SO, THIS IS THE ORIGINAL!! Daniel Balavoine - SOS d'un terrien en détresse (Reaction) (SRR Series 2)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.ย. 2023
- #DanielBalavoine #SOS #Reactions
Daniel Balavoine - SOS d'un terrien en détresse (Starmania) Reaction
Original Video: • Daniel Balavoine - SOS...
Message:
This is the song that boosted Dimash's career.
The original artist of this song was DANIEL BALAVOINE and was created for the show Starmania in 1978. It is considered to be one of the most technically difficult songs to sing. Daniel only performed this once on t.v. just a few weeks before his death. He died in a helicopter crash when they encountered a desert storm.
---
BACKGROUND MUSIC BY INFRACTION NO COPYRIGHT MUSIC:
• Infraction Music [Chan... - เพลง
![อาจารย์ยอด : สวยกินคน [ผี]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_-TIJOwkRA4/mqdefault.jpg)
FOR MORE INFO ON CUSTOM SERIES:
www.thefablesphere.com/custom-series
You can also join the Fable Community by becoming a site member, this is completely FREE: www.thefablesphere.com/fablecommunity
Bravo. Yes, there is something about this performance that you don't get with Dimash. Don't get me wrong, I learned of this performance through Dimash, but the pronunciation is authentic and the timing is original, especially 5:29. Daniel transitions lower sooner, which, when played all the way through, is truly beautiful. I've waited over a year to see a reaction to Daniel because no one thought to do one, and I stopped looking. So, I'm glad I found your reaction. What a coincidence.
Maybe you want to know that the compositer of the song was Michel Berger and the writer Luc Plamodon, specially made to Daniel Balavoine
Sorry for my english. Thanks for the video
I appreciate you see the difference between capability to sing high pitch notes, and the ability to deliver emotions when singing… for me this is the diiference between Dimash (perfect technic, no emotions) and Balavoine, natural voice and his guts feeling through his voice.
the same goes with dimash's perf over lara fabian's perfect concert
J'écoute Daniel Balavoine depuis 1978 quand j'avais 8 ans a l'époque, Daniel Balavoine c'est le patrimoine français 🇨🇵🇨🇵🇨🇵👍
It really is a beautiful song and very authentic sung by Daniel... quite different to what Dimash does with it. Also the language, beautiful language❤❤
I m french, u r spot on, luv ya
Es una canción preciosa, Dimash dijo en una entrevista que se inspiró en la versión de Gregory Lemarchal, este chico tiene una historia muy triste, murió muy joven por fibrosis quistica pero en su corta carrera musical dejó canciones preciosas entre ellas SOS, Gregory tenía una voz muy dulce, me gustaría que reaccionaras a ella, saludos 🤗🌹❤️🕊️🇪🇸
You may think the way he sang is modest (i take it as a compliment), Daniel feels every words of the lyrics wich is heartbreaking... not everyone or professional singers can sing this difficult song properly like him, please try it by yourself at home (he he ;-)). Not anyone could sing or is trained like Dimash, he is the best performer of SOS but for us who can really understand french we can't hold our tears when Daniel sings.
We should give also a big praise to Michel Berger, the composer.
Both Michel and Daniel were the full package: singers, songwriters, composers…
They both created many many masterpieces covered by the greatests.
Both died so young also 😢
🤍🤍
hi
Daniel Balavoine is a good example of patience, determination, and perseverance. He was rejected many times until he was given a break with this song.
Allah ondan razı olsun ve Nur içinde uyusun.Mesele bu sözleri yazmak ve notalarını yaratmak.
Nothing beats the original - Rien ne vaut l'original. Après tout ce temps, on pense toujours beaucoup à toi - After all this time, we still thinking about you a lot.
Salut, très jolis commentaires. Il faut bien savoir que "SOS d'un terrien en détresse" est à l'origine une chanson secondaire de Balavoine, perdue dans sa discographie et dans la comédie musicale dont elle est issue. Ca n'était pas un tube d'ailleurs, ça l'est devenu très progressivement, et il ne l'a interprété qu'une fois à la tv lors de ce live symphonique. Il le fait ici avec beaucoup de retenue et de sensibilité, mais Balavoine était aussi capable de performances vocales incroyables ("Tous les cris les SOS" ; "Mon fils ma bataille" etc.). Amitiés de France.
