Why did no one think of this idea before! Getting all these different creators together it’s awesome! All the big names working together to make the hobby better. Hope to see more of these videos in the future. Instead of trying to hunt down ten different videos on one topic it’s condensed down into one. Great job Jason and John!
Gotta go with the 40 gallon breeder. Cheap, plenty of stocking options, I can move one myself without popping a hernia, and it doesn't take up a ton of space. Of course, that 50 gallon low-boy might be worth changing my mind over. Made an audible "ooooooo" the first time I saw it. Great video! More of this!
Loved this one, guys!! For those of us constrained by apartment living and/or questionable floors not necessarily being level, I love the 20-long. But after I'd gotten my 45 gallon (36Wx12Lx24H) I wished I'd gone for that 40 breeder instead - way more front-to-back space and not so tall that it's too hard to maintain! I see there are some channels I haven't yet subscribed to! Really enjoyed all the opinions and people. ❤🐟❤
Silly responses from the experts. The best tank size is the roomiest one that houses your favorite type of fishes. For Nano keepers it will be smaller but for the monster fish keepers it has to be 100+ gallons. We saw that in their replies.
One of the hardest questions to answer! Personally I own 8) 20L, 3) 33's, 1) 25, 3) 29's 2) 55's, 1) 75, a 125 and a dozen or so 10's. I agree that water volume makes for better tanks but I'd give the 4' tanks like 33's, 55's and 75's the best score depending on the stocking. For nice aquascapes and nano/small fish definitely a 33 if you have the space. As the size of stock and aquascape increases, it's easy to go up in height. Jason, I would love to have a 50 low as a "coffee table" tank.
_Your swimming pool_ is the best fish tank size. Every other house here in Arizona has a swimming pool but not all of them are in use. I know a plethora of people who have converted their pools into an Aquaponics Farm with fish and everything. It is amazing what can be accomplished here in the Sonoran Desert. Then again, bigger is always going to be better when talking about fish tanks. I know this to be true because I specialize in Nano Tanks, and let me tell you, it is *not* an easy task! But I like a challenge and I think I have successfully set out to prove the community wrong (which I can safely say - mission accomplished). After all, the old adage rings true: _"There's no replacement for displacement."_ This can be applied to a myriad of applications whether they be car motors or fish tanks. In the case of the latter, there is a follow up adage: _"The solution for pollution is dilution."_ Stay classy my friends.
29 gal tank.. WHY ?... Because its the biggest tank that you can move by yourself... if you need to ask for help to pick it up or move it... Then it is to big.
So cool to see how people's choice vary depending on their favourite fish to keep. I would tend to say 30g, because that gives me a degree of versatility, while not getting so big that I can't keep a betta in it.
No Fish tank review? What a great idea tho. Havent heard of some of these creators. Awesome. In my opinion i have to say the 33 galon long is my favorite fish tank.
This was a great format, and nice to see the camaraderie. As I watched, it was fun to see each creator, hearing their perspective and wondering who would be up next. Now I'm convinced I could use a few more tank sizes. ;)
small apartment?? 20 extra tall(24t X 20w X 10d) with a simple finnex stingray 2 and double sponge filters w/ air stones in them. thats what i did and its awesome. huge viewing window at the foot of the bed! Anacharis, cript castro, jungle val. fish? massive endler mania! oh and eco-complete
Great video,,, my choice would be the 33 long , it’s 4 feet long by 12 by 12 Long enough to fit some slightly large fish but no overwhelming to take care of
glad shallow tanks are getting some love. i'm five feet tall with t-rex arms so maintenance can be daunting in taller tanks because, depending on the height of the stand, even on a stepstool i'm armpit deep trying to do maintenance. Running 20 long right now, but since i can just buy a 29 gallon bare and still use all of my same equipment, i think it would be doable since my stand is so low. Also I love that all of my favorite aquatics channels collaborated for this
in the size brackets the best tanks depending how much room you have is a 40 breeder for 3 feet a 75 for 4 feet and a 180 if you have 6. I think John wit KGtropicals is on the right track with a 125 but for a second story it's a bit to big. But with flip aquatics a 480 bigger is better I have an 800 and I love it
In retrospect I definitely wish I went with a 40g breeder over a 29g for my first aquarium. Granted, I love how my 29g looks after 10 months and it has served me well, but I definitely feel the limitations in footprint and accompanying stocking volume compared to a 40g breeder. Edit: Of the tank sizes I own (10g, 29g, 75g), the 75g is unquestionably the best. Great dimensions, excellent stocking options, and very forgiving compared to smaller tanks. The size also makes a great statement piece in a living room.
