as a Hamas supporter this is very informative thank you bro but, I think it is a failure to intercept 80dollar by at least 50 g, sometimes it is needed more than one interception but dont worry money is printed, and the debt is for future children of USA to pay, finaly isreal feel they are the chosen people of god, your and our beloved Jesus was crucified, bitten and spitted upon by the Jews, and to this day they say he is the son of a whore wake up, if they didn't respect Jesus, they wouldn't respect his followers
Isn't that great? Moreover imagine that the beneficiaries instead of being thankful to the donors, they make their best to promote open borders, transgender propaganda, DEI programs and antiwhitism.
Where do you "tax payer money" whiners think that money goes? Raytheon produces a large portion of the interceptor, it goes back to Americans who design and build these components.
Y’all ain’t that bright 😂 Israel came up with the funding for this weapon system themselves. American tax money didn’t fund this we made money off this by selling them things like the missiles components and computer/radar tech
Please Sub & Hit the Notification Bell New Video on Friday. These videos are purely for understanding the basic Engineering behind them Consult your nearest Military Engineer
nexts to be about Mk 19 grenade launcher, Mk 47 Striker, M777 howitzer, Avenger Air Defense System, Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) and Humvee.
A saturation attack will overwhelm the system and essentially render it almost useless. Hamas did just that, launching thousands of rockets in short order,the iron dome could only intercept some,many got through.
The failure of Iron Dome to protect Israel is a perfect example of complacency as a result of over-reliance / over confidence in a system that appears so invincible. There is no such thing as a magic bullet. When I was in the U.S. Air Force, my commanders always told us before every deployment to not be so dependent on a single equipment. Always have a back up and always think ahead of what would happen if your equipment fails. In other words, don't let the defense contractors convince you that their weapons are invincible. No weapon is.
as a Hamas supporter this is very informative thank you bro but, I think it is a failure to intercept 80dollar by at least 50 g, sometimes it is needed more than one interception but dont worry money is printed, and the debt is for future children of USA to pay, finaly isreal feel they are the chosen people of god, your and our beloved Jesus was crucified, bitten and spitted upon by the Jews, and to this day they say he is the son of a whore wake up, if they didn't respect Jesus, they wouldn't respect his followers
@@TFY-v8l I'm saying you always can add more launchers, it's not that expansive as many geniuses think - constant retaliations and wars are much more expansive. This system allows us to contain shootings instead of fighting endlessly, right now we have a good opportunity to end this kind of terrorism once and for all.
i cant comprehend how the Hamas missile costs $80. that has got to be the cheapest missile I've ever heard of edit: my short research makes me believe there was an error in the video. the hamas missile costs from $300 to $800 according to a quick google search
No payload in a missile to fool and empty iron dome launchers before using real ones.Imagine spending 50K $ to destroy a metal tube filled with concrete.Thats how.
Israel made so many Inventions.. Take for example the F16, an autonomous vehicle (sold to the United States), an armored tank (against mines), drippers, and really so many other things that it's simply amazing.. Oh and another very famous thing that I forgot, the 3D printer was created in Israel 20 years ago, but of course it was not as we know it, but simpler..
For your information🔴🔴: The Jews came from Eastern Europe to the land of Palestine and in 1948 they occupied it under the auspices of the West. They persecuted the Palestinians. this is the truth.
Its 80s Patriot missile tech that still works. Iron Dome/Patriot missile systems are overly complex and expensive. If you could incorporate the radar/tracking and "command center" into each missile it would be cost effective and better because currently if the command centers or radar stations are taken out the Iron Dome/Patriot system becomes useless. In the "next gen" missile you would have multiple independent command and radar stations.
or you just put the command center in a secure location/underground bunker and by this avoid making the system A LOT more expensive per interception. The cost of a patriot missile is already at a point where intercepting most missiles is incredibly cost-inefficient.
The beautiful thing about the interceptor is that he doesn't has any radar (cheaper than what everyone thinks), it's because the projectile trajectory is calculated many times a second, this allows the command center computer with the help of the very sophisticated radar to remotely guide the interceptor exactly to the meeting point.