Pas du tout c'est Starmania juste parallèle à son magnifique répertoire
look for "tous les cris les SOS" from him, it's a gem
I like that Sonja has requested so many originals. I've heard several renditions of this song incl. Daniel's original. We have to appreciate the authenticity of his performance.
The greatest thing (beside his unique talent) have done and continue doing is to let all of us know about singers and songs we would never hear if it weren't for Dimash, like SOS, Daybreak, Ikanaide, Autum Strong and so on. That songs and singers they would never be heard, for example, by a Portuguese woman like me, nor would they go out into the world from their own countries. Thanks Dimash!
So many of Dimash’s concerts, unfortunately, has SOS dedicated to someone who Dimash was very close to who passed away, and the SOS from Malaysia had me sobbing, so close to the passing of his Papa, just heartbreaking.
felt like he was saying goodbye, he doesn't have any commercial concerns, he's just saying goodbye😇💔
Daniel Balaboine 👏👏👏
Saludos 🇨🇱
Nice reaction I loved Daniel Balavoine artist I loves the base of this record !
I most agree with you dude it's a beautiful piece o a song , very sentimental , and thanks for sharing !!!!!!!!!!!
There are a few interpretations of SOS, but it’s true that nothing is like the original. It is inspiring to note that Dimash didn’t try to steal the songs, but interpreted them in a way that honoured the originals. Whenever I have heard Dimash cover a song, I have sought out the original to appreciate and understand (not compare!) where the song began. Lovely concept for your reactions. Cheers from Canada!
1 word : sincerity
Très sympa de passer la version de Daniel Balavoine, très cher aux cœurs des français, pour sa voix, mais aussi pour son engagement politique, qui lui a sans doute coûter la vie.
Maintenant, comparer Balavoine à Dimash, c'est comparer Bjorn Borg à Djokovic. Pas la même génération et le même entraînement incroyablement intense actuellement.
J ❤ Dimash, mais l'homme Balavoine m a aussi beaucoup touchée
je suis d accord, pas les mêmes arrangements. J adorai Balavoire, ses interprétations, son implication, les textes magnifiques...
Dimash a un immense talent, et communique tellement d émotions que j aime à penser que si Daniel pouvait l entendre de la haut, in serait sûrement fier et heureux 😢😢
Очень сомневаюсь в том , что Даниэлю понравилась бы версия Димаша .Вряд ли он захотел бы ее услышать во второй раз .
Beautiful, special performance of this song by Daniel ❤
tout a été écrit par l'immense Michel Berger. tu devrais écouter Starmania.
vive la France, Daniel, tu nous manques
Luc Plamondon pour le texte, Michel Berger est le compositeur.
Bona nit. Em sembla molt interessant escoltar les versions originals dels covers que Dimash va cantar en I'm a singer. 👏👏👏👏🎼❤🎼❤🎼❤🥰
Awesome that you have taken us on this particular journey! Thank you!!!
the difference between interpreting phonetically a song and singing in your own language
Waouh ❤️❤️ grandiose dimash lui rend Un très belle hommage pour l'éternité ❤❤❤
Sorry,
I'm glad Dimash took this song to stratospheric gold....but this is the one that makes me cry because I know that what Daniel wanted, Dimash achieved in this song. A raw version full of feeling and, but you can never take away the intention. Dimash took this song and existing masterpiece to a stratospheric level without taking away a single point of its feeling. Remarkable!
Look "sos d'un terrien en détresse" Grégory Lemarchal❤❤
Hi ! I'm French and I really like Daniel Balavoine's version, because he "sets the note" according to the meaning of the text.
Daniel ❤❤ this version is THE UNIC for eternal
I remember he was vers anxious before singing, he didn't sing it since several years, and didn't have a lot of time for preparing himself for the tv show. He wasn't realy happy about the result in the end I remember.
Daniel understands what he's singing. That's the main différence !!
And never took the song as a contest to show off a capability to sing high pitch… it was written for his voice, and he delivers all the emotions of the lyrics… hundred time better!
"Tous les cris les SOS" is amazing.
