Thank you for this, it will be helpful for us with our Mal. There are potential downsides to having the level of engagement that Fury has with you. For some dogs or people these things don't matter. Decreased problem solving development, decreased situational awareness, complete lack of respect for their handlers personal space when not wanting to interact with the dog (putting in crate or kennel is not always an option). All dogs by design (some more than others) receive more information about the world through their nose more than any of their other senses.
Just found your channel. Loving it so far! I rescued BelMalX off the street and while she's not too crazy, she's 10X more dog than any other dog I've had. I love all your real-world advice.
I have been watching your videos for the last two days. We are in the process of finding our next dog and I am leaning towards a mal/GSD mix because I love both breeds. In anticipation I have been trying to get my training skills to the next level with my dogs and this channel has been so helpful for me! Thank you so much for making your explanations so hands on descriptive it makes a huge difference.
Very interesting video! I have a pitbull that I've struggled with engagement and this video nails it - she only engages with me for treats/her ball. I've always been told I don't have high enough value treats for her continued engagement or that she'll eventually associate me with the treats/ball but that doesn't seem the case. Dirt is definitely more distracting than I am ;)
Thank you so much this is so helpful when I'm out with mine she finds everything else more interesting but now I have a few ways to get her to focus on me
Valuable nugget information that I haven't seen explained elsewhere. I can see it now when I bring my Mal out of her crate. She is hungry for attention and that anticipation tidbit is an eye opener. We just got done with AKC Rally novice and just wondering how I can increase engagement and this pops up!
I am still working on my 7mo old mal. I got her at 5.5mo old. I recently got a crate that she FINALLY likes going into. I do feel guilty putting her right back into the crate once we are done training. You’re video makes me feel not so alone in that feeling. Thank you.
I have a Sheltie that won't do what would normally be natural for her because she knows if I have treats on me even if I load up out of her sight. She also knows that I do not carry treats in the obedience trial ring so ring attitude goes south. Very occasionally, when she thought I had a cookie on me, I got beautiful engagement but it was in a practice match ring, not the real thing, and she knew it.
Definitely can see the difference in engagement between the two dogs. Does the e collar affect the engagement? Fury was wearing one so does she know e collar means training/play session? So her engagement was up. Riot didn't have one on so maybe he was just in chill out mode knowing it isn't a training session.
My Belgian malinois is fully engaged with me in a concealed park with gates and she listens and heels perfectly without even a leash but when at walks she gets really off of it and wants to attack everything how can i improve this
I took my dog out to an open field with some other dogs nearby, no toys or treats, and my dog kept running back to me and playing with only me. I didn't realize all that meant. I like how I can use that as a gauge for how engaged he is with me.
I have a 4 month old Malinois puppy. I got him a month ago and I started crate training 4 days ago. How long will I have to wait until I close the crate door and leave him?
We have that type dog, high drive and intelligence. Food and prey driven so easy to train. Wants to please and work. She's Catahoula Leopard Dog and Rottweiler cross. Super athletic.
Will this work even if the dog has had more freedom for around 8 months? My dog is totally engaged with me with play, but on the trail (off leash) or on a walk (leashed) he's pretty ambivalent to my existence would like to be more important. We do spend a lot of time together interacting, so it's not an issue of lack of bond.
so I work 8-5 job and I want to have that engagement with my GSD. I taking him out to play from 5:30 am -7:10am /get home by 6pm we go out for walks and then we play/ Train. Question: should I put him in his crate when I leave to work -and then take him out when I get out and before bed put him back?.. or that’s a lot of hours for him to spend in his crate?
Is it possible to do all these things with a 1 year old dog? my dog isn't crate changed he knows how to go in an out of the cage. but can i re train these things to him even thought the window of opportunity has gone?
I see the difference in the engagement, yet I see Fury's reaction as more trying to communicate what she wants before the engagement. Is communication a different step? I've had German Shepards before and the Belgian Malinois seems less people driven and more engagement oriented. A Belgian Malinois difference to me is a German Shepard on steroids. They are great but lots more work and while somewhat affectionate they are rougher than the german shepard. I see why they say this is not a dog for everyone. I love my Ariel yet she is rougher in her movements and moments I try to pet and love on her than any dog I've ever owned. I'm learning. Protection and Police Work is I believe their best placement.
A cool trick to get your dog to focus on You , is at a sit position at your side. Drop a piece of food from your mouth to his/hers. Every time you make a sound, they'll be locked on to your face /eyes. We can get so in tune with our dogs that it's possible for us to control them with nothing but our eyes.
