Interesting Vlog especially showing the North African Arabic and Islamic influence on Andalousia Civilization but I wished to see the Carthaginian influence in Spanish History as well or the Iberian peninsula because it was among the oldest in the region before Romans and some people say the Spain name has Carthaginian root and none talked about it.
Le mot Espagne est Ibérique et le mot Hispania c'etai a l'époque Romaine Hispania cet les GRECS qui ont donné le nom de HISPANIA a la péninsule IBÉRIQUE Et la seul chose de musulman , cet quelques constructions. Les influences nord africains ou Carthaginois!! il y a pas .les influences et civilisations sont bien Espagnoles latino comme les Français et Italiens de culture judeo Chrétiens et pas arabes ou africains arrête de prendre vos désir pour des réalités. L'Espagne cet l'occident Chrétien VOUS DONNÉ DES FAUSSE INFORMATION !!! Dites moi qu'elle influence Carthaginoise il y a en Espagne ?? Dites moi les influences du nord de l'Afrique en Espagne Je vous fais savoir que il y a trois niveaux d'influence 1- influence de individu - 2 - un Groupe , 3 - et Organisation J'attends votre réponse concernant les influences nord Africaine et Carthaginois sur l'Espagne ????😊
@@20CamelsEmily Attention avec les informations que vous recevez. Ne croyez pas tout de ce que ont vous dit . Renseigne vous bien avant de croire quelque chose. Consejo de un Ibérico SALUDOS ✋
I hope someday you create a video reflecting on your past, sharing how much you've discovered through your travels around the world. It would be fascinating to hear about the clichés that were shattered along the way and your evolved perspective on the world.
The story behind curtains according to some sources is one of profound sadness and emotional resilience... During the period of the Spanish Inquisition, certain oppressive practices were employed to monitor and control the lives of the Moors who had been forced to convert to Christianity (Moresques). One such measure was requiring these families to keep their doors open during certain hours of the day, so some Moors found other ways to comply with the open-door policy while preserving a degree of privacy. Instead of leaving their homes entirely exposed, they often used curtains or drapes in place of doors. These curtains allowed for airflow and a semblance of compliance with the authorities' demands, while also providing a minimal shield from the eyes of inquisitors and neighbors. Over time This necessity evolves to a tradition in some villages in spain and also in many old cities in Morocco where Moors sought refuge...
It is truly heartbreaking story which resonates deeply because it reminds us of the shared humanity that transcends borders and faiths. 🥲 These were families who had lived in Spain for generations (some for centuries) only to be cast out of the their houses built by their hands. The Moriscos carried their traditions and memories with them into exile enriching Morocco and other places and I can confirm in Moroccan homes, especially in traditional riads or rural areas, doorway curtains are still commonly used
Vous raconté n'importe quoi Premièrement les musulmans n'ont jamais était victimes de l'inquisition Cet des mensonges. L'inquisition c'etai pour les gens qui pratiquent de la sorcellerie et les mauvais Chrétiens. Sources Wikipédia. Et ils ont jamais obligé les musulmans a laissé leurs porte ouvertes, cet vraiment des conneries Il y a pas plus menteurs que vous dans les documentaires. 80 % de vos commentaires sont des mensonges, ont comprend pourquoi ont peut pas vous faire confiance,vous êtes des spécialistes de la Taqiyya même entre vous 🤡🤣🤣🤣
A salut from a Tunisian with andalusian roots, who's surnam, with the suffixe "oun", recalls the old castilian language that used to add this "oun" to give more importance to some family's social status... Like "Ibn Zeidoun" or "Ibn Khaldoun" and so on...
