Both are good paints, but the schmincke rewet more easily. WN always take more scrubbing to get the same amount of intense colour. Both your paintings are wonderful!
I actually recently got my first "real" set of watercolours, and was choosing between these two. So happy I went with the Schmincke; this just confirmed I made the right decision! :)
Schminche are so intense and have incomparable earth tone. However, there is a brightness to Windsor Newtons that I really like also. So I’m using both together. Why not ?
I loved your butterflies and I personally liked the Schmincke one better. I am a big fan of Daniel Smith Watercolors but I think it’s good to use othe brands for different colours. 😍
Thankyou so much for this comparison. I really needed to see this. I am really up for trying Schmincke and also St Petersburg White nights. I am all about the pigment .
Now that W+N is foreign owned, its Artist watercolours are made in France and Cotman paints in China, they are no longer the same company they once were. They have not kept up with their competition. But, by slipping down market, perhaps they will become more affordable? I haven't tried Schminke or Sennelier or Old Holland or Holbein Rembrandt series but I really like Daniel Smith tube paints and use it to refill old W+N pans; much cheaper if you buy in or near Seattle, USA too ;) Daler Rowney Artists grade paints can be very good value, I really like this historic English brand that is often overlooked. For student grade paints, I liked Cotman and Holbein Van Gogh well enough but wonder if Cotman is deteriorating, for example the Ultramarine and Cobalt blue seem more alike now than in the past, like different strengths of the same colour - and both seem weaker than they used to be. Blues are really important to me, so that is quite worrying - with its many blues, perhaps Schminke is the way forward ;). The Cotman Pthalo blue is very good though and could perhaps replace the now insipid Cobalt Blue, which used to be my favourite/ most used Cotman colour.
Thank you for this well-thought out and super interesting comment! I wasn't aware of a lot of those things. I'd really love to try out the Daniel Smith watercolours at some point - I keep hearing good things about them, & I'll try to make more comparison videos in the future. Thank you for taking the time to write this, it's been insightful for me and no doubt will be to others also.
Thanks for the video! I you were to recommend one set of 24/36 (I’ve found both brands online in the same price) - would it be Rembrandt or Schmincke? 😊
Hiii, I've just seen this comment - so sorry it's a late reply, I can't remember where I got it, possibly 'Cass Art' or 'ArtDiscount', it's a Winsor & Newton cotman brush. 🌻✨
Windsor and Newton cause Schmincke cannot beat that transparency!! But I love both brands for different uses Windsor and Newton are the best for botanical art and landscapes! And Schmincke for portraits and urban sketching!
Iam new subscriber Arabic lady citizen thank you for learning us to paint both adults and kids iwish for your channel more success and progress stay safe blessed
You should do an entire painting wearing *3D red and blue glasses.* Why? To see how well you mix the values and paint hahaha 😂 😂 😂 Just a fun funny freestyle experiment 🍪💋😘
Allanah Claire Art 😊❤️Awww thank you for loving my idea. I'll be waiting impatiently to see it. I bet it'll be so funny to watch, everyone will watch it over and over again woohooooo 🤪😁😃💜❤️💛
Heyy Kyomii, I definitely prefer how the Winsor & Newton watercolour butterfly looks... I don't know if it was because of technique or not though? Either way - You're right! They are both really good paint sets. I love them both 😍 💖 🦋 Xx
I prefer the one produced more pigment because it allows for more control to remove, and get more coverage in less strokes. Quality is always better versus quantity. If art is your passion, it's worth investing in high quality products and best brushes. Cheap material and paints will just cause more of a headache to get same effect that might take you two strokes worth good quality paints. Hope this makes sense. I bought an iPad mini 5 and apple pencil because no other stylus matches the apple pencil in realistic pencil work. Lani, your still the prettiest girl artist I know on TH-cam 😍❤❤❤ Never seen a beautiful girl whose art skill matches her beautiful smile 😚🌹💕
Windsor and newton are NOT low quality. They just dont whave quite as much pigment as schminke. But they are WAY cheaper. So for someone whos not a professional painter, the W&N is probably better
Hi there my sweet friend Alannah Claire! Hope all is well with you in your part of the world, and that life is treating you kindly! Was just thinking of you, wondering if we were going to have wait months for you to drop some more of your sweet and magical videos. BUT NOPE, WE HAVE A BRAND NEW ONE! YAYYYYYYYYYY! Thank you so much for this video my sweet friend Alannah! Please take good care of yourself my friend. 🖒🖒😉😃❤⚘Stay safe, stay well EVERYONE!Much love, your friend The Lone Wolf of Indiana 🐺🌵🇺🇸💖
Hi allanah, you're so great artist. Hmm this is just my idea, maybe you can make a video about tips on painting with watercolors or 'huge art supplies haul' video (?) I want to learn a lot from you.. Keep spirit, Allanah! * sorry for the bad english :(
Hi Ainn_, your English is perfect! Don't be sorry 💖 I will try to make some videos like the ones you asked for. Thank you for your lovely comment, & good luck on your art journey, keep up the hard work! 😁💛🌻🎨 Xx
Allanah Claire Art 💙 *Going watch it tomorrow.* We can watch it together haha! Bring some sweet cotton candy bibble and some soda pop, and I'll make us a home made pizza 🍕 for our movie night Lani. AVATAR ALL THE WAY YAYYY!🦋🦋🦋💙💙💙💙🦋🦋🦋
Winsor & Newton paints have deteriorated? In which way? What’s different now? I have been using Horadam and now I have discovered WN Professional Watercolours. I like that they offer tubes of 37 ml and more transparent colours.
