I’m almost 60 years old and I STILL have a Mother that lets me know how important I am and that she loves me. I wish this blessing for every child and adult.
@@treehuger1978 You're right. And parents have a fundamental right to raise their children. The law doesn't require perfection of parents in order to return children to them.
@@runninbyfaith777 Yes, they always feel remorse AFTER the fact. When will they all stand up as a group and DEMAND our government adequately funds this organization so they can do the job they need to? It's an unforgivable travesty that decade after decade we bury child after child because CPS was unable to protect them.
@Sara Allison Yes, but there are certain crimes that inmates _DON'T_ like/tolerate... Crimes on babies is one of them... i.e, sex crimes/murder of children, _especially_ a barely 3 month old baby.
@Sara Allison shes already said she had to be seperated from other inmates. Since the women tell her to hang herself everynight or they will kill her themselves.. but yes my sister works in a womens prison their is a lot of baby killers on womens prisons.
That woman hasn't picked her face up and made eye contact with anyone, except for the rage tantrum she threw with the prosecutor. She cried for herself and herself alone. This is so disgusting.
Also when the foster mother was speaking.She didn't even look up. All she had to do was give baby Dylan back to her. Could have been such a different ending.
I would love an update on the 15 year old son and the foster mother. I can’t imagine how strong they had to be to endure this, they are both absolute angels.
From what I see on public post on Facebook he's doing great. His Aunt & Uncle are raising him her name is Phyllis and Daniel is the second. He seems to be a smart, well mannered Senior now!! I pray he continues on that path, and blessings to his Aunt & Uncle as well.
Lisa Simpson using the statement “passed away” is not a cause of death. It’s simply a nice way to say “someone died”. Therefore, it was used today in court by the defense to lesson the impact on what these monsters did. They murdered their child. The defense will never use the phrase murdered. Using “passed away” is a lie. He was “killed” He was “murdered”.
The fact that the "mother" stopped crying after the judge said he found no genuine remorse from the mother, it's like the "mom" thought ok I can stop acting now.
I just hope he finds people who care about him and that he finds some semblance of happiness. This trauma will follow him. But with enough help and care he could move on with his life.
The Judge should of made it part of their sentencing that they can no longer have contact with him and their parenting rights taken away immediately forever!! They’ve already done enough damage to this poor boy . Him and his now deceased brother deserved so much better than these two piece of shits!!! I pray now that they are locked away he will get counseling and thrived in his mew life. ♥️
@@MMGV1992 One is legally the mother (jessica) and the other is a mother from the heart. One is crying for Dylan and the other is just sorry she got caught (jessica)... i wouldnt call that a mother either but legally she was... not anymore
@leny let's get one thing straight. Just because Jessica was the hole Dylan came out of don't mean she was ever a mom. The foster mom cried more than the baby's parents.
The foster mum would have rocked baby Dylan many times throughout the nights as he was going through withdrawals. She would have lovingly cared for him even if she was sleep deprived. Baby Dylan should have NEVER been taken from her. My heart goes out to her, she is what makes a true foster parent. Rest in Paradise Baby Dylan ❤❤
My oldest daughter has fostered and adopted 6 of them. All drug exposed and they suffered. I wish that precious baby would have been able to stay with the person who truly loved him and she did her best to help him through that torture. Rest well baby Dylan 👼💙🙏🕊️
Babies born on drugs are very irritable, cry regardless of what is done. You have to continue to give Iv meds in hospital to help. At home this child never stopped crying, won’t feed, won’t sleep and are many time shaken, hit, thrown etc. that will kill the baby. So if on drugs baby should have been left in foster home.
I was so glad she spoke for Dylan. If she hadn't, there would have been no one to speak for him, or shed sincere tears for his loss. She was the only light he ever had in his tiny tortured life.
I can see right through this. Neither of them are remorseful. The father is angry that he is being held accountable, and the mother is trying to get out of a life sentence. This is so sad.
I'm sorry, but if it was up to me after they were sentenced a week later I'd enforce the death penalty. Instead of these monsters living out thier lives not paying bills free food, cloths, roof over thier head, NO! ONE WEEK! THEN THE GET THE CHAIR! LETHAL INJECTION! EITHER WAY, 1 WEEK!
That prosecutor looked absolutely exhausted but she was exactly who Dylan needed to fight for his justice and she did exactly that and I really hope she's okay and taking care after all this. As for the fostermom, I hope she's okay and providing other vunerable children a home.
Why the F were these low life's given custody of the poor little baby when their older son was taken away from child services earlier?? Does that make any sense?
@@LouisianaSaturdayNight yeah even though her testimony was definitely needed. She helped establish the timeline and she reported Daniel's demeanor to CPS. It shows that CPS knew he was possibly using and they still sent Dylan with the father. CPS should be on trial for endangering that baby
Yeah that foster mom you can tell she really wanted that baby and the picture of her with the baby is so precious she was excited to have him but the” drug mother” Jessica, You could tell she just wanted to get rid of him she didn’t deserve a baby like Dylan he wasn’t even given a chance..
I was diagnosed with uterine cancer when I was 26. I can't have children. People like this make me so sick. I am so hurt by this. Having children is a privilege. A gift from God that not everyone on earth received. Shame on them. Bless the foster mom. She made me cry. This whole thing has broke my heart. At least he had 1 mommy who loves him. And it wasn't the bitch that birthed him.
I’m so sorry you can’t have children! For you to have to watch these parents kill their little baby when you would have loved with all your heart to have a child must kill you. God bless you!
It hurts so bad to watch people like this have kids so effortlessly and then discard them like trash. It's a different kind of hurt for women like us who will never have that experience. We can adopt or foster in some cases but never get to feel a baby kick or have morning sickness or put the baby in your arms after 9 months. It just sucks so bad.
How can anybody do this to a baby? I lost my baby son aged 10 months 52 years ago and I still long for him every day. May God have mercy on those parents. I cannot.
Your God asks you to forgive. Maybe you should practice your religion. I am sorry you lost your baby boy. Losing a child is one of the hardest things anyone goes through and your baby is never forgotten. This lady may not have been a good Mom at this time in her life but ask any 5 year old child what she wants to be when she grows up and she is not going to say "I want to be a drug addict" or "I want to kill a baby I gave birth to and then put him down a well".
@@neridaduncan2710 Drug use is not and NEVER WILL BE an excuse for doing ANYTHING!!! You make a solid CHOICE to do drugs in the first place and anything from there on is STILL on your shoulders!!! PERIOD!!!
@@salinal2783 addiction is a mental illness. someone can make the choice to do drugs but they are addictive and if the person is predisposed to addiction, they will get addicted. addiction is not a choice. if it were, no one would be addicted
Greatest respect for the judge's decisions in this case and for explaining why he made them as he did. No nonsense, just good sense. What a relief to see this! Thanks for posting.
@@personalcheeses8073 they took him from foster parents who loved and cared for him and gave him back to these monsters who did hard drugs while pregnant and was found to be unfit. . A short time later he was found beaten and dead. Yes, they did something very wrong.
@@noneofyourbusiness302 so the constitution is unconcievable? Got it. You know....if you'd ever commit a felony you'd embrace a legal defense with open arms. Don't be a hypocrite.
She doesn't even address her dead son or her living one. She apologizes to the man in charge of her sentencing. Not to her baby boy, and not to the older son she leaves behind
@@reginahumphres9293 You're insane. The baby was born with meth in his system and was placed in foster care. The mother never rehabilitated and in her drug induced rage, she injured the infant repeatedly. The son wasn't even living in the home consistently.
@@ChanelGreer your right I'm insane. I missed the part about meth being in baby. I full like a dog now. Thank you for putting me strat. I must be easy to get over on.
He will suffer the absence of his parents deep in his heart because right now he is sad, angry, upset, full of hate at the same time and heart broken because if his parents's actions. He will miss his baby brother as well too. Hope he seems God for healing and him able to forgive his parents for his own peace. Hope his parents seek God and repent for them to be forgiven by God because that is all what they can do for now til death. God is the only hope for everyone. Every baby is a blessing and it made me sad what that poor baby went through 😢.
Let's not forget Dylan s foster dad,he also must have loved him,he has sat beside his wife daily looking sick with sorrow but comforting his wife through this terrible ordeal
He knew her for 24 years she raised one child without any of this behaviour, how many of us would react with the same disbelief. I love how all you perfect people out there judge others.
@@TheGiulioSeverini i did too. I buried a child. He died in an accident. I just cannot for the life of me. As long as I live. I never be able understand parents like these. It goes against the grain, particularly of mother’s. As the instinct to protect esp a newborn, should be particularly strong. Just unreal.
