Muhammad Ibn Bandār al-Jurjānī said to Imām Ahmad ibn Hanbal (rahimahullāh), “It is hard upon me to say: ‘So-and-so is such-and-such and so-and-so is such-and-such’. So Imām Ahmad replied, ‘If you remain silent and I remain silent, how will the ignorant person know what is correct and from what is false?’“ - Majmū al-Fatāwā 28/231, Sharh ʿilal al-Tirmidhī 1/350.
@@منتصربنأحمدآلغانم the statement of the Imam is general so it applies in general to any Muslim and even to kuffar, not just ahl bida. please dont try to restrict what the ulama themselves have not restricted Baarak Allahu Feekum
Feel like this makes it worse for an ignorant person like me. One is saying he’s right the other is doing the same and everyone is making videos about the other u don’t even know what to follow anymore
*_Most Duat get sucked into fame and clickbait. They start with good intentions and later, they get consumed with the social media hype. Hopefully, Uthman Ibn Farooq will take heed of your valuable advice._*
I must admit that the portrayal of you by Daniel online initially made me cautious about you. My primary reason for watching this video was to hear your perspective on Sheikh Uthman. However, Alhamdulillah, I now understand the immense challenges and trials you must have faced due to the defamation of your character online. I truly admire your approach to dawah; it appears both genuine and heartfelt. I pray that Allah (SWT) protects you and restores your reputation, if not in this world, then surely on the Day of Judgment. May those who have wronged you come to realize their actions. I also pray that you find it in your heart to forgive those who have defamed and slandered you, as you seem to be a truly kind-hearted individual.
I too was able to see for myself who is lying and who is truthful. I watch both this brother and Daniel, and it is clear as day to anyone who is sincere what the truth is. This man has been slandered in a horrible way
I swear by Allah I am not even a student of knowledge but thanks god I know the basics of the dawah salafiya, and brother Othman clearly doesn’t know it may Allah guide him
May Allah provide you with abundant beneficial knowledge and make you a good student of knowledge akhi. I recommend to you the channel of Ustadh Abdulaziz al Haqqan حفظه الله called gardenofilm. بارك الله فيك
I took many knowledege from him. Sharh Zad al-Mustqani,. May Allah forgives him and guide him. Thanks for clarify this. My loyalty always to the Quran and Sunnah with understanding of Salaf. May Allah bless you and reward you Ustadh Faris. Make dua to muslims in Malaysia. Love from Malaysia.
Akhi, never be upset when people be harsh to you for spreading the truth, we are in a time that the truthfull will be seen as lairs and the lairs as the truthfull, islam is been protected and preserved by Allah and his soldiers, be one of those soldiers and you will be from the winners in sha Allah
Assalamoalaikum Sheikh Faris, thank you for addressing this issue. I was not sure about him as he is sitting with people of biddah as well and there are certain aspects that doesn't sit right with Islam like going and punching people or being extremely aggressive towards other people. Also accepting kharijits and praising them. He also sat down with Pakistani Deobandi Scholar Mufti Tariq Masood who is not only a deviant but a loud deviant and spread false stories about Scholars of Saudi. Uthman was all praises for him. All these things threw me off.
May allah increase your knowledge...we hope sheik usthman will see this video and give a response ..if he admites and return from his mistakes we respect him for sake of allah or else we have restrict ourselves and others from watching his videos for sake of our aqeeda... we hope for him and us guidance from allah
Wallahi I used to hate you Akhi because I didn't know what Salafiyyah was, I didn't know any scholars, I was filled with bid'ah and used to follow the people of Bid'ah but Al-Haadi guided me, Alhamdulillah. I used to think of you as a sellout, puppet and whatnot but Alhamdulliah I came to know the truth. Till today I admired Shaykh Uthman for this methodology of the Salaf and returning to the Quran and Sunnah and it was problematic for me but I ignored the fact that Shaykh Uthman said to Tariq Masood Deobandi (From Pakistan) that "I (Shaykh Uthman) is a Student of Knowledge and you (Tariq Masood) is the Mufti and when I (Shaykh Uthman) listens to you (Tariq Masood), I come to know that I'm (Shaykh Uthman) ignorant" And Tariq Masood did a very problematic critic of the Quran, he said that Quran contains Grammatical Errors, سبحان الله ! And he said that the Companions didn't correct it and it will be like that (the errors) till the day Of Judgement. سبحان الله, yani does الله ﷻ speech contains mistakes? He don't even know that الله ﷻ used past tense as present tense in the Quran, which is indeed new and interesting. For example: 1. Past Tense Usage (Traditional meaning "was"): For example, in Surah Al-Ahzab (33:40): "ما كان محمد أبا أحد من رجالكم" "Muhammad was not the father of any of your men" Here كان clearly refers to a past state. 2. Present/Continuous State Usage: In Surah An-Nisa (4:17): "إنما التوبة على الله للذين يعملون السوء بجهالة ثم يتوبون من قريب فأولئك يتوب الله عليهم وكان الله عليما حكيما" "Allah accepts repentance only from those who do evil in ignorance and repent soon afterwards; it is they to whom Allah will turn in mercy, for Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise" In this verse, "وكان الله عليما حكيما" (wa kana Allahu Aliman Hakima) uses كان but refers to Allah's continuous and eternal attributes of being All-Knowing and All-Wise. It doesn't mean "Allah was" in the past tense, but rather "Allah is and always has been." And we have testimony of the Chief of the Quraysh, that is Walid Ibn Mugheerah on the Quran: "والله إني لأعلمكم بالشعر، رجزه وقريضه، وأشعار الجن، والله ما يشبه الذي يقول شيئاً من هذا والله إن له لحلاوة، وإن عليه لطلاوة، وإن أعلاه لمثمر، وإن أسفله لمغدق، وما هو بقول بشر" Translation: "By Allah, I am the most knowledgeable among you in poetry - its rajaz and its qasid (different forms of poetry), and even the poetry of the jinn. By Allah, what he (Muhammad ﷺ) recites does not resemble any of this. By Allah, it (the Quran) has a sweetness to it, and it has a grace upon it, its highest part is fruitful, and its lowest part is abundant [in meaning], and it is not the words of any human." Also, you can read Miraculous Nature of The Quran by Bassam Saeh. I'm sorry I got very passionate to refute Tariq Masood (he's claim of Grammatical errors in Quran Video is on video but it's in Urdu). But now I can't support the position of Uthman Ibn Farooq, may الله ﷻ guide him, you and me and all of us to the Truth. Allahhumma Ameen.
Mufti tareeq Masood sahab already apologised for his mistake publicly. We are human not angels. He follows hanfi fiqh what is wrong with that. I am genuinely asking and wants to know because I follow him
Remember, ya ikhwah. We're not attaching ourselves to those duats due to their personalities or their popularities in the dawah scenes, but rather the messages that they're spread. Once they're deviated from the Qur'an and the Sunnah and they haven't repented from their deviated ways, then we're detaching ourselves from them. Don't do the same mistakes that those deviant sects loves to do by doing ghulluw and even worse than that which is doing taqlid to their teachers despite their misguided ways and acting like they can't do no wrong despite being ordinary human beings like all of us
8 วันที่ผ่านมา
are these guys Kuffar and end up burning in hell with abu-jahl?
@Lasagna-z8w Who told you that this is how it works? If someone appears with a misguided person, it doesn't immediately mean that he endorses everything they say or do. Second point this so called "Misguided person" in this case Ali dawah and Mohamed hijab. You have to have clear evidence and follow the Salaf method to label them as such. A person of innovations and mistakes is different from an innovator. If we follow this flawed methodology, then 95% of the scholars would be taken oustide the fold of Ahlul Sunnah. Go read the books of the salaf like "Classifying people based on suspicion and certainty" by the scholar Abdul Muhsin Al Abbad. Or the "Golden letter" by the scholar Bakr Abu Zaid. These scholars are praised by the likes of ibn uthaimeen and ibn baz and many other great scholars.
my islamic age is a young one, this will be my 3rd ramadan, inshallah. Alhamdulillah. this all brings me great confusion, seeing many of the brothers I heard about the truth from in my early days, turn on each other like snakes in a pit.. I am not educated enough to discern between these disputes on my own. i hope this is all settled between all the brothers everywhere and that the false brothers are clearly exposed, inshallah. i love you all. as salammu aalaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu
It’s understandable for you as a revert to be confused. I personally did also love the same people and watch them like 2 years ago and I at times got angry when someone I love got warned agaisnt/refuted. Later on alhamdullilah when I learned more I started to notice more things and more things made sense. I highly advice u brother if you want to understand these things then you gotta seek knowledge because seeking knowledge removes ignorance from us and makes us worship Allah based upon clarity.
Wa alaikum assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh What the other brother has advised is true in shaa Allaah Seeking knowledge actually helps in removing the doubts Also keep making du'aa
He praised Tariq Masood Deobandi, (he later clarified in middle of a podcast he doesn't support him but not as a separate video), for this reason shaykh Tauseef ur Rehman retracted his praise of Uthman Farooq. He praised al-Munajjid, kissed the forehead of Zakir Naik and when he was asked about Yasir Qadhi while Sneako was next to him he said "I mean he's a doctor and his name is Yasir." He doesn't support Yasir Qadhi but here he didn't clarify, why? A lot of times he says he won't refute in public and rather "work things out offline"
He refuted yasir And has said tariq masood has Many errors in aqeedah He disagrees with zakir naik Yes he has mistakes but don’t exaggerate and fear Allah
@@SjsnsidiFididthat's the problem exactly , he praises and says some things regarding them when asked. He doesn't clarify his position clear cut, he plays around confusing people!!!
@@DO_DHIKR_RIGHT_NOWwhat's right about him? Is he a salafi, who are his ustadh, whom did he take ilm from to give fatawa? He praises the ahlul bidah, his latest Qna and lectures in Pakistan has grave errors. The mashaykh warned about his deviance.
Jazakallah Khairan Sheikh for this compilation of violations. I used to take knowledge from him and I thank you for clearifying so I can stop taking Ilm from him. May Allah protect and preserve you Sheikh.
May Uthman take this advice, retract these huge violations, stop promoting Ahl Bida and learn the deen properly so he won't make such blunders in the future. We can not trust our Deen with such a person Again he refused to reply to the private messages thats mainly why this is public
And privately messaging first for open statements is not a principle anyway. I always find it strange and weird that someone would INSIST that they must be contacted privately for serious, open violations. It doesn't befit someone who cares for the Deen first, and not themselves. The sanctity of Islam is more important than any of our public reputations.
@@thesalafislav Yeah the vi0lation is in public. But the thing is, if you know the person, talk to him first, always better.In this case the man ignored the advice so
@talib5766 How dare you say that to a Muslim brother like sheikh uthman The arrogant person maybe yrself. Sheikh uthman is way knowledgeable than u are and have convinced a lot of people with the will of Allah. What do you do as a good muslim? Site and backbiting him?
Can you do another video like this on Assim al Hakeem? A lot of laymen watch his lectures and fatawa and I think it would be best if things are made more clear.
Sheikh assim al hakeem is an accepted sheikh and daee. He lives in saudi and has his studio right in the land of tawheed. He takes his knowledge from ibn uthaymeen, bin baaz, al bani etc so all his fatwas are based on the salaf. So what you are u on about?
@@raeesbismilla7171barekelahu feek akhi i listened to assim for years and i used to think that but ones u learn the methodolgy of the salaf his matter will be clear to you inshallah and what u said about he follows ibn uthaymin and ibn baz thats how ikhwanul muslimin speacialy the ones in saudi fool people because they know the love and respect people have for those scholars and ikhwan are very hideous people so barekalhu feek learn the manhaj of the salaf
What are the issues regarding Sheikh Assim, as I am not aware? Also I think it's better from the laymen to take from him than other individuals online.
JazakAllah khair Shaikh. May Allah bless you and increase you in knowledge, guidance and piety. The statement of Allah is more than enough for us to reflect on. (9:119). O you who believe, fear Allah and be with the truthful.
The emphasis on quality over quantity in the context of Islam aligns with the Quranic and prophetic teachings that highlight the value of sincerity, good character, and strong faith over mere numbers. A smaller group of committed, knowledgeable, and morally upright Muslims can have a more profound impact on society than a large group lacking those qualities.
This clarification was important. A lot of people on the fence about him. May Allah guide him. Ultimately our aim is of rectification and to warn people until he corrects himself inshallah.
