tim. Florida State was screwed. 13-0. Unbelievable
The ACC commissioner voted for a 4 team play off !!!!! If not for that you would be playing Georgia in the play off. Hey that's what will happen anyway. Go Noles Beat the Dogs !
@@leroybrown-coco Thanks to the bias Disney/ESPN/CFP FSU now has the opportunity to play Georgia in Orange Bowll for the National Championship.
So was Liberty ... but Liberty didn't sting up the field with only 224 and 219 yards of offense in last 2 games. They got 712 and 469
Florida State’s strength of schedule kind of tarnishes that 13-0 record.
Michigan beat Ohio State and Penn State. Washington beat Oregon twice. Alabama beat Georgia. Texas beat Alabama.
Who did Florida State beat?
@@sarahmccoy1941 everybody they faced. Undefeated. Can it be made any clearer?
This man is spot on in every point. INTEGRITY MATTERS!!
Wonder if Fox could start its own playoff scenario. Get Big ACC and Big12 the best of the G5 and say FU to sec. Force sec into a sec schedule and playoff only.
ooooo would love that!...great idea
Blame the “ alliance” for voting against expansion for this year.
@@terrysmith1957doesn’t matter. They still would’ve found a way to screw FSU with the seeding. The 12 team playoff will just invite even more bias. Half the teams will come from the SEC, watch.
Sec is the best conference if you want to fix that start winning and scheduling better games.
As a G5 alumni (Liberty), I fully support this idea!
College Football is the equivalent of pro wrestling.
A M E N . . .
GREAT analogy !
gotta really love tim brando, keeping it absoltuely 100
Finally someone with the gall to tell the truth!
Thank God for Tim Brando
My thing is the sec was kind of down this year. Although I think UGA and Alabama are great teams, neither really showed us anything outside of conference play. UGA only had one win against a power 5 team in a close win against gatech and Alabama lost their major non conference game. While FSU was 2-0 against the SEC and the ACC was 6-4 against the sec.
The ACC went 6-4 against the SEC because it was mostly the top ACC teams playing in those games....Florida St. Clemson, Georgia Tech and North Carolina. The ACC's 2nd best team lost to Kentucky (3-5 in SEC play).
@@chuckwest7045lost because of turnovers not outplayed…
@@SurferRC they lost
The SEC never is "down"
@@chuckwest7045 normally schedules are made 3 years in advance. There's no way for any team regardless of conference to know that the team they scheduled will be good in 3 years. As an FSU I'm thankful for the season and I'm more saddened for the players. A few years back we were woeful bad and recovering from a decline from bad coaches and trying to rebuild our team.
What concerns me the most is that this hurts our recruiting. All an SEC team has to say to a recruit is you dont want to play for FSU because even if you win all games you have a better chance in our SEC conference because we get the benefit of the doubt as far as the college football invitational championship game is concerned.
IMO this has nothing to do with football. Disney owns ESPN and DeSantis launched investigation into corruption at Disney. This is payback from Disney to hurt Florida financially. Connect the Dots. DeSantis has set $1 Million to litigate this in court. There is a Silent War happening and Florida State Football team ended up being the cannon fodder in this fight. Again this is my opinion. Follow the money.
Fucking poetic justice it would be, if that were true. DeSantis ain't FSU. When your presidential hopes are dwindling, going after a rival with some BS is pure desperation.
This is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. FSU is hot garbage without Travis. Texas and Bama are the two hottest teams in college football right now. Literally zero debate here.
I've always said that if CFB wants to be taken seriously, they will need a "TRUE" playoff, rather than a beauty contest. Every level of football, from peewee to Pop Warner to the pros, has a legitimate playoff system whereby the teams play their way into the playoffs. Everything is decided on the field, rather than being determined by a corrupt "selection" committee. That's why I can't watch gymnastics or figure skating. It's not determined by who performed the best, but based on opinions. Opinions don't win games, players and coaches do.
There’s 133 teams in D1. They can’t possibly all play each other, which means subjectivity is baked into the platform. You can’t play a garbage schedule AND look bad doing it. Winning alone isn’t enough. The eye test and style points matter in college football, they always have. If you don’t understand why that is, then college football isn’t the sport for you.
@@arubial1229 What a dumb comment. Why not have the conference winners make the playoffs and bracket the playoffs from that???? You make the playoffs by winning your conference instead of having a "committee" decide.