"Despite her elocution here today, I find that, throughout these proceedings, she has shown no genuine remorse." Judge saw right through those crocodile tears... 😎👍
I did notice she only had actual tears when she was sentenced, not when she was crying and mewling on the witness stand. I almost couldn't stand watching her lie and lie and lie on the stand. apparently she thought, "I don't remember" was a get out of jail free card. Sorry, I'm talking about another video than this one.
@@steveb4662 When you say another video, are you talking about the one from the same trial where the same defendant gives evidence? If so, no apology needed my friend. I imagine the judge was referring to that in his comments, too. Totally agree - I saw no real tears from her, either.
@@voraciousreader3341 No... It could be either. Allocution would make sense in reference to her monologue, but she offered in it neither advice nor warning, so it wasn't a standard allocution. Elocution, on the other hand, would refer to the way she has spoken and presented herself throughout trial - the phrases she has chosen, for example (which others on this thread have already pointed out came from her lawyer rather than her). I went with the latter because the judge wasn't hugely clear which he meant and, to me, elocution makes more sense.
@@nancyvandermeer4480 Totally agree. Did you see when their son testified (I think it was on another video, but same trial)? Both parents were bawling as he took the stand, until they realised that he was going to tell the truth and not cover for them. Then the tears were switched off. Immediately. Awful, awful people. I'm so grateful that the eldest child is now safe and I hope he gets all the support he needs to get through this. RIP Dylan x
@@dailybread7687 no parent should have to bury there child. This is the worse pain I have ever felt in my life. My condolences to you and your family. Your son and my daughter are shining down on us. Prayers for you and your family. God bless you ♥
Strange that the foster mom seems to be the only one genuinely hurting... Well, and of course the prosecutor, who I think did an amazing job representing Dylan.
After all that has been said and done and having felt many emotions, I asked myself why did she kill her infant son? Did she not unconditionally love him? Baby Dylan may you RIP❤
@Tranquility 32 I completely agree. I just wish dad's sentence was the same as moms. Dylan's foster family seemed to be the only family that truly cared for this little boy. His foster mom brought me to tears. RIP Dylan
The best thing a defense lawyer told me was if they don’t adequately and competently represent these monsters, there’s a better chance their convictions will be overturned because of technicalities on appeal.
@@musiclover9361 They didn't say these monsters did not deserve due process. They said they could not do the job of the defense attorney and defend them.
The lady prosecutor was amazing thank you for getting justice for Baby Dylan...to the foster mom you gave him the greatest 12 days of life. Prayers for healing and thank you for becoming a foster mother the world needs more like you. RIP sweet Dylan
It wasn't just murder it was torture. All abusers do this to their babies but usually know when to stop so they don't kill. She wasn't even smart enough to know that.
@@jstebakova And one way around that is to embarrass the City, County or State by making sure these cases come to public light (e.g. media, newspapers) and not allowed to be swept under the carpet. Not just these severe cases but most cases. You will be surprised how quickly they come up with the money to hire more help AND train them better.
I agree Tallouse. The prosecutor was excellent. I fell so much sadness for the foster mother. I hope this doesn't spoil her thoughts of continuing to foster children. She is what this broken system needs
I agree with you, she was apparently "bothered" with the case, so to speak. There was a moment when the prosecutor was speaking, and she had her tongue against her cheek, honestly, it gave me chills, she looked ready to jump on someone's neck. Work given and done with mastery. My dream is to have people like that in this country where I live.
People like this prosecutor are a rare breed. She could, no doubt, make a fortune as a corporate lawyer, but instead she fights the good fight. Remember her when people speak badly about the profession. The good ones do very worthwhile things.
I accidentally tripped my son 1x when be was little. He had a scrap on his elbow & I felt like crap for a week! Can't imagine what kind of person it takes to MURDER a child!
Same here. My 6 month old wriggled out of my arms while I was picking him up and he fell (not far maybe 4 inches). I still cry thinking about it, I feel horrible. This monster is on a hellish level of her own. It makes me sick.
I don't know how anyone could hurt a little baby who can't defend itself, what monsters. I know it's tough, I'm 66 now but I remember my first child never stopped crying because he had colic but I always knew that I would walk out of the door and just walk to the end of the drive before I would ever hurt my child. He's 41 now and I had 2 after him (a lot more quiet) and what's really lovely is that they tell me often what a kind mother that I was. I can't imagine anyone hurting a dear, precious little child.
The foster mom's impact statement broke my heart. God Bless her for loving this precious sweet boy. In my opinion, she is not the "foster" mom, but his ONLY mommy. 💔
I couldn't hold back the tears for the foster mom annd for the little baby she so loved. That little baby would have dearly loved her all his life. I hope his big brother gets a chance to get to know her.
Defense attorney: "I hope the court will be reasonable". As reasonable as brutalizing and murdering an innocent and precious newborn child. Be that "reasonable"
This trial was a really tough one to watch. The manner in which they disposed of Dylan's body....... The testimony of the firefighters who retrieved the makeshift coffin from the well.... And defence have the gall to ask the court to be reasonable.
Yeah cause remember they are the victims they have lost everything and they are being bullied and not the monsters everyone else sees ....smh ugh ..reasonable is having done to them what they did to that baby over and over til death .
Why is it that Children's services thinks that reunification is always in the best interest of the child? Until this changes, the poor children don't have anyone in a position of authority advocating for them, and situations like this will continue to happen. How many more babies will have to die before the system realizes that Reunification is NEVER in the children's best interest when methamphetamine is involved.
I was a Foster parent for yrs. No the best interest for the child falls way under the radar. It is very sad. Sometimes the home they place the child is far worse than the home they are leaving. A lot of the children I know have a great case for lawsuits. I am glad I was able to make a difference in some cases.
You may have been legally his "foster mom" but you WERE HIS MOM. Baby Dylan knew LOVE in your arms. You will always love him. For those few days, he was HOME. Bless you- and please, please keep loving the babies who need you.
Can we talk about how efficient all of this is? They finished testimony the same day the jury returned and sentencing was handed down. That’s impressive. Well done, Ohio.
That’s because it was open and shut. The jury is like why are we here? She did it, he helped her do it, let’s find them guilty and go home. What took so long is reading all that legal stuff.
@@beatleschick I think she was just saying good job to the prosecutor for how she handled the case and got the jury on her side which gave the judge all the counts on each person
I’m just hearing about this and am so heart broken. How could child services not notice a dying baby. Since it was stated he passed a couple of hours after they left. Those parents have so many issues that I can’t begin to comprehend. Baby Dylan should have stated with his foster mom. She’s a real mom with live in her heart. Bless her. I pray the older son continues to do well in live.
When you murder someone, especially a helpless child, your “lack of a previous criminal record” means ZERO! She’s sorry?! Sorry to who???? Dylan? Or to herself that she got caught?! I’m glad she has to live with that for the rest of her life.
HEROIN IS A MONSTER THAT CREATES COLD HEARTED DOPE FEAR OF WITHDRAWELS..KILLS ONES SOUL AND CHANGES ONE SO BAD THAT THEY BECOME MONSTEROUS.....THE CHAINING ZIPTIES ANCHOR AND 6 TXMES WRAPPED AND IN A MILK CRATES IS WREAKING OF EVIL AND THEN THROWN INTO A WELL SO DEEP..IS WREAKING OF DEMONIC MINDS...bb
@@amandao9869 you make a good point. I was implying when it can be proven that they ignored opportunities to help the child and didn’t. It happens a lot more than it ever should.
Aside from baby Dylan, I felt most bad for Daniel Jr. and Andrea Bowling. Her cries are unforgettable to me. That little boy should've been able to stay with her and have her as his mom. He should've been able to grow up and live his life as a happy boy and into a well adjusted man. It's sickening that the biological parents failed so badly. They are truly vile people. Especially Jessica.
At least she feels shame and remorse. Drug is an awful thing, I don't understand why it's not wildly admitted what drug and alcohol play in crimes. Drug dealers should be punished with the capital punishment. They are the root of so many misery.
@@verabolton did someone force the drugs into her system? Or was it voluntarily done? It’s funny how a woman makes excuses for another woman. Many people callously murder others while on drugs. That’s why drugs are illegal. There is NO excuse for what she did. You can live in fantasyland and blame the drugs, but it’s all on her. She beat this poor baby over a long period of time. That is not drugs. That is depravity towards another human. A baby, at that. Let’s hope you’re never on a jury where a woman is on trial.
Andrea Bowling is an angel on earth. For that short amount of time she had Dylan, he felt the genuine love of his mother. Nobody can EVER take that away from these precious two. RIP Dylan, and I wish for a long and healthy life for Andrea. 🙏🏻🥰
You didn't just fail as a mother, you failed as a HUMAN BEING !! Wild animals don't even treat their young so cruel. I love that the judge saw through her crocodile tears and saw she had no remorse. Painful watching her days on end performances. To the lady Prosecutor ~ THANKYOU !!