Riyad as-Salihin 668 Wa'il bin Hujr (May Allah be pleased with him) reported: Salamah bin Yazid Al-Ju'f (May Allah be pleased with him) asked Messenger of Allah (ﷺ): "O Prophet of Allah! Tell us, what you command us to do if there arises over us rulers who demand of us what is due to them and refuse us what is due to us." Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) turned away from him, but he repeated the same question. Thereupon Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "Listen to them and obey them. They are responsible for their obligations and you are accountable for yours." [Muslim]. وعن أبى هنيدة وائل بن حجر رضي الله عنه قال: سأل سلمة بن يزيد الجعفي رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ، فقال: يا نبي الله، أرأيت إن قامت علينا امراء يسألونا حقهم، ويمنعونا حقنا، فما تأمرنا؟ فأعرض عنه، ثم سأله، فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم “اسمعوا وأطيعو؛ فإنما عليهما حملوا، وعليكم ماحملتم” ((رواه مسلم)).
I love Uthman Faruukh for the sake of Allah but although people could be 99% right no one is at 100%. That means every thousand things said maybe 10 things are open for criticism. May Allah reward you both
May Allah reward you akh faris. Refutations are much needed in the messy english dawah scene. Praising heads of ikhwanis and sururis, mixing with those two ignorants ali dawah and hijab, watering down the calamities of omar suleiman in a podcast he went to. You wanna be a public figure, you must be responsible individual..
Question to our brother Uthmaan bin Farooq: Do you consider Ali Dawah a salafee? - If you say yes, then we understand your status - If you say no, then why are you befriending him in the manner that you are?
He has a masters in hadith. How can you say that he should not give dawa? If he can't with his credentials than who can? You made a clear mistake by this statement because nobody is perfect
@@en4560tell uthman to make tawbah for praising crimin@ls, for going against ahadith of the Messenger, for not knowing how to read Arabic properly etc etc
Uthman Farooq has been sounding ikhwani for some time now. i am surprised that when you are pointing it out then some are acting as if this is new! i thought everybody knew it.
@@MAli99923 he has done great work in dawa though but alas some traits of ikhwanism can be seen. why he did not get in touch with faris? any way May Allah guide him and Faris and you and me towards the huq and keep us steady on it till we meet our Lord. Ameen
Uthman Farooq met and had a podcast with Muhummed ali Muslim Lantern. now Muslim Lantern so far seems to be on the salafiyah with a caveat that he warns people from those who call themselves salafi ! otherwise he is cool and does good in dawa. So I don't know what is going on. I guess he (Muslim lantern) thinks the path of salaf is right but the ones who call themselves by a name like salafee are trouble. wonder why? but hey they are all responsible for their own deeds. I am just not qualified to say a thing. But I am qualified to stay away or keep on mind who is who.
i ll be honest i think he just try to avoid draging him dwon to the mud by poeple like danil , hijab and ali dawa so he avoiding them by been nice with them even thow he should know been priseing them them that maybe send poeple to there way and fall into there bad exsample may allh guid us and every muslime to the truth and make us standferm on it .
yall gotta stop taking ilm from random people that are famous and stick to the major scholars. Theres Rabbaniyyeen translations, sheikh Haytham sarhaan, sheikh abu saad, sheikh muuhammad al maliki and many more translations and english sources if you dont know arabic. and most importantly, learn arabic, this should a top priority.
@ I actually don't recommend him even tho I've got nothing to do with this whole fitnah. Uthman ibn farooq has been refuted a while ago by serieus scholars, thid is your religion so carefull who you take it from. If you feel bored or sad I recommend reading history of the sahabah and seerah and amazing stories of the imams like imam ahmed, el barbahari, el bukhari..etc
May Allah guide him, when he praised and sit with people of clear deviance whom he did not refute, I feared he took their stances and manhaj subtly time to time and his refusal to accept your private advice & rectifying his mistakes are the result of that. If this is not address swiftly, it might get worse in the future, may Allah prevents and guide him away from that.
Yes, if you want to collaborate. Collaborate with people like our Shaikh Faris, Shaikh Wajdi Akkari, Shaikh Abdul Aziz Al Haqqan. Set small differences aside and unite with those who have the correct belief and methodology to achieve greater good. Promote these people who are being slandered day and night.
It’s hard to tell because of the lighting but some of the books I could make out are: Taysir Karim al-Rahman Tafsir Kalam al-Manan (As-Sadi) Tafsir al-Tabari Muwatta of Imam Malik Bulugh al-Maram min Adilat al-Ahkam
@ you're the same guy who said muslims suffering [palestinians] share gruesome videos on social media for likes! look beyond yourself before yapping about others
@@khazixlol You're the one whose actions are in the enemies best interests because you don't want to remove that ignorance from yourself and how can you? You're the only righteous individual who is considerate of others and morally upright! Ignorant People like you only cause fitnah within the Ummah and the enemy loves this so much. Jaahil
I think these types of refutation videos would become less if some of the brothers with knowledge were less quick to praise and support some of these 'duaat' only a little while after coming to know of them. Alhamdulillah, we as Muslims are enthusiastic and overjoyed when we see someone calling to Allah's book and the Sunnah of the Messenger صلى الله عليه و سلم. However, and especially in these times, wisdom (and experience) dictates that one be patient and waits and watches before praising and giving recommendations for someone regarding their knowledge or dawah and whose appearance is a person of sunnah. How many times has the reality come out later??
statement of truth that intends falsehood akhi put things in its right place. No doubt statement of shaykh is correct but this isn’t the place he has many violations according to Quran and Sunnah
May Allah reward him for that, but other violations still have to be retracted. Especially the one where he sits with ppl of bid'ah/deviation + when he is not giving clear answers regarding the rulers and duats that are not learned and not to be taking islamic knowledge from. We have to be fair, he has done one retraction, the rest are also very important for him to adress bi'idniallah
I watched uthman recently and he mocked a sister and it was so embarrassing. I messaged the channel and the comments was very disrespectful. It was very off putting
If it's what I heard she was arragont and she thinks she better then a woman who stays home. What makes a Muslim good is Al Taqwa. I don't take anyone seriously who mixes with Ali dawah He said before were does it say you have to submit to Allah in the Quran this what Ali dawah said before and he said Allah is everywhere and he retracted that statement when he said Allah is everywhere Sheikh Uthman made a sexist comment about his wife that was offensive to me as a woman he put down his wife that showed me his real true character. He said something to sneako.
I will always admire Uthmans dedication to Allah and his pursuit of knowledge. However I completely agree with you. The way he debates most of the time is not to prove Islam to be true but to humiliate and belittle whoever he debates with. This is also very common with the Muslim speakers at Speakers Corner in the UK. There have been very few debates that I have watched where the Muslim(s) and non-Muslim(s) were actually engaged in a constructive and fruitful conversation.
this is not true, sometimes it gets argumentative but no way you think that most of the time it is like in the speakers corner rather than genuine dawah...
@@someon_e9 well watch their videos and see for yourself. I’ve seen many insults flying both ways. Islam forbids us to be disrespectful to others regardless of religion. Yet you see many different speakers and Speakers Corner throwing insults at non-Muslims. And they do it a lot more than you think. If you can, search a video on TH-cam of Muslims talking to a guy named Bir Mirir. I’m not sure if the video is still up, but look at the humiliation that this non-Muslim had tot take from a full panel of Muslims.
@ I do see his videos at times and i used to watch way more and years ago i used to see speakers corner videos a lot too, yes sometimes shaykh uthman says things i think would have been better not to be said but that is not the majority of times at all(unless he did a 180 in the recent times on his last posted videos that idk of). And keep in mind that many many of the people there are agnostic and only identify as christians by name, so when he mentions the problems within christianity or in their churches they usually agree themselves and i dont remember anyone take offense to that. Point is that to mention this about his dawah when it is minority of it just does not seem fair.
These type of videos often attract a lot of backbiting and people looking to cancel someone. Sh Uthman is KNOWN to be on the aqeeda of the salaf and has the qualifications to give dawah. Is he perfect? No, but his mistakes dont take him off the Sunnah.
@mohammadiaa If you watch his duroos, they are no doubt as to what he believes. Like I mentioned, he had made mistakes and they should be corrected but to say that his aqeedah/manhaj is questionable is absurd. What aqeedah beliefs does he have that are contrary to the Qur'an and Sunnah? His videos are not just the dawah videos, he has A LOT of classes/lectures on the masjid ribat channel where his beliefs are made crystal clear.
@@yd5698 his manhaj is correct but he mixes with and praises ahlul bid'ah? His manhaj is correct but he couldn't tell the questioner to hear and obey the ruler (in that which is permissible) as per the hadith?
@mohammadiaa I agree that he shouldn't have praised sh Tariq Masood the way he did but he did clarify his stance on deobandis. As for mixing with ahlul bidah I agree that it shouldn't generally be done but we should assume that this is his way of giving dawah to them face to face. As for the issue of the ruler, he has clarified many time that it is impermissible to rebel against the rulers. That clip that was shown is not him saying you can rebel but that the people don't have to obey the ruler in everything he says as is per the Sunnah.
I completely agree with the point in the beginning of the video, where you said that the dawah should not be done in a way where you 'roast' the other people. I hated this approach by anyone doing it, as you said Allah has said to speak in a way that is good.
@@Farishammadi Beautiful! (24:22). Let not those among you who are people of virtue and wealth swear to cease giving [aid] to their kinsfolk, the needy and those who have migrated in Allah’s cause. Rather let them pardon and overlook. Do you not like for Allah to forgive you? For Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. (3:134). Those who spend in times of both ease and hardship, who control their anger, and pardon people, for Allah loves those who do good; (12:92). He said: There is no reproach against you this day. May Allah forgive you, for He is the Most Merciful of those who show mercy.
May Allah SWT forgive you for opening your mouth and me for lending you my ear. As a revert and someone that took shahada and gives Dahwa in balboa park and Tijuana Mexico with our brother Uthman all this bickering Fitna exposing back and forth between brothers is just sickening to the gut to the point that it has sickened my heart and actually the main reason why many revert Muslims like myself leave Islam ☝️😞
I am a revert too and it is beautiful to see a student of knowledge giving priority to the Deen of Islam and very respectfully correcting the mistakes of another Muslim, and showing the grave matters (like promoting dàngerous and deviànt individuals) so that we know who to take knowledge from. This is an obligation in Islam. And he asked him respectfully to retract and correct himself. No one would leave the Deen because of people unless they haven't understood Tawheed properly because they are so attached to personalities instead of the Truth. Baarak Allahu feekum
@@E.Cerulean very true may Allah keep you steadfast upon his religion, I found that seeking knwoledge and reading the seerah of the sahabah and the prophet helps with that, I recommend the translated book of "Mubarak Furi" who I heard won a prize I think because of it.
This is a test from Allah, whether your heart is attached to Him or to personalities. Sometimes Allah tests us with different things and individuals in order to strengthen us and aid us to fully rely on Him and no one else. Let's see if you'll pass this test or fail it. Supplicate to Him to guide you to the path He is pleased with and never let you go astray.
May Allah reward you more and more and more and more and more. Despite a lot of trolls and backlash the way you stand up against all these, indeed you are the chosen one. May Allah reward you ameen..
If Non-Muslims are so confident about their beliefs or are curious about Islam, Study Islam and Comparative Religion with an open and unbiased mind willingly to know the learn the Truth. You cannot risk being wrong when it comes to this as it could be eternal damnation or eternal bliss. Study from the roots of these religions and how the other books have changed as well except Quran which is historically proven even by non Muslims to be unchanged. If you can’t research all this, watch debates by Dr. Zakir Naik with different religious figures and lecture on ‘Islam and comparative religion’ and also the ‘Prophesied coming of Prophet Muhammad in other religious books’, in some by name. Don’t take this lightly as your next life depends on it. ALHAMDULILLAH I’ve put in the time and I can say I’ve been guided to the Truth. There is No GOD except ALLAH and Muhammed (Peace be upon him) is the Messenger of ALLAH. ☝️♥️
Unfortunately, the belief of the eternality of the Quran is widespread in the dawah in the west world. They confuse uncreated with eternal, and uthman should not fall for it, and he wouldn’t fall for it if he had read a book on aqeedah. Even those who are believed to be knowledgeable are not immune from this mistake, such as yasir qadhi.
