Editorial with Sujit Nair: The Legacy of Justice Bobde
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- On Friday, Former Chief Justice of India SA Bobde's tenure came to an end. In his term in the Supreme Court, he has authored only 68 judgments in his seven years in the Supreme Court, seventeen months of those as the Chief Justice of India. In this episode of the Editorial, our Managing Editor Mr Sujit Nair speaks to senior Advocate Prashant Bhushan. #CJIBobde #SABobde #SupremeCourt #PrashantBhushan #DushyantDave
To Join TH-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscrib...
Download the HW News Network free app available on Android and iOS: onelink.to/bpk42n
For NEWS and POLITICAL updates in English. Send us a ‘Hi’ on our Whatsapp Number - 9820918578
#HWNewsEnglish #HwLatestNews
For advertising related queries write to us at sales@hwnews.in
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Deepak Mishra Ranjan Gogoi Arun Mishra and Bobde will surely have their name inscribed in the hall of Shame in the annals of Indian History led by Amit Shah and Modi
More to come
I think even more people like these jokers will come in coming years till the time this ranga and billa is there
All are following Nehru..who had one for him in every district. Constant or time variant I don't know
The damage to the image of the country is incalculable. How do we make them accountable.
@@MrAntonysimon They were Modis hatchetmen.Defeat Modi in 2024 and hang them by their balls
Talk of the Town. Ex-CJI Bobde joining RSS in Nagpur as legal advisor and officio of union law ministry.
They the RSS won't hire this no good jerk
He his half knicker walla
As usual against traditions
th-cam.com/video/yG9xnWL0gAQ/w-d-xo.html
NV RAMANA as CJI
Wearing Khakhi Pants,White Shirt, Black Cap Sporting a Lathi and like the RSS leader also a Shendi.
PB sir....u are such a brave soul.....India wil naver forget your Fight against injustice happening in this era
CJI Bobde won't be missed. Let's leave it at that
High hopes. Just wait for him to be nominated in RS.
He won't be remembered save for his miserable tenure as the CJI.
He will be appointed as Governor. At the moment Meghalaya governor may be on the block.
His conscience will deal with him accordingly
1
1 @@celsodias7895
ex cji ll be deeply missed by Arnab Goswami.
No one will miss him.
Modi will do setting with new CJI for Gooswamy.
His chat discloses that he can purchase judges .
😀
@@roshanrajanand5736 : from a chai seller to judge purchaser ...way to go Modi
Can't the judges be penalised with heavy penalty for their negligence arrogance misconduct and mistakes
They can be impeached
Advocate Prashant Bhushan is a fearless personality speak truth on facts , if public voting held for CJI post , I support Mr Bhushan
Yes
th-cam.com/video/yG9xnWL0gAQ/w-d-xo.html
NV RAMANA as CJI
Pitiable and horribly unfortunate that the Indian justice system has gone to the dogs, the country is in grave crisis altogether
Shame on these spineless judges. They have degraded the whole judiciary when the poor and downtrodden think that they are Gods. They turned out to be devils in black coats. GOD save this country. 🌹
Such a shame these people who are a curse to the people of this country and our Judiciary
But the biggest curse is the evil twins.
Hope many other judges are listening and watching this.
Your concern is right. These judges should know that people are watching them and they will be judged as well.
Action speaks louder than word, so worried about my country:-(
👍🙏
Tough one asked by Sujit Nair Sir & Adv. P B Sir was very Honest reply on India Against corruption. Hats off for both Honest and Genuine souls.
SC should take up all long pending issues like Rafael or 370 or CAA or EVMs.
This CJI just passed his time and made money.
Better if the are delayed, for obvious reasons 😁
He also number one... Andhra.c m complaint is modhi government take .a . hanging string.
Sir your frank & courageous comment without fear or favour is very admirable. You hve given corrects facts about these Ex-supposed to be the CJS. I think the incoming is also recommended by the previous & we can’t expect anything better if it’s true. God alone should save our Citizens
Wow... With Mr. Prashant Bhushan .... Waiting.
Probably, the judge who dared to send Amit Shah to jail was no other than Judge Akhil Qureshi.
And He is Suffering for this by denying His Elevation to the Supreme Court of India.