I’m working with a puppy who we think is around 9-12 months and I want to build her engagement. Only issue is my family🫤 they wanna leave the toys out and do literally the opposite of what is needed to build the engagement. I wanted to crate train and they don’t. All 3 of our other dogs are crate trained but when it comes to this dog which needs the crate the most they don’t want too. They want a dog that will engage with the whole family but they also want me to train her. I can’t even get her to engage long enough to begin her training but they aren’t understanding that certain things need to be done in order to have the dog they want.
I loved this video! And to find I’m doing 90% of these things right ! I have two 11 week old shepherd/husky litter mates brother & sister and they are so great BUT I can’t get them to focus on me when they are outside with each other or playing together .. if it’s one on one they are fine and respond to recall, etc.. any quick tips to help get their attention more ? They don’t really have a fave toy they are obsessed with YET 😂 they do know after training they get their chew ‘bones’ a flavored benebone ..PS so happy you came across my FYP on TikTok!
Hi. I have a 14 month old female Malinois that is crated and gives engagement like Fury. She has no access to toys other than when we go out. The issue I have is when she gets the toy, we play fetch or tug, but after a bit of time the recall fails and she shows signs of conflict. She will use things in my garden as barriers and it can be very difficult to get her to come back to me. I have tried to make me the only source of fun and engagement but this is still happening. Any ideas of what else I can do to prevent this from happening?
Really good tips. We crate our 7 mo. Mal for several 'nap' times a day and when released the focus is definitely stong. Now if I could just focus myself on training during those times we'd probably be much further along. My bad.
Great video. If you make yourself into a reinforcer, how do you create an Off switch when the dog is in the house with you? Also, do your kids train also, or you need to become the only predictor of food and play?
I have a question about fury: it seems to me like she’s showing signs of stress like panting, tense face and ears pinned back throughout a lot of the talking part of the video. Would you be able to tell me your take on that? I’m just looking to broaden my knowledge and am curious if there’s more to that than I notice. Thanks!
Yes, when I see videos that show the dog stressing and whining I wonder how healthy that level of excitement is, when nothing is going on, or just heeling is being asked for.
They are malinois (velcro dogs/perfect recall naturally) unless you did something wrong during puppyhood they never want you out of sight. They are not runners.
@@thunderandstorm4957 not all mals are that way. My friends mal is a runner and cannot be off leash much in an unknown environment. She is VERY prey driven. She is fully trained as a protection dog, and also does competitions in dock diving.
I dont have a Mali but an Akita now 11 months old male and a bugger to engage with me HAE WILL DO SIT LAY DOWN BUT WILL NOT COME TO ME SENDING ME CRAZY
I’ve never heard it this way but interesting, I’ve heard to teach a puppy to learn to be slightly independent or confident by themselves too so they don’t develop separation anxiety/ be extremely needy of you, they can sometimes help themselves, but also more than ready to engage with you, so would the time in the crate be that alone time of theirs? Soo what I’m asking is can you evaluate a little more, is this specifically for malinios that you wantt them to be on you looking at you for play/ direction. When is it engagement and when is it being needy to where sometimes you’re like okay i need to do this ‘task’, with you out of my way, but not necessarily in the cage every time u need to do something? or is this engagement for dogs in general I ask cause I’ve been confused. Usually ppl don’t want , what seems to be needy dogs but want their attention or focus calmly.
@@esaflaka9155 guess that depends on what the purpose of the dog is. If it’s a pet, they need to learn to chill around you in the house, plus you have a life outside of the dog. They are going to have alone chew time. If it’s for sport, some people only take them out to work, so they condition themselves to be a reinforcer for excitement only and don’t let the dog find them boring.
LOL Try doing engagement with a pitbull. Really easy with a Mal, even a tough Mal. The pitbull starts at the tough Mal leve and is much much harder, but it can happen.
By temporarily withholding the things the dog values, you're actually making them happier in the long run. If the dog constantly gets what it wants all the time, it will naturally become desensitized and lose value for those things, unable to achieve the same happiness from those objects/activities.
Hi can I ask you if it is normal for the malinois to bite you when you run? Cuz this happens when I walk with my malinois but when we're walking we're okay but when I run she tries to bite my legs or pants. How can I correct this behavior?
I find with my puppy if you have treats in your hand let him follow your hand around while you walk and reward him when he doesn’t bite it’s like the beginning of teaching them how to heel
Great food! The only company that I know of that the owner actually ate nothing but their dog food. I'm not sure how long he are it, maybe a month 🤔 Great video
Can there be engagement difference because of gender in general? As females are more softer, home, family oriented while males are more territorial, bit more independent wanderers in their nature?
