I have only recently got into these knives and I've fallen hard for them. I started with the Victorinox Walker and I was delighted. Then I was lured with a Spartan. Now I love the satisfying ''snap'' when the tools are closed and I love holding them in my hands. I have since bought the Midnight Manager and the Deluxe Tinker and I can't stop
I only own one sak and that is the classic sd . It comes with the toothpick and tweezers .I use it 2 or 3 times a week , had it for 5 years , does most of what need . I would certainly miss it .
To my taste, the best is the old Golfer 84mm with scissors. I have a couple of them. I often carry a Compact. I use the scissors as much as the blade. The best is the old, very rare, Alumnus, a little on the thick side, being three layers. It has all the tools I need.
Dan, just subscribed to your channel. Rapidly turning into a SAK addict. Currently have 18 in the collection. My go to light carry is the cadet, but I got the pioneer in mail yesterday and really like it. Also, to those who have not yet discovered suspension clips, get some and you won’t regret it.
great video I love the small tinker and wenger classic 07. you have very nice and interesting models this wenger snife and wenger black scales are very nice.
Love my Farmer, but the Soldier/Pioneer is great next to a wallet. Otherwise, my Sportsman, Recruit or Tourist fit the bill well, and can't forget the Classic SD.
Liked and subscribed. Relatively new to SAKS, only a couple years into my collection. I've had a Leatherman Skeletool clipped inside my pocket for the better part of a year and it's become a bit too much for me. I went back to a Climber which is much lighter even though it's three layers, and it works for me. Never had an Alox SAK but definitely in the future. The Alox knives look like they'd fit in well in an office environment and almost seem as much of an accessory as a nice watch. I like having scissors but the Highlander would be high on the list too. I prefer the key ring attached as I use a suspension clip to carry my SAK in my pocket so I dont have so much bulk in the bottom of my pocket. Thanks for the vids I've learned more about these knives just this evening than I've learned in the past year.
Thanks, and you're welcome. I've had the Compact on the radar and I just checked it out again. I actually think that'll get me what I need daily and with even less weight, so off to eBay to try and snag a deal on one. Thanks for the suggestion.
I carried an alox Bantam the entirety of last Summer when I was working in Lebanon. It has a special place in my heart. The combo tool is so good and this was my first experience with it.
I have a Classic SD Alox on my keys and a black limited edition Waiter on my pocket. The waiter is really underated by everyone. Looks like a Bantam, but the corkscrew carries the mini flat screwdriver which has a lot of use. For me, this is the best EDC combination.
I edc the alox bantam and alox classic everyday. The greatest combo of all time! The plus tools I carry in my wallet, so I have a complete almost unnoticeable everyday carry. I miss the Vic compact in your line-up, another great carry :-)
I have a spartan,waiter,bantan,swisschamp,minichamp,soldier and a rare champion 6 layers but i carry a Wenger evo!there is a lock blade,scissor and it's very compact!regards from Brasil!
Cellidor Bantam is the most lightweight, I think. But it is too lightweight, sometimes I forget about it and then it lies around in some dinner jacket's pocket. So for formal occasions I prefer the Alox Cadet. It's thin, it's got useful tools and it looks elegant.
In my opinion Sportsman is the more complete: large blade nail file (as small philips screwdriver) bottle opener (also to leverage, screwdriver and wire bender) can opener (as large philips screwdriver) corkscrew (also for the knot + mini screwdriver possibility) reamer/punch (both functions) toothpick tweezer stainless steel pin slot
Nice presentation. For me, the Pioneer (or Soldier) makes for a good urbsn EDC, or even a back up which one can pack in a carry bag or store in the glove compartment.
me too ...for urban living the main side of the climber has EVERYTHING YOU NEED, the pioneer x is as good but i would miss the small blade , my letter opener.
I've carried a wenger highlander since the late 90's but I just got a cadet a few days ago. I love them both. BTW, the Victorinox tinker is the equivalent to the highlander. I has the same setup with the Philips head screw driver.
I carried several Vics over the years. I learned quick that a smaller, lighter one is better for EDC. I have an Executive that works well for me, but I always find myself going back to a three or four layer 91. I have 84's both cellidor and alox, although those are just for the collection..... But I think that the scale tools on the celli are must haves. I am one of those gross people who use the toothpick DAILY. :0) Plus, my work requires me to move pallets occasionally so I get splinters. That means no alox for EDC. On a side note, I have carried both a 111 Fireman slide lock and a Rescue tool as EDC for many years! Now THOSE are heavy and big!