building under the side of the rock was for security purposes , same for the narrow streets in the old Medina they build very close to each so the neighbors could protect each other in case of invasion or bandit attacks .PS: the water baths(ronda part) are for horses to drink it's also very common in germany ,switzerland, austria ,belgium and netherland you can even find them to this days
Ahh, protection. I didn’t think of that, but it makes a lot of sense. As for the water baths, I’ve seen public fountains like the one next to the bath in Tunisia where its purpose is to provide free water to travelers, so I thought it was the same idea. Maybe it is the same concept I just misinterpreted the bath part. Thank you for sharing! 🙏🏼
and for the water fountain , its done in all arabic countries including Tunisia ( but now most of them were demolished ) this was used for their horses to drink and to let near the entrance of the medina or city
Great video, you answered many questions I had regarding Andalusia Spain. Great foot work camera shot of the Flamingo dance. I will keep you in mind for the Sally App when I am traveling. Dave from Los Angeles. Cheers
Heureusement que l'ignorance ne tue pas 🤣 La paella vient de la langue Castellane , ça n'a rien de arabe arrêté de dire n'importe quoi. Nous espagnols ont est habitué a vos mensonges concernant notre péninsule IBÉRIQUE , vous devenus des professionnels en mensonges en voulant vous attribué les savoirs des Espagnols. Vous êtes des vrais Hypocrites et surtout des 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@igorjeesorry but no , paella is the leftover of the food thats why its mixed with chicken , beaf and seafood, and vegetables.. its a mixture of the leftover, it was the food of the poor in the andalus .
there s a small city in south portugal called " tunez " , south europe area wasn't under just islamic ruling , it was under carthage empire... that's why is not weird that you find cultures near to tunisia's culture like in malta even the language is near to tunisian dialect
@20CamelsEmily yes, Carthaginians they were good traders and sailors, they used that and they did settlements in most of southern Europe and north africa ... And lately I see a report that they reach south America continent - to facilitate their trades . There's many cities in southern Europe established by Carthaginians....
A Good thanks the glorious Reconquista i liberate my country of Muslim invasion today only remain ruins and monuments of old buried and desintegrated past.
@@20CamelsEmilyIn Islam, if food directly touches pork or is cooked with it (e.g., in the same oil or pan without being washed), it is generally considered haram because of cross-contamination. The food absorbs the impurity, making it impermissible to eat. In this case removing the ham doesn't matter - the food remains haram anyway. :)
Andalusia is a complete civilization It brought together the inhabitants of North Africa, Turkey and Spain under a single emirate Known as the Islamic Caliphate But it is different and open from any other caliphate
Les habitants de Al Andalus étaient a majorité Hispanic très peux de nord africains et il y avait pas de Turque, les turque n'ont jamais mis les pieds dans la péninsule IBÉRIQUE arrêté de dire des mensonges Vous êtes fatigant vous avez des très grande grande bouche 👄
Wow so amazing since you're in Spain There is famous spanish family called " Romero family" who are actually called Moriscos There ancestors were Muslims but they didn't know until around 50 years ago when they actually converted to Islam and then their grandma saw them and she told them she saw her grandma pray like that way " Muslim's pray " It's really tragedy story for them after that the whole family were interested in history studies and they actually discovered a lot of Andalusia and they have difficulty with the current government of Spain they want to take that historical papers I wish you do a interview for them their Library is becoming a tourist spot This is a vlog of some TH-camr who went to their Library th-cam.com/video/FsjVQ6YmYV8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=EnWfGecqKFQe9p6z It's an Arabic I wish Gazy can get their location
@@20CamelsEmily You're much welcome I edited the comment and I put a link of a TH-camr who visited their historical Library, I wish one day I'm going to visit them too 😩♥️
@@20CamelsEmily It is not like one family is morisco. Most Spanish outside of the northernmost territories has Amazigh and Jewish roots. Cca 60% of Spain was Christian (of Basque/Iberian-Celtic-Roman-Visgothic stock), 30% Muslim (maybe 95% Amazigh, 5% Arab) and 10% Jewish, many left and were expulsed, but as many converted and stayed. So today, the average Spaniard is mostly pre-Islam with 10-30% Islamic time admixture. Basques and others in the north of course have the least amount.