You’ve got this somewhat backwards, actually. Bitches tend to be more domineering and territorial, as females are typically the leaders in canine packs.
they can smell indeed but I have tricked my dog several times with hiding the ball in the pocket. I know its counterintuitive but it works. Maybe out of sight out of mind.
Great engagement video. Also saw video of the time spent with each day training each Mali. Very inadequate for Mali's. Sorry, but they need much more and better exercise.
The dog that gave you such incredible engagement, can you “release” her so she knows that “now I can go be an actual dog, run/sniff/swim/mark/explore/chill etc? Or is she always this way? Maybe it’s a breed specific thing for working dogs as tools, but it seems so robotic. Not the way I imagine dogs having a good natural “dog” time. Also, crates are illegal where I live unless transporting.
I agree with much of what you say about restricting access to value-toys and such, but when I bring a dog into my home, he/she is here for companionship, friendship, interaction (other than training and playing), etc. For one, I raise Dobermans, and anyone who raises Dobies knows they are "velcro" dogs and crave their human's affection and attention; I'm not to saying they run the house or my life, for they do spend time in their crates when I have important things to do or must go where they can't, but to lock them up in their crates just to have them "starved" for ones attention, for me, that borderlines on cruelty, abuse and egocentric behavior. My Dobies are my friends, and there is a saying, "Get a Doberman, never go to the bathroom alone again." It's cute but true. Do I have focus issues? Yes, but I will give complete focus up anytime to have a friend who isn't starved for my favors; would you do that to a spouse or one you are dating or a friend just to get them to fixate on you or want more of your attention? I wouldn't.
I've watched a few of your videos now & alot of what you talk about makes sense. But why do you need to use an e collar or a prong collar on your dogs?
A dog weighs which half or more your own weight needs more effective control. Using the prong makes walking the dog POSSIBLE. No one benefits from being pulled down the street. The resistance against the pulling is very hard on the joints and is downright dangerous! Dogs need to be mannerly. These tools are needed for some dogs. There is no " one size fits all" training tool for dogs anymore than there is a " one size fits all" method for parenting children. Each child is unique. What works with one will not necessarily suit another.
Crates are for dogs to use as a safe and comforting place. Kinda like a kid's bedroom is their private resting place. Crate trained dogs are happier and calmer. So many misconceptions of the purpose for dog crates. There is a right and wrong way to crate train. Most people are just too lazy to put in the work.
Hi In case you don‘t only make your videos for people living in the USA, I just wanted to inform you that many of the things you suggest or use would be completely illegal in Europe. In Switzerland, where I live, it is illegal to keep your dog in a small cage. Cages may only be used for short periods of time and for a Malinois (according to size) the minimal space requirement would be 8 square meters (86 square feet) for such a cage, per dog. The E- Collars and any sort of spiked collars are not only illegal, they are considered animal abuse, also any sort of collars that may choke the dog are illegal. So we cannot train them with it here at all. It is illegal to keep the dog in a box too, specifically described in the law. It states that, if you let your dog sleep in a box, you must remove the door of the box first. In addition, leaving the dog run in a small backyard is not considered free range and neither is keeping them on a (even very long) chain. We are required to go on walks daily and the law also says we must let them roam free, off leash when possible and they must have social contact with other dogs. Germany has almost the same laws. This way, it can be much harder to properly train a dominant Malinois and have it engage with you and never be distracted. Btw not saying you are doing anything wrong, just wanted to inform.
That laws my friend are not casual, are not cause we like dogs run free, etc. Is just common sense and how other domesticated species are supposed to live out their lives. Boundaries are important, but more important is to educate your pets with love and dedication, socialise them to such an extent that they become friends with the ants if necessary. in this way they live a fuller life and so do you. Belgian Malinois are working dogs, which means that they adapt to ways of life that other dogs simply do not understand. Having three Malinois in your house loose is definitely not a good way to live in peace. The question is: why have three Malinois when you can have three golden retrievers loose in your house without them being a problem? Each breed of dog has been created to fulfil a function within its (pack) family. Choosing the right one is the best way to a successful and happy future development for everyone. The use of kennels in common sense is for transporting pets or specific situations in which we want the animal not to move, such as a medical problem; not to punish them or to make them sleep there or to get them into any kind of behaviour. Education is the key to keeping pets as free as possible without compromising their safety or the safety of other living things in the environment.
