Eve Barlow's Scheming: Depp V Heard Transcript Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Patreon: / runkleofthebailey
Locals: runkleofthebai...
BTC address: bc1qdqzpz6ny6w35qyl2rnasshjm60jvwcjgllwcay
All comments for information only. Do not take anything as legal advice--if you have a legal issue, contact a lawyer directly so that you can received advice tailored to your situation. All views expressed are solely those of the creator.
"Ms. Bredehoft is actually making things worse." Pretty much sums up the whole trial.
Classic Elaine 😂
It's funny how the way she's "defending" Eve Barlow is just her saying "I didn't know she did that" like it's just automatic for her to save her own ass first. and then she kiss ass the judge, whenever she can.
Somebody is hearing somebody scream ELAINEEE. 😂
@@druviseglite 😂
By the end of the trial I think this Judge officially couldn't stand Elaine
"First of all, Eve Barlow is not a journalist" - Elaine Bredehoft. Most truthful statement from Amber Heard's legal team during the whole trial.
Yet EB wonders why no one is calling her for her "journalism" skills. 😂😂😂 Elaine was on point with that remark.
She is a valued new addition to Heard's team. She was very proud and gave that wink to Elaine after her winning move. Why wasn't pseudo- barrister Barlow up there at the sidebar😂
Was about to say something about that! I love it! Even AH's lawyer is giving shade to Eve Barlow. XD
Looking forward to more of the sidebars.
Of course she’s not !!! She’s a rando lol
It is interesting to hear the transcripts of the sidebars. I must say that Judge A is an incredibly patient woman.
Too patient
@@wasteddemise2286No , not really . She allowed the trial to moving on .
She and Judge Dorow have shown me how little patience I have. AMAZING women. 💪💪
@@kristinehoya7396I don't agree with Dorow on some of her more personal opinions on issues, but she was an absolute bastion of patience and law and order during that trial. Basically superhuman.
incredibly patient AND forgiving. I would've yeeted barlow's butt straight to jail
I am glad to see that Eve Barlow is finally getting the recognition that she deserves. As Elaine Bredehof said "Eve Barlow is no journalist" which goes a long way to explaining why various media organisations are no longer accepting reports filed by her. Her inflated ego has finally been burst.
I love the name she chose for herself, "The Body Odor of Evil," or "Evil Musk."
I would love to hear the sidebars during the AH rebuttal when Elaine and Camille went to the bench at least half a dozen times. "What, if anything is not a cure all" "I'm trying! I'm trying!" That bit of testimony.
I second this motion!
I third this motion!
Yes! This is very interesting information.
Better than Netflix!
I would love to hear all the sidebars please.
How the hell Eve Barlow got away with this is beyond me.
Even after being kicked out, she snaked back into the court room the very next day!
Barlow was ruthless... and Bredehoft was clueless... that's how. 😅
Eve did belong in jail for this. There were multiple times Amber's side should have been sanctioned or punished in some manner. If I had one criticism of Judge A, it's that she let Amber's side get away with every slimy, dirty, underhanded trick they pulled.
Giving Amber's side the extra leeway, help removes any chance of that side being able to claim unfair in appeals.
While I do believe that Judge A could've punished AH's side a lot more for a lot of shit they did, I think she pulled back so there could be NO excuses for bias at the end. Granted, they did STILL try to make it act like there was bias, but anyone who watched the trial could see that they were given PLENTY of leeway.
When Elaine snapped "and what if any DOES cure all" I was shocked that did not get a reaction. I figured that Judge A didn't hear it, because that was obnoxious,.
I think she understood the case well enough to know that she could give the defendant's side plenty of leeway without really affecting the outcome of the trial. In the end, after a lengthy and hugely publicized trial such as this one, the judge just wants to cover all the bases, because she knows all kinds of appeals are coming after the trial is over no matter what.
From what I understand but I've yet to have anyone confirm or deny whether it is true is that Judge A sanctioned Elaine after the trial & appeal. I'm so sorry Eve wasn't, at the very least, held in contempt! AH knew Gina could've buried her!! I REALLY wanted her to testify! It's pathetic what they did to her! Too bad Judge A wasn't more tech savvy to know that clip wasn't at all knew. Granted, Gina admitted to screwing up but still... Eve screwed up a lot more!!!
