ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 เม.ย. 2017
- How much do TH-camrs and TH-cam make from ads and how are ads matched with videos? [The number in title is split between the channel and TH-cam 60/40].
Footnote †: Dollars Per Monetized View • † Dollars Per View on ...
Footnote ‡: TH-cam Red • Footnote ‡: TH-cam Red
Bonnie Bees:
Mark Govea, Thomas J Miller Jr MD, Bob Kunz, John Buchan, Andres Villacres, Nevin Spoljaric, Christian Cooper, Michael Little, Ripta Pasay, Tony DiLascio, Richard Jenkins, Chris Chapin, Saki Comandao, Tod Kurt, Jason Lewandowski, Michael Mrozek, Phil Gardner, سليمان العقل, Jordan Melville, Martin , Steven Grimm, rictic , Ian , Faust Fairbrook, Chris Woodall, Kozo Ota, Colin Millions, Guillermo , Timothy Basanov, Chris Harshman, ChoiceMechanicalDenver.com , Donal Botkin, David Michaels, Ron Bowes, Tómas Árni Jónasson, Mikko , Derek Bonner, Derek Jackson, Orbit_Junkie , Alistair Forbes, Robert Grünke (trainfart), Veronica Peshterianu, Paul Tomblin, Travis Wichert, chrysilis , Ryan E Manning, Erik Parasiuk, Rhys Parry, Maarten van der Blij, Kevin Anderson, Ryan Nielsen, Esteban Santana Santana, Dag Viggo Lokøen, Tristan Watts-Willis, John Rogers, Edward Adams, Leon , ken mcfarlane, Brandon Callender, Timothy Moran, Peter Lomax, Emil , Tijmen van Dien, ShiroiYami , Alex Schuldberg, Bear , Jacob Ostling, Solon Carter, Rescla , Andrew Proue, Tor Henrik Lehne, David Palomares, Cas Eliëns, Freddi Hørlyck, Ernesto Jimenez, Osric Lord-Williams, Maxime Zielony, Lachlan Holmes , John Bevan, John Lee, Ian N Riopel, AUFFRAY Clement, David , Alex Morales, Alexander Kosenkov, Elizabeth Keathley, Kevin , Pierre Perrott, Tadeo Kondrak, James Bissonette, Jahmal O'Neil, Naturally Curious, Nantiwat , Tianyu Ge, Kevin Jeun, Jason Ruel, JoJo Chehebar, Danny Lunianga Xavier, Jeremy Peng, Jennifer Richardson, Rustam Anvarov
Music by Broke for Free
if youtube really guessed my income, i wouldn't get ads.
That actually made me laugh
Me think sense?
@@bullterriergaming6424 yes me too
I dont get it, this is sad.
@@sarahgardinor2967 yes, me think sense
"Watch this video on as many devices as possible"
Nicely done, Mr Grey.
hahaha
I see what you did there.
patchodustki self promotion at its highest
patchodustki I died when he said that
Nice try, every ad was for Squarespace.
4 years later and he's still changing the amount of money in the title. That is dedication.
most likely automated
It's a bot that's coded
@@orion_paxx thats the joke
@@leaf5216 Clueless
@@craftspark don’t make jokes people have to guess
Just because of the small character you made for the TH-cam bot to look like, I’m now attached to them and I love them
Bro same ngl
I'm not, I want to murder them, kill & maim .
didn't get an ad on this even though I don't use Adblock...
& these ad bots are inefficient
same
GameMinds me neither mate
me too
Actually the money amount listed in the title is correct regardless of the view ratio because youtube takes a huge chunk so technically the money in the title that auto updates is the most accurate before youtube's chunk taken out.
"Buy 1 shoe, get 1 free!" - Why didn't anyone ever come up with this spin?
Genius marketing
"Buy 1 shoe, get 1 free"
I bought it so I can get anything I want?
Advertiser:Yes but onl-
Ok imma get that super long tv over there
Advertiser:But-
Ok then bye
Probably because unless you’re an amputee (and nowadays they can use prosthetics), you’ll always be shopping for a pair of shoes because you need two.
BOGO implies that you’re allowed to leave one if you don’t want it.
And depending on how they’re priced, you’ll likely always take the second. Would you pay $100 (full price for a pair) for one shoe but leave the second behind?
Because the company probably would be getting tons of false advertising lawsuits...
@Makise Kurisu I gotta believe his serious response got to be some kind of british comedy itself. I got to believe that, my faith in humanity is already pretty low.
Every time I watch this video I don’t get an ad. I don’t have Adblock or TH-cam premium. What’s going on?
This guy is about to start taking in the money, it has literally grown 2k in a day
honestly, raking in the cash
Over 3k now...