It is a beautiful song and this singer's delivery is profound. I think Dimash loves this song so much that he gave it a new life, when it was completely forgotten and he makes it his own because he also performs it with a lot of love and it reaches me just like the original.
Димаш любит не саму песню , а себя в ней .Ещё бы : ведь здесь можно в полной мере продемонстрировать свой фальцет ! Ну , а о том чтобы постараться передать эмоции , заложенные в песне , речь совсем не идёт .Димашу это ни к чему : он даже слова толком выучить за столько лет не удосужился.
Completly forgotten ? This songs is taken for Starmania and that musical has new versions played on stage avery severa years (in Quebec and France). This song is an heritage for us ....
The composer Michel Berger composée this song for the Balavoine voice's..both are dead young with their talent
Tehnic, așa cum ai spus, e departe de ce realizează Dimash, dar într-adevăr emoția este acolo și se transmite, iar partea instrumentală iese mult în evidență. Melodia e superbă. Dimash domină scenă și te umpli de vocea lui, emoția, chiar dacă alta, curge ca un rău căruia nu i te poți opune. Dar este un original bun. ❤
Bonne blague.
Phenomenal series absolutely amazing Thanku both lots an lots you ate wonderful thanku so much love an God bless always from Cyprus x x x x
The versions of Daniel Balavoine and that of Dimash are very different, at all levels, to the point that I find it difficult to compare them. My point of view is that of a musician/composer before being that of a Frenchman.
I recognize that Dimash has an extraordinary voice and impressive vocal range. But other elements must be taken into account to be objective.
The arrangement was significantly strengthened in Dimash's version, with intense orchestration helping to generate the emotion felt. The visuals broadcast on stage as well. Then the delay and reverb effects on the vocals.
I also notice that Dimash doesn't pronounce all the words. Some are just 'mumbled'. This provides more space on a technical level but takes away strength from the text.
Daniel Balavoine did not have the same technical means at the time and his version is more intimate. Important detail: He attached great importance to the text!
Note that he was capable of remarkable vocal performances live as demonstrated by his version of 'Frappe avec ta tête' at the Palais des Sports. It's a very different song, in a Rock style but which allows us to realize the fact that it was a beast of stage.
Tks to reated to Daniel Bellavoine (from France). And after him, you can react to Grégory Lemarchal (from France) and the last one is Bruno Pelletier (From Montreal, Quebec, Canada). The last one was Dimash. Sorry for their links, but I'm sure you can find them, pls. 'Cause I don't know how to put a link ;( . It's not to compare them, but just to listen to them. This song is so emotional and, it's my favorite for so many years. It's like, the lyrics, are my SOS....This song fits with my life. Tks so much. Take care pls. From Quebec, Canada ❤❤❤
Tan Bello como la de Dimash !!!!
صحيح اتفق ، المغني الرئيسي فعليا مشاعره واضحة وجلية ف اداءه لانه حاسس بكل كلمة يغنيها ، ديماش غناها يطريقته لكن لاننكر ان ديماش في اداءه 2021 كان حاسس فيها جدا لان كل ما يغنيها يتذكر صديقه الي كان يحب هذي الاغنية منه انقتل وهو بعمر صغير ، لاول مره بالامس شفت ديماش يبكي وهو يؤدي هذي الاغنية ، راح اعملك منشن على الانستقرام حتى تشوفه ، شكرا لك واحب رياكشناتك
Daniel Balavoine forever 😢
Dimash forever 😍
Daniel hated singing this song just because it's very difficult😅❤
Hello from Belgium 🤗
The song is about a guy waiting for death because the love of his life (his only reason for living) just died in his arms, I feel this despair in Balavoine’s version. Dimash's version is more a performance to show his great abilities in a song contest. I prefer the original but everyone has their own sensitivity.
For me, performing a song like this doesn't require breaking records in the highs or lows, but just putting your emotions into it and conveying them. Daniel BALAVOINE knew how to do this, as did Grégory LEMARCHAL, another magnificent French singer. I'm not criticizing "Dimash" because I don't know him particularly well.
However, I do admire the South Korean singer - Ko Eun Sung - because I think he interprets French songs very well. But that's my personal point of view.