Still cant believe Amber didn't face perjury charges on so many counts throughout this trial!!!
Yep 💯
Heard another lawyer said that its because its really difficult to get someone for perjury even though it may seem obvious since you have to prove they were intentionally doing it
@@spinasoul So basically her defense would just have to claim she's literally delusional? That would actually be hilarious. 'You're honor, my client can't be guilty of perjury because she's completely disconnected from reality and does not know what is and what is not real or true. Nothing she ever says should ever be taken at face value. Just ignore her, your honor.'
@@GrueTurtle i suppose it would go more like "under my impression this was what I saw, you cant accuse me of lying when he made me feel that way" kind of drama "my truth" that she kept trying on sns even after the trial
Ikr?! AH shouldn’t of just lost this trial she should’ve been held responsible and accountable for the perjury and misconduct she was exposed of throughout this entire hearing.
It is not surprising at all that Eve Barlow was pulling those shenanigans. Amber seems to surround herself with equally shady people.
When the trial was going on I thought to myself that Amber's team were on edge because of her and acting, well, nuts because of it.
It wasn't until the interviews with them after the trial was over that I saw that it was just them. Maybe she gave them stress, but they were really those people we saw pulling nonsense.
But can we be surprised? It's not like Amber has a strong moral compass, or that she's willing to follow rules. So of course she's going to hire those who don't seem to follow those things either.
And crooks!!!
It's like spicy Draco said, about Elaine's bid for 15 min of fame
Well, it seems that not even AH supporters will put up with her shit now.
Amber and her flying monkeys 🙄
Wait...Amber's lawyer was trying to pass off one of Amber's friends who works at The Guardian as part of her legal team? That's quite enlightening.
Just like her lawyers tried to pass off a photo of one incident as two different incidents.
@@linzi94 At what point does one get disbarred?
A friend of Amber's works at the Guardian?? That certainly explains the Guardian's peculiar and obsessive support of her...
Enlightening.. And, unfortunately, not AT ALL surprising 🤦🏽♀️
Don't put it past them!! Schemers!!
Trying to sneak into the court after being barred Eve was lucky to not be held in contempt
She should’ve been held in contempt. Her behavior was outrageous.
rich ppl seem to get warning after warning
But she was a new member of the stellar legal team, and she was so proud of her winning antics. She got someone booted in the first few days, surely she thought that she was going to be the VIP of the trial after Heard would win it. Fast-forward a couple of days to Eve watching from her sofa 🤣
Eve Barlow isn't rich.but she definitely should have been charged for falsifying evidence
The Absolute Audacity
Things I know now...
Today Sidebar: Amber tried to get Eve into court via the back entrance, knowing Eve was barred from coming to court.
Previous Sidebar: Amber's attorneys had blocked Dr Curry from answering certain question's.
Thats what irritated me most about Eve Barlow - her acting like she is above the law because she's associated with a celebrity
Ms Barlow is *not* a journalist….the only true thing that Elaine said in the whole trial.
Same argument to be made for Amber thinking she was a celeb because she hung out with a real celeb.
What celebrity?
@jaybestnz you mean had been married to one. Yes, they both seemed to view themselves as mightier than they are/were & sadly, the press had elevated AH, at least, to some seriously misplaced level of stardom she def NEVER had & NEVER will!! She'd already shot A2 & Into the Fire & we know she undoubtedly believed her own ideals of her levels of importance! In reality, she only means anything to dried up toilet paper media sites & 39 Tater Tots!! Eve means far less to anyone!!
There are always the people who has THE RIGHT to do stuff (in their own mind) but who never think of responsibilities. Those are for lesser people. You see these people belitteling and abusing verbally others but when you say something back they almost go to the police because they are "targeted". Better to stay away of them.
This is crazy. Amber was the one complaining about how social media was affecting her during the trial. Yet she had her trashy sidekick tweeting for her while the trial was going on?? She's more manipulative than I thought.