Bro 6k
my man just made 3 grand in a couple of days
@@jafeth12 bro it's at 9k rn, got damn
Changing the title on the fly.... this makes me tingle.
Destin you watch CGP Grey?! OMG
I could change my title for you all day, baby.
I thought this was your vid for a second.
I thought this was your vid for a second.
Hi, follow me. You will see effective videos.
CGP Grey Has officially passed his upload quota for the year.
lol
correct
:D
lmao true
And yet we will all still wait patiently for the next one because they are always gold.
Anyone else remember when TH-cam still let Creators make money off a video they liked, rather than stealing all it’s revenue because someone left a false report?
This is the first time that I saw someone explain in detail how it works and I don't see a single misconception or wrong statement in it. I've checked out how this works a lot of times (in general through informing but also doing them to see how it exactly works, to understand how TH-cam places ads) and it's honestly frustrating when some people talk about how it's done and it's utterly wrong or just looks at one part of the entire picture.
Edit: I may have skipped this part, but I think it would have been good to mention (UNLESS YOU MENTIONED IT, SORRY THEN) that TH-camrs decide on ad slots, which are just a chance for ads to appear, and that 8 minute videos (back then I think it was 10) allow midrolls (without them no ad slots can be set). The general concept for 8+ minute videos is that the revenue will be around $1-6, but this highly depends on the final length of the video, demographic and category it belongs to (though category also has to do mostly with demographic, since an e.g. gaming TH-camr can upload a finance video, which usually sees way higher revenue, but see 0 change in revenue due to the same audience watching it).
I like how the bot categorized the fake video as "cat + creeper", considering creepers in minecraft are scared of cats
Haha
noticed that too
Aww man
Ye
Read the video title and you will know something new
Ironically, I was offered no add for this video.
scaleyback195 "Isn't it ironic?"
I rarely ever see ads on videos less than 5ish minutes.
scaleyback195 same
Gleb Strelets doncha think.
Same
5 years later,
this video STILL slaps.
Imagine the people that clicked on this video 5 years ago, when it said that the video was worth 0$
So a 5 second ad is a win-win for everyone, right?
Hassan Alsayoud - Actually it is good for the advertiser as it increases the click-rate, meaning the ad gets shown more.
@@timno9804 Also I guess a 5 seconds advertisement should be cheaper to produce
Except the person making the add
Sorry for edit had a spelling problem
Jake_06 games - See my above reply, also Ad*
Not for the advertiser
I actually clicked the "X" when that fake ad appeared
...Why?
@@danese1636 Force of habit
Same and im on phone
same
Danese it’s a reflex
1:00 that me :D
Ayo
Lmao
by the title i tought he made it into an nft
same I thought they minted the link
Me: a male
TH-cam ads: I THINK HE WANTS TAMPONS
lmao
Me, on a 70$ ass phone: being broke
YT ads: YOU WANT AN IPHONE 131 NEW DELUXE + PRO SMALL NOW FOR ONLY $2000.99 (NOT INCLUDING TAX) AND YOU CAN ALSO GET AN IPAD 98 PRO DELUXE PLUS ++ LARGE FOR ONLY 50,000! WHAT A DEAL
Some how it knows I need aliners and keeps showing me Invisline adds
i mean some males do have periods
Same they are so annoying
I didn't get an ad because I'm not worth anyone's money, even bots look down at me.
Same
You are trash, and so am I
I forbid myself from ever clicking on an ad, money or no money, aint nobody got clicks fo dat ;p
Same, TH-cam can’t even get my recommended list right
Same here. I rarely get Ads & only on some specific channels, weirdly being the Reddit repost video channels.... hmm...
TH-cam now gives the creators 70%
UPDATE : the title went from $6,596 to $9,811
UPDATE : it went from $9,811 to 6,658 in feb,7,2022
UPDATE : it went from $6,658 to $9,388.33 in feb,8,2022
UPDATE : now its $11,742 in feb 10, 2022
UPDATE : no more updates
Interesting that it also goes down.
It's back to 9,629.
@@sIightIybored How can it go down? If TH-cam have paid you $11,742. Then surely they can’t take £2,113 back from you?
9629
yep, back at 9k 9794
1: Click ad
2: CGP Grey collects profit
3: Close ad window
4: Rinse and repeat
That doesn't sound right, but I don't know enough about ad revenue to dispute it.
Lol thx ima get 2 phones and a bit to do that for me primaski
Then his Adsense account get suspended... wait
TH-cam started to recommend me Chinese videos ever since my dad used my account just once.
delete your history, and start fresh
Same thing happened with my Filipino dad
delete your youtube history or click on the three dots on the recommend video and click on don't recommend channel or video
Is your dad Chinese?