You have too the wonderful cover of Grégory Lemarchal.
This song of Starmania was written by Luc Plamondon(Quebec) and composed by Michel Berger(France) in the 70's. For me, the best version is by Bruno Pelletier. He has such a power voice. He also sings Le temps des Cathédrales (Notre-Dame de Paris - Luc Plamondon/Richard Cociante). I am a big fan.
Moi aussi ,c’est una se mes préférées avec Bruno Pelletier ❤
Daniel Balavoine was a great singer. He wanted to work with Peter Gabriel.
😂
I have seen a video on YT showing different artists, mostly French, singing SOS.
Balavoine the number one. I don't know who is Dimash, but nobody is mentionning the Peter Kingsbery's version which is the second best and that is an issue to fix.
Very well said.
Devriez écouter "tous les cris les SOS" de Daniel Balavoine et aussi "Lucie" "Aimer et plus fort que d'être aimé" "Soulève-moi" "Lady Marlène" "Pour la femme veuve qui s'éveille" "partir avant les miens" et toutes les autres
With many of these original artists I never heard of them or the songs until Dimash sang them. With Daniel's performance what I like is the fluency of the language and pronunciation of the French lyrics.
Ok here is my view as a French native Dear :)
I absolutely love Dimash's versions of SOS, except the Singer version because he absolutely murders the language in that one as I think he was nervous, but all other versions are just amazing. Daniel's version is also beautiful because as you so rightly say he is so totally absorbed in his performance and it is very emotional too. It was composed in 1978 for a rock opera so obviously it is impossible to compare it to today's style and DImash. You can't compare apples and oranges! They are both beautiful. Daniel is more in the emotion, Dimash is more powerful, obviously has a better voice and his emotions are beautiful too in a different way. I think Daniel's range is good too as although he doesn't go as high as Dimash he definitely has range and his technique is very different. I remember the first time I heard Daniel sing SOS many years ago and we were all amazed by the range in one line!
There are many singers who have attempted to sing this song, some better than others and it would be really interesting to react to a few other ones too!
Thank you Fil! ;)
Je suis d’accord avec vous! Cheers from a French-American Dear!
Phil, this original song was part of a rock opera, so it was sung in that context. Dimash’s rendition would not sound right in a rock opera. I love that Daniel’s French is perfect. Dimash’s French leaves a lot to be desired (I am French), so it is nice to have the language to back up the song. I suggest you also listen to Gregory Lemarchal’s rendition of it. He won a French contest with it and went on to perform it to large audiences. He suffered from cystic fibrosis and I still can’t fathom how he had enough breath to sing this song. Gregory also died young, at 23 I believe, waiting for a lung transplant for his cystic fibrosis. I would like to also suggest a very beautiful song sung as a duet with Lara Fabian; it is called “An Ave Maria”, here is the link; th-cam.com/video/P7faUysT60U/w-d-xo.htmlsi=2YEw_Vl6w3pSzx8V
Thanks for this journey, very interesting!
My version favourite SOS from Dimash. And beautiful performance, amazing voice Gregory Lemarshal(RIP).
Dimash n'a pas d'émotions dans sa reprise et en plus il écorche la moitié des mots avec une mauvaise prononciation
@@irismanusco3074 D'accord avec vous, Dimash n'était que dans la technique sans émotion...
No way, Dimash was only technical, not in emotion as Daniel Balavoine, but Gregory Lemarshal had this emotion, Daniel and Gregory had go to young, RIP for them.
Sonja I'm loving your series 💕💕
to my french hearing ears, he sounds like he's vibing in the airs, so light in this performance. It's ironic bc he died in a helicopter crash (the pilot was a known Swiss pilot, and a lot of things were named after him. (His dad founded Air-glacier)
Yes, an original interpretation will always have an incomparable flavor and I think that it will always be less meritorious to cover it up by improving it because the flavor will never be the same.
