Best moment: Hugo approaches the patio door and we see his reflection in the glass. As a podcast listener who thought I knew what was coming, that was a very clever fakeout. Somehow, the shot of Hugo’s bare feet on the patio generated more tension than if we’d seen his face. Great stuff!
This was pretty good. The shots were done well and good tension building. Specifically the hand grabbing the door. Just the whole framing of the scene and barely seeing the monster. Perfect example of less is more. I wouldn’t say it’s particularly scary but definitely creepy. I’m assuming the elongated screaming at the end was a nod to Mark’s movie/ cheese. I also can’t unsee Ryan looking like a younger John Lovitz. RIP Woody. By far the best actor in this short and he will be remembered.
Great short! The one thing i didnt buy was Hugo just sitting down on the kitchen floor and fall asleep when there is someone trying to break in. If he had tripped somehow and hit his head then wakeup later would have made more sense. When you first conceived of the idea I remember you discussing the monster being himself since he is battling his drinking problem, and i was expecting something like night after night he locks the door just intime, until one night he drinks too much and it goes unshut, thats when he has failed himself again.
You all did a great job! Really enjoyed it and it was great seeing the faces behind such a great podcast! My favorite scene was when Maddy was making the tea and walked behind Ryan for the disappear and reveal that she wasn’t there. Hoping for a next season! Maybe Let’s make a Western. 🤠
Im currently in a remote cabin watching this at dusk, it definitely makes both patio doors here seem ominous. This short is unsettling, and a touch scary. Also Maddy is such a hottie! Great job guys!
I knew it was coming, but the hand stopping the door from closing made me gasp 😁 I'm at Maddy levels of horror appreciation but I still loved it. Can't wait for next season if y'all do another one. And RIP Woody ❤️
He's already opened the door for her while giving a half arsed invitation but she still asks if she can come in...like she's needing an official invite. That threw more red flags out than her being on the patio without access to stairs. It's not only vampires that need to be invited in.
The final short is great! Loved how it all panned out, and I thought extending the screams over the end credits was really effective.. Also, Woody was adorable, loved seeing him in the movie, and I am so sorry to see he passed. My condolences, Ryan. ❤
No. Not scary. But I 100% agree with all the feedback from the experts. It's actually an exceptionally filmed work and I truly feel like you all were really close to it being a seriously scary movie. More than anything I actually loved the whole theme of what the monster really represents. In my humble opinion, there were just little things here and there that you could have taken further or parts that just needed tweaks to sort of fill in gaps of what was going on. Seriously though. You all rock and you should be proud. Fantastic job for what seemed like a compressed process and for your first film.
I agree - honestly I think Maddy’s character was the creepiest, and I think they should have used her as “the monster.” The performances, production, and music was outstanding
When Hugo walks out onto the balcony after the knocking, I wanted to yell at him, “What are you doing?” That alone makes it a horror. Great season. Loved getting to see you make a short film! Make a sitcom pilot next!
Definitely some suspense and tension. Not super scary but I am the wrong person when it comes to horror movies. Complete baby. Putting Hugo’s face on the monster was a great surprise. Definitely some chills
Was it scary? … No. It wasn’t. Did I like it? Yes. I thought it was great! Best moments, the opening bits. distraught ryan, and ominous patio door. The cinematography and music and acting was all great. The suspense created around the patio door was fantastic, until the “monster” tried to open it. Then it fell flat for me. I think I wanted a hand to grab the handle outside, then a slow pan up to the monster, as ryan, shocked, registers what is even happening. Then, the panic sets in and fight for the door. The monsters hand being on the inside of the door during the fight just felt off. And the fight happened almost instantly, no time to really register fear/panic. Anyway. Otherwise, I thought it was great, and I love this podcast. Please make more… … shoutout to dave and SPY. :)
This was good especially bc you guys really established the emotional stakes with the realistic portrayal of the character struggling with his alchoholism.