Honest host, honest anchor and honest program...... Honest discussions...... Great show
Always pleasure to hear Mr.Bhushan sr.Advocate
Wonderful interview sir.. loved the last question, deep down inside prashant sir should feel that he is partially responsible for the rise of BJP in India.
New CJI must uphold the Constitution. Should not yield to Government.
Being a government appointee?
Lol keep dreaming
Last 2 CIJs contributed a lot for losing faith in our judiciary for many people.
It is people like Bobde who give confidence to people likeTushar Mehta to make statements which reek of arrogance and which incidentally is the trademark of the Modi sarkar,in the Delhi HC, when he told the Delhi government not to be a cry baby. The urgent hearing was to save lives. Lives are just a statistic with this government.
I n greatfull to u sir . Wonderfull topics n guest was apt n rarest best possible . U had list of questions those r really representing the people of india . U r voice real india hatts off sir .thanku to ur team .
Sir, with all the regards and respect towards sr.adv.Prasant Bhusan, I would like to summaries his opinion about " THE LEGACY OF RETIRED CJI.BOBDE" in one sentence, " Operation success but patient died " 🙏🙏🙏
Very true sir nice editorial hope someone really unbiased CJI is appointed
Very sad situation in our country :(
Lacklustre tenure. Just took it easy. Waited for retirement. Period.
Thank you Adv.Prashant Bhushan for so courageously exposing the face of evil in judiciary as well as the executive. Perhaps citizens may/will open their eyes, and brains....they are now ‘enjoying’ the governance they deserve.
What legacy? they all belong to RSS cadre. What good can you expect from them?
He might be a Governor in the making.
Only shame, no legacy at all
CJI was like Hanuman to Rama / Modi !
Is there any way to bring them to justice someday in future when this current regime is voted out?
How will they be voted out? First remove EVM, & for that EC has to be neutral.
@@57628588 if there is visible anti modi wave, they cannot rig elections as actual results would be evident. They can rig it only if there is ambiguity.
@@PranavGogwekar Ambiguity is a media creation for public consumption. Read the public responses unilaterally across posts on every matter there is an overwhelming NAY in the air.
Justice will be meted out by the one above. KARMA will be served.
@@PranavGogwekar Anti Modi wave can be controlled easily by Media. Even during these times it says Modi has over 67% popularity rating. It cant go any more below this.
Thanks
Congrats for showing the truth and being brave in these undeclared emergency days
Thanks for such a informative video
Dishonest of fair judgement by the Chief Justice of India and supportive of Modi BJP Govt are continues habbit of CJIs and all the four or five ex CJIs are not exceptional and we expect the same process by the incoming CJI
Absolutely brilliant interview/answers.
One became RS member and one became governor both are corrupted
Last four judges are shameless judges.
Very honest & upright lawyer.
May his tribe increase.
Jinnah too was upright.
Yes 👍
Shame on Modi Shah's puppet supreme court.
But you have to agree that loyalty is rewarded. Whether or not Justice is served...
We have heard enough of the evils the people are experiencing in all fronts not only judiciary. Something should be done immediately to chase these dogs from the corridor of our sacred Parliament, which were once illuminated by our memorable Gandhi, Nehru,Patel L B Shasthri & Vajpaye. It is very painful to note such honoured chairs are now occupied by rogues, cheats,criminals and fraudulent imposters. People must revolt.
I was shocked, when Mr.Bobdae said, "why are women and children in the FARMERS protest?" Don't women have the right to protest? If yes, then where should the children go? This is absolute insane.
Worth Re 1.
Hope the New SC Judge will not let down rhis country like other 3 favouring modi and BJP are really a shame to this country and our Judiciary
No way,till this regime continues.
Ex CJI bobde lacks dedication towards his profession, have no guts to take challenges, risks & face due consequences. Mr. Parshant Bhushan will never withdraw from his lawful statements.
Sir, you goofed up when you asked Mr Bhushan - "Was there a lack of apathy from the SC.....? "
Please be aware of your vocabulary. Otherwise, you are simply fantastic. And, I always wait for your editorial.
LOL...I realised it just now!
Why don't you please educate Mr. Nair by framing the question the right way. It is easy to criticise, difficult to come up with solution
I was not criticizing Mr. Nair. I was just making him aware of the incorrect vocabulary used. It should have been 'empathy', not 'apathy'. 🙂
Just a slip of tongue, it looks like. In all likelihood he meant 'empathy'
In that case, my sincere apologies. I wonder why we Indians are so sensitive to criticism, even when it is a constructive one?