The Victorinox classic is the best knife! (the most sold SAK ever!) I do carry a manager as it had perfect screwdriver, bottle opener and a pen - I normally do not need a pen but then I need it it's really saving some trips also pen works as bathroom door opener if my two year old locks himself in. And pen is mightier then a knife. still the most used EDC tool is a smartphone.
I say the "Alox Bantam" or the "Ambassador" with Dress Slacks. Or, the "Rambler" would cover All your needs , small knife , scissors , file , bottle opener , small Phillips screwdriver , toothpick , tweezers perfect for a day at the Office.Or even better yet, it might be better to be at home with All your SAKs and not be at the Office , then you can carry Any SAK you want 😁👍👍 Decisions , Decisions Dan 😁
The walker is slim and cool, if a bit impractical in urban areas. The saw works great on plastic clamshells and the like. I carry a super tinker, a waiter, a walker, an electrician, or (rarely) a spartan. I own a cadet, and that or my waiter combined with a classic on the keys would be my slim carry. I also have a sportsman in nylon, and I hang that off my archery quiver.
This guy gets it. Trying to go with a 2 oz SAK, but it’s hard if you want to buy any new knives that are practical. Seems like most knives Victorinox makes are 58mm keychain style knives or 91mm “full-size” knives. 85mm options are limited. I’d go custom, but that can get expensive. Ideal tool would be a special mechanic, th that’s crazy difficult to find and super expensive on eBay. Hopefully Victorinox will continue to innovate and give us more capable medium-size lightweight knives.
For me the Wengers are out because of their can opener and the Evo scales feel good in the hand but they're not pocket friendly. If I'm dressed up and have to take something light I alternate between the Cadet, the Sportsman and the Waiter. Plus I always have a Vic Money Clip so I have the scissors.
The Manager with pressurized pen is always in my pocket, except when I'm sleeping or under the shower. Than I like the Golfer 84mm and the Compact (one of my favorite). Lately I got an Alumnus 84mm with shissors, a little bulky beeing a three layers. If I need a blade and whish to be minimal I opt for a Waiter.
For me I love scissors. Absolute smallest would be 58mm alox. However, to me anything 3 layer or below is perfect. Wenger Teton or Traveler, then Victorinox Pioneer X, Compact and Climber are favorites. I do like the Victorinox Evo 14 for a locking SAK.
Hello Dan For me, the Bantam is a little to minimalistic. The Cadet is ideal for me if it has scissors. I am currently using a Sportsman (with a Classic SD Alox in the keychain) and it is great! I would like to give it a try to the Pioneer X... Greetings from Guatemala!
Leaning more towards the tinker because it's part of the WWP series. Will probably go back later for a Spartan and/or Pioneer and/or hiker/camper later
@@2371Anita I was able to visit your beautiful country many years ago while I was living in DE. Have you joined the Swiss Army Knights on forum.multitool.org?
I like the cadet alox myself. 2 layers yet still thin and lightweight with everything one may need with a decent sized blade. Much tighter of a package than say a pioneer which are the standard in the alox models imo.
I love the combo cap lifter/can opener tool. My Compact model has it. All of your knives are great although I'm used to carrying beefier ones. Anyway, you can't go wrong with a Victorinox knife. Hold tight to your Wenger because they've been more and more difficult to find these days since the company was taken over by Victorinox in 2015.
I have effectively the whole 'evolution' range but in the walnut skins. It is surprising how light the wood makes the knives. Especially compared to the larger pioneer and 91mm range
I don't think you had one there that had a saw.... IMO Swiss Champ is #1 and the bulk and weight is a lot easier to carry around than most people think. #2 is the Huntsman for all the basic tools including scissors and saw. #3 is the Trekker for everyday carry as EDC one hand open knife with locking blade. And if I was to go completely ultra light yet still stay functional, I would go with the Walker and the Bantam if I am wearing a suite or need my knife to be very slim.