I don't think y'all needed the blood! I did enjoy how it was shot, literally the screams at the end were the most unsettling part. It would be cool if there was a little more foley work to detail the carnage taking place off camera (ie.bones breaking, flesh tearing, even just final breaths) But overall I think this was a wonderful approach to making a horror short film. Especially given that y'all aren't that into the genre compared to sci fi and rom com. Congrats on finishing the project :)
Absolutely LOVED this you guys!! The cinematography, acting, and sound design were AMAZING!! Having followed along the whole way and hearing about all the obstacles you encountered when it came to the look of the monster, I can't help but want to pitch an idea even though it is clearly wrapped and over and too late and also I don't know you guys. BUT STILL! I had an idea after hearing Maddy's line about black bears-- what if the monster appears to be a black bear at first (you could probably cheat it by having it be heavily shadowed and some sorta furry suit and post production magic) to give us a jump scare that's then deflated by "oh well they mentioned there are bears here" but then we see the bear (Mark) STAND UP! Now it's a scary monster guy and whole other jump scare! I feel like it could be eerie enough to just have it stand there in much the same way Mark already does (but maybe red glowy eyes?). Then Maddy's character makes sense as a shape shifter who transforms into a bear, and her line about "I poke around too" hits different.
I loved it! To finally see the product after all these weeks is great. I felt so much tension and moments like seeing the bear spray on the counter while he walked to the door were really effective.
This was pretty good you guys suceeded in making a very well written film with a great great story. Demon was scary looking great acting in the film. Please make more films
It’s great to see where this podcast has ended up, actually making movies. I have loved every season but probably this one especially because I love the genre so. Now to answer the question you asked in the podcast: No, it’s not a very scary film. And I do think a whole lot can be done in the post production to make it better. I think that the main issue for me is that too much stuff has been cramped in to a too small film which makes the pacing a bit off. Like take the scene where Maddy is let in and then the reveal that she so to speak doesn’t exist. That scene goes by so quickly. There’s hasn’t really been the investment in her character as a viewer where you could be scared that she doesn’t actually exist. I also would like to say that there is way to much music. I mean SURE, music is what sells the horror, but when there is that unsettling music from the very start it feels like the genre is sort of jammed down your throat so to speak. Great horror actually disguises itself as another genre and then slams you with it.
I've been watching a lot of these horror shorts and I must say, renting a remote cabin or taking a hike in the woods is looking like a good way to meet a homicidal monster. I really like the girl/caretaker fakeout. She seems so open and nice. Yikes! Scary.
This is great guys, congrats on all your hard work and actually getting to make thing! I really loved the feedback at the end of the last podcast - the one suggested structural change would really elevate the fight against alcoholism (sub)text. He succeeds in fighting off the urge that is like a scary monster... but the next day fails to fight off the side of drink that is an insistent, happy, sexy distraction. That would definitely make it festival-worthy!
This was really good, IMO. Music and editing were spot on. I felt the tension. The blood splatter looked like diluted ketchup, though. Lol. Overall, I enjoyed it and the film managed to make me jump in a few scenes. Well done!
As others have said, not scary, but a bit unsettling. Ryan’s face is haunting - really, really great performance. The weird tonal shift at the end where it becomes a slasher didn’t work for me. I wonder if it would have been better to just cut immediately when the monster is revealed (a la Lights Out). Also, Maddy’s character was pretty creepy and would like to have seen more done with her.
That was GREAT! I am not a horror fan but I was enthralled. I haven’t listened to the newest pod yet, I couldn’t wait to see how the eyes turned out. Muah! Nice job!
You folks did a great job! I felt the tension for most of the film. Loved the camera work, sound design, and music. I especially enjoyed Ryan's performance. The ending didn't land for me, and made me laugh as the credits rolled 😆. Overall, excellent work, Ryan, Maddy, and Mark!
I am terrified of even the tiniest bit of suspenseful music in a movie (the velociraptors in Jurassic Park left me jumpy for days) and the only horror I’ve ever seen is Get Out, so I’m maybe not the best judge, but I definitely found this scary! Maybe you’ve invented a new genre, horror for people who really are well-equipped for horror
I think you've perfectly grasped it. I do not like horror but this was a good little step into the genre I'm much too chicken for. I'd watch movies that had the same level as this major time.