You'd be surprised how many animals will kill babies and others of their own species, just like humans do. We kept ducks for a while and you had to separate the mothers and babies from the fathers. The males frequently killed the ducklings and not by accident either.
The moment that Amazing foster mom began her impact statement i started crying😢 this case really broke my heart. RIP Baby Dylan🕊 , thank you Julie for bringing True Justice and putting these monsters in Jail!!
19:25 My heart breaks for the foster mom. I'm so glad she wrote a letter on behalf of Dylan to be read to the court. I hope something good comes from this trial for future cases like this. This is so sad.
That ‘mother’ was crying for herself , an utter narcissist .. what a terrible shame CPS let this child down .. at least he knew some love with his foster family 😪
“I sentence you to life without the possibility of parole, plus 32 years.” &… “I will give you credit for the 213 days you’ve served while in custody awaiting trial.” Like that’s gunna help her. 😂 They deserve it.
Seems like cases involving “child protective services” fail constantly. They need to get that under control at some point in history, right? Whoever thought it was a good idea at CPS to give Dylan back to either one of them should go to PRISON too. The issue starts with CPS, PERIODT!!! Rest In Peace baby boy 🚼🦋🍼🧸💙
It should but they are sooo understaffed with people that don’t have enough training in the field to manage cases on their own. Additionally, CPS consistently focuses on reuniting families and ends up putting them back in the hands of abusers and drug users because they think it’s more traumatic for kids to be in foster care. It’s why we see sooo many issues. They also tend to NOT take the bigger picture into consideration. If a young child always has bruises and isn’t old enough to verbalize what happened, the case workers just take the word of the parents. CPS needs more money to staff more case workers and they need to redo guidelines to have new case workers working with senior and experienced case workers instead of being on their own so soon. They need cops to get involved quickly when a child isn’t produced or when a parent the child doesn’t live with voices concern.
@@sassysav6859 it’s the same in Oz, child services just ignore repeated calls by numerous people.....and the parents are druggies, dealers, growers, never worked a day in their life, on welfare in government housing they trash the house, scream, bash each other, foulest language ever, constantly fight, when cops come ...nope everything’s fine ....they never get kicked out the house just keeps getting repaired....children finally taken away when they left three under five, one a baby, alone in the house and went out....oldest one jumped over fence to another yard “to play” that’s the only reason they were found out...now pregnant again....number seven ..... ! They sure know how to work the system even after going to jail .....
The issues start with parents who don’t want children! As we speak, pick up the phone and call CPS and ask them if they have enough foster homes to place kids, they don’t! Some people just shouldn’t have kids!, the issue starts there!
The foster mom's victim impact statement broke my heart. I wish so much she would've had a chance to raise the baby. She would've given him a great life.
I agree! That had me crying so hard and ive never met any of them!! This poor beautiful perfect human being was treated like garbage and i will never understand how anybody could even consider doing this to any body but even worse your own flesh n blood!! They should have takn that baby at the hospital n never give him back!!!! The nurses n staff could see how much she cared abt that baby that shld have been a huge red flag! If she doesnt care rt now do ya think she is going to when she takes him home???? I just cant understand anything like this n how anybody has it in them to do this!!!! Rip lil guy!! Jesus has you now and you are loved and will always be in my thoughts!
me too. so sad that she didn't get to give him the life he should have had. and Daniel Jr should have been removed long ago too. such a horrific situation for everyone who genuinely loved those children unlike their so called parents.
Michelle doe Thankfully we don’t have to judge. The jury already did. Don’t EVEN start to attempt to justify this heinous act by using Post Partum Depression. Literally HUNDREDS of women deal w this issue and DO NOT KILL THIER BABIES.
Thank you, Colleen Johnson! More workers need to be held accountable There need to be better laws! I'm a licensed social worker in California and I'm disgusted!
How many more cases have to pop up of them failing ultimately resulting in a childs death before something is done to hold them accountable or to at least CHANGE SOMETHING!
@Angela Reddick some common sense is missing. They just trusted the father who’s known to use his sons pee to pass drug tests and took him on his word that he’d be responsible for their baby and not allow his wife to spend the night......too lenient, no real supervision for such a big risk
When the Prosecutor said “ the pain the child was put through on his last days on this earth” he should had said “the pain that the innocent baby boy experienced since the moment he came into this world he immediately began suffering due to so many different substance withdrawals, he truly never experienced a moment of joy of this earth b/c of the defendant”
the only real tears were for herself at the end , none for that poor baby... I just cant even imagine it. Monster is not a strong enough word for her...
Generally you get one chance with any bad behaviour you do to an animal unless its very cruel and then the animal is taken from you. I don't understand how children are given back time and again, especially when it involves parents with drug issue or any kind of physical abuse.
Such a touching, beautiful and lovely depiction of what Baby Dylan would want have said if he had a voice. God bless that foster Mommy, she should have been able to keep him to raise him with the love he so deserved. Shame on the state of Ohio for being so negligent.
The Ohio children services should be sued to the ends of the Earth for taking that baby away from that Foster mother who obviously loved him and given him back to those two drug addicts to murder him unreal Child Services violated that baby's constitutional rights
I'm not quite sure who would sue the State of Ohio? but I'm from the UK and will readily admit to having no knowledge about suing pertaining to the US.
As a former Child protective services worker, when a child is places back with the parents, that is ordered by the juvenile justice judges. My last case as a CPS worker was to put 3 kids back into an abusive home on order of the judge. The state welfare system has ZERO power.. they cant remove children from a home, that is done by a police officer, which is why an officer is present when a child is removed and when a child is placed back with the parent it MUST be ordered by a judge. The state CPS workers are the "face" of a broken system but that is only bc they are the ones that are in the home and seen more than anyone. They make recommendations to the court but at the end of the day the judge makes the rules.
Unfortunately, CPS isn't really the one making those decisions. CPS produces a recommendation to a judge who is responsible for making such decisions. Many, many times, CPS disagrees with the judges decisions, however biological parents have a built in strong case to getting their children back. The system is in many ways broken, and the sad part is the children are the victims of the system.
This breaks my heart...I was a Foster Mom. We adopted our last foster baby that we got at 3 weeks. Both of his parents were doing jail time for drug related crimes. I can’t imagine what this Foster Mom went through...we loved our son from the second they put him in my arms just as much as my biological children. He has Autism...probably from drug use and will not have a normal life. He is 18 years old now and is very loved, healthy and happy. I cannot fathom loosing him like this Foster Mom did, only to have him be tortured and then murdered. I feel so sorry the the Foster Family and the big brother. 😩😢
I can not believe that DCFS pop out this child back into the home of a known addict. Where in the hell are their child neglect and child endangering charges.
Not in Texas. You or baby test positive and you will lose your rights. You can get the child back if you go through several steps. I know a girl who has lost all 7 of her children. Last 2 she lost because baby tested positive for morphine. She refused to do what she needed to get those two angels back. She was allowed to call and check on them but no physical contact at all. Couldn’t even visit family who ended up with the girls. We don’t play with that crap here. She sure uses the loss of all her children as if she never did anything wrong. Now the girls are with one of their sisters dad and family. “Mom” now prostitutes herself on the streets for drugs. Never has called or tried to straighten her life out for her children. Makes me sick.
I’m a recovering addict and even in my worse addiction I never hurt my kids. That’s a complete cop out she’s a monster . Addiction had zero to do with it
It's because of CPS, DHS, or any other name that child protective services go by depending on the state. The state child protective services screwed up their own case as shown by a state investigation of this particular case.
SCIOTO COUNTY, Ohio (WSAZ) - Two women who worked for Scioto County Children Services have been indicted on counts of endangering children. The prosecutor confirms the charges stem from their former employment at Children Services and cases where children died. Lisa Thomas, 56, of Wheelersburg, Ohio, is facing endangering children charges in connection with two separate cases. The first is surrounding the death of 2-month-old Dylan Groves. The second deals with the death of 5-year-old Annabell Greene. Renee Ginn, 54, of Garrison, Kentucky, is facing counts of endangering children and tampering with evidence. Her charges stem from the death of Annabell Greene.
I’m almost 60 years old and I STILL have a Mother that lets me know how important I am and that she loves me. I wish this blessing for every child and adult.
Not everybody is so privileged
@@user_abcxyzz That’s why “I wish this blessing for every child and adult.”
You should feel loved. It doesnt matter about age.
These people will be tortured in prison by other inmates if anyone knows why they're there
My mom still worries if i don’t eat 3 meals a day.
Children's services COMPLETELY failed this poor baby
As always!
Children services ALWAYS fails
It happens way too often!