@@SA-ux4qt I heard he has been falling into shirk, he's probably an ikhwani cuz that's their way: they say leave our differences apart and unite that's what qadhi said in a nutshell when he was saying jews are his brothers, which is against the Qur'an and what the prophet said: "I was ordered to fight the people until they bare whitness that their in no god except Allah, and and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah...the hadith in 40 Nawawi.
54:41 One thing I like about your refutations is that they are not mere refutations rather you teach what is correct and this one here is very important and you do not leave us hanging. Please correct me if I'm wrong "The Qur'an is the Speech of Allah. It is not eternal rather it began with Allah and returns to Him. It is one of the actions of Allah. However, the Speech as an attribute of Allah is eternal, He has always been speaking and will always be speaking and He speaks whenever He wills.
I don't get it. I came to the comments to see if anyone could elaborate. The Quran is the speech of Allah, and the speech of Allah is eternal. Then isn't the Quran eternal? But that understanding is wrong it seems.
Do you mean that the Quran is the Speech of Allah, it is not eternal but it is one of His actions like istawa, and that speech as an attribute is eternal in that Allah has always been able to speak and will continue to be capable of speech?
@@SA-ux4qt did he mention them by name. Show them their mistakes, by playing the clip, and then refuting it? Why when SPUBS is targeted, he uses vague terms and doesn’t mention by name
He never defended them, he spoke agàinst them many times and always defended our brothers and sisters. Beware of slanders. And clearly Uthman is not more knowledgeable as he can't even read juz 'Amma and shaykh Faris corrected his aqeedah mistake. Baarak Allahu Fikum
Can you substantiate your claim. Just a single irrefutable evidence? If you don't have one, repent and ask forgiveness from those whom you have slandered before a day comes where regret would be of no use.
brothers and sisters - learn Arabic and you will be able to access the scholars statements directly and find that much of what is said on youtube is so far from what the scholars guide to.
And what about those scholars like sheikh mehboob abu aasim who calls who are agnst the falasteen jhad to be munafiq? What about statement of sheikh mashoor hasan about these kind of individuals????
Regarding what you said about Sheikh Al-Albaani and Salman Al-Awdaa, I believe that discussion took place between Sheikh Al-Albaani and Nasr Al-Umar about Salman Al-Awdaa...not to him directly.
Quran and Sunnah as the companions of the prophet ﷺ understood it. The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The best people are those of my generation, and then those who will come after them (the next generation), and then those who will come after them (i.e. the next generation), and then after them, there will come people whose witness will precede their oaths, and whose oaths will precede their witness." خَيْرُ النَّاسِ قَرْنِي، ثُمَّ الَّذِينَ يَلُونَهُمْ، ثُمَّ الَّذِينَ يَلُونَهُمْ، ثُمَّ يَجِيءُ مِنْ بَعْدِهِمْ قَوْمٌ تَسْبِقُ شَهَادَتُهُمْ أَيْمَانَهُمْ وَأَيْمَانُهُمْ شَهَادَتَهُمْ ". (Bukhari) Allah says in surat at Tawbah about the companions: وَٱلسَّـٰبِقُونَ ٱلۡأَوَّلُونَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُهَـٰجِرِینَ وَٱلۡأَنصَارِ وَٱلَّذِینَ ٱتَّبَعُوهُم بِإِحۡسَـٰنࣲ رَّضِیَ ٱللَّهُ عَنۡهُمۡ وَرَضُوا۟ عَنۡهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمۡ جَنَّـٰتࣲ تَجۡرِی تَحۡتَهَا ٱلۡأَنۡهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِینَ فِیهَاۤ أَبَدࣰاۚ ذَ ٰلِكَ ٱلۡفَوۡزُ ٱلۡعَظِیمُ﴿ ١٠٠ ﴾ • Muhsin Khan and Taqi-ud-Din al-Hilali: And the foremost to embrace Islâm of the Muhâjirûn (those who migrated from Makkah to Al-Madinah) and the Ansâr (the citizens of Al-Madinah who helped and gave aid to the Muhâjirûn ) and also those who followed them exactly (in Faith). Allâh is well-pleased with them as they are well-pleased with Him. He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow (Paradise), to dwell therein forever. That is the supreme success. At-Tawbah, Ayah 100 So the hadith informs us that the best of generations are the first 3 (the salaf; the ones who came before us) and the aya also tells us that we must follow their way. Allah knows best I hope this clarifies things.
May Allah protect us from the fitan of the end of times , this is scary , please pray for me and all the ummah , having our feet firm in those days is hard may allah allow us to have a pure spot for knowledge in our heart so that it may come to us and so that Allah subhanaho wa taala always show us right from wrong . Allahumma amiin
Well guess what the president is in the country usman lives in... brother don't start splitting hairs with Islam. Everyone understands what is meant and you coming to argue semantics. Petty argument
@AmirAl-Haque does the quran or hadith use the word president or the word rulers? We can use common sense to get his meaning or we can use semantics to try to discredit him
Wait so you knew all these things about Uthman for years and you never bothered to publicly say anything? Honestly how irresponsible. There were people who were warning against him and treated like sectarians. I mean it’s good this is here now, but what’s the point making this video years after you should have when a lot of people already disassociated from him
May Allah protect us from always trying to find something negative to say... He tried to reach out to him thats what he was doing, when he saw that the person chooses to ignore and insists upon it, then he made this video. How many people are praising that person, الحمدلله he made this video
As salaam alaykum brother, How do you spell the names you mentioned? I have met the brother (umar farooq) in Toronto when i was providing AV event support a few years ago. I didn't know he prazed Khawarij, jazakhu Allah Khayrn for the reminder
@@SalamCast May Allah make ease for you. I ask your forgiveness for my inappropriate behaviour and for causing such inconvenience. Please whenever you ask a question, always mention the condition that you have so that the one who is supposed to answer is able to provide an answer accordingly. Again, do forgive me
@SA-ux4qt ameen, i didn't know disclosing my disability was required unless it was apart of my question. Plus not everyone transliterates Arabic words the same into roman writing, my Moroccan family use the French version, i use English. We're almost 2 billion Muslims worldwide, only a minority are English as first language. We should keep that in mind, except for obvious trolling. You're forgiven
@@SalamCast Your English is much better than mine and you're quite good at expressing yourself my beloved brother. Thank you for overlooking my mistake, that's all I needed.
@SA-ux4qt I spoke German before, but the school told my mother we should speak English at home when i was in Kindergarten in the 1980s. I'm trying to learn Arabic now, i need to find something that fits in my current work schedule.
I expected you to be more balanced: across Muslim countries there are scholars who have been oppressed, imprisoned, etc because they were asked not to speak the truth about genocide, reality of some non-Muslim countries exploiting Muslim countries and Muslims, explaining reality of New Year’s Day, valentine’ day, etc without inciting disorder (only giving historical and factual backgrounds) - in Tunisia scholars who spoke up against the secular govt law allowing Muslim women to ‘marry’ ahlul-kitab men, they we also harrassed. So that the reality not just what happened to 3 Saudi scholars you cited: lots of scholars oppressed in Egypt, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Turkey, Tunisia, Malaysia, etc
@ really? I know you are obsessed with rulers but i was talking about scholars simply talking to people about the reality of the genocide in Gaza, about the reality and background of pagan festivals that got packaged as Christian holidays and the “rulers” jail them. Scholars were simply educating the masses about these events because we all know Muslim rulers today don’t religiously educate.
@@Quantum-1157 The proper scholars are still with us teaching the Deen and they have been speaking against haram festivals and the issue of Ga za, but you people only listen to the slanderers, and you are 0bsessed with bash ing the ruler. thats the sad truth.
@@E.Cerulean ok so you are saying scholars who advise ‘rulers’ in whose territory there is easy access to zina, haram festivals, ‘fireworks’ during those festivals, etc they do so from time-to-time without being jailed or prosecuted? Also it’s not about rulers - some how everything in those who follow Faris is about rulers. We might be discussing aqeedah and the conversation will get turned to ‘brother, rulers, follow the rulers , brother rulers ‘ - we were,t even taking about rulers. But the world knows exactly why elected and unelected rulers in Muslim lands are paranoid about maintaining power. You can run from the truth and be in denial but truth doesn’t change and you can’t hide from it. I just hope you, me and our descendants aren’t following the ‘ruler’ in the end times when he orders the Mahdi to be arrested and the ruler’s army is chasing him in Arabia and he runs from them seeking shelter in the ka’ba. Be careful of what you decorate in your heart. All the best to you bro.
@@Quantum-1157 who are those scholars? We need names. It's so convenient and ambiguous to say "scholars" full stop. We have to be clear. Which scholars of the Sunnah are in prisons in the Muslim world? Just like Imam Ahmed ibn Hanbal r.a, they have to have a sabr, it's a test. We should focus on the affairs that Allah is testing us on and our families.
Pls how can u guys be arguing or going back and forth online. Why don’t u advise him privately. Or if u badly want to do it publicly call him and record ur point of view. Don’t do this u will confuse the youth
Hes been advised already but he he choose not to reply so the vi0lations have to be shown to the laymen so they wont be misguided, its a religious obligation
You are saying to name people to call out against them but Ustadh Abdul aziz haqqan said tht sheikh hisham tahiri said don’t take peoples name. Give a general ruling. Now then?
@ Bruv he said it in general to not refute by names. With or without live streams. I am not against them all I asking is 2 of them know the same mashaykhs and said something different. May Allah protect us all.
بارك الله فيك أستاذنا، Maybe classes about Shuruhaat of the Aqeedah books of the Salaf, for in the future In’Sha’Allah? Like Aqeedah Tahawiyah, Usul Sunnah, Sharh Sunnah Muzani, Sharh Sunnah Barbahari, Ar-Raziyyan, Kirmani, ibn abi Zayd Al-Qayrawani. Just a suggestion after Kitab Tawheed. با رك الله فيك أستاذ فارس
I mean look at the thumbnails of the videos on Uthman Farooq channel , it doesnt look like dawah at all or some salafi talib ul ilm channel. Seems like some roasting, playing around, boasting show off emoji vids that doesnt make you learn ilm or gets you closer to Allah. May Allah guide him
the channel isnt for teaching muslims durus, it is for non muslims to watch mainly... you dont go there for a dars, that isnt the purpose of the channel. do you want them to teach books when speaking to the kuffar? be fair pls. he has a different channel for durus
Salam, I am learning the way of the Salaf. I agree with you on that part that we should not mix with the people of bid'áh. Because in my country, the dawah of the salaf has been mixed up with dawah of the khawarij and deoband because of popular speakers and their fancy way of speech. Many young "salafi" scholars started talking about politics openly. Your all allegation against Uthman ibn Farooq might be truth, but he is not from the khawarij nor he tries to promote them. Because I think previously in one of his videos he said some thing like this: the government is from the people, even the army who keeps the government in power is from the same people. That is why we should spread dawah from the root so that people will know the deen, and then the government will be from the people of the deen. He did not say with the same wording, but he clarified his stances on this. I might be wrong, but at least on this one, i would like to give benefit of the doubt to Uthman ibn Farooq on this topic particularly. May Allah reward you, and please share more knowledge with us so that we can learn more about the way of the salaf. We would like to know about the Hizbut tahrir and their aqeedah. They want our nation to go on a war against a kuffar neighbors. So, if you share some light on them it would be great.
About the issue of his Quran recitation. Isn’t that a factor on which a person isn’t sinful meaning if he is a person who struggles, isn’t he rewarded more for that? The recitation was off but it’s not like he intentionally distorted the message. Thoughts?
if he was a laymen it would be excused, but he is the Imam of a Masjid, moreover has students of his own, and that's why it's being pointed out. Never mind the literal plagiarism.
@@E.Ceruleanthis isn’t the best of points. If your talking about in regards to Quran recitation, and teaching the Quran, sure you have a point, however when it comes to deen itself and it’s theology and giving dawah, there’s no relevance or correlation.
@RKnight4 Thats not correct. Knowing Arabic is the first step to even read and understand the texts that you are conveying. The man teaches books, as well as giving dawah. This is a no brainer. If you are a student and learning, it is understandable, but it is not allowed to have this level and teach, give dawah. That is probably why he made such a huge aqeedah blúnder when talking to wood.
Seriously sheikh? Clearly, sheikh uthman is not going in their countries to mock or make fun of them; he just points out things like contradiction and inconsistencies in the bible to convince them that this is clearly not entirely the word of God. If i were a Christian and sheikh uthman show me all those contradictions and inconsistencies in the bible I'm leaving Christianity cuz am logical and open minded.