It’s amazing!! I find it super scary. And I watched it at my desk at work at 10am. I was terrified. So you absolutely achieved your goal in my opinion!
When he open the door for her signaling that she could come in yet she asked, "can I come in"? as though she needed an official invitation to enter.......
This was super fun! Very tense! Love the sound design focusing on doors opening. Car, fridge, patio, really cool subliminal suggestion of discomfort. Also, now I have faces to associate with voices next time you guys are on SPYpod. :D
It’s not what I would call a horror, but i think it’s scary enough that I would NOT want to watch a feature length film with this much tension (I am in the same camp as Maddy when it comes to horror films). I agree with one of the experts that if the scene with Hugo making a drink had just been placed a bit later, perhaps after the dog scare to calm his nerves, then it would have made that part a lot more obvious. But I think the acting was great, the sound was awesome (I loved the repeat of the tapping throughout) and I think it was really well made. I have thoroughly enjoyed every season of this podcast!
Great!! Thought the part where he walking around at night through the cabin and you don't know what's coming pretty good. Also the black eyes did really work for me! And the creepy girl!
Yes- I was scared and it was mostly the sound effects creating suspense , and I loved the end... the shape-shifting possibility - It kept me thinking... was it the drinking that actually killed him?.... The blood was a bit campy - maybe not the dollar store blood another time...lol...yet that was still effective... not real blood but symbolic of death?...
@@cbcpodcastsPlease don't be pathetic bandwagon Taylor Swift fans because she's bigger than y'all's favorite weed smoking rap criminals, Most people have Morales 👍🏿
That was fun to watch. I didn’t really find it scary and like someone else said, scary adjacent. I thought that the rocking chair left rocking had potential and if anyone had come up to the patio door then I would have been scared, but that tension didn’t lead to anything. I actually laughed out loud when the blood spattered. I just thought the ending was random.
I think the first half is totally scary, but it began to break down for me after he finds Woody on the porch. How DID Woody get onto the patio? Why does he take him outside the front door? Why does he leave the patio door open? It felt like the suspense and mix of music with real clips up until he finds Woody was NAILED. I am a scary-cat. I hate horror, and usually close my ears because I am so easily brought in by the audio. So great job Joe! I think there were just too many threads of plot details from that part on, though, which made it confusing, and then the tone changed to campy, which was so different from the beginning.
Crazy, I don’t believe this is just a project from a podcast! Do you have more ? Love the podcast. By the way, would you also write a romantic comedy horror for next season?
I love the 70s type theme songs today horror is still pretty good but the horror of the 70s and 80s were all top notch the 90s horror werent bad either but the 70s and 80s were definitely the golden era for this superior genre IMO great chioce of music 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Loved this season!! For the brief... The battle with the monster at the door was definitely scary, the wake up to the tapping glass was scary, but the jump scare with the dog and the endjng wasn't scary. Memorable? Yes. Scary? Eh.
Let’s be totally honest: “Is it scary?” is NOT a yes/no, 0/1, dit/dot question; neither are “Is it funny?” or “Is it delicious?” When it comes to mass entertainment, you guys know better than most that comedy (horror’s kissin’ cousin) will always depend on far more than just the mysterious alchemy of the audience’s mood and ability to understand/process/appreciate whatever’s being communicated at a given moment. There MUST be a willingness for each individual audience member to not only suspend disbelief when consuming such an odd entertainment as horror or comedy, but to be open to the possibility of enjoying it. All the Cool Kids dig it, so I’m willing to pinch my nose and give it a try. Same as when we ate our first shrimp or drank our first whisky. I submit, folks, the better question will always be: “Is the piece worth the time and effort to consume?” This clearly was. Congratulations! (Mind just ONE more note? We could be shown how much drinking was going on with only a few quick shots of the “gifted” olive jar’s contents being depleted bit-by-bit. Last interior shot could then be blood spattering the side of the open jar instead of the open glass door. BONUS POINTS for getting blood in the olive juice.) Cheers!