There must be plenty of dog fights there with all the unleashed dogs roaming without responsible restraint. Your government is too oppressive. We have freedom of thought and belief here in the US. Crates are for dogs' benefit. " Freedom" to roam does NOT equal best dog care in all situations. Dogs don't have to be " socialized" by meeting other dogs face-to-face. That's a man made idea. I prefer to protect my dog from being attacked by other dogs. Here, if your dog is unleashed, you aren't controlling your dog in public, your dog is crossing boundaries or trespassing, and owners are legally responsible for any problems or damages your dog creates. What about a dog walking up and biting a child?
I agree with the concept of avoiding crates, but I think it's wrong for a government to be that invasive with people's liberties. I have a different way of getting complete engagement from my Malys without crating, but this requires a lot of work which most people are not willing to do. Most people want an easy, quuck way to have the full attention of their dogs by these types of extremes. I respectfully disagree with the concept shown here. I love my Maly- and he loves me- and the freedom he has. This respect leads to an awesome relationship with these little friends. I'm not looking for a perfect show piece dog that must stare at me every second they are with me- I just want my Maly to be a well behaved, obediant, healthy, disciplined friend- and he IS. Dont think for a second that you can't have absolute obediance AND engagement without crating- it just takes a lot of work. My (9th) Maly goes with me virtually everywhere, is in engagement when I want him to be, and enjoys a very full life as a partner in my work and family life. How? You must be willing to dedicate a lot of time to giving them attention- especially when in puppyhood. It is normal for puppies to have difficulty with focus for a considerable time- after all, they are discovering a whole new world. Once the basics are trained and they understand the concept of focus, they will engage you out of love- even over food. Thats when they become awesome partners and friends instead of showpieces that must live a restricted life...
Wow, and reminded me of our engagement with God as our source. The Giver and not the gifts. Hebrews 11:6 I need to work on leaving the house and leaving my dog alone at home in the crate. Just moved to a new place.
3 engagement methods at: 11:32
You rock
"She's a resourceful little bugger, isn't she"....as an Aussie, you had my total focus!
Thank you for this, it will be helpful for us with our Mal.
There are potential downsides to having the level of engagement that Fury has with you. For some dogs or people these things don't matter.
Decreased problem solving development, decreased situational awareness, complete lack of respect for their handlers personal space when not wanting to interact with the dog (putting in crate or kennel is not always an option). All dogs by design (some more than others) receive more information about the world through their nose more than any of their other senses.
I LOVE seeing an active, engaged dog. When they're going through their behaviours trying to MAKE you give them the reward... That's the best feeling.
Just found your channel. Loving it so far! I rescued BelMalX off the street and while she's not too crazy, she's 10X more dog than any other dog I've had. I love all your real-world advice.
Holy cow thank you for this! I’ve been in a rut with my Malinois. I had no idea this was what engagement was all along. Priceless information.
I have been watching your videos for the last two days. We are in the process of finding our next dog and I am leaning towards a mal/GSD mix because I love both breeds. In anticipation I have been trying to get my training skills to the next level with my dogs and this channel has been so helpful for me! Thank you so much for making your explanations so hands on descriptive it makes a huge difference.
Awesome how you explained the anticipation part. Great video!
Very interesting video! I have a pitbull that I've struggled with engagement and this video nails it - she only engages with me for treats/her ball. I've always been told I don't have high enough value treats for her continued engagement or that she'll eventually associate me with the treats/ball but that doesn't seem the case. Dirt is definitely more distracting than I am ;)
You definitely ENGAGED me with this awesome video...Great PRO Tips!
Very good information. I have a one year old Mal and I can see where everything you talked about here works. Thank you.
In my opinion this is one of your best, most valuable videos!
Absolutely.....MM is broadening her base...
I appreciate you making this video. You broke down everything perfectly. I can't wait to try this with my 7 week old Mal and see the results.
It’s so much nicer getting dog advice from a nice woman ❤, I find the male dog trainers on TH-cam to have major attitude and ego issues!!
Just don't ask for a reply for a question she doesn't!
That was a great video! I really enjoyed watching your video. Thanks for sharing ur videos
Got a girl 6 month's old your videos have really helped her engage with me amazing dogs 💗
Thank you so much this is so helpful when I'm out with mine she finds everything else more interesting but now I have a few ways to get her to focus on me
How do you keep them from running away?
Valuable nugget information that I haven't seen explained elsewhere. I can see it now when I bring my Mal out of her crate. She is hungry for attention and that anticipation tidbit is an eye opener. We just got done with AKC Rally novice and just wondering how I can increase engagement and this pops up!
I am still working on my 7mo old mal. I got her at 5.5mo old. I recently got a crate that she FINALLY likes going into. I do feel guilty putting her right back into the crate once we are done training. You’re video makes me feel not so alone in that feeling. Thank you.