Know that Daniel Balavoine has an even more fantastic song than this one and it is called "Tous Les Cris les SOS" and I am very surprised that Dimash did not cover it because he would have an even greater success with this one. I don't think anyone will be able to recreate the unique atmosphere of the original by Daniel Balavoine even though I know that Dimash is an exceptional singer.. th-cam.com/video/dg6Boku_bQc/w-d-xo.html
Tous les cris les SOS is great but not as great as this one tbh, it's musically fantastic
The vocal performance is not at all in the tradition of French song from France, which is more based on interpretation in the sense of the emotion released (Edith Piaf, Jacques Brel - who was Belgian -, Barbara... ). This notion of vocal performance arrived late in France via Quebec artists from Canada (Ginette Reno, Céline Dion, Lara Fabian...), it is more of a North American tradition.
Incidentally, this song comes from a 1979 Franco-Quebec rock opera "Starmania" and was made possible thanks to the vocal abilities of Daniel Balavoine, but was not at all the initially most famous song of this rock opera. It was as part of a reality TV singing competition that a young singer (unfortunately he also died very prematurely), Grégory Lemarchal, covered this song from the perspective of vocal performance in the 2000's. And it was Grégory Lemarchal's version that inspired Dimash Kudaibergen for his own performance in a televised singing competition on Chinese television.
gregory lemarchal sing this song too !!! in my opinion its the best version
I also like Norman Groulx version too!
Everyone (or almost!) knows that “SOS d'un terrien en détresse” is a song from the musical STARMANIA, created in 1979. The story told in this show has not aged a bit, it is timeless , this is why its success spans the decades with many new versions over the years.
I found a 1989 version with English subtitles here : th-cam.com/video/VKF_SqeKTYo/w-d-xo.html
And this one in English : th-cam.com/video/FmzUqFarQkE/w-d-xo.html
Tout le monde (ou presque !) sait que "SOS d'un terrien en détresse" est une chanson de la comédie musicale STARMANIA, créée en 1979. L'histoire racontée dans ce spectacle n'a pas pris une ride, elle est intemporelle, c'est pour cette raison que son succès traverse les décennies avec de nombreuses nouvelles versions au cours des années.
J'ai trouvé une version de 1989 avec les sous-titres en anglais ici : th-cam.com/video/VKF_SqeKTYo/w-d-xo.html
Salut regarde juste la chanson "tous les cris les SOS"de Daniel Balavoine .je rêve que dimash la reprenne la plus belle chanson de Balavoine.
His high notes are controlled. This song is a not about "performing". Balavoine can perform as well. Listen to his other songs.
I agree with you. Dimash's performance is outstanding and I've listened to it hundreds of times, but the authenticity and the obviously natural French sang by Daniel is also beautiful.
Hay una versión que me gusta mucho ,
Con Bruno Pelletier.❤
Ikanaide is the next!! Please! Now that one will be something else!
Fil has already done this song. He has a huge Dimash playlist. Some of the best reaction ever found on TH-cam.❤️
Gregory lemarshal funerals version,when SOS when back to the french tabloids by 3rd time in 40 years of the original SOS song.
another vibe,another time.
There are better sound quality of this performance, on stage or on the original 1978 record of Starmania
Bonjour.
Je souscris complètement à votre analyse concernant la différence entre la version originale et les reprises. Ces dernières peuvent être mieux orchestrées, la voix plus mélodieuse, mais c'est l'originale l'âme qui anime toutes les versions suivantes.
Cordialement
He was politically , and humainly engaged.
He did not crash, he has been killed.
This is the parallel story...that still makes co troversy , today...
Now, No Doubt....
Dimash version is above tbe stars of ANY interpretation.
You would have been even more sensitive to Daniel's emotional original had you had the French lyrics with the English subtitles. They are an important part of the song.
Piet Ariont hallgassátok meg!
Es que esta canción es muy grande...me gustan todas las versiones, quizas la que más me emociona es la de Gregory Lemarchal, ver a ese jovencito con sus pulmones enfermos ganar el concurso Stars Academy cantando esta bellisima canción, conmueve hasta las lagrimas😢...un par de años después murió de fibrosis quística, la maldita enfermedad se lo llevó con 23 años y un futuro prometedor por delante...
Hello.. do You know PIET ARION??.. I suggest You check him up.. he sings SOS too, and although he's not Dimash.. you won't be dissapointed..