I currently carry a waiter (84 mm) with the corkscrew swapped out for a Phillips screwdriver from a small tinker (84 mm)....easy mod. My next knife will have all the features of the 3 layer Hiker (91 mm) in a 2 layer 84 mm knife: get a small Tinker (84 mm) and swap out the two short blades ( can opener and bottlecap lifter) with a wood saw and a combo tool taken from the Walker (84 mm).... a perfect marriage requiring just a little file work to clear the tip of the saw down into the knife by trimming down the back spring on that end of the knife. I wish Victorinox would sell that from the factory...call it the "Small Hiker" ...I bet it would be a big seller.
Must have scissors, so 58mm classic it is. The Alox Classic gorgeously slim and only 16gms. Also, I have an aversion to the corkscrew as it creates an unpleasant hot spot when gripping hard, although when fitted with the eyeglass mini driver, the grip is a lot better.
I kinda wish the cadet had thicker more rounded aluminum scales like the 91mm but kept the 84mm size. But of course that’s the one thing I’ll always hate about victorinox, no matter what option you go for, your always going to miss that one tool that keeps it out of the perfect 1 and done pocket multi tool.
I carry a tinker everyday. If I had to wear slacks everyday I’d go with the cadet. Maybe a Compact. I think it best to retain functionality even when going small.
I've used Huntsman for like 15+ years, and it was so useful all these years. I even used the saw to cut some branches in the orchard. You can use it in areas where no other saw would fit. But then I lost it somewhere in the appartment and cannot find it) So I got the Outrider, and I love it. It's like Huntsman on steroids, so powerful, with knife lock. Now I'm thinking about something smaller like Bantam or Compact. One of the best variants I've seen is a mod called Compact Alox. But that is pretty expensive to make.
How’s this for a solution... classic sd on your keys and use and a bike inner tube sheath on your belt? Obviously choose a size that slips over your belt and cut it allowing for an extra 10mm either side of your knife. I carry my alox bantam like that even wearing a suit and it just hides in plain site and you don’t notice it’s even there. The best place for it to lay flat is either side of you flies inside one belt loop. If you fix it on the side where your belt overlaps when done up then that’s stealth mode territory!😂 I found 120mm hides the silver ends of the bantam and helps to hold it in place. Beauty of it is being a tube you can push the knife out either end. It just sits there held in by friction.
I'm a pastor and wear dress pants a lot ,I've found a climber with a nano clip on the ring holds it vertically and no one else can tell. That said spartan is my next choice with a nano clip.
I would love to add some original Wenger models to my collection but since I would have to trade or buy a pre-owned I'm paranoid about getting scammed. I know there are a lot of honest people out there but I'm not confident in my abilities to find and trust the right people
Spartan for every day is ideal no need for scissors even if you fish the s mall blade is perfect for cutting the edges in a knots No need for pholips too spartan small screw is perfect for philips I drink wine
@@swissarmydan9354 Finally after becoming junkie with vic I end for urban edc with a bandam allox and a manager in a keychain Lol for out dours a wenger everest Or a hercules or a handyman or or or lol
I allways prefere to have two blades on my SAK so I'd go with the Tourist for light edc. I only wish they put a small blade instead of the useless nail file on the Cadet.
To answer you in the corkscrew. I think I’d rather omit that. I don’t open wine or drink alcohol, so I’d rather have a philips there or nothing at all. The philips feels good in the hand. I think that’s the advantage of omitting the back tool. Better feel in pocket and hand.
Thank you everyone.. Actually I've bought the Recruit and it's cool.. Has the large and the small blade.. Also the can, bottle opener makes it look like a real multi tool :3 In my country people think that only robbers carry blades :') So recruit is the one that suits me I believe :')
Good video, Dan. I've had, and have, a bunch of SAK's. One of the first things I do with a new one is remove the key ring and file off the tab. I hate that thing It gets in the way, causes hot spots (and blisters), and wears holes in my pockets. Life is just slightly better without it..
I like the Wenger Highlander. I’ve had/carried a translucent model for several years, but now that it is out of production I’ve decided to sharpen/clean it and set it aside for special occasions. Now I’m carrying a 3-layer Camper, which I really do like (I’d trade the corkscrew for a phillips though...), but after watching your video I think I may keep an eye out for something slimmer on dress up days (I don’t work in an office). Great video, thanks for the comparisons!