THEY ALWAYS FAIL they either leave the baby in danger or steal babies from wonderful parents
True and so did the monsters that killed the poor little one
Whoever in CPS released this child from the foster mom to his murderous parents should also be incarcerated. CPS is far too laxed in their practices.
She was placed on leave but it’s the Scioto County Children Services that’s the issue. It is pure garbage.
@@The_Primary_Axiom cpa is limited to funding and what they can do
@@treehuger1978 You're right. And parents have a fundamental right to raise their children. The law doesn't require perfection of parents in order to return children to them.
I guarantee that person feels the guilt and weight of that decision.
@@runninbyfaith777 Yes, they always feel remorse AFTER the fact.
When will they all stand up as a group and DEMAND our government adequately funds this organization so they can do the job they need to?
It's an unforgivable travesty that decade after decade we bury child after child because CPS was unable to protect them.
You didn't just fail as a mother Jessica, you failed as a human being.
Alley cats are better parents
exactly what i was about to say!
I thought the same thing.
True
Could he have had a bone disorder?
Jessica is going to cry harder when her fellow inmates who miss their children find out what she did to poor Dylan.
@Sara Allison
Yes, but there are certain crimes that inmates _DON'T_ like/tolerate...
Crimes on babies is one of them... i.e, sex crimes/murder of children, _especially_ a barely 3 month old baby.
THANK GOD FOR PRISON JUSTICE!!!!!
Yep
@Sara Allison shes already said she had to be seperated from other inmates. Since the women tell her to hang herself everynight or they will kill her themselves.. but yes my sister works in a womens prison their is a lot of baby killers on womens prisons.
Unfortunately monsters get special cells away from the general prison population.
That woman hasn't picked her face up and made eye contact with anyone, except for the rage tantrum she threw with the prosecutor. She cried for herself and herself alone. This is so disgusting.
And even then the invisible tears are fake. That thing feels nothing.
Bc she realized her true colors came through and there was no coming back from it. Total narcissist
Phoney
@@ainsleystuart1234 and can't understand why aunt Linda won't answer her phone hahaha...boo hoo..
Crocodile tears.
LOL notice how she stopped crying the second the judge gave sentence . It’s cuz she knows there’s no point now , no need to act anymore
I disagree. I feel she realized she did wrong. No one really wins on both sides. Sad and terrible case.
Also when the foster mother was speaking.She didn't even look up. All she had to do was give baby Dylan back to her. Could have been such a different ending.
Not One tear from all that crying!
I was going to say the same thing. Crocodile tears !!!!
@@ainoah68 its good thing trial didn't last any longer than it did,public couldn't have afforded her boxes of
tissues!!
I would love an update on the 15 year old son and the foster mother. I can’t imagine how strong they had to be to endure this, they are both absolute angels.
From what I see on public post on Facebook he's doing great. His Aunt & Uncle are raising him her name is Phyllis and Daniel is the second. He seems to be a smart, well mannered Senior now!! I pray he continues on that path, and blessings to his Aunt & Uncle as well.
I'd rather let him get on with his life without the public intrusion.
Yes… The son is who I’m worried about. I just hope he grows into a great young man.🙏🙏🙏
One clarification, please: The baby didn't "pass away," he was murdered.
That's incorrect. He DID pass away. Cause of death: murder.
@@lisasimpson3832 😑 not wrapped too tight.
Greg George perfectly said.
Lisa Simpson using the statement “passed away” is not a cause of death. It’s simply a nice way to say “someone died”. Therefore, it was used today in court by the defense to lesson the impact on what these monsters did. They murdered their child. The defense will never use the phrase murdered. Using “passed away” is a lie. He was “killed” He was “murdered”.
The poor little kid was thrown away.
The fact that the "mother" stopped crying after the judge said he found no genuine remorse from the mother, it's like the "mom" thought ok I can stop acting now.
Yes exactly!
Those tears were for herself only.
Disgusting smh
Oh yeah, she’s a piece of work!
Shes a narcissistic sadistic psychopath
Im sorry for the 15yo son that had been left with all this horrible events, I hope he will be fine, and will become an honest and happy man
He’s the living victim in this. I pray he is getting the love and counseling he needs
He sounded like a very grounded young man. Let’s hope he gets any and all support he needs.
The best thing was for him to get away from these people. Such a young person... A child... should never have to go through this.
same, so sad
Absolutely
Jessica: “You can’t do anything more than I do to myself for failing as a mother”
Judge: “Oh yes I can”.
Yes challenge accepted
Here again- it was all about her.
@29:00 she shots into tissue twice, looks at it each time and she spotted on her hand and clothes😅
Surprised she didn't lick it up
I hope that Dylan's brother has only good in his life from now on.
He needs lots of counseling and prayers. He’s probably damaged too
@@BibleMadeEasy247 Y, how could he not be?
I just hope he finds people who care about him and that he finds some semblance of happiness. This trauma will follow him. But with enough help and care he could move on with his life.
How can he be ok. Poor kid.
The Judge should of made it part of their sentencing that they can no longer have contact with him and their parenting rights taken away immediately forever!! They’ve already done enough damage to this poor boy . Him and his now deceased brother deserved so much better than these two piece of shits!!! I pray now that they are locked away he will get counseling and thrived in his mew life. ♥️
This baby would be alive, healthy, on the road to recovery, and fully loved, if he had remained with his foster mom.
Life plus 32 years with no chance of appeal!! She got what she deserved and so did Daniel
Yup. That system is so broken.
A firing quad would be fitting! But, jail time will be rough, they will get what they deserve!
WELL SAID
Exactly!
I see two mothers crying, one is crying for baby Dylan, the other I crying for herself
sorry you cant call that a mother...
the foster mom is a mother, you not need to be the same blood to be a mother, true love does.
I was crying watching that part
@@MMGV1992 One is legally the mother (jessica) and the other is a mother from the heart. One is crying for Dylan and the other is just sorry she got caught (jessica)... i wouldnt call that a mother either but legally she was... not anymore
Shes not a mother she's only crying because she got caught
@leny let's get one thing straight. Just because Jessica was the hole Dylan came out of don't mean she was ever a mom. The foster mom cried more than the baby's parents.
The foster mum would have rocked baby Dylan many times throughout the nights as he was going through withdrawals. She would have lovingly cared for him even if she was sleep deprived. Baby Dylan should have NEVER been taken from her. My heart goes out to her, she is what makes a true foster parent. Rest in Paradise Baby Dylan ❤❤
The state and courts failed that child
My oldest daughter has fostered and adopted 6 of them. All drug exposed and they suffered. I wish that precious baby would have been able to stay with the person who truly loved him and she did her best to help him through that torture. Rest well baby Dylan 👼💙🙏🕊️
Babies born on drugs are very irritable, cry regardless of what is done. You have to continue to give Iv meds in hospital to help. At home this child never stopped crying, won’t feed, won’t sleep and are many time shaken, hit, thrown etc. that will kill the baby. So if on drugs baby should have been left in foster home.
~ rest in paradise ~ 😔 🕯
He got 47 years to life. 👏
She got life without parole, plus 32 years. 👏
Now that justice for that sweet baby boy
Meth heads off to prison
Why did she get more then him?
@@Rikachan92 she is the prime convict .. isn't she?
And that's how their marriage ended
The foster mother showed more emotion in three minutes than the biological "mother" did all week.
I wish Daniel jr could go with them. They are clearly amazing people that loved baby Dylan more than his own so called parents
She isn't a narcissist, most would show more emotion then the baby's bio parents they are self absorbed so any pain is just about them.
I totally agree with that!
I broke out in hard tears when she spoke. So sad.
I was so glad she spoke for Dylan. If she hadn't, there would have been no one to speak for him, or shed sincere tears for his loss. She was the only light he ever had in his tiny tortured life.
I can see right through this. Neither of them are remorseful. The father is angry that he is being held accountable, and the mother is trying to get out of a life sentence. This is so sad.
The only thing sad is that a baby was killed.
@@laracapsloock yikes. that’s implied in my comments
First time any real tears were shed.
I'm sorry, but if it was up to me after they were sentenced a week later I'd enforce the death penalty. Instead of these monsters living out thier lives not paying bills free food, cloths, roof over thier head, NO! ONE WEEK! THEN THE GET THE CHAIR! LETHAL INJECTION! EITHER WAY, 1 WEEK!
she will be fine theres plenty of meth in prison
That prosecutor looked absolutely exhausted but she was exactly who Dylan needed to fight for his justice and she did exactly that and I really hope she's okay and taking care after all this. As for the fostermom, I hope she's okay and providing other vunerable children a home.
Why the F were these low life's given custody of the poor little baby when their older son was taken away from child services earlier?? Does that make any sense?
exactly Gloria.!