I would love to have gotten a 40 breeder, or 4, for my fish rack. But as a less than handy person, I'm using a pretty standard heavy duty shelving unit, and it just doesn't have the depth available - the shelves are only 18 inches deep. So of the easily available on Craigslist or Kijiji tank sizes, I'm limited to the 30 gallon or so.
I watched a lot of U-tube videos before I stated my tank. At that time I though 55gal was the best way to go. Wish this video cane out first. 40 gal would have been a better tank.
Just for making this video you have a subscriber. Just got out of the pet store because I needed to be around all these sizes. Then I get to see all my favorite tubers in one video saying which they like best. This was a treat to watch
Missing a couple youtubers I like "Secret History Living in Your Aquarium", Lucas Bretz LRB Aquatics, Jadren Aquatics, and Dan's Fish..... I watch most of these youtuber too. Never miss a video here though. 40 breeder is the clear winner, the upside to a 40 breeder is amazing. Easy to clean lots of surface area. I breed mainly. I even down graded most of my 55s to 40 breeders because of the benefits to a 40 breeder. 20 Longs would be number 2.
Thank you Jason, Joanna and everyone!! This was absolutely awesome!! This is why I love this platform and love supporting all you guys as creators!! The experience and knowledge you all have helps so many people in the hobby especially me!! I don't care what I wonder about I can check you all out and usually find the answers to my questions and if not all you have to do is ask!! Y'all are always willing to help, save us time and money, and show us a better way!! One of the best collaboration videos ever!! I love each and everyone of you guys!! Thank you always from the bottom of my heart and I hope y'all are having a very blessed day!!🙏🌿🐟🌿💚
🤔 i learned… 💡! I would love a 40 gallon breeder tank. Thanks you guys 🐼 really enjoyed this video. Great idea too. I wonder what they all thing about Betta keeping and how would they decorate the betta tank or would they decorated?
The consensus with most experienced aquarists is the 40 breeder. Of course, this depends on the fish you keep and where you live. Since exchanging my tanks for rimless, I have to say my 48g tank (36x18x18) is the perfect size.
As a Newbie I have at my disposal 125gal ( with my Miracle Rescue Group of : 1x Common Pleco 7xBlood Parrots 3xTexas Cichlids 1xFiremouth They are all still with me And they are my Miracle 💕💕💕 Ok The rest of my List : 40gal 55gal 8gal ( glotank) 20gal High 20gal Long 29 gal 4x 2.5 gal (Baby boy betta in one/ Bamboo only in another) 3x 5ga( Swordtail family group in one / GLO tank with Cory Dora's in another?) 1gal with snails( quarantine) 44gal Hexagon with matching Stand( and a beautiful thing it is .I Know how Fortunate I am to have it😎) 1.5 gal hexagon 1.5 gal with snails grow out Have to pick up my 75 gallon 2x 10 gallon I think that's all of them Can someone please help me with all these 💕? How did I get so many in a year time? Many people are extraordinarily generous and have free tanks or sell them very inexpensively Ironically I have very few Fish. Throughout the live chats in the messages you can obviously tell that I have a yearning to be part of not only the fish keeping community but aquatic plant community put them together and what a beautiful thing. 💕💕💕💕
This was a very cool video with all the fishtubers. I would say my favorite is either the 75 or 20. If I had less space, the 20 long or if I had more space, the 75. I like the foot print and the ease of maintaining them. It isn’t expensive to filter or heat them either. Great video!
SUPER FUN!!! Fish Room Fever took us along when he made his video for you and that was Super Fun too! I gotta agree w/The Small Scape on this one, my fav is my 8 gallon but it's a 'Low Boy' 16x16x8. ;)
I find it funny that I already watch over half the creators featured. You all seem like some genuinely great people and it's super cool to see a collaboration like this.
I always heard if your going to do a 10 do a 20. Long.instead. I've had bigger and smaller. I really have been wanting a 20 for a long time. For the type of fish I would like to keep its perfect. 40 longs are nice to.