An alox cadet or compact ... Or a bantam for 1 oz ... I love your alox bantam ... I want one but not at $57 with shipping ... I wish Victorinox would bring that alox bantam back ...
@@xrysoryba I just caught this reply ... I have a cellador bantam that is very comfortable but I never thought about how it would handle with the thinner alox frame ... Thanks for the heads up ...
@ Rick Temmen... Also, there is a shockingly big difference in how well 2 or 3 of the very same tools work in hand between my new Night Manager and my Classic SDs. The handle is as important... or *more* so, than the tools themselves in determining the knife's effective utility on the task.
@@frederickj.7136 Very good point ... Thanks. BTW Is the manager more difficult to handle then you SD ... I have a couple Ramblers and many SD's and I haven't had any handling issues with any of those ... I have never owned a Manager ...
A latter model Voyageur might serve you well. Combine with a Rally for the file and Phillips. I most often carry a Compact with a Rally. Now I'll shut up before I start ranting about how Vx gets rid of some of their best knives. Oops, too late.
I have only recently got into these knives and I've fallen hard for them. I started with the Victorinox Walker and I was delighted. Then I was lured with a Spartan. Now I love the satisfying ''snap'' when the tools are closed and I love holding them in my hands. I have since bought the Midnight Manager and the Deluxe Tinker and I can't stop
I only own one sak and that is the classic sd . It comes with the toothpick and tweezers .I use it 2 or 3 times a week , had it for 5 years , does most of what need . I would certainly miss it .
Still the sd?
@debian_i3 i posted that 4 or 5 years ago . I still have it .
To my taste, the best is the old Golfer 84mm with scissors. I have a couple of them. I often carry a Compact. I use the scissors as much as the blade. The best is the old, very rare, Alumnus, a little on the thick side, being three layers. It has all the tools I need.
Best all around for me is the Alox Bantam and a Celidor Classic SD in the 1st aid kit.
Dan, just subscribed to your channel. Rapidly turning into a SAK addict. Currently have 18 in the collection. My go to light carry is the cadet, but I got the pioneer in mail yesterday and really like it. Also, to those who have not yet discovered suspension clips, get some and you won’t regret it.
What do you use now after six years?
Thanks for including all the metric measurements too, I can understand and convert inches but I never understood ounces. Great video
great video I love the small tinker and wenger classic 07. you have very nice and interesting models this wenger snife and wenger black scales are very nice.
Love my Farmer, but the Soldier/Pioneer is great next to a wallet. Otherwise, my Sportsman, Recruit or Tourist fit the bill well, and can't forget the Classic SD.
Liked and subscribed. Relatively new to SAKS, only a couple years into my collection. I've had a Leatherman Skeletool clipped inside my pocket for the better part of a year and it's become a bit too much for me. I went back to a Climber which is much lighter even though it's three layers, and it works for me. Never had an Alox SAK but definitely in the future. The Alox knives look like they'd fit in well in an office environment and almost seem as much of an accessory as a nice watch. I like having scissors but the Highlander would be high on the list too. I prefer the key ring attached as I use a suspension clip to carry my SAK in my pocket so I dont have so much bulk in the bottom of my pocket. Thanks for the vids I've learned more about these knives just this evening than I've learned in the past year.
CWB wow, great comment! Thanks for watching! Have you tried the compact?
Thanks, and you're welcome. I've had the Compact on the radar and I just checked it out again. I actually think that'll get me what I need daily and with even less weight, so off to eBay to try and snag a deal on one. Thanks for the suggestion.
@@swissarmydan9354 just wear a pair of WRANGLER jeans and put your multi-tool in the key pocket of your WRANGLER jeans.
I carried an alox Bantam the entirety of last Summer when I was working in Lebanon. It has a special place in my heart. The combo tool is so good and this was my first experience with it.
For keychain my favorites is Manager
I have a Classic SD Alox on my keys and a black limited edition Waiter on my pocket. The waiter is really underated by everyone. Looks like a Bantam, but the corkscrew carries the mini flat screwdriver which has a lot of use. For me, this is the best EDC combination.
The Hiker is an excellent EDC . Good urban and camper utilities.