Some amazigh keep saying it is not Arabic culture but amaziegh , can any amaziegh tell us any building built before the Arabs came with amaziegh language. Even Phoenician came originally from Lebanon
All you ve seen is moroccan not especially arab . It s amazigh moroccan culture and structures the same as moroccans .the relics of moroccans who lived there 800 years 🇲🇦🇪🇦 .and still know spain is full of moroccans and spanish from moroccan roots
What do you mean by “Alhambra was the last place to fall when the Christians REtook Spain”?!!! There was no Spain for them to retake! That’s the history written by Christians!
@@20CamelsEmily In Islam, if food directly touches pork or is cooked with it (e.g., in the same oil or pan without being washed), it is generally considered haram because of cross-contamination. The food absorbs the impurity, making it impermissible to eat. In this case removing the ham doesn't matter - the food remains haram anyway. :)
There is nothing Arab, no dress, no dancing, no architecture, next time you should look for the original, which is only Morocco, these are things you only find in Morocco.
In fact, it has nothing to do with Morocco or even Berber, this is architecture originally from the Middle East, specifically from Syria (I am Tunisian, btw)
The sultans and kings of Morocco were the ones who conquered Andalusia and lived there for centuries. The history of Andalusia is the history of Morocco, and the inhabitants of Andalusia are of Moroccan origins.
Your blue-eyed distrust and anxiety are so obvious in the beginning. Especially the way you said ruled by Muslims at the start of the film. The prejudice in your eyes was clear. Yet compared to other places in Spain it was so peaceful, safe, welcoming, and clean. I wonder why? 😉
I think she is Tunisian, at least she speaks Tunisian Arabic and loves the culture. For me actually she was trying to hard to find connections to the Muslim world.
Get an exclusive 15% discount on Saily data plans! Use code 20camels at checkout. Download Saily app or go to saily.com/20camels.
جميييل.. احب هذه النوع من التقارير
Your hat is perfect for Morocco sun especially in summer... so respect peace love ❤
I used Saily last week for my trip to Spain and it was 100% top, thanks to you Emily 🥰 thank you and as always, great contents 👌🏻
I’m glad it worked well 🥰🫶🏼 And thank you!! ❤️
Greetings from Michigan. Keep up the great work 👍
Thank you!!
Interesting Vlog especially showing the North African Arabic and Islamic influence on Andalousia Civilization but I wished to see the Carthaginian influence in Spanish History as well or the Iberian peninsula because it was among the oldest in the region before Romans and some people say the Spain name has Carthaginian root and none talked about it.
I had no idea what to look for in terms of Carthaginian heritage, but I agree that would be very interesting to see!
Le mot Espagne est Ibérique et le mot Hispania c'etai a l'époque Romaine Hispania cet les GRECS qui ont donné le nom de HISPANIA a la péninsule IBÉRIQUE
Et la seul chose de musulman , cet quelques constructions.
Les influences nord africains ou Carthaginois!! il y a pas .les influences et civilisations sont bien Espagnoles latino comme les Français et Italiens de culture judeo Chrétiens
et pas arabes ou africains arrête de prendre vos désir pour des réalités. L'Espagne cet l'occident Chrétien
VOUS DONNÉ DES FAUSSE INFORMATION !!!
Dites moi qu'elle influence Carthaginoise il y a en Espagne ??
Dites moi les influences du nord de l'Afrique en Espagne
Je vous fais savoir que il y a trois niveaux d'influence
1- influence de individu - 2 - un Groupe ,
3 - et Organisation
J'attends votre réponse concernant les influences nord Africaine et Carthaginois sur l'Espagne ????😊
@@20CamelsEmily Attention avec les informations que vous recevez.
Ne croyez pas tout de ce que ont vous dit . Renseigne vous bien avant de croire quelque chose.
Consejo de un Ibérico SALUDOS ✋
Looks lovely. Would love to explore Spain properly and get stuck into all the little towns. As always you do em justice.
