Worth it. I was sad when they died, but in the beginning of the short film I was literally fearful knowing that one day they would run out of light bulbs. I would SO rather have a moment of paradise
Yes but should you bring everybody with you? Steal from them there life source and use it for your own gain? Forcing your ideology instead of asking? Even if the majority is okay with it, should you really left the ones against it to rot with all of the others? Idk I find this message kind of creepy.
JFlame yes but what does wasting actually mean? It is actually extremely vague. I could say at the same time that quilling every one without fully achieving your dream is the most meaningless and pointless thing in the video. So what do you actually mean?
@@alexmoisaholt1206 there's a name for that. Planed obsolesces in the early days light bulb lifespan was deliberately short to sell more bulbs. The lifespan of these bulbs is nuts though. how were they even going to last an hour before running out of them.
People say it is a sad ending because they died. Look at their faces, they finished their lives with happiness and joy, how's that sad ? Isn't it beautiful to dedicate your whole being and soul to your most desired passion and motivation only to end it when completed
You miss the whole point, they where not human they didn't have happiness or joy they were machines doing what machines do. Living in a dim recollection of something they had no real experience of. The Sun.
why can't the robots share a room? imagine how much more efficient it would be if the robots shared the same light bulb and watched the same flip book. *THERE'D BE LESS LIGHT BULBS WASTED!*
@@Ifzall privacy doing what? the exact thing everyone else is doing? everyone knows exactly what everyone else is doing, it's not like they have personal information that is relevant, or have secrets.
@@umamifan all except that robot, of course, but that artificial sun secret has nothing to do with my main point that they could have shared energy from 1 light bulb. and if they did efficiently share a light bulb, the robot wouldn't have to have a secret of stealing other robots' bulbs because they'd be sharing one. therefore your point is nonexistent.
I feel that this has a deeper meaning that we are supposed to get from this. Excellent animation yet I think it is more than just one robot creating an artificial sun for a single moment of wonder. Would love to hear from the creator about this....
"it's help others and help yourself" bro you're brain dead if you think that's the right and unquestionnable awnser, the reall meaning of something can be find with at least 5 years of thinking of it and linking it with other speculations.
Quality of life over quantity of life. The one robot figured out that what they were doing wasn't living; it was just existing, so it used up all their remaining power all at once, but it was worth it since their collective dream finally came true.
I felt like this is a society of capitalism. Ppl all have money in their house. Some ppl die when it runs out, big corp steal all the money out of ur house and pocket by any means and methods, and make u be seduced and tempted that might make u feel like u are flying higher and higher , be rich and achieve fantasies u had in you, but when u are so close to it they cut the rope and let you fall to die because they dont want you to reach their position and get what they have... This is so sad ending imo
Вспомнилось: ... Тот был умней, кто свой огонь сберег - Он обогреть других уже не мог, Но без потерь дожил до теплых дней. А ты был не прав, ты все спалил за час, И через час большой огонь угас, Но в этот час стало всем теплей.
when they started flying i thought: oh, the moral of the story is that you shouldnt wait for something to happen but make it happen yourself instead. Then they fell and died and i just thought: maybe the moral is to be happy with what you got and dash all ambitions... Now I dont know anymore haha, either way really well done
i think it wants to say that one moment of paridise is better than a long life with no fun and no happyness, becaus when he dies he has a smile on his face
At one hand, a meaningful short live can be better than a meaningless long live. At the other hand, when you are closer to death you may come to realize why life is so precious
I interpret this film as a parallel to the evolution of mankind. One all of the bulbs were United, every individual experienced the power of every bulb at once, but since they all turned on at once, they all shut off at once. One great fire that burned incredibly fast. Once mankind units under one nation, the times will be wonderful, but quickly that nation will fall. Classic retelling of the fall of the great Roman Empire.
Gokalp, I as suppressed that you really read my comment, if I knew that you would read it I would have extended my thoughts. You have captured some aspect that is not totally in the human mind or emotion in you file. Ever Animation is or film, book, story is always something that emotes from the human mind. Your beings emoted an unknown feeling for the golden sun in the contraption that they viewed all day. I loved the way your being gentle circle the image of the sun, which he had never seen, with his unhuman finger. How he and is fellow beings would spend there mechanical time doing the same mechanical things - viewing images of an unknown --could it of been a past-- they don't know what a past is) but they do it as if it has meaning, but are your beings endowed with what meaning is? Replacing the source of their own illumination with a sense of importance but meaning- lessness. Him looking for a useful light bulb indicated to me that they had a limited amount of time left, but he didn't even know that. Watching out for the illumination of their fellow beings. I like how you gave them a sense of time with the wristwatch wish only had one purpose. It was all wonderful. A great ending that I myself is unable to articulate which also gives it a dimension that we human or your beings can not know. An insect my live close to this type of world. But I think not. Thank you for a most thoughtful experience and I hope a great future for you. P.S. Your film is so much more than your explanation.