I edc the alox bantam and alox classic everyday. The greatest combo of all time! The plus tools I carry in my wallet, so I have a complete almost unnoticeable everyday carry. I miss the Vic compact in your line-up, another great carry :-)
Midnight manager has it all. Carry it on key chain everyday
I have one and I use it everyday. In my opinion its the handiest little tool in the world
I have a spartan,waiter,bantan,swisschamp,minichamp,soldier and a rare champion 6 layers but i carry a Wenger evo!there is a lock blade,scissor and it's very compact!regards from Brasil!
i have a few, but i rotate my EDC between a Spartan, pioneer, and deluxe tinker. thanks for the video!
Cellidor Bantam is the most lightweight, I think. But it is too lightweight, sometimes I forget about it and then it lies around in some dinner jacket's pocket. So for formal occasions I prefer the Alox Cadet. It's thin, it's got useful tools and it looks elegant.
Just found an old serrated Recruit that I had. Very compact little knife, especially if you do not need any back tools
In my opinion Sportsman is the more complete:
large blade
nail file (as small philips screwdriver)
bottle opener (also to leverage, screwdriver and wire bender)
can opener (as large philips screwdriver)
corkscrew (also for the knot + mini screwdriver possibility)
reamer/punch (both functions)
toothpick
tweezer
stainless steel pin slot
Nice presentation. For me, the Pioneer (or Soldier) makes for a good urbsn EDC, or even a back up which one can pack in a carry bag or store in the glove compartment.
for me the climber is the best!
Me too!
me too ...for urban living the main side of the climber has EVERYTHING YOU NEED, the pioneer x is as good but i would miss the small blade , my letter opener.
The climber really is a thing of beauty.
Only the hook that isn’t useful
If you wear super tight jeans it's useful for pulling the zipper up lol
@@GadgetMart I actually like the hook :-) Handy for twisting or untwisting wire loops, tightening laces or string, carrying heavy gift bags etc.
I've carried a wenger highlander since the late 90's but I just got a cadet a few days ago. I love them both. BTW, the Victorinox tinker is the equivalent to the highlander. I has the same setup with the Philips head screw driver.
I carried several Vics over the years. I learned quick that a smaller, lighter one is better for EDC. I have an Executive that works well for me, but I always find myself going back to a three or four layer 91. I have 84's both cellidor and alox, although those are just for the collection..... But I think that the scale tools on the celli are must haves. I am one of those gross people who use the toothpick DAILY. :0) Plus, my work requires me to move pallets occasionally so I get splinters. That means no alox for EDC.
On a side note, I have carried both a 111 Fireman slide lock and a Rescue tool as EDC for many years! Now THOSE are heavy and big!
Mine is a Alox Bantam ever since december last year. Hasn't been out of my pocket yet. I also have a Alox Classic on the key chain.
I have the same two. They're both so incredibly thin at 6mm -- 2/3 of the normal Classics even. Feel incredibly solid.
I carry the 84 small tinker
It's a great carry. I favor the Tourist at the moment. Thanks for watching! Cheers!
I normally carry the standard tinker or the evo 11
The Victorinox classic is the best knife! (the most sold SAK ever!) I do carry a manager as it had perfect screwdriver, bottle opener and a pen - I normally do not need a pen but then I need it it's really saving some trips also pen works as bathroom door opener if my two year old locks himself in. And pen is mightier then a knife. still the most used EDC tool is a smartphone.
shpyrko great comment! Thanks for watching!
Swiss Army Dan thank you for making this video(s)! Really nice reviews! Very informative and interesting!
I say the "Alox Bantam" or the "Ambassador" with Dress Slacks. Or, the "Rambler" would cover All your needs , small knife , scissors , file , bottle opener , small Phillips screwdriver , toothpick , tweezers perfect for a day at the Office.Or even better yet, it might be better to be at home with All your SAKs and not be at the Office , then you can carry Any SAK you want 😁👍👍 Decisions , Decisions Dan 😁
The walker is slim and cool, if a bit impractical in urban areas. The saw works great on plastic clamshells and the like.
I carry a super tinker, a waiter, a walker, an electrician, or (rarely) a spartan. I own a cadet, and that or my waiter combined with a classic on the keys would be my slim carry. I also have a sportsman in nylon, and I hang that off my archery quiver.
I prefer the Compact, but that Pioneer Apprentice looks like it's worth checking out!