Thank you 😊 I highly recommend Spain. It's a beautiful country with tons of hidden gems
I hope someday you create a video reflecting on your past, sharing how much you've discovered through your travels around the world. It would be fascinating to hear about the clichés that were shattered along the way and your evolved perspective on the world.
That's a great idea!
You make Soo beautiful vedio ❤
Thank you 😊
The story behind curtains according to some sources is one of profound sadness and emotional resilience...
During the period of the Spanish Inquisition, certain oppressive practices were employed to monitor and control the lives of the Moors who had been forced to convert to Christianity (Moresques). One such measure was requiring these families to keep their doors open during certain hours of the day, so some Moors found other ways to comply with the open-door policy while preserving a degree of privacy. Instead of leaving their homes entirely exposed, they often used curtains or drapes in place of doors. These curtains allowed for airflow and a semblance of compliance with the authorities' demands, while also providing a minimal shield from the eyes of inquisitors and neighbors.
Over time This necessity evolves to a tradition in some villages in spain and also in many old cities in Morocco where Moors sought refuge...
🙏
It is truly heartbreaking story which resonates deeply because it reminds us of the shared humanity that transcends borders and faiths. 🥲 These were families who had lived in Spain for generations (some for centuries) only to be cast out of the their houses built by their hands. The Moriscos carried their traditions and memories with them into exile enriching Morocco and other places and I can confirm in Moroccan homes, especially in traditional riads or rural areas, doorway curtains are still commonly used
Thank you for these infos, I looked into it and it's true 😢
Thank you for bringing that forgotten memory to light
Vous raconté n'importe quoi Premièrement les musulmans n'ont jamais était victimes de l'inquisition
Cet des mensonges. L'inquisition c'etai pour les gens qui pratiquent de la sorcellerie et les mauvais Chrétiens. Sources Wikipédia.
Et ils ont jamais obligé les musulmans a laissé leurs porte ouvertes, cet vraiment des conneries
Il y a pas plus menteurs que vous dans les documentaires. 80 % de vos commentaires sont des mensonges, ont comprend pourquoi ont peut pas vous faire confiance,vous êtes des spécialistes de la Taqiyya même entre vous 🤡🤣🤣🤣
That statue is Mary, Our Lady of Fatima, a city in Portugal where she appeared in 1916.
Superb ✨ BTW, The first man who tried to fly was born in ronda which is Abbas ibn firnas
Love your channel
Thank you!
Nice at 15:44 can be seen Hashmi Kajal, a Pakistani product, a make-up item used for the beautification of eyes.
Best content on TH-cam.. Keep going
Thank you so much! ❤️
This is the result when an engineer makes a vlog👆 Awesome and professional video with fine details✨ Bravo Emily👍🏆🥇
Thank you Maher! 😊🙏🏼
A salut from a Tunisian with andalusian roots, who's surnam, with the suffixe "oun", recalls the old castilian language that used to add this "oun" to give more importance to some family's social status...
Like "Ibn Zeidoun" or "Ibn Khaldoun" and so on...
That’s so cool!
a daily reminder on how beautiful you are love your content and i hope the best for you incha alah
Thank you! 😊
Saily is AWESOME! They've helped me in multiple countries now. Great video! makes me so nostalgic for Spain.
building under the side of the rock was for security purposes , same for the narrow streets in the old Medina they build very close to each so the neighbors could protect each other in case of invasion or bandit attacks .PS: the water baths(ronda part) are for horses to drink it's also very common in germany ,switzerland, austria ,belgium and netherland you can even find them to this days
Ahh, protection. I didn’t think of that, but it makes a lot of sense.
