I have felt the hidden secret this man posses in midst of his heart while sitting behind this screen. Truly, truth has no language, no shape, no form, it neither depends on anything but its creator nor it ever changes itself because of anyone. Such a true inheritor of our Prophet Muhammad SAW. as he mentioned in one of His traditions: "Indeed Ulema are inheritors of the prophets"
Alhamdulillah, I come from a background where I never even thought of knowing such intellectuals, surely it is Allah's karam! Seeing y'all beautiful people commenting too makes me happy to know that there are so many people eager to catch up with the enlightened ones, May Allah grant y'all 'happiness'.
his final conclusion was that the basic problem of our Omma is the the lack of Àdab and Ahklack. isn't,t that the same massage of prophet Muhammad pbuh. I am really very sad to see this great wise scholar can not spread his knowledge and experience like somebody's in music and football !!! we're really in an age of misery !!! All we can do is to seek rahma and forgiveness from Allah the merciful. and may Allah the Almighty reward shayhk Nakib Al-Attas and shayhk Hamza yusuf Jannat Al-firdaws.
I absolutely love watching a conversation between two high-level intellectuals like this. For those who may be wondering why Shaykh Hamza is almost shouting his words, he's not being rude or anything. It's just due to the fact that the Professor is a little hard of hearing.
I think in subtitle a correction is needed "The word Adab" mean respect or humble manner, which is result of wisdom.... Most probably Dear Sir mentioned Adab not Adam/ adapt.... I am sorry for my comment... Just said because it may help others....
Islam is the most misunderstood religion in the world, why? because it is intellectually demanding. If you want the basics then start by reading this man's books the first of which is entitled " Prolegomena to the Metaphysics of Islam". I must warn you, it will be intellectually demanding and I recommend that you read it several times before you can start to understand the basics.
Thanks brother for informing us of this, I'm into these kinda stuff, do you have any more suggestions of getting my hands on to more sources of knowledge :)
Many people are scare with his knowledge or more apriopriate 'ilm', causes that he always restriced for spread his knowledge. That prove ISTAC was closed.
But if we hide core aspects of Islam while preaching it, that's going to be detrimental to Iman. Because the Iman that the person will be building up won't be based upon the whole truth, right? Isn't it more dangerous for their Iman if they later find out what Islam says but they weren't aware of it, and in fact what they believe then about Islam might be contradictory to what was hidden?
Dendy DM He's a Malaysian citizen who were born in kota Bogor, Indonesia. Biasa lah mereka keturunan Habib yang tinggal merata di Nusantara dari Singapore, Tanah Melayu hingga ke Indonesia. Ketika dahulu ulama kedua negara sangat rapat dan sering bertukar ilmu seperti mana ulama dari Makassar mengajar di Darul Fathani dan sebagainya. Hanya zaman modern ini mereka dipisahkan oleh ideologi barat iaitu nation state yang cintakan negara secara berlebihan hingga menjadi Arrogant dan Ignorant.
why muslim in Malaysia limit their knowledge about islam to mazhab Shafiee, where is the book from alFarabi, Ibn Sina,Aljabbar, alKhawaridzmi and so many others? Isnt it all the ilmu comes from Prophet Muhammad saw?
Nah we're not putting a limit to our society. As well as there's people of knowledge there will always ignorance among them. We're the people who celebrate all the mazaahib but love the way our grandfather teach us at the first place.
dude i think you've confused things up a little bit,learning a mazhab means learning sharia ,so its a must for everyone to tidy up your religious actions. the people or the scholars you are mentioning deal with hikmah which is for the ones who seek for, and hikmah is not as vital as shariah because without shariah hikmah means nothing more than words, salah for five times a day is a must for everyone and you start it immediately you become muslim or mukellaf about commandmants first things first
Knowledge is infinite in its nature. Prof syed naquib al attas was saying that to have wisdom is to place knowledge at its proper place. Blameworthy knowledge when it is place in its proper place is justice same goes to praiseworthy knowledge. For an example, knowledge on nuclear energy; If it’s placed wrongly in its proper place, it will be a destruction for humanity hence injustice would occur. If we don’t know the ‘tool’ to place things at its proper place, injustices would happen and it will cause destruction for ourselves and the world.
Yes indeed that was the real purpose , but the thing is.. how insan's nowdays undertand , acknowledge bout this , As an Aqidah or knowledge to be apply.
Sayyidina Muhammad Rasulullahb(pbuh) spent 13 years in Makkah propagating Aqeedah.The neverending problems of ummah right now is indeed the lack of adab/akhlakul kareemah.The pinnacle of knowledge is adab & not many understand Ihsan.
🤲🙏💕 as local in SE Asia the taylor bird's example is excellent for a good system when given to a monkey a good governance is shreded & ruined. Look around the world.
Be careful with this budak Wan Fayhsal kerana dia ni munafiq.... He tried to use the name of Sayyid Muhammad Naquib al Attas to gain political power for the wrong reason. May Allah SWT punish him for his wrong doing... Of course, we love Sayyid Muhammad Naquib al Attas and Hamzah Yusuf. But not this boy...