Hola Fil, si puedes fijate en la canción original de Estudio A con la canción de Sinful Passion que canta Dimash. Gracias
I grew up with Balavoine. The emotion is unparallelled. Dimash made a voice fest but did not grasp nor convey this song is about a person considering suicide. Faith also took Balavoines life and Gregory Lemarchal who had the second best delivery 20 years later.
Вам стоит послушать для разнообразия версию Кайрата Тунтекова, тоже казахстанский певец, его исполнение очень близко как к этому оригиналу, так и к монере исполнения Димаша. Так скажем, переходная версия 😂 Казахи обожают эту песню, а после того, как ее исполнил Димаш, она олицетворяет собой успех нации 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 гиперболизирую, конечно
Authenticity has a pungent take un like anything else.. Kindness your-way Lochness Scottish Highlands..
The original is nice...But the emotion Dimash puts into it is fantastaic!❤🇺🇲
If you grew up with this song or understands french, you see Dimash actually fumbles this song. Dimash turns the song to fit his voices capabilities. But in doing so he fails to convey he’s supposed to be a guy considering suicide.
Before commenting, I listened to the different versions and the different singers and Dimash's vocal performance is fantastic. But, because there is a but. It's yogurt, a random pronunciation of French, no emotion and why no emotion? Because he doesn't understand what he is singing and because in French song the music is certainly important but always less than the words and the stories they tell.
Fil, Dimash killed this song. This performance is very real and given the backstory, poignant. This IS a beautiful song.
#QcumberSquad #DanielBalavoine - Fil, I'm off back to the study.
Daniel Belavione was a very special singer, he gave his heart in every single performance. I have enjoyed more than 25 videos of different performances by Dimash singing this song always live. I would NOT want to start a debate, but it's natural that all Dears feel affected and tend to compare any version of "SOS de un terrien en détresse" with Dimash's. That is inevitable, that song is the one that opened the doors to his magical world to the majority of his followers. It goes without saying that no matter how good and emotional the previous or subsequent versions are since its premiere at Starmania, above all the versions by Belavione and Lemarchal, the song acquired a much superior connotation in Dimash's unique voice. That song IS already Dimash's, no one can take it away from him. When Michel Berger and Luc Plamondon composed it, they did not imagine that 18 years later its true owner would be born in Kazakhstan.
Love your comment!
Bravo👏
SOS.....My father loved Daniel's version, my mother preferred Grégory Lemarchal's version, as for me, I'll let you guess....🤔 Dimash's version touches me more deeply! There are so many other songs by Daniel Balavoine that you would love, but SOS for me is Dimash's song, he appropriated it and sublimated it! Thanks Phil 🙏
no version is more legitimate than Daniel's, Dimash doesn't have the depth because it's not about him, it's just a cover
Димаш очень сильно проигрывает с этой песней и Даниэлю Балавуану , и Грегори Лемаршалю .Нет глубины исполнения .Один лишь голос , да и то сомнительного качества .
Dimash?😅. Aucunes émotions. Un robot qui prend les chansons des autres.
No it’s Daniel’s song always and forever but there is beautiful others version
Nobody can trust or challenge Daniel....norman spirit
I loved those series ❤ for me Dimash is crushed it to the max 😁 thank you Phil ❤ greetings from Yemen 🇾🇪❤️
Greatings, my friend 🤗 I loved your face expressions while listening 😅👌 I respect the original version, but... light years away from Dimash's, right? 😉 What Dimash touches and sings, he makes it his own, and with a gold cover ✨️ As always, a great reaction! 🫶 Kisses from Portugal, my dear 😘🇵🇹
When you hear a cover by Dimash of a song that is not in your native langage, i can understand that you are impressed. When the song is in your own native langage, things are differents. The langage,the way it sounds, proprerly pronounced, and thus the way the lyrics are given, convey the emotion. The "performance" is not a question of pure technique. That is why, although his technique, i think that Dimash rendition of SOS d'un Terrien en Détresse is not so impressive to my hears.
