It's one rule that I understand both sides of, TBH. On one hand, if a catcher gets the throw early enough, it's perfectly good baseball to block the plate, in my opinion. You're preventing a run, right? That said, the runner *ALSO* has a "right" (if you will) to score. *I* think it's mostly dependent on how good and quick the throw is.
@@storyofcory yeah its tough but def better than letting catchers get run over. At least its only on the throw though. Once he has the ball he can block it all he wants
the one thing that i hate about it is that basically everytime, they are called out by the umpire and then it is overturned. the umpire clearly determined that the catcher was not blocking or interfering, if so, the umpire would call that right there on the field.
This home plate interference rule has caused far far more problems than it ever solved. There is no way for a catcher to always keep his eyes on the ball while getting set for a tag and somehow still be aware to perfection of giving the runner a perfect lane. Even with this, because it is so subjective and the standard is basically one of perfection, any runner has a great chance of challenging and winning even on situations where they are clearly tagged out. It makes the game less fun to watch.
Oliver Marmol was pissed about the strike zone, but what really set him off was when Buckner told him there was a reason Oliver wasn't a player anymore.
At least he made it to the Show, aka MLB. Buckner probably sucked so bad at baseball that the only way he could make it to the show was to buy himself a ticket lol.
The interference rule is so bad … it’s getting to the point where the catcher can’t even catch the ball & then they will be worried about the rule which will lead to errors … such bs
It's ridiculous back in the day you could block the plate and Runner could knock over the catcher which I don't agree with that but this is ridiculous I mean catcher now got to like try to tag him and stand on the side of the plate
@@skynicholson4121 Go home, you’re drunk. Just like all the idiot baseball fans who think the scores are too low,….which is probably what prompted the rule change.
There is a simple fix for this. Let the catcher tag the plate instead of the runner. That way the ump can clearly see who wins, and it keeps both runner and catcher from getting hurt.
The thing about the catcher blocking the plate rule is that, when a call is overturned for blocking the plate, I kinda feel bad for the umps because it wasn't their call.
Being allowed to block the plate with your body is absurd. If they are allowed to do that why doesn’t the catcher just lay on top of the plate every time their is a runner coming in and the pitcher can come down and field the ball while the runner is struggling to get under him.
They need to adjust the Posey rule. It's out of control. The play involving Sanchez and Toronto is 100% horseshit. It's also gotten to the point where every play at the plate is getting challenged whether it's warranted or not because there's a better than average chance a replay will overturn it.
Soooo what was up with the first clip? It looked pretty clean to me. The catcher is receiving the ball and puts a quick tag while having his legs far apart so a sliding runner can go between them to still try to score which the runner does.
While I don’t agree with the blocking the plate rules I also don’t understand a manager getting thrown out over it when it’s not the umpires call to overturn it. It’s literally the home office officials who over turn the call.
If I was a 3rd base coach, I'd start sending runners home every time. There's no way for the catcher to receive the ball and make a tag. This is ridiculous and ruining the game Edit:also a bad throw seems more desirable than a perfect throw Because it forces the catcher to move. They're being punished for putting the throw where it needs to be to be make the tag
Let's just make every play at home a force, like it's beer league slo-pitch. Double bag at first, the whole deal. That way nobody ever touches each other :)
Count them ladies and gentlemen: 5 I repeat FIVE times the home plate collision rule came into play in the month of August. It had NEVER been called at any other point this season. Even when Kevin Cash from Tampa Bay challenged it in early July they did NOT overturn the call. And now all of a sudden, it’s been called left and right. Also another update, they called it two more times on Tuesday September 6th. Because it’s a hard rule to interpret it just adds more aggravation and frustrations. It’s too late for MLB to do anything about it this season. But they need to clarify this rule during the winter. As for the rest of this season, perhaps catchers should just wave the runners home, handing them a cold bottle of water and some sunflower seeds as they pass by. MLB needs to change this RULE NOW for better or worse for the integrity of baseball because in my honest opinion this is getting out of hand.
The home plate rule is the most wishy washy rule in all of baseball. They need to either get rid of it or come up with a proper fix to this dumb rule in the offseason.