As if the trial didn't show how manipulative she was already in great detail lol.
@@neisan92That's what I'm saying lmao. Like planning and executing a plot to ruin your ex husband's life isn't already top tier manipulation.
It’s friking RIDICULOUS that Turds team got away with stunts like this. The fact that she was never admonished for NEVER submitting her phone, iCloud and computer data. JD was persecuted for what communications he had with a friend and so much more but nothing came out from Turds team that wasn’t modified to her benefit. Can’t imagine how much damaging information would have come out if we saw her messages and photos.
Strongly suspect they were willing to take any punishment necessary to keep her phone out of the trial.
Chances are her texts are extremely incriminating.
Just conjecture on my part.
@@LethalShadow I truly believe they would have done anything to avoid it as well. Between her blackmail material and discussions with her cronies to conspire to ruin Johnny.. it would have been damaging and exposing just how evil she really is. Johnnys team hired a digital forensic expert as well as requested sanitation’s for refusing to follow court orders. I don’t know why sanctions weren’t imposed especially when she cherry picked the few bs images from her devices. I’m actually even more pissed off that Netflix is about to release a story on the trial and it COMPLETELY rewrites history in The Turds favor.
@@Jennifermcintyrewhat! That’s terrible! I guess I’m glad I cancelled my NF subscription recently, as a combo of their raising their rates and how sh*tty they have been about the strikes. Because wow, what is WRONG with these people, that they can’t believe what was determined INCONTROVERTIBLY, that is, that AH was the aggressor, NOT JD. 🤦♀️
It's not surprising. They had to let them get away with it. They had the world watching. If they went after them for this, it could hurt them. It would halt proceedings and interest in the case. Depp's team couldn't afford delay.
@@DawnDavidson I heard the breakdown on it on That Umbrella Guys live today and they completely flip the script and make amber out to have been wronged in the law suit. I have no idea whatsoever why all these outlets continue to back the abuser. It’s really gross.
The Judge was top notch in this trial. I am glad that she did amazing job as a judge, and many people witnessed that, especially in times like this, the trust in our court system is very low.
I ❤️ Judge A
Eve Barlow should have have faced more consequences with her shenanigans
This only confirms my point that Elaine was never in control. And she was the head of the legal team!
Amber didn't react at all while this was going on, she totally knew what eve was doing
Makes me wonder what other underhanded stuff they were planning on if Eve hadn't have been booted.
And they've continued to do so to this day. Still trying to retry the trial with the narrative that any JD supporters are misogynistic and stomping on women's opinions to boot.
@@jeffrecrowley unfortunately stupid people will always be stupid.
I totally think it was planned. It was a gamble but I'd say AH planned to begin building her "how could they not look at social media" complaint! Elaine's also a pain!! Les from The Cheap Seats said she'd heard Elaine is a very good atty for obtaining settlements for her clients. Les said no wonder! No one wants to deal with her!! She's such a pain in court!!
@@PhoebeMcthis is a different type of lawsuit that was beyond Elaine her nepotismshowed big time😂😮
So interesting that, in VA, a witness watching the trial before testifying gets thrown out whereas in UK Amber Heard, a witness, was allowed to sit through the entire trial in the gallery, including through everything before she testified. Really shows how problematic the UK process was.
I wasn't aware of that! That's another extreme broach of the rules by her and by that crook of a judge. And that was the LEAST of the problems with that case! The judge who sold his verdict to Amber in exchange for a blow job was a MUCH bigger problem!
And the fact that were 3 different reasons why he was supposed to recuse himself right at the start, from even hearing the case, but didn't!
And the fact that the British system let all the many problems go, because he was retiring the day after the trial ended, as if it didn't matter anymore when he was gone.
And about a hundred other things. That bloody judge is a bigger criminal than any criminal in the UK.
Jeezuz they have the worst system in the whole western world. And it should be the very best, since it came first, and is the one all the others in the Commonwealth and beyond copied. I'm just so angry!
What do the rest of us get for playing by the rules? We get sh*t on, that's what we get.