I think there is a big mistake in this animation. The Tahir or Tamir missile need to have a data link sensor to get feedback from tracking radar via a data link. Only electro-optic sensor is not sufficient and it won't work at all to destroy a rocket.
Great video thanks. 4:30 I think it's better to unify the units. If you are using Kilometre, then use kilometre. You are using miles to explain the iranian missile, and feet as the man's height. Thank you, looking forward 2 your next video.
What happens to the interceptors that don't hit a target? Do they find a safe place to explode or there's a risk that they'll hit some populated area? Another question about the Iranian attack that happened just now: there were very few interceptors flying - does that mean the Iranian rockets/missiles were aimed away from populated areas? Thanks!
Israel need a long rang point defense system built around a 155 mm canon using ramjet shells that is guided that is cheaper than missiles. Italy have developed a similar system. The new German air defense artillery is excellent.
@@samuelmatheson9655 If Gaza is part of an apartheid state it is because of the violence that terrorist group like Hamas has perpetuated on the Israel people.
Use this expensive system to intercept cheap low tech rockets is a challenge to budget. The other day we witnessed the result which is a bit embarrassing. That were only 5000 rockets. Think big.
Here's what something alot of people don't understand. Iron Dome does not protect all of Israel... there's a limited amount of space air defense systems can protect and its usually the most critical or high population areas. Now 2500 or so rockets were fired into Israel we know that but the whole number doesn't really matter, what matters is the rockets that actually came into the areas where Iron Dome was defending. Israel said they intercepted 97%, if thats true then Iron Dome did its job nearly perfectly.
What they do not tell you is the shrapnel that falls after the missle explodes. Israeli sell the shrapnel to tourists. I know, because my friend has a wind chime made from pieces of missile. His wife purchased them while visiting and had them shipped home. Her husband made a wind chime. The pieces are heavy, so it is not a very good wind chime.
I have question. What 3d animation software you use to make this 3d animation video? And how much time does it usually take for you to finish a 3d animation video?
Blender. As for how long, it depends on the person or team's skill. It could take a few days, it could take a few weeks. I guess it took them 3 to 5 days for this. The animation are rather simple, no dynamic rigging is required. Texturing is very simple too. But still need some times to model all the equipments. But if you already have a model library, then life is easier.
You forgot to mention or avoid that it is effective but it could over come it with high number of rocket that it just would be limited to the number of the iron dome rocket and those afterwards could pass easily ( with low cost for qasam they could easily do that and replace thier rocket much faster.
The Iron dome is NOT as effective on smaller drone based missiles that can be flown at below radar levels and can change their flight paths Beautiful presentation. Best wishes
Or you simply launch a bunch of metal tubes filled with concrete instead of explosives and few real ones.When dome is empty you fire real missiles .They spend 50k on concrete missiles that cost 100$ to make ,when launch tubes are empty you send real ones.
you right but they keep reloading it they have no issue with money as they USA their daddy is paying for it not israeli , so even if they fire 10000 missile a day not issue for them , @@zumbazumba1
@@zumbazumba1 exactly. The Iron Dome have huge flow. The cost alone is enough to make Iron dome useless against overwhelming cheap missiles. and Iron Dome can't intercept a long range missiles means that Iron Dome is designed to intercept short to mid range missiles. Compare this to the cost make it Unpractical
@@hornerfarah2282 Can you blame them? It was created to defend against palastinian militias. Not actual militaries. You put it in conditions available on the Ukrainian front and it would be destroyed in a day.
The animation is great. Gives a clear understanding of how things work.