No be fair. He mocks them many times in the discussion. Thats no correct way of doing dawah! He went in their country meaning he went to live there (or his family whatever)
Regardless of that, are we just speed-passing the other greater violations? Put that one thing to the side, disinformation and wrongly speaking about Allah is a major violation. It has to be addressed. Let's focus on the bigger issues and not the semantics. These are severe errors and not to be taken lightly at all
Jazakallah khair sheikh faris, can you please make a video on assim al hakeem because he does praise abdul aziz and saleh al munajjid and he was mocking regarding the concept of manhajj-as-salaf and unfortunately many people believe that he is a salafi , may Allah bless you sheikh ❤
والله يا اخي ما له داع هذا الفيديو وما دام الشيخ عثمان بن فاروق ما استلم مكالمتك فانتظر او سافر له قبل هذا الفيديو وهذا كما تعلم اصبحت فضيحة لا نصيحة واستعجال في إصدار بيانات تثير ضجة وشكوك دوخاصة ممن اسلموا على يد اخينا عثمان حفظه الله ويا ليتكم قلتم في مقطع إن اخانا عثمان بشر يخطئ ويصيب ووقفت عندها لوصلت نصيحتكم ولكن سبحان الله! الغلاة التبديعيون المجرحون يظلمونه وشككوا فيه من اسلموا على يديه والاخ المتكلم فعل نفس الفعل الله المستعان اللهةيحفظك يا شيخ عثمان لقد ظننت ان الكفتر هم من سيضرونك ولكن كانوا من بني جلدتك بحجة النصيحة
سبحان الله تمييع !!؟؟ غريب لم لا تقل إنصاف وعدم استعجال ام لانك تحمل على اخينا الفاضل عثمان بن فاروق ! الرجل يتعب في بيان الحق والرجل يعرف كيف يجادل ويحاور وهناك من المواقف لو انك مكانه لفعلت كما فعل ولكنكم تركتم كل المقاطع التي فيها لين الى المقاطع التي اردتموها ثم عثمان بن فاروق تاب واسلم على يديه الكثير فماذا فعلت انت يا ابو التمييع ههههههه سبحان الله حتى الأدب لا تعرفه وتريد ان تقنعني بكلام الاخ المتكلم ان الحكمة لم تحالفه ؟؟ ههههههه غريب يا رجل ولكن ماذا اقول لك الا ما قاله الشاعر : تلتَمِسْ مِن مساوي النَّاسِ ما سَتَروا فيهتِكَ اللهُ سِترًا مِن مَساويكَا واذكُرْ محاسِنَ ما فيهم إذا ذُكِروا ولا تَعِبْ أحَدًا منهم بما فيكَا (روضة العقلاء ونزهة الفضلاء)) لابن حبان (ص: 128). او كما قال الآخر: أَقِلّوا عَلَيهِم لا أَبا لِأَبيكُمُ ... مِنَ اللَومِ أَو سُدّوا المَكانَ الَّذي سَدّوا... أولَئِكَ قَومٌ إِن بَنَوا أَحسَنوا البُنى .. وَإِن عاهَدوا أَوفَوا وَإِن عَقَدوا شَدّوا والسلام.....
اسلام علیکم ورحمة الله وبركاتہ It seems your English comprehension may need improvement as there are a few mistakes you're making where you are unable to comprehend what Shaykh Uthman is saying (like at 47:51 in the video). BarakAllahu feekum بارك الله فيكم
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته What’s the need for the passive aggressive approach video is an hour long you picked on one part to critique. Amazing is this affair those who let personalities and people blind them from the truth, he brought many proofs and even Shaykh Shaykh Abdur’Rahman Al-Omaisan حفظه الله تعالى has a refutation specifically on him a student from madina who has a PhD in aqidah one who is praised by over 10 of the major scholars. And we don’t see any of the scholars of Sunnah or its people with Uthman nothing personal emotions out of it. بارك الله فيك
21:33 SHEIKH UTHMAN ALREADY SAID HE DOESN'T KNOW WHAT'S BEEN GOING ON WITH DANEIL SO WHEN'S ASKED ABOUT IT HE SAID SOMETHING GOOD. U SAY SOMETHING GOOD OR STAY SILENT AND HE CHOSE TO SAY SOMETHING GOOD. + HE SAID WE RESPECT THE GOOD THAT THEY R DOING FOR THE UMMAH. HE DIDN'T SAY EVERYTHING HE'S DOING IS CORRECT OR APPRECIATE ABLE?!
Almost all deviants have some sort of good that they do, do we say about them “we appreciate the good that they do” despite all the heresies they have and the damage they’ve done to people and the dawah?
I just want to ask, how many people salafiyyah have reverted to Islam? People are reverted by people like them and then they come towards salaf... People like shykh uthman and zakir naik have some errors but they try to follow salaf, when they revert people, the reverted follows the madhab they are following... Not becomes one of the four... And their sitting with ahlul biddah, how will he able to convert people if he starts hating other da'is and parts himself? Somewhere we have to become political too... That field is just about convertibg people, later they can choose their own path..
@@SalafiOnyx Ha ha, out of 57 Muslim countries, 50 are secular. Where did the so many Hindu idol worshipping temples in Qatar come from? Why are Hindu idols being sold in Arab countries shops? How many Hindu temples are there in the UAE? Many big Indian anti-l Islamic activists live in Dubai, why doesn't the Dubai police bother them? Who is giving millions of Hindus space on Arab land? Who is building temples for them? Who is selling Arab lands to Hindus?
it's not Tariq Masood that's problematic, it's the Belief and Methodology of The Hanafis at large(There's nothing wrong with being a Hanafi in fiqh, however most Hanafis today are misguided in one way or the other). Most of them are Deobandis or Barelwis, meaning they are mostly Maturidi in theology, and one of the principles of The Maturidi School is that if a Hadith states something that goes against 'aql(intelligence), even if it is Authentic, they will reject it, never mind the fact that human intelligence can be flawed in many occasions, especially in theology, matters of the unseen. And the Deobandi Maturidis went even farther saying that if the apparent(or obvious) meaning of a verse(in the Qur'an) goes against what our Scholars said, we reject the apparent meaning. this is just the basics of it, if you want to know even farther then I suggest you to gain knowledge.
Muhammad Ibn Bandār al-Jurjānī said to Imām Ahmad ibn Hanbal (rahimahullāh), “It is hard upon me to say: ‘So-and-so is such-and-such and so-and-so is such-and-such’. So Imām Ahmad replied, ‘If you remain silent and I remain silent, how will the ignorant person know what is correct and from what is false?’“ - Majmū al-Fatāwā 28/231, Sharh ʿilal al-Tirmidhī 1/350.
Jazakallahu Khayr. May Allāh ﷻ reward you with good!!
Some of these people complaining can't even formulate a sentence in arabic. They should focus on something else.
@qwerty-qv1cr that was Ahmad ben hanbal, not you
Also, that was a man from ahl elbda'a not othman ben Farooq .
Brother, learn something else
@@منتصربنأحمدآلغانم the statement of the Imam is general so it applies in general to any Muslim and even to kuffar, not just ahl bida. please dont try to restrict what the ulama themselves have not restricted Baarak Allahu Feekum
Feel like this makes it worse for an ignorant person like me. One is saying he’s right the other is doing the same and everyone is making videos about the other u don’t even know what to follow anymore
*_Most Duat get sucked into fame and clickbait. They start with good intentions and later, they get consumed with the social media hype. Hopefully, Uthman Ibn Farooq will take heed of your valuable advice._*
This is so true.
In shaa Allaah
@@Bz-12345 you can see who does it for fame
@@HussainFahmy True uncle Hussain 💯
May allah reward you hussain fahmy
I must admit that the portrayal of you by Daniel online initially made me cautious about you. My primary reason for watching this video was to hear your perspective on Sheikh Uthman. However, Alhamdulillah, I now understand the immense challenges and trials you must have faced due to the defamation of your character online.
I truly admire your approach to dawah; it appears both genuine and heartfelt. I pray that Allah (SWT) protects you and restores your reputation, if not in this world, then surely on the Day of Judgment. May those who have wronged you come to realize their actions. I also pray that you find it in your heart to forgive those who have defamed and slandered you, as you seem to be a truly kind-hearted individual.
He is an amazing person ya akhi. Very sad what those people have done, but Allah will grant victory إن شاء الله
Well said akhi
May Allah reward you for being fair.
I too was able to see for myself who is lying and who is truthful. I watch both this brother and Daniel, and it is clear as day to anyone who is sincere what the truth is. This man has been slandered in a horrible way
I was the same, I literally started believing he was an agent or something, so I stayed away, until about a few months ago
Very useful , may Allah guide us and Uthman Ameen . Barak Allahu Feekum
I swear by Allah I am not even a student of knowledge but thanks god I know the basics of the dawah salafiya, and brother Othman clearly doesn’t know it may Allah guide him
May Allah provide you with abundant beneficial knowledge and make you a good student of knowledge akhi. I recommend to you the channel of Ustadh Abdulaziz al Haqqan حفظه الله called gardenofilm. بارك الله فيك
I took many knowledege from him. Sharh Zad al-Mustqani,. May Allah forgives him and guide him. Thanks for clarify this. My loyalty always to the Quran and Sunnah with understanding of Salaf. May Allah bless you and reward you Ustadh Faris. Make dua to muslims in Malaysia. Love from Malaysia.
Do that zad Al mustaqni classes by shaykh Saeed Hassan on the channel istisam sunnah
@@mahadwaqas_ May Allah rewards you brother. I will look into it inshAllah.
@@TheBlackCaptain1990 Ameen wa iyyak
Leave the "knowledge" you took from him behind.
@@Aastelll ofcourse. I will only took from a reliable scholar but not blindly. Always refers back to the Quran and Sunnah.
Akhi, never be upset when people be harsh to you for spreading the truth, we are in a time that the truthfull will be seen as lairs and the lairs as the truthfull, islam is been protected and preserved by Allah and his soldiers, be one of those soldiers and you will be from the winners in sha Allah
Crystal clear !
جزاكم الله خيرا وبارك الله فيكم
Assalam alaikum,brother are u personal student of sheikh faris?
Assalamoalaikum Sheikh Faris, thank you for addressing this issue. I was not sure about him as he is sitting with people of biddah as well and there are certain aspects that doesn't sit right with Islam like going and punching people or being extremely aggressive towards other people. Also accepting kharijits and praising them.
He also sat down with Pakistani Deobandi Scholar Mufti Tariq Masood who is not only a deviant but a loud deviant and spread false stories about Scholars of Saudi. Uthman was all praises for him. All these things threw me off.
May allah increase your knowledge...we hope sheik usthman will see this video and give a response ..if he admites and return from his mistakes we respect him for sake of allah or else we have restrict ourselves and others from watching his videos for sake of our aqeeda... we hope for him and us guidance from allah
Wallahi I used to hate you Akhi because I didn't know what Salafiyyah was, I didn't know any scholars, I was filled with bid'ah and used to follow the people of Bid'ah but Al-Haadi guided me, Alhamdulillah.
I used to think of you as a sellout, puppet and whatnot but Alhamdulliah I came to know the truth.
Till today I admired Shaykh Uthman for this methodology of the Salaf and returning to the Quran and Sunnah and it was problematic for me but I ignored the fact that Shaykh Uthman said to Tariq Masood Deobandi (From Pakistan) that "I (Shaykh Uthman) is a Student of Knowledge and you (Tariq Masood) is the Mufti and when I (Shaykh Uthman) listens to you (Tariq Masood), I come to know that I'm (Shaykh Uthman) ignorant"
And Tariq Masood did a very problematic critic of the Quran, he said that Quran contains Grammatical Errors, سبحان الله ! And he said that the Companions didn't correct it and it will be like that (the errors) till the day Of Judgement.
سبحان الله, yani does الله ﷻ speech contains mistakes?
He don't even know that الله ﷻ used past tense as present tense in the Quran, which is indeed new and interesting.
For example:
1. Past Tense Usage (Traditional meaning "was"):
For example, in Surah Al-Ahzab (33:40):
"ما كان محمد أبا أحد من رجالكم"
"Muhammad was not the father of any of your men"
Here كان clearly refers to a past state.