@@shinobix4925 yeah he is. I’m Chinese American
The algorithm have blessed your channel.
Informative and the animation/drawings were really funny to me for some reason xD
All I want to know is: How many more ads do I need to watch in order to get CGP Grey to post videos more frequently?
He does have a patreon you can donate to though I don't have the link
Found it www.patreon.com/cgpgrey
Get a job and pay the money with patrion, probably helps him more
n35w101 You can just give him a dollar directly and skip every add you'll ever watch on his videos.
4 Grey videos in one week. Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached nirvana and the apocalypse at the same time
Did anyone else notice that CGP Grey is changing the amount of money in the title? It used to be $385, now it's $425.
$453, refresh, $457
Probably a script running to generate the total based on views. Meaning, I doubt he is personally updating the video title.
I538I shhhhhh
$583
$597
South American youtuber here! Made $1,380.49 for 5.6 million views.
Dayum😳
@@nixty6795 no
@falsofacu en tus videos te entiendo pero no se ingles
If you wondering how did the GCP title change automatically There is a code in Google Script that you can modify so you can do your calculations and set it on your TH-cam video title and then It change automatically the things he set in the code, It’s a very simple thing to do There is a bunch of a tutorials about how to make it:)
I'm really bringing down the average for everyone.
Yeah k
Cyranek ok
$6000000000000000000000=¥1000000000000000000000000000000000098.876512256678909
Me me big dissapointment
No your not
"watch this video on a lot of different devices"
well played ya cheeky git
No ads here anymore...
WHAT THE HELL ONE DAY AGO IT WAS 6658
After 4 years this pops in my reccomended lovely
I find those robot figures adorable.
me, too!
So is your name ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
same.
Put that on a t shirt.
Adorable??? they're going to take our jobs...
just Kidding.. I don't have one.
THANK YOU.
There is so much misinformation out there about this.
Rob Scallon da faq are you doin' here Rob
This is a fascinating video. I dont think much has changed over the years, but I do wonder how much has.
Love the explanation, man. I knew this earlier, but still loved it
tried to close that in video ad... well played CGP Grey
Same
That ad was totally tailored to my liking.
Yes, I would like to scrap my sacred sheets of paper. Lul.
I have Red and I tried to close that ad. My overlay video reflex is still active, apparantly
Haha I closed that ad so fast I didn't even read it, I'm assuming most people didn't see or read it either.
Me too
every once in a while I pick a random ad to not skip and click through; all just to mess with the advertiser's data
Alley Peplinski Than you're prolly an outlier and they won't count it anyway.
This sounds like a story for www.reddit.com/r/pettyrevenge/ :D
Yea, they know about you and are looking for you.
Alley Peplinski nice haha
Your classified as a random add clicker then
I like how he actually changes the price in the title that's some dedication
It's a screen scraper bro.
1:22
the bot with 1c: 1c is fine
I feel stupid for trying to click away the ad...
Don't i did the same.....
Marko Reponen I did on mobile so.... ya I am stupid
You're not alone :D
me to m8
Use the ad time to go to the kitchen for food or the bathroom for a bio break. Problem solved and everyone wins.
Is the title auto-updating based on the money this video makes?
Yes
How?
Not sure about auto-update. Looks more like he is manualy updating. But well, there is a bot for everything.
Jonah Czerwinski most likely made a script / had someone make one to correct every x minutes
Well, minute earth once used a smiliar trick to visualize the amount of energy watching the video in question has consumed, which also features a conversion into more "understandable" units, like household-days of electricity.
So, I assume they use a bot, meaning such a thing exists. And given what we know about Grey from the podcasts, bot seems like a likely answer.
This video is showing in my recommendation for a thousand times, and finally clicked it..
This keeps getting on my recommended
I saw no ads on this video, I've been lied too.
same
to*
He said probably
christopher yepez same
I feel like the real question is why any of the robots think I want to see the SAME AD three times in a row. It's not getting more appealing, guys. Repetition is fine, if I forget or don't know what it was for, but spread out. The same ad three times out of ten or twenty is fine. But three times in a row I'm just annoyed. And also bored. Very bored.
AnnikaOakinnA THE Bot Society will consider your points...