Amazing short! Loved the lighting and comp. Hope to see a behind the scenes soon :) possibly one showing off the character rigs? Once again, kickass work guys!
Not entirely sure what was up with the first guy's drawings. was it a hope? Their origin? what was their purpose in life? well either way I found myself drawn in. I loved the whole thing. Beautiful.
one raising star who able to achive their dream whenever the journey for that needs unbelievable steps,which also not admirable. but after it u shall enjoy your life😊
This is a simple, sweet fable, with a beautiful lesson that's meant to be taken at face value, and I think the worst thing someone can do is over-analyze it, looking for some kind of hidden, deeper meaning.
I was so excited about the light returning. Now I'm saddened by the end of the video. But I understand that we can't see the true ending to the story of life and the value of such. 👍🏻 💚 Still, it gives me hope for the future!
I found this via the new Pentagram video and oh my god! I've been watching it several times a day every day! The robots look so smooth that I want to touch them! They're so beautifully designed. There's so much to think about in just eight minutes.
A wierd turn of events realy love the way you just miss lead the audience into believing that the story might have a happy ending and just end up into a dark twist realy amazing ,👍
Hocam çok güzeldi, ellerine sağlık. Sonu kalbimi titretti. Bir an bile sürecek olsa da, o anlık özgürlüğe değdi mi? Güzel bir soru bıraktı aklımda. Tekrardan ellerine sağlık.
hocam geçimimi sağlamak için yaptığım ticari işlerle birlikte yaklaşık bir yıla yayıldı ancak tahmin ediyorum net 6 ay çalıştım. Evet tek başıma ürettim.
Tebrik ederim, tek bir elden böylesi bir çalışmanın çıkması gerçekten takdire şayan, insan gururlanıyor. En yakın zamanda diğer projelerinize de bakacağım. :)
Every which has been created has to be destroy one day and you can't stop that This video gives us a lesson that we should try to make our dreams true until our last breath
Anyone can accomplish one single task but to do something extraordinary you need everyone's help. If you take too long to realize that... it will be too late.
"Freudian slip" reading? I'm always Freudian hearing, I know people didn't just say the stuff I hear sometimes! Also, did you realize what it actually said before, or after you clicked on it?
A moment of paradise rather than a life of darkness
Worth it. I was sad when they died, but in the beginning of the short film I was literally fearful knowing that one day they would run out of light bulbs. I would SO rather have a moment of paradise
You're...both right...thanks
Yes but should you bring everybody with you? Steal from them there life source and use it for your own gain? Forcing your ideology instead of asking? Even if the majority is okay with it, should you really left the ones against it to rot with all of the others? Idk I find this message kind of creepy.
Like life here on earth, use your precious time wisely, or waste it on never achieving anything.
JFlame yes but what does wasting actually mean? It is actually extremely vague. I could say at the same time that quilling every one without fully achieving your dream is the most meaningless and pointless thing in the video. So what do you actually mean?
Invest in some LED light bulbs my dudes
XD
Ikr? Thomas Edison would be breaking down their door asking them why they haven't got a single bulb that lasts over 30 seconds.
Yeah lol
@@alexmoisaholt1206 there's a name for that. Planed obsolesces in the early days light bulb lifespan was deliberately short to sell more bulbs.
The lifespan of these bulbs is nuts though. how were they even going to last an hour before running out of them.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 that was so funny.
People say it is a sad ending because they died. Look at their faces, they finished their lives with happiness and joy, how's that sad ? Isn't it beautiful to dedicate your whole being and soul to your most desired passion and motivation only to end it when completed
orehcele deep.
das prety deep m8
like donald trump and Kim Jong-un, they ll take us to their happy ending right?
You miss the whole point, they where not human they didn't have happiness or joy they were machines doing what machines do. Living in a dim recollection of something they had no real experience of. The Sun.
orehcele Completed ??? They flew for like 2 seconds !!!
why can't the robots share a room? imagine how much more efficient it would be if the robots shared the same light bulb and watched the same flip book. *THERE'D BE LESS LIGHT BULBS WASTED!*
This Yellow Face for real tho 😂
privacy
@@Ifzall privacy doing what? the exact thing everyone else is doing? everyone knows exactly what everyone else is doing, it's not like they have personal information that is relevant, or have secrets.