When I first heard Daniel sing it after hearing Dimash's version, it made me cringe so much that I had to turn it off part way through. Gregory Lemarchal's version was easier on the ears and I can see where Dimash got his version from after hearing Gregory's. It's like he took that as the base for his own cover rather than Daniel's version. The interesting thing is, both Daniel and Gregory died young - Daniel in the helicopter accident and Gregory from Cystic Fibrosis (but he won a big singing competition with this song before he passed away). Dimash seems to be attracted to songs that speak of loss and human tragedy, and this is certainly one of them. Not only is it sung on stage over the dead body of the hero's girlfriend, but two of the singers themselves died in tragic circumstances. Other examples are Sinful Passion (the lead guitarist of A' Studio was killed in a car accident) and Daybreak (the parents died saving their child). I'm enjoying this journey of originals that Dimash later covers. Great idea to do this. Kudos to the person who requested them, great job!
It’s actually concerning, but Dimash’s ability to convey emotion.
В интервью в июле 2018 года, на Славянском базаре, Димаш сказал, что песня Грегори. Вы правы, он взял его версию. Димаш во Франции встречался с сестрой Даниэля Балавуана. Кстати Батырхан Шукенов тоже скончался от сердечного приступа, солист группы А студио.
And of course Dimash turned it into a competition piece. Here it's sang as it was supposed to be sang in the rock opera as a young woman has lost her life and he is utterly devastated ❤
So sad that he died such a tragic death. Nice Reaction Phil! Dimash of course smashed it but I agree, this is a lovely song! ✌️😍🤩🥰❤️🇨🇦
Dimash do it with a lot of drama a lot of acting, Balavoine performance was most real and kinda honest
Dimash cannot sing that song. He has the voice but what he sings is totally incomprehensible. When Daniel sings, each word is clear. Dimesh is in serious need of French lessons
Vous nous saoulez avec dimash ..le vrai artiste c’est Balavoine , pas dimash qui ne fait que chanter la chanson d’un autre
🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️👌👍🥰🫂
Dimash sang this song with a performing perspective while the original version of Balavoine is by far more emotional
There is something to be said for being able to understand every word and the eloquence in which this performance provides versus Dimash's so-so French. I think we can all agree that Dimash takes all the awards in vocal ability, and that, that is the trunk of his talent. From which extends a plethora of branches. I think however from a Frenchman's perspective, this version might be, the preferred version. It has a punch to it, that is just exquisite, and is more relatable to the common man. Even though it has less of a WOW factor. Who knows, Dimash seems to have a continual improvement Factor, so in 5 years he may be singing SOS like a native French speaker. I wouldn't put it past him.
I hope that in 5 years, Dimash will be able to write and sings his own songs.
For me, only Dimash beats the original because the new arrangement of the song is made for Dimash's voice. Daniel is the most emotional for me, of course ❤❤ is a deeply introspective and emotional song that portrays the protagonist's internal struggles and desires. Balavoine's poignant lyrics and passionate delivery offer deep insights into the human experience, delving into themes of existentialism, escapism, and the longing for something beyond the ordinary. The song resonates with anyone who has contemplated their place in the world and aspires to a deeper existence.
Antes de Dimash, nunca conocí esta canción, sin desmerecer para nada a Belavoine. Gracias Phil
The difference between Dimash and Balavoine is that the latter is aware of what he says. He understands it and it feels. While Damish is a good technician but .... I do not understand a word of what he sings in French and I am not sure that he knows.
For a French -speaking the version of Dimash sounds false.
I have the same issue with him.I feel like his vocal acrobatics make a good show but don't convey much emotion, which is why he's over rated for me.
Dimash does understand but I agree that for all his hard work his French lacks authenticity. Lucky for me, there are only a few english words that are mangled to the point of losing meaning. Wind and starve being two.
He obviously is more successful at conveying emotion in Japanese, Russian, and Kazak. 😉 Since I cannot convey anything in either Russian, French or Kazak, I do not criticize.❤
Pour moi, et cela est mon avis personnel, Dimash dégage au contraire énormément d’émotion et de sincérité. Lorsque j’ai écouté son interprétation pour la première fois, j’en ai eu les larmes aux yeux. Daniel Balavoine et Grégory Lemarchal resteront à jamais dans mon cœur, et d’ailleurs je les écoute encore régulièrement. Chacune de leur interprétation est superbe mais complètement différente, et c’est justement cela que j’aime. Dimash apporte sa vision artistique à SOS (intégration du style lyrique, Pop, Rock qu’il adopte). Chaque artiste a son mérite et nous émeut de façon différente, ou pas du tout; mais cela ne veut pas forcément dire que l’artiste en question ne dégage aucune émotion: l’un n’empêche pas l’autre.