I could go on with details about that judge for another hour, but it would give me a heart attack. This video is already causing me extreme stress. To see what goddam crooks Scamber, Barlow, and Elaine are. And what hugely f*cking incompetant lawyer Elaine is!
I can hardly take any more. Runkie you're killing me! ❤
💩 👱♀️ 💩 👱♀️ 💩
I thought she could watch because she was testifying to things that "happened" to her? The same reason johnny depp and AH weren't barred from watching social media during this trial.
@@ColFlustered if she was testifying to things that supposedly happened to her, why would she need to hear what other witnesses were saying? Fact is she should have been treated like any other witness and been excluded from the court room until until after she had testified. Her presence the gallery gave her the opportunity to adjust her testimony according to the other witnesses, and she did. And in VA ALL witnesses, including the Plaintiff and Defendant were told to stay away from social media.
@kikicliff2519 don't forget that often in trials expert witnesses are allowed to sit through opposing experts testimonies. Not all witnesses are barred from the courtroom as you say. I agree the UK trial was BS, but youre misrepresenting things as fact when they're not. I'm not interested in arguing this though. Have a great day! 🥰
yeah her being able to hear other testimony makes it WAY too easy for her to form her own narrative with the same incidents she was given every opportunity to pretty much commit perjury with no punishment
Mislead the court? You mean like entering the same photograph for 2 separate incidents? Then have your witness testify to the authenticity of BOTH incidents?
or entering 2 photographs that are the same, saying one is under better light and taken a little later, but it's actually the same exact photograph (same second) eddited so it would seem like their is redness on the skin ?
or lying on the stand, about warning TMZ, or lying on the stand about selling the video to TMZ (video that Amber had the rights to, so she alone could sell it, and sell them the rights they got) ?
or using a photograph of a bed frame being broken (testifying JD broke it while attacking her) BUT the knife used to broke it is visible on the photograph ? ...
Frankly, when you see that only... how can you trust any word Amber says ??? If she's willing to fabricate evidence...
I just couldn't believe that no one got in trouble for all this.
This shows that you can do something shady and there will be no repercussions.
“The courts orders must mean something” is basically the same as seeing your younger sibling do something dumb and saying to your dad “you just gonna let them do that?”
Edit to add: and “nobody disrespects my sherriffs” is the polite court appropriate version of “nobody fucks with my marines”
YES!!!!
TBH it was not disrespectful to the sherriffs, but to the judge, becaus it was her order.
There were sly sidebar activities, in my opinion, all through the case (as far as I've got in the transcripts). In one instance Elaine was determined to get one guy off the jury because he kept 'waving at Mr Depp and communicating with him'. Only Team Heard kept seeing this alleged 'communication' even though the Court was keeping a specific eye on that Juror due to the initial claim. Turns out he 'waved' to whole courtroom and said 'Good Morning' every day. Not to Depp specifically at all.
He later ended up getting removed because of health issues and Elaine behaved like she'd scored a goal. She heavily implied the alternate to replace him should be the one of her choice, in opposition to the Court's initial suggestion of randomly picking from the alternate list. Eventually the Court just says the new juror will be the one Elaine wanted. Made no difference in the end, AH still didn't win. 😂
Why should Elaine pick the Jurors did she think it would make a difference
Eves career is over. Her behavior in this trial was just an example of her sparkling personality. She should’ve spent time in a cell for that fraud she pulled. I love your coverage of these side bars! Good stuff! Thanks Ian!
She will change her name and write a teen zine
Tells you so much about Herd and her coterie that even after being permanently barred from the court she would encourage Barlow to try to sneak in anyway. What a shower of operators.
Going over the side bar transcripts of this trial could be a whole series lol
Sounds great
I am all for it!
@@brendaleelydon-carpenter1554 I second that!
AH was very disrespectful when she walked out while the judge was on the bench
And the jury were still there
Ah, I miss that trial. I mean, obviously it sucks about the human tragedy surrounding it, but it came at the tail end of the Covid crisis and we were all united through yours and other Lawtube channels. It was kinda fun.
Lol neat way to describe that
Agreed ❤
i hate how msm still treat her as the victim
For. Reals. I’ll never get over it.