I have a Sheltie that won't do what would normally be natural for her because she knows if I have treats on me even if I load up out of her sight. She also knows that I do not carry treats in the obedience trial ring so ring attitude goes south. Very occasionally, when she thought I had a cookie on me, I got beautiful engagement but it was in a practice match ring, not the real thing, and she knew it.
one of the best engagement tips im looking for....
Thanks for making this particular video, i had the same misconception
Definitely can see the difference in engagement between the two dogs. Does the e collar affect the engagement? Fury was wearing one so does she know e collar means training/play session? So her engagement was up. Riot didn't have one on so maybe he was just in chill out mode knowing it isn't a training session.
Fury is a fully trained protection dog. So I’m assuming it is just for both of their safety as well as training 🤷♂️
@@robward6517 riot is a protection dog and wasn't wearing an e collar. So being a protection dog has nothing to do with my question.
She just probably had it on her at the time and didn't take it off or they had a session before, so that is why she was likely crated, to "cool down"
I see what you mean. Yes, I would like to know if she knew what the collar meant as well.
That's a perceptive inquiry and it requires a video re-do.
Fury barks alot I love it
Had no idea this was a 20 minute video. This video was super ENGAGING lol 😂😂
Oh my gosh why didn’t I think about this earlier it makes so much sense. I’m going to start implementing this tonight.
Very helpful . Great explanations!!!
How long should they be in the creat for before and after training?
Emotions is one the strongest treat on planet earth 😍🙏
The difference is 👏🏻 clear, awesome video, I agree the best so far well done.x
This is awesome! I love the real and raw of this channel❤
Wow that impressive. Thank u very much. More power to your channel 💪
Is the same to keep the dog in the crate in your living room or in the crate in the garage where is no people around?
Thanks MaligatorMom it works on my Mal 6months old 😊
My Belgian malinois is fully engaged with me in a concealed park with gates and she listens and heels perfectly without even a leash but when at walks she gets really off of it and wants to attack everything how can i improve this
Love this video , such amazing information. Definitely needed to be said !! Thank you!
I took my dog out to an open field with some other dogs nearby, no toys or treats, and my dog kept running back to me and playing with only me. I didn't realize all that meant. I like how I can use that as a gauge for how engaged he is with me.
I have a 4 month old Malinois puppy. I got him a month ago and I started crate training 4 days ago. How long will I have to wait until I close the crate door and leave him?
We have that type dog, high drive and intelligence. Food and prey driven so easy to train. Wants to please and work. She's Catahoula Leopard Dog and Rottweiler cross. Super athletic.
We love our tactipup collars too! The handle is awesome, plus they look bada$$ too lol.
Will this work even if the dog has had more freedom for around 8 months? My dog is totally engaged with me with play, but on the trail (off leash) or on a walk (leashed) he's pretty ambivalent to my existence would like to be more important. We do spend a lot of time together interacting, so it's not an issue of lack of bond.
i have a doberman that someimes on walks acts like im not even there. i just started doing these steps and i allready noticing a difference
Is there a point where it’s good to let your dog just be with you inside? We have an 11 mo Samoyed. Thank you!
so I work 8-5 job and I want to have that engagement with my GSD. I taking him out to play from 5:30 am -7:10am /get home by 6pm we go out for walks and then we play/ Train.
Question: should I put him in his crate when I leave to work -and then take him out when I get out and before bed put him back?.. or that’s a lot of hours for him to spend in his crate?
Is it possible to do all these things with a 1 year old dog? my dog isn't crate changed he knows how to go in an out of the cage. but can i re train these things to him even thought the window of opportunity has gone?
I see the difference in the engagement, yet I see Fury's reaction as more trying to communicate what she wants before the engagement. Is communication a different step?
I've had German Shepards before and the Belgian Malinois seems less people driven and more engagement oriented. A Belgian Malinois difference to me is a German Shepard on steroids. They are great but lots more work and while somewhat affectionate they are rougher than the german shepard. I see why they say this is not a dog for everyone. I love my Ariel yet she is rougher in her movements and moments I try to pet and love on her than any dog I've ever owned. I'm learning. Protection and Police Work is I believe their best placement.
A cool trick to get your dog to focus on You , is at a sit position at your side. Drop a piece of food from your mouth to his/hers. Every time you make a sound, they'll be locked on to your face /eyes.
We can get so in tune with our dogs that it's possible for us to control them with nothing but our eyes.