2. Present/Continuous State Usage:
In Surah An-Nisa (4:17):
"إنما التوبة على الله للذين يعملون السوء بجهالة ثم يتوبون من قريب فأولئك يتوب الله عليهم وكان الله عليما حكيما"
"Allah accepts repentance only from those who do evil in ignorance and repent soon afterwards; it is they to whom Allah will turn in mercy, for Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise"
In this verse, "وكان الله عليما حكيما" (wa kana Allahu Aliman Hakima) uses كان but refers to Allah's continuous and eternal attributes of being All-Knowing and All-Wise. It doesn't mean "Allah was" in the past tense, but rather "Allah is and always has been."
And we have testimony of the Chief of the Quraysh, that is Walid Ibn Mugheerah on the Quran:
"والله إني لأعلمكم بالشعر، رجزه وقريضه، وأشعار الجن، والله ما يشبه الذي يقول شيئاً من هذا
والله إن له لحلاوة، وإن عليه لطلاوة، وإن أعلاه لمثمر، وإن أسفله لمغدق، وما هو بقول بشر"
Translation: "By Allah, I am the most knowledgeable among you in poetry - its rajaz and its qasid (different forms of poetry), and even the poetry of the jinn. By Allah, what he (Muhammad ﷺ) recites does not resemble any of this.
By Allah, it (the Quran) has a sweetness to it, and it has a grace upon it, its highest part is fruitful, and its lowest part is abundant [in meaning], and it is not the words of any human."
Also, you can read Miraculous Nature of The Quran by Bassam Saeh.
I'm sorry I got very passionate to refute Tariq Masood (he's claim of Grammatical errors in Quran Video is on video but it's in Urdu). But now I can't support the position of Uthman Ibn Farooq, may الله ﷻ guide him, you and me and all of us to the Truth. Allahhumma Ameen.
@@shaadpatel20 may Allah be kind to you, and reward you for your kind words
Mufti tareeq Masood sahab already apologised for his mistake publicly. We are human not angels. He follows hanfi fiqh what is wrong with that. I am genuinely asking and wants to know because I follow him
@@SamreenAyyoub-_ to be honest if a person follows any one of the 4 madahib it doesn't automatically mean their aqeedah is also correct.
@ I think you didn’t listen him because barelvis of india and Pakistan accuse him to be a salafi because he also believes that Allah is above heaven
Brother or sister don't make your sins public
Remember, ya ikhwah. We're not attaching ourselves to those duats due to their personalities or their popularities in the dawah scenes, but rather the messages that they're spread. Once they're deviated from the Qur'an and the Sunnah and they haven't repented from their deviated ways, then we're detaching ourselves from them. Don't do the same mistakes that those deviant sects loves to do by doing ghulluw and even worse than that which is doing taqlid to their teachers despite their misguided ways and acting like they can't do no wrong despite being ordinary human beings like all of us
are these guys Kuffar and end up burning in hell with abu-jahl?
A lot of people in ybe dawag scene get affected by this, May allah guide Brother uthman farooq and us
Also his appearance with Ali Dawah and Muhammad Hijab proves that he is not right.
If he appeared with people who have mistakes, what's your proof that it means "he's not right"?
So you mean to say if someone appears with someone there whole work is multiplied with zero ?
Subhan'Allah. Are you that extremist ?
Seriously? So how do u guys label Muhammad hijab, Ali dawa, and the like, ignorant?
Think before u say or write anything.
@@Jaafar_Alkhalifabecause he mixes with them Okay and he was on the deen show he is not correct aswell
@Lasagna-z8w Who told you that this is how it works? If someone appears with a misguided person, it doesn't immediately mean that he endorses everything they say or do.
Second point this so called "Misguided person" in this case Ali dawah and Mohamed hijab. You have to have clear evidence and follow the Salaf method to label them as such. A person of innovations and mistakes is different from an innovator. If we follow this flawed methodology, then 95% of the scholars would be taken oustide the fold of Ahlul Sunnah.
Go read the books of the salaf like "Classifying people based on suspicion and certainty" by the scholar Abdul Muhsin Al Abbad.
Or the "Golden letter" by the scholar Bakr Abu Zaid.
These scholars are praised by the likes of ibn uthaimeen and ibn baz and many other great scholars.
my islamic age is a young one, this will be my 3rd ramadan, inshallah. Alhamdulillah. this all brings me great confusion, seeing many of the brothers I heard about the truth from in my early days, turn on each other like snakes in a pit.. I am not educated enough to discern between these disputes on my own. i hope this is all settled between all the brothers everywhere and that the false brothers are clearly exposed, inshallah. i love you all. as salammu aalaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu
It’s understandable for you as a revert to be confused. I personally did also love the same people and watch them like 2 years ago and I at times got angry when someone I love got warned agaisnt/refuted. Later on alhamdullilah when I learned more I started to notice more things and more things made sense. I highly advice u brother if you want to understand these things then you gotta seek knowledge because seeking knowledge removes ignorance from us and makes us worship Allah based upon clarity.
Wa alaikum assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh
What the other brother has advised is true in shaa Allaah
Seeking knowledge actually helps in removing the doubts
Also keep making du'aa
Focus on learning the Deen. He has many classes here (livestream) and stick to reliable people
He praised Tariq Masood Deobandi, (he later clarified in middle of a podcast he doesn't support him but not as a separate video), for this reason shaykh Tauseef ur Rehman retracted his praise of Uthman Farooq. He praised al-Munajjid, kissed the forehead of Zakir Naik and when he was asked about Yasir Qadhi while Sneako was next to him he said "I mean he's a doctor and his name is Yasir." He doesn't support Yasir Qadhi but here he didn't clarify, why? A lot of times he says he won't refute in public and rather "work things out offline"
He refuted yasir
And has said tariq masood has Many errors in aqeedah
He disagrees with zakir naik
Yes he has mistakes but don’t exaggerate and fear Allah
Whats wrong with naik??
@@SjsnsidiFididthat's the problem exactly , he praises and says some things regarding them when asked. He doesn't clarify his position clear cut, he plays around confusing people!!!
@ you can say that but wallahi this comment will mislead people into thinking he supports them when he doesn’t
@@DO_DHIKR_RIGHT_NOWwhat's right about him? Is he a salafi, who are his ustadh, whom did he take ilm from to give fatawa? He praises the ahlul bidah, his latest Qna and lectures in Pakistan has grave errors. The mashaykh warned about his deviance.
Jazakallah Khairan Sheikh for this compilation of violations. I used to take knowledge from him and I thank you for clearifying so I can stop taking Ilm from him. May Allah protect and preserve you Sheikh.
May Uthman take this advice, retract these huge violations, stop promoting Ahl Bida and learn the deen properly so he won't make such blunders in the future. We can not trust our Deen with such a person
Again he refused to reply to the private messages thats mainly why this is public
And privately messaging first for open statements is not a principle anyway. I always find it strange and weird that someone would INSIST that they must be contacted privately for serious, open violations. It doesn't befit someone who cares for the Deen first, and not themselves. The sanctity of Islam is more important than any of our public reputations.
@@thesalafislav Yeah the vi0lation is in public. But the thing is, if you know the person, talk to him first, always better.In this case the man ignored the advice so
He’ll never, he is too arrogant
@talib5766 How dare you say that to a Muslim brother like sheikh uthman
The arrogant person maybe yrself. Sheikh uthman is way knowledgeable than u are and have convinced a lot of people with the will of Allah. What do you do as a good muslim? Site and backbiting him?
@@assancamara7178 you don’t know him everyone in San Diego knows this fool
Unfortunately we have a problem with listening and not learning and the biggest I find is blind following it’s a big sickness in the ummah
blind "taqleed"
Can you do another video like this on Assim al Hakeem?
A lot of laymen watch his lectures and fatawa and I think it would be best if things are made more clear.
Sheikh assim al hakeem is an accepted sheikh and daee. He lives in saudi and has his studio right in the land of tawheed. He takes his knowledge from ibn uthaymeen, bin baaz, al bani etc so all his fatwas are based on the salaf. So what you are u on about?
@@raeesbismilla7171Watch Ustadh Faris' lecture on Surooriyyah, you will see.
@@raeesbismilla7171barekelahu feek akhi i listened to assim for years and i used to think that but ones u learn the methodolgy of the salaf his matter will be clear to you inshallah and what u said about he follows ibn uthaymin and ibn baz thats how ikhwanul muslimin speacialy the ones in saudi fool people because they know the love and respect people have for those scholars and ikhwan are very hideous people so barekalhu feek learn the manhaj of the salaf
What are the issues regarding Sheikh Assim, as I am not aware?
Also I think it's better from the laymen to take from him than other individuals online.
i'm open ears if there are any violations commited by a scholar, but regarding him i've never heard any in present.
JazakAllah khair Shaikh. May Allah bless you and increase you in knowledge, guidance and piety. The statement of Allah is more than enough for us to reflect on.
(9:119). O you who believe, fear Allah and be with the truthful.
He also mentioned the other day that Daniel is doing good work for the ummah
The emphasis on quality over quantity in the context of Islam aligns with the Quranic and prophetic teachings that highlight the value of sincerity, good character, and strong faith over mere numbers. A smaller group of committed, knowledgeable, and morally upright Muslims can have a more profound impact on society than a large group lacking those qualities.
This clarification was important. A lot of people on the fence about him. May Allah guide him. Ultimately our aim is of rectification and to warn people until he corrects himself inshallah.
Riyad as-Salihin 668
Wa'il bin Hujr (May Allah be pleased with him) reported: Salamah bin Yazid Al-Ju'f (May Allah be pleased with him) asked Messenger of Allah (ﷺ): "O Prophet of Allah! Tell us, what you command us to do if there arises over us rulers who demand of us what is due to them and refuse us what is due to us." Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) turned away from him, but he repeated the same question. Thereupon Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "Listen to them and obey them. They are responsible for their obligations and you are accountable for yours."
[Muslim].
وعن أبى هنيدة وائل بن حجر رضي الله عنه قال: سأل سلمة بن يزيد الجعفي رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ، فقال: يا نبي الله، أرأيت إن قامت علينا امراء يسألونا حقهم، ويمنعونا حقنا، فما تأمرنا؟ فأعرض عنه، ثم سأله، فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم “اسمعوا وأطيعو؛ فإنما عليهما حملوا، وعليكم ماحملتم” ((رواه مسلم)).
I love Uthman Faruukh for the sake of Allah but although people could be 99% right no one is at 100%. That means every thousand things said maybe 10 things are open for criticism. May Allah reward you both
May Allah reward you akh faris. Refutations are much needed in the messy english dawah scene. Praising heads of ikhwanis and sururis, mixing with those two ignorants ali dawah and hijab, watering down the calamities of omar suleiman in a podcast he went to. You wanna be a public figure, you must be responsible individual..
You are stupid If you think Faris IS goos
Question to our brother Uthmaan bin Farooq: Do you consider Ali Dawah a salafee?
- If you say yes, then we understand your status
- If you say no, then why are you befriending him in the manner that you are?
He has a masters in hadith. How can you say that he should not give dawa? If he can't with his credentials than who can? You made a clear mistake by this statement because nobody is perfect
Do you even understand where ustaadh is talking abouth?
@@AbiMohammedI understand very well. Please tell your ustad to do tawba for his error
@@en4560tell uthman to make tawbah for praising crimin@ls, for going against ahadith of the Messenger, for not knowing how to read Arabic properly etc etc
Yasir Qadhi graduated from Madinah University. Should he give Dawah as well?
@@SA-ux4qtyasir qadhi deviated .
Uthman Farooq has been sounding ikhwani for some time now. i am surprised that when you are pointing it out then some are acting as if this is new! i thought everybody knew it.
Has to be done based on evidence for the laymen to see.
@@MAli99923 he has done great work in dawa though but alas some traits of ikhwanism can be seen. why he did not get in touch with faris? any way May Allah guide him and Faris and you and me towards the huq and keep us steady on it till we meet our Lord. Ameen
Uthman Farooq met and had a podcast with Muhummed ali Muslim Lantern. now Muslim Lantern so far seems to be on the salafiyah with a caveat that he warns people from those who call themselves salafi ! otherwise he is cool and does good in dawa. So I don't know what is going on. I guess he (Muslim lantern) thinks the path of salaf is right but the ones who call themselves by a name like salafee are trouble. wonder why? but hey they are all responsible for their own deeds. I am just not qualified to say a thing. But I am qualified to stay away or keep on mind who is who.
i ll be honest i think he just try to avoid draging him dwon to the mud by poeple like danil , hijab and ali dawa so he avoiding them by been nice with them even thow he should know been priseing them them that maybe send poeple to there way and fall into there bad exsample may allh guid us and every muslime to the truth and make us standferm on it .
yall gotta stop taking ilm from random people that are famous and stick to the major scholars. Theres Rabbaniyyeen translations, sheikh Haytham sarhaan, sheikh abu saad, sheikh muuhammad al maliki and many more translations and english sources if you dont know arabic.
and most importantly, learn arabic, this should a top priority.