I mean yeah, but then there's a high risk of injury for the catcher. Posey suffered a season-ending injury due to a home plate collision. The rule is indeed bs though.
I feel like teams are gonna start exploiting that home plate rule now. Like they know on a close play even if they’re called out the catcher is likely to do something considered “interference” and they could get the run anyway
Is the catcher supposed to stand in the second row and try to tag the runner out? Plenty of room to slide in, which is what the runner did! Rule is so dumb.
So the Giants ejection of Kapler was because of a taunting gesture that Garcia made at them as a taunt. The umpires went to the Giants dugout and gave Kapler an earful, telling him how to manage his team which Kapler took offense to because he AGREED with the umps that Garcia was taunting and was going to deal with it so Kapler said some choice words and that got him his first ejection as a Giant. This was more because the Dodgers owned us BADLY this year and the Giants were playing like the worst team in MLB so tensions were very high in the entire clubhouse at the time.
MLB is slowly ruining the game. I get it They don’t want the catchers to get hurt, The best play in baseball,and thr killing it. Runners are gonna run home every time knowing that if the catcher blocks the plate he will be safe
The catcher was fielding the ball and therefore not in violation of any rules..they have ruined baseball. It was fine for over a hundred years but non fans wanted to speed up the game. A bad call . They should read the rules.🇺🇸
Why do umps get to scream at players/managers but when players/managers yell back they get pushed away by other umps. Aren't allowed to touch an ump but they can push you?
Soooo future catchers and outfielders there’s no more plays at the plate. If a guy is rounding third don’t throw the ball home, hit the cutoff man. Cause the run would score either way😐 they need to fix that rule and the umpires need to read it and understand it
@@torijohnston7428 very true. For being an Cleveland fan and he’s competing in the AL Central, he had every right to be hot about that call. Umps in NY missed that one. Rocco is also very mild mannered when he gets that mad it’s usually because he’s right.
MLB doesn't need that remote decision that is frequently wrong and an insult to the umps on the field. The blocking rule is seldom correctly used.. [read the whole thing]
I was mostly in favor of the catcher interference rule. But watching this, it’s like a black and white rule instead of grey. Orrrrrrrrr, the guys up in New York are just bad at their job
This rule does suck if you call the runners safe in the forst place your gonna have managers arguing that he was tagged out but if you call them out in the first place then you have them arguing this rule
9:32 Unfortunately for the commentators, the umpires are right. Nobody from either team CAN NOT come out after a challenge, it is an immediate ejection, because it is not their call, but rather the call of the officials up in New York.
![[UNCUT]“ฅนตื่นธรรม”ปะทะ“หมอปลา-ปู่มหามุนี-อั๋นโอกิ”สะเทือนกระทรวงเวทมนตร์ Iคนดังนั่งเคลียร์I10 ตค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/peMD_SAkwNc/mqdefault.jpg)
Bob Melvin getting ejected before the ump turned off his mic was hilarious
Honestly that was the best one.
Second best was Marmol telling Bucknor he needs to retire
@@SPCHouston4568 Yes, that was a good one, too!
I seen that one with the mic on when Bob Melvin got tossed
That catcher rule is tough, I don’t know what else he can do there
It's one rule that I understand both sides of, TBH. On one hand, if a catcher gets the throw early enough, it's perfectly good baseball to block the plate, in my opinion. You're preventing a run, right?
That said, the runner *ALSO* has a "right" (if you will) to score. *I* think it's mostly dependent on how good and quick the throw is.
@@storyofcory yeah its tough but def better than letting catchers get run over. At least its only on the throw though. Once he has the ball he can block it all he wants
the one thing that i hate about it is that basically everytime, they are called out by the umpire and then it is overturned. the umpire clearly determined that the catcher was not blocking or interfering, if so, the umpire would call that right there on the field.
that blocking the plate rule is the new "catch/no catch" rule from the NFL
This home plate interference rule has caused far far more problems than it ever solved. There is no way for a catcher to always keep his eyes on the ball while getting set for a tag and somehow still be aware to perfection of giving the runner a perfect lane. Even with this, because it is so subjective and the standard is basically one of perfection, any runner has a great chance of challenging and winning even on situations where they are clearly tagged out. It makes the game less fun to watch.