I like the secretary for work, i carry it in my back pocket and use it for small tasks like sharpening my pencil etc
Thanks for watching, Will! The secretary really disappears in the pocket too! Cheers!
I usually remove the key ring points on my edc SAKs
This guy gets it. Trying to go with a 2 oz SAK, but it’s hard if you want to buy any new knives that are practical. Seems like most knives Victorinox makes are 58mm keychain style knives or 91mm “full-size” knives. 85mm options are limited. I’d go custom, but that can get expensive. Ideal tool would be a special mechanic, th that’s crazy difficult to find and super expensive on eBay. Hopefully Victorinox will continue to innovate and give us more capable medium-size lightweight knives.
For me the Wengers are out because of their can opener and the Evo scales feel good in the hand but they're not pocket friendly. If I'm dressed up and have to take something light I alternate between the Cadet, the Sportsman and the Waiter. Plus I always have a Vic Money Clip so I have the scissors.
The Manager with pressurized pen is always in my pocket, except when I'm sleeping or under the shower. Than I like the Golfer 84mm and the Compact (one of my favorite). Lately I got an Alumnus 84mm with shissors, a little bulky beeing a three layers. If I need a blade and whish to be minimal I opt for a Waiter.
The Manager is great! It really goes well with a Bantam or Waiter. I still don't have an Alumnus, what a great SAK! Love my Climber Small.
I carry dedicated knife anyway so I go with Jetsetter with a ballpoint pen scale. I took it from Mini Champ. For me, that is the perfect combination.
For me the compact, dose it all ,I have 3 of them and its always with me
For me I love scissors. Absolute smallest would be 58mm alox. However, to me anything 3 layer or below is perfect. Wenger Teton or Traveler, then Victorinox Pioneer X, Compact and Climber are favorites. I do like the Victorinox Evo 14 for a locking SAK.
Hello Dan
For me, the Bantam is a little to minimalistic. The Cadet is ideal for me if it has scissors.
I am currently using a Sportsman (with a Classic SD Alox in the keychain) and it is great! I would like to give it a try to the Pioneer X...
Greetings from Guatemala!
What is the model/name of the first knife you show, the one a viewer (Graham) sent you?
Best lightweight EDC Swiss army is the alox solo.
I totally agree. Perfect blade, strong spring and no key ring for hot spots. Very light and good looking.
Super Tinker has been my EDC for many years, has everything I need.
Leaning more towards the tinker because it's part of the WWP series. Will probably go back later for a Spartan and/or Pioneer and/or hiker/camper later
great collection
Darn, I need people sending me some victorinox swiss army knives! 😍
Anita,, in which country are you located? Holland?
Yes, the Netherlands! 🇳🇱😊
@@2371Anita I was able to visit your beautiful country many years ago while I was living in DE. Have you joined the Swiss Army Knights on forum.multitool.org?
@@swissarmydan9354 I just did! Thanks.
I like the cadet alox myself. 2 layers yet still thin and lightweight with everything one may need with a decent sized blade. Much tighter of a package than say a pioneer which are the standard in the alox models imo.
I would choose the rambler if I only carried a 58mm. A step up from that would be a cadet or a sportsman.
I love the combo cap lifter/can opener tool. My Compact model has it. All of your knives are great although I'm used to carrying beefier ones. Anyway, you can't go wrong with a Victorinox knife. Hold tight to your Wenger because they've been more and more difficult to find these days since the company was taken over by Victorinox in 2015.
For ease of carry and utility without overlap, the Tourist is my pick. 👌
I've been carrying the Tourist lately... Excellent point about lack of overlap. Tfw. Cheers!
The cadet is my pick and my EDC
Midnight Manager (58 mm, in key-chain) + Compact (91 mm) or Cadet (84 mm; when minimalist EDC is needed)
I'd go with either a manager or an ambassador.
I have effectively the whole 'evolution' range but in the walnut skins. It is surprising how light the wood makes the knives. Especially compared to the larger pioneer and 91mm range
I don't think you had one there that had a saw.... IMO Swiss Champ is #1 and the bulk and weight is a lot easier to carry around than most people think. #2 is the Huntsman for all the basic tools including scissors and saw. #3 is the Trekker for everyday carry as EDC one hand open knife with locking blade. And if I was to go completely ultra light yet still stay functional, I would go with the Walker and the Bantam if I am wearing a suite or need my knife to be very slim.
