One thing that puzzles me about Harry dying in the Forbidden Forest is that being the true master of the Elder Wand, Voldemort's killing curse should have rebounded on him as he cast Avada Kedavra using the Elder Wand just like he did when he met his demise later on when he faced off again with Harry in the Great Hall and met his demise.
I think the answer to that is that Harry intentionally sacrificed himself in the forest. The wand never defeated its master because his intention was to die there.
This is interesting, other Harry Potter channels have said similar but different things. As for the things you agree with, you both quote Dumbledore: Harry is saved by Lily's Love protection, since his blood is in Voldemort's body, as a result instead of Harry and the Horcrux both being destroyed, only the horcrux was destroyed. Kind of like, narrowly missing being hit by a runaway car because a pole was in the way, but your bike got totaled.
Interesting explanation for Harry surviving the killing curse from Voldemort. I had not heard it, so I had come up with a different theory: that the curse hit the fragment of Voldemort within Harry and thereby Harry was partially shielded from the full force of the curse.
I thought the Pensieve was always the property of Hogwarts long before Dumbledore even became headmaster just like the Sorting Hat and the Sword of Gryffindor.
how is Dumbledore there? If this is the way station between realms. Does that mean he has the power to go from realm to realm? …could he come back to ours?
On response to the thumbnail alone. Old moldbreath knew he had the stone, so thus had no "lesson" to teach harry... Perhaps in death dumbledore had learned about his evil ways...... I mean... Death... Eater.... Like... Zombies?
I was just listening to that part of the book. That tension in the scene was just captivating. You could feel Harry's feelings and turmoil. The movies didn't do the real justice.
Yea but how come he didn't poop his pants when he died for those brief moments. Do wizards not do that when they die. Hagrid should have had poop on him from carrying Harry.
Likely no avada kedavra is meant to rip of souls from the body and in this case Voldemort’s soul was ripped out and Harry’s soul was then in limbo but I don’t think that the spell can be used on objects
Harry didn't die, the piece of Voldemort's soul inside him died instead. So Harry was free to return.
That’s as I understand what happened as well!
One thing that puzzles me about Harry dying in the Forbidden Forest is that being the true master of the Elder Wand, Voldemort's killing curse should have rebounded on him as he cast Avada Kedavra using the Elder Wand just like he did when he met his demise later on when he faced off again with Harry in the Great Hall and met his demise.
I think the answer to that is that Harry intentionally sacrificed himself in the forest. The wand never defeated its master because his intention was to die there.
probably because the wand was targeting the horcrux in harry
The anwer is that harry actually dies Voldemort inside him survives but he acts until end of deathly halllows!!
This is interesting, other Harry Potter channels have said similar but different things.
As for the things you agree with, you both quote Dumbledore:
Harry is saved by Lily's Love protection, since his blood is in Voldemort's body, as a result instead of Harry and the Horcrux both being destroyed, only the horcrux was destroyed.
Kind of like, narrowly missing being hit by a runaway car because a pole was in the way, but your bike got totaled.
Interesting explanation for Harry surviving the killing curse from Voldemort. I had not heard it, so I had come up with a different theory: that the curse hit the fragment of Voldemort within Harry and thereby Harry was partially shielded from the full force of the curse.
I wonder if you could do a piece on all the lovely music that goes with the movies?
Yes, a commentary on the music would be fabulous!
Love your videos!!
Hi bro,
Love your vids
Please can you please explain the pensive?
How it works, and, how dumbledore got it
I thought the Pensieve was always the property of Hogwarts long before Dumbledore even became headmaster just like the Sorting Hat and the Sword of Gryffindor.
@@barbiquearea Hogwarts was build where the pensive was found I think.
So Harry finally free to make his own decisions
More amazing videos 😊
Nice job 👍
how is Dumbledore there? If this is the way station between realms. Does that mean he has the power to go from realm to realm? …could he come back to ours?
Amazing 🤩
In the movie I was wondering about it. In the book it was loud and clear.
On response to the thumbnail alone. Old moldbreath knew he had the stone, so thus had no "lesson" to teach harry... Perhaps in death dumbledore had learned about his evil ways...... I mean... Death... Eater.... Like... Zombies?
And Draco’s mom knew he was alive because she said “is draco alive?” And Harry moved he’s head and it was yes. So she knew.
I was just listening to that part of the book.
That tension in the scene was just captivating.
You could feel Harry's feelings and turmoil.
The movies didn't do the real justice.
Yea but how come he didn't poop his pants when he died for those brief moments. Do wizards not do that when they die. Hagrid should have had poop on him from carrying Harry.
Did he talk to Dumbledore or Death? He took off the Cloak and greeted Death like an old friend.
???the resurrection stone???
No more night mares no more talking to snakes 🐍
My question is can avada kedavra kill horcruxes too? It appears so based on this.
Likely no avada kedavra is meant to rip of souls from the body and in this case Voldemort’s soul was ripped out and Harry’s soul was then in limbo but I don’t think that the spell can be used on objects
@MewStor maybe it cannot be used on objects, but if it can destroy horcruxes in living things, it could have been used for Nagini.
Ouch 🤕
Painful ironic 😣
U know who was only killed the horcrux in Harry not Harry himself
Crazy 😜
🏞🏝🏜🌏
Seriously 😒