My wife and I are doing a recycling focused co-op run. We did the math for 1000 pots with angler and lure master, and, using all the coal from trash to smoke lobsters, crabs, and as many crayfish as you can, you’d make roughly the same money from freshwater pots as ocean ones. It was an interesting find.
I started a game with a bunch of mods, one of them being automation. I set up several traps in the lake, with a chest to store what they catch, a deluxe worm bin to supply the traps daily, a trash recycler to convert all the junk they gather, and a smoker to boost the value of the fish caught. With this setup, checking it once or twice a year can net a pretty significant profit considering the minimal effort and materials needed. Great video btw!
I do much the same 5 pots to 1 wormbin with a recycler, A kiln to convert any wood from the recycled trash to coal and a smoker. This can scale up by adding pots and wormbins. I generally just pull all the fish smoked or not on the 28th to give me a boost to cash for the next seasons crops. This also works well with the mod "fishnets" this introduces fishnets (duh) that work the same as the pots except that they catch regular fish
Here's a quick tip for PC users: 1. Download the "Automate" mod. 2. Line up your crab pots. 3. Place a chest beside just one of those crab pots. 4. Place your preferred bait inside the chest. And there you have it. The chest will automatically place baits on your crab pots each day and retrieve the catch, and place it on your chest. And to make things better, place a recycling machine beside the chest so that garbage will automatically be converted to something useful.
I set up 3 crab pots and one deluxe bait ratio. This does two things. One obviously you'll always have enough bait for the pots, two any leftover bait is sent to my fishing rod. I don't fish daily but usually pass by some crab pot stations. This lets me slowly build up my bait count in the fishing rod for when I do want to go fishing for a specific reason. Granted it's not a huge amount of exp, but it's more than enough for me to make fertilizer.
I think you're on to something. If CDs and glasses didn't eat the bait, then you should be able to catch them without baiting the crab pots at all. Proof of sentient trash in Stardew?
i'm currently doing my first proper playthough (just hit ginger island) and was using 12 crap pots the whole game. i put them in the small pond on the farm and have 4 deluxe bait maker to feed them + extra for fishing myself. I was using all the cashed fish for creating quality fertilizer but stopped in year 2 for deluxe speed-gro. i'm currently using it to make sashimi and thats my goto food for any situation + i just gift it when ever i see a villiger. it's like by most villigers and loved my sebastion. just don't give it to emily, kent or Evelyn.
Crab pots fill/create in a new niche in a super diverse game. It adds to the game, and I'm sure some enjoy it! I never use them but to fish for the items needed for fishing perfection and MAYBE orders. Repeat visit loading is bad enough in other machines that give even greater rewards. I'd rather decide between when to plant crops, harvest, mine, or just pole fish on most days.
i find "rebaiting" the pots incredibly annoying so unless i have to do the crabpot bundle or im looking to romance Elliot the only crab pots in my playthroughs are gonna be for decoration xD
The mod "automate" can help with that with this mod if the pots are adjacent to a chest anything caught buy the pots is automatically transferred to the chest and any bait in the chest transfers to the empty pots. Next add a wormbin next to the chest. The bait produced by the bin automatically transfers to the chest
I think crab pots deserve a buff, like they always catch a fish with bait and only trash without, one level 10 profession is mariner and luremaster combined (you don't need bait to catch fish), and the other is chance to catch treasure maybe, or make your fish iridium quality.
I'm with you, there. I really wanted mariner or luremaster to be worth it, but they are so disappointing compared to most other professions, it's hard to justify going that route, even just for variety on different playthroughs.
To be honest, I do beach foraging, crab hunting in the mines, and checking the Traveling Cart until I get what I need to complete the Crab Pot Bundle for the 3 free pots, use them just enough to catch enough of each Crab Pot fish to complete Gourmet Chef, Master Angler, and any Raccoon Requests, and then never look at them again. I just find the pots to be too space, labor, and time intensive for the amount of money they bring in. You can't easily group them together like you can with crops, animals, artisan equipment, or mushroom logs. They require constant daily maintenance in order to maintain the gold flow (also one of the reasons why I prefer bats to mushrooms for the cave), so any day you don't spend emptying and refilling them is lost income. And since I don't play with mods, they have to be manually loaded and unloaded, but unlike other similar equipment like kegs or casks there is the additional risk of accidentally misclicking, pulling a pot out of the water, and then having to spend a few extra seconds putting it back. By comparison, I can head down to the beach, spend a few in-game hours in one spot catching some gold or iridium-quality ocean fish, pop them in smokers, and make as much money from that one haul as I would from meticulously maintaining dozens of crab pots. And if I don't feel like doing that again the next day, I'm free to do something else with that time without the spectre of losing money from skipping a daily task.