Hello I would like to ask you if you could make Lou from uglydolls the movie I wanted to see how the person would turn out heh and if you could do it your next video thanks
Link to my Etsy store:- www.etsy.com/uk/shop/PrincessOfPainting?ref=search_shop_redirect
Both are good paints, but the schmincke rewet more easily. WN always take more scrubbing to get the same amount of intense colour. Both your paintings are wonderful!
I work with Schmincke Horadam and W&N professional line and i find both equally very good in quality! 👏
I actually recently got my first "real" set of watercolours, and was choosing between these two. So happy I went with the Schmincke; this just confirmed I made the right decision! :)
That's so exciting!! I hope you enjoy your new paints, they are great to work with. I love them 💞🌻✨
@@AllanahClaireArt I love mine too!
Schminche are so intense and have incomparable earth tone. However, there is a brightness to Windsor Newtons that I really like also. So I’m using both together. Why not ?
I loved your butterflies and I personally liked the Schmincke one better. I am a big fan of Daniel Smith Watercolors but I think it’s good to use othe brands for different colours. 😍
🦋🦋 Hiii Maureen! I've never tried Daniel Smith watercolours - I'll have to find some to try out at some point! Thank you for your lovely comment 💖 Xx
Thankyou so much for this comparison. I really needed to see this. I am really up for trying Schmincke and also St Petersburg White nights. I am all about the pigment .
Now that W+N is foreign owned, its Artist watercolours are made in France and Cotman paints in China, they are no longer the same company they once were. They have not kept up with their competition. But, by slipping down market, perhaps they will become more affordable?
I haven't tried Schminke or Sennelier or Old Holland or Holbein Rembrandt series but I really like Daniel Smith tube paints and use it to refill old W+N pans; much cheaper if you buy in or near Seattle, USA too ;) Daler Rowney Artists grade paints can be very good value, I really like this historic English brand that is often overlooked.
For student grade paints, I liked Cotman and Holbein Van Gogh well enough but wonder if Cotman is deteriorating, for example the Ultramarine and Cobalt blue seem more alike now than in the past, like different strengths of the same colour - and both seem weaker than they used to be. Blues are really important to me, so that is quite worrying - with its many blues, perhaps Schminke is the way forward ;). The Cotman Pthalo blue is very good though and could perhaps replace the now insipid Cobalt Blue, which used to be my favourite/ most used Cotman colour.
Thank you for this well-thought out and super interesting comment! I wasn't aware of a lot of those things. I'd really love to try out the Daniel Smith watercolours at some point - I keep hearing good things about them, & I'll try to make more comparison videos in the future.
Thank you for taking the time to write this, it's been insightful for me and no doubt will be to others also.
Which paper did you use?
Thanks for the video! I you were to recommend one set of 24/36 (I’ve found both brands online in the same price) - would it be Rembrandt or Schmincke? 😊
Where did you get that super tiny brush you used for detail on the butterfly?
Hiii, I've just seen this comment - so sorry it's a late reply, I can't remember where I got it, possibly 'Cass Art' or 'ArtDiscount', it's a Winsor & Newton cotman brush. 🌻✨
Have you tried the mission gold paints? Love both of these paintings but prefer the Schmicke one the best. x
schmincke.. hands down winner... either Scmincke or Daniel Smith.. no need to buy anything else!
Windsor and Newton cause Schmincke cannot beat that transparency!! But I love both brands for different uses Windsor and Newton are the best for botanical art and landscapes! And Schmincke for portraits and urban sketching!