Thanks
Yes,, 😅
I think it is the most informative video on the Iron Dome topic here on TH-cam. Great job! Thank you!
as a Hamas supporter
this is very informative thank you bro
but, I think it is a failure to intercept 80dollar by at least 50 g, sometimes it is needed more than one interception
but dont worry money is printed, and the debt is for future children of USA to pay,
finaly isreal feel they are the chosen people of god, your and our beloved Jesus was crucified, bitten and spitted upon by the Jews, and to this day they say he is the son of a whore
wake up, if they didn't respect Jesus, they wouldn't respect his followers
The missiles name is Tamir not Tahir
Thanks for your feedback 👍
0:41 4:26 6:29 it's not a BM-21 Grad rocket, it's 9K58 Smerch
3:31 mistake: 4 to 70km, not 4 to 7km
Thanks for your feedback 👍
SMERCH!? Now that's overkill
Yep
@@Barri2410 hehe, it's not the scariest one. check out TOS-1A
yeah
the cost of the missiles are irrelevant for the interceptors, its American tax payer money, its free
Isn't that great? Moreover imagine that the beneficiaries instead of being thankful to the donors, they make their best to promote open borders, transgender propaganda, DEI programs and antiwhitism.
It’s not taxpayers money, it’s printing machine/debt money
Where do you "tax payer money" whiners think that money goes? Raytheon produces a large portion of the interceptor, it goes back to Americans who design and build these components.
It's doing a damn good job given the Hamas overwhelming numbers but yeah costs need to come down it makes the defence ultimately unsustainable
Y’all ain’t that bright 😂 Israel came up with the funding for this weapon system themselves. American tax money didn’t fund this we made money off this by selling them things like the missiles components and computer/radar tech
Please Sub & Hit the Notification Bell
New Video on Friday.
These videos are purely for understanding the basic Engineering behind them
Consult your nearest Military Engineer
can you also make a video on m302 missiles which hamas have about 6000 according to web
@@cookingstreet9362 Yes On Saturday Or Monday.
Is it Iranian Made?
nexts to be about Mk 19 grenade launcher, Mk 47 Striker, M777 howitzer, Avenger Air Defense System, Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) and Humvee.
It is a chinese designed syrian made rocket
You forgot to add that Iron Dome needed 2 interceptor missile in each target .
Yes agreed but I heard it's just a backup since they followed the Patriot missile Strategy
A saturation attack will overwhelm the system and essentially render it almost useless. Hamas did just that, launching thousands of rockets in short order,the iron dome could only intercept some,many got through.
It is possible to add more iron domes or (a new development) an iron beam that should be put into operation in 2025
So in your opinion it should be dismantled and shouldn't be used??
The failure of Iron Dome to protect Israel is a perfect example of complacency as a result of over-reliance / over confidence in a system that appears so invincible.
There is no such thing as a magic bullet.
When I was in the U.S. Air Force, my commanders always told us before every deployment to not be so dependent on a single equipment.
Always have a back up and always think ahead of what would happen if your equipment fails.
In other words, don't let the defense contractors convince you that their weapons are invincible.
No weapon is.
Good advice for all parts of life, not just the military.
Iron Dome wasn't really the failure there. It was the border fence.
Very detailed video I ever seen on this iron dome topic
love the simple explanation
Mulțumim! Excellent video and invention of Israel. Next can be about NASAMS System and one about IRIS-T, battery, launchers and etc.
Thanks @razvanciobotaru For the financial Support we love you guys!
Love the way you animated, pro.
Awesome animation with explanation as usual. How do you do it everytime 😍.
We do it just for you guys 🙏
as a Hamas supporter
this is very informative thank you bro
but, I think it is a failure to intercept 80dollar by at least 50 g, sometimes it is needed more than one interception
but dont worry money is printed, and the debt is for future children of USA to pay,
finaly isreal feel they are the chosen people of god, your and our beloved Jesus was crucified, bitten and spitted upon by the Jews, and to this day they say he is the son of a whore
wake up, if they didn't respect Jesus, they wouldn't respect his followers
At 03:24 you make no sense. Please note that 4-7 Kilometers roughly equates to 2.5 - 4.3 miles not 43 Miles.
Its main flaw is that you can just overwhelm it with numbers.
Living safe in Israel is expansive but possible and it worth it
Thats the same flaw with any air defense system genius lol
@@TFY-v8l
I'm saying you always can add more launchers, it's not that expansive as many geniuses think - constant retaliations and wars are much more expansive. This system allows us to contain shootings instead of fighting endlessly, right now we have a good opportunity to end this kind of terrorism once and for all.