@@xkilla911 technically the robot who made the artificial sun had a secret. considering he didn't tell anyone else about it
@@umamifan all except that robot, of course, but that artificial sun secret has nothing to do with my main point that they could have shared energy from 1 light bulb.
and if they did efficiently share a light bulb, the robot wouldn't have to have a secret of stealing other robots' bulbs because they'd be sharing one. therefore your point is nonexistent.
If anyone has any question please shoot! I am here as the director of this film and ready to answer. Enjoy!
gökalp gönen amazing job!
Thank you Zach!
I have so many questions but i think it's better if they aren't answered. Great Job this was amazing.
gökalp gönen is there a story behind this?
@The Physicist çok sağol hocam! :)
Complimenti per il progetto ben scenografato e costruito nello spazio di un cortometraggio… pura poesia 🎥
better to live free for a moment then to live in fear for ever.
Absolutely..
I'd rather live than die
@C....14x.
Ok
I'm getting the sense we don't know the full story here. Like why were they like that in the first place? How are they getting the bubles etc.
I've watched a lot of short stories on here... This was by far one of the best. It was very creative. I like everything about it.
Agreed
I feel that this has a deeper meaning that we are supposed to get from this. Excellent animation yet I think it is more than just one robot creating an artificial sun for a single moment of wonder. Would love to hear from the creator about this....
All shall be revealed upon your consumption of a psychedelic compound. Be careful not to see more than your mind can handle...
It’s to help others and your self
"it's help others and help yourself" bro you're brain dead if you think that's the right and unquestionnable awnser, the reall meaning of something can be find with at least 5 years of thinking of it and linking it with other speculations.
Quality of life over quantity of life. The one robot figured out that what they were doing wasn't living; it was just existing, so it used up all their remaining power all at once, but it was worth it since their collective dream finally came true.
I felt like this is a society of capitalism.
Ppl all have money in their house. Some ppl die when it runs out, big corp steal all the money out of ur house and pocket by any means and methods, and make u be seduced and tempted that might make u feel like u are flying higher and higher , be rich and achieve fantasies u had in you, but when u are so close to it they cut the rope and let you fall to die because they dont want you to reach their position and get what they have... This is so sad ending imo
Подобные анимации прекрасны тем, что доступны для понимания всех людей, вне зависимости от их родного языка, вне зависимости от прошедших лет
Such nice words ❤
Вчем смысл?, сновым годом
Вспомнилось: ...
Тот был умней, кто свой огонь сберег -
Он обогреть других уже не мог,
Но без потерь дожил до теплых дней.
А ты был не прав, ты все спалил за час,
И через час большой огонь угас,
Но в этот час стало всем теплей.
when they started flying i thought: oh, the moral of the story is that you shouldnt wait for something to happen but make it happen yourself instead. Then they fell and died and i just thought: maybe the moral is to be happy with what you got and dash all ambitions...
Now I dont know anymore haha, either way really well done
TheMissPelled id be smilling too if my only reason to live was to make sure my neighbor doesnt die ends because one guy gave me wings
But every last one of them died because of the selfish actions of one guy. Even if the majority was happy, what about the others? It’s super creepy...
i think it wants to say that one moment of paridise is better than a long life with no fun and no happyness, becaus when he dies he has a smile on his face
Maybe That's just How we Humans are A life time of Misery A Moment of Joy Do you even know how Hard it is To Find love In this Life?
A morte era uma questão de tempo, ao menos houve uma tentativa;
I love the expresions of the robot. You can see so much throught the eyes only. This was beautifully done, thank you. ❤
The enjoyment was short, but it was enjoyment
At one hand, a meaningful short live can be better than a meaningless long live.
At the other hand, when you are closer to death you may come to realize why life is so precious
Oh god I found this very cool!
The effects sounds and lights/shadows are amazing! :D
What is the idea behind of this film 🎥 not the light and sound
man, i remembered when this came out. seeing it again makes me realize how good it was for its time and even now.
My, that was unexpected. Brilliantly conceived and executed until the very end. Bravo!
I guess everyone have their own way of interpretation, but that's what I got!!! out of it!! Beautifully done!!!! Thanks!!!!!!!!!
Damn, that was a rug pull.
Loved how the animator designed them to be so expressive, though.
Gökalp Gönen! Kutlarım. Bana gurur verdiniz. Çok etkileyici bir öykü. Bir kez daha izlemem gerek.
А что? С первого раза ничего не понял?
Ne zamandır kısa film izliyorum ilk defa bi Türk e denk geldim, çok güzel verilen mesaj da helal olsun :)
aynen öyle :) Altın Vuruş
si scusa You English
Aynen
Mesajı anlamadım ?