Iam new subscriber Arabic lady citizen thank you for learning us to paint both adults and kids iwish for your channel more success and progress stay safe blessed
I miss you I'm so happy you Back I just in love with your Account 🦋
Thank you! It's so nice to be back.🦋
My next vid is a super long one... 💖 Hopefully it'll be finished & uploaded soon! Xx
I just spontaneous bought a 48 set of schmincke ahaha. Poor for the rest of the month now🤣
💖Art supplies always get me like that too... They are so expensive, haha. These will last you years though, it's worth it! 👏Xx
You should do an entire painting wearing *3D red and blue glasses.* Why? To see how well you mix the values and paint hahaha 😂 😂 😂 Just a fun funny freestyle experiment 🍪💋😘
I LOVE that idea!! 💖 Xx
Allanah Claire Art 😊❤️Awww thank you for loving my idea. I'll be waiting impatiently to see it. I bet it'll be so funny to watch, everyone will watch it over and over again woohooooo 🤪😁😃💜❤️💛
The Winsor and Newton one is definitely more luminous but both are good paints.
Heyy Kyomii, I definitely prefer how the Winsor & Newton watercolour butterfly looks... I don't know if it was because of technique or not though? Either way - You're right! They are both really good paint sets. I love them both 😍 💖 🦋 Xx
I prefer the one produced more pigment because it allows for more control to remove, and get more coverage in less strokes. Quality is always better versus quantity. If art is your passion, it's worth investing in high quality products and best brushes. Cheap material and paints will just cause more of a headache to get same effect that might take you two strokes worth good quality paints. Hope this makes sense. I bought an iPad mini 5 and apple pencil because no other stylus matches the apple pencil in realistic pencil work.
Lani, your still the prettiest girl artist I know on TH-cam 😍❤❤❤ Never seen a beautiful girl whose art skill matches her beautiful smile 😚🌹💕
Windsor and newton are NOT low quality. They just dont whave quite as much pigment as schminke. But they are WAY cheaper. So for someone whos not a professional painter, the W&N is probably better
Hi there my sweet friend Alannah Claire! Hope all is well with you in your part of the world, and that life is treating you kindly! Was just thinking of you, wondering if we were going to have wait months for you to drop some more of your sweet and magical videos. BUT NOPE, WE HAVE A BRAND NEW ONE! YAYYYYYYYYYY! Thank you so much for this video my sweet friend Alannah! Please take good care of yourself my friend. 🖒🖒😉😃❤⚘Stay safe, stay well EVERYONE!Much love, your friend The Lone Wolf of Indiana 🐺🌵🇺🇸💖
Hey Allen! Thank you for this very sweet message! I hope you've been okay, it's always so lovely to see you! 🦋💖 Xx
Love your art and your voice by the way~❤️
Thank you Sammie!! 💖🦋Xx
I miss your drawing😊
Hi allanah, you're so great artist.
Hmm this is just my idea, maybe you can make a video about tips on painting with watercolors or 'huge art supplies haul' video (?) I want to learn a lot from you..
Keep spirit, Allanah!
* sorry for the bad english :(
Hi Ainn_, your English is perfect! Don't be sorry 💖 I will try to make some videos like the ones you asked for. Thank you for your lovely comment, & good luck on your art journey, keep up the hard work! 😁💛🌻🎨 Xx
😍
Love ur art
Thank you so much!! 💖 🦋 Xx
I would say shes lovely but her art is even more lovlier, so i cnt decide whom I would choose 😣
Nice artwork!!
Thank you!! 💖🦋Xx
10:54 You make a pretty avatar. Hope you saw the Avatar movie to know what I mean haha 🦋💙🦋
Haha!! Yes, that movie is so so beautiful, you've made me want to watch it again... 💙🦋Xx
Allanah Claire Art 🥶🥶🥶
Allanah Claire Art 💙 *Going watch it tomorrow.* We can watch it together haha! Bring some sweet cotton candy bibble and some soda pop, and I'll make us a home made pizza 🍕 for our movie night Lani. AVATAR ALL THE WAY YAYYY!🦋🦋🦋💙💙💙💙🦋🦋🦋
Pintas bonito y tienes una letra preciosa, thank you
They get very juicy if you put a lot of water on them that's why.
I'm also with Schmincke .... sorry W&N your days are over
No
Winsor & Newton paints have deteriorated? In which way? What’s different now? I have been using Horadam and now I have discovered WN Professional Watercolours. I like that they offer tubes of 37 ml and more transparent colours.
seni ozledim😍
Ben de seni özledim, bu videoyu izlediğiniz için teşekkür ederim. İyi günler 💖🦋Xx
@@AllanahClaireArt turk'cen benden guzel! seni izlemeye doyamiyorum , burda senin gibi guzeli yok!
او الرسم حلو كثير استمري يا مبدعه
بس انا مابعرف الغه
Beautiful
Thank you!! 💖🦋Xx
Schmincke all the way!
Hello I would like to ask you if you could make Lou from uglydolls the movie I wanted to see how the person would turn out heh and if you could do it your next video thanks
JESUS loves you and so do i!