@@sdsdsd8888 user-ft2zc5or9d was replying to original comment.
@@sdsdsd8888it won't be safe for long.. trust me
3:29 4-7 kilometers are far less than 43 miles.
Yes will lokk into it
5k = to about 3 miles
He said 4-70 kilometers, the illustration lost a 0 there.
Nicely explained 👌
Impressive explanation , as always.
Thanks again!
But the context is all wrong, like all the vids involving weapons sent to Ukraine. It's called propaganda.
I love the videos but i also liked the real voices
Clear Explanation ,bro good job 👍👏👍👏
3:41 Iron Dome's Missile Name is Tamir not Tahir
Thanks for the correction
@@Aitelly welcome
The most accurate and comprehensive video about iron dome
Thanks for the video what haappened to the patria amv video idea u said u were making???
Great explanation with beautiful animations.What is the software that you are using?
blender
ChatGPT
Can you please explain why the iron Dome can intercept MLRS while other air defense systems can't?
i cant comprehend how the Hamas missile costs $80. that has got to be the cheapest missile I've ever heard of
edit: my short research makes me believe there was an error in the video. the hamas missile costs from $300 to $800 according to a quick google search
As it is locally made the smallest costs $80 to $1000
Many of them fail to make it to the target. A lot of them end up falling in their own territory. Those that make it are destroyed.
No payload in a missile to fool and empty iron dome launchers before using real ones.Imagine spending 50K $ to destroy a metal tube filled with concrete.Thats how.
@@uap24 At least they are trying to do something to get out of this 20-year siege. If I could help, I would
@@zumbazumba1 oooh that makes sense. guess u could call em decoy missiles. thanks
What is the app that you designed the missile by it
Blender Open Source Software it's free
I hit subscribe because of clear and great presentation. Good job!
It's good. I think I'll sub, too.
Now the name change become The Holy Plastic Dome 🤣🤣🤣
Thanks for another good and interesting video
This is what i subscribed for, simple explanation how things works.
You guys are really fast!
just wondering if there were any technology can reverse the missiles back to exactly where it came from? Like send them back to where it was launched?
That would be interesting.
Honestly you spoke my mind, such invention is indeed necessary
Israel made so many Inventions.. Take for example the F16, an autonomous vehicle (sold to the United States), an armored tank (against mines), drippers, and really so many other things that it's simply amazing.. Oh and another very famous thing that I forgot, the 3D printer was created in Israel 20 years ago, but of course it was not as we know it, but simpler..
Pretty sure F-16 isn’t made by Israel but in the 1970s by the US
cap wasn't israel
@@Relativity_Space-SFS Israel might have contributed to research
America is under Israel. They just follow their masters order
All caps lock
47km or 4-7km? Or 43 miles or 4-3 miles at 7:01. I got confused there
This makes me remember black panthers shield during infinity war.thanks its well explained
Great video, nicely done... LIKED 👍 & SUBSCRIBED 🔔
Thanks for the sub!
The hamas militia apparently overwhelmed it with cheap rockets. This strat is the krytonite for all air defense systems.
For your information🔴🔴: The Jews came from Eastern Europe to the land of Palestine and in 1948 they occupied it under the auspices of the West. They persecuted the Palestinians. this is the truth.
How it works? With American tax dollars, 5 billion every year.
America have power
Allah have power,,free palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
@@ekawahyu8985 never free...they are terrorist.
😂😂
Why American providing their money to protect a terrorist regime??
The interceptor missile is called TAMIR (not TAHIR)
I think there's an error at 3:27, the math does not match, 43 miles is 69 km. Good video tho, love it 👍
Thanks for the info
Thank you for the good video.
Can you possibly explain how the radar works?
How can the radar cover 360 degrees?
it doesnt. they turn the radar to face enemy territory so they don't really need 360
Lazzy Dome ....😂 Sleeping Dome
Please, make video on MERKAVA TANK.
Coming this month.