Aynen
I interpret this film as a parallel to the evolution of mankind. One all of the bulbs were United, every individual experienced the power of every bulb at once, but since they all turned on at once, they all shut off at once. One great fire that burned incredibly fast. Once mankind units under one nation, the times will be wonderful, but quickly that nation will fall. Classic retelling of the fall of the great Roman Empire.
this was DEEP, and everyone who thought it was sad its okay because it explain life in every aspect. look past the sadness.
Moral : Buy Phillips LED'S.. they last longer than a few minutes🤣🤣🤣..
Jk the CGI was impressive 😌
@BOLT Gaming loll
that was intense. i love their little smiles at the end c: great job! i was sad that it ended that way but i think its the better way of ending it!
Ah. The story of the moths with a steampunk twist.
I've watched many many animated shorts but this was by far the coolest I've ever seen. what imagination. so different
Thank you so much Pat. I am working on a new short now, and was having some motivation issues. Now i feel really good :D
Gokalp, I as suppressed that you really read my comment, if I knew that you would read it I would have extended my thoughts. You have captured some aspect that is not totally in the human mind or emotion in you file. Ever Animation is or film, book, story is always something that emotes from the human mind. Your beings emoted an unknown feeling for the golden sun in the contraption that they viewed all day. I loved the way your being gentle circle the image of the sun, which he had never seen, with his unhuman finger. How he and is fellow beings would spend there mechanical time doing the same mechanical things - viewing images of an unknown --could it of been a past-- they don't know what a past is) but they do it as if it has meaning, but are your beings endowed with what meaning is? Replacing the source of their own illumination with a sense of importance but meaning- lessness. Him looking for a useful light bulb indicated to me that they had a limited amount of time left, but he didn't even know that. Watching out for the illumination of their fellow beings. I like how you gave them a sense of time with the wristwatch wish only had one purpose. It was all wonderful. A great ending that I myself is unable to articulate which also gives it a dimension that we human or your beings can not know. An insect my live close to this type of world. But I think not. Thank you for a most thoughtful experience and I hope a great future for you. P.S. Your film is so much more than your explanation.
Мечты разбиваются об реальность!!! Хотелось как лучше,но получилось как всегда...!😎
when i played this video my laptop went into power saving mode
😂
Oh, no!
XD
That's great! LoL 😹🤣
its an omen
Fascinating animation! Gökalp Gönen'e animasyonu için teşekkür ederiz.
This isn't even their final form
oh no.. i know what u think :/
What do you think
Huh?
jep ok...
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
The light that burns twice as bright burns half as long.
Amazing short! Loved the lighting and comp. Hope to see a behind the scenes soon :) possibly one showing off the character rigs? Once again, kickass work guys!
this is animation is so high detailed
oh my god...that was insane...my absolute favorite...I was so intrigued the entire time and the end had me SHOOKETH!!!!
Thanks elle!
Hi beautiful
Like the humans. Beautiful Film !!
Not entirely sure what was up with the first guy's drawings. was it a hope? Their origin? what was their purpose in life? well either way I found myself drawn in. I loved the whole thing. Beautiful.
There dream and hope
Данунах...)
Life is not lost by dying. Life is lost minute by minute, day by dragging day, in all the thousands small uncaring ways.
i really like those who took the meaning ""something good for a moment better than for ever bad"
THIS IS TOO GOOD FOR ME TO CRITICISE ANYTHING. JUST……WOW🎉🎉🎉🎉
one raising star who able to achive their dream whenever the journey for that needs unbelievable steps,which also not admirable.
but after it u shall enjoy your life😊
İlk defa Türk yapımına denk geldim👌 güzel çalışma🌵
BENDE KISA FİLMLERİ İZLİYOR VE İNCELİYORUM. BUNU YAPABİLENİN ELİNDE İMKAN VARSA, İMKANI OLANLARINDA YENİLERİNİ ÇIKARMASI MÜMKÜN
This is a simple, sweet fable, with a beautiful lesson that's meant to be taken at face value, and I think the worst thing someone can do is over-analyze it, looking for some kind of hidden, deeper meaning.
You are perhaps the best animator on TH-cam who can compete with Disney and Pixar.
Wow, that ended...completely different from what I expected. Interesting message though, and great animation!
Woah. So many cosmic entities at once.
This began scary then came beauty then came death😔 R.I.P to these robots
I was so excited about the light returning. Now I'm saddened by the end of the video.
But I understand that we can't see the true ending to the story of life and the value of such. 👍🏻 💚
Still, it gives me hope for the future!
I found this via the new Pentagram video and oh my god! I've been watching it several times a day every day! The robots look so smooth that I want to touch them! They're so beautifully designed. There's so much to think about in just eight minutes.