Texas has over 3200 high schools broken into 6 classes based on school size. Each class has 2 divisions. All the teams play their way into the playoffs. It's not a beauty contest, there is no stupid "eye test". You win your district, you earn your way into the playoffs. Single elimination. You lose you go home. You win you keep playing. We are currently down to the semi-finals in most divisions and it will be decided by Christmas. If there's a will, there's a way.
With the NCAA, there's never been a will to change due to money and corruption. The game should be decided on the field, not by a "committee" of corrupted decision makers. People say Alabama's a better team than FSU, but who's to say FSU can't find a way to win. Think of the 1999 Rams, the 1969 Jets, the list of Cinderella stories goes on and on. Let the teams decide it on the field.
@@chopkong how the hell can 133 teams decide it “on the field”? Seriously let’s hear your solution. More than half the teams are garbage programs that leach off the big programs and literally would not exist without paychecks from them. Why should they get a seat at the table when they literally bring nothing to it?
@@arubial1229 FSU got screwed and I hate it, but I 100% agree with you. You can't decide it on the field with 133 teams and I also don't want to see a 16 team playoff ever in my lifetime. I actually like the 4 team playoff (up until this year). Ive agreed with the committee every single year til this year. I don't need a 8-4 team playing in a playoff. I love that every year we have 3 undefeateds and a one loss team playing for a NC. I don't want teams playing 4 playoff games. It waters down the best regular season in sports.
@@arubial1229 Your not very smart. Texas has over 3200 high schools that play football, broken into 6 classes based on school size. Each class has 2 divisions. All the teams play their way into the playoffs. It's not a beauty contest, there is no stupid "eye test". You win your district, you earn your way into the playoffs. Single elimination. You lose you go home. You win you keep playing. Here in Texas, we are currently down to the semi-finals in most divisions and all the Champions of each division will be decided by Christmas. If there's a will, there's a way.
With the NCAA, there's never been a will to change due to money and corruption. The game should be decided on the field, not by a "committee" of corrupted decision makers. People say Alabama's a better team than FSU, but who's to say FSU can't find a way to win. Think of the 1999 Rams, the 1969 Jets, the list of Cinderella stories goes on and on. Let the teams decide it on the field.
There was a pro team that won with only field goals a couple of weeks ago. They didn’t get criticized. It’s a win and it won’t keep them out of the playoffs if the record allows it!!
You do realize that we are talking about college football, right? Please stick to the subject.
Truth! You go Brando!
Corruption is the best & ONLY word for it.
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
Brando is 100% correct
TY Tim Brando. You have made the most sense. Why didn't the ESPN just say they never wanted FSU anyway in the CPP? Don't say that there was a benefit for players not to play in a meanlessful bowl when they have to care about their futures. If a player gets hurt, will ESPN pay for their injuries or commentators playing in these non-CPP games to play, especiallyy if you were were FSU? ANSWER: NO!!!
What Tim Brando stated that this CFP lacked integrity, is hitting the nail on the head! "nebulous" piece of garbage, is another perfect statement, as well. "Situational ethics", another perfect and appropriate word!
Tim Brando told the truth. 💯
ESPN about to send Mickey after Tim. He wielded a blowtorch this whole interview. Great listen. Refreshing really. So many conflicts of interest that he highlights about his fellow media members that you wouldn’t normally hear.
This is a rule that I always go by when it comes to Bama favoritism: You have to beat Alabama twice. Alabama only has to beat you once.
Bingo
Brando is the best. Miss his show😊
I so agree that one of the worse and most offensive parts is the insulting excuse. Just have the integrity to admit you have no integrity. Just be honest and say listen an SEC needed to be in. End of story. instead, they continue to repeat their story and gaslight everyone
when uga beats fsu will you admit that the committee was right?
@@perfectblindguy I actually think UGA has a reason to be pissed off, too. They used one criteria to drop FSU to 5 but ignored the very same “best” team argument and ranked UGA behinds FSU. Was the committee saying that FSU is better than UGA? …Or rather more deserving? Pretty sure they don’t think FSU is better than UGA so must be “more deserving” of #5 since they have no real justification based on precedent. It’s all just gaslighting and hypocrisy….and about $ and an “entertainment package”… and from that perspective, even a half ass, FSU v UGA match up with playmakers not playing…is more interesting and better entertainment than a rematch of UGA and Alabama in their mind….so they screwed UGA as well.