Its 80s Patriot missile tech that still works. Iron Dome/Patriot missile systems are overly complex and expensive. If you could incorporate the radar/tracking and "command center" into each missile it would be cost effective and better because currently if the command centers or radar stations are taken out the Iron Dome/Patriot system becomes useless. In the "next gen" missile you would have multiple independent command and radar stations.
Noted but have you considered the cost factor associated with it.
or you just put the command center in a secure location/underground bunker and by this
avoid making the system A LOT more expensive per interception.
The cost of a patriot missile is already at a point where intercepting most missiles
is incredibly cost-inefficient.
Well that's every long range SAM system though, East and West. A modular system means you can transport and swop out INOP components easily.
Good luck with that,it would make things even more expensive .Unless you are intercepting planes or ICBMS its not worthy.
The beautiful thing about the interceptor is that he doesn't has any radar (cheaper than what everyone thinks), it's because the projectile trajectory is calculated many times a second, this allows the command center computer with the help of the very sophisticated radar to remotely guide the interceptor exactly to the meeting point.
I think there is a big mistake in this animation. The Tahir or Tamir missile need to have a data link sensor to get feedback from tracking radar via a data link. Only electro-optic sensor is not sufficient and it won't work at all to destroy a rocket.
Great video thanks. 4:30 I think it's better to unify the units. If you are using Kilometre, then use kilometre. You are using miles to explain the iranian missile, and feet as the man's height.
Thank you, looking forward 2 your next video.
What's absolutely amazing is that all this happens at two times the speed of sound.
What happens to the interceptors that don't hit a target? Do they find a safe place to explode or there's a risk that they'll hit some populated area? Another question about the Iranian attack that happened just now: there were very few interceptors flying - does that mean the Iranian rockets/missiles were aimed away from populated areas? Thanks!
Cannot sleep overnight inside the dome
Qassam and Grad and others are rockets not missiles !
Yes agreed sometimes it's tough to co-ordinate and make animation videos from scratch in 2 days.
Will keep it in check.
Unguided rockets
thanks
Actually , the range of the interceptor doesn't exceed 15 km max
I’m guessing the accuracy will drop off around the 15 km range?
@@JenniferA886 i think it is about kinematics , the interceptor is small
Israel need a long rang point defense system built around a 155 mm canon using ramjet shells that is guided that is cheaper than missiles. Italy have developed a similar system. The new German air defense artillery is excellent.
Israel needs to stop apartide
@@samuelmatheson9655 If Gaza is part of an apartheid state it is because of the violence that terrorist group like Hamas has perpetuated on the Israel people.
It has proven to be the best in the world intercepting 70-90% of 5000 rockets in 1 day is unprecedented
They finally did it!
Thanks !
finally
Now that's a sci-fi in real life 😊
The title should be how it doesn't work 😂
Thank u very much 🎉❤
thanks for letting Geopop use your material, I've just subscribed your channel as well ;)
i will subscribe
Nice work
Lovely videos keep it coming Kindly requesting to do a video on Israeli MBT Merkava Next time❤
how does he make like this one can you tell me? Soft ware?
@@Mubashar783 Sir he mentions it in the end of every video but the actual app or software I don't know since I'm not the creator
Sistem pendeteksi sudah mendeteksi jauh sebelum peluncuran. Ketika peluncuran sudah lepas landas jarak 20 km
Use this expensive system to intercept cheap low tech rockets is a challenge to budget. The other day we witnessed the result which is a bit embarrassing. That were only 5000 rockets. Think big.
So the iron domen are connected all Around the country ?
Super good videos. Definitely my go-to channel for learning about this stuff!
Glad you enjoy it! Next is the Engineering about Merkava Tank
and the Iron Dome have 90% of success
and trust my it's very relaxing that you have this amazing sistem that save you'r life every day
Please explain:
QRSAM
LRSAM
MRSAM
SRSAM
XRSAM
Kush ADS(ERSAM)
AADs(Ballastic 2000KM)
Akash NG
Spyder ADS
Arrow ADS
Any idea the G limit on these missiles?
Probably not "multi-seeker mode", but "multi-mode seeker".