Full disclosure: I am not a horror movie fan and never watch them. So I'm not going to comment on whether it was scary--that would be for others to decide. I did very much enjoy following the process. However, I'd love to see you do a season on Let's Make a Documentary OR Let's Make a Road Movie. I think either would be a really fun change of genre. The joy of documentary is that you could do any length from 10 minutes to whatever, and you can choose from a million topics. (Also, I once set out to make a doc and chased that idea for a couple of years before realizing it wasn't going to work.)
Any normal person would find it very uneasy that she got onto the patio that has no stairs. Thats a clear red flag. My good judgement and survival instinct woud surely kick in. What was he thinking when he let her in.
I didn't think it was scary but I watched it in broad daylight in a McDonald's parking lot.... Kinda wish I watched this before listening to ANY of the podcast rather than just episode 9 to be fully surprised!
Why was the blanket wrapped Jar of Olives on the ground??.I would put it on a table outside.🙂Did he Lock the closed Patio door???Does he want to be mauled by an animal or monster??😲A human like creature??😲What!?? Phew!Now it is locked.🙂😀Tell her to walk around to the front door.Now please.:-(Too late.EEEWwww!Oh mYGosh! it is such a great short horror film.😲😞😀
Yeah! Like I even wonder if cutting out him making the Martini, go from staring in the fridge, to him sitting in the chair, digitally edit out the Martini, so you only empty bottle only later in when he wakes up with the bear spray?
IS IT SCARY? The answer is YES, it is on the scary side of the continuum. Will it be highly scary to every person of every age & life background, in no matter what context they watch it? No. As someone who is not a horror film enthusiast but has probably watched an average number, and who is biased b/c I am a fan of you three, I found the final scene where Maddy disappears, then the doppellganger appears and then we hear the sounds of Hugo being presumably killed to be unexpected, engaging, effective, unsettling and yes, a little bit scary, like 3.75 out of 10 level, maybe.
Best moment: Hugo approaches the patio door and we see his reflection in the glass. As a podcast listener who thought I knew what was coming, that was a very clever fakeout. Somehow, the shot of Hugo’s bare feet on the patio generated more tension than if we’d seen his face. Great stuff!
OMG they did it. The reflection work on the patio door hinting the menace as he walks by it inside the cabin was phenomenal.
Man you've got 2 good eyes!
I had to repeat the view many times just to see what you saw......chills up and down 'the-you-know-what'.....😳
This was pretty good. The shots were done well and good tension building. Specifically the hand grabbing the door. Just the whole framing of the scene and barely seeing the monster. Perfect example of less is more. I wouldn’t say it’s particularly scary but definitely creepy. I’m assuming the elongated screaming at the end was a nod to Mark’s movie/ cheese. I also can’t unsee Ryan looking like a younger John Lovitz. RIP Woody. By far the best actor in this short and he will be remembered.
Great short! The one thing i didnt buy was Hugo just sitting down on the kitchen floor and fall asleep when there is someone trying to break in. If he had tripped somehow and hit his head then wakeup later would have made more sense. When you first conceived of the idea I remember you discussing the monster being himself since he is battling his drinking problem, and i was expecting something like night after night he locks the door just intime, until one night he drinks too much and it goes unshut, thats when he has failed himself again.
You all did a great job! Really enjoyed it and it was great seeing the faces behind such a great podcast! My favorite scene was when Maddy was making the tea and walked behind Ryan for the disappear and reveal that she wasn’t there. Hoping for a next season! Maybe Let’s make a Western. 🤠
Ooh! Yes. I love the Western genre! Whether it's a period Western or a modern Western.
From a sci-fi pilot script to an actual short film. And a horror film! Awesome job guys!
THE "BLOOD" LOOKED LIKE BUFFALO SAUCE LMAOO 😭😭
Nobody said it wasn't buffalo sauce.