Once Ginger Island is unlocked, you can also mine those beach rocks for extra fish. I collected so many that by the time I finished with smoking them all, I had a 30k profit from them because I had angler and artisan, and they count as fish.
Small note (I'm not sure if you said it and I missed it): If you are planing on catching any specific fish (like mussels to trade for mango saplings), you should NOT pick the mariner profession since it overwrites the chances to be all equal to 0.143 regardless of the bait used. Thus, it is best to get any other profession and use targeted bait for a chance of 0.218 (in case of mussels).
Good point. I didn't mention that explicitly, so thanks for bringing it up. In that case it would also be wise to avoid luremaster, since it would be auto-baiting with standard bait instead of targeted bait. Thanks for watching!
In coop you can have both Mariner and Angler, as some perks are shared, mostly the ones that affect prices, so that there isnt a "i sell these and you sell these items" kind of hassle. So it might have been worth to have had a theoretical of the both of em together.
Crab pots are worth not for the money but for the ability to get a lot of refined quartz daily. That's why I value Luremaster skill since it save the time and effort to refill the lure and you want more junk anyway.
I think with all the Roe we got in 1. 6 we need an aquaculture builing to hatch fish. The building could even go in the water or be a bit like a storage shed with some room for machines in addition to like 3 tanks to hatch roe.
I like crab pots. if you have Recycling Machines they're awesome. so I have the Automate Mod that allows machines to automatically work with a chest right next to them. if you put one of each fish they catch and each trash item they auto harvest them too. so what I do is put down a chest and a whole line of Pots then I either put some bait in the chest and let them work. but I found out that I can actually put a Bait Bin down next to the chest too and the Bait Bin will auto deposit it's bait into the chest which will automatically put it in the pots as long as they're in a line and Touching each other. it's pretty awesome. I never take Mariner because I want Trash.
On my first 1.6 playthrough I spent nearly two ingame months with half a dozen crab pots failing to get the mussel I needed to complete my fishing collection and it NEVER occurred to me that I could have made bait from the foraged ones to help out 😭
Have u ever factored in using mariner profession to get the goods and then switch professions to angler to sell the fish? Wouldn’t that change profits?
Good thought, but unfortunately no. Someone else brought up multiplayer and stacking professions, which would do something similar. You could definitely boost profits if you plan it out right, but since switching professions is a fixed cost, it really depends on how much you collect before you make the switch. Could definitely be worth considering if you're using a lot of crab pots. Thanks for watching and commenting!
Is there any way to increase the chances of bigger crabpot fish? Like luck or fishing level? (I only need a 5 in. shrimp to have max size for all fish except legendary, and it's not giving me one :(
All of the calculated profits assume recycled trash is sold as-is. Specific trash recycling products may be more valuable to keep though (coal?), so the true value may vary person to person. Thanks for watching!
My wife and I are doing a recycling focused co-op run. We did the math for 1000 pots with angler and lure master, and, using all the coal from trash to smoke lobsters, crabs, and as many crayfish as you can, you’d make roughly the same money from freshwater pots as ocean ones. It was an interesting find.
you would def like the walk of life mod version of the trapper profession, check it out, I loved it
That’s cool because I made my characters clothing with cloth made from recycling the soggy newspaper
That conversation with Willy explained so much about why he is still single. My heart goes out to you, poor misunderstood man.
it never occurred to me to use targeted bait in crab pots. Now i can make crab cakes without ponds. Pog
I started a game with a bunch of mods, one of them being automation. I set up several traps in the lake, with a chest to store what they catch, a deluxe worm bin to supply the traps daily, a trash recycler to convert all the junk they gather, and a smoker to boost the value of the fish caught. With this setup, checking it once or twice a year can net a pretty significant profit considering the minimal effort and materials needed. Great video btw!