I'm like John for this one.. I have a 210g so id naturally choose that or a 180g.. but the 125g is a very reasonable tank as he mentioned so thats where id end up if i couldnt do 180g/210 For someone else who wants medium sized fish.. 75g For smaller fish, 20g Long pattern? Footprint.. More space at the bottom the better. Then its just about what kind of fish you want to keep. xD
I love my 40 breeder with a 20 long sump. The foot print is easy to work with, cleaning the glass, etc etc. Water changes are easy and not an excessive amount. Doesn’t take up a lot of wall space. Not expensive to scape. Not super heavy to move if you move. You could do it by yourself and it will fit in pretty much any car. It’s also not crazy heavy when when running, you can run it on another floor. Really versatile. I will go bigger eventually but won’t get rid of it because it’s fun. I think a 75 gallon with a 40b sump would be a runner up if cichlids are the goal.
If the question is, 'If you could only have one fish tank what size would it be'? My response would have to be, Who is laying down this rule? Get that person out of your life, we don't need that sort of negativity.
This was a cool video! I gotta go with the 29 gallon. All the benefits and stocking options of the 20 long, but with some extra height so you can do a top-middle-bottom dwellers thing nicely.
Hum, for a traditional tank my favorite is the 29 gallons. I like it over the 20 long because my favorite plant is Jungle Val. and it is hard to keep up with in a 12 inch tank. For the average person I think the 10 gallon and 55 gallon are the best options. You can walk into just about anywhere and get a full kit. The 10 gallon fits in lots of places and the 55 is a substantial show piece for many people with lots of loadout options. Having said that, my favorite "tank" is a 2.5 gallon glass cookie jar. It is low tech with no filter, no light (indirect sunlight and room lighting) and rare water changes. Just top up about every 6-10 days (depends on the season) and I only feed three times a week (snello and the like). Heavy on plants such as Dwarf Sag, Bacopa, Java Moss and Salvinia. Inhabitants are ramshorns and cherry shrimp. For an office I like things like the Fluval Betta, Spec III, Ebi etc. Pretty much any 3ish gallon kit tank that looks good. So, it just really depends on the situation, for me. It is super interesting to see what everyone chooses and why.
Yes! I like the look of the 20 long tanks, but would always end up with the 29 gallon, because same footprint, and more water volume for my fishies! 🐟🐟🐟
The introduction banner for each speaker is way too small and goes away to soon to be able to read. I still don't know who everyone was. Have to go back for each one and try to read. Great concept however.
I love my 40 gallon breeder tanks but my complaint about them is the bowing. Many complaints about leaking with these tanks. They should put a cross brace on them.
My local aquarium shop has a unique low and wide tank for their stem plants they’re selling, I’ve always wondered the size, thanks to this video, I now know it’s a 50 Lowboy! I love that layout, I will eventually own a 50 Low!
EASY....40g breeder! If a friend or family member asks me what size is a good size to start, can keep a good amount of livestock, and reasonably affordable...I recommend a 40g breeder. You can get a really nice setup done for ~$150-200ish price range. It's a large enough to keep consistent parameters. Lastly, it's a tank you can grow with as a hobbyist. And 50g lowboy is my favorite tank too. :)
omg thanks for this video. I am looking for replacing my 29 gallon to rimless one. 18" is too high ,my fish is not swimming that high and its waste of space, waste of RODI water , extra buckets of water etc. I will buy 22 gallon rimless long
Right on Jason. The series is off to a good start. Love the format. Can't wait for the next one. Nice to see all the fishtubers that I subscribe to in one place. One question: Will all fishtubers post the same video on their channel? or, Do we have to hunt down which fishtuber will be posting the next question in the series?
What a fun video! It is so interesting to hear everyone’s opinion on the perfect tank size. I enjoyed seeing so many different channels represented. Some I follow now and some new ones to look for. Thank you for creating such an enjoyable video.
Ooh I liked this! Neat format can’t wait to see more like this. I don’t do a lot of browsing on TH-cam so this gives me some new channels to check out too!
Loved this video! Great to learn everyone’s personal favs and why. Since I only have two, a 29 and a 10 gallon, I’m going to have to say both! I love one just as much as the other. Maybe someday I’ll venture on to bigger, we shall see. In the meantime I’ll keep enjoying what you and so many other great fish TH-cam educators are teaching and doing!👍🏼❤️
My favorite tank personally is my 33 long that I have had since Feb 2020. I really like 4 foot tanks and its big enough to keep a decent amount of plants and fish, but without being overwhelming to care for. I also really like the 40 long and 40 breeder. I think in the 30-40 gallon size is kind of the sweet spot IMO.
Hey, I love this concept and I was glad to see my girl Joanna included! My favorite size is the 75G…I wish I could have one in each room of my house. My next favorite size would be in that 6 to 8 gallon range for my mini scapes.