![Shaykh Hamza Yusuf with Shaykh Syed Muhammad Al-Attas [English+Chinese Subtitle]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j0MRhoRFaPM/mqdefault.jpg)
You can see Shaykh Hamza is in awe of this man!
I have felt the hidden secret this man posses in midst of his heart while sitting behind this screen. Truly, truth has no language, no shape, no form, it neither depends on anything but its creator nor it ever changes itself because of anyone. Such a true inheritor of our Prophet Muhammad SAW. as he mentioned in one of His traditions:
"Indeed Ulema are inheritors of the prophets"
Watching in 2021. Thank you for sharing. Two gems.
"Masa lalu itu hidup manakala masa depan itu mati"
Prof Dr Syed Naquib Al Attas
Alhamdulillah, I come from a background where I never even thought of knowing such intellectuals, surely it is Allah's karam! Seeing y'all beautiful people commenting too makes me happy to know that there are so many people eager to catch up with the enlightened ones, May Allah grant y'all 'happiness'.
"Quran speaks about trees, isn't it?"
Spoke that with his shimmering smile. Really loved that ♥️
This video seriously deserves more views. All I can say is, WOW to this video. extremely insightful..
Maa Shaa Allah, very useful resource for the Ummah.
Jazak Allah Khair
Audio is Perfectly Fine! This is a fascinating conversation.
Syed muhammad naquib al-attas invokes deep thought. Thanks for uploading
"Iman from Allah but we must prepair underground"
Prof Dr Syed Naquib Al Attas
The ground
Thanks for all contributes, very very useful discussion, Allah may bless on all of us.
beautiful man janabq Naquib al Attas. Love his demeanour.
Wow..syaikh hamzah yusuf learn from him..18 may 2020..
A great but simple easy to understand scholar May Allah bless him and all his relatives and associates Ahmeen
Wonderful,wonderful,just wonderful!
MasyaAllāh TabarakAllāh this is such a gem 💎 To see both of them in discussion. Jazakallahu khayran for uploading!
Syed Naquib al-Attas is called Imam Ghazali fi Zamanina..
@@abidrahim7607 in our time
Haha you speaking in lughah mukhtalitah
Profesor diraja now alhamdulillah
@@bangjack2384 ikr.
Laa budda lahu for me to laugh. 😆
A historical dialogue between two contemporary oceans... Allahu yubarik fikum..
Masyallah.....some ppl have knowledge but without adab....VERY VERY TRUE
Our great scholar in present time
@@PSCJunction Yes, he still alive but ailed
Thankyou for this ...Masha Allah
Wise man, wish I could buy his book.. not available here in the netherlands..
Maybe you can order from here. facebook.com/casisbookstore/
sayyid muhammad nauqi bin ali bin abdullah bin muhsin bin alwi bin slim bin umar bin ali bin umar bin aburahman al attas
Such a wise and yet modest man🙌👏
We need more of Prof Al-Attas lecture that has been recorded
Ma sha Allah. Very useful resource 🌹❤
I watch this again and again
Excellent.
jazakallah for upload this amazing talks. sadly just know ISTAC died without him.
ISTAC?
@@hamidswift he used to be the director of istac
@@ammarhusaini what has become of istac is so saddening :'(
MashaAllah, his dialect it's totally Sundanese...:)
He was born in Bogor, west Java of East indies back to 1931
He was in Malaysia??????!!! Mashaallah!!! Darn it I missed a chance to meet him. Thank you for uploading this.
he is from Indonesia and born in Indonesia, Bogor.
and he is malaysian
@@mrezarifki he is Malaysian citizen now
He is malaysian... Indonesian please stop claiming..😁
Syed naquib has been in Malaysia since his childhood. He is malaysian.
Wan Fayhsal punya youtube channel rupanya
his final conclusion was that the basic problem of our Omma is the the lack of Àdab and Ahklack. isn't,t that the same massage of prophet Muhammad pbuh. I am really very sad to see this great wise scholar can not spread his knowledge and experience like somebody's in music and football !!! we're really in an age of misery !!! All we can do is to seek rahma and forgiveness from Allah the merciful. and may Allah the Almighty reward shayhk Nakib Al-Attas and shayhk Hamza yusuf Jannat Al-firdaws.
Allahumma Ameen
I have my own conclusion about ummah. It's far from what this man has spoken. I felt major concern for what already done by his words of lies.
@@saudaramalaya6641 what did he say that was a lie and where did he say it
@@saudaramalaya6641 I didn't watch the whole thing yet just the first 2 minutes then went to the comment section
@@pufftiloe sorry but not sorry. I know this bcs Quran still alive. I know what I know, if I'm wrong, Allah knows more.
Omg I love him so much.
Thanks for your knowledges I have no way of knowing in my life.
nice
looking for cooper and i found gold
I absolutely love watching a conversation between two high-level intellectuals like this. For those who may be wondering why Shaykh Hamza is almost shouting his words, he's not being rude or anything. It's just due to the fact that the Professor is a little hard of hearing.