In this Country Babies lives don't matter..
Yes Good question
Grand Ol' CPS!
Now that I read about the case. I'm baffled, if you can't take care of one child, you can't take care of ANY.
The foster mom is an absolute force. I was bawling and my heart breaks over and over for her pain. She is a true mother.
She is an angel on earth ❤️
and Daniel’s attorney said in her closing arguments that her testimony was emotional and unnecessary. unbelievable
@@LouisianaSaturdayNight yeah even though her testimony was definitely needed. She helped establish the timeline and she reported Daniel's demeanor to CPS. It shows that CPS knew he was possibly using and they still sent Dylan with the father. CPS should be on trial for endangering that baby
Yeah that foster mom you can tell she really wanted that baby and the picture of her with the baby is so precious she was excited to have him but the” drug mother” Jessica, You could tell she just wanted to get rid of him she didn’t deserve a baby like Dylan he wasn’t even given a chance..
I was bawling my eyes out at the foster mothers letter as well. Another case of family services failures
"I failed as a mother" you failed as a human being.
🙌
I find it difficult to even call her a human being!!
@@dorapete4536 I said this out loud when she said she failed
SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE ONES IN THE BACK🙌🏾
🙌
That awkward moment when your lawyer refuses to ever work on an appeal with you 😬
Right? He wants nothing to do with this trash fire!
Ya.
..her silence said it all....
Sentencing starts at 30:00 minutes you're welcome
🙏
Thank you VERY much !
Thank you! Have a cookie 🍪and some milk 🥛
👍
Thank you
I was diagnosed with uterine cancer when I was 26. I can't have children. People like this make me so sick. I am so hurt by this. Having children is a privilege. A gift from God that not everyone on earth received. Shame on them. Bless the foster mom. She made me cry. This whole thing has broke my heart. At least he had 1 mommy who loves him. And it wasn't the bitch that birthed him.
I’m so sorry you can’t have children! For you to have to watch these parents kill their little baby when you would have loved with all your heart to have a child must kill you. God bless you!
Suck..I am sorry.
Same here!! I have endometriosis. I understand you sister.
Are you considering becoming a foster parent
It hurts so bad to watch people like this have kids so effortlessly and then discard them like trash. It's a different kind of hurt for women like us who will never have that experience. We can adopt or foster in some cases but never get to feel a baby kick or have morning sickness or put the baby in your arms after 9 months. It just sucks so bad.
How can anybody do this to a baby? I lost my baby son aged 10 months 52 years ago and I still long for him every day. May God have mercy on those parents. I cannot.
❤️💐
Your God asks you to forgive. Maybe you should practice your religion. I am sorry you lost your baby boy. Losing a child is one of the hardest things anyone goes through and your baby is never forgotten. This lady may not have been a good Mom at this time in her life but ask any 5 year old child what she wants to be when she grows up and she is not going to say "I want to be a drug addict" or "I want to kill a baby I gave birth to and then put him down a well".
@@neridaduncan2710 you're why people can't stand religious people.
@@neridaduncan2710 Drug use is not and NEVER WILL BE an excuse for doing ANYTHING!!! You make a solid CHOICE to do drugs in the first place and anything from there on is STILL on your shoulders!!! PERIOD!!!
@@salinal2783 addiction is a mental illness. someone can make the choice to do drugs but they are addictive and if the person is predisposed to addiction, they will get addicted. addiction is not a choice. if it were, no one would be addicted
Greatest respect for the judge's decisions in this case and for explaining why he made them as he did. No nonsense, just good sense. What a relief to see this! Thanks for posting.
People from children services that were involved in this case need to be terminated
And fined and imprisoned. They were his only chance to stop the torture and death.
oo aa Why is there any evidence to say any of them did anything wrong or are you just making yourself judge and jury without any facts?
@@personalcheeses8073
My statement stands. Anyone that was involved in monitoring this little baby should be terminated as well as the supervisor.
@@angelajames7917
I agree with you completely
@@personalcheeses8073 they took him from foster parents who loved and cared for him and gave him back to these monsters who did hard drugs while pregnant and was found to be unfit. . A short time later he was found beaten and dead. Yes, they did something very wrong.
“This has impacted my client” seriously?!?! Your Client MURDERED a baby! An innocent baby. Your Client is evil.
The attorneys has to say things like that
Lori, those words wouldn't come out of my mouth for millions of dollars! I understand your statement, but it is still unconceivable!
Its quite a privilege to be an American isnt it?
@@noneofyourbusiness302 so the constitution is unconcievable? Got it. You know....if you'd ever commit a felony you'd embrace a legal defense with open arms. Don't be a hypocrite.
I think the prosecutor is trying to be another Nancy. Grace. Which is a great thing. This prosecutor did a great job!!!
She doesn't even address her dead son or her living one. She apologizes to the man in charge of her sentencing. Not to her baby boy, and not to the older son she leaves behind
Narcissism
@@reginahumphres9293 You're insane. The baby was born with meth in his system and was placed in foster care. The mother never rehabilitated and in her drug induced rage, she injured the infant repeatedly. The son wasn't even living in the home consistently.
@@ChanelGreer your right I'm insane. I missed the part about meth being in baby. I full like a dog now. Thank you for putting me strat. I must be easy to get over on.
@Timothy Gray yeah because the dad was a stand up guy, right? Men never hurt their kids or women. Let's not go that route..
Sick!
The expression on the foster dad's face took my breath away. I hope that they have a strong, lasting support system.
If we only tried senators and congressmen like this we might actually have a functioning country
@Kate M.hunter can't ride that train!
I couldn't agree more
Agreed, rise. If only we had fewer Republicans in positions of power. Let’s see what happens after Nov. 3, 2020.
@@Turandot29 you misunderstood my statement my friend they all who are corrupt should be held accountable I'm not talkin party here
@@Turandot29 this country is a free Nation for one reason and if we let it slip away all the men who died for it had died in vain🇺🇸🙏🇺🇸
CPS should've been on trial for facilitating in Dylan's heinous demise.
@Angela Reddick CPS don't help they take children that shouldn't be taken and leave children that should be taken
@Angela Reddick they placed the baby back with the parents and the baby ended up dead.They are partly responsible.
Absolutely
Such a broken system. Children are failed every single day.
Noooo, it's the parents job
“I failed as a mother”...you failed as a human.
Becky Kegley I said the same thing
She didn't fail, she betrayed
I look at those two and all I feel is disgust...maybe this angel's death will be a WAKE-UP CALL TO MANY(RIP DYLAN)
PHILICIA DRAYTON
DPS and laws dealing with child abuse and drug abuse need to protect these little angels...
Not the drug addled addicts rights...
Amen.
Just imagine how the 15year old feels....breaks my heart x
I'd change my name. Poor child
@@Kiki-7 my thoughts exactly. He's named after his murderous father. Constant reminder of who did this to him and his baby brother
He will suffer the absence of his parents deep in his heart because right now he is sad, angry, upset, full of hate at the same time and heart broken because if his parents's actions. He will miss his baby brother as well too. Hope he seems God for healing and him able to forgive his parents for his own peace. Hope his parents seek God and repent for them to be forgiven by God because that is all what they can do for now til death. God is the only hope for everyone. Every baby is a blessing and it made me sad what that poor baby went through 😢.
Nasty bastards I hope the son finds a good home
I am saddened to think any one could harm a innocent child. Thy shall not Kill
Let's not forget Dylan s foster dad,he also must have loved him,he has sat beside his wife daily looking sick with sorrow but comforting his wife through this terrible ordeal
They were the only ones that ever showed that baby love.
@Tyler More Too bad America is an "each man for himself" country that is unwilling to pay for enough foster beds for the children that need them.
@Tyler More You can start by looking at the countries that provide health care for all their citizens.
Yes, the foster dad was a hero to that baby as well as the foster mother.
He knew her for 24 years she raised one child without any of this behaviour, how many of us would react with the same disbelief. I love how all you perfect people out there judge others.
His foster mom should have been his mom. You can feel the love she has for that baby. Her statement was so emotional, it put me out of breath.
I cried from the first letter to the last. :(
Time stamp please
@@biriyaniaddictasmr8078 19:23
@@TheGiulioSeverini i did too. I buried a child. He died in an accident. I just cannot for the life of me. As long as I live. I never be able understand parents like these. It goes against the grain, particularly of mother’s. As the instinct to protect esp a newborn, should be particularly strong. Just unreal.
If you compare the foster mothers and the birth mothers way of talking, you can really see who is genuinely sad about this little baby's death.
Killing your own child. There no words powerful enough to say how disgusting that is.
"Despite her elocution here today, I find that, throughout these proceedings, she has shown no genuine remorse."