It was two rich people arguing over who was the shittier person. I don't care about any supposed tragedy at all, but I agree that it was a ton of entertainment.
Thank you for going through all of this. This episode that Eve tried to pull shows how desperate and dishonest Amber was to win at any cost. It should be an example for people to understand how dishonest the testimony of Amber and company was in the UK also.
Yeah, she won't change for the better bc she e joys destroying others for her favor!! TIME SHE IS STOPPED ONCE AND FOR ALL!!!
Judge A was so great throughout this trial. Thank you Ian, going back to look at the sidebars is extremely interesting and entertaining too.
I completely agree. I was just about to write this but then I saw you did so I'll just say "ditto."
Wait what? Did you seriously commend this judge as "great"???? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 More like a frightened school kid afraid of loosing friends "are you mad at me? Please don't be mad at me." The most cowardly woman I've ever seen, let alone to be holding any position of authority. Absolutely zero back bone! Nothing great about such weakness, fear of bullies, & enabler of curruption!
I would love to hear the side bars!! I don’t think it’s boring. Hearing how the Judge handles the side bars makes me respect her more and more.
**I’m dying to know what the sidebar was when Camille was cross examining Amber and Amber kept saying “I produced everything” when Camille challenged her about producing a photo with the injuries underneath her makeup.
Emily covered some of those it was hilarious how many times Judge A had to explain same things again and again to Elaine😅
I just love the karma of it all. AH's team got a witness removed by shady tactics with an old post and if it weren't for that, Judge A wouldn't have every asked her if she had seen any posts.
Meanwhile, JD's team got Barlow removed with nothing but the truth and AH's team, despite really trying for some godforsaken reason, had no argument against it. She was texting, she was conversing with the legal team, she was on her phone. She was doing all the things they said she was doing and yet Bredehoft was STILL trying to make an argument over why she should still be allowed. I also really liked "Miss Barlow doesn't come through security" and Bredehoft acts like she was completely unaware that Eve Barlow was barred, despite being in the prior argument getting her barred.
She did not try pretend she didn't know Eve was barred. Even Elaine is not that dumb. She tried to act like she didn't know Eve came in the back way with Amber, thereby AVOIDING SECURITY.
Another vote for all the side bars! That's where Judge A shone.
Also when they go to the court about the info on the phone, Eve Barlow moves over to the other people on the bench beside her to have a little meeting with them, obviously to talk about what she sent to Rottenborn.
When court went on break, it was more than apparent that Amber, her team, and her witnesses had not only watched all the covered but also read all of the internet comments that busted her on lies and they changed their testimony to show such. It was so blatant that as soon as she was called to the stand by Elaine, she was asked each of the questions that proved her a liar over and over again and also tmz was fed information during the break by Amber too.
My husband and I just put on TH-cam for our evening and I think this is the earliest we’ve caught a video. Kids down, lawtube on, we’re good now over here 👌🏼
Why is this Barlow woman not held to account...wow
During this trial, I kept wondering if I was biased against Amber's council. I just felt there was something off. Now I see my instincts were right, I wasn't being biased . There was a whole different story ,and the proof was all in the sidebars.
I realize Gina Deuters' testimony was struck from the record, but the jury still heard it, and she escaped un-crossed.
She never really got a chance to testify to anything substantive. They were only a few questions in to her testimony and they were still just asking her basic foundation laying questions. So while the jury still heard her, there was really nothing to hear because opposing counsel was successful in getting her testimony cut off before it really started.
If I remember correctly, she didn't testify anythin usefull. She was only able to say she took drugs with Depp a number of times, which only depicted him further as the drug addict. The point they were trying to make, I think, is that even though she saw Depp of heavy drugs, she never witnessed him being violent. Which considering Heard claimed he would become a monster while on drugs, would have been useful, but because the testimony was cut short, instead of saying "JD is not violent when he does drugs" she was only able to say "JD does drugs", so maybe it would have been better she didn't testify at all.
Thanks, Ian. Eve and friends seemed determined to run a mean girl case from the beginning. I’m glad Judge A. wasn’t having any of it!
So if she'd have said "No, I've been avoiding trial news like the plague" and they confronter her with the undated tweets, how would've that played out?