Footprint refers to the amount of space it takes up, i.e. length versus width. So, for example, the popular "20 gallon long" is 30 inches long (from one end to the other) and 12 inches wide (from the front to the back). That is the same footprint as a 29 gallon tank, but a 29g is 18 inches tall, whereas a 20g is only 12 inches tall. If you were putting the tank on a bathroom or kitchen counter, or a sturdy shelving unit, they'll take up the same amount of space, but the 29g will give you extra water volume.
I saw, I think it was a 150 that was 60x24x24 or so that looked nice, though I would probably say 180 at 72x24x24. You can always have small fish in a big tank, but it's really hard to have large fish in a small one. But as far as smaller tanks, like a 10g is so small you might as well move up to a 20, and if you are looking at a 20L then you might as well go to a 29.
For 1 tank only deff the 75g. Lots you can do in a tank that size, while being practical, frugal, and artistic. Wow I love this video collaboration 🙂👍🏻
10 Gallon Gang let's gooooo! Cool seeing the compilation all together with other keepers perspectives. 🔥
Just upgraded from a 10 to a 20 high sorry
Yup got 15 10 gallons myself right now.
10 gallons are great and cheap Can't beat that.
💪🙌
Salamander tank next Tanner!!
It shocks me that the tank I suggest is the largest in the group, I would have never guessed ha ha!! This is so much fun!!!
Should have asked Big Rich too. Haha
I'm guessing big Rich would say, the average pool size would would be the best
@@tonilynn1597 🤣🤣🤣
Why did no one think of this idea before! Getting all these different creators together it’s awesome! All the big names working together to make the hobby better. Hope to see more of these videos in the future. Instead of trying to hunt down ten different videos on one topic it’s condensed down into one. Great job Jason and John!
Thanks! I appreciate you being here.
Absolutely awesome 😎👍💪
This is a Beautiful idea ! Can't thank you enough
@@oinkmastersupremeforever ❤️❤️🥰
Is Cory a communist though?
Gotta go with the 40 gallon breeder. Cheap, plenty of stocking options, I can move one myself without popping a hernia, and it doesn't take up a ton of space. Of course, that 50 gallon low-boy might be worth changing my mind over. Made an audible "ooooooo" the first time I saw it.
Great video! More of this!
Agreed. First time hearing of the 50 gal low-boy & it has my attention.
Yay! Thanks for including me! 😀
You the bomb dot com 💥
Loved this one, guys!! For those of us constrained by apartment living and/or questionable floors not necessarily being level, I love the 20-long. But after I'd gotten my 45 gallon (36Wx12Lx24H) I wished I'd gone for that 40 breeder instead - way more front-to-back space and not so tall that it's too hard to maintain! I see there are some channels I haven't yet subscribed to! Really enjoyed all the opinions and people. ❤🐟❤
Ps your comments are disabled it happens to me all the time but I just love your blue betta flaring at the ramshorn😂❤️🥰
Silly responses from the experts. The best tank size is the roomiest one that houses your favorite type of fishes. For Nano keepers it will be smaller but for the monster fish keepers it has to be 100+ gallons. We saw that in their replies.
One of the hardest questions to answer!
Personally I own 8) 20L, 3) 33's, 1) 25, 3) 29's 2) 55's, 1) 75, a 125 and a dozen or so 10's.
I agree that water volume makes for better tanks but I'd give the 4' tanks like 33's, 55's and 75's the best score depending on the stocking.
For nice aquascapes and nano/small fish definitely a 33 if you have the space.
As the size of stock and aquascape increases, it's easy to go up in height.
Jason, I would love to have a 50 low as a "coffee table" tank.
33s are the best.
@@guy8646 I tend to agree.
Really great concept bringing all these folks together! I’m excited to see what else you have planned for this series.
_Your swimming pool_ is the best fish tank size.
Every other house here in Arizona has a swimming pool but not all of them are in use. I know a plethora of people who have converted their pools into an Aquaponics Farm with fish and everything. It is amazing what can be accomplished here in the Sonoran Desert.
Then again, bigger is always going to be better when talking about fish tanks. I know this to be true because I specialize in Nano Tanks, and let me tell you, it is *not* an easy task! But I like a challenge and I think I have successfully set out to prove the community wrong (which I can safely say - mission accomplished).
After all, the old adage rings true: _"There's no replacement for displacement."_ This can be applied to a myriad of applications whether they be car motors or fish tanks. In the case of the latter, there is a follow up adage: _"The solution for pollution is dilution."_
Stay classy my friends.