Amen
Starting to think if there was a World Series of ejections,the Pirates would have many rings.
Oliver Marmol was pissed about the strike zone, but what really set him off was when Buckner told him there was a reason Oliver wasn't a player anymore.
At least he made it to the Show, aka MLB. Buckner probably sucked so bad at baseball that the only way he could make it to the show was to buy himself a ticket lol.
And a couple months later Bucknor showed he shouldn’t be a MLB umpire. Dude was so butt hurt that he refused to shake his hand in spring training
Bucknor is an absolute disgrace and has no class. It's like those who can't do, teach. Those who can't play, ump.
Love these ejection videos! IMO ejections are a badge of honour in baseball especially for managers
I would have gotten heated too. Yea the catcher is in the basepath but there is still a clear "path" to the plate. That was a clean play be Servin
The home plate rule HAS to go
If MLB Ejection Tracker ever decides to make t-shirts, one saying "He's Getting His Money's Worth" has to be at the top of the list.
And if Close Call Sports does, it needs to have the Mario coin on it.
I would buy one
15:08 Umpire: Bob! You can't, boom... (I know, I know!) 🤔
Ump: I know this rule is horrible, but I have to throw you out🤬
The interference rule is so bad … it’s getting to the point where the catcher can’t even catch the ball & then they will be worried about the rule which will lead to errors … such bs
It's ridiculous back in the day you could block the plate and Runner could knock over the catcher which I don't agree with that but this is ridiculous I mean catcher now got to like try to tag him and stand on the side of the plate
This call/rule change will ruin baseball if they don’t change it.
Lol Keith, Chucky, and Linford...y’all sound like some real old farts
@@skynicholson4121 Go home, you’re drunk. Just like all the idiot baseball fans who think the scores are too low,….which is probably what prompted the rule change.
@@skynicholson4121 with a name like Sky… you sound like a 10 year old
THE plater interference blocking rule is a terrible rule.
If/when it happens in a playoff game this year, it’s going to be awful
There is a simple fix for this. Let the catcher tag the plate instead of the runner. That way the ump can clearly see who wins, and it keeps both runner and catcher from getting hurt.
It's not a force, but you have a point
The thing about the catcher blocking the plate rule is that, when a call is overturned for blocking the plate, I kinda feel bad for the umps because it wasn't their call.
Being allowed to block the plate with your body is absurd. If they are allowed to do that why doesn’t the catcher just lay on top of the plate every time their is a runner coming in and the pitcher can come down and field the ball while the runner is struggling to get under him.
That home plate rule is ridiculous. I miss old baseball
This Buster Posey rule has been ridiculous. MLB needs to get rid of it.
That plate-blocking rule has got to be the dumbest rule MLB has ever implemented.
Blame Buster Bosy
If a player or coach can't touch an umpire, then the umpire should not be able too touch a player or coach under any circumstance!
The "blocking the plate" rule has changed baseball to replay-ball.
September video coming soon?
They need to adjust the Posey rule. It's out of control. The play involving Sanchez and Toronto is 100% horseshit. It's also gotten to the point where every play at the plate is getting challenged whether it's warranted or not because there's a better than average chance a replay will overturn it.
Soooo what was up with the first clip? It looked pretty clean to me. The catcher is receiving the ball and puts a quick tag while having his legs far apart so a sliding runner can go between them to still try to score which the runner does.
Thanks Buster Posey
While I don’t agree with the blocking the plate rules I also don’t understand a manager getting thrown out over it when it’s not the umpires call to overturn it. It’s literally the home office officials who over turn the call.
As a former catcher, that rule is complete bs
Angel, Bucknor, Laz Diaz, Culpa and Chris Conroy all need to leave the damn game.
If I was a 3rd base coach, I'd start sending runners home every time. There's no way for the catcher to receive the ball and make a tag. This is ridiculous and ruining the game
Edit:also a bad throw seems more desirable than a perfect throw Because it forces the catcher to move. They're being punished for putting the throw where it needs to be to be make the tag
When is September ejection video coming?