The tweets were a couple of years old but they claimed the date to be last week. That was very clear in this presentation
I'm not in law but I'd assume once she saw the post/tweet and said they were from 2021, the judge would've questioned her a bit further and then her testimony would've continued. No reason to excuse her at that point. But would be one more mark against AH's team for not fact-checking and surely JD's attorney's would've proceeded as they did to get her kicked out. Elaine was right, Eve is clearly not a journalist with this messy behavior.
Thanks so much for this Ian. We all love Judge A. I've been on twitter when Eve Barlow was tweeting right after this and after hearing all of this, I see that she is exactly what I think she is but I won't post that here on YT. She and Amber deserve each other.
Yes, Mr. Runkle, you shall read these sidebars methodically to please us gentlefolk. You shall, you must, you will. Thank you.
Eve Barlow should thank her lucky stars that she got to sleep in a comfortable hotel bed, she could've easily found herself napping on a plastic-covered piece of foam at the local free hotel.
Shw as staying with Scamber Turd in a $20,000 a month mansion.
Love this Ian. I can’t wait until you get to the side bars during the cross by Ms. Vasquez of AH. Elaine was pretty animated.
The fact she didnt get held in contempt was a blessing for her. She not once did it, not twice, but 3 times before they escorted her out. Of course she played it out like she was a victim. Its all she does. Just goes to show you how manipulative of people her and AT are.
I'm enjoying this series of the sidebars. Keep showing us the ones you find interesting, pivotal, or funny. Thanks.
Judge A really does have the patience of a saint. I keep being impressed anew by her
I’m really enjoying these videos! The mystery of the sidebars is finally unveiled 🕵🏼♀️
In the beginning, I had the impression that the judge was leaning more towards Ah and her council. But then as the trial moved on, she probably could see how nefarious ah and her council were.
Yeah, in the begging she seemed quite hostile with Depp in her interactions, then as the trial moved and evidence started to pile in the other direction, you could feel she had a short fuse for Amber's Legal team and the B.S they were trying to pull up. Really shows that even Judges are human.
I think she just let them do things like the way a teacher just let's that one kid keep eating the glue cos its so tiring to have to keep explaining basic things to them. I think she was also trying to be fair and unbiased and because she really must have started to dislike ahs team from their constant nonsense she just either took the easy way out or was trying to be very fair and give them some little wins in objections etc. Her patience with elaine was superhuman ..like depps patience with amber
The judge probably formed some opinions when she was going through all of the evidence - the evidence allowed and the evidence she didn't let in
Judge A may not have been tech savvy, but she was JUDGE savvy. She was in control of her courtroom. Eve Barlow dont wanna be messin' with Judge A's staff.
Judge A is a true professional. So happy she was there.
Yes, thanks Ian . Hope you’re well .🎉( EVE IN A CELL IS A DELIGHTFUL IMAGE❤)😂😂
I want to second that we would love to see the sidebars from AH's cross when EB kept blurting things out, and sidebars from the "I'm trying!" moments.
Emily d baker covered those
I’m a super diplomatic person…until someone disrespects my employees. I have no tolerance for that.
Wow!! I had no idea Eve Barlow tried to come back in the court!! This is very interesting! Please keep these coming!
I REALLY like these transcript reviews, Ian. It's really cool to hear what they're wrangling while they're up there with the judge, while we sit here missing out. Thank you for sharing these with us. (And I hope you're feeling much better.)
Eve's shenanigans make me even more interested in what Gina Deuters was going to say, something that Eve wanted to suppress so much that she would risk being evicted from court or worse.
I assume Gina did a deposition but that that transcript has not been made public, correct me if I am wrong.
Im also even more intrigued to know. It must have been something quite damaging.
@@mashpojayde-o She was at the wedding in Australia where Amber had drugs as part of the party (they gave Gina molly), and her husband previously testified in the UK trial. Until the testimony was struck, she was acting as character witness to Johnny. An interview has her verifying that she never saw him be violent to Amber, and in fact was being isolated by the "sociopathic show pony" Amber and her friends. And during the wedding, Amber was grilling her and trying to sus out whether Gina would "really fight" (meaning physically fight?) with her husband Steven.