Worth a shot.....A golden shot..And what i mean by shot ks not the animation but the one who created the "sun"
This was really well done
they are destined to live in a loop.
tebrik ederim bizim de böyle güzel şeyler yapabilmemiz gurur verici
I don't speak....German? (No offense please don't kill me)
This brought me to tears. I don't exactly know why but it did.
This is dedicating me about the present pure water on earth . This is really very good animated series. Hats off guys for your wounderful work.
Well that cheered me up no end...
why do they die its sad. I want them to live.
DyNaMiC KhAoSs ok well you wish they we're alive or something
DyNaMiC KhAoSs IKR
DyNaMiC KhAoSs same
Your dead parents never loved you.
bowl4two wow you're a jackass
Dude the music in here is absolutely nerve racking
A wierd turn of events realy love the way you just miss lead the audience into believing that the story might have a happy ending and just end up into a dark twist realy amazing ,👍
The moment before death is the moment that one can truly be happy.
İnanılmaz güzel bir çalışma olmuş. Gurur duydum. Başarılarınızın devamını dilerim 😇😍
永遠の不自由より
一瞬の自由を選び果てる
切なくも美しい…
Hocam çok güzeldi, ellerine sağlık. Sonu kalbimi titretti. Bir an bile sürecek olsa da, o anlık özgürlüğe değdi mi? Güzel bir soru bıraktı aklımda. Tekrardan ellerine sağlık.
çok teşekkürler hocam :)
2 sorum olacaktı müsaadenizle. Proje üzerinde tek başınıza mı çalıştınız ve birde ne kadar sürede tamamladığınızı öğrenebilir miyim? Mümkünse... :)
hocam geçimimi sağlamak için yaptığım ticari işlerle birlikte yaklaşık bir yıla yayıldı ancak tahmin ediyorum net 6 ay çalıştım. Evet tek başıma ürettim.
Tebrik ederim, tek bir elden böylesi bir çalışmanın çıkması gerçekten takdire şayan, insan gururlanıyor. En yakın zamanda diğer projelerinize de bakacağım. :)
@@triplepen TÜRKİYE'DE BU İMKANLAR BULUNABİLİYORMU?
No questions. Great job
Uno solo no puede cambiar el mundo, se necesita de colaboración. Todos debemos ayudar. 👍🏻
Every which has been created has to be destroy one day and you can't stop that
This video gives us a lesson that we should try to make our dreams true until our last breath
I literally shouted "NO" when the light went off in the final part
Anyone can accomplish one single task but to do something extraordinary you need everyone's help. If you take too long to realize that... it will be too late.
that was splendid
OH
MY
GOD
THAT
WAS
THE
BEST ENDING I GOT SO HAPPY
THEN THEY DIEDDDDDD
Well that was depressing. 12/10
Simply amazing.
Türk kardeşimiz yapmış vay be tebrikler
I thought they were bad. I’m so happy.
I'm not going to lie, when this popped up in recommended video, I thought it said "Golden Shower" 😱🤣🤣
"Freudian slip" reading? I'm always Freudian hearing, I know people didn't just say the stuff I hear sometimes!
Also, did you realize what it actually said before, or after you clicked on it?
amazing short !
That was beautiful, and depressing.
Amazing story and animation. Very very well done
Reminds me of the myth of Icarus, who burned his wings by flying too close from the sun.
that pretty cool, how when they die, they die at a moment of pure joy, so that they don't die in vain. Also very interesting concept!
That went dark..(no pun intended)
A+
5:53 When your mom calling you with a firm voice
Brilliant!
oh no
the FEEEEELLS
Tebrikler gokalp 🙌🙌🙌🙋
It's so MYST-esque and beautiful.
❤️🧡❤️
But am I wrong at 3:30, the creature suddenly holds up the right wrist instead of the left?
man! as the creator of this film, even i didn't realize that. After 5 years! thank you!! :D
Look at that, was amazing creepy, dang good..
"Don't put all your eggs in the same basket"
Great! Unique!
i don't know about you, but i find this ending funny. the robots got jebaited into dying lol.
I gotta say it was a little sad when they all fell and BROKE apart
But an animation is just an animation
The moral of the story: sun is most important thing in our life
Great job Garry you killed us all
morale of the story? Praise the su....welp that backfired
This reference.....
I don’t know what I just watched but know I’m crying
dat ending O.o
Excellent animation
This reminds me of 9
Kayla Barakat same
Well at least nobody is getting soul sucked
9 the movie
now I want to watch 9 again..
Same
It's the WD-40 Single-day fly, and they all completed the mission, chapeau!