I hope the new chief justice of India deliver good Jugement best of luck to the nation
can someone please list the stay orders issued by sc against central govt from past 7 years
He was only eager to take case / care of ARNAB 🤣
An RSS CJI is being replaced by another RSS CJI so there won't be difference in judgements. All judgements on future too shall be in favour of ruling party even if it's for the murder of innocent Indians suffering from pandemic due to huge mismanagement by the ruling Government
Best to close courts and save tax payers money. This institution is beyond repair!
Retired judges to be prosecuted for their omissions and commissions while in office?
I'm failing to understand as to what can be the motivation behind acting so passively and inefficiently after becoming the CJI!!!! The Constitutional significance of the Apex Court is eroding away rapidly.
state of all the independent institutions of our country. The rot had been on for many yearsnow. The previous govts are also responsible. This govt just took advanmtage of the situation and took it to its logical conclusion. What is needed is to remove these institutions from political control
Agree
Caesar's wife should be above suspicion.
He is the most unscrupulous man ever
Difficult questions...Ably answered by Bhushan Ji.
Mr. Prashant Bhushan observations absolutely critical and impressive. He deserves applaud.
Top to bottom Sab government officials institutions president vice President governor election commission supreme court income tax department CBI CAG NIA DVAC enforcement agencies and police department Sab ke Sab andar hi andar darthe Hain Gujarat ke goondas Modi and Amit Shah.
Hope ex-CJI will be rewarded with some plum post. Congrats in advance to Bobde.
Who is No: I? Each competing to beat his predecessor. So, obviously Bobde comes out on top of the heap. But he had a jolly good life, when the rest of us suffered during COVID, finding the easy way out by being led by Tushar Mehta and friend Salve. No wonder that India's 1st Law Officer eminent legal KK Venugopal kept scrupulously out of the mayhem.
Very sad state of affairs in SC in recent years. A pillar of democracy has fallen
All the pillars are giving up,it has been dragged to beneath 😀.!???
He became governor or RS MEMBER
India needs a court/ media like USA at the time of presidential election otherwise India can never be a superpower of its own.
First we need to bring back the ballot...
Thank you sir for your courage. Many of the Supreme Court chief and other justices were rewarded also. All in the name of justice. Shameful. People are losing faith in the Supreme Court
'lack of sympathy or empathy' not 'lack of apathy'; in fact, the problem is that there seemed to be apathy and not lack of it.
Prashant Bhushan and Dushyant Dave have all cases with one vein... LIBRANDU thought process
Tum logo ki Mullaiyat wali Chatukarita aur Mullaiyat ki tabiyat kharab ho gayi hain
Chorkat
In the rule of Modi, Shah difficult to carry out the constitutional duties where a thereat for own life there and all officials even want to carryout the proper duty unable to perform in fair way or the justice denied to anyone who talk or report against the government and how Siddiq Kappan being a journalist muslim treated by the U P government and court? Mera Bharat Mahan.
'Legacy' is a misnomer. We will be apologising to our future generations for this decade for a very long long time. It will take us a few decades just to apply for readmission to humanity.
Very interesting and honest discussion
Ayooo you back , ma man , drop the thunder on their blunders
Superb daringly said and interviews.
All 4 pillars demolished now there is only one pillar.
BOBDEY lives up to his name !!!!!!
Justice Bobde said in his farewell speech that he did his " best ". His predecessor too did his "best". We very well know what this "best" meant to the ordinary Citizens of India and what this "best" meant in delivering judgements favouring the Goverments. I'm not sure whether any more Chief Justices will follow their predecessors path to this " Hall of Shame ". While Modi and team are burning their midnight oil to find pliable judges, it also happened with Indira Gandhi, let's keep our fingers crossed with the appointment of the new Chief Justice.
TIME FOR HIGH COURTS TO DISREGARD THE SUPREME COURT COME WHAT MAY !!!!!!!!!
Some People are Most Dangerous
Serving in their Office. I Welcome
the Retirement. India is Saved. 🙂
If SC is for the Govt, of the Govt, by the Govt, we do not require SC at all. What is the alternative for such CJI's or SC. Let us enforce HCs with higher powers given to SC.