Including Faris right?
@ I actually don't recommend him even tho I've got nothing to do with this whole fitnah. Uthman ibn farooq has been refuted a while ago by serieus scholars, thid is your religion so carefull who you take it from. If you feel bored or sad I recommend reading history of the sahabah and seerah and amazing stories of the imams like imam ahmed, el barbahari, el bukhari..etc
@ more serieus scholars would be, "abdullah el bukhari" , "el fawzan" and their likes. May Allah keep you steadfast upon his religion.
May Allah guide him, when he praised and sit with people of clear deviance whom he did not refute, I feared he took their stances and manhaj subtly time to time and his refusal to accept your private advice & rectifying his mistakes are the result of that. If this is not address swiftly, it might get worse in the future, may Allah prevents and guide him away from that.
Our brother Uthmaan bin Farooq has disunited with the salafees to unite with the non-salafees?
Yes, if you want to collaborate. Collaborate with people like our Shaikh Faris, Shaikh Wajdi Akkari, Shaikh Abdul Aziz Al Haqqan. Set small differences aside and unite with those who have the correct belief and methodology to achieve greater good. Promote these people who are being slandered day and night.
I admire your courage in spreading the truth despite all the heavy and toxic opposition.
Baarakallaahu feekum.
The books in the background look so aesthetically captivating! Could anyone kindly help me with their titles?
It’s hard to tell because of the lighting but some of the books I could make out are:
Taysir Karim al-Rahman Tafsir Kalam al-Manan (As-Sadi)
Tafsir al-Tabari
Muwatta of Imam Malik
Bulugh al-Maram min Adilat al-Ahkam
بارك الله فيك
Ustadh may Allah bless you with immense reward for showing the truth Ameen 🤲 This is really a beneficial video for the truth seekers
have people forgotten that you were the only one muslim who was actually indirectly supporting Israel?
Explain to me. How can people forget something that never took place in the first place?
@@khazixlol yeah they all knew it’s a lie. Except for the wicked they feed off lies and slanders may Allah expose them
@ you're the same guy who said muslims suffering [palestinians] share gruesome videos on social media for likes! look beyond yourself before yapping about others
@@khazixlol its because of the people like you the Ummah is in such a state. Self-centered, over-dramatic, ignorant self-righteous and shameless
@@khazixlol You're the one whose actions are in the enemies best interests because you don't want to remove that ignorance from yourself and how can you? You're the only righteous individual who is considerate of others and morally upright! Ignorant People like you only cause fitnah within the Ummah and the enemy loves this so much. Jaahil
I think these types of refutation videos would become less if some of the brothers with knowledge were less quick to praise and support some of these 'duaat' only a little while after coming to know of them.
Alhamdulillah, we as Muslims are enthusiastic and overjoyed when we see someone calling to Allah's book and the Sunnah of the Messenger صلى الله عليه و سلم. However, and especially in these times, wisdom (and experience) dictates that one be patient and waits and watches before praising and giving recommendations for someone regarding their knowledge or dawah and whose appearance is a person of sunnah. How many times has the reality come out later??
Shikh uthaimeen says hasad between the schlers and students of knowledge is more severe then hasad between average people
Your point?
@@mohammadiaa His point is never listen to the ignorant. So don't listen to this person.
??
statement of truth that intends falsehood akhi put things in its right place. No doubt statement of shaykh is correct but this isn’t the place he has many violations according to Quran and Sunnah
You you count correction and refutation as hasad 😂😂
May Allah guide him.
Shaikh uthman didn't know about thuraifi and he had retracted from praising him and he clarified that case
th-cam.com/video/z-jBWqHTUVQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=H0C1lOX1ub1rtoNq
May Allah reward him for that, but other violations still have to be retracted. Especially the one where he sits with ppl of bid'ah/deviation + when he is not giving clear answers regarding the rulers and duats that are not learned and not to be taking islamic knowledge from.
We have to be fair, he has done one retraction, the rest are also very important for him to adress bi'idniallah
I watched uthman recently and he mocked a sister and it was so embarrassing. I messaged the channel and the comments was very disrespectful. It was very off putting
Where
where?
If it's what I heard she was arragont and she thinks she better then a woman who stays home. What makes a Muslim good is Al Taqwa. I don't take anyone seriously who mixes with Ali dawah
He said before were does it say you have to submit to Allah in the Quran this what Ali dawah said before and he said Allah is everywhere and he retracted that statement when he said Allah is everywhere Sheikh Uthman made a sexist comment about his wife that was offensive to me as a woman he put down his wife
that showed me his real true character. He said something to sneako.
@ hmmm
So why didn't you hide his sin instead of exposing it here?
Baraka Allahu feek akhi Faris 🌹
I will always admire Uthmans dedication to Allah and his pursuit of knowledge.
However I completely agree with you. The way he debates most of the time is not to prove Islam to be true but to humiliate and belittle whoever he debates with. This is also very common with the Muslim speakers at Speakers Corner in the UK.
There have been very few debates that I have watched where the Muslim(s) and non-Muslim(s) were actually engaged in a constructive and fruitful conversation.
Brother be careful with this statement “dedication to Allah”, what do you mean by that or are you mistaken
@ what’s wrong with saying that? Maybe you are misinterpreting as something else?
this is not true, sometimes it gets argumentative but no way you think that most of the time it is like in the speakers corner rather than genuine dawah...
@@someon_e9 well watch their videos and see for yourself. I’ve seen many insults flying both ways.
Islam forbids us to be disrespectful to others regardless of religion. Yet you see many different speakers and Speakers Corner throwing insults at non-Muslims. And they do it a lot more than you think.
If you can, search a video on TH-cam of Muslims talking to a guy named Bir Mirir. I’m not sure if the video is still up, but look at the humiliation that this non-Muslim had tot take from a full panel of Muslims.
@ I do see his videos at times and i used to watch way more and years ago i used to see speakers corner videos a lot too, yes sometimes shaykh uthman says things i think would have been better not to be said but that is not the majority of times at all(unless he did a 180 in the recent times on his last posted videos that idk of). And keep in mind that many many of the people there are agnostic and only identify as christians by name, so when he mentions the problems within christianity or in their churches they usually agree themselves and i dont remember anyone take offense to that. Point is that to mention this about his dawah when it is minority of it just does not seem fair.
The better response would have been to talk about and disprove the two Saudi guys that Uthmaan ibn Farooque praised.
These type of videos often attract a lot of backbiting and people looking to cancel someone. Sh Uthman is KNOWN to be on the aqeeda of the salaf and has the qualifications to give dawah. Is he perfect? No, but his mistakes dont take him off the Sunnah.
Praising Ahl Bidah constantly is being on the Manhaj of the Salaf? Nope
Akhi are you colorblind? There are red flags all over him
@mohammadiaa If you watch his duroos, they are no doubt as to what he believes. Like I mentioned, he had made mistakes and they should be corrected but to say that his aqeedah/manhaj is questionable is absurd. What aqeedah beliefs does he have that are contrary to the Qur'an and Sunnah? His videos are not just the dawah videos, he has A LOT of classes/lectures on the masjid ribat channel where his beliefs are made crystal clear.
@@yd5698 his manhaj is correct but he mixes with and praises ahlul bid'ah? His manhaj is correct but he couldn't tell the questioner to hear and obey the ruler (in that which is permissible) as per the hadith?
@mohammadiaa I agree that he shouldn't have praised sh Tariq Masood the way he did but he did clarify his stance on deobandis. As for mixing with ahlul bidah I agree that it shouldn't generally be done but we should assume that this is his way of giving dawah to them face to face. As for the issue of the ruler, he has clarified many time that it is impermissible to rebel against the rulers. That clip that was shown is not him saying you can rebel but that the people don't have to obey the ruler in everything he says as is per the Sunnah.
I completely agree with the point in the beginning of the video, where you said that the dawah should not be done in a way where you 'roast' the other people. I hated this approach by anyone doing it, as you said Allah has said to speak in a way that is good.
Assalamu alaikum ustadh. Why did you strikethrough "may Allah guide him" in the description?
He did not, he put it between "-" instead of (), so the system did it.
JazaakAllaahu khayran ustadh. May Allaah guide him and us
As'salámu'ãlaikum wa rahmatul'láhi wa barakatu, please forgive me for believing in false accusations against you.
@Abdullasson وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
How can I not forgive you. Bless you
@@FarishammadiÁllahumma barikk fíkum
@@Farishammadi Beautiful!
(24:22). Let not those among you who are people of virtue and wealth
swear to cease giving [aid] to their kinsfolk, the needy and those who have migrated in Allah’s cause. Rather let them pardon and overlook. Do you not like for Allah to forgive you? For Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
(3:134). Those who spend in times of both ease and hardship, who control
their anger, and pardon people, for Allah loves those who do good;
(12:92). He said: There is no reproach against you this day. May Allah forgive you, for He is the Most Merciful of those who show mercy.
May Allah SWT forgive you for opening your mouth and me for lending you my ear.
As a revert and someone that took shahada and gives Dahwa in balboa park and Tijuana Mexico with our brother Uthman all this bickering Fitna exposing back and forth between brothers is just sickening to the gut to the point that it has sickened my heart and actually the main reason why many revert Muslims like myself leave Islam ☝️😞
I am a revert too and it is beautiful to see a student of knowledge giving priority to the Deen of Islam and very respectfully correcting the mistakes of another Muslim, and showing the grave matters (like promoting dàngerous and deviànt individuals) so that we know who to take knowledge from. This is an obligation in Islam.
And he asked him respectfully to retract and correct himself. No one would leave the Deen because of people unless they haven't understood Tawheed properly because they are so attached to personalities instead of the Truth.
Baarak Allahu feekum
@@E.CeruleanGod bless u dear
The truth is the truth no matter what. Brother Uthman should address these problems and correct them. He is not above criticism as a public da’i.
@@E.Cerulean very true may Allah keep you steadfast upon his religion, I found that seeking knwoledge and reading the seerah of the sahabah and the prophet helps with that, I recommend the translated book of "Mubarak Furi" who I heard won a prize I think because of it.
This is a test from Allah, whether your heart is attached to Him or to personalities. Sometimes Allah tests us with different things and individuals in order to strengthen us and aid us to fully rely on Him and no one else. Let's see if you'll pass this test or fail it. Supplicate to Him to guide you to the path He is pleased with and never let you go astray.
May Allah reward you more and more and more and more and more. Despite a lot of trolls and backlash the way you stand up against all these, indeed you are the chosen one. May Allah reward you ameen..
If Non-Muslims are so confident about their beliefs or are curious about Islam, Study Islam and Comparative Religion with an open and unbiased mind willingly to know the learn the Truth. You cannot risk being wrong when it comes to this as it could be eternal damnation or eternal bliss. Study from the roots of these religions and how the other books have changed as well except Quran which is historically proven even by non Muslims to be unchanged. If you can’t research all this, watch debates by Dr. Zakir Naik with different religious figures and lecture on ‘Islam and comparative religion’ and also the ‘Prophesied coming of Prophet Muhammad in other religious books’, in some by name. Don’t take this lightly as your next life depends on it. ALHAMDULILLAH I’ve put in the time and I can say I’ve been guided to the Truth. There is No GOD except ALLAH and Muhammed (Peace be upon him) is the Messenger of ALLAH. ☝️♥️
JazakAllah khair for sharing this. May Allah increase you in guidance and knowledge
There is no science in Islam called comparative religion, itt is a misguided manhaj introduced by Ahmed Deedat and Zakir Naik
Unfortunately, the belief of the eternality of the Quran is widespread in the dawah in the west world. They confuse uncreated with eternal, and uthman should not fall for it, and he wouldn’t fall for it if he had read a book on aqeedah.
Even those who are believed to be knowledgeable are not immune from this mistake, such as yasir qadhi.