Excellent information…luv your pups 🐶
I’m working with a puppy who we think is around 9-12 months and I want to build her engagement. Only issue is my family🫤 they wanna leave the toys out and do literally the opposite of what is needed to build the engagement. I wanted to crate train and they don’t. All 3 of our other dogs are crate trained but when it comes to this dog which needs the crate the most they don’t want too.
They want a dog that will engage with the whole family but they also want me to train her. I can’t even get her to engage long enough to begin her training but they aren’t understanding that certain things need to be done in order to have the dog they want.
hi maam i have Belgian Malinois too.. i always watching your vedios im also your subscriber
Thank you! Do you let them play with the toy after training for a bit before talking it away?
Wow so helpful thank you so much
I loved this video! And to find I’m doing 90% of these things right ! I have two 11 week old shepherd/husky litter mates brother & sister and they are so great BUT I can’t get them to focus on me when they are outside with each other or playing together .. if it’s one on one they are fine and respond to recall, etc.. any quick tips to help get their attention more ? They don’t really have a fave toy they are obsessed with YET 😂 they do know after training they get their chew ‘bones’ a flavored benebone ..PS so happy you came across my FYP on TikTok!
When you say he is in his kennel do you mean crate? Or the bigger cubical area behind you?
Great video and information
How did u train her to bring the toy back.
Hi. I have a 14 month old female Malinois that is crated and gives engagement like Fury. She has no access to toys other than when we go out. The issue I have is when she gets the toy, we play fetch or tug, but after a bit of time the recall fails and she shows signs of conflict. She will use things in my garden as barriers and it can be very difficult to get her to come back to me. I have tried to make me the only source of fun and engagement but this is still happening. Any ideas of what else I can do to prevent this from happening?
Thank you for your videos there great
So interesting to see this video. I’ve been down the TH-cam rabbit hole looking for way to get this one way engagement!! I have you’re first dog, 🤣
Really good tips. We crate our 7 mo. Mal for several 'nap' times a day and when released the focus is definitely stong. Now if I could just focus myself on training during those times we'd probably be much further along. My bad.
Great video. If you make yourself into a reinforcer, how do you create an Off switch when the dog is in the house with you? Also, do your kids train also, or you need to become the only predictor of food and play?
I pause the video to go collect all the balls lol
😂
I have a question about fury: it seems to me like she’s showing signs of stress like panting, tense face and ears pinned back throughout a lot of the talking part of the video. Would you be able to tell me your take on that? I’m just looking to broaden my knowledge and am curious if there’s more to that than I notice. Thanks!
Yes, when I see videos that show the dog stressing and whining I wonder how healthy that level of excitement is, when nothing is going on, or just heeling is being asked for.
What a great video thanks x
Thank you as always!
Do you gave an underground fence? Or how do you keep the dogs in the yard?
They are malinois (velcro dogs/perfect recall naturally) unless you did something wrong during puppyhood they never want you out of sight. They are not runners.
@@thunderandstorm4957 not all mals are that way. My friends mal is a runner and cannot be off leash much in an unknown environment. She is VERY prey driven. She is fully trained as a protection dog, and also does competitions in dock diving.
video starts @ 4:30 you're welcome.
Very well said
I dont have a Mali but an Akita now 11 months old male and a bugger to engage with me HAE WILL DO SIT LAY DOWN BUT WILL NOT COME TO ME SENDING ME CRAZY
Your videos are very helpful t you thank you 😊
I’ve never heard it this way but interesting, I’ve heard to teach a puppy to learn to be slightly independent or confident by themselves too so they don’t develop separation anxiety/ be extremely needy of you, they can sometimes help themselves, but also more than ready to engage with you, so would the time in the crate be that alone time of theirs?
Soo what I’m asking is can you evaluate a little more, is this specifically for malinios that you wantt them to be on you looking at you for play/ direction. When is it engagement and when is it being needy to where sometimes you’re like okay i need to do this ‘task’, with you out of my way, but not necessarily in the cage every time u need to do something? or is this engagement for dogs in general
I ask cause I’ve been confused. Usually ppl don’t want , what seems to be needy dogs but want their attention or focus calmly.
Leaving the dog alone does help develop independence and prevents separation anxiety.
@@NinoTheCorso yes exactly, so im tryna know if cage time is independent time or they do have other times where it’s independent time to
@@esaflaka9155 cannot leave them unsupervised, so only crate time.