29 gal tank.. WHY ?... Because its the biggest tank that you can move by yourself... if you need to ask for help to pick it up or move it... Then it is to big.
In my house it's all about the fish! So if it's "one tank only".. I need a 125 for my blood parrots. 🧡🧡
So cool to see how people's choice vary depending on their favourite fish to keep. I would tend to say 30g, because that gives me a degree of versatility, while not getting so big that I can't keep a betta in it.
@@pjp9383 Yeah, reading the comments was loads of fun!
No Fish tank review? What a great idea tho. Havent heard of some of these creators. Awesome. In my opinion i have to say the 33 galon long is my favorite fish tank.
The 33 long is an amazing tank. I just wish they were easier to find in my area.
This was a great format, and nice to see the camaraderie. As I watched, it was fun to see each creator, hearing their perspective and wondering who would be up next. Now I'm convinced I could use a few more tank sizes. ;)
It was fun to work with everyone!
Loving these recommendations! So awesome to see everyone here 🐢
Jamie you did great! So glad you were part of it 🙂
So glad you were part of it!
BRO I LOVE THIS CROSSOVER!!! Not only that but I like how everyone can help each other out in this hobby, help the hobby grow!!!!!
That was the fun part!
small apartment??
20 extra tall(24t X 20w X 10d) with a simple finnex stingray 2 and double sponge filters w/ air stones in them. thats what i did and its awesome.
huge viewing window at the foot of the bed! Anacharis, cript castro, jungle val. fish? massive endler mania! oh and
eco-complete
Great video,,, my choice would be the 33 long , it’s 4 feet long by 12 by 12
Long enough to fit some slightly large fish but no overwhelming to take care of
Love that one too!
glad shallow tanks are getting some love. i'm five feet tall with t-rex arms so maintenance can be daunting in taller tanks because, depending on the height of the stand, even on a stepstool i'm armpit deep trying to do maintenance. Running 20 long right now, but since i can just buy a 29 gallon bare and still use all of my same equipment, i think it would be doable since my stand is so low.
Also I love that all of my favorite aquatics channels collaborated for this
My boy MD-!!! I love this series brilliant!
in the size brackets the best tanks depending how much room you have is a 40 breeder for 3 feet a 75 for 4 feet and a 180 if you have 6. I think John wit KGtropicals is on the right track with a 125 but for a second story it's a bit to big. But with flip aquatics a 480 bigger is better I have an 800 and I love it
I'd say a 125 is the ideal size tank if you're just gonna have 1 tank
In retrospect I definitely wish I went with a 40g breeder over a 29g for my first aquarium. Granted, I love how my 29g looks after 10 months and it has served me well, but I definitely feel the limitations in footprint and accompanying stocking volume compared to a 40g breeder.
Edit: Of the tank sizes I own (10g, 29g, 75g), the 75g is unquestionably the best. Great dimensions, excellent stocking options, and very forgiving compared to smaller tanks. The size also makes a great statement piece in a living room.
I would love to have gotten a 40 breeder, or 4, for my fish rack. But as a less than handy person, I'm using a pretty standard heavy duty shelving unit, and it just doesn't have the depth available - the shelves are only 18 inches deep. So of the easily available on Craigslist or Kijiji tank sizes, I'm limited to the 30 gallon or so.
I watched a lot of U-tube videos before I stated my tank. At that time I though 55gal was the best way to go. Wish this video cane out first. 40 gal would have been a better tank.
Just for making this video you have a subscriber. Just got out of the pet store because I needed to be around all these sizes. Then I get to see all my favorite tubers in one video saying which they like best. This was a treat to watch
Glad you are here!
Missing a couple youtubers I like "Secret History Living in Your Aquarium", Lucas Bretz LRB Aquatics, Jadren Aquatics, and Dan's Fish..... I watch most of these youtuber too. Never miss a video here though. 40 breeder is the clear winner, the upside to a 40 breeder is amazing. Easy to clean lots of surface area. I breed mainly. I even down graded most of my 55s to 40 breeders because of the benefits to a 40 breeder. 20 Longs would be number 2.
Great creators!! Maybe that could be a part 2 🤔🙌💪❤️
I imagine the group will grow 😀
Could definitely use a little bit of Rachael O' Leary and some Pecktec in there.