Spartan is all you need ❤️
I currently carry a waiter (84 mm) with the corkscrew swapped out for a Phillips screwdriver from a small tinker (84 mm)....easy mod.
My next knife will have all the features of the 3 layer Hiker (91 mm) in a 2 layer 84 mm knife:
get a small Tinker (84 mm) and swap out the two short blades ( can opener and bottlecap lifter) with a wood saw and a combo tool taken from the Walker (84 mm).... a perfect marriage requiring just a little file work to clear the tip of the saw down into the knife by trimming down the back spring on that end of the knife.
I wish Victorinox would sell that from the factory...call it the "Small Hiker" ...I bet it would be a big seller.
PS I always have my Rambler with my keys ... It has everything you need
Agree! I also carry Rambler
Must have scissors, so 58mm classic it is. The Alox Classic gorgeously slim and only 16gms. Also, I have an aversion to the corkscrew as it creates an unpleasant hot spot when gripping hard, although when fitted with the eyeglass mini driver, the grip is a lot better.
Wenger classic 63 and Wenger evolution 81 are cool knives, both lightweight
Where to look for what year it is made?
I kinda wish the cadet had thicker more rounded aluminum scales like the 91mm but kept the 84mm size. But of course that’s the one thing I’ll always hate about victorinox, no matter what option you go for, your always going to miss that one tool that keeps it out of the perfect 1 and done pocket multi tool.
I carry a tinker everyday. If I had to wear slacks everyday I’d go with the cadet. Maybe a Compact. I think it best to retain functionality even when going small.
I've used Huntsman for like 15+ years, and it was so useful all these years. I even used the saw to cut some branches in the orchard. You can use it in areas where no other saw would fit. But then I lost it somewhere in the appartment and cannot find it) So I got the Outrider, and I love it. It's like Huntsman on steroids, so powerful, with knife lock. Now I'm thinking about something smaller like Bantam or Compact. One of the best variants I've seen is a mod called Compact Alox. But that is pretty expensive to make.
The dilemma of having too many options lol, it's why I have to limit myself 😕
I carry the Compact in my khakis at work.
How’s this for a solution... classic sd on your keys and use and a bike inner tube sheath on your belt? Obviously choose a size that slips over your belt and cut it allowing for an extra 10mm either side of your knife. I carry my alox bantam like that even wearing a suit and it just hides in plain site and you don’t notice it’s even there. The best place for it to lay flat is either side of you flies inside one belt loop. If you fix it on the side where your belt overlaps when done up then that’s stealth mode territory!😂 I found 120mm hides the silver ends of the bantam and helps to hold it in place. Beauty of it is being a tube you can push the knife out either end. It just sits there held in by friction.
Thomas Harrison , this is an interesting idea, I think I will give it a try. Thanks for the suggestion!
I'm a pastor and wear dress pants a lot ,I've found a climber with a nano clip on the ring holds it vertically and no one else can tell. That said spartan is my next choice with a nano clip.
You deserve more subs
Thanks for returning and for the kind words. :) Cheers!
Swiss Army Dan You're welcome, keep up the good work!
I would love to add some original Wenger models to my collection but since I would have to trade or buy a pre-owned I'm paranoid about getting scammed. I know there are a lot of honest people out there but I'm not confident in my abilities to find and trust the right people
The manager is the bomb
It sure is, it's great by itself and it's the perfect complement to a large number of SAKs. Thanks for watching! Cheers!
Loved my Golfer till Spanish airport security took it . . . Pocket Pal or Cadet for small SAK carry . . .
How can you call yourself an ambassador if you can't open a bottle of beer or wine? LOL
the recruit or hiker. you have it really tough trying to pick from your goo goo gobs of saks, first world problems eh, Dan? :-D
Spartan for every day is ideal
no need for scissors even if you fish the s mall blade is perfect for cutting the edges in a knots
No need for pholips too spartan small screw is perfect for philips
I drink wine
No argument here! Thanks for watching, my friend! Cheers!
@@swissarmydan9354
Finally after becoming junkie with vic
I end for urban edc
with a bandam allox and a manager in a keychain
Lol for out dours
a wenger everest
Or a hercules or a handyman or or or lol
Tinker.