Quant à son accent, cela ne me dérange pas du tout. Lorsque Lara Fabian chante en Russe, par exemple, elle a un fort accent également mais je ne me focalise pas dessus. Je préfère me laisser porter par la musique et la voix magistrale de Dimash. Sous prétexte qu’il a un fort accent par endroit, il ne comprend pas ce qu’il chante? Au contraire, c’est bien mal connaître l’artiste: il choisit ses chansons en fonction des paroles et du message qu’il véhicule justement. Bref, je trouve l’interprétation de Dimash magnifique, toute en nuance, et surtout emplie d’émotion!
Sachez enfin que lors de son premier concert à Moscou, une immense photo en noir et blanc de Grégory Lemarchal fut projetée derrière lui, ainsi que celles de plusieurs artistes qu’il admire: cet hommage m’a également ému. C’est un artiste talentueux avec une voix magnifique, mais c’est également un jeune homme que j’admire car, tout comme Balavoine de son vivant, il est impliqué dans les actions humanitaires qui lui tient à cœur, dont récemment Project C.U.R.E, une organisation humanitaire qui envoie des équipements médicaux dans les régions du monde qui en ont besoin.
@@kalliopesensei3023 S"achez enfin que lors de son premier concert à Moscou, une immense photo en noir et blanc de Grégory Lemarchal fut projetée derrière lui". Et c'est une énorme faute de goût et totalement irrespecteux de ne pas avoir mis Daniel Lavoine en tant que créateur (en tant qu'interprète ) de cette chanson. Il fallait mettre les deux ou personnes.
@@philippes.9571 Oh là, mais je ne sais pas comment vous avez pu en venir à la conclusion que Dimash était irrespectueux de ne pas avoir également projeté la photo de Daniel Balavoine… Voyons voir, et si on mettait les choses dans leur contexte pour ainsi dire?
Pour commencer, je vous signale que Dimash est né en 1994. Il avait donc 18 ans en 2012 lorsqu’il a découvert SOS grâce à l’interprétation de Grégory Lemarchal, et non pas celle de Daniel Balavoine.
Ainsi, les projections des artistes à qui il a rendu hommage lors de son concert à Moscou sont les artistes avec qui il a grandi et admiré, Daniel Balavoine n’en faisant pas parti bien qu’il soit l’interprète original de SOS. En résumé, il ne connaît pas Daniel Balavoine comme vous et moi, il n’a donc pas le même attachement. En somme, cela n’a absolument rien à voir avec le manque de respect ou une faute de goût, mais tout à voir avec les artistes qu’il connaît et affectionne.
Daniel Balavoine est mort lorsque j’étais en école primaire, mais mon père en était un grand fan et j’ai grandi avec ses chansons, ce qui n’est pas le cas de Dimash! Il rend hommage aux artistes qui l’ont inspiré, et Daniel Balavoine n’en fait pas parti, tout simplement, même si, effectivement, il est le chanteur original de SOS!
Pour vous donner un autre exemple, c’est comme si je mentionnais dans un article les peintres impressionnistes qui m’ont inspiré le plus dans mon art tels que Renoir, Monet, Paul Cézanne, excepté Édouard Manet alors qu’il est est considéré comme l’instigateur du mouvement impressionniste; mais seulement voilà, pourquoi le mentionner s’il ne fait pas parti de ceux qui m’ont influencé? Vous voyez ce que je veux dire? Ne pas mentionner une personne, n’équivaut pas à un manque de goût ou être irrespectueux. En gros, il ne faudrait pas tout mélanger et remettre les choses dans son contexte.
Cela dit, c’est votre ressenti mais, malheureusement, il est basé sur un malentendu quant aux raisons de son hommage. Je le répète donc encore une fois: il rend hommage aux artistes qu’il admire et affectionne, il ne rend pas hommage aux interprètes de SOS spécifiquement!
Just like my feeling when heard "Ikanaide" from the original singer.
Just feel deeper than Dimash, although Dimash perform it better.