In fact it's an gimbaled AESA seeker.
Here's what something alot of people don't understand. Iron Dome does not protect all of Israel... there's a limited amount of space air defense systems can protect and its usually the most critical or high population areas. Now 2500 or so rockets were fired into Israel we know that but the whole number doesn't really matter, what matters is the rockets that actually came into the areas where Iron Dome was defending. Israel said they intercepted 97%, if thats true then Iron Dome did its job nearly perfectly.
God be with Israel! Thank you for your amazing vid. To put this up this quickly to correlate to current events must have tough
I dont think god likes them that much ,he did make them wonder the desert for 40 years instead a simple 6 days walk !
So...if something went wrong with the Battery, the whole system would fail? Seems like it's pretty dependent.
How does the missile get oxygen for propulsion
Ok no problem next time work ,iron doron
What they do not tell you is the shrapnel that falls after the missle explodes. Israeli sell the shrapnel to tourists. I know, because my friend has a wind chime made from pieces of missile. His wife purchased them while visiting and had them shipped home. Her husband made a wind chime. The pieces are heavy, so it is not a very good wind chime.
its not iron dome paper dome is correct name
What about a CIWS from a ship but grounded one? Can it do the same job for cheaper?
Sir I can use your vedio short clip
Kelemahan iron dome jika ditempatkan rudal besar2 besaran secara bersamaan maka lama2 akan tembus jika isi rudal irone dome habis
can i use this clip ..........
It is important to consider not only the cost of the interceptor, but also the potential damage avoided.
I have question. What 3d animation software you use to make this 3d animation video? And how much time does it usually take for you to finish a 3d animation video?
Blender its Free.
www.blender.org/download/
Blender. As for how long, it depends on the person or team's skill. It could take a few days, it could take a few weeks. I guess it took them 3 to 5 days for this. The animation are rather simple, no dynamic rigging is required. Texturing is very simple too. But still need some times to model all the equipments. But if you already have a model library, then life is easier.
It took just 2 days for us to get this done
But the AC130 video took 30 days
On Friday another Video just for you guys
You forgot to mention or avoid that it is effective but it could over come it with high number of rocket that it just would be limited to the number of the iron dome rocket and those afterwards could pass easily ( with low cost for qasam they could easily do that and replace thier rocket much faster.
oh i understand khnow thanks😃
Falto la recreación de la falla del domo de acero. Pero Muy buen video.
Worked well on October 7th.
Thank you
The Iron dome is NOT as effective on smaller drone based missiles that can be flown at below radar levels and can change their flight paths
Beautiful presentation. Best wishes
Or you simply launch a bunch of metal tubes filled with concrete instead of explosives and few real ones.When dome is empty you fire real missiles .They spend 50k on concrete missiles that cost 100$ to make ,when launch tubes are empty you send real ones.
you right but they keep reloading it they have no issue with money as they USA their daddy is paying for it not israeli , so even if they fire 10000 missile a day not issue for them , @@zumbazumba1
@@zumbazumba1 exactly. The Iron Dome have huge flow. The cost alone is enough to make Iron dome useless against overwhelming cheap missiles. and Iron Dome can't intercept a long range missiles means that Iron Dome is designed to intercept short to mid range missiles. Compare this to the cost make it Unpractical
@@hornerfarah2282 Can you blame them? It was created to defend against palastinian militias. Not actual militaries. You put it in conditions available on the Ukrainian front and it would be destroyed in a day.
somehow, 70 people are upset because someone explains how a modern air defence system works
They r upset because of lack of education, they've been raised to hate everything about israel.
So einfach funktioniert ein Land nicht der so viele Feinde hat. Land von anderen wegnehmen wird niemals Ruhe geben.
Last thursday doesn't work.
IT DOesnt intercept ballistic missile
As a kurd I rate this missile 6/10
AN ULTRALIGHT PARACHUTE DOES NOT APPLY?
Can you Tor-M2/SA-15?
Can you make a video about iron beam
its the Tamir missile not Tahir
Great work telly, keep it up.
Thanks saumyan