If we're suggesting names, Quebec Cichlids, Fishman and Fish For Thought are a few from the Canadian contingent. 🙂
@@johnnygee4206 oh yes👍🙌
40 gallon breeder! I like that I don't have to stick my WHOLE arm in it to clean or scape like my 55s lol.
Thank you Jason, Joanna and everyone!! This was absolutely awesome!! This is why I love this platform and love supporting all you guys as creators!! The experience and knowledge you all have helps so many people in the hobby especially me!! I don't care what I wonder about I can check you all out and usually find the answers to my questions and if not all you have to do is ask!! Y'all are always willing to help, save us time and money, and show us a better way!!
One of the best collaboration videos ever!! I love each and everyone of you guys!! Thank you always from the bottom of my heart and I hope y'all are having a very blessed day!!🙏🌿🐟🌿💚
I really like the 20 gallon longs if I could pick any size tanks for future Fish room 💚
Thank you so much for being here!
🤔 i learned… 💡! I would love a 40 gallon breeder tank. Thanks you guys 🐼 really enjoyed this video. Great idea too. I wonder what they all thing about Betta keeping and how would they decorate the betta tank or would they decorated?
As large as will fit in your house. End of discussion.
The consensus with most experienced aquarists is the 40 breeder. Of course, this depends on the fish you keep and where you live. Since exchanging my tanks for rimless, I have to say my 48g tank (36x18x18) is the perfect size.
I am surprised that so many people chose the 20 long instead of the 29 gallon. Once I replaced my 20 long with a 29 gallon I had no regrets.
29 gallons is my favourite 👍🏻
LOVE this format! That was really fun! My favorite is definitely the 40g breeder. Just love it!
As a Newbie I have at my disposal
125gal
( with my Miracle Rescue Group of :
1x Common Pleco
7xBlood Parrots
3xTexas Cichlids
1xFiremouth
They are all still with me
And they are my Miracle 💕💕💕
Ok
The rest of my List :
40gal
55gal
8gal ( glotank)
20gal High
20gal Long
29 gal
4x 2.5 gal
(Baby boy betta in one/ Bamboo only in another)
3x 5ga( Swordtail family group in one / GLO tank with Cory Dora's in another?)
1gal with snails( quarantine)
44gal Hexagon with matching Stand( and a beautiful thing it is .I Know how Fortunate I am to have it😎)
1.5 gal hexagon
1.5 gal with snails grow out
Have to pick up my 75 gallon
2x 10 gallon
I think that's all of them
Can someone please help me with all these 💕?
How did I get so many in a year time? Many people are extraordinarily generous and have free tanks or sell them very inexpensively
Ironically I have very few Fish. Throughout the live chats in the messages you can obviously tell that I have a yearning to be part of not only the fish keeping community but aquatic plant community put them together and what a beautiful thing. 💕💕💕💕
That is a growing list. Haha
My absolute favorite is the 125 gallon, closely followed by a 75 gallon and a 33 gallon long.
Ditto!
Love all of them!
Love this! All my favourite fishtubers in the one place and some new ones to investigate...bliss!
My favourite is 55 gallon
I'd have to go with either a 40g breeder or 75g.
This was a beautiful video enjoyed it 40 breeder sounds like my next tank
You won't regret it.
This is such a nice video!!
This intrudes people to so many talented individuals! THANK YOU!
This was a very cool video with all the fishtubers. I would say my favorite is either the 75 or 20. If I had less space, the 20 long or if I had more space, the 75. I like the foot print and the ease of maintaining them. It isn’t expensive to filter or heat them either. Great video!
GREAT SERIES! SO Excited for the rest of the videos. It feels like a new era of fish tube....
Me too!
SUPER FUN!!! Fish Room Fever took us along when he made his video for you and that was Super Fun too! I gotta agree w/The Small Scape on this one, my fav is my 8 gallon but it's a 'Low Boy' 16x16x8. ;)
That’s cool!
20 gallon high nano, 40 gallon breeder for big tank, I live in a small apartment
Gotta agree with John here! ^^
Shoot. Nobody even mentioned a 29 or 30 gallon tank. :-(
That's ok, you can still like them :-)
I find it funny that I already watch over half the creators featured. You all seem like some genuinely great people and it's super cool to see a collaboration like this.
Thank you!
I always heard if your going to do a 10 do a 20. Long.instead. I've had bigger and smaller. I really have been wanting a 20 for a long time. For the type of fish I would like to keep its perfect. 40 longs are nice to.
