@@manjunathgowdara3101 yes you are true they are acually sane and only difference is script,hindi speaker and muslim speaker in their colloquial speech just dont have any difference. However saying that it was introduced by muslim or mughals is completely wrong as it was spoken in present day delhi region even prior to mughals. Amir khusro(muslim poet in earlier muslim sultanates) composed poem in delhavi dialect(hindi and urdu are stnadarised in this dialect similar to how kannada is standarised in dialect near to mysuru bengaluru region) with native sanskrit prakrit word and neglible persian word(two three persian words only),it got persianised in later century as persian was official language of successive muslim empires and that persian version got different name rekhta and urdu (in1780). Hindi was not brought by mughals,it is native indian language. My comment on this video was not 𝗮𝗿𝗿𝗼𝗴𝗮𝗻𝘁,it was just a 𝗰𝗵𝗮𝗹𝗹𝗲𝗻𝗴𝗲. I gave similar comment on hindi speaking instagram influencers living having kannada knowledge to speak in kannada as challenge,do not misinterprete it sir
@@Shjsskk2728 It is very sad to know that a heavily persianised language spoken in Pakistan and Northern India is promoted and forced upon the entire country. This persianised language has killed several indigenous languages in the Northern India and moving towards south to cause threat to the southern languages.
@@manjunathgowdara3101 well bro my comment in this video was not in this context and as challenge only,i gave similar challenge to hindi speakers also in marathi,gujrati,bangla etc. About hindi and its persianisation,i dont think it is heavily persianised as hindi has diglossia similar to many languages in world and in its literary language it very less persian words(less than 5%),in its colloquial speech it has definitely persian influence due to influence of bollywood and its standard dialect was not properly depersianised in its standardisation process but than also it is less than 10%-12% in colloquial speech. Almost every persian words used in hindi has native tatsam and tatbhav word which are actually in use along with these persian words(example-saanj/sandhya for shaam,savera for subah,antar for farq,sashan/prasashan for sarkar,apradhi for muzrim,..) Even highly persianised mullawood songs has maximum 20-25% and normally around 10%-15% persian words are actually in use in songs,they are used not used in daily life a such level,it is
Simikar to many videos in kannada where person used english words(around 25% sonetimes) but normaly people dont use english word to that extent. Hindi killed language is completwly false and misleading as standard dialect cannot be compared to non standard dialect of any language ,all the dialects are spoken and also have large social media presence similar to how uttar karnataka region people use their dialect and even create content in their dialect and also use standard dialect ,but we cant say kannada killed that that language ,same applies to hindi. About imposition question,i think linguistic policy of central govt is very bad and unjustified it should be reformed immediately i am myself non kannada speaker(from haryana) learning kannada through books and videos
Too good
One challenge to you-full vlog in hindi
Hindi and Urdu are same languages only script is different and Hindi is brought to India by moguls and sultans.
@@manjunathgowdara3101 yes you are true they are acually sane and only difference is script,hindi speaker and muslim speaker in their colloquial speech just dont have any difference.
However saying that it was introduced by muslim or mughals is completely wrong as it was spoken in present day delhi region even prior to mughals.
Amir khusro(muslim poet in earlier muslim sultanates) composed poem in delhavi dialect(hindi and urdu are stnadarised in this dialect similar to how kannada is standarised in dialect near to mysuru bengaluru region) with native sanskrit prakrit word and neglible persian word(two three persian words only),it got persianised in later century as persian was official language of successive muslim empires and that persian version got different name rekhta and urdu (in1780).
Hindi was not brought by mughals,it is native indian language.
My comment on this video was not 𝗮𝗿𝗿𝗼𝗴𝗮𝗻𝘁,it was just a 𝗰𝗵𝗮𝗹𝗹𝗲𝗻𝗴𝗲.
I gave similar comment on hindi speaking instagram influencers living having kannada knowledge to speak in kannada as challenge,do not misinterprete it sir
@@Shjsskk2728 It is very sad to know that a heavily persianised language spoken in Pakistan and Northern India is promoted and forced upon the entire country.
This persianised language has killed several indigenous languages in the Northern India and moving towards south to cause threat to the southern languages.
@@manjunathgowdara3101 well bro my comment in this video was not in this context and as challenge only,i gave similar challenge to hindi speakers also in marathi,gujrati,bangla etc.
About hindi and its persianisation,i dont think it is heavily persianised as hindi has diglossia similar to many languages in world and in its literary language it very less persian words(less than 5%),in its colloquial speech it has definitely persian influence due to influence of bollywood and its standard dialect was not properly depersianised in its standardisation process but than also it is less than 10%-12% in colloquial speech.
Almost every persian words used in hindi has native tatsam and tatbhav word which are actually in use along with these persian words(example-saanj/sandhya for shaam,savera for subah,antar for farq,sashan/prasashan for sarkar,apradhi for muzrim,..)
Even highly persianised mullawood songs has maximum 20-25% and normally around 10%-15% persian words are actually in use in songs,they are used not used in daily life a such level,it is
Simikar to many videos in kannada where person used english words(around 25% sonetimes) but normaly people dont use english word to that extent.
Hindi killed language is completwly false and misleading as standard dialect cannot be compared to non standard dialect of any language ,all the dialects are spoken and also have large social media presence similar to how uttar karnataka region people use their dialect and even create content in their dialect and also use standard dialect ,but we cant say kannada killed that that language ,same applies to hindi.
About imposition question,i think linguistic policy of central govt is very bad and unjustified it should be reformed immediately i am myself non kannada speaker(from haryana) learning kannada through books and videos