Thanks and Regards,
The Bot Society
As a more boring comment on The Bot Society's neatly sardonic post, it's probably a good thing that it's like this. Avoiding it would probably require the bots to keep more information about what we watch than we should be entirely comfortable with. The ideal solution would probably be the TH-cam bots factoring in which ads you've seen into the auction - "You've advertised to AnnikaO 3 times now: you're not winning again unless you offer a grand." - or more likely, passing that info to the advertiser bots - "We've advertised to AnnikaO three times now so we expect a skip and won't bother in the auction." Any bots that actually run on such a system would almost certainly just move to the situation where they just stockpile that info and sell it for more than the ads would be worth, to all our detriment. Let's hope that the reason repeats like this happen is that TH-cam's got a blanket ban on keeping that sort of info.
AnnikaOakinnA The same ad three times in a row?! I get the same ad for a few weeks.
What about the same ad for only ONE channel that you really like and this goes on for 4 months. WTF youtube?!
Actually, it is not about forgetting the ad. Generally, the more you see anything really, the more easily your brains process the information meaning that it sounds more appealing or more true. This is called the mere-exposure effect or the familiarity principe: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere-exposure_effect. It is an unconscious process.
i did not expect to get so invested into this and actually watch it
This still on my recommended after 4 years
"Discover audio books, with a free audio book on us"
Wak
Style your midfade uninterrupted
*Two CGP Grey videos in one week?*
The end of the world is approaching. Temporal anomalies are happening.
*Edit:* Actually four videos... this is severe.
We will all die in 2012
yay you predicted an event that already happened.
congratulations you have the gift of hindsight.
There's only one explanation for this. CGPGrey is now a bot or has been replaced by a bot.
segtendonerd64 how do we know he wasn't always a bot?
Ironic because I have a tornado watch.
Why did i get this video in my recommendation after 5 years
I just got this in my recommended 4 years after this video is created. Nice
"Try watching this video on many different devices"
Really smooth there with that self advetistiment, had me fooled for a second.
who the fuck clicks on an ad? honestly
Wondering the same. I can't remember the last time I clicked an ad (or if I have done it at all).
Never clicked on an ad either. But if it is around 30 seconds or shorter, I will just watch the ad.
If it's a good movie trailer I'd click to rewatch it.
children.
I have clicked than by accident and them exited out of the new window with great annoyance.
I managed to get a video around 250,000 views on a different account and it only gave me like 40-45 dollars a few years ago. I couldn't even get the money because you needed at least $100 to withdraw or something similar to that.
Re-evaluating my TH-cam channel plans... 😭😆
pov: you have TH-cam Premium.
The title is updating, that's really cool!
Yep!! I wonder how...
There's probably a bot that changes it based on how many views it's gotten.
CGP Grey might also be monitoring it for the first couple hours
Yeah I'm assuming he is monitoring it because it doesn't seem to be updating often and updating it once every 10-20 mins for the first several hours it's live would be easier than making a bot. Only takes like 40 seconds to update it manually probably.
40 seconds every time he updates, I can't imagine Grey actually doing that rather then spending maybe 2 hours to write a bot and have it update the title, no time investment needed, for the foreseeable future.
Sooo....all i have to do is leave my computer at night playing an infinite playlist of geriatric videos and youtube will flag me as "ad unworthy"? :D
there is a site called like web static or something, it fills your search history full of auto generated words, making the ads unable to detect whats good for you, therefore, it most likely won't give you any
GreenEvilMilesSmilez _ or just use an adblocker
why is that a good thing
Lachun Adblock uses a ton of memory
or just use adblock, it's free for me and you
So this video is basically an NFT
I don't know how you drew this conclusion; especially when it doesn't even make logical sense...
This is literally in my recommended after 4 years
I love the changing title
+
+
+
+
Soz testing the + thing
2:12 "guess the viewer's age, chromosomes, income..."
Is this why all my youtube ads are about down syndrome dating sites?
herpderpmonkey m
The fuck
wtf
O h
Damn
Big Drop: 11,000$ to 9,200$
great work mate
I have only 20 pairs of chromosomes. Does TH-cam know that?
Yeah it's a new discovery actually. The tie and stethoscope add 1.
Just checked and TH-cam has my chromosome under "account info"...I feel violated
well now it does
well according to the handicap parking spot handbook, 20 chromosomes seems about right
I lost one chromosome last year.
Since you said that you did in a TH-cam comment, yes.
me: a 13 year old
youtube: Home insurance!
be proud, I guess
Do not say your age on the internet
@@zxyAprte124 it aint like people can find out where i live from my age
@@amadeus6987 yes you live in the world!
14 years old means i get life insurance and since I turned 15 I’m getting TRUCK CRASH LAWYERS
This is an adorable presentation 😅
0:01 people with yotube premium
"I won't pay if people skip my ads"
Maybe don't make your advertisements 2-10 minutes long about really boring and trival things, and people won't skip them? Like keep it short and sweet, you'll spend less money, and have less people skipping your ads.