I do much the same 5 pots to 1 wormbin with a recycler, A kiln to convert any wood from the recycled trash to coal and a smoker. This can scale up by adding pots and wormbins. I generally just pull all the fish smoked or not on the 28th to give me a boost to cash for the next seasons crops. This also works well with the mod "fishnets" this introduces fishnets (duh) that work the same as the pots except that they catch regular fish
Here's a quick tip for PC users:
1. Download the "Automate" mod.
2. Line up your crab pots.
3. Place a chest beside just one of those crab pots.
4. Place your preferred bait inside the chest.
And there you have it. The chest will automatically place baits on your crab pots each day and retrieve the catch, and place it on your chest.
And to make things better, place a recycling machine beside the chest so that garbage will automatically be converted to something useful.
put a worm bin next to the chest. it will make bait, put it in the chest, which will then get pulled by the pots.
I set up 3 crab pots and one deluxe bait ratio. This does two things. One obviously you'll always have enough bait for the pots, two any leftover bait is sent to my fishing rod. I don't fish daily but usually pass by some crab pot stations. This lets me slowly build up my bait count in the fishing rod for when I do want to go fishing for a specific reason. Granted it's not a huge amount of exp, but it's more than enough for me to make fertilizer.
Now they just need to make a bait that targets CDs and glasses...
I think you're on to something. If CDs and glasses didn't eat the bait, then you should be able to catch them without baiting the crab pots at all. Proof of sentient trash in Stardew?
I usually only keep a couple of crab pots around, mostly for making lobster bisque. I think wild bait may be best in that case.
I like collecting the trash from the crab pots turning glasses into quarts can be nice.
i'm currently doing my first proper playthough (just hit ginger island) and was using 12 crap pots the whole game. i put them in the small pond on the farm and have 4 deluxe bait maker to feed them + extra for fishing myself. I was using all the cashed fish for creating quality fertilizer but stopped in year 2 for deluxe speed-gro. i'm currently using it to make sashimi and thats my goto food for any situation + i just gift it when ever i see a villiger. it's like by most villigers and loved my sebastion. just don't give it to emily, kent or Evelyn.
Crab pots fill/create in a new niche in a super diverse game. It adds to the game, and I'm sure some enjoy it! I never use them but to fish for the items needed for fishing perfection and MAYBE orders. Repeat visit loading is bad enough in other machines that give even greater rewards. I'd rather decide between when to plant crops, harvest, mine, or just pole fish on most days.
i find "rebaiting" the pots incredibly annoying so unless i have to do the crabpot bundle or im looking to romance Elliot the only crab pots in my playthroughs are gonna be for decoration xD
The mod "automate" can help with that with this mod if the pots are adjacent to a chest anything caught buy the pots is automatically transferred to the chest and any bait in the chest transfers to the empty pots. Next add a wormbin next to the chest. The bait produced by the bin automatically transfers to the chest
I think crab pots deserve a buff, like they always catch a fish with bait and only trash without, one level 10 profession is mariner and luremaster combined (you don't need bait to catch fish), and the other is chance to catch treasure maybe, or make your fish iridium quality.
I'm with you, there. I really wanted mariner or luremaster to be worth it, but they are so disappointing compared to most other professions, it's hard to justify going that route, even just for variety on different playthroughs.
To be honest, I do beach foraging, crab hunting in the mines, and checking the Traveling Cart until I get what I need to complete the Crab Pot Bundle for the 3 free pots, use them just enough to catch enough of each Crab Pot fish to complete Gourmet Chef, Master Angler, and any Raccoon Requests, and then never look at them again.
I just find the pots to be too space, labor, and time intensive for the amount of money they bring in. You can't easily group them together like you can with crops, animals, artisan equipment, or mushroom logs. They require constant daily maintenance in order to maintain the gold flow (also one of the reasons why I prefer bats to mushrooms for the cave), so any day you don't spend emptying and refilling them is lost income. And since I don't play with mods, they have to be manually loaded and unloaded, but unlike other similar equipment like kegs or casks there is the additional risk of accidentally misclicking, pulling a pot out of the water, and then having to spend a few extra seconds putting it back.