Im currently in a remote cabin watching this at dusk, it definitely makes both patio doors here seem ominous. This short is unsettling, and a touch scary. Also Maddy is such a hottie! Great job guys!
I knew it was coming, but the hand stopping the door from closing made me gasp 😁 I'm at Maddy levels of horror appreciation but I still loved it. Can't wait for next season if y'all do another one. And RIP Woody ❤️
He's already opened the door for her while giving a half arsed invitation but she still asks if she can come in...like she's needing an official invite. That threw more red flags out than her being on the patio without access to stairs. It's not only vampires that need to be invited in.
The final short is great! Loved how it all panned out, and I thought extending the screams over the end credits was really effective..
Also, Woody was adorable, loved seeing him in the movie, and I am so sorry to see he passed. My condolences, Ryan. ❤
That was great!
Maddy, Mark, and Ryan should all be so proud of themselves.
Great job Let's Make A Horror team!!!
Soundtrack was great! Everyone was really good - y'all made it look easy. RIP Woody
No. Not scary. But I 100% agree with all the feedback from the experts.
It's actually an exceptionally filmed work and I truly feel like you all were really close to it being a seriously scary movie. More than anything I actually loved the whole theme of what the monster really represents.
In my humble opinion, there were just little things here and there that you could have taken further or parts that just needed tweaks to sort of fill in gaps of what was going on.
Seriously though. You all rock and you should be proud. Fantastic job for what seemed like a compressed process and for your first film.
I agree - honestly I think Maddy’s character was the creepiest, and I think they should have used her as “the monster.” The performances, production, and music was outstanding
When Hugo walks out onto the balcony after the knocking, I wanted to yell at him, “What are you doing?” That alone makes it a horror.
Great season. Loved getting to see you make a short film! Make a sitcom pilot next!
Definitely some suspense and tension. Not super scary but I am the wrong person when it comes to horror movies. Complete baby. Putting Hugo’s face on the monster was a great surprise. Definitely some chills
This is scary adjacent. Keep up the good work.
I definitely think you've nailed it on the head. what a perfect phrase.
Was it scary? … No. It wasn’t. Did I like it? Yes. I thought it was great!
Best moments, the opening bits. distraught ryan, and ominous patio door. The cinematography and music and acting was all great.
The suspense created around the patio door was fantastic, until the “monster” tried to open it. Then it fell flat for me. I think I wanted a hand to grab the handle outside, then a slow pan up to the monster, as ryan, shocked, registers what is even happening. Then, the panic sets in and fight for the door. The monsters hand being on the inside of the door during the fight just felt off. And the fight happened almost instantly, no time to really register fear/panic.
Anyway. Otherwise, I thought it was great, and I love this podcast. Please make more…
…
shoutout to dave and SPY. :)
This was good especially bc you guys really established the emotional stakes with the realistic portrayal of the character struggling with his alchoholism.
When Maddy is on the patio that has no steps. I knew she was trouble. 😁
I don't think y'all needed the blood! I did enjoy how it was shot, literally the screams at the end were the most unsettling part. It would be cool if there was a little more foley work to detail the carnage taking place off camera (ie.bones breaking, flesh tearing, even just final breaths) But overall I think this was a wonderful approach to making a horror short film. Especially given that y'all aren't that into the genre compared to sci fi and rom com. Congrats on finishing the project :)
Absolutely LOVED this you guys!! The cinematography, acting, and sound design were AMAZING!!
Having followed along the whole way and hearing about all the obstacles you encountered when it came to the look of the monster, I can't help but want to pitch an idea even though it is clearly wrapped and over and too late and also I don't know you guys. BUT STILL! I had an idea after hearing Maddy's line about black bears-- what if the monster appears to be a black bear at first (you could probably cheat it by having it be heavily shadowed and some sorta furry suit and post production magic) to give us a jump scare that's then deflated by "oh well they mentioned there are bears here" but then we see the bear (Mark) STAND UP! Now it's a scary monster guy and whole other jump scare! I feel like it could be eerie enough to just have it stand there in much the same way Mark already does (but maybe red glowy eyes?). Then Maddy's character makes sense as a shape shifter who transforms into a bear, and her line about "I poke around too" hits different.