Cucu al qutb alhabib abdullah bin muksin alathos empang bogor indonesia
I think in subtitle a correction is needed "The word Adab" mean respect or humble manner, which is result of wisdom.... Most probably Dear Sir mentioned Adab not Adam/ adapt.... I am sorry for my comment... Just said because it may help others....
Islam is the most misunderstood religion in the world, why? because it is intellectually demanding. If you want the basics then start by reading this man's books the first of which is entitled " Prolegomena to the Metaphysics of Islam". I must warn you, it will be intellectually demanding and I recommend that you read it several times before you can start to understand the basics.
Thanks brother for informing us of this, I'm into these kinda stuff, do you have any more suggestions of getting my hands on to more sources of knowledge :)
🤲🤲🤲
Wow WAF ada youtube channel rupanya, idola dia orang yang bijak
PMX yg 'tolong' idola dia ni establish ISTAC
kenapa tak ada subtitle indonesia? :(
Mutiara bangsa
hi brother, why is this video not available to download offline ? buat la boleh download pleasee
Nobody will hate the teach of Ibrahim, except those who numb.
😍
What does he say at 10:48?Someone please tell me.
Many people are scare with his knowledge or more apriopriate 'ilm', causes that he always restriced for spread his knowledge. That prove ISTAC was closed.
Allahauakbar
0:27
Where can I find more?
May I ask for this video to be download? So we can share and public would benefit for this video?
Yes you can.. please
@@asmaweahmad7179 the download button disable... Could u pls enable the download button?
4:25 , 6:20
Uploader dah jadi menteri ehehe
But if we hide core aspects of Islam while preaching it, that's going to be detrimental to Iman. Because the Iman that the person will be building up won't be based upon the whole truth, right?
Isn't it more dangerous for their Iman if they later find out what Islam says but they weren't aware of it, and in fact what they believe then about Islam might be contradictory to what was hidden?
Sadly this channel owner learn nothing from this video😢
He should be in the government if he's not already..
Syed Naquib sounds like Indonesian when speaking English
Dendy DM hes malaysian
Dendy DM He's a Malaysian citizen who were born in kota Bogor, Indonesia. Biasa lah mereka keturunan Habib yang tinggal merata di Nusantara dari Singapore, Tanah Melayu hingga ke Indonesia. Ketika dahulu ulama kedua negara sangat rapat dan sering bertukar ilmu seperti mana ulama dari Makassar mengajar di Darul Fathani dan sebagainya. Hanya zaman modern ini mereka dipisahkan oleh ideologi barat iaitu nation state yang cintakan negara secara berlebihan hingga menjadi Arrogant dan Ignorant.
why muslim in Malaysia limit their knowledge about islam to mazhab Shafiee, where is the book from alFarabi, Ibn Sina,Aljabbar, alKhawaridzmi and so many others? Isnt it all the ilmu comes from Prophet Muhammad saw?
Nah we're not putting a limit to our society. As well as there's people of knowledge there will always ignorance among them. We're the people who celebrate all the mazaahib but love the way our grandfather teach us at the first place.
nobody stops u from learning all mazhab, but this country mazhab is shafiee. malay is the proudest shafiee ever
@@amirasyraf9808 brother is it true that wahabiism is flourishing in Malaysia fast?
Yusuuf jihadaa
dude i think you've confused things up a little bit,learning a mazhab means learning sharia ,so its a must for everyone to tidy up your religious actions. the people or the scholars you are mentioning deal with hikmah which is for the ones who seek for, and hikmah is not as vital as shariah because without shariah hikmah means nothing more than words, salah for five times a day is a must for everyone and you start it immediately you become muslim or mukellaf about commandmants first things first
Altay Solar clearly you don't understand
Knowledge is infinite in its nature. Prof syed naquib al attas was saying that to have wisdom is to place knowledge at its proper place. Blameworthy knowledge when it is place in its proper place is justice same goes to praiseworthy knowledge. For an example, knowledge on nuclear energy; If it’s placed wrongly in its proper place, it will be a destruction for humanity hence injustice would occur. If we don’t know the ‘tool’ to place things at its proper place, injustices would happen and it will cause destruction for ourselves and the world.
Yes indeed that was the real purpose , but the thing is.. how insan's nowdays undertand , acknowledge bout this , As an Aqidah or knowledge to be apply.
Sayyidina Muhammad Rasulullahb(pbuh) spent 13 years in Makkah propagating Aqeedah.The neverending problems of ummah right now is indeed the lack of adab/akhlakul kareemah.The pinnacle of knowledge is adab & not many understand Ihsan.
🤲🙏💕 as local in SE Asia the taylor bird's example is excellent for a good system when given to a monkey a good governance is shreded & ruined. Look around the world.
Mana adab dan akhlak kau sekarang dalam berpolitik kau sekarang Mat Jargon?? Dasar khianat.. Wayangg!
Be careful with this budak Wan Fayhsal kerana dia ni munafiq.... He tried to use the name of Sayyid Muhammad Naquib al Attas to gain political power for the wrong reason. May Allah SWT punish him for his wrong doing...
Of course, we love Sayyid Muhammad Naquib al Attas and Hamzah Yusuf. But not this boy...
thanks yb. great video.