Judge saw right through those crocodile tears... 😎👍
I did notice she only had actual tears when she was sentenced, not when she was crying and mewling on the witness stand. I almost couldn't stand watching her lie and lie and lie on the stand. apparently she thought, "I don't remember" was a get out of jail free card. Sorry, I'm talking about another video than this one.
@@steveb4662 When you say another video, are you talking about the one from the same trial where the same defendant gives evidence? If so, no apology needed my friend. I imagine the judge was referring to that in his comments, too.
Totally agree - I saw no real tears from her, either.
It’s ALLOCUTION. Just thought everybody should know!
@@voraciousreader3341 No... It could be either.
Allocution would make sense in reference to her monologue, but she offered in it neither advice nor warning, so it wasn't a standard allocution. Elocution, on the other hand, would refer to the way she has spoken and presented herself throughout trial - the phrases she has chosen, for example (which others on this thread have already pointed out came from her lawyer rather than her).
I went with the latter because the judge wasn't hugely clear which he meant and, to me, elocution makes more sense.
@@nancyvandermeer4480 Totally agree. Did you see when their son testified (I think it was on another video, but same trial)? Both parents were bawling as he took the stand, until they realised that he was going to tell the truth and not cover for them. Then the tears were switched off. Immediately.
Awful, awful people. I'm so grateful that the eldest child is now safe and I hope he gets all the support he needs to get through this. RIP Dylan x
I've watched this whole trial without crying, but the foster mums statement broke me. She really loved that baby 😔
Yes me too! That woman was the only one who truly loved that baby. Shame on CPS for giving the baby back to the parents so quickly.
A true earth Angel!
Where did u watch the whole case ?? I want to watch please thank you
@@chaparravelasc1904 look it up on you tube.. this all happened last year this is a replay
@@chaparravelasc1904 this channel has a playlist with the whole case
That Foster mom was the only one who showed that baby any love. Bless her!!
I disagree. I think big brother loved baby Dylan as well.
@@kenyettaready I totally agree I watched his interview when he took the stand and he seemed completely heartbroken😞
🤡 That disgusting woman didn't miss a chance to make this tragedy about herself
And his older brother Dylan!
@@onflux4787 the foster mom?!?! You kidding? The woman who put her life on hold to take in a baby she has no ties to, that was withdrawing from drugs?
I lost my 21 year old daughter 11 months ago I still cry for her everyday these monsters should be ashamed of themselves
@@dailybread7687 no parent should have to bury there child. This is the worse pain I have ever felt in my life. My condolences to you and your family. Your son and my daughter are shining down on us. Prayers for you and your family. God bless you ♥
Strange that the foster mom seems to be the only one genuinely hurting... Well, and of course the prosecutor, who I think did an amazing job representing Dylan.
checkout foster Dad and lady other side of Mom....the whole family loved that little baby.....
She wanted to be that babies Momma .
After all that has been said and done and having felt many emotions, I asked myself why did she kill her infant son? Did she not unconditionally love him? Baby Dylan may you RIP❤
@@TheIndependentLens I think so. She is very passionate for justice for baby.
@Tranquility 32 I completely agree. I just wish dad's sentence was the same as moms. Dylan's foster family seemed to be the only family that truly cared for this little boy. His foster mom brought me to tears. RIP Dylan
I could not be a defence lawyer for any amount of money or notoriety, I could not defend monsters like these’
Rip Dylan x
The best thing a defense lawyer told me was if they don’t adequately and competently represent these monsters, there’s a better chance their convictions will be overturned because of technicalities on appeal.
Everybody is entitled to representation, even these two patently evil monsters. It's called 'Due Process'.
@@musiclover9361 They didn't say these monsters did not deserve due process. They said they could not do the job of the defense attorney and defend them.
@@kristenjustkristen9462, I know. Your comment doesn't contradict anything I have written.
@@musiclover9361 It wasn't meant 2.
The lady prosecutor was amazing thank you for getting justice for Baby Dylan...to the foster mom you gave him the greatest 12 days of life. Prayers for healing and thank you for becoming a foster mother the world needs more like you. RIP sweet Dylan
How dare she say she failed as a mother. Murder is NOT failure it’s an act of evil like no other.
It wasn't just murder it was torture. All abusers do this to their babies but usually know when to stop so they don't kill. She wasn't even smart enough to know that.
How many times is child protective services going to fail children.
As many as they can
. They don't care about anything.
@@marymoore3585 very very true.!!!!
They're underpaid and understaffed. It's the state's fault. When resources are scarce, children fall through the cracks.
@@jstebakova And one way around that is to embarrass the City, County or State by making sure these cases come to public light (e.g. media, newspapers) and not allowed to be swept under the carpet. Not just these severe cases but most cases. You will be surprised how quickly they come up with the money to hire more help AND train them better.
exactly like with gabriel hernandez that case was pure evil
I wish all prosecutors were as passionate as this one is. She seems to care more about Dylan’s death then both parents. She did a great job.
I agree Tallouse. The prosecutor was excellent. I fell so much sadness for the foster mother. I hope this doesn't spoil her thoughts of continuing to foster children. She is what this broken system needs
I agree with you, she was apparently "bothered" with the case, so to speak. There was a moment when the prosecutor was speaking, and she had her tongue against her cheek, honestly, it gave me chills, she looked ready to jump on someone's neck. Work given and done with mastery. My dream is to have people like that in this country where I live.
People like this prosecutor are a rare breed. She could, no doubt, make a fortune as a corporate lawyer, but instead she fights the good fight. Remember her when people speak badly about the profession. The good ones do very worthwhile things.
I agree 💯
Its theyre job to act the way to have more effect
What a wonderful life Dylan would have had with his foster mom. The system failed. His birth parents failed. RIP little one.
Typical system
~ rest in paradise ~ 😔 🕯
Her constant crying shows to me that she is completely fixated only with her OWN emotions/consequences. Narcissist.
I accidentally tripped my son 1x when be was little. He had a scrap on his elbow & I felt like crap for a week! Can't imagine what kind of person it takes to MURDER a child!
Same here. My 6 month old wriggled out of my arms while I was picking him up and he fell (not far maybe 4 inches). I still cry thinking about it, I feel horrible. This monster is on a hellish level of her own. It makes me sick.
at least you remembered! prayers to you and child
Drugs. Unfortunately that's all it takes.
@@KSGomez88 I’ve almost done this too many times while babysitting, they always squirm! Haha hopefully it never happens knock on wood 😂
@@amandathompson6327 it's so scary!!! I hope it never happens to you!!
As far as I'm concerned his foster mom was his mom, the only person to ever truly love him. Rest in peace beautiful baby boy.
The parents should have NEVER GOTTEN THAT CHILD BACK!!!!
Ya think?
Exactly
I agree cps should be held accountable as well
Yes, system is broken and worse, talk about complicit !
I don't know how anyone could hurt a little baby who can't defend itself, what monsters. I know it's tough, I'm 66 now but I remember my first child never stopped crying because he had colic but I always knew that I would walk out of the door and just walk to the end of the drive before I would ever hurt my child. He's 41 now and I had 2 after him (a lot more quiet) and what's really lovely is that they tell me often what a kind mother that I was. I can't imagine anyone hurting a dear, precious little child.
The foster mom's impact statement broke my heart. God Bless her for loving this precious sweet boy. In my opinion, she is not the "foster" mom, but his ONLY mommy. 💔
Yes she was his only mom
I couldn't hold back the tears for the foster mom annd for the little baby she so loved. That little baby would have dearly loved her all his life. I hope his big brother gets a chance to get to know her.
Amen
Tears are falling
In my eyes there is a different between mother and mom and that lady was that boys mom. No foster, just mom 🥺
Defense attorney: "I hope the court will be reasonable". As reasonable as brutalizing and murdering an innocent and precious newborn child. Be that "reasonable"
Barbie, well put!
Yes!
This trial was a really tough one to watch. The manner in which they disposed of Dylan's body....... The testimony of the firefighters who retrieved the makeshift coffin from the well.... And defence have the gall to ask the court to be reasonable.
Yeah cause remember they are the victims they have lost everything and they are being bullied and not the monsters everyone else sees ....smh ugh ..reasonable is having done to them what they did to that baby over and over til death .
I think the court was reasonable indeed: life without the possibility of parole plus an additional 32 years for her. Some 40 plus years for him.
I worked for Children Services in a different state for over a decade. And I am well aware that "the best interest of the child " is pure bs !
an actual admission instead of "we're too busy" " we're overwhelmed"" we try to keep the family together"....same old BS from CPS.
it’s never in the best interest most of the time
So sad. So not under-funded?
Why is it that Children's services thinks that reunification is always in the best interest of the child? Until this changes, the poor children don't have anyone in a position of authority advocating for them, and situations like this will continue to happen. How many more babies will have to die before the system realizes that Reunification is NEVER in the children's best interest when methamphetamine is involved.