@@NinoTheCorso yes ofc I didn’t mean alone time as in out of sight. Meant alone time like has a chew toy and aren’t giving engagement at the moment
@@esaflaka9155 guess that depends on what the purpose of the dog is. If it’s a pet, they need to learn to chill around you in the house, plus you have a life outside of the dog. They are going to have alone chew time. If it’s for sport, some people only take them out to work, so they condition themselves to be a reinforcer for excitement only and don’t let the dog find them boring.
I laughed so hard when he seen that ball...all bets were immediately off
LOL Try doing engagement with a pitbull. Really easy with a Mal, even a tough Mal. The pitbull starts at the tough Mal leve and is much much harder, but it can happen.
By temporarily withholding the things the dog values, you're actually making them happier in the long run. If the dog constantly gets what it wants all the time, it will naturally become desensitized and lose value for those things, unable to achieve the same happiness from those objects/activities.
Hi can I ask you if it is normal for the malinois to bite you when you run? Cuz this happens when I walk with my malinois but when we're walking we're okay but when I run she tries to bite my legs or pants. How can I correct this behavior?
I find with my puppy if you have treats in your hand let him follow your hand around while you walk and reward him when he doesn’t bite it’s like the beginning of teaching them how to heel
@@Poo-ed Okay I'll take note of that thank you so much😁👍
Great food! The only company that I know of that the owner actually ate nothing but their dog food. I'm not sure how long he are it, maybe a month 🤔
Great video
Can there be engagement difference because of gender in general? As females are more softer, home, family oriented while males are more territorial, bit more independent wanderers in their nature?
You’ve got this somewhat backwards, actually. Bitches tend to be more domineering and territorial, as females are typically the leaders in canine packs.
My female is super territorial-- bordering on aggression.
Dogs smell everything even a ball in pocket
they can smell indeed but I have tricked my dog several times with hiding the ball in the pocket. I know its counterintuitive but it works. Maybe out of sight out of mind.
@lorodz took the words right out of my mouth lol
The dog kept looking at her hip.
Great engagement video. Also saw video of the time spent with each day training each Mali. Very inadequate for Mali's. Sorry, but they need much more and better exercise.
The dog that gave you such incredible engagement, can you “release” her so she knows that “now I can go be an actual dog, run/sniff/swim/mark/explore/chill etc? Or is she always this way? Maybe it’s a breed specific thing for working dogs as tools, but it seems so robotic. Not the way I imagine dogs having a good natural “dog” time. Also, crates are illegal where I live unless transporting.
Yes, imagine this being a Swedish trainer, it would be massive protests. Still, she has a point.
I agree with much of what you say about restricting access to value-toys and such, but when I bring a dog into my home, he/she is here for companionship, friendship, interaction (other than training and playing), etc. For one, I raise Dobermans, and anyone who raises Dobies knows they are "velcro" dogs and crave their human's affection and attention; I'm not to saying they run the house or my life, for they do spend time in their crates when I have important things to do or must go where they can't, but to lock them up in their crates just to have them "starved" for ones attention, for me, that borderlines on cruelty, abuse and egocentric behavior. My Dobies are my friends, and there is a saying, "Get a Doberman, never go to the bathroom alone again." It's cute but true. Do I have focus issues? Yes, but I will give complete focus up anytime to have a friend who isn't starved for my favors; would you do that to a spouse or one you are dating or a friend just to get them to fixate on you or want more of your attention? I wouldn't.
Training your dog not to watch where it’s going is just plain dumb.
Malagstior mom holds up a ball+
Riot having a bone in his mouse* immediately drops it when he sees the
ball riot:OMG BALL
I've watched a few of your videos now & alot of what you talk about makes sense. But why do you need to use an e collar or a prong collar on your dogs?
A dog weighs which half or more your own weight needs more effective control. Using the prong makes walking the dog POSSIBLE. No one benefits from being pulled down the street. The resistance against the pulling is very hard on the joints and is downright dangerous! Dogs need to be mannerly. These tools are needed for some dogs. There is no " one size fits all" training tool for dogs anymore than there is a " one size fits all" method for parenting children. Each child is unique. What works with one will not necessarily suit another.
Do you help train dogs?
What kind of toy is Fury chewing on
Where do you get your dogs? Love the channel
She addresses this in the video about "What to look for in a litter" or something along those lines.
Adopt a dog (or cat) rather than shop for one. There's a perpetual ocean of them already out there waiting for a good home.
Engagement... 😂🤣😂🤣 I that is something I never thought about
nice crats are not legal in my country only for transportation, hmm
Crates are for dogs to use as a safe and comforting place. Kinda like a kid's bedroom is their private resting place. Crate trained dogs are happier and calmer. So many misconceptions of the purpose for dog crates. There is a right and wrong way to crate train. Most people are just too lazy to put in the work.