I allways prefere to have two blades on my SAK so I'd go with the Tourist for light edc. I only wish they put a small blade instead of the useless nail file on the Cadet.
The Cadet is cool but I really like the toothpick and it doesn't have one.
I would like a lightweight with a saw and one blade
Check out the Walker! It used to be called the Lumberjack. 84mm
Cheers!
To answer you in the corkscrew. I think I’d rather omit that. I don’t open wine or drink alcohol, so I’d rather have a philips there or nothing at all. The philips feels good in the hand. I think that’s the advantage of omitting the back tool. Better feel in pocket and hand.
I like my tinker
Hello everyone.. I just need the large and the small blade SAK... Can anyone please suggest me one?!
Morshedul Rifat unfortunately the 2 blade combo is only available in the 84mm & 91mm sizes as far as I know. Maybe a pocket pal?
Swiss Army Dan Thanks :') I think the Bantam looks good.. I'll go for that one
If you just need large and small blade maybe you'll like the Victorinox excelsior.
Thank you everyone.. Actually I've bought the Recruit and it's cool.. Has the large and the small blade.. Also the can, bottle opener makes it look like a real multi tool :3 In my country people think that only robbers carry blades :') So recruit is the one that suits me I believe :')
@@morshed492 great choice! It was good enough for MacGyver!!! :) cheers!
I carry the Rambler
Thanks for watching, Alejandro! I MO the Rambler/ Manager is the best 58mm SAK. Cheers!
Tough decision my friend....I guess a pioneer will be perfect, but guess that all depends on the combo of tools you might need. Cheers!!!
can i put vaseline like a lubricant instead oil for SAK?alternative?
Good video, Dan.
I've had, and have, a bunch of SAK's. One of the first things I do with a new one is remove the key ring and file off the tab. I hate that thing It gets in the way, causes hot spots (and blisters), and wears holes in my pockets. Life is just slightly better without it..
Which 84mm with scissors ?
I meant to say scissors not knife.
I like the Wenger Highlander. I’ve had/carried a translucent model for several years, but now that it is out of production I’ve decided to sharpen/clean it and set it aside for special occasions. Now I’m carrying a 3-layer Camper, which I really do like (I’d trade the corkscrew for a phillips though...), but after watching your video I think I may keep an eye out for something slimmer on dress up days (I don’t work in an office).
Great video, thanks for the comparisons!
Tinker!!
come on man where is the Swiss champ lol good video thanks Swiss army Dan
Bantam Alox here
Cadet huge fan for EDC
Hey do you know which Swiss Army knife is with scissors and pliers?
Bri O hi! Thanks for watching! The Deluxe Tinker has both the scissors and Pliers. Cheers!
Swiss Army Dan Thank you very much the video was great ! Subscribing
An alox cadet or compact ... Or a bantam for 1 oz ... I love your alox bantam ... I want one but not at $57 with shipping ... I wish Victorinox would bring that alox bantam back ...
I really lusted after an alox Bantam till I got one. To me it's really too thin to be comfortable to use, but it is great for carry.
@@xrysoryba I just caught this reply ... I have a cellador bantam that is very comfortable but I never thought about how it would handle with the thinner alox frame ... Thanks for the heads up ...
@ Rick Temmen... Also, there is a shockingly big difference in how well 2 or 3 of the very same tools work in hand between my new Night Manager and my Classic SDs. The handle is as important... or *more* so, than the tools themselves in determining the knife's effective utility on the task.
@@frederickj.7136 Very good point ... Thanks. BTW Is the manager more difficult to handle then you SD ... I have a couple Ramblers and many SD's and I haven't had any handling issues with any of those ... I have never owned a Manager ...
Spartan 👌
A latter model Voyageur might serve you well. Combine with a Rally for the file and Phillips. I most often carry a Compact with a Rally. Now I'll shut up before I start ranting about how Vx gets rid of some of their best knives. Oops, too late.
Leatherman squirt, very small and all the tools you will ever need.
Tourist is my choice, i like to drink some wine so corkscrew is important tool for me.
Climber 👍🏼
I'm not a fan of the keyring. I usually Dremmel them off.
I want this knife sir
You never identified the first knife!!!
He did later on. It's the Alox Bantam.