As for the water baths, I’ve seen public fountains like the one next to the bath in Tunisia where its purpose is to provide free water to travelers, so I thought it was the same idea. Maybe it is the same concept I just misinterpreted the bath part. Thank you for sharing! 🙏🏼
@@20CamelsEmily you're welcome ,i just watched the part of the curtain , curtain serve to keep insect and dust outside and also to keep privacy
Islam is best ❤❤❤
and for the water fountain , its done in all arabic countries including Tunisia ( but now most of them were demolished ) this was used for their horses to drink and to let near the entrance of the medina or city
Thank you Emily for this marvelous video 🙏🙏👍👍👏👏🌸💐🌴🌼🪷🙋🪷🌼💐
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you 😊
Good luck in Spain, very interesting vlog never knew they still have islamic sights. See you soon in next video & nice nail art
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it :)
👍🏻
Great video, you answered many questions I had regarding Andalusia Spain. Great foot work camera shot of the Flamingo dance. I will keep you in mind for the Sally App when I am traveling. Dave from Los Angeles. Cheers
Hi Dave, thank you! I’m glad you found the video informative. Safe travels! - Emily
The phonician had influence on the region of big grenada 3000 years ago.
Paella is from the arabic word al bakia wich means the left over it was the food of the poor in the ANDALUS .
Heureusement que l'ignorance ne tue pas 🤣
La paella vient de la langue Castellane , ça n'a rien de arabe arrêté de dire n'importe quoi. Nous espagnols ont est habitué a vos mensonges concernant notre péninsule IBÉRIQUE , vous devenus des professionnels en mensonges en voulant vous attribué les savoirs des Espagnols. Vous êtes des vrais Hypocrites et surtout des 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
No, it is from Latin 'patella' meaning 'pan'. See Italian and catalan 'padella'.
@@igorjeesorry but no , paella is the leftover of the food thats why its mixed with chicken , beaf and seafood, and vegetables.. its a mixture of the leftover, it was the food of the poor in the andalus .
@@BeZRules My 'no' refers to your mistaken etymology (origin of the word).
Nice watch
Thank you :)
Goodbye from Tunisia and welcome from Spanish
It was a short trip to Spain! The next video will be in Tunisia again :)
@@20CamelsEmily We are happy to have you around us in Tunisia 😊
@@pistolero66 Ayshek 🥰
there s a small city in south portugal called " tunez " , south europe area wasn't under just islamic ruling , it was under carthage empire... that's why is not weird that you find cultures near to tunisia's culture like in malta even the language is near to tunisian dialect
Oh wow, that is really cool! I will have to go there one day and check it out :)
@20CamelsEmily yes, Carthaginians they were good traders and sailors, they used that and they did settlements in most of southern Europe and north africa ... And lately I see a report that they reach south America continent - to facilitate their trades . There's many cities in southern Europe established by Carthaginians....
A Good thanks the glorious Reconquista i liberate my country of Muslim invasion today only remain ruins and monuments of old buried and desintegrated past.
la rajel ya ghazi tekl f l7am 5enzir rabi yehdik
Howwa ma klaysh l7am 5enzir khater ena ne7it lkol qbal 😊
@@20CamelsEmilyIn Islam, if food directly touches pork or is cooked with it (e.g., in the same oil or pan without being washed), it is generally considered haram because of cross-contamination. The food absorbs the impurity, making it impermissible to eat. In this case removing the ham doesn't matter - the food remains haram anyway. :)
اذا بليتم فاستترو يا غازي تاكل في الحلوف لا حشم لا جعرة
توانسه اغلبهم مرتد
Andalusia is a complete civilization It brought together the inhabitants of North Africa, Turkey and Spain under a single emirate Known as the Islamic Caliphate But it is different and open from any other caliphate
Les habitants de Al Andalus étaient a majorité Hispanic très peux de nord africains et il y avait pas de Turque, les turque n'ont jamais mis les pieds dans la péninsule IBÉRIQUE arrêté de dire des mensonges
Vous êtes fatigant vous avez des très grande grande bouche 👄
Turkey presence in Andalusia what a joke
Turkey? WTH
Love From Pakistan
Wow so amazing since you're in Spain There is famous spanish family called " Romero family" who are actually called Moriscos There ancestors were Muslims but they didn't know until around 50 years ago when they actually converted to Islam and then their grandma saw them and she told them she saw her grandma pray like that way " Muslim's pray " It's really tragedy story for them after that the whole family were interested in history studies and they actually discovered a lot of Andalusia and they have difficulty with the current government of Spain they want to take that historical papers I wish you do a interview for them their Library is becoming a tourist spot
This is a vlog of some TH-camr who went to their Library th-cam.com/video/FsjVQ6YmYV8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=EnWfGecqKFQe9p6z It's an Arabic I wish Gazy can get their location
I would love to visit them! Thank you for sharing
@@20CamelsEmily
You're much welcome I edited the comment and I put a link of a TH-camr who visited their historical Library, I wish one day I'm going to visit them too 😩♥️
@@20CamelsEmily It is not like one family is morisco. Most Spanish outside of the northernmost territories has Amazigh and Jewish roots. Cca 60% of Spain was Christian (of Basque/Iberian-Celtic-Roman-Visgothic stock), 30% Muslim (maybe 95% Amazigh, 5% Arab) and 10% Jewish, many left and were expulsed, but as many converted and stayed. So today, the average Spaniard is mostly pre-Islam with 10-30% Islamic time admixture. Basques and others in the north of course have the least amount.