Mr Prashant Bhushan is a rare indian in the league of the Bajaj father and son who've had the cojones to express the truth. Even the Sri Sri Ravishankars, the Sadhgurus and the Baba Ramdevs who have failed miserably to defend the poor and downtrodden, like the migrant workers. Cowardice is an integral part of the Indian DNA. Very seldom will you find a sizable number who will stand up for anything worthwhile. In a mob we find our strength. Shame.
Every judge of every court is supposed to uphold the law of the land. That has to be the only legacy, they should be leaving behind as and when they retire from active service. But it is so unfortunate that many of them from the lowest to the highest court like for example the Supreme Court of India are doing just the opposite. Ideology is always socio-political. It cannot be extended to the legal and administrative domain. So both judges and civil servants need to be ideologically neutral.
Once supreme court had the.highest respect in india
What is his next position that he's assured if by the govt ?
The episode with Justice Akhil Qureshi just shows you that merit alone is not enough for you to serve the country in the best possible way that there is. On the other hand, you have people like Bobde, Gogoi, who have made a sellout of themselves IMO. But then people say, Muslims enjoy equal freedom in this country.
மண்டை ஓடுகள் மண்டிய நாட்டை மன்னன் ஆளுவதோ 😭 மன்னன் ஆளுவதோ...
பேயாட்சி செய்தால் பிணம் தின்னும் சாத்திரங்கள்.
Can we talk and ask from PM about availablity of resources against 10 lacs or more cases for Covid 19..
In reality, India is suffering for more than 5 Lacs cases..
In resources, we need to focus all below.
1.) Beds n Hospitals
2.) Medicine and Kits
3.) Oxygen, their Cylinders
4.) Doctors, Nurse, supportive team
5.) Administrative teams
Because any distribution in any resource is very critical to save life of people.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Pls ad bhim payment system oso, I tried bt ders only gpay n it needs card details
He will come to know,if he has been falsely charged, should be punished for the human rights violations 😀.!???
One must know we have large populatio , If the SC delays the hearing only couple of thousands will die. Sab jangasi hai.
The only remedy is to ban appointment of ex- Judges of SC for any post after retirement and increase their retirement age upto 75 yrs
Today's world anywhere and everywhere truth speaking or writing is becoming very very dangerous to our life and families.
Prashant Bhushan Sir is always right about the gobber bobde... bjprss ko bhagavo Desh ko bachavo...#kisanektazindabaad
I think he forgot the Kunal kamra case.
The Nation gets the Govt it deserves....
What is the point in discussing the issues... why the Country brought BJP and Modi into power... we all knew Modi and Shah had blood in their hand...
No Mr. Bushan it was a plot. One CAG and one ANNA was selected and used with outmost cunningness. Lot of right thinking people like you too fell into the trap. The resources and kind of characters like Babas and sadhus being used by RSS were visible and obvious. By the it was too late and the anti congress emotions were too strong to recuse from the commitments unwittingly made. Now the realization hurts you but ego stops you from admitting it. Fine, you too are human. But, what about those blissfully enjoying the fruits of a sin, like Kejriwal, Bedi etc etc.
Well, I don't expect an answer.
Very soon, Mr. Bobde will become a politician, and then he will get a good share of electoral bond money.... then how could he issue a judgement against it.... that is a big fortune... RJ membership is a very small position, compared to electoral bond.... from Serum Institute, Ambu and Andu bhai, from those Rich who became double richer in just one year...
Supreme Court justice Retired, list out realised best and bad effort public, public possible judgement and public against judgment, after retirement person only discuss, and Govt support Retirement judgment, list previous 10 year who is best judgement, public so happy, and Govt also possible, such judgment looser public hope, who is best judge age success of service.
We require a higher judiciary comprising high calibre judges, and this can be secured only by establishing the NJAC, which the Congress - led opposition thwarted with unbelievable myopia. From an ideologically and politically inbred community of judges, India is facing crises of personal integrity, civilisational wisdom and ideological neutrality. Hence , one of public confidence as well. Political and sectarian partisanship is not productive.
Further, the interpretation of the Same Law is open to interpretation by different Judges by their ' own inferences' ; leading to different Judgments,how , even the best legal luminairy,or Lawyer can foresee this.? Waiting for the justice,and not the Judgment..??