Mission accomplished: Patio doors will never be the same again.
I loved it! To finally see the product after all these weeks is great. I felt so much tension and moments like seeing the bear spray on the counter while he walked to the door were really effective.
This was pretty good you guys suceeded in making a very well written film with a great great story. Demon was scary looking great acting in the film. Please make more films
Was great following along the process and setting the final product! Patio doors have changed now thanks to you all. Well done.
It’s great to see where this podcast has ended up, actually making movies. I have loved every season but probably this one especially because I love the genre so.
Now to answer the question you asked in the podcast: No, it’s not a very scary film. And I do think a whole lot can be done in the post production to make it better. I think that the main issue for me is that too much stuff has been cramped in to a too small film which makes the pacing a bit off. Like take the scene where Maddy is let in and then the reveal that she so to speak doesn’t exist. That scene goes by so quickly. There’s hasn’t really been the investment in her character as a viewer where you could be scared that she doesn’t actually exist.
I also would like to say that there is way to much music. I mean SURE, music is what sells the horror, but when there is that unsettling music from the very start it feels like the genre is sort of jammed down your throat so to speak. Great horror actually disguises itself as another genre and then slams you with it.
Im too scared to watch 🙈, but congrats on the finished product. Love the podcast!
Oh that was a good one. 😮
I've been watching a lot of these horror shorts and I must say, renting a remote cabin or taking a hike in the woods is looking like a good way to meet a homicidal monster. I really like the girl/caretaker fakeout. She seems so open and nice. Yikes! Scary.
This is great guys, congrats on all your hard work and actually getting to make thing!
I really loved the feedback at the end of the last podcast - the one suggested structural change would really elevate the fight against alcoholism (sub)text. He succeeds in fighting off the urge that is like a scary monster... but the next day fails to fight off the side of drink that is an insistent, happy, sexy distraction. That would definitely make it festival-worthy!
This was really good, IMO. Music and editing were spot on. I felt the tension. The blood splatter looked like diluted ketchup, though. Lol. Overall, I enjoyed it and the film managed to make me jump in a few scenes. Well done!
As others have said, not scary, but a bit unsettling. Ryan’s face is haunting - really, really great performance. The weird tonal shift at the end where it becomes a slasher didn’t work for me. I wonder if it would have been better to just cut immediately when the monster is revealed (a la Lights Out). Also, Maddy’s character was pretty creepy and would like to have seen more done with her.
yes, I agree completely.
That was GREAT! I am not a horror fan but I was enthralled. I haven’t listened to the newest pod yet, I couldn’t wait to see how the eyes turned out. Muah! Nice job!
I LOVE this! Good job, and yes, it IS scary!!
Y'all did such a great job! So cool to see it come together!
You folks did a great job! I felt the tension for most of the film. Loved the camera work, sound design, and music. I especially enjoyed Ryan's performance.
The ending didn't land for me, and made me laugh as the credits rolled 😆.
Overall, excellent work, Ryan, Maddy, and Mark!
I am terrified of even the tiniest bit of suspenseful music in a movie (the velociraptors in Jurassic Park left me jumpy for days) and the only horror I’ve ever seen is Get Out, so I’m maybe not the best judge, but I definitely found this scary! Maybe you’ve invented a new genre, horror for people who really are well-equipped for horror
I think you've perfectly grasped it. I do not like horror but this was a good little step into the genre I'm much too chicken for. I'd watch movies that had the same level as this major time.
🔥🔥🔥
It’s amazing!! I find it super scary. And I watched it at my desk at work at 10am. I was terrified. So you absolutely achieved your goal in my opinion!
Whhen the caretaker disappears in the kitchen = scary!
I really enjoyed it, I'm now inspired.