Superb dance!
Some amazigh keep saying it is not Arabic culture but amaziegh , can any amaziegh tell us any building built before the Arabs came with amaziegh language. Even Phoenician came originally from Lebanon
All you ve seen is moroccan not especially arab . It s amazigh moroccan culture and structures the same as moroccans .the relics of moroccans who lived there 800 years 🇲🇦🇪🇦 .and still know spain is full of moroccans and spanish from moroccan roots
🤡😂😂😂
❤
👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you!
🇹🇳♥️🌷🇹🇳🤍
its not Arab it Amazigh people from north Africa
Podrška iz prijateljske Bosne.Andaluzija neiscrpna motivacija.Sve je kao iz bajke.Sretni živite. sufarabosna.ba podržava vaš humanitarni rad
If you come to Morocco, you’ll understand everything and you’ll see there are no Arabs in the story, just the moors who are Amazighs
Fatima is a the name of the prophet muhammed's daughter you can read about her and her huge impact in the extension of islam in north africa
did the Tunisian man eat the pork !!
That's for horses to drink from not a bath
What do you mean by “Alhambra was the last place to fall when the Christians REtook Spain”?!!! There was no Spain for them to retake! That’s the history written by Christians!
Is your tunisian friend eating 🐷 or am i mistaken 😮
I removed all of the ham from the part he ate from 😊
@@20CamelsEmily In Islam, if food directly touches pork or is cooked with it (e.g., in the same oil or pan without being washed), it is generally considered haram because of cross-contamination. The food absorbs the impurity, making it impermissible to eat. In this case removing the ham doesn't matter - the food remains haram anyway. :)
first
There is nothing Arab, no dress, no dancing, no architecture, next time you should look for the original, which is only Morocco, these are things you only find in Morocco.
oki 🤣🤣😂🤫
المغرب أنشأها الجنرال الفرنسي الليوطي لم تكن موجودة أصلا.
😂😂😂
In fact, it has nothing to do with Morocco or even Berber, this is architecture originally from the Middle East, specifically from Syria (I am Tunisian, btw)
It has nothing to do with Morocco LOL many north african tribes built andalusia, not morocco and ibn ziyad was NOT moroccan.
كان قعدو فيها العرب راهي الزبل في كل بلاصة
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The sultans and kings of Morocco were the ones who conquered Andalusia and lived there for centuries. The history of Andalusia is the history of Morocco, and the inhabitants of Andalusia are of Moroccan origins.
Your blue-eyed distrust and anxiety are so obvious in the beginning. Especially the way you said ruled by Muslims at the start of the film. The prejudice in your eyes was clear. Yet compared to other places in Spain it was so peaceful, safe, welcoming, and clean. I wonder why? 😉
I think she is Tunisian, at least she speaks Tunisian Arabic and loves the culture. For me actually she was trying to hard to find connections to the Muslim world.