Do you compete with your dogs?
We can’t see the dogs during the explanation, so it’s hard to follow
Hi
In case you don‘t only make your videos for people living in the USA, I just wanted to inform you that many of the things you suggest or use would be completely illegal in Europe.
In Switzerland, where I live, it is illegal to keep your dog in a small cage. Cages may only be used for short periods of time and for a Malinois (according to size) the minimal space requirement would be 8 square meters (86 square feet) for such a cage, per dog.
The E- Collars and any sort of spiked collars are not only illegal, they are considered animal abuse, also any sort of collars that may choke the dog are illegal. So we cannot train them with it here at all.
It is illegal to keep the dog in a box too, specifically described in the law. It states that, if you let your dog sleep in a box, you must remove the door of the box first.
In addition, leaving the dog run in a small backyard is not considered free range and neither is keeping them on a (even very long) chain.
We are required to go on walks daily and the law also says we must let them roam free, off leash when possible and they must have social contact with other dogs. Germany has almost the same laws.
This way, it can be much harder to properly train a dominant Malinois and have it engage with you and never be distracted.
Btw not saying you are doing anything wrong, just wanted to inform.
That laws my friend are not casual, are not cause we like dogs run free, etc. Is just common sense and how other domesticated species are supposed to live out their lives. Boundaries are important, but more important is to educate your pets with love and dedication, socialise them to such an extent that they become friends with the ants if necessary. in this way they live a fuller life and so do you. Belgian Malinois are working dogs, which means that they adapt to ways of life that other dogs simply do not understand. Having three Malinois in your house loose is definitely not a good way to live in peace. The question is: why have three Malinois when you can have three golden retrievers loose in your house without them being a problem? Each breed of dog has been created to fulfil a function within its (pack) family. Choosing the right one is the best way to a successful and happy future development for everyone. The use of kennels in common sense is for transporting pets or specific situations in which we want the animal not to move, such as a medical problem; not to punish them or to make them sleep there or to get them into any kind of behaviour. Education is the key to keeping pets as free as possible without compromising their safety or the safety of other living things in the environment.
There must be plenty of dog fights there with all the unleashed dogs roaming without responsible restraint. Your government is too oppressive. We have freedom of thought and belief here in the US. Crates are for dogs' benefit.
" Freedom" to roam does NOT equal best dog care in all situations. Dogs don't have to be " socialized" by meeting other dogs face-to-face. That's a man made idea. I prefer to protect my dog from being attacked by other dogs. Here, if your dog is unleashed, you aren't controlling your dog in public, your dog is crossing boundaries or trespassing, and owners are legally responsible for any problems or damages your dog creates. What about a dog walking up and biting a child?
I agree with the concept of avoiding crates, but I think it's wrong for a government to be that invasive with people's liberties. I have a different way of getting complete engagement from my Malys without crating, but this requires a lot of work which most people are not willing to do. Most people want an easy, quuck way to have the full attention of their dogs by these types of extremes. I respectfully disagree with the concept shown here. I love my Maly- and he loves me- and the freedom he has. This respect leads to an awesome relationship with these little friends. I'm not looking for a perfect show piece dog that must stare at me every second they are with me- I just want my Maly to be a well behaved, obediant, healthy, disciplined friend- and he IS. Dont think for a second that you can't have absolute obediance AND engagement without crating- it just takes a lot of work. My (9th) Maly goes with me virtually everywhere, is in engagement when I want him to be, and enjoys a very full life as a partner in my work and family life. How? You must be willing to dedicate a lot of time to giving them attention- especially when in puppyhood. It is normal for puppies to have difficulty with focus for a considerable time- after all, they are discovering a whole new world. Once the basics are trained and they understand the concept of focus, they will engage you out of love- even over food. Thats when they become awesome partners and friends instead of showpieces that must live a restricted life...
hey...my dog name is Storm!! lmao
!!!
Beautiful
Second Dog's engagement feels more like an obsession with you. That feels a bit over the top for me. I prefer a more relaxed dog.
I WANT my dog to be obsessed with me 😉
It’s a lot better than having a dog that doesn’t care about you as a handler at all.
I try to play with her with no “third party motivation” she definitely doesn’t care 😢
Wow, and reminded me of our engagement with God as our source. The Giver and not the gifts. Hebrews 11:6
I need to work on leaving the house and leaving my dog alone at home in the crate.
Just moved to a new place.
OOPS!!! My 4 month old Mal Buddy has been spoiled. I had tons of toys on the floor in my family room...they will all be removed now.
Dog training made simple…