I guess he was checking out early.
Scary!
Well done!! Can't wait for next season :D
Bravo 👏 👏 👏!!!
This is a scary movie that I enjoyed very much.
That hollin' at the end is . . . 😂
That was fantastic! Even knowing the plot, I felt the suspense. Great use of music/audio, including the moments of silence. Well done, what's next???
solid gold.
Stawppp!!! The landlord's name must be Jenny...
When he open the door for her signaling that she could come in yet she asked, "can I come in"? as though she needed an official invitation to enter.......
❤ Woody
Awesome ❤❤❤🔪🔪🔪
You guys did such a good job!
Lol, i really hope you guys make a second one and we can see the progress. Loved the podcast tho
This was super fun! Very tense! Love the sound design focusing on doors opening. Car, fridge, patio, really cool subliminal suggestion of discomfort.
Also, now I have faces to associate with voices next time you guys are on SPYpod. :D
It’s not what I would call a horror, but i think it’s scary enough that I would NOT want to watch a feature length film with this much tension (I am in the same camp as Maddy when it comes to horror films). I agree with one of the experts that if the scene with Hugo making a drink had just been placed a bit later, perhaps after the dog scare to calm his nerves, then it would have made that part a lot more obvious. But I think the acting was great, the sound was awesome (I loved the repeat of the tapping throughout) and I think it was really well made. I have thoroughly enjoyed every season of this podcast!
Wow this turned out great!
Awesome! I loved it!!!!
Great!! Thought the part where he walking around at night through the cabin and you don't know what's coming pretty good. Also the black eyes did really work for me! And the creepy girl!
Bravo!
Big fan of the podcast and you three! Great work, I really enjoyed this short.
Yes- I was scared and it was mostly the sound effects creating suspense , and I loved the end... the shape-shifting possibility - It kept me thinking... was it the drinking that actually killed him?.... The blood was a bit campy - maybe not the dollar store blood another time...lol...yet that was still effective... not real blood but symbolic of death?...
Loved this and the podcast! Great work guys
AHHHHHH. So good! I’m a big fan of the podcast
We agree! Soooo good!
@@cbcpodcastsPlease don't be pathetic bandwagon Taylor Swift fans because she's bigger than y'all's favorite weed smoking rap criminals, Most people have Morales 👍🏿
Very interesting and waaaay better than any horror flick in theaters today. (2023)
That was fun to watch. I didn’t really find it scary and like someone else said, scary adjacent. I thought that the rocking chair left rocking had potential and if anyone had come up to the patio door then I would have been scared, but that tension didn’t lead to anything. I actually laughed out loud when the blood spattered. I just thought the ending was random.
New subscriber!
Yes - scary 👍👍
Yes. Unsettling AF
So good! Definitely need to rewatch it a few times. Loved hearing the journey of making it. Season 4 - Fantasy period piece please
Awww, cute puppy. 💕
Yes scary! I loved it
I think the first half is totally scary, but it began to break down for me after he finds Woody on the porch. How DID Woody get onto the patio? Why does he take him outside the front door? Why does he leave the patio door open? It felt like the suspense and mix of music with real clips up until he finds Woody was NAILED. I am a scary-cat. I hate horror, and usually close my ears because I am so easily brought in by the audio. So great job Joe! I think there were just too many threads of plot details from that part on, though, which made it confusing, and then the tone changed to campy, which was so different from the beginning.
this was good thank you. impending dread feeling through out for me
It's not scary, still love it tough!
Not scary. But it is awesome you made this! And more blood! That patio door should be completely dripping in blood! BTW, I love this podcast series.
Crazy, I don’t believe this is just a project from a podcast! Do you have more ? Love the podcast. By the way, would you also write a romantic comedy horror for next season?
I love the 70s type theme songs today horror is still pretty good but the horror of the 70s and 80s were all top notch the 90s horror werent bad either but the 70s and 80s were definitely the golden era for this superior genre IMO great chioce of music 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Please team up with the "No Bad Ideas" Podcast to adapt some of their pitches.