Steven Deuters testified in the UK trial that he was in the flight where Amber alleged that Johnny kicked her and planted his boot in her back while she was down; he was there and saw Amber get increasingly aggressive at Johnny. He was with them on a trip to Tokyo and attested that she didn't look the least bit injured the day after she alleged that Johnny hit her. He wasn't present in the Australia incident with the finger but saw the injury a day later and could verify how bad it was and that Johnny was trying to hide the cause of it. He never heard Amber claim _during_ the relationship that Johnny was abusing her and saw no sign of it; he heard it along with everyone else when Amber was filing the TRO.
I actually talked to Gina after, she said she was almost done testifying & she didn't have anything that damaging, she was basically a character witness. She thought it was silly to be honest
@@Rainy-Day wow… all that effort for nothing 🙈😂 tbh makes it even worse for AH and EB lol
@@Rainy-Day Was Eve pulling a "power move"?
Even without insight from the sidebars, it is blatantly obvious that Judge PA had the patience of an absolute saint throughout the case. There were several moments where you can physically hear her exasperation, yet she always remained polite and always gave people enough time and space to work with. I'm surprised she didn't start choking out attorneys during moments of repetitive grandstanting and testifying to the jury instead of asking proper questions. It's funny how "the court" and "social media" is apparantly to blame for Amber losing - yet there is no mention of the scummy subterfuge that was attempted to help her out on the side.
Oh this was quite illuminating. I knew Eve got kicked out but I didn't know she tried sneaking back in! Also, thr PR guy, I wondered what happened to him. First he was in court then, POOF he was nowhere....now we know why. What a jerk.
Thank you for taking us through these, they are extremely interesting and having your legal take on them is the icing on the cake.
Keep 'em comin'!
“She was a marine” respect plus
Keep up with the good ones. Because of Elaine and her incessant rambling and arguing with no point there is a bunch that are just dumb I am sure. At this point Elaine doesn’t need any help looking worse.
I wish judges were even harder. I saw one recently where the judge took the phone and said they would get it back after the trial was over, no matter how long the trial was. That's someone being serious, I bet their kids only did something wrong ONCE.
Ian thank you so much for bringing this to us. I watched the entire trial and wondered what was said at sidebar. Enjoying this. Please bring more. Appreciate you and love your channel.
That must be a loooooong ass transcript!! You are an absolute BEAST for reading it and giving us JUST the juicy and interesting stuff 🙌🏽 Thank you so much for taking the time ❤
Right on!
This series is great!
I think it's really important to point out that when the witness admitted she'd seen clips of the trial proceedings, *she did exactly what she should have done*. If you're testifying in court, your job is to answer honestly.
I watched the entire trial and it was fascinating to me. I'm so happy I saw this notification. I had no idea we were going to get the transcript of the side bars and this is truly awesome that you are sharing it with us. Thank you so much Ian I really appreciate all the hard work!!
The Judge's protectiveness comes from her days as a marine. "You don't fuck with my people, that's my job" tends to be the mentality
Thank you Ian! These sidebars are fascinating!!
I appreciated that this just confirmed what we all felt watching the trial, and that justice was actually served.
This is a great series - more please 🙏
I fully enjoy these vignettes back into the Depo trial- please continue covering them Ian!
Love the new unheard information ...
Please keep it coming!!!
I’m very much enjoying the coverage of the sidebars. I would like to hear EVERY sidebar conversation from the trial (I watched the whole trial, so I want all of the sidebars!). Especially if you can do a clip from the trial just before, and just after the sidebar.
But wait. You know what would be EVEN BETTER! If LawTube could get together and do re-enactments!
Ben Chew - Ian, Runkle of the Bailey
Camille Vasquez - Natalie Lawyer Chick
Elaine Bredehoft - Alyte, LegalBytes
Ben Rottenborn - Rob, Law & Lumber
Honorable Judge Penny Azcarate - Emily D Baker
I don’t know if we would need “actors” for the other attorneys (if they have sidebars then we would), so we could fill out those roles with other LawTubers (Kurt, Rick, etc).