By comparison, I can head down to the beach, spend a few in-game hours in one spot catching some gold or iridium-quality ocean fish, pop them in smokers, and make as much money from that one haul as I would from meticulously maintaining dozens of crab pots. And if I don't feel like doing that again the next day, I'm free to do something else with that time without the spectre of losing money from skipping a daily task.
Once Ginger Island is unlocked, you can also mine those beach rocks for extra fish. I collected so many that by the time I finished with smoking them all, I had a 30k profit from them because I had angler and artisan, and they count as fish.
Small note (I'm not sure if you said it and I missed it): If you are planing on catching any specific fish (like mussels to trade for mango saplings), you should NOT pick the mariner profession since it overwrites the chances to be all equal to 0.143 regardless of the bait used. Thus, it is best to get any other profession and use targeted bait for a chance of 0.218 (in case of mussels).
Good point. I didn't mention that explicitly, so thanks for bringing it up. In that case it would also be wise to avoid luremaster, since it would be auto-baiting with standard bait instead of targeted bait. Thanks for watching!
In coop you can have both Mariner and Angler, as some perks are shared, mostly the ones that affect prices, so that there isnt a "i sell these and you sell these items" kind of hassle.
So it might have been worth to have had a theoretical of the both of em together.
That's a great point. I totally overlooked stacking professions in multiplayer. I'll have to keep that in mind for future videos. Thanks for watching!
Crab pots are worth not for the money but for the ability to get a lot of refined quartz daily. That's why I value Luremaster skill since it save the time and effort to refill the lure and you want more junk anyway.
I think with all the Roe we got in 1.
6 we need an aquaculture builing to hatch fish. The building could even go in the water or be a bit like a storage shed with some room for machines in addition to like 3 tanks to hatch roe.
I really like that idea. Would love to see fish pond or fish hatchery related professions too. Thanks for watching!
Let me tell you the tale of the automate mod.....
I think they are worth it. I use them to make quality fertilizer
I like crab pots. if you have Recycling Machines they're awesome.
so I have the Automate Mod that allows machines to automatically work with a chest right next to them.
if you put one of each fish they catch and each trash item they auto harvest them too.
so what I do is put down a chest and a whole line of Pots then I either put some bait in the chest and let them work.
but I found out that I can actually put a Bait Bin down next to the chest too and the Bait Bin will auto deposit it's bait into the chest which will automatically put it in the pots as long as they're in a line and Touching each other. it's pretty awesome.
I never take Mariner because I want Trash.
On my first 1.6 playthrough I spent nearly two ingame months with half a dozen crab pots failing to get the mussel I needed to complete my fishing collection and it NEVER occurred to me that I could have made bait from the foraged ones to help out 😭
Have u ever factored in using mariner profession to get the goods and then switch professions to angler to sell the fish? Wouldn’t that change profits?
Good thought, but unfortunately no. Someone else brought up multiplayer and stacking professions, which would do something similar. You could definitely boost profits if you plan it out right, but since switching professions is a fixed cost, it really depends on how much you collect before you make the switch. Could definitely be worth considering if you're using a lot of crab pots. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@ 🤗👍🏻
I've always thought of crab pots as a good, passive way to raise your fishing skill?
Is there any way to increase the chances of bigger crabpot fish? Like luck or fishing level? (I only need a 5 in. shrimp to have max size for all fish except legendary, and it's not giving me one :(
I think the Deluxe Bait has a chance of improving the quality. A better quality fish is usually a bigger fish too I think. Worth a try.
Unfortunately I play on ps4 so no deluxe bait yet
how profitable are they considering the value of the recycled trash ?
All of the calculated profits assume recycled trash is sold as-is. Specific trash recycling products may be more valuable to keep though (coal?), so the true value may vary person to person. Thanks for watching!
Poor Eliot is always getting a hated gift
He needs to "Get a Haircut and Get a Real Job", as the song goes!
I don't craft or buy them - I get them from the cc and the trout derby, and just use about 6 or 7 for anything I need.
*10 sec to make bait. not 10 min.
Oh, that's 10 in-game minutes to make bait (according to the game clock). Sorry if that wasn't clear 😊
@@Kitadollx gotcha
Nope!
The only thing worth doing is making coops and silos!
Then sleep for a thousand years and sell your golden eggs!
What am I doing with my life
First?!?