But dont praise yasir, he's the w0rst
Umm everything was going well until I got to the last part of your comment.
@@SA-ux4qt I heard he has been falling into shirk, he's probably an ikhwani cuz that's their way: they say leave our differences apart and unite that's what qadhi said in a nutshell when he was saying jews are his brothers, which is against the Qur'an and what the prophet said: "I was ordered to fight the people until they bare whitness that their in no god except Allah, and and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah...the hadith in 40 Nawawi.
@@SalafiOnyx he's a deviant
@@MangoFruit-u8q Who is a deviant? Yasir Qadhi? Bro he's worse than a deviant, worse than an innovator.
54:41
One thing I like about your refutations is that they are not mere refutations rather you teach what is correct and this one here is very important and you do not leave us hanging.
Please correct me if I'm wrong
"The Qur'an is the Speech of Allah. It is not eternal rather it began with Allah and returns to Him. It is one of the actions of Allah. However, the Speech as an attribute of Allah is eternal, He has always been speaking and will always be speaking and He speaks whenever He wills.
@@SA-ux4qt yes exactly
@@Farishammadi JazakAllah khair Shaikh!
I don't get it. I came to the comments to see if anyone could elaborate.
The Quran is the speech of Allah, and the speech of Allah is eternal. Then isn't the Quran eternal?
But that understanding is wrong it seems.
@@Farishammadi I hope Shaikh reads this and explains it whenever he is free. I really don't want to occupy his time. May Allah bless him
Do you mean that the Quran is the Speech of Allah, it is not eternal but it is one of His actions like istawa, and that speech as an attribute is eternal in that Allah has always been able to speak and will continue to be capable of speech?
I don’t understand one thing. You mentioned that ahlu sunnah expose by name. Why don’t you make an hour video about spubs? Mention them by name.
He made a 2 hour video.
@@SA-ux4qt did he mention them by name. Show them their mistakes, by playing the clip, and then refuting it? Why when SPUBS is targeted, he uses vague terms and doesn’t mention by name
A person defending Israel is talking bad about a more knowledgeable person
He never defended them, he spoke agàinst them many times and always defended our brothers and sisters. Beware of slanders.
And clearly Uthman is not more knowledgeable as he can't even read juz 'Amma and shaykh Faris corrected his aqeedah mistake. Baarak Allahu Fikum
Can you substantiate your claim. Just a single irrefutable evidence? If you don't have one, repent and ask forgiveness from those whom you have slandered before a day comes where regret would be of no use.
Ya sheikh what does it mean that it's contagious like atopic dermatitis ?? Is it possible to get more clarification please? JazakhAllah Khyran
brothers and sisters - learn Arabic and you will be able to access the scholars statements directly and find that much of what is said on youtube is so far from what the scholars guide to.
What would be the permissibillity of seeking knowledge from the shaykh as I have been going through his series on zad al mustaqni'
better to stay away and listen to this channel, OneWayToParadise and GardenofIlm instead, barakAllahu feek akhi
@@qwerty-qv1cr Not OneWayToParadise, he's deviant himself supporting likes of Saalim at-taaweel who said the Gazans are not martyrs
@@qwerty-qv1cr I know those channels and Alhamdullilah benefit from them but I was just wondering about it.
And what about those scholars like sheikh mehboob abu aasim who calls who are agnst the falasteen jhad to be munafiq? What about statement of sheikh mashoor hasan about these kind of individuals????
You’re a very lost individual.
Regarding what you said about Sheikh Al-Albaani and Salman Al-Awdaa, I believe that discussion took place between Sheikh Al-Albaani and Nasr Al-Umar about Salman Al-Awdaa...not to him directly.
where do i find it?
Yes you’re right.
@FidanHasanzadeStudent th-cam.com/video/3OPCplTSZ8w/w-d-xo.htmlsi=vI0FRGyF5vOBzhuF
Ibn abass is a salaf ? So if a salaf understand something from the quran and from sunnah .. who's understanding shuuld we follow?
Quran and Sunnah as the companions of the prophet ﷺ understood it.
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The best people are those of my generation, and then those who will come after them (the next generation), and then those who will come after them (i.e. the next generation), and then after them, there will come people whose witness will precede their oaths, and whose oaths will precede their witness."
خَيْرُ النَّاسِ قَرْنِي، ثُمَّ الَّذِينَ يَلُونَهُمْ، ثُمَّ الَّذِينَ يَلُونَهُمْ، ثُمَّ يَجِيءُ مِنْ بَعْدِهِمْ قَوْمٌ تَسْبِقُ شَهَادَتُهُمْ أَيْمَانَهُمْ وَأَيْمَانُهُمْ شَهَادَتَهُمْ ".
(Bukhari)
Allah says in surat at Tawbah about the companions:
وَٱلسَّـٰبِقُونَ ٱلۡأَوَّلُونَ مِنَ ٱلۡمُهَـٰجِرِینَ وَٱلۡأَنصَارِ وَٱلَّذِینَ ٱتَّبَعُوهُم بِإِحۡسَـٰنࣲ رَّضِیَ ٱللَّهُ عَنۡهُمۡ وَرَضُوا۟ عَنۡهُ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمۡ جَنَّـٰتࣲ تَجۡرِی تَحۡتَهَا ٱلۡأَنۡهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِینَ فِیهَاۤ أَبَدࣰاۚ ذَ ٰلِكَ ٱلۡفَوۡزُ ٱلۡعَظِیمُ﴿ ١٠٠ ﴾
• Muhsin Khan and Taqi-ud-Din al-Hilali:
And the foremost to embrace Islâm of the Muhâjirûn (those who migrated from Makkah to Al-Madinah) and the Ansâr (the citizens of Al-Madinah who helped and gave aid to the Muhâjirûn ) and also those who followed them exactly (in Faith). Allâh is well-pleased with them as they are well-pleased with Him. He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow (Paradise), to dwell therein forever. That is the supreme success.
At-Tawbah, Ayah 100
So the hadith informs us that the best of generations are the first 3 (the salaf; the ones who came before us) and the aya also tells us that we must follow their way. Allah knows best I hope this clarifies things.
May Allah protect us from the fitan of the end of times , this is scary , please pray for me and all the ummah , having our feet firm in those days is hard may allah allow us to have a pure spot for knowledge in our heart so that it may come to us and so that Allah subhanaho wa taala always show us right from wrong .
Allahumma amiin
He didnt say rulers. He said president. Comeon.
Well guess what the president is in the country usman lives in... brother don't start splitting hairs with Islam. Everyone understands what is meant and you coming to argue semantics. Petty argument
@ZiZiMorgan It is called misquoting. It is not semantincs. And he misquoted it several time to to egxagerate it.
@AmirAl-Haque does the quran or hadith use the word president or the word rulers? We can use common sense to get his meaning or we can use semantics to try to discredit him
The President is the one who rules the country. He is the ruler of the country.
Wait so you knew all these things about Uthman for years and you never bothered to publicly say anything? Honestly how irresponsible. There were people who were warning against him and treated like sectarians. I mean it’s good this is here now, but what’s the point making this video years after you should have when a lot of people already disassociated from him
May Allah protect us from always trying to find something negative to say... He tried to reach out to him thats what he was doing, when he saw that the person chooses to ignore and insists upon it, then he made this video. How many people are praising that person, الحمدلله he made this video
As salaam alaykum brother, How do you spell the names you mentioned?
I have met the brother (umar farooq) in Toronto when i was providing AV event support a few years ago. I didn't know he prazed Khawarij, jazakhu Allah Khayrn for the reminder
@SA-ux4qt I'm dyslexic bro, that's why i asked.
@@SalamCast May Allah make ease for you. I ask your forgiveness for my inappropriate behaviour and for causing such inconvenience. Please whenever you ask a question, always mention the condition that you have so that the one who is supposed to answer is able to provide an answer accordingly. Again, do forgive me
@SA-ux4qt ameen, i didn't know disclosing my disability was required unless it was apart of my question. Plus not everyone transliterates Arabic words the same into roman writing, my Moroccan family use the French version, i use English. We're almost 2 billion Muslims worldwide, only a minority are English as first language. We should keep that in mind, except for obvious trolling. You're forgiven
@@SalamCast Your English is much better than mine and you're quite good at expressing yourself my beloved brother. Thank you for overlooking my mistake, that's all I needed.
@SA-ux4qt I spoke German before, but the school told my mother we should speak English at home when i was in Kindergarten in the 1980s. I'm trying to learn Arabic now, i need to find something that fits in my current work schedule.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته. هل يمكن مشاركة البريد الالكتروني للتواصل بشأن موضوع مهم يخص ما ذكرته عن الأثر المذكور؟
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
راسلوني على انستقرام او تويتر
I expected you to be more balanced: across Muslim countries there are scholars who have been oppressed, imprisoned, etc because they were asked not to speak the truth about genocide, reality of some non-Muslim countries exploiting Muslim countries and Muslims, explaining reality of New Year’s Day, valentine’ day, etc without inciting disorder (only giving historical and factual backgrounds) - in Tunisia scholars who spoke up against the secular govt law allowing Muslim women to ‘marry’ ahlul-kitab men, they we also harrassed. So that the reality not just what happened to 3 Saudi scholars you cited: lots of scholars oppressed in Egypt, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Turkey, Tunisia, Malaysia, etc
It seems that you’re ignorant when it comes to public advice to the rulers.
@ really? I know you are obsessed with rulers but i was talking about scholars simply talking to people about the reality of the genocide in Gaza, about the reality and background of pagan festivals that got packaged as Christian holidays and the “rulers” jail them. Scholars were simply educating the masses about these events because we all know Muslim rulers today don’t religiously educate.
@@Quantum-1157 The proper scholars are still with us teaching the Deen and they have been speaking against haram festivals and the issue of Ga za, but you people only listen to the slanderers, and you are 0bsessed with bash ing the ruler. thats the sad truth.
@@E.Cerulean ok so you are saying scholars who advise ‘rulers’ in whose territory there is easy access to zina, haram festivals, ‘fireworks’ during those festivals, etc they do so from time-to-time without being jailed or prosecuted? Also it’s not about rulers - some how everything in those who follow Faris is about rulers. We might be discussing aqeedah and the conversation will get turned to ‘brother, rulers, follow the rulers , brother rulers ‘ - we were,t even taking about rulers. But the world knows exactly why elected and unelected rulers in Muslim lands are paranoid about maintaining power. You can run from the truth and be in denial but truth doesn’t change and you can’t hide from it. I just hope you, me and our descendants aren’t following the ‘ruler’ in the end times when he orders the Mahdi to be arrested and the ruler’s army is chasing him in Arabia and he runs from them seeking shelter in the ka’ba. Be careful of what you decorate in your heart. All the best to you bro.
@@Quantum-1157 who are those scholars? We need names. It's so convenient and ambiguous to say "scholars" full stop.
We have to be clear. Which scholars of the Sunnah are in prisons in the Muslim world?
Just like Imam Ahmed ibn Hanbal r.a, they have to have a sabr, it's a test. We should focus on the affairs that Allah is testing us on and our families.
Can you please show a clip or situation where he disrespected people. I have not seen any yet therefore asking.
😢 قلت له في البداية انه لا يجوز الاستهزاء بالنصارى ،، و الآن تستهزئ بإخيك المسلم ؟
Pls how can u guys be arguing or going back and forth online. Why don’t u advise him privately. Or if u badly want to do it publicly call him and record ur point of view. Don’t do this u will confuse the youth
Hes been advised already but he he choose not to reply so the vi0lations have to be shown to the laymen so they wont be misguided, its a religious obligation
Umm but he made this video to clarify to the youth because they seem pretty much confused already.
29:00 if you actually watched you would have no need to ask this question.
he did try reaching him privately go watch the video before commenting
@@SalafiOnyxbro what are u ? His paid lawyer? U comment on each comment
You are saying to name people to call out against them but Ustadh Abdul aziz haqqan said tht sheikh hisham tahiri said don’t take peoples name. Give a general ruling. Now then?
Yeah he’s talking about asking on his livestream. HUGE difference
@ Bruv he said it in general to not refute by names. With or without live streams. I am not against them all I asking is 2 of them know the same mashaykhs and said something different. May Allah protect us all.