Samuel Moniz -
Jessica Meyers -
Adam Nadelhaft -
That would be so fun.
Thank you Ian. This is so thoughtful of you. Not only is this an education, it answers so many questions. Not being an attorney, the sidebar always makes me a little anxious. Watching Eve and whatshisface canoodling at the table really angered me. I get the point now but, still, it was rude. There were better ways, I'm sure. She should have been " some kind of punished " so many times. Thanks again for the insight. You're golden.
"Eve Barlow is not a journalist"
Wow, burned by Elaine 😂
Big yes to more sidebars! I love to see behind the scenes!
I first became aware of your channel during Depp V Heard from LegalBytes. It has been so great watching you & Rob become friends, and your channels grow. 🍻 👏
Thank you for sharing. Keep them coming, please
in detail please because there was always something interesting and they all build on each other. im interested in the debbie Lloyd testimony and the call on her license the day before her depo.
TUG showed these transcripts the morning after this court day if im recalling correctly, it could have even been later in night same day. I remember watching the video , its so funny the access he had to case and the multiple callouts he got from Ambers legal team on cross of 2 different witnesses. I always wondered what else Eve would have tried to do had she not been caught with this. Gina had so much good dirt too. Gina was never even crossed. Ambers team didnt have any time spent on her.
I've always wondered what Gina had on Amber - can you enlighten me?
They were just made available now. TUG can’t have had the sidebars then.
@@Isabella-nd3rqI believe the transcript of the sidebar and the plaintiff’s motion about Barlow getting banned was obtained after it happened, Emily D Baker and LegalBytes talked about it in a livestream during the trial. Some of the transcripts were available back then and some things weren’t.
Also search “ThatUmbrellaGuy Eve Barlow Removal” and you’ll find the video the other person is talking about.
Not unsurprising that Amber would have a friend who is a conniving liar?? Birds of a feather stick together.
Fascinating video, thank you! I had no idea of the depth of Barlow's sneaky, deceptive tricks, one of which got Gina Deuters kicked off the witness stand. But karma is sweet: Eve's friend lost anyway, and now neither she nor AH has work. 😂
Summers Eve should have spent 3 days in jail for contempt.
Thank you Ian. I really enjoyed this rendition of this side bar. Please do more of them. 💞💞
I'm enjoying your clarification of various situations that occurred and conversations...behind the scenes!
These are great! It’s like being let in on the secrets. I’d love if you covered some when AH was on the stand and Elaine couldn’t get her questions out and had to keep going up for the side bars.
Aside from AH’s lawyers, the JUDGE also jumped on this *too quick,* EVERYONE missed checking the damn date! Acting in the heat of the moment causes mistakes in anything you do, that’s why pilots have special rules for these things.
It's not even a question of colluding; sometimes you don't recollect the details, but when you hear someone else testify to a detail you've forgotten, you're reminded, and you then start to forget that your memory of the event isn't actually a memory. The mind plays tricks.
If you didn't notice what colour the car was, but someone else says it was definitely blue, in your memory, you'll start to picture the car as blue, and never really realize it's new information.
Totally.... memory is very influenced ...
I hope there is transcript for when Ambers team was trying to prevent the ex TMZ guy from testifying and created a subpoena to help the TMZ lawyer argue that he should not be allowed
Thank you. That was interesting
I want to know how the lawyers didn't get in trouble for taking Eve's phone and using the information she provided them
Thank you Ian
God Judge A has the patience of a saint
Thank you, Ian!
*I AM LOVING THESE @Runkle Of The Bailey !!!*
*THANK YOU!!!*
When the jurors are removed and then return to a missing witness, what effect is there on the jury ?
Judge A seems to have the patience of a saint!
Do a live with you, Rob and EDB taking turns reading the sidebars etc! Especially the AH testimony, cross and redirect!!! ❤😊
Oh yes please! I was thinking the same thing! Emily, Rob, and Runkle reunion readings FTW!! 😂 👏
Yes!! This would make it so much fun. I do want to hear them all and having all of you would make it so interesting.