I was a Foster parent for yrs. No the best interest for the child falls way under the radar. It is very sad. Sometimes the home they place the child is far worse than the home they are leaving. A lot of the children I know have a great case for lawsuits. I am glad I was able to make a difference in some cases.
God bless that foster mom. She showed genuine love for Dylan and expressed it beautifully. RIP Dylan.
~ rest in paradise ~ 😔 🕯
baby dylan
You may have been legally his "foster mom" but you WERE HIS MOM. Baby Dylan knew LOVE in your arms. You will always love him. For those few days, he was HOME. Bless you- and please, please keep loving the babies who need you.
Can we talk about how efficient all of this is? They finished testimony the same day the jury returned and sentencing was handed down. That’s impressive. Well done, Ohio.
first time those last three words have ever been said
I take it that this didn't take place in California?
That’s because it was open and shut. The jury is like why are we here? She did it, he helped her do it, let’s find them guilty and go home. What took so long is reading all that legal stuff.
@@tamerajohnson5587 exactly. The truth was apparent from jump street.
Too bad CPS wasn't equally as impressive though.
Life + 32 years without the possibility of parole for the Mom of the year. Fitting. Dad 50 years to Life. Congratulations Prosecutor 👍
@@beatleschick I think she was just saying good job to the prosecutor for how she handled the case and got the jury on her side which gave the judge all the counts on each person
@@beatleschick all the times add up to 47 years . That’s why 47-life
I’m just hearing about this and am so heart broken. How could child services not notice a dying baby. Since it was stated he passed a couple of hours after they left.
Those parents have so many issues that I can’t begin to comprehend. Baby Dylan should have stated with his foster mom. She’s a real mom with live in her heart. Bless her. I pray the older son continues to do well in live.
When you murder someone, especially a helpless child, your “lack of a previous criminal record” means ZERO! She’s sorry?! Sorry to who???? Dylan? Or to herself that she got caught?! I’m glad she has to live with that for the rest of her life.
She GETS to live with that for the rest of her miserable life. Little Dylan does not.
She's not sorry.
HEROIN IS A MONSTER THAT CREATES COLD HEARTED DOPE FEAR OF WITHDRAWELS..KILLS ONES SOUL AND CHANGES ONE SO BAD THAT THEY BECOME MONSTEROUS.....THE CHAINING ZIPTIES ANCHOR AND 6 TXMES WRAPPED AND IN A MILK CRATES IS WREAKING OF EVIL AND THEN THROWN INTO A WELL SO DEEP..IS WREAKING OF DEMONIC MINDS...bb
@@bonniebrooks7745 chills when I read that..wow
Why do u get points for not being a felon?
CPS should be prosecuted along with the parents. EVERY TIME.
there are so many people who failed that little baby... not just the parents... drug dealers should be on death row too...
Maybe in this situation...but no, not every time. Not every time is it obvious. If this were the case NOONE would do this job.
@@amandao9869 you make a good point. I was implying when it can be proven that they ignored opportunities to help the child and didn’t. It happens a lot more than it ever should.
Those aren't parents... they are murderers.... parents love and protect their children
If you want to prosecute ppl trying to help you won't find help any more.
Don’t call your self “foster mommy“just say Mommy! Thank God he had you even if only for a short time. Now he is with Jesus and the angels.
Aside from baby Dylan, I felt most bad for Daniel Jr. and Andrea Bowling. Her cries are unforgettable to me. That little boy should've been able to stay with her and have her as his mom. He should've been able to grow up and live his life as a happy boy and into a well adjusted man. It's sickening that the biological parents failed so badly. They are truly vile people. Especially Jessica.
She can hide her face all she wants, she’s still going to die in jail.
@Desiree Hall & that's being kind
lets hope
Crystal Yeary Exactly! 🤞
At least she feels shame and remorse.
Drug is an awful thing, I don't understand why it's not wildly admitted what drug and alcohol play in crimes.
Drug dealers should be punished with the capital punishment. They are the root of so many misery.
@@verabolton did someone force the drugs into her system? Or was it voluntarily done? It’s funny how a woman makes excuses for another woman. Many people callously murder others while on drugs. That’s why drugs are illegal. There is NO excuse for what she did. You can live in fantasyland and blame the drugs, but it’s all on her. She beat this poor baby over a long period of time. That is not drugs. That is depravity towards another human. A baby, at that. Let’s hope you’re never on a jury where a woman is on trial.
34:00 - This judge says that while these two 'fooled' their caseworkers, neither Daniel nor Jessica showed true remorse. Good for you, judge!!
horrible .. horrific .. heartbreaking 💔
Heartbreaking speech from the only person who loved that baby his foster mom 😪🤧🤧
Absolutely!!! I havent seen the dad even shed one tear!!??
CPS fails another infant/child - the foster mom should still have Dylan ...
So sad ov a case its a pity foster mam did not have full coustody
Susan Strait exactly. I saw Jessica, not “mother”, shed ONE but only for herself right before sentencing.
Janet P so heartbreaking poor little angel..
Andrea Bowling is an angel on earth. For that short amount of time she had Dylan, he felt the genuine love of his mother. Nobody can EVER take that away from these precious two. RIP Dylan, and I wish for a long and healthy life for Andrea. 🙏🏻🥰
Thank you to the foster mother. She was a beautiful force within this baby's short life. Surely he loved her.
The moment the foster mom opened her mouth, my tears are streaming down and my heart breaking into pieces.
Same same SAME
That was so SO SO tough to watch. I live in Ohio, and I couldn't imagine this evil that close. That poor baby.
I'm holding my son extra tight tonight.
You didn't just fail as a mother, you failed as a HUMAN BEING !! Wild animals don't even treat their young so cruel.
I love that the judge saw through her crocodile tears and saw she had no remorse. Painful watching her days on end performances. To the lady Prosecutor ~ THANKYOU !!
You'd be surprised how many animals will kill babies and others of their own species, just like humans do. We kept ducks for a while and you had to separate the mothers and babies from the fathers. The males frequently killed the ducklings and not by accident either.
We are nothing more than animals
Wild animals are pretty well known to eat their own young
How did it actually happen it has not been addressed.the 15 year old wasn't harmed .?
HAMSTERS
The moment that Amazing foster mom began her impact statement i started crying😢 this case really broke my heart.
RIP Baby Dylan🕊 , thank you Julie for bringing True Justice and putting these monsters in Jail!!
19:25 My heart breaks for the foster mom. I'm so glad she wrote a letter on behalf of Dylan to be read to the court. I hope something good comes from this trial for future cases like this. This is so sad.
idc if ur religious or not, that is a person who will be going to a merciful place. she is so good of heart it makes me want to cry.
Thank you for time stamp on this.
"I Failed as a mother". No, you failed as a human being.
My thought was, "it's one thing to feel like a failure as a mother, it's quite another to bash your infant in the head for crying"! Ugh
That ‘mother’ was crying for herself , an utter narcissist .. what a terrible shame CPS let this child down .. at least he knew some love with his foster family 😪
The judge who allowed the child to go back to that home let him down. CPS did exactly what needed to be done just to be failed by the justice system.
I wish they would have left him there 😔
You could tell by how she acted on the stand how man she was that she got caught. What an evil narcissist she is.
I saw no tears so fake
sociopath
“I sentence you to life without the possibility of parole, plus 32 years.”
&…
“I will give you credit for the 213 days you’ve served while in custody awaiting trial.”
Like that’s gunna help her. 😂 They deserve it.
BOTH should have gotten the death penalty! That poor baby didn't get a chance to live his life, so why should they? 🤬🤬🤬
Seems like cases involving “child protective services” fail constantly. They need to get that under control at some point in history, right? Whoever thought it was a good idea at CPS to give Dylan back to either one of them should go to PRISON too. The issue starts with CPS, PERIODT!!!
Rest In Peace baby boy 🚼🦋🍼🧸💙
It should but they are sooo understaffed with people that don’t have enough training in the field to manage cases on their own. Additionally, CPS consistently focuses on reuniting families and ends up putting them back in the hands of abusers and drug users because they think it’s more traumatic for kids to be in foster care. It’s why we see sooo many issues.
They also tend to NOT take the bigger picture into consideration. If a young child always has bruises and isn’t old enough to verbalize what happened, the case workers just take the word of the parents.
CPS needs more money to staff more case workers and they need to redo guidelines to have new case workers working with senior and experienced case workers instead of being on their own so soon. They need cops to get involved quickly when a child isn’t produced or when a parent the child doesn’t live with voices concern.