@@perfectblindguy oh, and to answer your question. No. Because I believe there should be a college football championship and not an invitational. I believe that results on the field should indeed count more than the subjective assessment of a handful of Rando‘s. In my personal opinion …it’s about principal and as such… my answer is no it would not change my opinion, and I would not think the committee was right. The committee was wrong, and nothing will change my opinion because for me, it’s about principle
Brando my fave ....no wonder he never worked for ESPN on Fox of course
I've always loved listening to Tim Brando. He's spot on with his take on the cfp.
Every conference should receive an automatic bid to a "real" college football playoff.The current system is garbage and contains too much bias, speculation, and hypothetical nonsense.
You had a typo, you mean "hypocritical nonsense"
they will starting next year and would have started this year but the Big 10 and Acc voted no
I know this fan will find something else to do on my fall saturdays. They hurt FSU's program for a decade at a minimum.
I can't agree more. Totally corrupt. They all should be fired.. Thank you Tim Brando for confirming what all of us already knew. I hope Herbstreit goes away.. forever what a suck up.
Thank you!!!! I lost ALL respect for Herbstreit. What a POS!!!
It’s all about money. Sucks for FSU. They should sit out the orange bowl in protest.
Might as well. UGA is going to destroy them anyway.
@@arubial1229 by how much
The biggest issue affecting the new B12:
- New B12 will only get 1 team in the new playoff ( along with the ACC and G5)
- We are in the P2 and G7 Era of college football.
They will get two
Biggest issue will be the 4 teams that get a bye. The committee of 13 still have the power to pick winners and losers.
@@ardentlions6636 Maybe. This year, FSU would have been in through the ACC. For Louisville to get in, they would have had to avoid the Pitt or Kentucky loss and beat FSU. It would have required both FSU and Louisville to go 12-1. A 2 loss ACC team would lose out to a 3 or 4 loss Missouri, LSU, Penn State, or Ole Miss type team.
@@a-fox| Yep. The committee has shown that they are essentially a surrogate of the SEC. Even Ray Charles can see that.
It’s only really the “P2” in terms of revenue sharing. As far as on the field results, AKA national championships, it’s the SEC and no one else.
There should have never been a 4 team playoff with 6 conferences to begin with. They should have had 6 team playoff from the start.
5 Power conferences.
👍😂❤
5 power conferences and 1 automatic bid
@@Tony-bp1nr Yeah, I always thought an 8 team playoff made sense. 5 conference champs, 2 at large and 1 small conference team.
5 “power” conferences lol. You mean 2…ish.
How do you do!! Thank you for speaking truth to power, Tim!
Herbstreet, is all about the Big 10 and Sec. That's how he keeps his job imo.
Herbstreet is a Sham.
Those two conferences literally run college football. The other conferences are irrelevant. What do you expect?
Agreed, bc he is a JOKE period
Guy is all Ohio State!
@@arubial1229big 12 is literally better than the big 10 all they have had is Ohio state and now michigan and TCU owned them
Wow Brando hit it RIGHT ON THE HEAD with EVERYTHING he said. I mean every angle that they would try to lie and wiggle out with a lame excuse he covered and covered WELL. I can play this audio 50 times because what he’s saying is Deeply Factual. Tell em Brando!💪🏿
Agree 100% with Tim. Stop trying to feed this BS to us and just say what is really going on...this was a business decision.
Thanks Tim for standing up for RIGHT and WRONG.
Tim Brando is speaking nothing but the truth keeping preaching!!! The narrative "FSU got screwed" should be talked about for the next month and a half!
I’m a lifelong UGA fan. FSU belongs in the playoff. I’m throwing in the towel on the sport. I turned my tv off on the NFL in 2016. I haven’t watched a game since. I got my Sundays back then and looks like I’ll get my Saturdays back this coming year. I hope the ratings for this years cfp drop like a rock.
If you don’t understand why FSU didn’t make the playoffs, then I don’t know what to tell you.
@@arubial1229 Never said I didn’t understand. I know exactly why.
@@michaelw366 you clearly don’t understand because you said “FSU belongs in the playoff”
@@arubial1229 Agree to disagree.
Remember ESPN is owned by Disney THINK ABOUT THAT
And ESPN owns the sec network
@@Robert-fs6ge also the ACC network...lol
@@demarius71 yeah so they basically just choose whatever teams they want for the playoff
@@demarius71ESPN didn't give 300 million to the ACC 🤔