Wasn't blocking the plate but he was actually safe so the call ended up being correct for the wrong reason.
Which one? Might want to include that when at least 5 of these are blocking the plates calls
They can cry all they want the catcher has to learn to play the bag just like all the other bases.
Is there not going to be a September video?
Is the league making a push on how blocking the plate is being interpreted, seems like a sudden change.
MLB has publicly denied that, but it's pretty obvious.
What umpire leads in ejections??
Jerry Meals?? JB Buckner?
Just curious
Let's just make every play at home a force, like it's beer league slo-pitch. Double bag at first, the whole deal. That way nobody ever touches each other :)
GET RID OF THE CATCHER!
You don't even have to slide into home anymore!
Count them ladies and gentlemen: 5 I repeat FIVE times the home plate collision rule came into play in the month of August. It had NEVER been called at any other point this season. Even when Kevin Cash from Tampa Bay challenged it in early July they did NOT overturn the call. And now all of a sudden, it’s been called left and right. Also another update, they called it two more times on Tuesday September 6th. Because it’s a hard rule to interpret it just adds more aggravation and frustrations. It’s too late for MLB to do anything about it this season. But they need to clarify this rule during the winter. As for the rest of this season, perhaps catchers should just wave the runners home, handing them a cold bottle of water and some sunflower seeds as they pass by. MLB needs to change this RULE NOW for better or worse for the integrity of baseball because in my honest opinion this is getting out of hand.
I'd like to see an umpire use his mask to give a manager a cup check.
The rules are for both teams. Sometimes for your benefits, sometimes for others. The goods of this rules: avoid extreme and danger collisions at home.
These ejection videos make me laugh sometimes
The home plate rule is the most wishy washy rule in all of baseball. They need to either get rid of it or come up with a proper fix to this dumb rule in the offseason.
This home plate rule is killing the game
Just wait until infield shifts are banned next season
Replay is killing the game!
I'm sorry but the home plate interference rule needs to change or e let's not have it at all
It's a ridiculous Overreaction to the Buster Posey injury
He was safe anyway. I slowed it down.
I agree...... Dumb rules
Mike Schmidt was good at that
Deal with it
September ejections please
“Bob you can’t boom”
Can we just bring back running into the catcher and all. Cause that would probably work better than this bs rule of blocking the damn plate.
I mean yeah, but then there's a high risk of injury for the catcher. Posey suffered a season-ending injury due to a home plate collision. The rule is indeed bs though.
@@RealDarragh they have to get rid of New York making these calls too. It needs to be the umpires actually at the game to look at the review!
what does the stats at 27:52 means? px:0.95, pz 1.22 sz_bot RAD, MOE. ?
Umps are fooled way to damn much by the catcher pulling the ball.
best part of the first clip is runners foot literally crosses right over the middle of the plate
This rule was not put in to play to interfere with clean plays at home
I feel like teams are gonna start exploiting that home plate rule now. Like they know on a close play even if they’re called out the catcher is likely to do something considered “interference” and they could get the run anyway
The home plate collision rule sucks!! Let's just get back to trucking the catcher then there is no argument!!
Is the catcher supposed to stand in the second row and try to tag the runner out? Plenty of room to slide in, which is what the runner did! Rule is so dumb.
The home plate collision/blocking rule needs to go away. Go back to pre-2014
So the Giants ejection of Kapler was because of a taunting gesture that Garcia made at them as a taunt. The umpires went to the Giants dugout and gave Kapler an earful, telling him how to manage his team which Kapler took offense to because he AGREED with the umps that Garcia was taunting and was going to deal with it so Kapler said some choice words and that got him his first ejection as a Giant. This was more because the Dodgers owned us BADLY this year and the Giants were playing like the worst team in MLB so tensions were very high in the entire clubhouse at the time.
Garcia pointed at his head. That's not a taunt. It's worse.
Don’t forget the April 2024 Ejections
I thought I saw one of the coaches that was the WWE superstar Cesaro
Don’t forget September 2022 Ejection Tracker
September ejections?