@@sassysav6859 it’s the same in Oz, child services just ignore repeated calls by numerous people.....and the parents are druggies, dealers, growers, never worked a day in their life, on welfare in government housing they trash the house, scream, bash each other, foulest language ever, constantly fight, when cops come ...nope everything’s fine ....they never get kicked out the house just keeps getting repaired....children finally taken away when they left three under five, one a baby, alone in the house and went out....oldest one jumped over fence to another yard “to play” that’s the only reason they were found out...now pregnant again....number seven ..... ! They sure know how to work the system even after going to jail .....
i agree....
The issues start with parents who don’t want children! As we speak, pick up the phone and call CPS and ask them if they have enough foster homes to place kids, they don’t! Some people just shouldn’t have kids!, the issue starts there!
What a True Comment! ....... & a VERY Moving One.💔🧸🙏
The foster mom's victim impact statement broke my heart. I wish so much she would've had a chance to raise the baby. She would've given him a great life.
I agree! That had me crying so hard and ive never met any of them!! This poor beautiful perfect human being was treated like garbage and i will never understand how anybody could even consider doing this to any body but even worse your own flesh n blood!! They should have takn that baby at the hospital n never give him back!!!! The nurses n staff could see how much she cared abt that baby that shld have been a huge red flag! If she doesnt care rt now do ya think she is going to when she takes him home???? I just cant understand anything like this n how anybody has it in them to do this!!!! Rip lil guy!! Jesus has you now and you are loved and will always be in my thoughts!
@@susanluvsrobbyfox You dear lady, said such a heartfelt statement. God bless your compassionate 💝 In Christ's love..🌹🌝✝️
me too. so sad that she didn't get to give him the life he should have had. and Daniel Jr should have been removed long ago too. such a horrific situation for everyone who genuinely loved those children unlike their so called parents.
@Michelle doe that's being too strung out to give a damn
Michelle doe Thankfully we don’t have to judge. The jury already did. Don’t EVEN start to attempt to justify this heinous act by using Post Partum Depression. Literally HUNDREDS of women deal w this issue and DO NOT KILL THIER BABIES.
So called child protective services 🤬 I wish they could stand trial
CPS hides and behind what? Why allow them to hide let's all hold them accountable
Thank you, Colleen Johnson! More workers need to be held accountable There need to be better laws! I'm a licensed social worker in California and I'm disgusted!
How many more cases have to pop up of them failing ultimately resulting in a childs death before something is done to hold them accountable or to at least CHANGE SOMETHING!
@Angela Reddick some common sense is missing. They just trusted the father who’s known to use his sons pee to pass drug tests and took him on his word that he’d be responsible for their baby and not allow his wife to spend the night......too lenient, no real supervision for such a big risk
@Angela Reddick exactly the cops need to go in and watch him pee. Common sense. Work collaboratively with law enforcement
When the Prosecutor said “ the pain the child was put through on his last days on this earth” he should had said “the pain that the innocent baby boy experienced since the moment he came into this world he immediately began suffering due to so many different substance withdrawals, he truly never experienced a moment of joy of this earth b/c of the defendant”
I feel like the mom has been fake crying through this entire trial. I don’t see any actual tears.
I love the sentence this monster received..The judge nonstop talking..excellent. and they will pay prosecution costs..great, monsters.
Absolutely. All fake tears.
the only real tears were for herself at the end , none for that poor baby... I just cant even imagine it. Monster is not a strong enough word for her...
She feels sorry for herself not the baby boy
My thoughts exactly 😡
DCFS still needs to be held accountable for this though
Thank you Genny Zelis for reiterating that extremely important statement!
I agree 👍
Genny Zelis I agree. They failed this baby.
ABSOLUTELY!!!
Generally you get one chance with any bad behaviour you do to an animal unless its very cruel and then the animal is taken from you. I don't understand how children are given back time and again, especially when it involves parents with drug issue or any kind of physical abuse.
The foster mom's statement had me ugly crying.
I'm a mom and I can't even imagine intentionally hurting my children... Disgusting.
Me too 😭
Me too 😭😭😞
I'm in uncontrollable tears
Me as well
who is the "foster mom" name... I'm trying to follow this....
Poor young man & little baby. This is just heart breaking.
At what point do we prosecute child protective services? We NEED to start. Should have started years ago.
The foster mother's statement was beautiful. Heartbreaking but beautiful. God bless her and RIP little baby Dylan
Such a touching, beautiful and lovely depiction of what Baby Dylan would want have said if he had a voice. God bless that foster Mommy, she should have been able to keep him to raise him with the love he so deserved. Shame on the state of Ohio for being so negligent.
Yes... It was a very touching statement. I think the judge tried hard not to cry after such words. What a sad situation.
She broke my heart
The Ohio children services should be sued to the ends of the Earth for taking that baby away from that Foster mother who obviously loved him and given him back to those two drug addicts to murder him unreal Child Services violated that baby's constitutional rights
I'm not quite sure who would sue the State of Ohio? but I'm from the UK and will readily admit to having no knowledge about suing pertaining to the US.
As a former Child protective services worker, when a child is places back with the parents, that is ordered by the juvenile justice judges. My last case as a CPS worker was to put 3 kids back into an abusive home on order of the judge. The state welfare system has ZERO power.. they cant remove children from a home, that is done by a police officer, which is why an officer is present when a child is removed and when a child is placed back with the parent it MUST be ordered by a judge. The state CPS workers are the "face" of a broken system but that is only bc they are the ones that are in the home and seen more than anyone. They make recommendations to the court but at the end of the day the judge makes the rules.
@@valleygirlxx3526 you can actually sue a state here (mapp v ohio, mcculloch v maryland, miranda v arizona)
@@kitycatlover112 Thank you so much for yor information
Unfortunately, CPS isn't really the one making those decisions. CPS produces a recommendation to a judge who is responsible for making such decisions. Many, many times, CPS disagrees with the judges decisions, however biological parents have a built in strong case to getting their children back. The system is in many ways broken, and the sad part is the children are the victims of the system.
Thank you Judge and Jury.
Wow, even the judge verbally acknowledged the mother shows no genuine remorse.
This breaks my heart...I was a Foster Mom. We adopted our last foster baby that we got at 3 weeks. Both of his parents were doing jail time for drug related crimes. I can’t imagine what this Foster Mom went through...we loved our son from the second they put him in my arms just as much as my biological children. He has Autism...probably from drug use and will not have a normal life. He is 18 years old now and is very loved, healthy and happy. I cannot fathom loosing him like this Foster Mom did, only to have him be tortured and then murdered. I feel so sorry the the Foster Family and the big brother. 😩😢
Man that foster mom's statement had me hard crying. Bless her for caring for that baby the way she did.
Thank you Andrea god bless you - this breaks my heart
I can not believe that DCFS pop out this child back into the home of a known addict. Where in the hell are their child neglect and child endangering charges.
It's done a lot, everywhere..
Not in Texas. You or baby test positive and you will lose your rights. You can get the child back if you go through several steps. I know a girl who has lost all 7 of her children. Last 2 she lost because baby tested positive for morphine. She refused to do what she needed to get those two angels back. She was allowed to call and check on them but no physical contact at all. Couldn’t even visit family who ended up with the girls. We don’t play with that crap here. She sure uses the loss of all her children as if she never did anything wrong. Now the girls are with one of their sisters dad and family. “Mom” now prostitutes herself on the streets for drugs. Never has called or tried to straighten her life out for her children. Makes me sick.
Yes, especially after only 12 days with the foster parent.
I’m a recovering addict and even in my worse addiction I never hurt my kids. That’s a complete cop out she’s a monster . Addiction had zero to do with it
Why was this child EVER RETURNED BACK TO THESE 'SO CALLED' PARENTS?? There has got to be stronger rules in this area!!
It’s in Scioto county. That says everything to me. I live nearby this county
It's because of CPS, DHS, or any other name that child protective services go by depending on the state. The state child protective services screwed up their own case as shown by a state investigation of this particular case.
damselcausingdistress 81 that maybe true but I can bet you southern Ohio is the worst part in all Ohio
@@littleangel5101 to me that DOES NOT mean a thing. It's all or nothing.
Benjamin Sorenson I guess you have to live there
The baby didn’t “ pass away!” He was murdered by his parents
SCIOTO COUNTY, Ohio (WSAZ) - Two women who worked for Scioto County Children Services have been indicted on counts of endangering children.
The prosecutor confirms the charges stem from their former employment at Children Services and cases where children died.
Lisa Thomas, 56, of Wheelersburg, Ohio, is facing endangering children charges in connection with two separate cases. The first is surrounding the death of 2-month-old Dylan Groves. The second deals with the death of 5-year-old Annabell Greene.
Renee Ginn, 54, of Garrison, Kentucky, is facing counts of endangering children and tampering with evidence. Her charges stem from the death of Annabell Greene.