بارك الله فيك أستاذنا،
Maybe classes about Shuruhaat of the Aqeedah books of the Salaf, for in the future In’Sha’Allah? Like Aqeedah Tahawiyah, Usul Sunnah, Sharh Sunnah Muzani, Sharh Sunnah Barbahari, Ar-Raziyyan, Kirmani, ibn abi Zayd Al-Qayrawani.
Just a suggestion after Kitab Tawheed.
با رك الله فيك أستاذ فارس
JazakhAllah Khyran for this beneficial awareness Sheikh
Jazakallahu khairan for informing us. May Allah reward you abundantly. Barakallahu feekum.
I mean look at the thumbnails of the videos on Uthman Farooq channel , it doesnt look like dawah at all or some salafi talib ul ilm channel. Seems like some roasting, playing around, boasting show off emoji vids that doesnt make you learn ilm or gets you closer to Allah. May Allah guide him
He doesn't edit these videos
the channel isnt for teaching muslims durus, it is for non muslims to watch mainly... you dont go there for a dars, that isnt the purpose of the channel. do you want them to teach books when speaking to the kuffar? be fair pls. he has a different channel for durus
Salam, I am learning the way of the Salaf. I agree with you on that part that we should not mix with the people of bid'áh. Because in my country, the dawah of the salaf has been mixed up with dawah of the khawarij and deoband because of popular speakers and their fancy way of speech. Many young "salafi" scholars started talking about politics openly.
Your all allegation against Uthman ibn Farooq might be truth, but he is not from the khawarij nor he tries to promote them. Because I think previously in one of his videos he said some thing like this: the government is from the people, even the army who keeps the government in power is from the same people. That is why we should spread dawah from the root so that people will know the deen, and then the government will be from the people of the deen. He did not say with the same wording, but he clarified his stances on this.
I might be wrong, but at least on this one, i would like to give benefit of the doubt to Uthman ibn Farooq on this topic particularly.
May Allah reward you, and please share more knowledge with us so that we can learn more about the way of the salaf. We would like to know about the Hizbut tahrir and their aqeedah. They want our nation to go on a war against a kuffar neighbors. So, if you share some light on them it would be great.
th-cam.com/video/_ayPdlRggg0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=EZVF9ou54YGpXkLt
^from shaykh al albani.
@@ob1934 jazakallahu Khair. is there any English sub Title to this?
@@gravity_336 salam aleikum brother can you tell me ur discord. I wanna show u some stuff
brother can you show me ur discord. I wanna add u
I want to send you some websites about this
About the issue of his Quran recitation. Isn’t that a factor on which a person isn’t sinful meaning if he is a person who struggles, isn’t he rewarded more for that? The recitation was off but it’s not like he intentionally distorted the message. Thoughts?
Thats not the point. The point is that it shows that he is not qualified to teach the Deen. That and the aqeedah blunder and his plàgiarism, etc
if he was a laymen it would be excused, but he is the Imam of a Masjid, moreover has students of his own, and that's why it's being pointed out. Never mind the literal plagiarism.
@@E.Ceruleanthis isn’t the best of points. If your talking about in regards to Quran recitation, and teaching the Quran, sure you have a point, however when it comes to deen itself and it’s theology and giving dawah, there’s no relevance or correlation.
@RKnight4 Thats not correct. Knowing Arabic is the first step to even read and understand the texts that you are conveying. The man teaches books, as well as giving dawah. This is a no brainer. If you are a student and learning, it is understandable, but it is not allowed to have this level and teach, give dawah. That is probably why he made such a huge aqeedah blúnder when talking to wood.
@@RKnight4 All the adillah (proofs) for dawah and all the deen are Quran & Sunnah. How you're giving dawah but you cant read juz 'Amma? Oh plz
جزاكم الله خيرا وبارك الله فيكم
Ahki why didn’t you call him
Seriously sheikh? Clearly, sheikh uthman is not going in their countries to mock or make fun of them; he just points out things like contradiction and inconsistencies in the bible to convince them that this is clearly not entirely the word of God.
If i were a Christian and sheikh uthman show me all those contradictions and inconsistencies in the bible I'm leaving Christianity cuz am logical and open minded.
No be fair. He mocks them many times in the discussion. Thats no correct way of doing dawah! He went in their country meaning he went to live there (or his family whatever)
Regardless of that, are we just speed-passing the other greater violations? Put that one thing to the side, disinformation and wrongly speaking about Allah is a major violation. It has to be addressed. Let's focus on the bigger issues and not the semantics. These are severe errors and not to be taken lightly at all
Jazakallah khair sheikh faris, can you please make a video on assim al hakeem because he does praise abdul aziz and saleh al munajjid and he was mocking regarding the concept of manhajj-as-salaf and unfortunately many people believe that he is a salafi , may Allah bless you sheikh ❤
He talked about him in his livestream about the Sururis
@E.Cerulean jazakallah khair akhi, I'll watch it
والله يا اخي ما له داع هذا الفيديو
وما دام الشيخ عثمان بن فاروق ما استلم مكالمتك فانتظر او سافر له قبل هذا الفيديو
وهذا كما تعلم اصبحت فضيحة لا نصيحة واستعجال في إصدار بيانات تثير ضجة وشكوك
دوخاصة ممن اسلموا على يد اخينا عثمان حفظه الله
ويا ليتكم قلتم في مقطع إن اخانا عثمان بشر يخطئ ويصيب ووقفت عندها لوصلت نصيحتكم ولكن سبحان الله!
الغلاة التبديعيون المجرحون يظلمونه وشككوا فيه من اسلموا على يديه
والاخ المتكلم فعل نفس الفعل
الله المستعان
اللهةيحفظك يا شيخ عثمان لقد ظننت ان الكفتر هم من سيضرونك ولكن كانوا من بني جلدتك بحجة النصيحة
واضح التمييع عليك
سبحان الله
تمييع !!؟؟ غريب
لم لا تقل إنصاف وعدم استعجال
ام لانك تحمل على اخينا الفاضل عثمان بن فاروق !
الرجل يتعب في بيان الحق والرجل يعرف كيف يجادل ويحاور وهناك من المواقف لو انك مكانه لفعلت كما فعل
ولكنكم تركتم كل المقاطع التي فيها لين الى المقاطع التي اردتموها
ثم عثمان بن فاروق تاب واسلم على يديه الكثير فماذا فعلت انت يا ابو التمييع ههههههه
سبحان الله حتى الأدب لا تعرفه وتريد ان تقنعني بكلام الاخ المتكلم ان الحكمة لم تحالفه ؟؟ ههههههه غريب يا رجل
ولكن ماذا اقول لك الا ما قاله الشاعر :
تلتَمِسْ مِن مساوي النَّاسِ ما سَتَروا
فيهتِكَ اللهُ سِترًا مِن مَساويكَا
واذكُرْ محاسِنَ ما فيهم إذا ذُكِروا
ولا تَعِبْ أحَدًا منهم بما فيكَا
(روضة العقلاء ونزهة الفضلاء)) لابن حبان (ص: 128).
او كما قال الآخر:
أَقِلّوا عَلَيهِم لا أَبا لِأَبيكُمُ ...
مِنَ اللَومِ أَو سُدّوا المَكانَ الَّذي سَدّوا...
أولَئِكَ قَومٌ إِن بَنَوا أَحسَنوا البُنى ..
وَإِن عاهَدوا أَوفَوا وَإِن عَقَدوا شَدّوا
والسلام.....
BaarakAllahou fiek for this !❤
That's clear. Jazak Allah kheiran
اسلام علیکم ورحمة الله وبركاتہ
It seems your English comprehension may need improvement as there are a few mistakes you're making where you are unable to comprehend what Shaykh Uthman is saying (like at 47:51 in the video).
BarakAllahu feekum بارك الله فيكم
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
What’s the need for the passive aggressive approach video is an hour long you picked on one part to critique. Amazing is this affair those who let personalities and people blind them from the truth, he brought many proofs and even Shaykh Shaykh Abdur’Rahman Al-Omaisan حفظه الله تعالى has a refutation specifically on him a student from madina who has a PhD in aqidah one who is praised by over 10 of the major scholars. And we don’t see any of the scholars of Sunnah or its people with Uthman nothing personal emotions out of it.
بارك الله فيك
False, sheikh Uthman ibn Farooq is in my opinion the best.
He is my favorite brother in the dawah scene.
Not forget muslim lantern ❤
But your opinion doesn't matter bro ❤
learn how to follow the religion and the truth not poeple no matter who they are you need to stand with the truth .
another individual that follows personalities, instead of following the Haq.
DH is a trojan horse.
And he has a master’s in Hadith? How
Inshallah may Allah make me one of your students for face to face classes... Ameen
21:33 SHEIKH UTHMAN ALREADY SAID HE DOESN'T KNOW WHAT'S BEEN GOING ON WITH DANEIL SO WHEN'S ASKED ABOUT IT HE SAID SOMETHING GOOD. U SAY SOMETHING GOOD OR STAY SILENT AND HE CHOSE TO SAY SOMETHING GOOD. + HE SAID WE RESPECT THE GOOD THAT THEY R DOING FOR THE UMMAH. HE DIDN'T SAY EVERYTHING HE'S DOING IS CORRECT OR APPRECIATE ABLE?!
Almost all deviants have some sort of good that they do, do we say about them “we appreciate the good that they do” despite all the heresies they have and the damage they’ve done to people and the dawah?
منهجه اخواني يعذر كل أحد لكن حينما اتى لسلفيين لم يجب المداهنة يجالس كل أحد إلا اهل الحق
This is not violence
I just want to ask, how many people salafiyyah have reverted to Islam? People are reverted by people like them and then they come towards salaf... People like shykh uthman and zakir naik have some errors but they try to follow salaf, when they revert people, the reverted follows the madhab they are following... Not becomes one of the four...
And their sitting with ahlul biddah, how will he able to convert people if he starts hating other da'is and parts himself? Somewhere we have to become political too...
That field is just about convertibg people, later they can choose their own path..
Don't speak without knowledge
This is exactly what he said: If you have a issue go and talk to him this youtube video's about each other is ...... sad
Already messaged him first. He ignored the messages. Always watch the video before comment Baarak Allahu feekum
watch the video, he already messaged him a few times, didn't get any response
Salam. Who do you reccomend we listen to in english other that al haqqan and abu mussab?
Listen to Shaikh Abdul.Aziz and Wajdi Akkari instead.
Anwar wright ,Mustafa George
@@SA-ux4qt abu mussab is wajdi akkari
Abdurrahman Hasan, Sa'eed Hasan, Abu Atiyyah, Abu Fajr
Khalid green
4:54 calling sulaiman al-alwan and abdulaziz turaify scholars of hadith
15:50 praise Ali dawah, DH
31:23 bad Quran recitation
18:46 as a salafi what's wrong on that statement???
Thats pure kha"rijism. Making ta"kfir of all Muslims rulers. No Sala"fi would ever do that, only surooris, kha"warij pretending to be Sa"lafi !
@@SalafiOnyx Ha ha, out of 57 Muslim countries, 50 are secular. Where did the so many Hindu idol worshipping temples in Qatar come from? Why are Hindu idols being sold in Arab countries shops? How many Hindu temples are there in the UAE? Many big Indian anti-l Islamic activists live in Dubai, why doesn't the Dubai police bother them? Who is giving millions of Hindus space on Arab land? Who is building temples for them? Who is selling Arab lands to Hindus?
@@IBRAHIM42970 Stop echoing the rhetoric of that rag-tag political group and take some time to genuinely seek and learn the truth.
idk if Sh. Uthman actually said that, but if he did, he basically takfeered every single Muslim govt out there
Can anyone explain me what is wrong with mufti tareeq Masood. Because I follow his fatwas and listens to him.
it's not Tariq Masood that's problematic, it's the Belief and Methodology of The Hanafis at large(There's nothing wrong with being a Hanafi in fiqh, however most Hanafis today are misguided in one way or the other). Most of them are Deobandis or Barelwis, meaning they are mostly Maturidi in theology, and one of the principles of The Maturidi School is that if a Hadith states something that goes against 'aql(intelligence), even if it is Authentic, they will reject it, never mind the fact that human intelligence can be flawed in many occasions, especially in theology, matters of the unseen.
And the Deobandi Maturidis went even farther saying that if the apparent(or obvious) meaning of a verse(in the Qur'an) goes against what our Scholars said, we reject the apparent meaning.
this is just the basics of it, if you want to know even farther then I suggest you to gain knowledge.
@ please suggest me I want to know