Loved this season!! For the brief... The battle with the monster at the door was definitely scary, the wake up to the tapping glass was scary, but the jump scare with the dog and the endjng wasn't scary. Memorable? Yes. Scary? Eh.
i guess i accidentally downvoted this? not my intention! thanks so much for the feedback!
Mattie (Maddie?) needs to be in more horror shorts.
Excellent
Enjoyed it very much. Suspenseful? yes. definately. Horror? Maybe not so much
Its very nice, why it has so low ratio of views? Its really nice! GJ
Only thing I learned is that I am sort of into a comedy host, but the whole thing was very funny!
Yes
Loved it.
And to answer the question; no. 😬
It IS scary.
You've also ruined rolled up towels for me.
I don't trust them anymore, especially on the floor of a patio...
Not enough aquans
Let’s be totally honest: “Is it scary?” is NOT a yes/no, 0/1, dit/dot question; neither are “Is it funny?” or “Is it delicious?” When it comes to mass entertainment, you guys know better than most that comedy (horror’s kissin’ cousin) will always depend on far more than just the mysterious alchemy of the audience’s mood and ability to understand/process/appreciate whatever’s being communicated at a given moment. There MUST be a willingness for each individual audience member to not only suspend disbelief when consuming such an odd entertainment as horror or comedy, but to be open to the possibility of enjoying it. All the Cool Kids dig it, so I’m willing to pinch my nose and give it a try.
Same as when we ate our first shrimp or drank our first whisky.
I submit, folks, the better question will always be: “Is the piece worth the time and effort to consume?”
This clearly was. Congratulations!
(Mind just ONE more note? We could be shown how much drinking was going on with only a few quick shots of the “gifted” olive jar’s contents being depleted bit-by-bit. Last interior shot could then be blood spattering the side of the open jar instead of the open glass door. BONUS POINTS for getting blood in the olive juice.)
Cheers!
Full disclosure: I am not a horror movie fan and never watch them. So I'm not going to comment on whether it was scary--that would be for others to decide. I did very much enjoy following the process. However, I'd love to see you do a season on Let's Make a Documentary OR Let's Make a Road Movie. I think either would be a really fun change of genre. The joy of documentary is that you could do any length from 10 minutes to whatever, and you can choose from a million topics. (Also, I once set out to make a doc and chased that idea for a couple of years before realizing it wasn't going to work.)
Any normal person would find it very uneasy that she got onto the patio that has no stairs. Thats a clear red flag. My good judgement and survival instinct woud surely kick in. What was he thinking when he let her in.
OK it didn't really "scare" me but I did enjoy it and it was creepy.
Agreed
I didn't think it was scary but I watched it in broad daylight in a McDonald's parking lot....
Kinda wish I watched this before listening to ANY of the podcast rather than just episode 9 to be fully surprised!
Why was the blanket wrapped Jar of Olives on the ground??.I would put it on a table outside.🙂Did he Lock the closed Patio door???Does he want to be mauled by an animal or monster??😲A human like creature??😲What!?? Phew!Now it is locked.🙂😀Tell her to walk around to the front door.Now please.:-(Too late.EEEWwww!Oh mYGosh! it is such a great short horror film.😲😞😀
A few extra cuts and some tweaks in the editing, and you're ready for the festival circuit.
Yeah! Like I even wonder if cutting out him making the Martini, go from staring in the fridge, to him sitting in the chair, digitally edit out the Martini, so you only empty bottle only later in when he wakes up with the bear spray?
IS IT SCARY? The answer is YES, it is on the scary side of the continuum. Will it be highly scary to every person of every age & life background, in no matter what context they watch it? No. As someone who is not a horror film enthusiast but has probably watched an average number, and who is biased b/c I am a fan of you three, I found the final scene where Maddy disappears, then the doppellganger appears and then we hear the sounds of Hugo being presumably killed to be unexpected, engaging, effective, unsettling and yes, a little bit scary, like 3.75 out of 10 level, maybe.