So many excellent informed options, but I still can’t make my mind up. Would be great to have the space (and money) for at least one off every size 😃
Someday🙌❤️🌿🐟💚
Yes that would be amazing 🤗
I'm like John for this one.. I have a 210g so id naturally choose that or a 180g.. but the 125g is a very reasonable tank as he mentioned so thats where id end up if i couldnt do 180g/210
For someone else who wants medium sized fish.. 75g
For smaller fish, 20g Long
pattern? Footprint.. More space at the bottom the better. Then its just about what kind of fish you want to keep. xD
With you guys doing this are you gonna do a fish keeper family feud with all the info 😎
Now that would be cool!
I love my 40 breeder with a 20 long sump.
The foot print is easy to work with, cleaning the glass, etc etc. Water changes are easy and not an excessive amount. Doesn’t take up a lot of wall space. Not expensive to scape. Not super heavy to move if you move. You could do it by yourself and it will fit in pretty much any car. It’s also not crazy heavy when when running, you can run it on another floor. Really versatile. I will go bigger eventually but won’t get rid of it because it’s fun.
I think a 75 gallon with a 40b sump
would be a runner up if cichlids are the goal.
Love the mega collab, I have 4 40 breeders so I guess it’s my go to
Great video each tank size has its pros and cons
If the question is, 'If you could only have one fish tank what size would it be'? My response would have to be, Who is laying down this rule? Get that person out of your life, we don't need that sort of negativity.
😆😂🤣
Excellent response!
Yeah, we don't have to take this! No limits!!!
Holy cow - I’m in tears!! 😂🤣
You guys and gals did awesome 🙂 love hearing everyone's ideas.
Thanks Lisa!
I love this collaboration video!!!
40 breeder ftw
This was a cool video! I gotta go with the 29 gallon. All the benefits and stocking options of the 20 long, but with some extra height so you can do a top-middle-bottom dwellers thing nicely.
Hum, for a traditional tank my favorite is the 29 gallons. I like it over the 20 long because my favorite plant is Jungle Val. and it is hard to keep up with in a 12 inch tank. For the average person I think the 10 gallon and 55 gallon are the best options. You can walk into just about anywhere and get a full kit. The 10 gallon fits in lots of places and the 55 is a substantial show piece for many people with lots of loadout options.
Having said that, my favorite "tank" is a 2.5 gallon glass cookie jar. It is low tech with no filter, no light (indirect sunlight and room lighting) and rare water changes. Just top up about every 6-10 days (depends on the season) and I only feed three times a week (snello and the like). Heavy on plants such as Dwarf Sag, Bacopa, Java Moss and Salvinia. Inhabitants are ramshorns and cherry shrimp.
For an office I like things like the Fluval Betta, Spec III, Ebi etc. Pretty much any 3ish gallon kit tank that looks good.
So, it just really depends on the situation, for me. It is super interesting to see what everyone chooses and why.
My favorite is the 29 gallon. Good size yet small enough to squeeze into tight spots.
Yes! I like the look of the 20 long tanks, but would always end up with the 29 gallon, because same footprint, and more water volume for my fishies! 🐟🐟🐟
The introduction banner for each speaker is way too small and goes away to soon to be able to read. I still don't know who everyone was. Have to go back for each one and try to read. Great concept however.
All their info is posted in the description as well.
I'm the blue haired guy 😂
Cool concept Jason! I subscribe to a bunch of this group. I’m agree with John. 125G is the winner. I also love the 75G. For a small tank 20 long
I love my 40 gallon breeder tanks but my complaint about them is the bowing. Many complaints about leaking with these tanks. They should put a cross brace on them.
My local aquarium shop has a unique low and wide tank for their stem plants they’re selling, I’ve always wondered the size, thanks to this video, I now know it’s a 50 Lowboy!
I love that layout, I will eventually own a 50 Low!
EASY....40g breeder! If a friend or family member asks me what size is a good size to start, can keep a good amount of livestock, and reasonably affordable...I recommend a 40g breeder. You can get a really nice setup done for ~$150-200ish price range. It's a large enough to keep consistent parameters. Lastly, it's a tank you can grow with as a hobbyist.
And 50g lowboy is my favorite tank too. :)
omg thanks for this video. I am looking for replacing my 29 gallon to rimless one. 18" is too high ,my fish is not swimming that high and its waste of space, waste of RODI water , extra buckets of water etc. I will buy 22 gallon rimless long
90x55x55 cms for me..anything 90cm long is perfect for a 1 tank only setup..