Nyaria I don’t give two shits about ads though, so yeah.
Counterpoint, the people who watch your ad are far more likely to be interested in your product, so if you have a very niche product that's hard to calculate the demographic for, skipable ads mean you aren't paying for the people who won't buy your stuff anyways
Isn't it a strategy to make long ads so that people won't click and you don't have to pay while the consumer still sees the ad?
Nyaria they are long add often skip
@@bassfight2936 yeah one ad I got was just a full episode of the Bill Maher show. All 45 minutes of it.
So that's why I get local lawyer ads sometimes...
No, the FBI is just investigating you and they're being merciful for now by giving you the lube.
Noah Stemann I get stop drinking and driving ads... where I live is scary...
Me moving my screen so it shows just a portion of the video: my goals are beyond your understanding
Saw this pop up after listening to Cortex!
no cap, that was probably the most amount of information I took in and understood it all. Well done.
fr fr
2 videos in 1 week?
WHO ARE YOU AND WHAT HAVE YOU DONE WITH OUR CGP GREY?
Well, there could be other explanations than a doppelganger kidnapping our favorite TH-camr.
For example, perhaps CGP Grey spent a few months inside a room that's accelerated compared to the outside, so for us it's been a week but for him it's been seven months.
Lets be real though, a doppelganger has kidnapped Grey
I think Grey has finally figured out how to infuse his mind with a machine. That seems the most probable
He's been working on this one since November and the other one since February they happened to finish very close to one another.
+LeMysterieux01 But you can only stay in the Hyperbolic Time Chamber for 24 hours (our time) at a time, and you can only be in there twice
Saw this and immediately thought “videos sold as nfts”
POV you see this video on recomendend when video uploaded before 5 years:
"just watch this video on a lot of different devices", I see what you did there grey
...Am I missing something?
@@Pyrodiac extra views = extra cash
I just hope TH-cam learns that I will never buy a chrome book no matter how many times they say it has 'over 10 hours of battery life' and 'can watch Netflix offline'.
I literally hater Chromebooks because of this ad.
Chromebooks are literally waffle makers with internet access. The schools like them only because a chromebook is easily configurable to stop kids from playing games during lessons.
It's actually thesecond time a penny has proven too great a measure of value. The US used to (in the early 19th century) have half cents that was used in many day to day transactions
Can't believe this video was made before Covid-19
I love the way Grey draws bots.
They’re so cute!
Yesh they do
Video: Watch me Brush my Teeth
Bots: *CATEGORY: MINECRAFT AND CATS*
i mean, its accurate
But creepers hate cats
In TH-cam, It Would Be Cats.
In Minecraft, Ocelots, To Be Accurate.
I alway thought that, instead of cat+creeper it meant cat+gory=category
@@maxplaysgamez-sharesgaming1756 ocelots arent cats anymore, they are different mobs.
At this point the algorithm is just randomised for everyone, I have never watched any video of this category, but it got recommended to me, and just the same happens to everyone else
This is from 4years ago??? Wow it just came up on my feed randomly
Price in the title keeps changing. Not sure how but its pretty cool.
he has a script of some sort running, to constantly update the amount of money that this video has made for him thus far.
Damn, I didn't even notice that.
no, he just changes it every so often, he'll stop when the vid becomes less relevant
I seriously doubt he manually changes it. Itll be a script that updates every few minutes.
Mark Colville This is a job foe bots.
Don't the bots know that I want to see hot single girls in my local area? Step your ad game up TH-cam!
hi dad
PictureFit don't you mean hot FIT girls???
Only the fittest.
this gets recommended to me like 20 times a day
A rhetorical masterpiece
After watching this video I'm suddenly more okay with watching the full ads on some channels.
i remember watching some South Park video, and one character there is "Captain Diabetes" and everyone in description was saying they were getting insulin pump ads
I just got recommended this video crazy, also 2022 sucks
When I saw the title I immediately thought "oh no video NFT"
No wonder I keep getting "I WON THE LOTTERY" type of ads.
@@FulllNameUnknown Could also means he's a gambling addict and TH-cam views him as easy to manipulate.
and i keep gettting fake gurus that said - HEY WELCOME TO THE GTFO METHOD PAY ME 38240948298759 DOLLARS AND GWET FREE MONEY :))))))))) 100% LEGIT NO SCAM
@@Ze_eT no it just means im low income. Poor
Then the classic "every website thinks I'm a gambling addict because my little bro asked what's the vehicle prize at the casino in GTA Online"
A CPG Grey video is like a present on Christmas morning
Yes
I love that it gets updated
I shall "borrow" this video :]