DB Bukner is a disgraced to his job as an umpire he needs to be fired immediately
He's not great but I still think Angel is on another level of incompetence
August was the month of ridiculous home plate violation calls
18:01 Perfect pitch
MLB is slowly ruining the game. I get it They don’t want the catchers to get hurt, The best play in baseball,and thr killing it. Runners are gonna run home every time knowing that if the catcher blocks the plate he will be safe
The catcher was fielding the ball and therefore not in violation of any rules..they have ruined baseball. It was fine for over a hundred years but non fans wanted to speed up the game. A bad call . They should read the rules.🇺🇸
Why do umps get to scream at players/managers but when players/managers yell back they get pushed away by other umps. Aren't allowed to touch an ump but they can push you?
It is in fact against the rules for the umps to touch players but they ALWAYS get away with it
@@barrystorms6891 There are a lot of rules that get ignored.
I thought if the catcher had the ball he could block the plate
That catcher rule is rough idk they probably should take out the rule
The Yankees seem to always have the angriest players and managers
When did they start using challenges in baseball like they do in football? That’s a good idea
I think around 2009.
@@Sharkie626 remember who was the 1st player involved in a challenge?
The use of a mic in challenges? It's a new thing this year
2015.
I'd like one of the managers to point at the ump and make the same "throwing them out of the game" gestures
I've definitely seen that before a couple of times
Soooo future catchers and outfielders there’s no more plays at the plate. If a guy is rounding third don’t throw the ball home, hit the cutoff man. Cause the run would score either way😐 they need to fix that rule and the umpires need to read it and understand it
The whole reviewed in NY i will never understand that. Why would they have better views snd understanding then the umpires on the field.
I'm surprised more of them don't get knocked out
Umpires seem as confused as everybody else about some of these rules.
What happened to the rockies catcher happened to the twins catcher too. It's a ridiculous rule
When Rocco gets that mad, you're wrong
@@torijohnston7428 very true. For being an Cleveland fan and he’s competing in the AL Central, he had every right to be hot about that call. Umps in NY missed that one. Rocco is also very mild mannered when he gets that mad it’s usually because he’s right.
@@ZackAttack1295 exactly
Oli dd amazing with CB lol
Love to watch an umpire get one straight to chest
0:42 is this football
MLB doesn't need that remote decision that is frequently wrong and an insult to the umps on the field. The blocking rule is seldom correctly used.. [read the whole thing]
The video keeps saying “No Stream Tap to Retry”?? Can you fix it plz!
I was mostly in favor of the catcher interference rule. But watching this, it’s like a black and white rule instead of grey. Orrrrrrrrr, the guys up in New York are just bad at their job
Buster Posey rule is horrible. Too many Umpires are narcissists. Umpires are not the game. Baseball desperately needs a new commissioner.
They should just let the runner score from now on
The blocking the plate rule is stupid. Go back to nailing the catcher
Call the damn replay on the field instead of NY and you would probably get more even calls.
This stupid rule of home plate is caused a lot of problems, that’s is not how the game is play ,
Badcall 😮
Due they review calls in New Jersey or New York 4:04
If ump makes the error then should not be permitted to throw anyone out of game because they caused problem
Why is ump yelling at people, if they that one time the ump should be removed .
There's no questions umps are awful this year
This rule does suck if you call the runners safe in the forst place your gonna have managers arguing that he was tagged out but if you call them out in the first place then you have them arguing this rule
Oh well deal with it 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
9:32 Unfortunately for the commentators, the umpires are right. Nobody from either team CAN NOT come out after a challenge, it is an immediate ejection, because it is not their call, but rather the call of the officials up in New York.
Between 8:30 and 9:00, umpire is right! That catcher can’t blocked the whole plate!
VERY Clear obstruction by catcher.
You may not entirely block plate or bases before making a play on the ball.
Great call.
Get rid of the catcher!
エグゼクティブ・デシジョン スチュワート・ベアード監督 アクション/スリラー
PARKERパーカー テイラー・ハックフォート監督 アクション/クライム
Go back to letting the base runner and catcher collide. The game is getting softer as the years go on. Unwatchable.