Right on Jason. The series is off to a good start. Love the format. Can't wait for the next one. Nice to see all the fishtubers that I subscribe to in one place. One question: Will all fishtubers post the same video on their channel? or, Do we have to hunt down which fishtuber will be posting the next question in the series?
I will share the videos that get posted if they are not on our channel so you don’t miss out.
Love this video! "I know her channel!" "I know his channel!" It's like an All-Stars game
I have 4 10 gallons. They're light. They're small enough to fit in random places
What a fun video! It is so interesting to hear everyone’s opinion on the perfect tank size. I enjoyed seeing so many different channels represented. Some I follow now and some new ones to look for.
Thank you for creating such an enjoyable video.
I've had a 40 for a few years now. Excited to upgrade to a 75!
Ooh I liked this! Neat format can’t wait to see more like this. I don’t do a lot of browsing on TH-cam so this gives me some new channels to check out too!
Definitely check them out and be on the lookout for more videos like this to come.
For me it would be the 125 gallon tank ,I would be starting in 2022 from a 55 gal wish me luck thanks
great little project :)
40 gallon breeder sounds like an excellent 👌🏼 idea.
Loved this video! Great to learn everyone’s personal favs and why. Since I only have two, a 29 and a 10 gallon, I’m going to have to say both! I love one just as much as the other. Maybe someday I’ll venture on to bigger, we shall see. In the meantime I’ll keep enjoying what you and so many other great fish TH-cam educators are teaching and doing!👍🏼❤️
Anyone like the 53gallon? I think its like a 40 breeder but taller? It looks amazing when you see it it really stands out
My favorite tank personally is my 33 long that I have had since Feb 2020. I really like 4 foot tanks and its big enough to keep a decent amount of plants and fish, but without being overwhelming to care for. I also really like the 40 long and 40 breeder. I think in the 30-40 gallon size is kind of the sweet spot IMO.
Love the 33 longs!
All Wrong!
Answer: Whatever can for through GD door! 😅
For me I like 75 or 100gal.
I have had a 70gal.tall and I always wished it was a bit wider.
IT AINT NUTHIN BUT A 40 GALLON GANGSTA PARTY...PARTY...PARTY!!!🤣🤣🤣
Excellent!! Thank you all so much. This series is going to be fun and educational. That's the best 😊
Glad you enjoyed it!
wheres cory from aquarium co-op?
We’re always looking to add people who want to contribute. 😀
Hey, I love this concept and I was glad to see my girl Joanna included! My favorite size is the 75G…I wish I could have one in each room of my house. My next favorite size would be in that 6 to 8 gallon range for my mini scapes.
20 long or a 30.best for beginners.best for me is 75.bcs it has space to create anything.
i agree with joey, mark and john that bigger is better, and not only because their the only ones on this list i actually watch
My boy MD is the same circle as my other fav FishTubers!!! 👍
we got it, u have the monster 480g omg, now speak about for a normal life
What does “footprint” means in this context? I’m not a native speaker
Footprint refers to the amount of space it takes up, i.e. length versus width. So, for example, the popular "20 gallon long" is 30 inches long (from one end to the other) and 12 inches wide (from the front to the back). That is the same footprint as a 29 gallon tank, but a 29g is 18 inches tall, whereas a 20g is only 12 inches tall. If you were putting the tank on a bathroom or kitchen counter, or a sturdy shelving unit, they'll take up the same amount of space, but the 29g will give you extra water volume.
@@pjp9383 thank you so much!
@@Lina_729 You're welcome!
40 breeder, full stop accept no substitutes
Great tank!
Agreed 👍
Where's my 40g breeder crew at? It's such a pleasure to be not only a part of this video but also this community series. Thanks again!
Glad you were part of it!
Ahhh ALL MY FAVORITE PEOPLE IN ONE VIDEO!!! 🤩🤩🤩
Anyone know were to gat the 8 gallon or have a link???
i loved this video and it was brilliant to see md fish tanks made my day
I saw, I think it was a 150 that was 60x24x24 or so that looked nice, though I would probably say 180 at 72x24x24. You can always have small fish in a big tank, but it's really hard to have large fish in a small one. But as far as smaller tanks, like a 10g is so small you might as well move up to a 20, and if you are looking at a 20L then you might as well go to a 29.
Both are cool!
For 1 tank only deff the 75g. Lots you can do in a tank that size, while being practical, frugal, and artistic. Wow I love this video collaboration 🙂👍🏻
I agree 75 is the way to go
I have a 60, so sorry I didn't go for the 75